#3 Yes but I think it's confirmed Jay doing Over Me. #5 I agree with you. But I think they only want 1 Korean Yuehua either Yujin or Gyuvin not both of them. #6 Even in dance battle of Wang Zihao and Yedam. I can see that some highlights part was strangely cutting out. I think it's really heavy edit. Yedam dance highlighted so much with this. Wang Zihao is one of my pick to debut. #10 Agree with you💔 #13 I'm torn between Jay and Seongeon.
@@teumedeobi I'm not sure yet if Zhanghao, Chen Kuan Jui and Ricky will do Over Me. I also seen alot of spoilers that pointing out Jay was really doing Over Me.
Well, till now the angel edit has been working a little too well for shanbin and he does seem like a genuinely good person too. Unless mnet takes it to Dayeon level, I don't think shanbin will get hate for the edits.
I vote for Jay everyday since the beginning of the show and when I see the teaser of the artist song mission I am frustrated. We know that Jay is a strong vocalist, he knows that too. We also know that the killing part fitted more with his vocals, and he knows that too (that’s why he sang that part on the voting period of the song) But I am frustrated, he lowered his hand at the end, he didn’t want to impose himself in this battle. And I am afraid, the trainee most voted will be the one with the killing part (line distribution problems) Compared to the 1-3 ep of the show, I cannot see the Jay’s charm (full with confidence)in the other mission. JUST BE YOURSELF JAY, YOU WILL ATE ANYWAY, please please SING AT EASE CONFIDENCE We have your back, we are behind you, you are talented, you can succeed here or anywhere. We are here with you JUST SING BOY ! FIGHTING !
Mnet released a video which is kind of a teaser for the sports activity of the next show, and we can see that jay was placed in “Over Me”. But that can change because if there are too many surviving trainees in this group they will have to remove some so it's not 100% sure yet but I doubt the other contestants want to remove Jay from this song since 'he would be amazing in it and could make them win
if mnet edits the performance well for Over Me i do have a ton of faith that jay will enter back into the top 9. His adlibs elevate the song to a world class level and based on what attendees said he was perfect in the vocal department last Saturday.
hi, so i’m commenting after they performed it, i’m sure you’re aware but jay got last place :((( but they won the benefit, so hopefully he will be back in the top 9!!
People are gonna be mad at me but I think Jiwoong has decent stage prensence but in terms of skills he shouldn't have such high ranking. He always wears revealing clothes in all of his performances which I think attracts lots of fans
I also do think Hui’s spot in the top 9 is shaky, because of how drastic the changes are in rankings everytime, and the fact that he dropped out once is a concern alr
hmmm taerae instead of gyuvin, i can definitely see it. gyuvin won the most votes in love killa but was barely shown on screen. i feel kinda bad for him. he reminds me of mingyu from seventeen haha. and tbh i didnt realize taerae was from wakeone!! bc they havent really heavily pushed him but he's super talented and main vocal material and i do like him. he would be a great addition to the final lineup, also since i dont know what mnet wants to do with hui.
i think it's going to be zhang hao, matthew, and maybe keita as the 3G. most likely hanbin, jiwoong, yujin/gyuvin probably taerae, gunwook barely there (aka 10-12) jongwoo, hui, park hanbin (wakeone), maybe jay i didnt think lee daeul would make it in the first few episodes evwn before the editing, but based on previous seasons it actually very well could have happened. i know some viewers are upset that matthew and gunwook are getting favorable screentime, but i dont think people will be upset with hanbin to the point it will affect his ranking. he has SO many people in love with him not matter what he does.
My hot take is that there should be a second/third star level test to see how much they have progressed as INDIVIDUALS bc i feel that a lot hide better on groups but aren't all that. Besides the judges kind of become obsolate after episode 2, idk, justify your salary i guess 🤔
I thought Lee Seunghwan would receive more recognition after his viral 1 minute PR video, too bad. I hope he continues to prove himself as the wildest all-rounder in the show.
