@@sobhankhaleghi3041 arthur is like a real person. It's like i was there to be lectured by him. Batman is just a comic book hero, with fiction. History>Fiction lol
What I do is whenever I finish a playthrough, I wait a couple months like 2-4 months. Then play again like it’s my first time experiencing this great game. Works at least for me.
This game just takes me back to my last year in high school. I remember being so hyped for this game and it was such a beautiful experience playing this game. It's an experience that I will constantly look back.
My son Davide died last month of brain cancer, on January 15th ... he was just turned 18.... I listen this song every day because he loves Arthur so much and RDR2 was his favourite game by far. I know that the story of Arthur's illness and death inspired him a lot, helped him deal with his own. I will love you forever my son
My partner who passed last August, loved watching me play this, (I am a nearly 60 year old girl😊) Said when his time comes, he'd like this song played. ❤
When Sister Caldera said “Do a loving act”, that changed me, now I need to help others in need the same way Arthur did, this game is such a masterpiece.
You can tell that it broke dutch down when he said that, the realization of such a blindness was all too clear to him.. to have abandoned his son was the worst sin that he could have committed, and he did so with a cold heart.. to both Arthur, and John. Arthurs words cut him deep. Ah Dutch... there was good in you.. cant cry about what could have been tho. Thats the way it is
Things we learn playing this game: - a bad man can turn into a good Man - its never too late for redemption - be loyal to what matters - revenge is a fool's game - you can't do bad things and expect to have a good life - there is no shame looking for a better world - life is full of pain, but there is also love and beauty - we can’t change what’s done, we can only move on A truly masterpiece, i think i never played such a wonderful game.
I preordered this game and got it five years ago. I finally just beat it three weeks ago on it’s five year anniversary. I purposely waited that long be I knew once I beat it, there wouldn’t be a game as great at RDR 2 for years to come. I’m 29 and I’ve never cried so hard in my life over a character besides John Marston I’m RDR 1
@@Libertycityking17 I know exactly what you feel... I just played the game years after released with zero spoilers....I cant remember anything that made me cry this much
i actually also just beat rdr2 just 2 days ago and whenever im here listeing to this im just end up in tears the story the character bonding in this game is amazing its been 2 days but still everytime i see a arthur morgan video even a meme i just cry the last mission was so fucking sad i cried the whole mission i wished if arthur had drink a tonic potion i wish
Today my brother died. He got me into Red dead redemption. We both looked forward to Read Dead Redemtion 2. We both loved the game. This song stuck into my mind. Hours after he passed and here I am... I'm sorry
When this song plays, everything feels like it's in slow motion just like in the game. There's not even words that can describe the feelings I have for this game and how sentimental it gets to me.
I just completed it for the 3rd time yesterday. I always wanted to show my dad this game cause he liked western movies, and overall just games with a beautiful story. I was thinking that this time i would play it with him and show how beautiful this game is, and Im 100% sure he would’ve loved this story. We were planning on playing it together a few months back and he was looking forward to it. Unfortunately my dad passed away before we ever got the chance. He died 2 months ago and I miss him so much. I always remember him for this song I don’t know why though. Rip dad I love you
Recently played RDR2. The game being so popular, along with it being 4 years old, I was spoiled Arthur's death and the final fistfight with Micah. However, I did not know about the last ride. I was not expecting to actually shed a tear for a game I was spoiled the ending of.
When Arthur knew he was going to die, he said he was scared. I will never forget that look of his face.... For me, it's the best game i have ever played so far. I will not delete it, until another heart touching game out come. It's not only a masterpiece, it's something more.
You simply arent human if you played through the whole game , got to Arthurs last ride and heard this song and didnt have some form of emotional reaction
Hosea: When I die, Just want to be buried with friends. Lenny: Me too.. with friends or with family, I dont think that matters more than that Hosea: What about you Arthur Arthur: Bah I dont care in that nonsense Hosea: OOH come on Arthur: Face me to the West so I can watch the setting sun And... remember all the fun times we that way...
What's pretty cool about that quote is that instead of Arthur watching a setting sun symbolising him fading away to death, he instead watches a sunrise which symbolises that he brought life to John, so that he could finally have a life with his family.
