Health Crisis | Report Card Series | Ep7
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 05. 2024
- The COVID 19 pandemic exposed the fragility of our health systems. For the poor, pandemic or otherwise, access to quality healthcare was and continues to be a pipe dream. The majority in the country are just one health shock away from slipping into utter destitution. Healthcare must be a right and cannot be left to the vagaries of the market. However, despite many promises and the horrors of the pandemic, healthcare continues to be woefully underfunded leading to high out of pocket expenditure. Primary health centres are short staffed, nurses are not compensated adequately and cost of medicines remain high. High waiting time and fear of high costs prompts many from poorer households to completely avoid going to hospitals. Environmental degradation with poor air quality and unchecked pollution adds to the health woes. Finally, what is really striking is the indignity meted out to those who lost their lives during the pandemic due to Covid. By multiple scientific estimates, the Narendra Modi led union government has grossly under-reported the lives lost due to Covid. Estimates suggest that, in reality, 10 times more lives have been lost in India due to Covid compared to what the government claims. The 3 parts of this video delve into these vital aspects. The health data used in this video is based on the report prepared by the Centre for Financial Accountability (CFA) as part of their comprehensive ‘Balance sheet of the decade’ series. The CFA reports can be found here: www.fanindia.net/indian-econo... Watch this video to learn more.
Special thanks to Rajendran Narayanan and Vivek Gilani.
Sources:
• Health care expense 2.16% of the GDP at 0:53: Source Health report card - Centre for Financial Accountability www.fanindia.net/wp-content/u...
• STATE OF HEALTH FINANCING IN INDIA: The myth of OOP reduction by Indranil
www.cenfa.org/state-of-financ... (page 72 of the document)
• Expenditure of other G20 countries -- WHO, Global Health expenditure database. apps.who.int/nha/database/cou...
• Among 55 Low Middle-Income Countries, we are tenth from the bottom, in terms of public spending on health as a % of GDP - Source: STATE OF HEALTH FINANCING IN INDIA: The myth of OOP reduction by Indranil www.cenfa.org/state-of-financ...
• NFHS data shows that 50% of households in India do not generally seek health care from the public sector. The percentage of households that do not generally use government health facilities is highest in Bihar (80%) and Uttar Pradesh (75%): Source NFHS- 5 (page 449 of this link) rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5Report...
• Reasons for low hospitalisation: Source: NFHS 5 rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5Report... (Page 478)
• Challenges to get medical treatment for women in the 15-49 age group: Source: NFHS 5 rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5Report... (page 484)
• Rural Health Statistics: Source main.mohfw.gov.in/sites/defau...
• 25% doctors: Source Rural Health Statistics 2021-22
• 36% children under 5 being malnourished, 32% underweight and 67% Anaemia: Source: NFHS 5 (page 375) rchiips.org/nfhs/NFHS-5Report...
Estimation of COVID Deaths
• “Estimates of pandemic excess mortality in India based on civil registration data” by Murad Banaji and Aashish Gupta journals.plos.org/globalpubli...
• Meta-analysis of nationwide SARS-CoV-2 infection fatality rates in India by Lauren Zimmerman and Bhramar Mukherjee journals.plos.org/globalpubli...
• The WHO estimates of excess mortality associated with the COVID-19 pandemic - ByWilliam Msemburi, Ariel Karlinsky, Victoria Knutson, Serge Aleshin-Guendel, Somnath Chatterji & Jon Wakefield www.nature.com/articles/s4158...
• Pollution Sources:
blog.mumbaivotes.com
• National Air Plan:
sansad.in/getFile/loksabhaque...
www.bjp.org/manifesto2019
• Green Fund:
sansad.in/getFile/annex/218/A...
www.bjp.org/manifesto2019
• TB-free India:
dashboards.nikshay.in/communi...