1. I don’t really care for him to form an opinion, though I will say that he could be the dark horse of BP and make it to top 9 if he continues to rise in the rankings. 2. Agree 3. Considering what the rumored lineup is for Over Me (not gonna name it here) I’d say it’s a toss up. Like I could see it go both ways, but right now I am leaning more towards disagreeing, especially when it comes to the last sentence. Although I could see him enter back into the Top 9 for the 3rd round of eliminations (mostly cause Jay fans are upset that he dropped out of the Top 9 during the 2nd round and are now campaigning more than ever) Jay has a harder chance of debuting than his other Top 9 contenders, and I don’t think the Over Me performance is gonna change that and I’m a huge Jay fan, he’s my one pick so I don’t say this out of malice, I’m more so being realistic. MNET wants 3 global trainees and right now it’s looking like it’s gonna be Matthew, Zhang Hao, and Keita. 4. Don’t really care for this opinion, but I do agree that he might not get it because popular trainees want it. 5. Since Taerae took Hui’s spot in the Top 9 (I predicted either Gunwook or Taerae taking Hui’s spot at some point) and Gunwook will most likely be taking the “4th global trainee” spot, I see Gyuvin staying in the Top 9 especially considering that he won the benefit in Love Killa even with Jiwoong and Matthew in the same performance. The only way I see Gyuvin dropping is that a dark horse trainee takes his spot (this could be anywhere from previous Top 9 contestants like Jay and Hui, or a legit dark horse like Jongwoo or Park Hanbin) Right now I’m leaning more towards disagree but we’ll see what happens. 6. HARD AGREE (I wouldn’t be surprised if he gets evil edited in the 3rd round, but it’s most likely gonna be hide Wang Zihao as much as possible) 7. Yeah…I could see it. 8. DISAGREE. Matthew is debuting either way, so his inclusion in the Top 9 is not going to dictate whether or not the final lineup has 4 G group members. At this point Matthew could debut and the lineup could be just 2 G group members. Matthew is a cutie, but he does not have that kind of power lmao 9. Yeah I agree. I even had him as my 1st final lineup debut before I changed it after the 1st round of eliminations. 10. Agree. I would even add other people like Dang Hong Hai and Wang Zihao in the mix. 11. Disagree. I think his unique voice is what’s gravitating fans into voting for him. He shouldn’t change it. 12. AGREE. Also because Pentagon and CLC are completely different groups when it comes to how CUBE has treated them. CLC has basically been mismanaged and neglected and has lost a couple of members before Yujin decided to join Girls Planet, while Pentagon has been given every opportunity in the world to succeed but sadly has not been able to (due to people generally not being interested in the group, also the dating scandal hindered them as well) People also do not want to vote for him because he either is overqualified, they don’t want him to leave Pentagon, he’s “too old” or all of the above. So right now, it is leaning more towards him NOT debuting (which is sad for me cause I think the final lineup would benefit a lot from having him, since he’ll be a great leader and a producer for the group as well has having pipes of steel and a third lung lol) 13. Correction: Jay is the strongest G group vocalist on Boys Planet. We still need to account for trainees like Hui and Seungeon (and to an extent even Taerae?) But he has a good voice and I want him to debut soooo badly. 14. Agree. But he’s also MASSIVELY popular so people aren’t complaining as much as when Dayeon was getting the angel edits. 15. HARD YES!!!! SAY IT FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK lol
For the 8th one, I think the point is that the producers can excuse Matthew as a G group trainee since he’s culturally and in most sense a Korean trainee. So that way there’s more bandwidth for the producers to push other G-group trainees who are actually ethnically foreign, and say that their group is ‘global’ because they would then have 4 G-group members, when practically keep the number to 3 (as per with Kepler).
