Dream Theater - Hell's Kitchen + Lines in the Sand (REACTION!)
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 09. 2020
- ❤️ PATREON: / halflifesistah
☕️ SAY THANKS: buymeacoffee.com/halflifesistah
😎 TIP: streamelements.com/halflifesi...
👉 OFFICIAL MERCH STORE: www.halflifesistah.com ™️
❤ Let’s Connect! ✊🤘
*** Twitch: / halflifesistah
*** Facebook: / halflifesistah
*** Instagram: / halflifesistah
Business Inquiries: Email: Halflifesistah@gmail.com
Mail:
HalfLifeSistah
P. O. Box 278354
Miramar, Florida 33027
#halflifesistah #dreamtheater #progressivemetal - Hudba
![First time hearing Dream Theater - Breaking All Illusions [LIVE] [Breaking the Fourth Wall] reaction](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JPm7Os6hnCs/mqdefault.jpg)
Lines in the Sand: One of Petrucci's most beautiful guitar solos for sure.
It’s my personal favourite..
I am not the biggest DT fan and I sometimes think that maybe it is the most beautiful rock solo ever.
@@JoseSantos-eg2oz I am actually quite the fan of DT up to Octavarium, or a bit further. They did some masterful music.
And the thing about Petrucci is, when he plays melodically, the man's a genius soloist. But yeah, Lines in the Sand has always been a dear favourite of mine, and the solo is downright wonderful (the only solo I've ever learned of his, in fact xD. Not that I could play almost any of his music. Fucking complicated, to say the least)
Edit: actually, not true. I did learn, back in the day, the ending solo of Octavarium, another great moment.
@@GaudyGabriev Thanks. I am not exactly the biggest fan, I just know things when I listen. Yo me this solo is a small heaven.
The drumming was more fantastic
OMG THIS GIRL HAD THE BEST REACTION I EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE
That one felt the music in the right way
Metropolis Part 2: Scenes From a Memory will send you through an emotional rollercoaster.
This 👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻
and best Labrie either
This one is MANDATORY
Just "Home" on its' own would probably do the trick!
@@SirGingerOfKnight That's what I was thinking... She will be an actual puddle of tears by the end of that one.
Watching her face during this and one thing is clear - she gets it.
Please more Dream Theater
A change of seasons next.. hi John 😻
More more more please
pleases
Dream Theater is definitely not an easy listen. This is one of those bands that significantly grow in you after few listens. You will not regret spending the time with their music. They have so many classics and songs that will touch you guys.
I'm not as expressive as Sistah, but her reactions are EXACTLY how these songs effect me!
And it looks great how she reacts to Doug's super soul groovy voice.. Or Petrucci solo!!!
her face is showing everything of dream theater’s world!
Singer from King's X on accompanying vocals!!
dUg Pinnick!!!! 🤘 😎 🤘
Ive been one of the very few lucky people to see him this song on the progressive nation at sea cruise with Portnoy, sherinian, macalpine and bill
Her reaction is GOLDEN! So great to see someone totally get this music with her whole appearance.
The Lines in the Sand solo is one of the most soulful, guitar solos I've ever heard. Always a fan and underrated song. II've been playing guitar for 10 years. Great videos!
Very underrated songs from them. It's like a Rush on steroids
"Lines in the Sand" is actually my favorite DT song. Real gem on this album.
That line, "living comes much easier once we admit we're dying" is a gut punch every time.
Studio make them underrated, but actually demos version more better
I think of Limelight everything I hear the intro of Hell's Kitchen
The guy from King's X, Doug, is on this song, so that's why
Sistah gonna cry with Learning to Live, trust me!!!
A bit of backstory on Hell's Kitchen, it was originally supposed to be an instrumental breakdown in the middle of Burning My Soul (another song from the same album). But the record company -- who were meddling a lot in this album -- made them cut the instrumental out into its own song. Presumably to make Burning My Soul more concise and accessible.
If you search Burning My Soul demo you can hear the original version.
