Maybe, WhiteStorm? Hear me out, he was wise is multiple ways, was loyal and experienced. He could organize and more. Sometimes I feel WhiteStorm is under appreciated but that might just be me ❤
Redstar of Thunderclan! Oakstar of Riverclan! Deadstar of Windclan! Shellstar of Riverclan! Stonestar of Riverclan! (THEY SOUND SO GOOD OML MY FAV iS DEADSTAR
the actual redstar in the books ( not red tail ) sucked, one lf Thundercats meanest leaders, it would have been nice of there was another red star that was noble and kind, not weak and mean.
@@T03_B3ANS imo leopardstar is one of my favourites kjsksjsj i understand her a lot - she was in a position of power, sure, yet controlled by a strong force and she felt so pressured (iirc she didn’t really.. be glad about ordering her deputy to kill half-clan cats)
SANDSTORM!! Her role in firestar's quest was so leader-like. Her agility and method to train apprentices would be a great inspiration for other cats and she would overall be a top tier leader.
@@LunaEquestrian-ss4pki doubt it now that ivy is deputy (is cinderheart still alive i can’t remember?) , and now squirrelstar has her nine lives it will take ages before she’s dead; though ‘Star’ may kill her or ivypool off. honestly they might pull a brambleclaw and make nightheart the next dep
Whitestorm, He is a wise cat whom is organized, like seen when he was helping Fireheart. Not to mention he's loyal and strong, two good traits, yet respectful, he is also respected by quite a lot of the clan, so personally he would be an amazing canindate for deputy, eventually leader!
@@RepublicOfRomaniathey say a lot and most aren’t finished with heart like: Deadfoot, Ashfoot, Talltail, Mudclaw, Crowfeather, Harespring, Gorse Fur, Leopardfur, Ivypool, Squirrelflight, Crookedjaw, etc
I feel like both Lionheart and also Whitestorm would be great leaders Lionheart was always wise and loyal also he only appear in the first 2 or 3 books before he died Whitestorm was caring Loyal and underrated
Ik she wasn’t ever a deputy.. but Brightheart ! After going through that much and still surviving, she shows a lot of perseverance, even though half of her face got ripped off and she had to lose her best friend. Anyone with me?
Bueno, no estoy de acuerdo. Nunca se le vio liderando. Lo que sí hubiera estado de acuerdo es que se le dieran más aprendices ¡era una excelente mentora!
Definitly russetfur, not a day of her life after she joined shadowclan from being a kittypet did she ever let them down, she went from confident little kittypet to extremely loyal killing machine.
Finally someone that likes Deadfoot too! I think that Ashfoot, Dust Muzzle (idk if he becomes after the end of path of the stars), Mudclaw and my beloved Crowfeather deserved too
Literally a die hard decision but BRIGHTHEART - I mean her bright and loyal personality she fought and survived dogs , she stopped a hawk from stealing a kit and continuing to steal prey. She was one of the only cats who supported Firestar to go on the mission (( aside from sandstorm )) and I could keep going on.
@@BloodStarWcue thought* However I have read the graphic novel “ a thief in thunder clan” where she is the only one who encourages him to go thinking it is the “will of starclan” even when everyone thinks that it’s leaving the clan in jeopardy. I have heard many people agree to this however you have your own opinion! :)
I am starting with you ❤ Dear God, the sweetest woman is reading this and is beautiful and amazing. Please help her live life to the fullest and bless her in all she does! Now, you're on the clock. In 9 minutes something will make you happy. Please share this with 15 girls you love. Remember, only for ladies. Once you read this, you have to send it to 15. It's not that hard. Whoever sent this to you must care about you. Don't know how to send it? Lol. Just hold your finger on it and it should say forward.