all of my opinions are from AFTER all of the artist battle mission performances (episodes 9 and 10) #1. agree! finally someone agrees with me on this. he is definitely good looking, but his rap and singing don't match up with his visuals. #2. agreed. i didn't really think of this until you said it. mnet just has to get fans somehow #3. its after the performance, and he got last :(( butl they got the benefit, so im thinking he might be able to make it back in the top 9. i really hope so, hes my number 1 pick!!! so talented #4. agree to disagree. he got into en garde i think it suits him a lot more, but id love to see him do say my name #5. agree. im not sure if im upset or fine with it. gyuvin and taerae are some people that i just am not too sure of. they have different skills. i dont think gyuvin will make it because they already have 2 dancers in the top9 (gunwook,yujin) but at the same time they have 3 vocalists (zhanghao, hanbin[although hes an all-rounder], and matthew[hopefully jay comes back in there too]) #6. its true, sadly. he got less popular as time went on. hes very talented #7. agree. if they got to perform together my life would be complete. #8. i think matthew is going to debut regardless. #9. not too sure about this one. tbh, i haven't paid much attention to him, but he definitely was evil edited. #10. yep. and they started giving krystian a bit more screen time RIGHT BEFORE he was eliminated. so dumb #11. honestly, im not sure abt this one either. taerae is not one of my favorite vocalists. his style isnt very unique to me. hes definitely good, but is he as good as people make him out to be? #12. not sure about this one because i didn't watch girls planet. however, i am aware they have made it very difficult for hui to debut. people have various opinions on him, like "hes too old to debut" "hes already in a kpop group" "hes too good for the show" stuff like that #13. i agree. he might be one of the most trained ones too. (excluding hui) there is something so special about his voice that i just cannot grasp. it is very charismatic. #14. i disagree. i think mnet is favoring hanbin for a reason. although, mnet definitely has a bias toward the korean group. i think hanbin is a good person, however, and i dont think mnet is making him seem better than he actually is #15. so true. they are feeding into their plan and falling right into it.
Ooo thanks for sharing your thoughts! It's cool to revisit some of the points made here now after the third mission - ya Seunghwan really delivered on En Garde so much that I kinda can't imagine him elsewhere now lol. I guess I thought that because based on his time in 1THE9, his visuals and vocal tone were so good for bright concepts. And you're right, S Hanbin is definitely not edited to look like someone 'better' than how he actually is (he's really that kind and skilled), but I did have mixed feelings about the amount of coverage he has on the show.
@@rainosaurus no problem! yes it definitely is!! haha yes seunghwan really outdid himself and i can completely understand where you’re coming from people companies LOVEEE to make people seem way better than they actually are
I don't really think Jay is the best vocalist on the show. Obviously Hui is right there but excluding him too there is Seungon Taerae and even Zhang Hao
Another unpopular (?) opinion I'd like to share: I think Ollie is the Guinn Myah (GP999) of this series.. I only watched GP999 halfway so I might be wrong about this, but judging by how he has been edited, I find it very similar to how Mnet edited Guinn Myah (basically portraying him as the cute maknae) I might be wrong about this, so feel free to correct me / share your opinions about this, but please be respectful! I don't want to start arguments.. :)
I disagree with the #1 (on the rap part) simply because of Love Killa, Jiwoong's voice was the one who made Gyuvin sound so bland and uninteresting, while Jiwoong had a lot of characteristics in it. Even in instances from previous episode, like when he did his singing part in Mirotic, Jiwoong's voice was strained, and yet, it gave him character that make it work, weirdly enough. #12, I think it is exactly how mnet wants you to see it, simply because it gives them justification to either push Hui to debut or push him away. It gives them leeway to do either. and the #13 as well, don't get me wrong Jay is great and has a lot of character in his voice, but there are instances where his voice didn't work, like Home. He was great, but I don't think he carried the emotion of the song pretty well IMO. Seo Won on the other hand, Mnet literally was so scared of him that they cut his commentary a lot ever since "Very Nice" performance because they don't want him debuting despite how much screen time Seowon get in the 1st/2nd episode.
@@snehaswati Yes... since he was sick, we don't know how much better it could have been if he was feeling well. And we have to remember that the whole team had to lower two "notes" (keys? idk how to call) to be able to sing Home, because everyone was having voice cracks in the practices. Jay wasn't the only one who struggled, and in the end, even though he was sick, he did a great job and didn't get out of tune any moment. He still did his part flawless.