I actually like it better this way. Hell's kitchen on its own came out way better than in BMS. You know, the record company gets a lot of shit from the DT community on it's involvement and commercialism of Falling Into Infinity, but I really think this album is very cohesive. There are a few songs that are backing track at the bar worthy for sure. Like the kind of shit people would get up and sing at Karaoke and nobody cares. Like Anna Lee. But there are some really great tracks on here. New Millennium, Just Let Me Breathe, Trial of Tears (I always hated this song until I saw it played live at Bank of America Pavilion in Boston and it suddenly came alive), Hell's Kitchen and Lines in the Sand of course. Oh, and Peruvian Skies. God I love Peruvian Skies!!!!
I really love how nuestra amiga Sistah reacts to any touching song. She's the physical depiction of what happens inside the rest of us when listening to this kind of music.
>_< ♥
She gets it. Los vi en esa gira. Esa canción me volvió loco.
Yes, the emotional overwhelming sensation is hard for guys to externalize.
Bye the way the soulful voice in the song is Doug Pinnick from Kings X. Great singer!
Doug's a living legend. What an incredible talent.
You finally made it to Dream Theater!! They've been around for over 30 years, so there's a massive discography of incredible music to choose from.
Your fellow reactors Kel & Rich, who you met at the Iron Maiden concert a few months ago, have reacted to a LOT of Dream Theater songs (they're Rich's favorite band). Kel has been reduced to tears on several occasions listening to masterpieces like "Metropolis Part II: Scenes From a Memory", "The Count of Tuscany", "Octavarium", "The Best of Times", or "A Change of Seasons"... some of them are true eargasms from start to finish. A few suggestions for next reactions to DT: the live versions (from "Breaking the Fourth Wall, live at the Boston Opera House) of "Illumination Theory", "The Shattered Fortress" or "Breaking All Illusions", all three from the same concert, or "This Dying Soul", "Beyond This Life", "Hollow Years" and "Instrumedley" from the "Live at Budokan" concert.
If you want to hear some 'moving' songs these are some recommendations which fit the bill in my opinion:
Images and Words (1992)
- Another Day
- Learning to Live
Awake (1994)
- Erotomania/Voices/The Silent Man
- Scarred
- Space Dye Vest
Scenes from a Memory (1999)
- The whole damn thing
Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence (2002)
- Misunderstood
- Disappear
- the title track
Octavarium
- the title track
Systematic Chaos (2007)
- In the Presence of Enemies 1&2
- The Ministry of Lost Souls
Black Clouds and Silver Linings (2009)
- Count of Tuscany
- The Best of Times
A Dramatic Turn of Events (2011)
- This is the Life
- Outcry
- Breaking All Illusions
Dream Theater (2013)
- Illumination Theory
Distance over Time (2019)
- Barstool Warrior
- At Wit's End
They need to hear Trial of Tears (Breaking the 4th Wall live version)
Need to add Wait for Sleep on I&W
@@wjadragon6782 I didn't include the prequel/intro songs as it appeared in the reaction that they don't know where the songs start and end if they bleed together
@@kennhern I think Sista would cry through Wait for Sleep but it is only like 2 mins long
26 years on and Space Dye Vest still gives me chills every time I hear it!
Her reactions were as epic as the song.
Omg, that must be the first time in hundreds that I've seen a person in these reactions videos that listen to it twice in a row! Amazing
James' voice wasn't utilized that much in Falling Into Infinity, since it is a few years after he damaged his vocal cords due to food poisoning (vomiting violently and all that). If you want to hear James' voice in its full glory, listen to any song from the two albums before this, Images and Words and Awake.
When Dream Theater made this song they also felt a King's X vibe. So they decided to get the vocalist from King's X to help out on vocals. It's all about the build up both vocals and instruments. Please keep doing more Dream Theater. You will be truly inspired.