Just beat it with my girlfriend she wasn’t super into games but she is now and she cried during this mission and said “I never thought a game could be so beautiful” it was my third time playing the game all the way through and i still cried I think I cried more then the first time Especially when Arthur tells the sister he’s afraid gets me every time to see him so strong as a man yet he’s so afraid to face death
It’s 2023 and this is still the most unavoidably saddest song from the saddest ending to any game. Just listened for the first time in 3 years and brought immediate tears to my eyes
I played it for the first time in October once, then got it for Christmas since it was taken off game pass the week after I got it, man... what a game.
i played it over my first time with cheats unlocked and it still made me upset when Arthur died, Sooooooo i played it over again without cheats and a 100% full honor bar
With high honor when this plays in the one of the ending missions when Arthur is riding his horse, I literally couldn't stop crying. Same things make us smile, make us cry 😢😢😢
It’s dumb but I legitimately feel like I’m grieving for Arthur. It’s been days and I still feel choked up about it. Never had this happen from any game, book, or TV series before.
@@katyalupochev9589 its not dumb at all. Great games with great stories are hard to find and when you play one like RDR2 you invest yourself into characters. Rockstar just knows how to make epic games.
It never hits the same after completing the game for the first time, nothing compares to the excitement of booting up rdr2 to finish the game and be hit with Arthur’s death. That scene hit hard for the first time, it will never feel the same after confronting Micah at mount hagen
Arthur taught us to be good people to be loyal even though he does not exist doesn't mean that the emotions in the urge to do the loyal and right thing doesn't exist.
I Just Finished The Game Today (Without The Epilogue) When I Heard This Music In Game It Made Me Cry Knowing What's Gonna Happen Next And Now My Eyes Teared Up When I Heard This Again Now 😢 Best game I Ever Played.
This game will never leave me, I’ve been listening to this music since my first playthrough. I think rdr2 will forever and ever be my favorite video game, probably my favorite over all form of media/entertainment. It feels good to see new comments even still.
The quote from AC4 Black Flag when Blackbeard says: "In a world without gold, we might've been heroes" kind of gives me Arthur Morgan vibes. Despite being an outlaw he always did what he did out of loyalty and in the end just wanted John and the boy to get away from it all when he couldn't
Red Dead Redemption 2 was an absolute masterpiece. The soundtrack, the story, the characters, the gameplay… EVERYTHING. It’s the greatest game ever made imo.
The only thing i knew is that Arthur will die. Cause i never thought i would play this masterpiece. I had no idea about anything else and i was still astonished and cried my eyes out when Arthur died.
Samurai Goroh LOL. Here I was, reading through countless comments with Arthur’s most meaningful and emotional quotes.. and this just made me laugh so hard (and cry a little :) ♥️👍🏻
I learned so much from a man that never existed
@@sobhankhaleghi3041 what the fuck?
Me too he tought me so much
@@sobhankhaleghi3041 lol in my opinion batman was a dick
More than I ever learned from school, LMAO
@@sobhankhaleghi3041 arthur is like a real person. It's like i was there to be lectured by him. Batman is just a comic book hero, with fiction.
History>Fiction lol
Achievement Unlocked:
*Red Dead Depression*
You're great. 👍👍
Yes
I swear why does everybody have to copy comments 😂
Otario :)
Ikr I got really sad after the very end because of how it ended
The sad thing about this game, is that we will never be able to play it again for the first time
What I do is whenever I finish a playthrough, I wait a couple months like 2-4 months. Then play again like it’s my first time experiencing this great game. Works at least for me.
@@RedHollow.yep it worked for me after 1 year
This game just takes me back to my last year in high school. I remember being so hyped for this game and it was such a beautiful experience playing this game. It's an experience that I will constantly look back.
That’s why when GTA 6 comes out, enjoy every second on your first playthrough.
It Hurts Even More When I Saw Micah Blow A Hole In Arthur's Head When I Thoughtt I Saves Him For My First Ending
The same things that make us smile, make us cry.
-Big Smoke
You picked the wrong game fool!!!!
Yes
Pretty much...
Make us laugh*
Make us laugh*
Let this game inspire you to live your own life on High Honor.
lmao enough of this low honor shit I'm boutta go catch and release a bunch of fish
SchwiftedBear or greet a bunch of people
Dam man
@@esco5593 You sir are a fish!