@@snehaswati THAT'S TRUE, I FORGOT! Well, i still think Seowon carrying the whole top 9 on his back was very impressive (and yes, un popular opinion, but i do think Matthew was under performed as well in love Killa)
@@AnaCristina-qg9zc that's true, i did think he'd have slayed the song, so i was pretty disappointed when he didn't, forgetting the fact that he was sick. My bad.
Mi opinión es que muchos son talentosos y otros tantos aún les falta pulido, mnet ya tiene su grupo formado, esos programas son puro engaños y repeticiones de lo mismo. Las agencias meten manos, y los votos son manipulados, en Corea se dejan llevar más por la apariencia de niños y niñas perfectos. Se actúan como en el script saldrán victoriosos entre comillas, un ídolo jamás mostrar su verdadera cara al público, pues sabe que no será aceptado tal y como es. Una verdadera pena que sigan usando a los chicos y la audiencia de esa manera.
#3 Yes but I think it's confirmed Jay doing Over Me.
#5 I agree with you. But I think they only want 1 Korean Yuehua either Yujin or Gyuvin not both of them.
#6 Even in dance battle of Wang Zihao and Yedam. I can see that some highlights part was strangely cutting out. I think it's really heavy edit. Yedam dance highlighted so much with this. Wang Zihao is one of my pick to debut.
#10 Agree with you💔
#13 I'm torn between Jay and Seongeon.
who else is in over me?
@@teumedeobi I'm not sure yet if Zhanghao, Chen Kuan Jui and Ricky will do Over Me. I also seen alot of spoilers that pointing out Jay was really doing Over Me.
@@hoshisphonecase8854 oh ok! i rlly wanted zhanghao, keita and jay to do over me tgt
@@teumedeobi Yes. Zhanghao, Jay and Keita but I saw that Keita got kick out of the team I hope it's not true.
@@hoshisphonecase8854 whatt that’s so sad
wang zihao one is so true he has been cut and left out of screen time at every possible opportunity
Well, till now the angel edit has been working a little too well for shanbin and he does seem like a genuinely good person too. Unless mnet takes it to Dayeon level, I don't think shanbin will get hate for the edits.
Correction Jay is the strongest singer in the g group only. Hui . Lee hoetaek is the strongest and best singer in the program bp
I vote for Jay everyday since the beginning of the show and when I see the teaser of the artist song mission I am frustrated. We know that Jay is a strong vocalist, he knows that too. We also know that the killing part fitted more with his vocals, and he knows that too (that’s why he sang that part on the voting period of the song)
But I am frustrated, he lowered his hand at the end, he didn’t want to impose himself in this battle.
And I am afraid, the trainee most voted will be the one with the killing part (line distribution problems)
Compared to the 1-3 ep of the show, I cannot see the Jay’s charm (full with confidence)in the other mission.
JUST BE YOURSELF JAY, YOU WILL ATE ANYWAY, please please SING AT EASE CONFIDENCE
We have your back, we are behind you, you are talented, you can succeed here or anywhere. We are here with you
JUST SING BOY ! FIGHTING !
You are speaking so much facts. Def the ones with Jay, lets make him debut!
I’m praying jay gets in over me because I just know he’s gonna kill it
Mnet released a video which is kind of a teaser for the sports activity of the next show, and we can see that jay was placed in “Over Me”. But that can change because if there are too many surviving trainees in this group they will have to remove some so it's not 100% sure yet but I doubt the other contestants want to remove Jay from this song since 'he would be amazing in it and could make them win
Mnet is trying their best to not show Wang zi hao. But I hope he debuts :/ nobody matches him as a main dancer with stable vocals
if mnet edits the performance well for Over Me i do have a ton of faith that jay will enter back into the top 9. His adlibs elevate the song to a world class level and based on what attendees said he was perfect in the vocal department last Saturday.
hi, so i’m commenting after they performed it, i’m sure you’re aware but jay got last place :((( but they won the benefit, so hopefully he will be back in the top 9!!
