Parliament passes expropriation bill: Prof Ruth Hall

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 24. 08. 2024
  • So now that the Expropriation Bill has been adopted by the National Assembly it will be sent to the National Council of Provinces for concurrence. Importantly it would allow no compensation to be paid to landowners under certain circumstances. On this, land expert Prof. Ruth Hall from the University of the Western Cape joins us.
    For more news, visit sabcnews.com and also #SABCNews on all Social Media platforms.

Komentáře • 102

  • @MrCstross
    @MrCstross Před rokem +12

    Why does "Prof Ruth" keep smiling STUPIDLY ? This is a serious matter.

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem +2

      Because she know what goes through the minds of Stupid.

    • @faa9261
      @faa9261 Před rokem +1

      @@truth-Hurts375 I guess the Stupid got you scared😆

  • @cloudstrife8791
    @cloudstrife8791 Před rokem +10

    This women sounds way to happy. Hells gates opening soon...

    • @Predikant
      @Predikant Před rokem

      Oh yes, emaciated skeletons that have been starved through the Holodomor that she is promoting.

  • @jacqueslorenz1386
    @jacqueslorenz1386 Před rokem +19

    This lady does not understand that this bill will be used as a tool to wreck havoc by greedy operatives

  • @stevennortje8399
    @stevennortje8399 Před rokem +11

    Why should the owners go to court? And have all the cost that goes with it?

  • @markstuart-howie5242
    @markstuart-howie5242 Před rokem +10

    Pure evil

    • @samanthaholm9634
      @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem +1

      @african125 They are expropriating everyone's lands and it's not going back to the 'natives' as you call them. It will be utilised how the government sees fit example could be CADRE sharing. Ministers suddenly getting 'new' land 'unitilised' land. Impossible you say. Ask a nice Zimbabwean what they think.

    • @samanthaholm9634
      @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem +1

      @african125 Lets hope not. But this government does crazy things. And with the coalition government coming they are like a bunch if children with massive egos never taught to share. Everything is how they are feeling not seeing the bigger picture for the country us the citizens. G-D HELP US.

    • @Dotata2009
      @Dotata2009 Před 5 měsíci

      Evil is when the colonizers took our land. Now they tell us it's evil to pass this bill.

  • @ntsakobalow4807
    @ntsakobalow4807 Před rokem +10

    A big joke

  • @saamstaan6540
    @saamstaan6540 Před rokem +5

    All soe's are now mine,i claim them for myself,because they are under utilized,lying there dormant,and no compensation will be giving.

    • @samanthaholm9634
      @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem

      Yes I also want an unused mine. Not being operated as they have no consistent electricity.

  • @swartkat4394
    @swartkat4394 Před rokem +15

    This lady's smile will disappear when Woolworths' shelves are empty, banks collapse and the masses are starving. Or maybe she'll run to England and say 'it's bad, but they didn't do it the right way'

    • @hendriklerou4902
      @hendriklerou4902 Před rokem

      This leftist smiling lady is so dangerous.

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem

      Why dont you listen to what she have to say??? Stop making up your own bullshit stories.

    • @Predikant
      @Predikant Před rokem

      Bravo, well said!
      South Africans are going to starve.
      Be very wary of these Liberals,all smiles whilst the hatchet rains down on the necks of the Proletariat.

  • @stevennortje8399
    @stevennortje8399 Před rokem +8

    Why have a law like that, should the constitution not protect against that? There is also the clause whereby they could occupy your property and can than be expropriated.

    • @FistoMnisi
      @FistoMnisi Před rokem

      We will change this constitution trust me with or without the ANC we will tackle the Roman Dutch English laws as overarching laws this is not Rome, Dutchland or England as that's where the problem is. The theft by your people will be reversed its just a matter of time.

    • @pato1541
      @pato1541 Před rokem

      Did you do research before you decided to be a clown on the internet?

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem

      Who are THEY ???

    • @samanthaholm9634
      @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem

      'They' is anybody.

    • @pato1541
      @pato1541 Před rokem

      @@samanthaholm9634 I bet you ask for the manager at every restaurant.