i’m not gonna like this since it’s i view this as begging and i don’t like it but 100% (though i am starting to like brambleclaw, im glad he’s retired) and firestar was so closeee to choosing him :(( leafpool should’ve kept quiet about the sign
Aquí mi opinión: - De Redtail no tenemos certeza de como hubiera liderado. - De Oakheart no lo creo una buena opción de ser Lider, puede que se haya salido con la suya con su amorío de Bluestar, pero seguía teniendo sentimientos por ella, no hubiera terminado bien para ambos lideres - Deadfoot definitivamente era la mejor opción. Un gato leal, muy valiente, inteligente y ágil. Hubiera encajado bien para tallstar y definitivamente no tuviéramos a Onestar o tal vez si pero después de el. Hubiera sido fascinante ver a un gato cojo de líder y hubiera encajado en la historia que se mantuviera por más tiempo - Shellheart dejo su puesto de diputado por su cuenta, ya era mayor, no creo que haya durado mucho como líder o que lo hubiera disfrutado - Stonefur definitivamente era una excelente opción, incluso me atrevo a decir que era mejor opción que Mistyfoot o Leopardfur. Era un gato leal, valiente, muy fuerte (Estaba desnutrido y aun asi tuvieron que poner 2 gatos para asesinarlo, eso demuestra su fuerza) y seguía el código guerrero. Se veía en los libros su liderazgo y su esfuerzo en mantener relaciones diplomáticas con otros clanes, además de su razonamiento y estrategias. Si hubiera sido líder, Riverclan no hubiera tenido tantos problemas y hubiera prosperado, a decir verdad, Stonefur probablemente hubiera sido de los líderes más duraderos de Riverclan. Sin embargo considerando en los movimientos y drama de los libro, no sería la mejor opción para sobrellevar la historia.
Underrated opinion: Jayfeather should've been a leader Okay, hear me out: Jayfeather wouldn't be a medicine cat if he wasn't blind, and if he wasn't blind, he wouldn't be rude and snappy. He was only rude because people always thought he wasn't as good at things because he was blind, so if he wasn't blind, he would be a nice, normal cat. Oh also, is too smart for his own good so yea-
I used to like Leopardstar, hate her now.. Poor Stonefur, lost his life because his 'loyal' leader made him fight for the apprentices. Story : (WARNING:SPOILERS)So, in the last book of warrior cats, blood clan (scourges kittypets and shadowclan) wanted to grow bigger, so they decided to make an offer to the other clans. Tigerstar had already convinced Leopardstar to let Riverclan join Bloodclan, however, Windclan and Thunderclan refused in the name of Starclan. Firestar had made a plan to save Greystripes children because he knew they would slaughter half-clan cats (including:Mistyfoot and Stonefur because they are the kits of Bluestar)while Firestar was watching blood clan so they can save them at rhe right time, he noticed Stonefur, Feathertail and Stonefur were in front of Darkstripe, Tigerstar and Leopardstar. Tigerstar said to Stonefur that he would only survive if he proved his loyalty by killing the kits. Stonefur claimed that he only took orders from his leader, Leopardstar. Sadly, she agreed with Tigerstar and ordered Stonefur to kill her own Clans kits. Stonefur refused. Tigerstar wanted Darkstripe to finish Stonefur off to prove his loyalty to him. They began to fight wildly. Poor Stonefur fought so bravely, but he was against 3 of the strongest cats in Shadow clan. He died, and only because Leopardstar couldn't speak up.. - (sorry if the information is at anytime wrong)
I feel like hollyleaf would have been a really good leader- in the first few books i was thinking she would be leader. if she hadnt died so quick after she returned then maybe she could have been a really nice leader
Though she isn’t close to the spot of a leader, I find Ivypool would fit the role super well. She’s been through plenty in her younger years, to give her better wisdom. Also Ivypool is rather decent at reading other cats. I could see her being a honest and loyal leader. Always willing to listen and work for the good of her clan.
Mudclaw maybe, if you read the “winds of change” graphic novel than you’ll know. Tallstar can’t just change the leader at death like that! Also, I think mudclaw would have been a better leader than OneWhiscker.
![[Vowel]물고기는 물에서 살아야 해🐟🤣Fish have to live in the water #funny](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3G9MH063Cx4/mqdefault.jpg)
Want part 3? Comment who should be next!