Dream Theater began with Mike Portnoy (drums), Kevin Moore (keys), John Petrucci (guitar), John Myung (bass) and Charlie Dominici (vocals) for the first album "When Dream & Day Unite", which then shifted to bring in singer James LaBrie for their second "Images & Words" - THE career launching album by progressive/mainstream standards. They remained intact for two albums until their forth album "A Change of Seasons" (people argue over it, but though it seems to be an EP it was an album release in my eyes since they haven't made a habit of releasing such things) which brought keyboard player Derek Sherinian in place of Kevin. This again maintained for another album until "Metropolis Part II" when Jordan Rudess took over from Derek (Jordan had been on the bands radar when Derek joined, but I believe for gigging reasons he was unavailable at the time), and kept their longest stable line up to that point, through six albums. Then in 2009/2010 saw another departure when original member Mike Portnoy sought space for his creativity. He wished to put Dream Theater on hold for a while, causing a professional conflict with the other guys who wanted to continue. After a fascinatingly documented process of interview and try outs for what would be I feel the hardest replacement to date, by virtue of Mike being a founding member, in came Mike Mangini. This has been Dream Theater's Roth/Hagar moment for the fandom, and as with that situation IMHO the sensible fans appreciate both. The band has maintained this line up for the last four albums.
This reaction is to tracks from the second album of the Sherinian era. Funnily but you seemed to say about King's X as though you didn't know the featured extra vocals in the chorus of "Lines in the Sand" IS Doug Pinnick!?. Anyway, you picked a contentious album to start with..hehe. Amongst both band and fan alike I think the album FALLING INTO INFINITY represented a nexus point, where (possibly well meaning but harmful nonetheless) studio interference in their work almost caused the band to break up completely. Fortunately they managed to wrestle creative control back and haven't looked back since "Metropolis Pt. II" which rightfully reaffirmed their position with fans and critics, and became something of a rebirth for them. In spite of all that FALLING had some wonderful work on it, including the three part finale "Trial of Tears" which has some gorgeous keyboard tones on it! I highly recommend giving it a listen (maybe even a reaction?). I think the two of you will really enjoy those qualities which Sistah says she love about this.. Dream Theater have plenty of deep blues/soul flavour infused through the heavily progressive work in their catalogue ("Metropolis Pt II" album is a fine example of such), and as you go you'll find plenty to think about over their work. They aren't a light band to indulge, and as a listener I predict you WILL be challenged. From one music fan to another though guys, it is worth the journey. As the hell priest would say, they have such sights to show you.
Overall? Dream Theater are as dynamic, ferocious, soulful and technically refined a band as you're ever likely to experience, and yes you got the right songs.. The split between songs is the percussive beat down. You'll find as you explore the catalogue that they have a knack for classical arrangements which have a lot of call back arrangements and themes. One thing I'll say straight away for you as you go through this exploration is that James LaBrie has taken some stick for his vocals, and is often cast amongst the more critical fans and cynics as the weakest link in the band.. this has a ring of truth but is honestly somewhat unfair since for a long while he's struggled with damaged vocal cords, something perhaps not known in general circles. His being arguably the "voice" of the band which can hold its own in terms of technical musicianship, would I think be fair comment on why he remained in place and didn't either temporarily retire or have them put projects on hold, given that as a group they have a talent for the aforementioned prolific workload, which would ironically trigger Portnoy's departure. You get variations in his capacity more in live performances than studio, although the studio isn't immune to that variation. This is by no means a critique from myself, as I think overall he's maintained his game admirably given the level of the band and their creative ethos.
Hell's Kitchen is the instrumental part, and Lines in the Sand is the long song it segues into.
Trapped inside this
oc
ta
va
ri
um!!!
my favorite DT song by a mile. or just a kilometer ;)
So glad you started with this. This album in recent times have been negatively appraised by fans but have been seeing newfound appreciation today. Underrated yes, but a hidden gem if you get into it.
Strange how well it has aged. I used to hate this album back in the day, but in recent years it has really grown on me.
@@T1hitsTheHighestNote it is where I think Dream Theater went to groove and soundscape territory which I found to be lacking in more metal-focused releases. The initial hate came from the fact that this is softer than their other releases, but when you're given album upon albums of metal, FII gives that little backpedal to a more melodic time
One of my fav albums!!!
I got a new appreciation for this album once the band released the demos of the songs they’d written for it & heard what they’d have done if not for the record label’s edict that Kevin Shirley got final say. Of course, when this album failed to produce another “Pull Me Under” sized hit, the band bet it all on doing it their way on the next album (Scenes). And the rest is history.