• Health security for ASHA/ANGANWADI Workers:
business.outlookindia.com/ins... - Komedie
80% of GDP is going for managing Modiji's lifestyle
Konsa Ganja fukta h bhai 😂
base for statement
Arey bhai bachhpan mai jo kuchh nahi mila uski purti ho rahi hai....
Hazaron khwaheshein aisi ke her khwahesh pe bummmmmm nikle.....
WhatsApp university se data mat laya kr bhai
source - Trust me Bro
India is a country where biggest achievement is to leave it.
true...m too waiting for it.
Yes please leave
@@saptarsi7868 Brain drain is one of the biggest problems in india if this continues our country will crumble due to lack of talented young people. It’s not a thing to encourage 😒
Yes kyuki chutye log bhaagte h or ache log yhi rhke isme Sudhaar krne ki koshish krte h
Bhaagne walo ko bhagode khte h
Comedians and Teachers become reporters
Reporters become comedians
Whaa kya vikas hai!!!
Anyways bro great work 👏👏👏
Ache din a chuke h
@@Aman-vh7nd lagta to easa hi kuch hai bhai..
Teachers kon sa reporter pls share the channel name
#ShameOnModiGov.. people should #watch this entire Report and #Share it's clips for Awareness -❤️🙏
@@kirtisurya3603 Naiya Paar Education
One month before Indian elections, BJP was like "ab ki baar, 400 par" but what a blow from The desh bakht, Dhruv Rathee, the newslaundry and Kunal ♥️♥️♥️
You'll be remembered.
15 lakh doctors for 150 crore population…lack of medical institutions is one of the core reasons behind issues in healthcare
#ShameOnModiGov.. people should #watch this entire Report and #Share it's clips for Awareness -❤️🙏
Judiciary and Education system
these need miles of improvement
like litteraly miiiiilllllesssssssssss
Its not that bad a relation or proportion.
But those doctors never coming to the hospital and earning at their private clinics or private hospitals is the problem
Institutions undergrad ke toh bohot khol diye but naam ke hai no amenities are there, even new aiims ki haalat theek nhi, but specialization ki seats hi nhi badha Rahe, just like fishes of sea fighting to get in aquarium so get ur facts clear same 10 Saal Purani lines use naa kare!!😒😒😒
@@uditnarayan9489excuse me but do u realize the time, efforts and money spent to become a doctor,what wud u know, why wud a doctor after sacrificing so much work in low income , poor quality and longgg working hours in govt hospital but still does usme bhi fault aap doctor kaa nikaal rahe
Fighting the right battle is the thing that only matters
#ShameOnModiGov.. people should #watch this entire Report and #Share it's clips for Awareness -❤️🙏
This one of best thing you are doing mate, great fan of your work, I’m from United Kingdom
Where in the UK? I’m from UK too.
@@rahildoshi4626 from Maidenhead
Aap log uk me rahte. Kya aap log vote Dene aate ho??
Aapka bhi to right hai vote karna.
Stay there only don't bother in India matter
Paulette idhar Jo log hain un sabka to voting list mein naam aajaaye…
Where is main stream media 🤬🤬? They should raise the issue right?
Stream 😅
They are trying to figure out how is rs 400 cylinder is more expensive than 1200 when you have to wait more than one hour to meet a doctor then it's not a treatment it's a torture do I have to talk about if you have to do any test it's will take at least some one month for your turn just thinking this scares me to going to the doctor people have to wait for more than a one month for simple simple ultrasound and one of the most disgusting thing is if you get from the private the government hospital doesn't recognise this the literally allergy form private test while forgetting their situation
They are literally street media! @@avb7340
Who owns the media? 😅
Media busy hai modi ji k new costume capture krne m😂
During covid time, there were many things that haunt us, like migrant workers on road, people gasping for oxygen (only the Gurudwaras, Youth Congress's Srinivas and a few NGO helping), dead bodies burning or buried on Ganga banks.... But the thing that exposed our health system was our then Health Minister and Road & Infrastructure Minister promoting Ramdev's CORONIL as a prevention and cure of COVID. Can you beat that?