Idk why but I feel like Greystripe would’ve been a good leader tbh
@@Addygmanyeah, he's in part 1 😁
@@Book-Haven Oop I didn’t see part 1 😅
Ima watch it tho rn 😅
Brightheart!
Definitely Lionheart, he is very wise and underrated. He deserved to stay in the books longer.
Totally not die in the first book!😭
Frrr!
Thats what i was thinking
Fr it felt like he lived for 2 seconds
EXACTLY!
Maybe, WhiteStorm? Hear me out, he was wise is multiple ways, was loyal and experienced. He could organize and more. Sometimes I feel WhiteStorm is under appreciated but that might just be me ❤
Yeah I agree, that's why I put him in part 1!
Oh, sorry didn’t fully watch part one, now I have though lol
Yeah like he is savirly under appreciated
He would be great if he where younger as it says in the book he was ageing
@@stxrry.cloxds mistystar exists =]
Redstar of Thunderclan!
Oakstar of Riverclan!
Deadstar of Windclan!
Shellstar of Riverclan!
Stonestar of Riverclan!
(THEY SOUND SO GOOD OML MY FAV iS DEADSTAR
Same lol I love WindClan and Deadfoot is my 3 fav Tom of WindClan and of all
PLEASE WE NEED DEADSTARRRRR HE WAS SUCH A GREAT CHARACTER AND WE WOULD HAVE A REASON FOR CROWFEATHER'S EXISTANCE
the actual redstar in the books ( not red tail ) sucked, one lf Thundercats meanest leaders, it would have been nice of there was another red star that was noble and kind, not weak and mean.
YESSS
Mudstar maybe?
Nightpelt deserved to actually be accepted by StarClan to be leader.
Yes, him too.
Yh but Broken Tail had still 1 life then, so he couldn't
Maybe do a vid that "who DON'T deserved to be a leader?"
Coloquemos a Onestar y a Rowanstar en la lista
brokenstar, brambleclaw, tigerclaw, hawkfrost(didn’t deserve to be deputy at one point), clear sky, onestar:😀
@@dolledphoenixdon’t forget leopard star
@@T03_B3ANS imo leopardstar is one of my favourites kjsksjsj i understand her a lot - she was in a position of power, sure, yet controlled by a strong force and she felt so pressured (iirc she didn’t really.. be glad about ordering her deputy to kill half-clan cats)
@@dolledphoenix she didn’t order her deputy to, her deputy, stonefur, was half clan cat, and died from black foot/ black star
SANDSTORM!! Her role in firestar's quest was so leader-like. Her agility and method to train apprentices would be a great inspiration for other cats and she would overall be a top tier leader.
Your prof pic is cherry on a top
Firestar pfp !!! :D
Firestar, we know that's you
SandStar? Hmm
I feel like if cinderpelt wasn’t run over she would’ve been a solid candidate for deputy, I honestly would love to see a cinderstar.
Fr
That's the first cat I thought of!
We might see that in Cinderheart!
@@LunaEquestrian-ss4pki doubt it now that ivy is deputy (is cinderheart still alive i can’t remember?) , and now squirrelstar has her nine lives it will take ages before she’s dead; though ‘Star’ may kill her or ivypool off. honestly they might pull a brambleclaw and make nightheart the next dep
SAMEMEMEMMEMEEEE
Lionheart and Whitestorm both deserved to be leader, their deaths were so sad😢
Yea..
Whitestorm should have been a leader, he is patient, opinion does not cloud his judgement, and he was a senior warrior.
👇
fr tho
He was deputy once at least
Hollyleaf was always guided by reason and compassion, she should have become Hollystar.❤
Whitestorm, He is a wise cat whom is organized, like seen when he was helping Fireheart. Not to mention he's loyal and strong, two good traits, yet respectful, he is also respected by quite a lot of the clan, so personally he would be an amazing canindate for deputy, eventually leader!
Oakheart changed his mind about being a leader. He said that it was every kit's dream to be ons
Stonefur would be a very honorable leader, I respect him.
