Five for Fighting - What If
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 09. 2013
- Get the new album, “Bookmarks” featuring the song "What If" on iTunes ow.ly/ok93d & Amazon ow.ly/ok91f now
Check out www.fiveforfighting.com for more info and exclusive content
Music video by Five for Fighting performing What If. (C) 2013 Wind-up Records LLC - Hudba
10 years later and this song still touches the heart
My son, CJ Giordano, was the art director for this video. He lives far from us now, but I watch this video over and over. I love the song and the story. It's beautiful to me.
He did an incredible job bringing this song to life, just like his mom did with him ❤
Awesome. I know you're proud of his work.
He did a great job. More people should watch this video over and over, too.
Beautiful, you must be so proud!
he should make this a movie
He saved the boy's life giving a heart thing a human rarely think of doing. ♥
Empathy, it's what makes us human.
Five For Fighting is one of the greatest, most thought-provoking artists of all time!
I'm 54 and this song makes me cry because it has a message of sacrifice. We need more songs with messages like this one
same as you bro, same as you 😉
Gets me every time! Either just the song or the video 😢
This song came out when I needed it the most. Thank you. 6 months depression free!
Congratulations bother. I am glad to hear that. Stay strong.
FinallyIhavecomeback *brother
Thank you brother. I shall remain strong. Life is a blessing.
That's huge!!! :) We are soo proud of you!! Keep going! Life is beautiful!
Thank you all! you guys/girls are amazing!!!
I think the song's message is about understanding each other's differences and learning how to sympathize with them. The video portrays a robot, which represents a foreign entity from society. The robot gives the little boy his heart--an act that implies "if I give you my heart, you'll be able to understand the pain and suffering I go through, being estranged from the rest of society." The repetition of "what if" connects to the powerful messages of sympathy and understanding, which is further emphasized in the video (learning to live with each other in harmony, despite the differences). While we may have different values, beliefs, and lifestyles, we all have something in common that makes us human--a heart.
Marco Recio damn, nice breakdown and interpretation
Very well said Mate and you got it in one. That's what it's about. It's a shame there's other humans who never will understand that. Those who forget we all start our journey from the time of our birth as a baby.
Marco Recio right I love this song😍
Those were some some power words.
The Five Commands For Fighting are from THE ALMIGHTY FATHER who is portrayed in this video as a ROBOT, as HIS Son, is a genetically engineered 'terminator' ('nanites', 'beings' 'AI') who starts out as a 9 year old, but by the end of the video is 18 years old.
My sons birthday is today.....he had a hearttransplant and it lasted 12 years...Happy Birthday David Alan Goeke, RIP 11/28/80-8-20-09....WHAT IF??????? I love you and miss you horribly my firstborn son......thanks for the song and video....... :'{
Oh, Sue... this is heartbreaking. I cannot even imagine the pain. God bless your sweet boy. I hope that you are reunited with him one day.
Drew Eric Whitman I couldn’t have said it better myself
I know this is late but I am sorry for your loss. I hope you are doing ok and that your son is in a better place.
Late to this, too. My condolences, Sue.
I hope your scars are healing little by little. Sorry for your loss. In Islam people that die before puberty and some people with mental disorders have a guaranteed place in heaven. Inshallah your son is there and you will be able to meet him again one day. I'll pray for you to be reunited with your son in heaven when your time comes.
I was the first little boy in this music video, and it was so amazing to see this
Whoa
I watched this entire thing... THE FEELS MAN. OH MY GOD i'M CRYING. THIS NEEDS TO BE A MOVIE.
*wink* Working on it.
Evan Zhang I thought it was a movie at first..
I'm with you. I'm ready to cry if there's a movie :')
is it sad i cried like a little girl? this is truly a beautiful song.i love every part of it.
Dedicated to my dearly beloved brother who left us on 17/Oct/2012... Adam my heart aches to hold you.... :( aku rindu gila kat hang.... :( wait for me when my time comes baby brother :(.... Rip beautiful....
thank you James :(
So sorry Sarah .... he will be there waiting for you of that I am Certain! I've seen it with my own eyes!
Be strong
Are u from indonesia?
I was 12years old
I grew up to these types of song I'm trying to find music I used to listen to when I was a little squirt it's just crazy how much music has changed I wish it was like the old 2000's I loved it
True...
It is true. Why do you think it is true
i would like to meet you one day. Do you live close to Bloomington IL?
the 80's were even better!
By contrast, 99% of today's music is pure crap.
Why this kinds of songs are so underrated
This is a perfect example of an amazing song matched with the perfect music video to make anyone cry
Oh gosh -- it made me cry. Wonderful video! I wish I could tell you personally how much your music has meant to me. Every time I hear one of your songs, it transports me back to the 70's when songs were so pure and inspiring. Singer/songwriters like you barely exist anymore. I just love everything about the music. Keep doing things exactly as you have. You are so unique in this world. Thank you, John Ondrasik!!
Agree about his music, but he wasn't an artist in the 70's. 1988-present.
@@EDWINWOLLET Correct! I said the music "transports me back to the 70s" -- in other words, it REMINDS me of the music from the 70s when we had the best singer/songwriters.
Love this song and Five For Fighting. Even their name is positive! Notice how none of their songs are crap!! Keep it up. Fans love you!!
just letting you know he is the only man in this band. I know him personally and i have asked him this. he wrote a song about my uncle called Augie Nieto adn that was when i asked him
Jesus, I wasn't prepared for this. I haven't cried in over 2 years and this almost got me.
This man's voice is the embodiment of my years in school. Every time I hear one of his songs, I see myself back in those years of homework, recess, and lunch with friends.