Good thing you don't get low honor for killing that racist guy in Saint Denis. Or antagonizing a theater show.
I’d literally give anything to play this game for the first time again...
Same
I cried during this scene on my second playthrough, because it's still hard to face the fact that Arthur passes
Same
I think we all would
your soul?
My son Davide died last month of brain cancer, on January 15th ... he was just turned 18.... I listen this song every day because he loves Arthur so much and RDR2 was his favourite game by far. I know that the story of Arthur's illness and death inspired him a lot, helped him deal with his own. I will love you forever my son
Im sorry for your loss, be strong!
Thats what youre son want now.
im sorry for your loss 😢
Sorry bro
Life is hard .head up move forward keep memories be healthy
rest in peace to your son my man. And stay strong, sending you my thoughts and prayers.
Arthur wasn't a good man, but he did his best to become one and that is commendable in and of itself
wtf the act man
Yes sir. Beautiful masterpiece of a game.
You... It's you glad another CZcamsr is listening to this
LOOK OUT
Finally someone who can accept that Arthur isn't a normal morally good dude, but still appreciates him
I don't know why but I feel like Arthur was more than a "video game character"
Turtleboy 156 he a god deem family member
@@alexkhaid Yeah
@Turtleboy 156
I know what you mean, he's like a part of my soul I would say
Dominika Nowakowska fr tho
same
And now I remember when we said that we don’t want this dude, we want John marston
What dumb fools we were
Damn right there
I want both
I remember thinking that he will be a cheap replacement with no real character. Sounds ridiculous now.
They could make it just like gta v, switch charachters.
They couldn’t have, it’s Arthur’s story. Watching it through John would be worse.
This was played at my brothers funeral. Sometime I listen to this to pretend he’s still with me. 2006 - 2023
May your brother rest in peace
My partner who passed last August, loved watching me play this, (I am a nearly 60 year old girl😊) Said when his time comes, he'd like this song played. ❤
Played the game a couple of times, and cry like a baby at this bit.... 😢
Rip
Two brothers lost eh?
When Sister Caldera said “Do a loving act”, that changed me, now I need to help others in need the same way Arthur did, this game is such a masterpiece.
I did that whole side mission but her line didn’t play during Arthur’s ride back, which upset me.
i think you were supposed to talk to her afterwards too@@tazinboor3913
@@tazinboor3913 i usually do all side missions i encounter but i didn't encounter this so it didn't show the cutscene i was legit mad
Beautiful you must be Arthur Morgan reincarnation after all. But that's life and it is what it is.
Imo the reverend swanson talk is better cus it's more personal to arthur cus swanson knows what type of man arthur is
I gave you all I had Dutch
ARTHUR MORGAN except tuberculosis, should have gave him that too.
Edit: Jesus Christ! 1.9k likes? Damn, thanks for the love.
@@ImAfemaleNoob2 idk why but i found your comment funny af XD
You can tell that it broke dutch down when he said that, the realization of such a blindness was all too clear to him.. to have abandoned his son was the worst sin that he could have committed, and he did so with a cold heart.. to both Arthur, and John. Arthurs words cut him deep. Ah Dutch... there was good in you.. cant cry about what could have been tho. Thats the way it is
Where did you find your profile photo
Oh, Arthur 😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Things we learn playing this game:
- a bad man can turn into a good Man
- its never too late for redemption
- be loyal to what matters
- revenge is a fool's game
- you can't do bad things and expect to have a good life
- there is no shame looking for a better world
- life is full of pain, but there is also love and beauty
- we can’t change what’s done, we can only move on
A truly masterpiece, i think i never played such a wonderful game.
- Dutch had a goddamn plan
- No one could ever find Gavin
@@TheBoobTube Thats because Nigel (the man calling for Gavin) has a dissociative identity disorder and is actually Gavin himself
@@Cr4ix wait really? is this canon? where did you learn this?
Go play god of war lol
That's nothing to be afraid of. Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act.