Most characters that are deputies end in “heart”
Tiger heart
Fire heart
Oak heart
Night heart
Greystripe and Whitestorm: Hehehehe
@@RepublicOfRomaniathey say a lot and most aren’t finished with heart like: Deadfoot, Ashfoot, Talltail, Mudclaw, Crowfeather, Harespring, Gorse Fur, Leopardfur, Ivypool, Squirrelflight, Crookedjaw, etc
Longtail, Talltail, thats two different ways to clear up your tail is long, @@Cheetahwindstar
Lionheart!!
nightheart isn’t a deputy? ivypool is
I feel like both Lionheart and also Whitestorm would be great leaders Lionheart was always wise and loyal also he only appear in the first 2 or 3 books before he died Whitestorm was caring Loyal and underrated
All I can say is...
I 100% agree 😅😅😅
such a brave and strong tomcat
BRIGHTHEART!! She deserves so much better! She would be a great leader!!
Lol, I just only read "Into the Wild" and I still think something is wrong about Lionheart being deputy.
you have alot to learn..
I love tigerclaw and how he ended oakhearts life after oakheart ended redtail
Can we PLEASE talk about Whitestorm? He would've been an awesome leader! Also Feathertail
I honestly wish whitestorm lived, he would of been the best leader!
Ik she wasn’t ever a deputy.. but Brightheart ! After going through that much and still surviving, she shows a lot of perseverance, even though half of her face got ripped off and she had to lose her best friend. Anyone with me?
Brightheart.
Isn’t she an elder though?
@@The_Dizzy_kitty if she was still a warrior she should be leader she deserved leadership in her warrior ages
No. She didn't tho
@@BloodStarWcue wdym?
Bueno, no estoy de acuerdo. Nunca se le vio liderando. Lo que sí hubiera estado de acuerdo es que se le dieran más aprendices ¡era una excelente mentora!
Whitestorm was always a great character, always loyal and caring also mousefur is an og aswell
My baby stonefur would’ve been the best leader…but Mistystar is pretty good too
I think Brightheart deserved to be a leader, she had so much strength, skill, and potential and it got thrown out.
Brightheart deserved to be leader in my openion she was a wonderful warrior and would have been a amazing deputy and leader
In my opinion, Hollyleaf could have been an interesting leader :3
tbh if Lightning Tail didnt die he would have been a noble leader for Thunderclan
Redstar! Where did you g- ...
Tigerclaw..?
Cloudpelt!!!! He's so underrated 😢
who??
@@tobytaiga22 from Yellowfang's secret
Definitly russetfur, not a day of her life after she joined shadowclan from being a kittypet did she ever let them down, she went from confident little kittypet to extremely loyal killing machine.
Who remembers that Deadfoot used to be called Hopkit and didn’t talllstar mentor him?
Lion blaze he would do anything for his clan
Bright heart, too.
Deadstar is actually such a sick name tho
MudFur! I feel like half of the problems in warriors could’ve been solved if he had been leader
Redtail is so handsome
Brightheart Team
👇
Curlfeather for sure
redtail and stonefur hit different
Finally someone that likes Deadfoot too!
I think that Ashfoot, Dust Muzzle (idk if he becomes after the end of path of the stars), Mudclaw and my beloved Crowfeather deserved too
I think Cloudpelt from Yellowfang’s secret should be a leader
Please credit all the artists! Even if they allow their art to be on edits they should still be credited!
Swiftpaw, he should be because he went after the dogs to get rid of them and saved Brightheart.
CROWFROST! CROWSTAR, HE WOULD BE A GOOD LEADER HE WAS FAIR, BELIEVED IN JUSTICE BUT WASNT SOFT! HE WOULD HAVE BEEN THE PERFECT SHADOWCLAN LEADER!
Literally a die hard decision but BRIGHTHEART - I mean her bright and loyal personality she fought and survived dogs , she stopped a hawk from stealing a kit and continuing to steal prey. She was one of the only cats who supported Firestar to go on the mission (( aside from sandstorm )) and I could keep going on.
