Low notes: B3 - Ari Bb3 - Ari because vibrato A3 - Jade G#3 - Ari G3 - Ari F#3 - tie F3 - tie E3 - Jade Eb3 - Jade D3 - Jade ( vibrato ) Belting: A4: Ari ( sounds fuller ) Bb4: Ari B4: Ari C5: Ari ( clean Celine vibrato! ) C#5: Ari ( more emotion ) D5: tie Eb5: Ari E5: Ari F5: Ari ( obv break free ;) ) F#5: tie G#5: Ari A5: Ari ( so powerful! ) Bb5: Ari ( held it longer ) Falsetto: E5: Ari F5: Ari F#5: Jade G5: Ari G#5: Tie ( interesting note change of Ari! ) A5: Ari Bb5: Ari B5: Ari ( so powerful ) C6: Tie ( Ari sustained ) C#6: Ari D6: Ari Eb6: Ari E6: Ari As you can see, Ariana is just on a different level. Don't get me wrong, Jade is a amazing range and a lovely tone. c:
Low notes: B3 - tie Bb3 - Ari A3 - tie G#3 - tie G3 - Ari F#3 - tie F3 - Jade (very close, Jade was just slightly fuller) E3 - Jade Eb3 - Jade D3 - Jade Belting: A4: tie Bb4: tie B4: Ari C5: Ari C#5: Ari D5: Tie Eb5: Ari E5: Ari F5: Ari F#5: Ari G#5: Ari A5: Ari Bb5: Ari Falsetto: E5: Ari (because of that precise run) F5: Jade F#5: tie G5: Ari G#5: Tie A5: Jade Bb5: Ari B5: Ari C6: Tie (Jade´s riff was great but Ari sustained, hard to decide, let´s make it a tie) C#6: Tie D6: Ari Eb6: Ari E6: Ari Ari: 30 Jade: 17 What can i say, both are amazing but Ariana is Ariana, she´s one of top5 best vocalists of this generation, there are only very few people who can challange her, Jade is still really amazing.
These 2 remind me of each other sometimes with their falsetto usage but technically Ariana is superior to Jade in Lows & Belting but falsetto I feel they are more comparative and maybe sometimes agility w/ Ariana having the edge showing more technical skill‼️ Love ❤️ this video - both are amazing …. I also think in belting Jade’s vibrato holds her back a good bit - needs more development & relaxation - sounds very tense a lot of times ….. both of their tones are sooo gorgeous in their falsettoes
Definitely. Even though she did lipsync a fair amount of her high notes, she was consistently able to belt up to Eb5 live (in Love Me Or Leave Me and Woman Like Me) and even hit her highest belt ever (a Bb5 in Woman Like Me on the first night of the tour).
@@notyourdaddy2148 It was actually live on opening night (at Belfast on 9th April). She took the vocal from that night and added it to the track so that she could lipsync it because, except for Ariana, no one would dare to sing a long note like that, ending with a sustained Bb5, every night.
@@varunravi27 it doesn’t sound like it to me, she the sound quality is much different from before the high notes but i don’t doubt she could do it on a live setting
Oh man...jade is my absolute favorite but I can't lie Ariana is technically better and more rounded. That said I prefer jade because she is flexible and her stylistic way of singing does it for me. She is amazing on stage and I'd rather watch her perform over Ariana 🙈 still love Ariana though.
I have been waiting for this 🤍 Jade and Ariana are more alike as vocalists than some people like to think. Anyways, this is my opinion: Low notes - B3: Tie (both were supported, even though Ariana's was fuller) Bb3: Tie A3: Tie G#3: Tie G3: Jade F#3: Tie F3: Tie E3: Ariana Eb3: Jade D3: Tie Belted notes - A4: Tie Bb4: Tie B4: Ariana C5: DEFINITELY Ariana C#5: Ariana (I think Jade was overpushing it a bit) D5: Tie Eb5: Tie E5: Tie F5: Ariana F#5: Ariana G#5: Tie A5: Ariana Bb5: Tie Falsetto - E5: Ariana F5: Tie F#5: Tie G5: Ariana G#5: Tie A5: Tie Bb5: Tie B5: Tie C6: Ariana C#6: Ariana D6: Jade Eb6: Ariana E6: Ariana Low notes - Jade > Ariana (this is the only register in which my opinion does not apply; both ladies have equally good lows. Both have consistent support/freedom down to G3, sometimes even F#3; in terms of projection, Ariana tips the scale slightly, even though she does tend to sing with a lot of breathiness) Belted notes - Ariana > Jade (Ariana is consistent up to at least Eb5 while Jade, despite having improved her belting recently, remains at B4/C5) Falsetto - Ariana > Jade (in terms of overall control, I'd say these two are equal; both of them are able to maintain good pitch most of the time and can use their vocal agility in this register; but, in terms of consistency, I would give it to Ariana because, even on a bad day, her falsetto is still good, at least most of the time) Ariana - 32 Jade - 23 I never realised Jade would be this far behind Ariana, considering how competent she is, but Ariana wins!
