ANDY GIBB, How can you mend a broken heart?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
  • How Can You Mend A Broken Heart? is a song released by the Bee Gees in 1971. The song had been written by Barry and Robin Gibb in August 1970.when the Gibb brothers had reconvened following a period of break-up and alienation. They said that they originally offered it to Andy Williams, but ultimately the Bee Gees recorded it themselves and included it on their 1971 album, Trafalgar.

Komentáře • 534

  • @harukolane4369
    @harukolane4369 Před 11 lety +18

    Another beautiful voice from the Gibbs. Sorry that he was the youngest brother and died earliest. Rest in peace Andy, Maurice and Robin, you are immortal to us, and God Bless Barry, the oldest brother and his family. We love all of you.

  • @Nadine-uh3qt
    @Nadine-uh3qt Před 3 lety +11

    2021 and still missing all of the Gibb brothers.

  • @stickywicket7585
    @stickywicket7585 Před 4 lety +31

    I love this song but it makes me so sad. He's been gone for so long. It just breaks my heart. If I only could I'd bring Andy, Maurice and Robin back. I miss them all so much. I can't even imagine how their family must've felt losing those three beautiful people. It's just not fair. No one said a word about the sorrow.

  • @francobassobertrand9206
    @francobassobertrand9206 Před 4 lety +14

    Para mi el mejor tema de los Bee Gees y excelente versión de Andy Gibb en Viña del Mar👏👏👏👏👏

  • @johnhiram1207
    @johnhiram1207 Před 11 lety +18

    All the Gibbs brothers left us with an amazing legacy of gorgeous music. Some of the best music ever.

  • @ChristiLatte
    @ChristiLatte Před 13 lety +6

    I got to meet him, about a year before the end. He was so sweet, touring the B circuit. It was at the hotel he was staying at, in the bar. I was shy and young, and he seemed a little hurt when I didn't reach out to him when he did me. When I did, he brought me in to him, like a side hug. It was amazing, I was a fan from the beginning. We got a table next to the stage, and he sort of sang to me a few times in the show. I'll never forget Andy. Heart broken the way he spent his last 6 months.

  • @MySanko
    @MySanko Před 14 lety +16

    I will forever cherish your performance, Andy. Thank you for the wonderful people who made this collection possible. You will always be alive in my memory!

  • @nadjabacelar3061
    @nadjabacelar3061 Před 6 lety +15

    I love his voice.
    It's very painful to know he's not here anymore.

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 4 lety +30

    9/28/19 Andy still makes me cry. I miss him Gone way to soon.

  • @BedfordFalls7
    @BedfordFalls7 Před 11 lety +42

    He was so handsome and talented. Every time I see him, I have to say "Why" why did he have to go. :(

    • @stephencraig5938
      @stephencraig5938 Před 4 lety +2

      Still so sad

    • @ivantrostolf7754
      @ivantrostolf7754 Před 3 lety

      Drugs, what a pity!!! No one neither himself had head to control this shit called drugs. Drugs that some stupids still approve, some politcs.

    • @juliuscaesar5001
      @juliuscaesar5001 Před 3 lety +3

      This world is not a place for a delicate good hearted human being, they all leave early

    • @felinaumali6538
      @felinaumali6538 Před 3 lety +3

      Same here,keep asking why?

  • @TheFishMiester
    @TheFishMiester Před 8 lety +40

    It's amazing how the youngest went first and the oldest is still left !

    • @ralex3697
      @ralex3697 Před 6 lety +8

      The mom outlived three of her sons, beyond sad

    • @Harrisonianne
      @Harrisonianne Před 3 lety +4

      I've heard a story in which Barry was involved, that he would have been the first Bee Gee whod die as a child due to an accident he had in the kitchen. Somebody knows about it?