Where do you get this information from Sandstorm litterally only let him go because she was going and tought he was making this about Spottedleaf xd
Also, PLEASE NOT BRIGHTHEARTT
@@BloodStarWcue thought*
However I have read the graphic novel “ a thief in thunder clan” where she is the only one who encourages him to go thinking it is the “will of starclan” even when everyone thinks that it’s leaving the clan in jeopardy. I have heard many people agree to this however you have your own opinion! :)
Yeah! Bright heart is my favorite character!
@@BloodStarWcuebright heart is worthy
Lionheart and Sandstorm!!
Who they’d choose as their deputy
Redstar; Longtail
Oakstar; Stonefur
Deadstar; Crowfeather
Shellstar; Crookedjaw
Stonestar; Feathertail
My fave books ever🎉
Stonfur looks a lot like bluestar mother, like daughter
Grey Wing? I love him ❤❤
I think hollyleaf would’ve made an awesome leader.
I am starting with you ❤ Dear God, the sweetest woman is reading this and is beautiful and amazing. Please help her live life to the fullest and bless her in all she does! Now, you're on the clock. In 9 minutes something will make you happy. Please share this with 15 girls you love. Remember, only for ladies. Once you read this, you have to send it to 15. It's not that hard. Whoever sent this to you must care about you. Don't know how to send it? Lol. Just hold your finger on it and it should say forward.
Team Brakenfur should have been deputy in the second series
👇
i’m not gonna like this since it’s i view this as begging and i don’t like it but 100% (though i am starting to like brambleclaw, im glad he’s retired) and firestar was so closeee to choosing him :(( leafpool should’ve kept quiet about the sign
Deadstar sounds so cool
Imo:
Cinderpelt
Lionheart
Redtail
Stonefur
Whitestorm
Brightheart
Swiftpaw
POOR DEPUTYS :(
Deadstar goes hard
Who else stans RedStar(tail)
(Ik he died, I just like to imagine a world where he became leader)
Ppl who want ivypool to be leader
👇🏻
IvyPool LionBlaze WhiteStorm team
👇🏽
Red tail 😢 oak heart should have thought twice before killing him
❤SO TRUE ❤
I also think Russetfur and Lionheart would of been good leaders
Yes omg that’s sooo true ( I read the books)
You forgot abt ivypool , she fought in the dark woods and is one of the best characters in the books!
¡Ya es diputada! Ojalá Squirrelstar no muera pronto, pero definitivamente merece ser la líder proxima
Clean sky !!!!❤
I was waiting for lionheart
Lionheart. If Graystripe wasn't so much of a goofball as he was as an apprentice I would say he would be a suitable leader. (If he is well... no)
And tigerheart too!
idk i haven’t seen the first one but BRIGHTHEART
Aquí mi opinión:
- De Redtail no tenemos certeza de como hubiera liderado.
- De Oakheart no lo creo una buena opción de ser Lider, puede que se haya salido con la suya con su amorío de Bluestar, pero seguía teniendo sentimientos por ella, no hubiera terminado bien para ambos lideres
- Deadfoot definitivamente era la mejor opción. Un gato leal, muy valiente, inteligente y ágil. Hubiera encajado bien para tallstar y definitivamente no tuviéramos a Onestar o tal vez si pero después de el. Hubiera sido fascinante ver a un gato cojo de líder y hubiera encajado en la historia que se mantuviera por más tiempo
- Shellheart dejo su puesto de diputado por su cuenta, ya era mayor, no creo que haya durado mucho como líder o que lo hubiera disfrutado
- Stonefur definitivamente era una excelente opción, incluso me atrevo a decir que era mejor opción que Mistyfoot o Leopardfur. Era un gato leal, valiente, muy fuerte (Estaba desnutrido y aun asi tuvieron que poner 2 gatos para asesinarlo, eso demuestra su fuerza) y seguía el código guerrero. Se veía en los libros su liderazgo y su esfuerzo en mantener relaciones diplomáticas con otros clanes, además de su razonamiento y estrategias. Si hubiera sido líder, Riverclan no hubiera tenido tantos problemas y hubiera prosperado, a decir verdad, Stonefur probablemente hubiera sido de los líderes más duraderos de Riverclan. Sin embargo considerando en los movimientos y drama de los libro, no sería la mejor opción para sobrellevar la historia.
