Manticore Project - Pictures at an Exhibition (ELP Cover)
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 04. 2016
- Courtesy of Komunitas Salihara
Video Shot by: Tridoso Novrianto
Sound Engineer: Danny Ardiono
Lighting Designer: Maruli Hutabarat
Currator: Tony Prabowo
MANTICORE PROJECT “Tribute to Emerson, Lake and Palmer”
@ Salihara Theatre, Jakarta
Dameria Hutabarat: Grand Piano & Pipe Organ Sound
Krisna Prameswara: Hammond Organ, Mini Moog & Keyboard
Dave Lumenta: Bass, Guitar, Synthesizer & Vocal
Farman Purnama: Tenor Lead Vocal
Yandi Andaputra: Drums & Percussions
As the song says, "you don't know what you've got till it's gone". While I was a big fan of ELP during my youth, now that they're gone I realize what incredible geniuses they were. I was fortunate to see them many times over the years. Oh what a lucky man I was!!
Right there with you brother!!!!
All the great artists' just gone! But many fans of ELP are still missing them. RIP!
Very well done !! I wish I could have been there for the recording.
excellent
Takes balls/talent to attempt this. NICE JOB!
Wow, Listen to the Drummer! All in all very nice performance 👍
Mantaaab..saya gak nyangka ternyata Manticore Project ini dari Indonesia..sangat jarang group Band Indonesia membawakan lagu" ELP...seingat saya dulu sekitar tahun 1975 - 1980 an group Band Indonesia yang sering membawakan ELP adalah SAS Band (Soenata T, Arthur K dan Syech A) ..mereka sering membawakan Karn Evil 9 (Brain Salad Surgery), Promaenade sampai The Hut of Baba yaga (Picture of an Exhibittion) juga Living Sin (Trilogy)...anyway saya bangga dgn Manticore Project ini karena saya Huge Fans ELP juga..secara musikalitas mantaab...cuma vokalisnya kok terkesan seperti Penyanyi Seriosa..lanjut
ブラボー！素晴らしい！！ELPの再現力半端ないです！！！思わず最後まで聴き入ってしまいました。
Great, Great rendition of my favorite ELP classical renditions.Excellent!!!Everybody in this band played with the same momentum as played on the LP...thank you for honoring Rock's finest band.Great.!! Death is life is the appropriate lyrics in the end.
WOW !! Very nicely done Bravo !! Very close to the original 70s album version. I like the way they fit “Fanfare for the Common Man” into it.
The vocal style added a different flavor also. Almost operatic in feel.
All in all, GREAT job 👏
Wow, amazing beyond words. ELP recreated with love and passion.
I love that they are honoring the best! I’m disappointed there are so few views. Sad most people have no idea who these stars truly were in the day that they created such technology when it previously never existed half a century ago!
Amazing performance guys!!! 👋👌
😮outstanding ! They would be proud !
Thanks on nice performance and efforts invested, it's really needed hard work to play ELP.
Bravi tutti, ma il timbro della voce di Lake rimane unico ! RIP Lake and Keith...
Wonderful to hear this great performance, congratulations and thank you for sharing this!
I'm to the vocal coming in. I'm staying to the end. Great job w the vocal. That determined it. Band is great.
Carl Palmer would be proud of that drumming.
EXELENTE EXCELENTE EXCELENTE 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍
If you are going to do a tribute you got to up the ante! Carl Palmer will surely smile if he sees this performance!
Excellent work chaps. I think Rachael Flowers should have been on keyboards though. 👍
Welcome back my friends to the show that never ends, ladies and gentlemen
¡Extraordinaria versión! Impecable ejecución de este sagrado himno de ELP.
Respetable ejecución, gran talento, aunque 5 musicos para replicar lo que hizo el trio ELP hace 50 años, siempre nos deja la sensación de lo grandiosos que fueron. RIP Keith and Greg, y larga vida al buen Carl Palmer.
Great! Completely unique cover! Greetings from Hungary, from the land of Béla Bartók.
The end part is especially good .
GREAT!!! Greetings from Brazil.
Great cover of this masterpiece of Moussorsgy Of course ELP played it perfect in the seventies
Very very sensational 👍👍👍
Que bueno que existen estos grupos que tocan la musica de ELP, porque el hacerlo..keith y Greg siguen viviendo gracias a todos ellos
Yes. All remembers. This music of Russian compositor. Modest Mussorgsky. 😊
Very good 😊
Great sound of the bass 👍
Great performance !!!
Beh...bravissimi.
Il tastierista e' una belva. Spacca?
Di dove siete?
Where you come from?
Indonesia
Grazie, un abbraccio da
Italia.
Incredibly soberb!!!!
Outstanding!!
This was great with heart, Thanks
Only surprised not to see Rachel Flowers on keyboard.
GReat sound!!!!!!!!!!!
Got that Ultra Clean GL sound absolutely down
Long live Western culture!
Da,mi-a plăcut.!