Excellent report. Its a shame that we are not focusing on essential issues or whitewashing the truth.
Saffronwashing*
#ShameOnModiGov.. people should #watch this entire Report and #Share it's clips for Awareness -❤️🙏
Proud of you. Never liked Kamra the comedian's sense of humour, but Kamra the journalist is amazing, given when their is no media being critical.
This is really good video. The way you lay down facts. Its mind blowing. Please continue making video like these
First underground hospital in the world -AIIMS Darbhanga and AIIMS Madurai😮
Wah modiji wah😂
75 years ago there were gandhiji , sardar patel, netaji bose and many more who sacrificed there lives for independence and today, there are dhruv rathee , kunal kamra, ravish kumar who are doing same thing
Bt they are speaking. Not doing. No one can do anything now. Cuz now if u do. U will lose ur job and in the end ur family will suffer.
@@Dattebayo3089fact👍
You are among the few who can be trusted to call a spade a spade 🙏🏻. All thanks to you for giving us a voice and vision.
everyone has to fight otherwise we will not be able to speak with such freedom in this great nation
I've been a huge fan when you did stand up. Now that you're sitting and talking facts, minds are being blown.
A hard core comedian doing hard core journalism and top journalists are doing hard core comedy.
Facts! Facts!
This is what Dhruv Rathee thought his videos would look like.
What is your point?
2025: well go back in history and thank 3-4 people like @kunal kamra @dhruv rathee @ravish @deshbhakt to actually stop BJP from taking away India from the world map.
❤
That green fund joke was lit 😂😂😂😂😂😂
पेशेंट जीवन मुक्त हो रहा है।😅😅😅
You are doing a great job. This things should be the primary topic of discussions.
I feel very happy to be in Hyderabad. Telangana, where the government have a very nice scheme in which they give all the medical expenses out of free. Even the doctors are very good.The hospitals are maintained❤❤
Yeah bro ... I was thinking the same...
I just came back to India after 5 years. It's just dust and super dirty. It was much better when I left. I used to ride a bike before but now I cannot even think of getting out of the car. You can't just step out of the house or the car. That's absurd! Imagine people who don't have the luxury of an ac room. The hygiene level has dropped so low. Just look at the 10 km radius of IGI airport. Roads dug up, no road safety. This is the heights of ignorance. I think going back to another country is only way out.
Have you been inside a government hospital in Delhi or NCR? Apart from AIIms or RML, these hospitals looks dirtier than a Pig farm. I come from a family of government doctors and we all left India. In one government hospital in UP, dogs came inside the NICU and took a new born baby and ate it inside the hospital. That’s the condition of government hospitals. India is gone to the dogs now.
Go Back to Pakistan 😂 Yogi Modi Logic
#ShameOnModiGov.. people should #watch this entire Report and #Share it's clips for Awareness -❤️🙏
@@satyakammisra
....
At least aap ke desh mai 1 percent toh honest log hai government mai, hum log ka toh sab chor/chorni hai. Love from Nepal 🇳🇵
Rabi dai good luck
@TheMaPyComment his past and present are not promising 😕. His saying and doing is completely opposite.
Modi is now old and we should vote someone else to bring peace to him 😂
He didn't do any good while he was young either. But to agree with you ..he must go!!!
I really apreciate Kunal trying his best to educate Indians but at this moment, majority of us are high on Communalism and fascism. There is no cure for that.
Kunal ji....hospital nahi chahiye. School nahi chahiye...sadak nahi chahiye...education nahi chahiye....development nahi chahiye....feel sorry for these people.
Give like for congress❤❤❤❤
The difference between the number of views on Kamra's standup comedy video and purely informative videos like these is the actual reason why we are in the condition that we are in right now.