    • @juongsianglim2744
      @juongsianglim2744 Před 3 lety +1

      @@Harrisonianne he could talk or cry until he's nearly 1 year old only became normal , yes supposedly Barry was the about supposed to past away but now he's the last beegees standing Legend

    • @decorosomonsantojr.6489
      @decorosomonsantojr.6489 Před 3 lety

      gerat sound.like his brother barr gibb😊☺️♥️❤️

    • @shannontaylor3725
      @shannontaylor3725 Před 3 lety +1

      @@Harrisonianne yes he spilt boiling water over himself. He spent months in hospital including in coma.

  • @cababyboomerq6012
    @cababyboomerq6012 Před rokem +9

    Barry Gibb really was the brains behind this musical family. He knew how to make them stars and keep them stars. I wish Andy had lived to be in the group. It would have been great. His voice was just like theirs. A perfect brotherly fit.

    • @r.j.vanderveen4852
      @r.j.vanderveen4852 Před 4 měsíci

      No not at all...your wishfull thinking...he had his own concept being solist performer...you stick everything together dont you...? Your not God...are you?😅

    • @r.j.vanderveen4852
      @r.j.vanderveen4852 Před 4 měsíci

      God s the brains afther their talents n gifts dont you think???

  • @1JulianneD
    @1JulianneD Před 6 lety +9

    truly a great singer! wonderful tone, interpretation, control, he just has it all. love u andy!

  • @philsan6743
    @philsan6743 Před 5 lety +4

    Reste le chanteur inoubliable ! Quel talent ! 😍😄

  • @chachris08
    @chachris08 Před 13 lety +2

    andy gibb... my childhood idol... i still think about you after all these years....

  • @Eightiesgirl46
    @Eightiesgirl46 Před 14 lety +17

    Bless him....his eyes just look so sad. Too bad he didnt realize how much he was truly loved. He gave so much of himself in his performances and such a class act!

    • @r.j.vanderveen4852
      @r.j.vanderveen4852 Před 4 měsíci

      Thats called assuming...right?😮

    • @r.j.vanderveen4852
      @r.j.vanderveen4852 Před 4 měsíci

      Oh he really knew how he was loved...dont you think...????...you dont know him so well do you???

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 7 lety +2

    It doesn't matter what day or time I see this song I still tear up such a loss

  • @rubyheft2951
    @rubyheft2951 Před rokem +3

    What a talent. Too bad he didn’t stay with us. We needed his wonderful talent.

  • @penteleisheila6530
    @penteleisheila6530 Před 9 lety +2

    Gyönyörű hangja volt ! Nagyon fáj !!!!
    Szerettem !!!

  • @lorrainejames
    @lorrainejames Před 15 lety +5

    I love the song but the lyrics ring true for me. It rings true for everyone who's gotten their heart broken and wanted the pain to stop.

  • @rosaurasanchez9651
    @rosaurasanchez9651 Před 9 lety +7

    andy todavía lo escuchó y me hace vibrar en verdad es maravilloso

  • @CVsnaredevil
    @CVsnaredevil Před 17 lety +2

    omg andy had a voice just like his brothers. What an amazing family the gibbs.

  • @Kantarranas
    @Kantarranas Před 15 lety +16

    A beautiful song. I didn´t know this Andy's
    version existed. I really like it. Thanks so much for sharing.

  • @bethvirginiaphillips4583
    @bethvirginiaphillips4583 Před 2 lety +4

    Andy once said he'd give anything to be one of the Bee Gees but was never let in that elite group. He was one talented guy, and surely missed.

    • @cooter-of7ej
      @cooter-of7ej Před 3 měsíci +1

      thats not right they tried to get him to join them but he liked the solo

    • @SL-fu7sh
      @SL-fu7sh Před 2 měsíci

      Andy was going to be a Bee Gee. Everyone was excited but then he died suddenly! So heartbreaking ❤️‍🩹

  • @bettinaallramseder5894
    @bettinaallramseder5894 Před 3 lety +2

    So wonderful voice with great and deep feeling.. love forever dear Andy Gibb

  • @Ricardo-ng6ou
    @Ricardo-ng6ou Před 7 lety +8

    Saudoso Andy,perfeito na voz.