  • @jhelm1712
    @jhelm1712 Před rokem +2

    ANC cant even pay their very own staff . People have no idea how dangerous this move will be on the future of South Africans!!!... Giving a government such powers over your property !! Specially giving the ANC that power to take your assets at no cost !!!😑😑😑

  • @everything4304
    @everything4304 Před rokem +3

    The watering down of this bill speaks to how loyal ramaphosa is to white monopoly capital.

  • @stlouisix3
    @stlouisix3 Před rokem +6

    South Afc's becoming Venezuela🇻🇪🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😅

    • @Kholmi.28
      @Kholmi.28 Před rokem

      Zimbabwe too. A great example of the danger this bill poses is right next door.

  • @matthysvandenberg1082
    @matthysvandenberg1082 Před rokem +10

    Viva Zimbabwe 2

    • @thomasmsza858
      @thomasmsza858 Před rokem +3

      No problem with your intimidation

    • @matthysvandenberg1082
      @matthysvandenberg1082 Před rokem

      @@thomasmsza858 its not intimidation its a fact dumb clown

    • @matthysvandenberg1082
      @matthysvandenberg1082 Před rokem

      @@thomasmsza858 can see you are 1 of those brain dead people

    • @Dotata2009
      @Dotata2009 Před 5 měsíci

      Did Zim people die. They are still alive and they are wiser. The grandchildren of the former colonizers can go back to their forefathers land if they don't want this direction.

    • @matthysvandenberg1082
      @matthysvandenberg1082 Před 5 měsíci

      @@Dotata2009 lol im i dont argue with an Professional Idiot lol

  • @Dinuzulu1879
    @Dinuzulu1879 Před rokem +2

    Every other African country they own their land but us. We have to chase these settlers to the sea

  • @hendriklerou4902
    @hendriklerou4902 Před rokem +2

    This smiling mentality where she has no idea the seriousness of this matter.
    I think this lady is a Cadre of the ANC. I wonder how much they paid her .
    THIS WILL DRIVE SOUTH AFRICA INTO MASS POVERTY.

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem +1

      THINKING is definately not the thing for you to do...

    • @hendriklerou4902
      @hendriklerou4902 Před rokem

      After you destroy SA, then you will cry you have no food or work.
      What will you entitled people do then?

  • @architecture.w
    @architecture.w Před rokem +2

    Great news!!

  • @freelancekate8919
    @freelancekate8919 Před rokem +2

    this sounds like what they did in Zimbabwe.

  • @deanthechamp5669
    @deanthechamp5669 Před rokem +4

    Theft

  • @peace6325
    @peace6325 Před rokem +7

    Not the first time it has been whispered into South African's ears with a smile. We know where this madness is heading. "For now" are words spoken before anarchy.

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem

      Meet Stupid...

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem +2

      You meant to say before crazed communism, not before anarchy {which would simply mean voluntaryism}.

    • @peace6325
      @peace6325 Před rokem +1

      @@stlouisix3 exactly 👍😁

  • @basmdaka6954
    @basmdaka6954 Před rokem +4

    All stolen land must be returned - thieves know themselves

  • @rtasvadam1776
    @rtasvadam1776 Před rokem

    This is going to end in Disaster.

  • @TheNosarajr
    @TheNosarajr Před rokem

    It will destroy the farms, because the farmer has the skill, and he's paying a mortgage. A fool taking ownership will be a disaster.

  • @samanthaholm9634
    @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem +2

    It's not just your property they can expropriate your assets as well. It vaguely tells you it can take any of your assets. It will be selective on people according to what 'they' think. I love she says there is a misreading it sounds vague and open to misinterpretation. The court is only the land court not high court with you having no right to legal representation. You have to represent yourself. The vagueness is going to take land.

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem +1

      The word 'property' includes all assets, though I understand that you're referring to physical land property and the buildings 🏠 atop it👍🏻

    • @peace6325
      @peace6325 Před rokem

      Yes, and at the end of the day, this is the 'same system' which told South Africans they are not going to give cause and effect the benefit of the doubt when it comes to the explicit words 'ki## the boer'. Why? Because we are also just 'misreading' it.

    • @samanthaholm9634
      @samanthaholm9634 Před rokem

      @@stlouisix3 Again as I say the vaguenes and misinterpretation is bad enough to take our assets. What people don't understand if they can do it to me they can do it to you. Its early days.