People are gonna be mad at me but I think Jiwoong has decent stage prensence but in terms of skills he shouldn't have such high ranking. He always wears revealing clothes in all of his performances which I think attracts lots of fans
You are correct friend you will show what you have right.
yep
I also do think Hui’s spot in the top 9 is shaky, because of how drastic the changes are in rankings everytime, and the fact that he dropped out once is a concern alr
I need Lee Seung hwan to debut, he's amazing, an all rounder, so pls guys give him a chance 🥺
I agree with more than 90% of your video
Exactly
Totally agree with the jay one. I vote for him every single day.
No.6 is so true🤣
The entire BP community is for sure at a consensus with this one 😂
fr it's so obvious that I kind of feel embarrassed for mnet 🤣 but as zihao stan, it doesnt make me feel good. I am hurt every episode 🥲
hmmm taerae instead of gyuvin, i can definitely see it. gyuvin won the most votes in love killa but was barely shown on screen. i feel kinda bad for him. he reminds me of mingyu from seventeen haha.
and tbh i didnt realize taerae was from wakeone!! bc they havent really heavily pushed him but he's super talented and main vocal material and i do like him. he would be a great addition to the final lineup, also since i dont know what mnet wants to do with hui.
i think it's going to be zhang hao, matthew, and maybe keita as the 3G.
most likely hanbin, jiwoong, yujin/gyuvin
probably taerae, gunwook
barely there (aka 10-12) jongwoo, hui, park hanbin (wakeone), maybe jay
i didnt think lee daeul would make it in the first few episodes evwn before the editing, but based on previous seasons it actually very well could have happened.
i know some viewers are upset that matthew and gunwook are getting favorable screentime, but i dont think people will be upset with hanbin to the point it will affect his ranking. he has SO many people in love with him not matter what he does.
Vote KEITA
Jay deserved better than rank 12
i agree jay is the best vocalist on bp!
My hot take is that there should be a second/third star level test to see how much they have progressed as INDIVIDUALS bc i feel that a lot hide better on groups but aren't all that. Besides the judges kind of become obsolate after episode 2, idk, justify your salary i guess 🤔
yesss
I thought Lee Seunghwan would receive more recognition after his viral 1 minute PR video, too bad. I hope he continues to prove himself as the wildest all-rounder in the show.
1. I don’t really care for him to form an opinion, though I will say that he could be the dark horse of BP and make it to top 9 if he continues to rise in the rankings.
2. Agree
3. Considering what the rumored lineup is for Over Me (not gonna name it here) I’d say it’s a toss up. Like I could see it go both ways, but right now I am leaning more towards disagreeing, especially when it comes to the last sentence. Although I could see him enter back into the Top 9 for the 3rd round of eliminations (mostly cause Jay fans are upset that he dropped out of the Top 9 during the 2nd round and are now campaigning more than ever) Jay has a harder chance of debuting than his other Top 9 contenders, and I don’t think the Over Me performance is gonna change that and I’m a huge Jay fan, he’s my one pick so I don’t say this out of malice, I’m more so being realistic. MNET wants 3 global trainees and right now it’s looking like it’s gonna be Matthew, Zhang Hao, and Keita.
4. Don’t really care for this opinion, but I do agree that he might not get it because popular trainees want it.
5. Since Taerae took Hui’s spot in the Top 9 (I predicted either Gunwook or Taerae taking Hui’s spot at some point) and Gunwook will most likely be taking the “4th global trainee” spot, I see Gyuvin staying in the Top 9 especially considering that he won the benefit in Love Killa even with Jiwoong and Matthew in the same performance. The only way I see Gyuvin dropping is that a dark horse trainee takes his spot (this could be anywhere from previous Top 9 contestants like Jay and Hui, or a legit dark horse like Jongwoo or Park Hanbin) Right now I’m leaning more towards disagree but we’ll see what happens.