Just finished the game and I'm just in tears
I preordered this game and got it five years ago. I finally just beat it three weeks ago on it’s five year anniversary. I purposely waited that long be I knew once I beat it, there wouldn’t be a game as great at RDR 2 for years to come. I’m 29 and I’ve never cried so hard in my life over a character besides John Marston I’m RDR 1
@@Libertycityking17 I know exactly what you feel... I just played the game years after released with zero spoilers....I cant remember anything that made me cry this much
i actually also just beat rdr2 just 2 days ago and whenever im here listeing to this im just end up in tears the story the character bonding in this game is amazing its been 2 days but still everytime i see a arthur morgan video even a meme i just cry the last mission was so fucking sad i cried the whole mission i wished if arthur had drink a tonic potion i wish
This scene makes me tear up even when it shows up randomly on CZcams.
“All them years…”
Finished last night, and am sitting here bawling, hearing That's the Way It Is and Unshaken again 💔😭
“You’re a good man Arthur Morgan”
The best decision I made was to play this game and do things with high honor, and hear those last words on the way to camp
A good man..
Arthur Morgan:
Lived an outlaw...
Died a hero.
Died an inlaw.
And that's only half of the story
would you of let him live
Thanos plis dont snap plis plis NO0O0 slowly fades into dust
YOU bastard you killed tony stark why?
Arthur: I’m not a good man
Fan base: Arthur is a good man
I really enjoyed the game and the ending was sad for me, but after all I fought that Arthur was just an outlaw and he did many bad things.
Arthur not a good man
Arthur's a real man
@Findlay Robertson I can apply that to all members of the gang even Dutcb, yet except obviously Micah
It's not canon
Arthur: Am I a joke to you?
For everyone out there remember: "Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act"
Take that gamble, Arthur took it and made a lot of folk happy
Arthur in the game kills over 1000 people😊
“You're a good man, Arthur”
Today my brother died. He got me into Red dead redemption. We both looked forward to Read Dead Redemtion 2. We both loved the game. This song stuck into my mind. Hours after he passed and here I am... I'm sorry
im really sorry
So sorry about your loss
May him rest in peace stay strong man
I’m sorry
I’m really sorry about your brother I lost my dad a few years ago of a heart attack and this song always reminds me of him.
"Hey there, mister!" - Arthur Morgan, 1899
"You're allright, boah" - Arthur Morgan 1899
"Who's a good boah?" - Arthur Morgan 1899
“Easy boah!” Arthur Morgan, 1899
Randy Marsh Goddammit Randy you’ve been playing Red dead redemption again haven’t you?
"The back of your head is your best feature" - Arthur Morgan, 1899
"Revenge is a fool's game."
-Arthur Morgan
1863-1899
1863-1999?
@@dom8153 Yes, but mama aqui o glup glup
@@dom8153 he would be 36 what's strange about that
So he was 36 years old.
@@Kamal_AL-Hinai Mhm
No scene in any movie, show or other video game made me cry as much as this. Masterpiece. Long live RDR2.
-Abigail Roberts...
-I always was a good thief
-That you was
Player: *starts crying*
It's strange how you can have such a complex connection with a completely fictional character
It's because Arthur is realistic, unlike most video game characters.
John too, at least in old RDR. Died for his family.😢😢😢
@Caçador de Spam no u
@Caçador de Spam no u
@Caçador de Spam yeah curse us in your language while you still can.
Graphics: 10/10
Music: 10/10
Acting: 10/10
Gameplay: 10/10
Story: 1000/10
Sadness: 1,000,000/10
Truer words my eyes have not seen.
Arthur:100000000/10
*hotel trivago and uncle lumbago*
Makes me sad that some people think this game isn't good.
Bro,this is legit one of the only songs that i can't listen to without crying and feeling depressed for no reason
When this song plays, everything feels like it's in slow motion just like in the game. There's not even words that can describe the feelings I have for this game and how sentimental it gets to me.
@@theneverenders5018 same
Facts
The story of Red Dead Redemption 1 & 2; will always be such an important piece of my life.
It's the only thing in any media that's ever made me cry
*" I gave you all I had Dutch"*
- *_ARTHUR MORGAN_*
ESKA - FIFA
“I... I...”
-Dutch
"I did"
thank God there was a epilogue
without it, it would be too sad for me xd
ESKA - FIFA pretty messed up how Dutch just left him “your like a son to me Arthur”
*TAHITI*
Some People Will Forget Arthur...
But Not Us....