Informative video Kunal
Not only information
Information with fun
Kunal kamra your work yaar
Hat's off
Great come Back❤
NextStep Review : Infrastructure,Transport, privatization, railways and accidents,postal services
First to comment, was waiting for this one. Kunal Kamra, you're an inspiration for all of us, Thanks for taking this role as nowadays comedians are spitting facts and politicians are doing comedy.
Bus na kitna chatega ....
Jali na teri bhi jali na😂😂@@gogamerboi5977
O man ❤ comedian becomes journalist. ..and doing better than national dog( godi media ) ..keep it up bro ❤
Modi ji ka bas chalena to vo heart Patient kobhi bandage laga ke ghar bhejde !😅
Somewhere what Mr Kamra is doing is true service to the nation ❤️
Badiya Jabardast Presentation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This series is so underrated. I wish many many people to watch these.. Kunal keep up the work. I really like this format.
Last year we took a poor girl from our neighborhood to the govt hospital for tb test( you can only get the tb meds from the govt hospital) both times she was given negative report. But upon taking her to a private doctor he said she definitely has tb but he was scared of even admitting on paper so finally we had to take her to a private lab to test her and submit that in the govt hospital to even get the medicines that was important for her. This is so dystopian. They have started giving negative results so that they can underreport
Noida Twin Towers were demolished, couldn't they be converted into hospitals?
No cuz uski structure sahi nhi tha wo kbhi na kbhi girta hi isliye gira diya gya
😢
i m n architect and i 😊confirm the fact that it was not feasible for people to live there because it was hazardous for them......thats why it was demolished 🤞
with peace✌️
@@Halal_wayz right
Great work sir💪🏻
watching from London
जुड़ेगा भारत, जीतेगा INDIA🇮🇳 🔥
Being a doctor I can say for a fact that we are facing a severe shortage of medicines for tuberculosis. In comparison we have an extreme high case load of undiagnosed patients.
So the goal is definitely not reachable anytime soon. All thanks to 56inches
Yes, high patient load, overtime work for resident doctors. For this sacrifice, you will beaten by patients.
If you don't have enough medicines for the conventional treatment of TB then it's death sentences for the MDR-TB's AND XDR-TB's patients....it's catastrophic situation Doc....
@@ff_dostlog Exactly why there is a line of doctors ready to leave India. It's not just the abuse though. the politics and hopelessness add to the reasons
@@khkarandoyzazai It is! The spread is ginormous after Covid19. The burden of the disease keeps increasing as do the resistance (due to other reasons too)
Osm video kunal sr
Maine to police se dande khaye the 😂😂
Informative..comedians is better than prime time journalists addressing people concerns
I agree with the fact that There is no transportation (Ambulance) available for emergencies.
I called 108 for emergency service but the people operating them are so disinterested, it's sickening. I'm lucky that we had a car to take him to a hospital but think of the people who can't afford to do that.
I hear your name
But this 1st time I see your videos
Tq for show real issues in india 🙏
Impeccable 😊
The problem is low amount of doctor government hospitals or private hospital both have some of the excellent doctors but the number is too small
Appreciate your work and stats! Hope we will get better services for whatever tax we paid for and all such corrupt people soon behind bars. Thanks for your work.
ना पहले किसी नें Series लिया था
ना अब कोई Series ले रहा हैं "😇✌️
आश्चर्य इस बात पर है को पढ़े लिखे लोग भी इनकी बातो और वादों पर विश्वास करते है। जबकि इनकी योजनाओ का हाल धरातल पर वो भी देख रहे है।
Congress ko vote de ❤❤🎉🎉
20014 jo humko azadi dilaya hai usi ko vote diye h 😂😂😂
Very informative video. Please make videos like this on other parties manifest and also on what they did in thier tenure in their state as well us in this country when they were in power.
Really cool saying that "5 saal ki umar se struggle shuru hota hai aur chal ta rehta hai"
Thanks
1.Oxygen Committee was constitued in April-2020 in the Ministry of Industrial Development, one of the ministry in Modi Government, which did not meet for one year despite Prime Minister being chairmam of the National Disaster Management Authority who was also responsible to deal with it as chief leader for tackling Covid-19 Disaster, which was also notified so on day of " Taali-Thalli " .