I don't understand why many DT fans consider this is the worst album of DT? I mean there are Hell's kitchen, Lines in the sand, Trial of tears, Hollow Years which are great songs to me.
Yes, but there are also songs like You Not Me, Anna Lee and even Burning My Soul, which are easily the lowest points of their musical output. Which is saying a lot, because those are still great songs. Just not so much compared to the rest of DT's discography. You Not Me, had been released by any other band, would have been considered one of the best hard rock songs of the late 90s, but since DT is not "any other band", it's one of their bottom tier songs.
I don't dislike Falling into Infinity at all. It's just that I see why it's considered their weakest record (to me, it's their 3rd weakest, after The Astonishing and their debut. The Astonishing has too many ballads for my taste, it's kind of repetitive and is just too damn long and in the debut they still hadn't completely found their feet, even ignoring they had a different singer)
The Falling Into Infinity album was the result of a *lot* of record label interference; they wanted the band to make more commercial music. That's why there's a bunch of weaker songs on there that don't feel like Dream Theater tracks.
Hells Kitchen / Lines In The Sand is an incredible song though, along with Trial of Tears, which are the highlights of the album for me.
The Astonishing is my least favourite of their albums, whilst their latest (Distance Over Time) seems to be a return to form; easily some of their best-sounding work since Mike Mangini joined the band (he is an unbelievably good drummer, but I wasn't in love with how his drums sounded on the other albums he's been on).
This album would've been 8 out of 10 for me if they included Raise the Knife instead of those shitty songs but I do love it still
@@graemeporter yes i agree with you, this album is much slower and kinda funky style especially with Lines in the sand. But the albums which came along after, just so crazy such as train of thought.
Peruvian skies is a masterpiece aswell
Didn't expect people still listen to this. I found this DT album to be the most underrated one. So many goosebumps raising moments.
Halflifesista, u have expressed how I felt about the guitar solo of Lines in the Sand for the pass 20 years. When I need that moment, I listen to this, close the door, off the light and close my eyes.
We saw them live at Greek Theater and since Kingx opened for them and Satriani, Doug sang with them on this song...it was epic! Doug sings with sooo much soul. Love it and will never forget that awesome moment!!!🤘🍻
I saw that tour as well and yes, that was epic.
I’m a 70s guy, but Dream Theater and Kings X were my two favorite bands of the late 80s/early 90s, so when I heard Dug Pinnick on this song, I was thrilled. One of my favorite DT songs. Great solo by Petrucci, too.
I love how emotive and moved she is and how stoic he is. Great counterpoint to each other.
God, I haven't listened to this critically in ages. Now that I have, much of its genius is owed to Derek Sherinian. His brand of atmospheric synth is much like Jonn Serrie (think The Stargazer's Journey), and the super jazzy quality is not unlike something you'd hear on a John Beasley or John Patitucci album in the '90s. This song strikes such a fine balance between flash and restraint. I understand that DT fans aren't exactly after that, but having been a fan for almost ten years (damn, already?), I find this to be a perfectly written tune, and certainly a top favorite of mine.
I love when people catch the emotion of a godlike Petrucci solo.
Pleaaaaseeee! More Dream Theater!!! I believe Sistah will fall in love with them as much as I am. 🤘🤘🤘❤️❤️❤️
Based on your reaction, I think "The Count of Tuscany" or "The best of times" would be very enjoyable to you.
TRUST ME: if you listen to Dream Theaters "The Count of Tuscany" you will flow in heaven!!!!!!!!
This !
The song is basicly the story of when Petrucci was in Italy. Its very good
Not, not even a good song from DT
YES!!!
nah, not even in the top 20 of Dream Theater. Overrated song. Way overrated
Wolfkain is how my face react. Halflifesistah is how my heart react
I love her reaction. She hears what is really going on.
Hells kitchen is such a great Dream Theater song. I'm glad to have enjoyed it with the two of you!
Bro, I didn't know James LaBrie started reacting to his old material!
(Joking aside, I loved seeing you guys get into this. DT is my favorite band, and I hope you guys do more reactions to them.