Juan Cisneros not us.
Juan Cisneros not us.
Some people will forget Tony
But not us
Not us
Not us
I just completed it for the 3rd time yesterday. I always wanted to show my dad this game cause he liked western movies, and overall just games with a beautiful story. I was thinking that this time i would play it with him and show how beautiful this game is, and Im 100% sure he would’ve loved this story. We were planning on playing it together a few months back and he was looking forward to it. Unfortunately my dad passed away before we ever got the chance. He died 2 months ago and I miss him so much. I always remember him for this song I don’t know why though. Rip dad I love you
im sorry for your loss
The high honor ending hit so hard you wanted to be good to the people you didn't know irl
Horse get shot
Arthur:Thank you.
Everyone:Cries
Damn, that scene literally broke me! Grown man, and I was holding up my tears
@CRAZY GAMER spelling isn't your strong suit huh
Yeah this got me right in the feels.. Had the same horse from the start of the game and it was so sad
@@thomasmcewan9465 that same slow, low stamina, low health horse?
That’s beautiful man 😢
@@thomasmcewan9465 I had Buelle, Hamish’s horse. Broke me down into pieces...
Horse is wounded
Arthur: Thank you
Everybody: *cries*
inJUSTice 00 nah that was the toughest the part man😔
Rest up Harry💔
one of the only deaths that made me genuinely cry 😔
Omg you have to remind me of that tragic moment 😭😭😭😭😭😭
Rip my gold Turkmen bell 😭😭😭😭😭😭
me too [*] płotka
I did
I’m sad I’ll never get to play this game for the first time again.
That's the way it is😔
I’m jealous of the new players, they have a choice tho, high or low honor 😔
The only thing I want is someone playing this song for me when I'm really old
Recently played RDR2. The game being so popular, along with it being 4 years old, I was spoiled Arthur's death and the final fistfight with Micah. However, I did not know about the last ride. I was not expecting to actually shed a tear for a game I was spoiled the ending of.
Same here
Beginning of the game: “YEEHAWW IM A COWBOY!”
End of game: “What’s the meaning of life?”
Exactly how I felt with this game lol
Arthur Morgan Hails
Me, when I first got the game : "haha cowboy go brrrr."
Me, at the end of chapter 6 : "depression one hundred"
Exactly
Who knows the meaning of life? But I know you should never waste a second.
Unus and Annus taught me that...
A moment of silence for the red dead fans who passed away before this game came out 😔
I lost my grandpa I think before he saw me play rdr2 I wish he was here watching me play it
*Takes cowboy hat off*
That's the way it is
@@alastortheradiodemon9266 Trust me when I say he probably had his hand on your shoulder watching you play the entire game
well they are in heaven with arthur lenny john hosea and the rest
If the next red dead game is as good as this one, I’m more than willing to wait another decade for it.
what flag is in ur profile picture
@@bruhgimmememes bisexual pride flag
When Arthur knew he was going to die, he said he was scared. I will never forget that look of his face.... For me, it's the best game i have ever played so far. I will not delete it, until another heart touching game out come.
It's not only a masterpiece, it's something more.
"I guess i'm...i'm afraid"
Even Arthur was a fictional character it felt like losing a real person
i literally felt like i lost my best friend i just finished my first play through bro
Same here
For both of ya
I just beat the game I cried twice during the last ride and his death
I can't cry, my body doesn't let me, but if I could I would during that
Who else start a new game just to play with Arthur Morgan.
Yep at the middle of chapter six now not really gonna do much missions, just hunt and find Easter eggs and new mount chiliad mysteries
I did.. I missed Arthur so much
me
Me
I did, restarted game at chapter six. Arthur will never die.
"I gave you all I had"
R. I. P. Arthur 😢
This game is a masterpiece, I am a grown ass man, still cried like a baby
Ain’t that the truth
We Al did
Real talk
Nostalgia at its highest rn
Oh god this can be considered nostalgia now; has it really been that long?
@@Gage_The_Comrade_or_Something sure has mate!
Who else actually shed tears at the end of this game.
Me. And I'm not ashamed. Rockstar made this great, deep, awesome character. How could you not cry?