2.INSAGOG chief scientist warning was also not heeded by Modi Govt. in March -2021 about explosion of deadly Covid Delta virus in Maharashtra , but Modiji remained busy from January-2021 to March-2021 in Kumbh-2021 Mela and Bengal State Assembly elections -2021. So many people died for want of oxygen after afflicted with Covid -19 in second phase.
3.I filed a Public Interest Litigation in Supreme Court which came for hearing before Justice Chandrachud Bench which closed it by verbally stating that even advanced countries could not tackle Covid -19 pandemic.
4.Kunal , kindly consider making seven minutes slot on criminal abdication of duty by the Oxygen Committee under the Prime Minister of India.
Very true sir, apart from being busy in kumbh mela and Bengal election, the entire nation was busy in welcoming Donald Trump on 24-25 Feb 2020. In Next week i.e. March 2020, the total lockdown was announced
Application. Ye andaz accha laga. Mediclaim par bhi tax
Government hospitals me aadhe departments band pade hai. Enjiography plasty stant insertion heart' institutes kama rahe hai. Very informative and awareness .❤️👍❤️❤️❤️❤️Good job like it.
Keep up the good work. And the contribution towards the national revolution in the time of need is commendable. More power to you Kunal bhai
These videos should be played on loop publicly everywhere!
सर बस हेल्थ केअर ही नहीं तब जिनके business के लग गये उनका भी कुछ नहीं किया 🥹🥹🥹🥹
Kunal i show your work.. It's amazing man.. It is good to see someone coming forward and trying to show the truth. I am proud of the work you are doing.. Cheers
Doesn't matter , for Indian people the population is 150 - 160 crores, if 5-10 crore people die , it wouldn't matter much in this country.
Great job🐻
Kunal bhai apke ye video pe modi ki health guarantee ka ad chal raha hai 😂
You are doing a fantastic job, Kunal sir. Appreciate the effort you put in making these informative videos.
Ise kehte hai asli information, thank you sir for this video❤
कोई कुछ भी कहे लेकिन भक्तों की समझ में नहीँ आएगा 😄😄😄😄 स्कूल मैटर्स 😍
Amazing
want to thank you for the report card series. I really wish more and more people see this and understand the truth. Congratulations and best wishes. looking forward to brighter future of our beloved country.
Gazab!!
My an uncle is doctor, he gets badly infected after taking booster dose ,now he getting severe heart problems 😢
Very good analysis thanks for opening eyes bringing down all the relevant data . People will understand what to the right candidate Jay Hind we will definitely win
Last month two weeks back my friend met with an accident. He had a severely damaged leg , lost lot of blood, he was admitted in private hospital in Deogarh Jharkhand. There was no blood in tat hospital, they sent his family to goverment hospital to get blood O + , when they went there to the goverment hospital blood bank they said no blood even though they had . The patients hameiglobin level was 6.4 gm . So getting blood was unavoidable . Then they got someone ready to donate for which i paid for two bottles 10k.
Believe it or not its just unbelievable. In this day and age for there was no 0+ blood plus no one ready to donate blood + goverment blood bank had blood still they didnt give
Wait, Gov. hospital charge your friend for blood? Strange. O+ blood is a rare, maybe hospital doesn't have blood, in this emergency hospital asks medical students to donate blood & we donate it.
Your work on reports is exceptionally excellent as usual..
we miss your stand up..