Buenas opiniones, coincido contigo en la mayoría. Gracias por dedicar tiempo a escribir esto 😁
Oak heart , I haven't read the warrior cat books cos I don't have any but I just has to be him
Me just realizing a she cat named her kit Deadkit💀
This is so true
Im sad that spottedleaf died in the first book 😭😭
I feel bad for Stonefur
Sadly i feel like if we had gotten one of these cats as a leader, they might pull a onestar on us..
Underrated opinion: Jayfeather should've been a leader
Okay, hear me out: Jayfeather wouldn't be a medicine cat if he wasn't blind, and if he wasn't blind, he wouldn't be rude and snappy. He was only rude because people always thought he wasn't as good at things because he was blind, so if he wasn't blind, he would be a nice, normal cat. Oh also, is too smart for his own good so yea-
I used to like Leopardstar, hate her now.. Poor Stonefur, lost his life because his 'loyal' leader made him fight for the apprentices.
Story : (WARNING:SPOILERS)So, in the last book of warrior cats, blood clan (scourges kittypets and shadowclan) wanted to grow bigger, so they decided to make an offer to the other clans. Tigerstar had already convinced Leopardstar to let Riverclan join Bloodclan, however, Windclan and Thunderclan refused in the name of Starclan. Firestar had made a plan to save Greystripes children because he knew they would slaughter half-clan cats (including:Mistyfoot and Stonefur because they are the kits of Bluestar)while Firestar was watching blood clan so they can save them at rhe right time, he noticed Stonefur, Feathertail and Stonefur were in front of Darkstripe, Tigerstar and Leopardstar. Tigerstar said to Stonefur that he would only survive if he proved his loyalty by killing the kits. Stonefur claimed that he only took orders from his leader, Leopardstar. Sadly, she agreed with Tigerstar and ordered Stonefur to kill her own Clans kits. Stonefur refused. Tigerstar wanted Darkstripe to finish Stonefur off to prove his loyalty to him. They began to fight wildly. Poor Stonefur fought so bravely, but he was against 3 of the strongest cats in Shadow clan. He died, and only because Leopardstar couldn't speak up..
- (sorry if the information is at anytime wrong)
Lionheart
Graystipe
Whitestorm
Stonefur
BRO MY BRAIN WENT FULL ON "WHO ARE U PEOPOLE!?"
Please (if u want to ) do whitestorm he definitely in the 1st series made Blue’star more calm after tigerstar tried to kill her
i litterally told myself redtail was gonna be there before watching-
I feel like hollyleaf would have been a really good leader- in the first few books i was thinking she would be leader. if she hadnt died so quick after she returned
then maybe she could have been a really nice leader
Don’t forget Brackenfur!! Maybe in another part!
Facts!!!!!!!!
I'd vote that Whitestorm deserved it tbh
Though she isn’t close to the spot of a leader, I find Ivypool would fit the role super well. She’s been through plenty in her younger years, to give her better wisdom. Also Ivypool is rather decent at reading other cats. I could see her being a honest and loyal leader. Always willing to listen and work for the good of her clan.
I totally agree ❤
Longtail though 🗿
So true. But if redtail became leader, how would firestar save the clans by leading them against bloodclan?
I also think whitestorm❤
Like I’m sad that red tail died in the first book’ :(
Man oak heart died b4 he got a chance :(
Cats who should have been leaders (my opinion) -
Oakheart
Stonefur
Redtail
Lionheart
Whitestorm
Graystripe
Brightheart
Mudclaw maybe, if you read the “winds of change” graphic novel than you’ll know. Tallstar can’t just change the leader at death like that! Also, I think mudclaw would have been a better leader than OneWhiscker.