Would argue that Ariana has a stronger lower register than Jade. Jade’s consistent down to G3. And despite Ariana only consistent with G3/G#3, she’s able to maintain better quality in the D3-Bb3 range, with support down to F#3 at her best, whereas Jade has never supported below a G3. As for belted notes and mid range in general, I’d also give it to Ariana. Jade pushes and strains a lot past B4, whereas Ariana has more ease up to Eb5, with consistency up to B4/C5. However, Jade puts up a fight when it comes to opened belts, as she’s inconsistently able to produce resonance while Ariana hasn’t been able to resonate since her regression. Upper register also goes to Ariana, who has a more connected head voice. Jade has only recently started to see improvements in her head voice, as she’s relied on her falsetto throughout the years. Ariana: (F#3)G3/G#3 - B4/C5(Eb5) Jade: G3 - B4(C5)
@@taeslilclown9801 Actually, that statement about Ariana's resonance is quite untrue. She has resonated quite a lot in 2021 (e.g.- the C5s in her cover of It's All Coming Back To Me Now, some A4s and B4s in her performance of Just Look Up).
@@varunravi27 she’s improved a lot around Sweetener era but I’m not entirely sure if she’s resonated again. have seen those performances you’re talking about, and they’re definitely open and free, especially in her Tattooed Heart performance
In My Opinion: B3 - Ari Bb3 - Ari A3 - Ari G#3 - Ari G3 - Ari F#3 - Jade F3 - Jade E3 - Jade Eb3 - Tie D3 - Jade A4 - Ari Bb4 - Jade B4 - Tie C5 - Ari C#5 - Ari D5 - Ari Eb5 - Ari E5 - Ari F5 - Ari F#5 - Tie G#5 - Jade A5 - Ari Bb5 - Ari E5 - Ari F5 - Ari F#5 - Ari G5 - Ari G#5 - Ari A5 - Ari Bb5 - Tie B5 - Jade C6 - Ari C#6 - Ari D6 - Jade Eb6 - Ari E6 - Ari
Sweetie perrie isn't on Arianas level. IMO Leigh Anne is technically better than perrie in belting now but none of little mix are better than Ariana let's just stop.
Hope you liked It! 🤍
More *Ariana Grande* Videos ⏬
czcams.com/play/PL_bLxnTF2SM1OsVNiBHkCV1GiueD2voWW.html
More *Jade Thirlwall* Videos ⏬
czcams.com/play/PL_bLxnTF2SM37bHIEI31cAhzhtyYyUr3p.html
Both are great vocalists,but Ariana is just next level!
Ari is just on another level , her control and technique are one of the best
Low notes:
B3 - Ari
Bb3 - Ari because vibrato
A3 - Jade
G#3 - Ari
G3 - Ari
F#3 - tie
F3 - tie
E3 - Jade
Eb3 - Jade
D3 - Jade ( vibrato )
Belting:
A4: Ari ( sounds fuller )
Bb4: Ari
B4: Ari
C5: Ari ( clean Celine vibrato! )
C#5: Ari ( more emotion )
D5: tie
Eb5: Ari
E5: Ari
F5: Ari ( obv break free ;) )
F#5: tie
G#5: Ari
A5: Ari ( so powerful! )
Bb5: Ari ( held it longer )
Falsetto:
E5: Ari
F5: Ari
F#5: Jade
G5: Ari
G#5: Tie ( interesting note change of Ari! )
A5: Ari
Bb5: Ari
B5: Ari ( so powerful )
C6: Tie ( Ari sustained )
C#6: Ari
D6: Ari
Eb6: Ari
E6: Ari
As you can see, Ariana is just on a different level. Don't get me wrong, Jade is a amazing range and a lovely tone. c:
Low notes:
B3 - tie
Bb3 - Ari
A3 - tie
G#3 - tie
G3 - Ari
F#3 - tie
F3 - Jade (very close, Jade was just slightly fuller)
E3 - Jade
Eb3 - Jade
D3 - Jade
Belting:
A4: tie
Bb4: tie
B4: Ari
C5: Ari
C#5: Ari
D5: Tie
Eb5: Ari
E5: Ari
F5: Ari
F#5: Ari
G#5: Ari
A5: Ari
Bb5: Ari
Falsetto:
E5: Ari (because of that precise run)
F5: Jade
F#5: tie
G5: Ari
G#5: Tie
A5: Jade
Bb5: Ari
B5: Ari
C6: Tie (Jade´s riff was great but Ari sustained, hard to decide, let´s make it a tie)
C#6: Tie
D6: Ari
Eb6: Ari
E6: Ari
Ari: 30
Jade: 17
What can i say, both are amazing but Ariana is Ariana, she´s one of top5 best vocalists of this generation, there are only very few people who can challange her, Jade is still really amazing.