We pay taxes so that they can study in less fees . But those bastards instead of being grateful leave us and go abroad. When government tried to stop them, they started protesting . Return our money if you can't treat us 😡😞🙏
😢🙏
If you go and ask refund for infrastructure not taken place out of your taxes
Then you will get more money
Rather than doctors who either pay the whole amount before going abroad or complete their rural services and then they will be able to leave
You are too brainwashed to understand
You will never understand what doctors go through nowadays
We pay taxes too and we don't get refund of our taxes also and instead pay the whole fees if we skip bond
So we end up paying tax, college fees+bond cancellation fees for the same course
So think before you write
@@Samosa_Today doctors never suffers,it's just a part of their study,that they need to serve the rural area for one year,after that doctor left the offered gov. jobs & makes a hell lot of money with the help of private practices & getting huge commissions from pharma companies for prescribing their products,not only that they also get huge commissions from diagnostic labs, they are earning in crores, infact our medical infrastructure is so weak due to unavailability of doctors in government set up,that jhola chaap doctors are making hell lot of money, so don't advertise your study years as your struggle,
It's like,I became an IAS after years of preparation,now I am having every right to do the corruption,
@@saurabhsharma7307 Rural Service is never part of Curriculum go and read MBBS guidelines and Central Government Colleges have no rural bond and pay less fees than us.
And commission earning is illegal and I am talking about legal earning
Complain against doctor taking commission who is stopping you from that
Private practice needs investment and competition from big corporate hospitals for major procedures , not everybody is earning crores although they are not poor and earn decent no doubt
Again Corruption is illegal and we don't justify corruption and commission as a part of our service.
No government doctor ask money from you and it's your choice to get generic or branded of the same drug written on prescription
And in corporate hospital it's the management who earn lot of money not each and every doctor working there
Lv Uh merA VeeR. ❣️
GhainT Kam .
Lv FroM B-TOwN 🍁
My Mom is an ASHA Worker. She got paid only 4500 + incentive = Approx 6500 to 7000. Nowadays in a government sector govt is paying 6500 . 😂😂😂😂
Can you imagine which fucking country we are living in...? Also Asha worker are 365 days 24 hours active. No leave, no pension, no da, no ta just nothing. What a fucking country we have & what a fucking government we have 😂😂😂😂😂
Asalam alaikum bhaiya g from Hyderabad ❤😂❤
Halat itna kharab hain comedian ko serious banadeya
As much as this series is eye opener ( if the facts presented are 100% correct), it is disheartening as well that a standup comedian needs to seat down and make a series of general knowledge topics about current state of affairs. Thankyou Kunal for making this series 🙏.
Kunal bhai,, Great Job with detailed data and to the point evaluation. Isse criticism nhi keh sakte, Ye actual report hai.
Ye Video Series Thodi Jaldi Nahi La sakte the, Ab to Maine BJP ko vote De 🪔
Don't worry ...at least jaha pe abhi elections baki hai ....udhar ke logon tak ye video share kar skte hai.
Aap ko baki mudde nhi dikhe kya aapko bus yehi mudda chahiye tha kya iski hi rah dekh rahe the
Aap ek andhbhakt gobarbhakt ho ye Maan lo aap tarkik nhi ban sakte
Bjp ko vote de 🪔
Kuchh bhi kuchh bhi
Thanks Kunal for this entire eye opening series. We can see the impact with people‘s vote👍🏻
Awesome report card ❤ thank you Kunal Kamra Brother 🎉
This man showing reality of our health care..
Keep up the good work Kunal. We are with you and the country.❤
I am gonna be a doctor and I can confirm that even we don't visit our hospitals for treatment even when it is free for us 😢
Had to get my mother operated (her lens had to be replaced). Doctors said if you use golden card, you could only get a cheaper lens.
It is so sad, that the media is completely finished and comedians are having to bring us information. Kudos to you and team Kunal, keep up the good work.
Problem is dispite of public private partnerships. Cost expenditures are double. Because hospitals takes money from govt and out of pocket also
Kya mast reporting karta hai "mota" bhai!
Please don't stop bro, excellent quality of work.
good going. keep it Kunal Ji
Excellent Analysis and Informative
Excellent reporting Sir ji.....❤❤❤
Too good information bhai, I hope the future government backfills all these gaps.