Hell, I'm shedding tears right now listening to this. Fucking Rockstar man, making me care so much about a bunch of polygons
Micah Broch Rockstar sure did do a great job with this game. The best I’ve ever played by far. Probably the best game so far, period.
Mike Maya This song is a perfect example of how powerful this goddamn game is.
Cblindvking45 I sobbed
“I tried. In the end...I did.”
- Arthur Morgan
The way his voice sounded, that crack and whisp from TB, I wanted to cry so damn bad.
"I CRIED. In the end....I did."
I gave you all I had, Dutch
@@jdog167 i really started crying when he said that.
Hell i cried 3 fucking times in the end...
“Oooh Dutch..... He’s a rat”
When he said that I almost started balling man, he sounded so sad
I get extremely freaked out by How a game can be this absolute masterpiece
Só quem já jogou o jogo sabe que honra vale tudo....
This was not a simple game, it was an experience
The Van der Linde Gang isnt just a fictional Gang its Family
I was a bad Arthur.. that's the way it is.
Yeah, it was a roller coaster of plans
You god damn right.
That's... that's what a game is...
The Hardest Mission in the game and it was just holding one button
they knew we couldn't do anything else since we were blinded by tears or blowing our stuffy noses from bawling so much with tissues
That part is you and arthur holding on
Nah hardest mission is taking that damn bull in epilogue part 1
@@supermegaepictriangleguy6899 wasn’t that
@@ninjireal yes it was that bull sucked but it wasn’t as hard as those skinner brothers
You simply arent human if you played through the whole game , got to Arthurs last ride and heard this song and didnt have some form of emotional reaction
After 5 years, still the best game ever made in my opinion. What a goddamn masterpiece.
Not just your opinion, same here
I completed the game with High Honor and helped John escape.
I felt complete.
imo That's the true ending. Has to be.
@@jackmarston8337 yup
i had kinda low honor and saved john , i still wish to play the game again with no memory so i can do it high honor
@@bryanramirez8140 same here 😞 im replying again with as high honour as possible
@@jackmarston8337 agreed
Red dead depression
Sebas Peimbert LOL it so pity but thanks for this comment 😂😂😂
Lmao
C mamo jdjdjdjdjdjd
Among my tears of sadness , your comment made me a laugh hahahahahaha
Gave us all the big depression
This game has taught me more then anything I’ve ever known. Live your lives with the highest honor.
Rest in piece Arthur, you gave everything.
I miss arthur so much, Rest in peace you legend!
Hosea: When I die, Just want to be buried with friends.
Lenny: Me too.. with friends or with family, I dont think that matters more than that
Hosea: What about you Arthur
Arthur: Bah I dont care in that nonsense
Hosea: OOH come on
Arthur: Face me to the West so I can watch the setting sun And... remember all the fun times we that way...
What's pretty cool about that quote is that instead of Arthur watching a setting sun symbolising him fading away to death, he instead watches a sunrise which symbolises that he brought life to John, so that he could finally have a life with his family.
Damn, and weren't Hosea and Lenny burried side by side!?
Fuck off stop making me cry
i can't stop crying
hue hue hue
adz2459 here comes the waterworks
How to listen to Thats the way it is correctly.
1. Turn it on
2.cry
Yup
@@alastortheradiodemon9266 glad you agree
We don’t need money Dutch WE NEED MORE KIDNEY BEANS
I cry in this moment the first time„Shine in the darkness" and then forever
Yes
Arthur: "I'm not a good man."
Me after fighting and living a wonderful adventure with him: "no, you are the best man of all"
Red Dead Redemption 2 was the peak of myself as a gamer. No other experience has been the same since.
The saddest thing about this game isn't this song, it's that you will never experience it for the first time ever again.
Worth trying to hit a head with something heavey =)
i have never played it yet completely so i will experience it first time :D
@@dreamxxx333mmm2 you are extremely lucky. For now =)
Just beat it with my girlfriend she wasn’t super into games but she is now and she cried during this mission and said “I never thought a game could be so beautiful” it was my third time playing the game all the way through and i still cried I think I cried more then the first time Especially when Arthur tells the sister he’s afraid gets me every time to see him so strong as a man yet he’s so afraid to face death
true....
Arthur dying felt like losing a really close friend, he was such a relatable and realistic character.