I love Sherinians work on here. You can also really hear Myungs bass on this album, which usually gets lost alot.
If you want something driven by a groovy bass line, you should check out Trial of Tears, same album. In the opening they use their instruments to paint a mental picture of it raining. Easily one of my favorite pieces.
When you discover a really good band like this This happened ! This woman's reaction say it all ,i hope more people appreciate and understand how good dream theater actually is and its not only technique!
Welcome to Dream Theater, guys. You've got a long and glorious journey ahead. Enjoy it. Let me just ask this: start from the begining, so you go through their evolution.
I like watching people listening to DT songs for the first time , her reaction makes this song even more beautiful, she felt it
This is lovely timing, I've just found your channel yesterday and now you're listening to two of my favorite tracks/songs from my favorite band. I'm glad you did both at the same time, they go really well together. Love the discussions and the effort you put into these videos, great stuff!
Dream Theater obligatories: Erotomania + Voices, anything from Imagines and words from Take the time till the last song, Home, Count of Tuscany.
Mike Portnoy is a highly technical and very creative drummer. He was basically my childhood idol for drumming, and I learned so much watch him play. Big respect to the guy! Also love you guys
John Myung Bass sounds sooo meaty in this song.
These two songs, together, the way you two heard them, in my opinion, is the best two song sequence ever.
Listening to Dream Theater is like entering a new dimension.
Enjoy your new discovery.Lots lots lots of DT reaction videos to come..
Thanks for the video. I came across it seeing the title and very surprised by it! Hell's Kitchen and Lines in the sand, or hell, the whole album "falling into infinity" is so underrated because its pretty damn unique, even in their discography.. which ranges from a lot of different genre's in the prog scene. Hell's Kitchen has been consistently been my favorite instrumental from them for years now. I've been a fan since i was a kid, and would love to recommend a lot of DT, but i wont do that. I'll just suggest "Scarred".
One of my favourite guitar solos of all time. The phrasing is so good!
And the part of the song after the solo is where the vocals really shine, I agree. I love that part as well. I think the song is not very typical, as it relies much more on the groove than most of their stuff, but it‘s not a bad introduction, as it‘s not too exuberantly progressive.
God I love Mike Portnoys' bass pedals rolls! So freakin tight!
Funny. I just heard the part that Wolf said this part was very Kings X'ey! Good ear Wolf!
It's very easy: I see you have uploaded a video, dream theater is in the title, i press like 😂😂😂😂✌️
Let's also not forget that in order to ever really and fully appreciate any piece one must listen numerous times in order to allow the music to either resonate or not. Rarely do I hear a song for the very first time and absolutely love it, albeit it does occur from time to time. Dream Theater has many very lengthy songs that propel you through a gamut of emotions. There are parts that I absolutely adore and others not so much. Regardless, this band has been one of my all-time favorites for over 35 years. They are brilliant.
One of the highlights of my concert going life is seeing this song done live exactly as its performed on the record. King's X opened the show and when Dream Theater played this Dug Pinnick came out and sang. 20 some years on and i STILL get goosebumps thinking about it
In case you don't already know the lyrics by heart:
Sometimes, for a moment of bliss
And the passion, we're craving
There's a message we miss
Sometimes when the spirits left alone
We must believe in something
To find if we've grown
[Bridge]
Tragic reflex, shattered calm
Static progress, senses gone
Numb awareness, final psalm
[Chorus]
Swept away with the tide
Through the holes in my hands
Crown of thorns at my side
Drawing lines in the sand
[Verse 2]
Sometimes, if you're perfectly still
You can hear the virgin weeping
For the savior of your will
Sometimes, your castles in the air
And the fantasies you're seeking
Are the crosses you bear
[Bridge]
Sacred conflict, blessed prize
Weeping crosses, stainless eyes
Desperate addict, faith disguised
[Chorus]
Swept away with the tide
Through the holes in my hands
Crown of thorns at my side
Drawing lines in the sand
[Guitar Solo]
[Verse 3]
We fabricate our demons
Invite them into our homes
Have supper with the aliens
And fight the war alone
We conjure up our skeletons
Enlist the den of thieves
Frightened from our closets
Then sewn upon our sleeves
In the stream of consciousness
There is a river crying
Living comes much easier
Once we admit we're dying
[Verse 4]
Sometimes, in the wreckage of our wake
There's a bitterness we harbor
And hate for hatred's sake
Sometime we dig an early grave
And crucify our instincts
For the hope we couldn't save
Sometimes a view from sinless eyes
Centers our perspective
And pacifies our cries
Sometimes the anguish we survive
And the mysteries we nurture
Are the fabrics of our lives
[Chorus]
Swept away with the tide
Through the holes in my hands
Crown of thorns at my side
Drawing lines in the sand
Thank you :) ♥
I always knew HLS would fall in love with dream theater. You have so much joy coming
Well...my way to describe Dream Theater: "The Pink Floyd of metal"
My favorite part lyrically
Living comes much easier once we admit we're dying!!!