  • @Lotus-ox6is
    @Lotus-ox6is Před 5 lety +1

    How can you stop the sun from shining what makes the world go around? Rest Easy Sweetie! We love and miss you! Andy!

  • @MaiNguyen-fy4sv
    @MaiNguyen-fy4sv Před 3 lety +1

    He had so much charm!!!!!

  • @outraclasse
    @outraclasse Před 3 lety +1

    This is a real man broken heart.. great Andy Gibb

  • @lilane4ever
    @lilane4ever Před 15 lety +1

    Gosh he looks so much like Barry! God bless him...so sad how he left this world.

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 7 lety +5

    What a sad day in the music world when Andy died. I could listen to his music for hours. You wonder what he could have done if he lived. Love Love Love Andy

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 4 lety +2

    8/20/20 Damn it I hate that he did die of a broken heart. I still love his music and he makes me cry that he left so soon.

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 6 lety +2

    I LISTEN TO THIS EVERY DAY. I JUST LOVE HOW HAPPY Andy was.

  • @leticiahernandez2169
    @leticiahernandez2169 Před 7 měsíci

    Puro talento Andy giib, lástima q se fue tan joven, disfruté mucho de su música en mi juventud y adolescencia

  • @sherrynordan9821
    @sherrynordan9821 Před rokem

    He sounded so much like his brother, Barry to me. They were all special!

  • @barbaracovell
    @barbaracovell Před 15 lety

    sweeet ...love this song, so tender xxandy i would have mended your heart hunni x

  • @bettyboo880
    @bettyboo880 Před 10 lety +4

    Awesome he was one among artists in his era that was great and died so young.

    • @SSol-ib1fe
      @SSol-ib1fe Před 10 lety +2

      es cierto andy era y siempre sera un artista de verdad a los artistas de verdad como andy no se lo olvida facilmente al contrario se lo recuerda siempre porque se lo amaremos hasta el fin de vuestras vidas

  • @neesousunebonneetoile
    @neesousunebonneetoile Před 2 lety +2

    Andy Gibb 1958-1988. Paix à son âme 😇🕯️🕊️

  • @sparkie92567
    @sparkie92567 Před 15 lety +4

    Andy maid a wonderful addition to the Gibb brother,his big brothers taught him well,so sad to see him go so early in his life!

  • @Eightiesgirl46
    @Eightiesgirl46 Před 14 lety +5

    At 0.15- I just love how when Andy smiles his whole face would just lite up! What a beautiful soul he was. Miss him!!

  • @tinamac916
    @tinamac916 Před 15 lety +3

    What a tragic loss, not the hair or the clothes, but the man. RIP

  • @leticiahernandez2169
    @leticiahernandez2169 Před rokem +1

    Qué lindo fué Andy gibb, talento extraordinario, lastima se fue tan rápido , Dios lo tenga en su santa gloria.

  • @johnny10301968
    @johnny10301968 Před 9 lety +33

    Andy paying tribute to his brothers.

  • @gdmxia
    @gdmxia Před 4 lety

    Damn this man how can i only know you now???????😭😭😭 cries in 90s born kid

  • @mrsandygibb7342
    @mrsandygibb7342 Před 10 lety +8

    ARG, ur broken heart has been mended because u r in the loving arms of our Heavenly Father. I THANK God everyday for ur beautiful music & memories. U r the BEST of the BEST. And U will NEVER EVER be forgotten. LV U ALWAYS!!!

  • @terry21651
    @terry21651 Před 9 lety +48

    GOD he sounds like Barry!

    • @shandi4114
      @shandi4114 Před 9 lety +7

      Looks just like Barry, too. And according to Barry, they had the exact same birthmark (just born 12 years apart!)

    • @shachardave
      @shachardave Před 8 lety +2

      +terry21651 NO KIDDING, I HAD TO LOOK TO SEE WHICH ONE IT WAS. HE WAS BARRY RE-INCARNATED.