Seriously. I can handle loss pretty well and I'll be damned if i didn't cry like a baby when Arthur died.
My grandpa died and it diidnt feel this bad fam hahahhahahaha
My friend spoiled me the ending of CH 6 when I was a few (2 or 3) missions from it. Now he's at Odd Fellow's Rest's.
I cried when arthur and hosea died
ikr
I've been crying for the past 5 minutes because of this soundtrack, really hits hard.
It’s 2023 and this is still the most unavoidably saddest song from the saddest ending to any game. Just listened for the first time in 3 years and brought immediate tears to my eyes
Just imagine
"Playing this game for the first time again".
I can fucking give anything to play this game for the first time again!
I played it for the first time in October once, then got it for Christmas since it was taken off game pass the week after I got it, man... what a game.
i played it over my first time with cheats unlocked and it still made me upset when Arthur died, Sooooooo i played it over again without cheats and a 100% full honor bar
I gonna play this game and i think i will cry like fucking baby
Currently in chapter 6 so there is still more to play for me. It will suck completing this game. Guess il restart after
“I’m sorry son, it’s a hell of a thing”
Why
God damn tuberculosis
The line that made me feel empty inside.
You got tuberculosis
"That's rough buddy"
With high honor when this plays in the one of the ending missions when Arthur is riding his horse, I literally couldn't stop crying.
Same things make us smile, make us cry 😢😢😢
Man I would die to this song
I’d be there with you brother
That's the way it is 💔
The gang is nearly back together except mohammed
@@wumpusman983 cheers brother
you`re good man Mr. Morgan
20% of me is here to listen to a great song. The other 80% is here to read the comments and join in on the Arthur Morgan support group.
5% me crying 5% me listening to the song 10% reading comments 80% loving and missing Arthur 😭😭😭😭❤
Me too
It’s dumb but I legitimately feel like I’m grieving for Arthur. It’s been days and I still feel choked up about it. Never had this happen from any game, book, or TV series before.
@@katyalupochev9589 me too bro its really intersting that this is the only game that has made me do that
@@katyalupochev9589 its not dumb at all. Great games with great stories are hard to find and when you play one like RDR2 you invest yourself into characters. Rockstar just knows how to make epic games.
You saved my life
I cried during Arthur's last ride
"You saved my life... You're a good man!"
Thanks
I remember that scene cause I always save them unless they tried to kill me
“Maybe it’s a sign Arthur try… try to do the good thing.”
Tore me apart when I first played lmao.
Thank you feller. You know there ain’t enough kindness in this world that’s for sure.
John: "But what about loyalty Arthur?"
Arthur: "Be Loyal to what matters,"
Arthur: “Go, don’t look back”
Michael Kelly “we aren’t the ones that changed”
“ go and be a god damn man!’
"I know...I know"
Michael Kelly god of war better dont @ me
It never hits the same after completing the game for the first time, nothing compares to the excitement of booting up rdr2 to finish the game and be hit with Arthur’s death. That scene hit hard for the first time, it will never feel the same after confronting Micah at mount hagen
I cried my fucking eyes out during this scene, and i dont cry easily anymore...
_"This whole thing is pretty much done. We're more ghosts than people"_
*-A.Morgan*
Read it at the same part lol
Thats a amazing quote
"Our time has pretty much past" " I gave you all I had dutch!!" A. MORGAN
RIP Hot air balloon man.
Poor Mr Bullard
That guy was actually lit.
Amen
"I kind of liked him" - Arthur Morgan
Neil Waldron so we all did :(
He was funny
This song hits harder than any song I have heard in my life.....
Well done rockstar.
Rest in Peace Arthur Morgan.
You were a good man, even if you didn’t believe it
R.I.P. Arthur Morgan
A man who even though he doesn't exist, taught us a lot of things.
he was more a teacher and a part of us than a fictional character
He exists. He touched all of our hearts in a very special never done before way.
Arthur taught us to be good people to be loyal even though he does not exist doesn't mean that the emotions in the urge to do the loyal and right thing doesn't exist.
Especially about M O N E H
RIP Arthur...
RIP Bud...
"There's a good man inside you...but he's wrestling with a giant"
Looks like that good man kicked the giants ass
In the end he became a *giant good man.*
[Beacon Autem Dolor] possibly green?