Wow that hit me hard 🙏
The album cover was done by Storm Thorgerson, the head artist for Hipgnosis, an old graphic design team that did a lot of album covers for Pink Floyd in particular, along with many other classic bands from Genesis and The Alan Parsons Project to Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin, which is why this may have a very Wish You Were Here or Division Bell aesthetic to it. It's very much an old school style. Thorgerson always made his art very particular and ambiguous. Usually the image is very simple, but the harder you look, the more details you see and he can manage to tell a story or set a scene with just one image.
Yes, about the album cover, it was designed by Storm Thorgerson, same guy who did Dark Side of The Moon, so yeah, it has the classic old school vibe to it.
I loved her reaction ❤️
These reactions are so good!
When I first heard this amazing solo back in 1997, tears flowed because there was so much passion and longing just like HalfLifeSistah. She gets it 👍🏻
Hello guys, congratulations for the channel, I'm a 50 years old metalhead from Chile, and really enjoy watching Sistah reactions and Wolf speeches about being atheist, morals and the like, we're on the same page. Take a look at the song Veil of Maya from Cynic when you have a chance😉.
Let the metal flow!🤘
Thank you :) guys for reaction on my previous asking you for ;)
I wish we had a Derek Sherinian DT for Train of Thought. That would have been absolutely INSANE! His style would have made that absolutely ridiculous!
the other singer in the chorus is the lead singer from Kings X, whose name I have forgotten.
Thank you to whoever recommended this instead of the usual metropolis pt1 and dance of eternity. Those are not good songs to introduce dream theater to someone.
A personal favorites of mine for people approaching dream theater are (ill try to pick one per album) learning to live, scarred, a change of seasons, finally free (even tho scene from a memory pt 2 should be listened in one go as it's a concept album with a story), octavarium, as i am, systematic chaos, the count of tuscany, breaking all illusions, the looking glass, moment of betrayal, and as the last album I'd say fall into the light.
These are imo good songs for someone that wants to explore dream theater a bit deeper.
...in the stream of consciousness, there is a river crying. Living comes much easier once we admit we're dying
One thing I totally love is the way they drop call backs into their new albums.
You hear it and you instantly remember the story that melody came from.
You guys are more into fast heavy stuff. This should fits you more:
Dream Theater - Glass Prison
Nice that you heard those songs together as it maybe was planned. Voice of Doug "fckn awesome " Pinnick is Awesome
King's X was one of the inspirations for Dream Theater. Their lead singer is guest appearing with James during the chorus.
Fun Fact, it's not Hell's Kitchen + Lines in the Sand, It's actually Burning My Soul + Hell's Kitchen + Lines in the Sand, and Hell's Kitchen was originally the instrumental in Burning My Soul. You can hear the original in the Lost Not Forgotten Archives: Falling Into Infinity Demos.
This is one of the best best albums ever, in my opinion. It's a style that I don't see as often as I would like.
my reaction to this song is literally what the dude is doing. straight face and vibe.
You can see how she is just feelin it😂🔥
I started listening to Death so today I found out what is your intro song ;)
React another prog, "Neal Morse"
1. The neal morse band
2. Transatlantic
3. Spocks beard
4. Flying colors
Thanks for saying transatlantic, fellow men of culture.