These 2 remind me of each other sometimes with their falsetto usage but technically Ariana is superior to Jade in Lows & Belting but falsetto I feel they are more comparative and maybe sometimes agility w/ Ariana having the edge showing more technical skill‼️
Love ❤️ this video - both are amazing ….
I also think in belting Jade’s vibrato holds her back a good bit - needs more development & relaxation - sounds very tense a lot of times …..
both of their tones are sooo gorgeous in their falsettoes
Jades upper belts from improved a lot in confetti era
Definitely. Even though she did lipsync a fair amount of her high notes, she was consistently able to belt up to Eb5 live (in Love Me Or Leave Me and Woman Like Me) and even hit her highest belt ever (a Bb5 in Woman Like Me on the first night of the tour).
@@varunravi27 ikr
@@varunravi27 the Bb5 was lipped but i mean, it’s still her, she recorded so yeah
@@notyourdaddy2148 It was actually live on opening night (at Belfast on 9th April). She took the vocal from that night and added it to the track so that she could lipsync it because, except for Ariana, no one would dare to sing a long note like that, ending with a sustained Bb5, every night.
@@varunravi27 it doesn’t sound like it to me, she the sound quality is much different from before the high notes but i don’t doubt she could do it on a live setting
my love ari and my baby jade, ari is just the greatest vocalist of this decade but jade is an AMAZING vocalist
I LOVE videos like this one 😍
Same
I think if Jade did more straight tone we could really hear the power and tone
i love both omg😂
Ariana 👑🛐
We need Ariana vs Halle (Chloe x Halle)!
Jade is gonna prove herself solo. I am just going to wait
Queens!!! 👏👏😍😍❤❤☺☺
I love them both but we all agree that Ariana always win😍
Oh God this is really hard to select...tie
Oh man...jade is my absolute favorite but I can't lie Ariana is technically better and more rounded. That said I prefer jade because she is flexible and her stylistic way of singing does it for me. She is amazing on stage and I'd rather watch her perform over Ariana 🙈 still love Ariana though.
No love for the lonely had sm good lows
I love jade and I'm more a fan of her than Ariana but vocally Ariana is better. She is just on another level and her technique is great.
Ariana grande canta demais
Quem esta jade
Lows : jade
A4: jade
Bb4: jade
B4:tie
C5: ari
C#5:ari (jade was flat)
D5:jade
Eb5:ari
E5:tie
F5:tie (jade for power/ ari for ease)
F#5:ari
G#5: jade
A5:ari
Bb5:ari
Head voice
E5:tie
F5: jade
F#5:jade
G5:jade
G#5:jade
A5:jade
Bb5:ari
B5:ari
C6:ari
C#6:ari
D6:tie
Eb6:tie
E6:ari
They're one of the few light sopranos in pop music that I absolutely adore❤❤❤
I have been waiting for this 🤍 Jade and Ariana are more alike as vocalists than some people like to think.