6. HARD AGREE (I wouldn’t be surprised if he gets evil edited in the 3rd round, but it’s most likely gonna be hide Wang Zihao as much as possible)
7. Yeah…I could see it.
8. DISAGREE. Matthew is debuting either way, so his inclusion in the Top 9 is not going to dictate whether or not the final lineup has 4 G group members. At this point Matthew could debut and the lineup could be just 2 G group members. Matthew is a cutie, but he does not have that kind of power lmao
9. Yeah I agree. I even had him as my 1st final lineup debut before I changed it after the 1st round of eliminations.
10. Agree. I would even add other people like Dang Hong Hai and Wang Zihao in the mix.
11. Disagree. I think his unique voice is what’s gravitating fans into voting for him. He shouldn’t change it.
12. AGREE. Also because Pentagon and CLC are completely different groups when it comes to how CUBE has treated them. CLC has basically been mismanaged and neglected and has lost a couple of members before Yujin decided to join Girls Planet, while Pentagon has been given every opportunity in the world to succeed but sadly has not been able to (due to people generally not being interested in the group, also the dating scandal hindered them as well) People also do not want to vote for him because he either is overqualified, they don’t want him to leave Pentagon, he’s “too old” or all of the above. So right now, it is leaning more towards him NOT debuting (which is sad for me cause I think the final lineup would benefit a lot from having him, since he’ll be a great leader and a producer for the group as well has having pipes of steel and a third lung lol)
13. Correction: Jay is the strongest G group vocalist on Boys Planet. We still need to account for trainees like Hui and Seungeon (and to an extent even Taerae?) But he has a good voice and I want him to debut soooo badly.
14. Agree. But he’s also MASSIVELY popular so people aren’t complaining as much as when Dayeon was getting the angel edits.
15. HARD YES!!!! SAY IT FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK lol
For the 8th one, I think the point is that the producers can excuse Matthew as a G group trainee since he’s culturally and in most sense a Korean trainee. So that way there’s more bandwidth for the producers to push other G-group trainees who are actually ethnically foreign, and say that their group is ‘global’ because they would then have 4 G-group members, when practically keep the number to 3 (as per with Kepler).
Kim Taerae is the Chaehyun of this seasons
This is the very first time I actually agree with every opinion in one entire video 😭
all of my opinions are from AFTER all of the artist battle mission performances (episodes 9 and 10)
#1. agree! finally someone agrees with me on this. he is definitely good looking, but his rap and singing don't match up with his visuals.
#2. agreed. i didn't really think of this until you said it. mnet just has to get fans somehow
#3. its after the performance, and he got last :(( butl they got the benefit, so im thinking he might be able to make it back in the top 9. i really hope so, hes my number 1 pick!!! so talented
#4. agree to disagree. he got into en garde i think it suits him a lot more, but id love to see him do say my name
#5. agree. im not sure if im upset or fine with it. gyuvin and taerae are some people that i just am not too sure of. they have different skills. i dont think gyuvin will make it because they already have 2 dancers in the top9 (gunwook,yujin) but at the same time they have 3 vocalists (zhanghao, hanbin[although hes an all-rounder], and matthew[hopefully jay comes back in there too])
#6. its true, sadly. he got less popular as time went on. hes very talented
#7. agree. if they got to perform together my life would be complete.
#8. i think matthew is going to debut regardless.
#9. not too sure about this one. tbh, i haven't paid much attention to him, but he definitely was evil edited.
#10. yep. and they started giving krystian a bit more screen time RIGHT BEFORE he was eliminated. so dumb
#11. honestly, im not sure abt this one either. taerae is not one of my favorite vocalists. his style isnt very unique to me. hes definitely good, but is he as good as people make him out to be?
#12. not sure about this one because i didn't watch girls planet. however, i am aware they have made it very difficult for hui to debut. people have various opinions on him, like "hes too old to debut" "hes already in a kpop group" "hes too good for the show" stuff like that
#13. i agree. he might be one of the most trained ones too. (excluding hui) there is something so special about his voice that i just cannot grasp. it is very charismatic.
#14. i disagree. i think mnet is favoring hanbin for a reason. although, mnet definitely has a bias toward the korean group. i think hanbin is a good person, however, and i dont think mnet is making him seem better than he actually is
#15. so true. they are feeding into their plan and falling right into it.