@@wyattbequette3596 Green and associated with canned vegetables
He Died Like a *Good* Man
I Just Finished The Game Today (Without The Epilogue) When I Heard This Music In Game It Made Me Cry Knowing What's Gonna Happen Next And Now My Eyes Teared Up When I Heard This Again Now 😢 Best game I Ever Played.
Same, this is the best game i ever played.
This game will never leave me, I’ve been listening to this music since my first playthrough. I think rdr2 will forever and ever be my favorite video game, probably my favorite over all form of media/entertainment. It feels good to see new comments even still.
dad: are you winning son?
me: **crying** no.... arthur won
I related to this comment for only a few seconds until I started dying when I saw your name
@@Leftoverbone lmao same
@@Leftoverbone lol
Good meme. Sad. But good nonetheless.
Hy won
Hard to believe Arthur Morgan is a fictional character.
He just felt so real.
So real it... hurts to see him go...
( speechless ) Not every stories have " They lived happily ever after "
@@intrepidoutlaw706 in the end, we all get caught.
that's the way it is ...
the honest truth
rud ded radempion is rasicist
The quote from AC4 Black Flag when Blackbeard says: "In a world without gold, we might've been heroes" kind of gives me Arthur Morgan vibes. Despite being an outlaw he always did what he did out of loyalty and in the end just wanted John and the boy to get away from it all when he couldn't
Those are my 2 favorite games there so similar I always wondered what would happen if Edward kenway and Arthur Morgan met
Red Dead Redemption 2 was an absolute masterpiece. The soundtrack, the story, the characters, the gameplay… EVERYTHING. It’s the greatest game ever made imo.
This game was spoiled for me.
Still cried
Me too
me too
The only thing i knew is that Arthur will die. Cause i never thought i would play this masterpiece. I had no idea about anything else and i was still astonished and cried my eyes out when Arthur died.
Yeah, I regret reading spoilers because I feel like the game would hit much more differently to me if I didn’t know the ending
same Tariq
It's been a year and I'm still not quite over it
Same Man😭😭😭
Same 😭
Still recovering man
Aionios man it’s been a year
Rockstar really didn't have to make the horse die as well. I'm starting to cry just thinking about it 😢😢
I'm not crying! You are crying!...
I aways cry watching this song
“Outta the damn way” -Arthur Morgan
Samurai Goroh LOL. Here I was, reading through countless comments with Arthur’s most meaningful and emotional quotes.. and this just made me laugh so hard (and cry a little :) ♥️👍🏻
So poignant. The man had the soul of a poet.
LOL WHAT IF THAT WAS IN FLASHBACK DIALOGUE
See You In Juvie Bitch if the game comes to pc that needs to be the first mod
See You In Juvie Bitch you’re a kind man mister.. I know you can- OUTTA THE DAMN WAY!
Games of this quality are extremely rare, what a damn masterpiece.
Zico Tops Se nota que te encanta el arte:)
True
Hola prro
:( true
Indeed my friend 😭
Just finished the game for the very first time last night. 34 year old man bawling my eyes out here
This game is a masterpiece.
I will never forget when Arthur said " revenge is a fools game". That sentence really can help in life.
Yes and when he says to John Marston - “ get the hell out of here and be a goddamn man” 💔…
Yup Ellie from tlou2 can learn a thing or two from Arthur
I learned so much from a man that didn't even exist, and I cried for a man that never existed too
I sometimes say to myself "revenge is a fools game, and I'm sure as hell a fool"
I'm now going to use this
There are two phases in life. One before you play Red dead redemption 2 and one after you play Red dead redemption 2.
thats so true, it really affects the way you look at anything
I finished it today… I’m on the other side now; just like Arthur
I've never felt the same after beating this game for the first time.
Yeeee me too😯😯😯😢
True man😥
亞瑟摩根永遠活在我的心中,Arthur Morgan will always live in my heart.
There you are Lenny!
This isn't a game. This is interactive piece of art.
The great Roger Ebert - may he rest in peace - once argued that video games weren't art. I wish he could have experienced this game.
Videogames are infact one of the many beautiful forms of art
That ain’t art.Its a fucking masterpiece
That is every video game. A form of escapism.
wOaH there, you have 666 likes on that comment buddy