This is one of the best reactions to a Dream Theater song that I have ever seen. So much genuine emotion. It reminds me of when I was 8 years old and heard them for the first time. They have been my idols ever since.
Yeah, DT really benefits from multiple listens. First time through most of their songs can be overwhelming and feel chaotic, but on subsequent listens you’ll start to become aware of the underlying structure and how it actually all comes together. You’ll begin to anticipate the music and feel how it ebbs and flows in such a unique way. Hope you do more of their music as I really like your reactions. Sistah feels music the same way I do inside, but in a much more extroverted fashion. :D
4:46 Remind me why this is my fav DT's instrumental. still gives me goosebumps to this day.
If I remember correctly, the producer on this album was pushing the band towards a more stripped down, commercial sound. The band was by and large unhappy with the result.
It wasn't the producer, per se, it was the label that was really encouraging that attitude. Kevin Shirley did certainly encourage that stripped back aspect, but that what he was hired to do by the label's recommendation.
Hey all this is my first comment on your channel but I've watched alot. I keep remembering my first time hearing this song when I was 18 in 1997. I honestly didn't like it and I had been a Dream Theater fan since 1992. And it's just like you said the parts that sounds like Kings X just don't fit right into a Dream Theater song. Other than that this song has grown on me over the years and now I love it. I really enjoy the contrast between you and your wife. She is feeling pure musical emotion while your are analyzing everything. I am more towards the analysis side of things and this song is full of amazing music. But watching her react is very special and an almost private moment. You can really get into and enjoy Dream Theater if you do it the right way. And this was a great start. The rest of this album is very good but also very commercialized. I have many favorites but may I suggest listening to Change of Seasons next. It's with the same lineup but is one of the most awesome progressive metal songs of all time. Thank you again.
Dug Pinnick from Kings X on background on the chorus is so freaking sweet!!! Great album from start to finish!
John Petrucci has a very "David Gilmore" vibe in the slow parts. Very nice!
You know what, I've wanted to check out Dream Theater for many years but never got around to it. This is as good an opportunity as any, I will be taking this journey along with you.
2 of my favourite songs of DT. Amazing ! :) How much i listened to these songs......
Same here. More than 2 decades. How time flies
Good stuff! Thanks for sharing another great DT song.👏✌
Awesome Reaction !!!! The only 2 Bands that I "feel"and "look" like #halflifesistah are Dream Theater and Unleash The Archers !!! Both Bands take My breath away on So many levels !!!! Cheers !!!!
Dream theater, the real inventors of prog metal, or how to have 100 emotions in a truely beautiful piece !
It's the right song. You downloaded Hel's Kitchen [instrumental] and Lines in the Sand [with vocals].
@23:52 LOL "This chorus here is very King's X-ie" Well Doug Pinnick (lead singer of King's X) is singing on the song so, that was a pretty decent comparison. LOL
You know the extra singer on the tune is the dude from King's X :) Wolf, Prog has so much going on it can throw people for a loop at first. Spin it again and just follow the drummer through the song, eyes closed headphones. Do it again and follow the guitar, both of them have amazing journeys.
Octavarium, by far my favorite song from Dream Theater.
The guest singer is actually Doug Pinnick from King's X. Nice ear! :)
My favorite part is also the mid-section with the Pink Floyd meets Southern Rock section.
The most beautiful songs from Dream Theater in my opinion are:
- Goodnight Kiss
- Through Her Eyes
- Repentance
- Trial of Tears
- The Glass Prison
- Vacant
- Octavarium
- The Ministry of Lost Souls
- Beneath the Surface
Both Hells Kitchen and Lines in the Sand run together on the CD with a very short break.
The solo keyboard intro Is lines in the sand.
You did not mention that the back up vocals is Dug Pinnik of Kings X.
I love these songs together and DT is the most talented band in the world.
Both raw talent, technical virtuosity and their body of work.
Been a fan since Images and Words.
And have met James LaBrie
Mazzy-dog says thanks for the shout out at the end BTW, with your "poopetyscoop"
Listening to this is no different than love making