    • @lowriderlandon4377
      @lowriderlandon4377 Před 4 lety

      ABSOLUTELY

    • @metalinl-a1128
      @metalinl-a1128 Před 4 lety

      They look like each other.
      Yea, he should of stayed under Barry's wing more. Who knows.
      He rocked it starting at 14 yrs old. That's amazing I. 16 years of touring and studio recordings.
      People don't know that Andy had QUIT the yoyos.nAnd then in 1987 recorded " Arrow Through The Heart" another Barry Gibb production. Incredible stuff. Andy had a heart condition. Doctors did not have the life saving protocal\ information his UK doctors knew about or had in his medical so dossier. Destiny.
      He was like his interview stated " On his next round of conquering" the music world again. I believe in 1987/ 1988 Andy WOULD HAVE TOURED along with the BEEGEES or cobheadlined with them.
      Incredible Musical Strength invtgat Family. All 4 of them.
      And then Maurice went down in his early 50s? Then Robin at like 62? Ish. And who's left. The eldest brother. " Staying Alive he is that ole BARRY" THBS UP

  • @barbaracovell
    @barbaracovell Před 15 lety

    i love you andy ...you will always be in my heart and i will listen to ur music everyday ..you are so missed babe x

  • @berlinstadtderjugendberlin8478

    Beutiful. Voice!! I just love it!!

  • @ginbn7019
    @ginbn7019 Před 2 lety +2

    Andy seems to retain the pain in this song only he knew what he felt when singing this song😢

  • @zenalaus
    @zenalaus Před 12 lety +1

    And no one can 'claim' him except for Mama & Papa Gibb & his Gibb siblings!

  • @VonSeeka
    @VonSeeka Před 14 lety +13

    I remember being in Chile when Andy performed this (at Viña del Mar Music Festival in the early eighties). I was amazed for two things: He was so loved by the people there and he knew it. He sang for almost two hours (maybe more) in order to pay back his public for all the love they gave to him, singing songs he hand't prepared like this one. See that girl that climbed the stage just to kiss him full on his lips. Only latins would do such a thing and what Andy did?..He just let her do it....

    • @daviddavila7486
      @daviddavila7486 Před 2 lety +2

      Increíble.....comentario!!!. Gracias andy desde stgo Chile 👍🇨🇱

    • @gleycianesantos6515
      @gleycianesantos6515 Před 2 lety +1

      How can be possible fall in love for.someone that you Never met in life and that person doesn't exist anymore!? That'S exactlly wha i'm Felling 4 Andy Gibb.

  • @eddiekhuratchajaval3063
    @eddiekhuratchajaval3063 Před 11 lety +2

    I miss you Andy!! RIP.

  • @MaryMRevis
    @MaryMRevis Před 17 lety +1

    Barry always said that since Robin and Mo were twins...Andy was his *smile*. God bless you Andy..rest in peace.

  • @ellenludtke3223
    @ellenludtke3223 Před 5 lety +5

    Amazing how much he sounded like Barry’s!

  • @Elphonzier
    @Elphonzier Před 14 lety

    i wish i was growing up during the BeeGees era... back in 67 lets say... i wish.... but sadyno im young :( but i love the wonderful music of the Gibb's

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 3 lety

    12/18/20 Still listening and MISS Andy!!

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 4 lety +1

    9/5/20 still love Andy.

  • @gaylemillerround123
    @gaylemillerround123 Před 7 lety +1

    My first concert was Any Gibb-RIP♥️♥️♥️

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 3 lety +1

    3/2/21 I still LOVE & MISS Andy!!!!

  • @brendasmith6046
    @brendasmith6046 Před 4 lety +3

    5/20/20 LOVE & MISS Andy he still makes me cry.

  • @onceuonceu3266
    @onceuonceu3266 Před 3 lety +1

    Awesome Performance !

  • @mackayellen
    @mackayellen Před 12 lety

    andy that victoria was a cradle robber she never should have led you on you were to special to all your fans and well love are hearts were all broke when you past rip love always

  • @grandmasmurf2915
    @grandmasmurf2915 Před rokem

    Imo the best looking Bee Gee!