    • @kithinjikwiriga2666
      @kithinjikwiriga2666 Před rokem

      Yes they should target criminals and proceeds of crime.in this case all the white or Asian land owners are thieves and they should be targeted and their assets repod

    • @gideo5792
      @gideo5792 Před 9 měsíci

      It is all stolen assets, the invaders should not be given a dime for any of their ill-gotten gains.

  • @jsvanderheever691
    @jsvanderheever691 Před rokem +1

    The Soros employees from PLAAS wrote this and passed to ANC, thus why such a big smug smile on her face.

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem +1

      Are you certain it wasn't specifically the UN or WEF?🤣😂😅😅

    • @Predikant
      @Predikant Před rokem

      @@stlouisix3 I am certain that this pack of ravenous Wolves are all in it together.
      Let us not overlook the IMF and The Clinton Foundation too!

  • @jimmymshali6661
    @jimmymshali6661 Před rokem +5

    these. satanists. must bring our land back. to the rightful owners

    • @sellomabina3939
      @sellomabina3939 Před rokem

      @Brandon Liechti it is ,its for africans

    • @jhelm1712
      @jhelm1712 Před rokem

      It was never yours to start off with lol...

    • @sellomabina3939
      @sellomabina3939 Před rokem +1

      @@jhelm1712 then why was there wars before it was taken ,it's our land get used to it

  • @hantieprins3891
    @hantieprins3891 Před rokem

    Why has she been entrusted with this issue... what is her credentials...

  • @vanessaa306
    @vanessaa306 Před rokem +4

    It's just a bill it's not law. We're not contracted to Anc in anyway. No legal agreement therefore its not valid

    • @matthysvandenberg1082
      @matthysvandenberg1082 Před rokem +4

      They dont care about papwork if they want it they will take it !!

    • @truth-Hurts375
      @truth-Hurts375 Před rokem

      Grow a brain !!! A law is a law...idiot !!!

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem +1

      That applies to all governments globally, not only the ANCsocialist elite👍🏻

    • @vanessaa306
      @vanessaa306 Před rokem

      @@stlouisix3 only if you allow it. I didn't not sign anything with anc so it doesn't apply. They're a corporation, I'm an individual. Corporation cannot do business with an individual. Go study common law, that's God's law. The only law that applies to all individuals worldwide!!

    • @vanessaa306
      @vanessaa306 Před rokem

      @@matthysvandenberg1082 it is illegal what they're doing but they get away with it because people don't know their rights. The same applies to debt. That was just to enslave mankind but it's nearly all over thanks to Trump

  • @jimmymshali6661
    @jimmymshali6661 Před rokem +5

    they took our land. without compensation now they want to. be compensated for the land they took from. the owners without compensation

    • @redeemablesoul
      @redeemablesoul Před rokem +2

      You do realize that they can come for your house as well

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem +2

      @@redeemablesoul they're too filled with vengeance and retaliation to ever think rationally and reasonably, so no -he just wants to punish not think or realise.

    • @stlouisix3
      @stlouisix3 Před rokem

      @@redeemablesoulbut we should still try help them see the facts and the ☦✝☦light 💡 🤣🤣😂😅

    • @Predikant
      @Predikant Před rokem

      ....and now these Marxists are going to take the food from your plate.
      This is my 100% written guarantee
      Zimbabweans had an option, South Africans don't!

    • @sellomabina3939
      @sellomabina3939 Před rokem +1

      @@redeemablesoul nope thats not what it means

  • @ChickenVeggi
    @ChickenVeggi Před rokem +1

    Land expropriation with compensation is okay. Most country has that. In US its called eminent domain. But it has to be strict. the process must be clean and fair. Compensation must be fair. But South Africa's corrupt government doesn't give confidence

    • @faa9261
      @faa9261 Před 11 měsíci

      That’s hogwash the land was stolen.

  • @irvinnhlumayo9864
    @irvinnhlumayo9864 Před rokem +1

    It's about time

  • @grantbarnado7007
    @grantbarnado7007 Před rokem

    Prefer Ruth of the Bible..