Anyways, this is my opinion:
Low notes -
B3: Tie (both were supported, even though Ariana's was fuller)
Bb3: Tie
A3: Tie
G#3: Tie
G3: Jade
F#3: Tie
F3: Tie
E3: Ariana
Eb3: Jade
D3: Tie
Belted notes -
A4: Tie
Bb4: Tie
B4: Ariana
C5: DEFINITELY Ariana
C#5: Ariana (I think Jade was overpushing it a bit)
D5: Tie
Eb5: Tie
E5: Tie
F5: Ariana
F#5: Ariana
G#5: Tie
A5: Ariana
Bb5: Tie
Falsetto -
E5: Ariana
F5: Tie
F#5: Tie
G5: Ariana
G#5: Tie
A5: Tie
Bb5: Tie
B5: Tie
C6: Ariana
C#6: Ariana
D6: Jade
Eb6: Ariana
E6: Ariana
Low notes - Jade > Ariana (this is the only register in which my opinion does not apply; both ladies have equally good lows. Both have consistent support/freedom down to G3, sometimes even F#3; in terms of projection, Ariana tips the scale slightly, even though she does tend to sing with a lot of breathiness)
Belted notes - Ariana > Jade (Ariana is consistent up to at least Eb5 while Jade, despite having improved her belting recently, remains at B4/C5)
Falsetto - Ariana > Jade (in terms of overall control, I'd say these two are equal; both of them are able to maintain good pitch most of the time and can use their vocal agility in this register; but, in terms of consistency, I would give it to Ariana because, even on a bad day, her falsetto is still good, at least most of the time)
Ariana - 32
Jade - 23
I never realised Jade would be this far behind Ariana, considering how competent she is, but Ariana wins!
Would argue that Ariana has a stronger lower register than Jade. Jade’s consistent down to G3. And despite Ariana only consistent with G3/G#3, she’s able to maintain better quality in the D3-Bb3 range, with support down to F#3 at her best, whereas Jade has never supported below a G3.
As for belted notes and mid range in general, I’d also give it to Ariana. Jade pushes and strains a lot past B4, whereas Ariana has more ease up to Eb5, with consistency up to B4/C5. However, Jade puts up a fight when it comes to opened belts, as she’s inconsistently able to produce resonance while Ariana hasn’t been able to resonate since her regression.
Upper register also goes to Ariana, who has a more connected head voice. Jade has only recently started to see improvements in her head voice, as she’s relied on her falsetto throughout the years.
Ariana: (F#3)G3/G#3 - B4/C5(Eb5)
Jade: G3 - B4(C5)
@@taeslilclown9801 Actually, that statement about Ariana's resonance is quite untrue. She has resonated quite a lot in 2021 (e.g.- the C5s in her cover of It's All Coming Back To Me Now, some A4s and B4s in her performance of Just Look Up).
@@varunravi27 she’s improved a lot around Sweetener era but I’m not entirely sure if she’s resonated again. have seen those performances you’re talking about, and they’re definitely open and free, especially in her Tattooed Heart performance
@@taeslilclown9801 Ariana does and can resonate and didn't regress imo
@@taeslilclown9801 She has resonated after that imo so I disagree but I respect your opinion
In My Opinion:
B3 - Ari
Bb3 - Ari
A3 - Ari
G#3 - Ari
G3 - Ari
F#3 - Jade
F3 - Jade
E3 - Jade
Eb3 - Tie
D3 - Jade
A4 - Ari
Bb4 - Jade
B4 - Tie
C5 - Ari
C#5 - Ari
D5 - Ari
Eb5 - Ari
E5 - Ari
F5 - Ari
F#5 - Tie
G#5 - Jade
A5 - Ari
Bb5 - Ari
E5 - Ari
F5 - Ari
F#5 - Ari
G5 - Ari
G#5 - Ari
A5 - Ari
Bb5 - Tie
B5 - Jade
C6 - Ari
C#6 - Ari
D6 - Jade
Eb6 - Ari
E6 - Ari
Can i ask you where was this performance of Moonlight 5:24?
Hong Kong
@@popvocalstv thanks
Wait I suggested this- I think?
Maybe but I have a playlist with these clips since July 2022 🗣️🗣️🗣️
@@popvocalstv Awesome! Love it!
7:03 what's the name of that song??? She killed It 👁👄👁💅🏻 and also the F#5 on head voice
Only 1
@@popvocalstv thank you so much🙏🏻
Goodnight n Go and Only 1
Where was Ariana’s F#3 and Jade’s G5 (upper register)?
Charlotte and Brisbane
I think Jade's G5 is "No More Sad Songs"
@@popvocalstv Thank you!!
Jade nice but in little mix, only Perrie is a competition to Ariana
definitely not
Sweetie perrie isn't on Arianas level. IMO Leigh Anne is technically better than perrie in belting now but none of little mix are better than Ariana let's just stop.
@@AlwaysLM2011 leigh anne what? Leigh anne is the worst singer of litt’e mix lmao, Perrie the best one, yall real delusional
@@lvc_as9763 anyway like I said none of them are better than Ariana period.
@@AlwaysLM2011 i dont recall saying she was better, I said she’s the only one that can be a competition
Jade is top
No se, si soy el único pero sus voces siempre me han parecido un poco similares