  • @larkat50psd
    @larkat50psd Před 15 lety

    i love u andy and i always will . yes ev1 has problems and rhey allways will.but u will a;ways be with us all till we die..may u rest in peace mvgf. love u forever

  • @RolandD70
    @RolandD70 Před 15 lety +1

    Really beautiful and soulful version of Andy (RIP), initially i did not like this version but, hearing carefully he hd a fell really amazing, My total respect to the minor brohter of Gibbs, HI FROM MEXICO!!!!!

  • @DreaRahming
    @DreaRahming Před 9 lety +4

    Such talented boys all of them they made us fall in love with them and we can never stop and we like it that way

  • @pinkpanthersdad
    @pinkpanthersdad Před 14 lety

    Out of all the Brothers Gibbs I had no idea which one was Andy, now I know and I feel for him, I once had a lady that I can relate to what he felt!!!

  • @barbaracovell
    @barbaracovell Před 15 lety

    andy your just perfect beautiful soul......and this performance is stuning ,,xxxr i p sweety andy my lovexxxxxbabs

  • @user-es2dz5sf7v
    @user-es2dz5sf7v Před rokem

    Hermoso!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤🙏🙏✨😘💞🫂💥💥😎💯💯💯💯💯🤗🤗

  • @dinodeano1
    @dinodeano1 Před 11 lety +3

    your right they dont make music like that anymore. The bee gees were in a league of their own. Ive been listening to alot of videos on you tube. sure brings back memories. I have been moved by their beautiful music, and sadened by the loss of the the 3 Gibbs brothers

  • @AprilMckeen
    @AprilMckeen Před 10 lety +5

    one of my favorites :)

    • @AprilMckeen
      @AprilMckeen Před 10 lety +1

      Thank you*music is whats keeping me alive**sad*much love
      April Mckeen

  • @barbaracovell
    @barbaracovell Před 15 lety

    such a heartwrending song...sung
    with great passion by sweer andy!
    his voice is angelic here....love ya till eternity andyx
    babs hugs to you amy xxx

  • @marlenesullivan3113
    @marlenesullivan3113 Před 4 lety +1

    SWEET SWEET MUSIC MAN 🕺💔

  • @Badfingerbabe777
    @Badfingerbabe777 Před 11 lety +1

    Andy my heart will never mend from missing you,, God Bless you and your family!!

  • @coromilcoromil9394
    @coromilcoromil9394 Před 2 lety

    Angelical que bello 🤗😍 en paz descanse 🙏😍😍😍😍

  • @lullaby61
    @lullaby61 Před 11 lety +4

    Always loved...god bless our Andy...x

  • @Cynporro
    @Cynporro Před 15 lety

    Beautifuuuul song, beautiful Hairrrrr

  • @jewelrouse3537
    @jewelrouse3537 Před 10 lety +2

    How can u let drugs ruin ur life? Miss ur songs!

    • @Holymakinaw
      @Holymakinaw Před 9 lety +2

      Springbrook Poodles His heart problems were brought on by years of drug abuse.

  • @andronicomenachiroque2814

    Desde Perú, grande Andy Gib, que pena que las drogas lo liquidaron.
    Sus canciones perdurarán en el tiempo.

  • @herasmarket
    @herasmarket Před 14 lety

    yes I miss Andy to and Victoria Principal was on Dark Shadows out of all places -- and you know how hard it is when you're young to fall for someone and than puff it's over....

  • @mackayellen
    @mackayellen Před 12 lety

    poor andy didnt have many younger days if he had a broken heart i know there was many woman who would have love to fix it love always rest in peace our angel

  • @Cassidy1136
    @Cassidy1136 Před 8 lety +2

    So sad he's gone. I always thought of him as a 'mini Barry' ... same vibrato in his voice.

    • @33MarciS
      @33MarciS Před 8 lety +1

      I did too and they were reportedly especially close.