Ooo thanks for sharing your thoughts! It's cool to revisit some of the points made here now after the third mission - ya Seunghwan really delivered on En Garde so much that I kinda can't imagine him elsewhere now lol. I guess I thought that because based on his time in 1THE9, his visuals and vocal tone were so good for bright concepts. And you're right, S Hanbin is definitely not edited to look like someone 'better' than how he actually is (he's really that kind and skilled), but I did have mixed feelings about the amount of coverage he has on the show.
@@rainosaurus no problem! yes it definitely is!! haha yes seunghwan really outdid himself and i can completely understand where you’re coming from people companies LOVEEE to make people seem way better than they actually are
I don't really think Jay is the best vocalist on the show. Obviously Hui is right there but excluding him too there is Seungon Taerae and even Zhang Hao
Another unpopular (?) opinion I'd like to share: I think Ollie is the Guinn Myah (GP999) of this series..
I only watched GP999 halfway so I might be wrong about this, but judging by how he has been edited, I find it very similar to how Mnet edited Guinn Myah (basically portraying him as the cute maknae)
I might be wrong about this, so feel free to correct me / share your opinions about this, but please be respectful! I don't want to start arguments.. :)
agree. I watched gp too and myah and ollie are giving the same energy, cute maknaes.
I think it's Takuto.
@@christybecera7669 actually... yes
By the way WHERE IS MYAH???
@@mylovechoerry2233i think she is a trainee at top media ent. there were rumors that she might debut this year but idk
I disagree with the #1 (on the rap part) simply because of Love Killa, Jiwoong's voice was the one who made Gyuvin sound so bland and uninteresting, while Jiwoong had a lot of characteristics in it. Even in instances from previous episode, like when he did his singing part in Mirotic, Jiwoong's voice was strained, and yet, it gave him character that make it work, weirdly enough.
#12, I think it is exactly how mnet wants you to see it, simply because it gives them justification to either push Hui to debut or push him away. It gives them leeway to do either.
and the #13 as well, don't get me wrong Jay is great and has a lot of character in his voice, but there are instances where his voice didn't work, like Home. He was great, but I don't think he carried the emotion of the song pretty well IMO. Seo Won on the other hand, Mnet literally was so scared of him that they cut his commentary a lot ever since "Very Nice" performance because they don't want him debuting despite how much screen time Seowon get in the 1st/2nd episode.
I would like to point out that Jay was sick during Home stage, but mnet choose not to point that out
@@snehaswati Yes... since he was sick, we don't know how much better it could have been if he was feeling well. And we have to remember that the whole team had to lower two "notes" (keys? idk how to call) to be able to sing Home, because everyone was having voice cracks in the practices. Jay wasn't the only one who struggled, and in the end, even though he was sick, he did a great job and didn't get out of tune any moment. He still did his part flawless.
@@snehaswati THAT'S TRUE, I FORGOT! Well, i still think Seowon carrying the whole top 9 on his back was very impressive (and yes, un popular opinion, but i do think Matthew was under performed as well in love Killa)
@@AnaCristina-qg9zc that's true, i did think he'd have slayed the song, so i was pretty disappointed when he didn't, forgetting the fact that he was sick. My bad.
the way i agree with every single opinion-
#10 is so true and so sad😢
I agree with most of these opinions lol
Mi opinión es que muchos son talentosos y otros tantos aún les falta pulido, mnet ya tiene su grupo formado, esos programas son puro engaños y repeticiones de lo mismo. Las agencias meten manos, y los votos son manipulados, en Corea se dejan llevar más por la apariencia de niños y niñas perfectos. Se actúan como en el script saldrán victoriosos entre comillas, un ídolo jamás mostrar su verdadera cara al público, pues sabe que no será aceptado tal y como es. Una verdadera pena que sigan usando a los chicos y la audiencia de esa manera.
Can i share your’re video on twitter?
Yes sure! Please credit the channel as well 👍