Excellent arrangement and performance, wonderful young musicians are passing the torch. Now I need to research the last 3 words, I thought it was “Death is Life”, but in this version I hear “Time has Come”. Perhaps ELP themselves altered those words in different eras.
I don’t think so
Awsome! darn good musicians. For a moment i though Keith Emerson was playing the keyboard
Very close to palmers skill and style 🎉🎉
Great stuff! But I'm heartbroken that there isn't a Greg Lake sound alike or ever will be.
the songs no need for vibration in my opinion
Did not like the singer .sounded like an Opra singer with a heavy accent
@@lorraine6848 That's why I liked him. I was expecting a Greg Lake tribute singer and was pleasantly surprised. I caught Crimson's last tour. The only downside other than at least one too many drummers , was the vocalist singing too much like Wetton .
Thank you.
Amazing!
Amazing Dame
Isso é muito mais que um tributo. Transcende !! ! !!
Soberb
Excellent !!!!
Una verdadera maravilla 😃
Belleza en toda.su expresión
Excellent! I really enjoyed that, great job
DAMN! Brilliant, you all, thank you!
Love the "King Crimson - Red" T-shirt
Superb!
I deeply have vibrato vocals, especially in a pice that doesn't call for it.
Bravo!!!
Excelente......
It was great but
Why don't you guys do the more consolidated version from 77-78 live?
That was the best.
NASSAU COLISEUM 78
I hate to disagree with you the best was Isle of Wight. I've seen them all.
Great:-)
To be more precise - Modest Musorgsky cover...
No, it's an ELP cover, not considering that there is also Edvard Grieg's "Solveig's Song", you call cover the Ravel's orchestration?
I much prefer the lone piano or Rock band versions to Ravel's . He doesn't seem to get the feel.
goood
Thank you, great great playing. But where is the Blues Improvisation, much better piece, instead Fanfare for the common Man.
bravi
Brasil🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
A bit nervous, but excellent job!
Bravi👏👏👏👏👍👍🎹🎹🎹
Having had the priviledge of actually attending the original ELP recording in 1971 feel a little underwhelmed with this version.
Do as much acid as you did then, and it might be more whelming. Even if you didn't/don't turn on, a concert experience is much more intense than sitting in your living room .
Hut of Baba Yaga
time has what?
Come
Where’s Blues Variation? The best track on the album. Why replace it with Fanfare? Too difficult to play?
You're absolutely right. Blues variation just might have been the most difficult keyboard piece to play that I've ever heard or seen there's no way these guys could have done that. At least they know their limitations.
Amen. How do they leave that out???? However, I do think this is a great reproduction effort overall
I agree. It's the best part of a brilliant musical masterpiece. I guess it's too difficult for them to play. It's too bad because it is my favorite part.
@@davidallmond5598 Blues variation was the ultimate jazz blues rock keyboard piece on the Hammond like only the great Keith Emerson could do it. Unfortunately I saw that the movies in the 1970s and later on DVD and they used the Psychedelic color flashover effects during the amazing keyboard parts. To totally block everything out except the audio. It's available on DVD as part of the original pictures at an exhibition release by Emerson Lake and Palmer in 1970. I would kill if there was a way to clean that up so we could actually see Blues variation as it was played. Unfortunately back done everything had to have a psychedelic Edge to it and what a waste that that was the song they did it too. I don't think any keyboardist could have pulled that off like the great Emerson could. I think Rick Wakeman and Tony Banks would have slobbered theirselves if they even tried. Keith Emerson God on keyboards.
@@davidallmond5598 not only that David whoever put the video together screwed up that particular song big time the original movie that came out in the seventies was called rock and roll your eyes. It's schold the tracks off of their first album and all of pictures at an exhibition. The entire song Blues variation was masked in 1960s early 70s psychedelic lights and cartoon superhero figures the sound was great but you couldn't see the musicians playing and that was a tragedy. When the DVD of that concert once released in the later 80s it was exactly the same. I asked around about a way to take all of that out electronically somehow but was told it was part of the original and therefore impossible. It's a shame they covered up the greatest Keith Emerson peace ever.
Only the bassist is paying good tribute to ELP/Greg Lake, the others whose technical skills may be more than sufficient, don't seem to understand ELP let alone Moussorgsky.
Well executed but curiously lacking in emotion.
Is that George Soros on vocals? You know he wrote Pictures at an Exhibition... he said so!
As much as the singer put his heart into it he just didn't make it. Greg Lake's voice very hard to follow it was made for this piece. I wish they could have had just one keyboard player. A few minor screw UPS but overall not a bad try.
Ive heard alot of covers of ELP this is average garage band stuff .... best part was the analog synth .. worst part was a tie between the vocals and the drumming ...A for effort but the execution didnt move my needle one volt accept for some of the synth
Sorry, but this is nowhere near the original. Average!
I don't understand why the bass players covering ELP don't use a proper bass distortion....Otherwise, great performance