  • @MariaHelena-vd9nl
    @MariaHelena-vd9nl Před 3 lety +5

    Linnndooo💞

  • @pedromdrveiga9777
    @pedromdrveiga9777 Před 3 lety +2

    Man, you can easily be fooled as to which one of them (either Barry or Andy) you're actually listening to!!! Impressive. Each other's spitting image.

    • @virginiaconner3340
      @virginiaconner3340 Před 2 lety

      Been listening to Bee Gees since late 60s and to me his voice isn't as good as Barry's. The vocal tones are not as rich and clear. Andy's voice had more rasp; however, he sounded a little hoarse here.

  • @farmyardflavours
    @farmyardflavours Před 11 lety +1

    Excelent !!

  • @lorrainemackin3749
    @lorrainemackin3749 Před 2 lety

    He was as Good as his 3 Older Brothers. His death was so sad.😞

  • @janicecarroll7590
    @janicecarroll7590 Před 7 lety

    He seems so happy here. And so beautiful ! Oh be still my beating heart.

  • @Rosanninhabm
    @Rosanninhabm Před 11 lety +1

    Gibbs forever in our hearts

  • @DianaArnaizdee59
    @DianaArnaizdee59 Před 8 lety +1

    always a memorable one ...

  • @paulinebolt6308
    @paulinebolt6308 Před 10 lety +9

    always loved you andy. so sadly missed. x

    • @SSol-ib1fe
      @SSol-ib1fe Před 10 lety +1

      pauline los demas se podran olvidar de andy pero nosotras nunca lo olvidaremos al contrario lo recordaremos siempre porque andy merece que se lo recuerde siempre no se vos pero no te gustaria si andy viviera obvio no decirle cuanto lo amamos y cuanto lo extrañamos a mi si y decirle tambien que nunca habra otro como el hermoso dulce sexy talentoso todo eso quisieramos decirle

  • @ginodellarocca3060
    @ginodellarocca3060 Před rokem

    Pena q viveste tão pouco tempo... curti muito vc. Sdds para sempre dos melhores tempos já vividos...!

  • @ElectedOfficial1
    @ElectedOfficial1 Před 8 lety +1

    Love it!! Wish that girl had been me!

  • @123kateboo
    @123kateboo Před 14 lety

    Beautiful

  • @daramixtv4462
    @daramixtv4462 Před 2 lety

    I love you Andy till now

  • @thereseember2800
    @thereseember2800 Před 5 lety +1

    Rest in peace, dear Andy 🙏

  • @chazking575
    @chazking575 Před 4 lety +2

    Great version of this song.

  • @marmacy
    @marmacy Před 12 lety

    @Velvet2Rose ........so true.. he was a shining spirit..........life takes it out of many of us.
    RIP Andy

  • @shorak98
    @shorak98 Před 10 lety +6

    my hear it's broken losing you .god bless everyone .from Trinidad West Indies. Too the US I will always love you::: never would l forget you holding my hand and singing directly to me ... At Valleyfair Minnesota 👍🏻👍🏼🙏🏻

    • @nguyenthingocanh4
      @nguyenthingocanh4 Před 10 lety

      lucky you

    • @shorak98
      @shorak98 Před 10 lety

      He's nicest guy in the world to me., and I love him

    • @rick3674
      @rick3674 Před 10 lety

      ahhh ! , , mmm one magic moment ,, epic, touches the heart

    • @shorak98
      @shorak98 Před 10 lety

      Yes my heart

    • @rick3674
      @rick3674 Před 10 lety +1

      I meant both :-)

  • @azdificultoso
    @azdificultoso Před 8 lety +38

    Amazing song and voice, he broken ours hearts when died, R.I.P

    • @theressreed5988
      @theressreed5988 Před 6 lety +2

      azdificultoso don't worry...u will see him again....

  • @elhombrenuclear2007
    @elhombrenuclear2007 Před 3 lety +1

    Bella canción !