This song deserves more views. I just come back after not listening to this song for long time. So nostalgic.
Love this video. I always enjoy music videos that tell a story rather than simply show the performer singing the song.
I'm turning 17 and I'm absolutely proud of myself that I grew up with his songs since 1997. And the song "Superman" is one of my favourites. The best as always. :')
Adam this one is for you. Would give you part of my heart if it means having you back in our lives. Rest In Peace Baby Brother :(.. 03-04-1992 - 17-10-2012
So sad, sweet, and amazing this song.
I am a bit "cold" naturally and distrustful of many people due to personal experiences/struggles. This song "warms" me somewhat and speaks to me in a visceral way, I never had close friends or anything like that and the robot makes me think of that and how I can't trust most people but yet knowing if I ever found someone I could completely trust/engage with I would "give them my heart" and enjoy our time together even if the sacrifice ends my own life.
Also this song/video always makes me cry.
Absolutely love this song. I view it as a comparison to parents giving life to their children, and one day their child having to say goodbye -- despite the want to do anything to keep them alive.
That's the beauty of music -- it's our own interpretation. Bravo, Five For Fighting. Bravo!
This song represents the whole life
Couldn't stop the tears. So many strong emotions from this song. A journey through all of our human emotions in only a few moments. So very powerful when your lyrics explain the things we feel and we hear your song, but more importantly, we feel this song. Bring my mortal self back to the simplest things in life that I could not live without. No man can create those things with his hands, but only with his heart. People close their hearts off and never find what they are looking for. Afraid to lose, afraid to hurt. If one never loses, than one never learns to win. If one never loses a friend, than one never learns to cherish or to miss. If one never hurts, than one never knows what joy truly is. They would never find or know happiness. That thing that everyone is looking for, doesnt come from anyone else, you cant touch it. You will find it when you give it. Amazing how something so simple is so hard for many to comprehend and harder still to give it away.
Well written. Thank you for writing what I couldn't.
Thank you
That was powerful my dude brought a tear to my eye, so much lessons in this simple you tube comment. Thank you for taking your time to write this, it has given me a new lease on life.
@urmumsacowurapoo aww, that makes me happy to hear, my love. Pay it forward gorgeous. 😊
@urmumsacowurapoo aww, that makes me happy to hear, my love. Pay it forward gorgeous. 😊
There's something in this song that i can't explain!
Please continue to make good songs like these. I have grown up listening to your music and I find your music more meaningful than most of the hits today.
I found myself crying near the end. This video bespeaks of much love and kindness they had for each other. The way we are all supposed to be with each other.
i remember i used to watch vh-1 every day before school in elementary and i’d always cry when this music video came up omg🥺
Videos and songs like these should get a lot of recognition. Creative and meaningful, I'm glad Five for Fighting hasn't lost their touch.
These are the songs that will last the ages
I cant watch this a single time with out crying!
Types while cries😭😭😭😭
There are lots of song like these out there that deserves to be heard, but most of people overlook these songs.
For me it wasn’t just the song it was a combo of the song and video as it wouldn’t have stood out to represent half what it did if it weren’t for both together…..
Just wanna say something. Out of all the robot related concepts out there, this is by far my favorite. It's heartfelt, beautiful, and just plain powerful. It has a message. Way better than transformers LOL
This is so beautiful... I honestly haven't had this kind feeling for so long from listening to a song.
Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The robot un-selfishly gave him the boy his heart so he can live. That is truly being a HERO.
John O is simply one of the most talented song writers alive today. One song after another, this guy is amazing.
When I was little, every morning I would watch "VH-1" with my brother before we went to school and this would always play and I loved it. It's now 5 years later and I searched through time and space for this video, I didnt remember the name of it so all I was putting in my search bar was "music video of boy and robot" and I couldn't find it anywhere until now😭😭
Please keep making these songs. We know you're not getting a billion views each but the million that are here are on repeat!
Since the late 90's/early 2000's....they still got it. Keep it up, guys!
My god, absolutely incredible song and video. Shocked this does not have 30+ million views. The robot loved the kid more than himself. Amazing theme.
This song always makes me cry at the end. When she first saw me cry to this song she would try to cover my eyes so I wouldn't cry. Now, she sometimes sings the song from time to time.
I love the part "can we love what we don't know?" Love that ! Like we can love what we learn and experience through someone else and see through them, seeing through someone elses heart and their scars and had their tears, amazing to think about! The words and melody hit with compassion!
Man, saw this the first time it came out. Cried then, Crying now.
I watch this for the first time tonight. And it instantly brought me to tears and the end. Reminds me of my friends and the loved ones I have lost. Happy and sad all at the same time.
Everyone aboard the feels bus. We are going on a trip to more heartfelt songs ( ; - ; )
I'm Down :'D
Dont leave without me! 😄
Wait for me!!!!
Hope It hasn't left already!
+apples apple It leaves in four days. ;)
This video has a criminally small amount of views...
still is underrated after 6 years, but we all know this deserves more view than this
Five for Fighting is so underrated. One of the best groups with the best messages.
@@shawnzimmerman5335 man this is a one man band . look up John Ondrasik lll
Everything this guy touches turns to gold. He can probably sing Happy Birthday and I'd bawl my eyes out.
I remember my teachers showing us this in 6th grade, I have a wife and kids now. I’ll always remember the first time I heard it:)
who's cutting onions...
me....
haha
dog: are u crying?
me: huh.. ? wat? im just cutting onions
dog: for real cutting onions in ur room?
deez nuts
Chris InMASS what no why
My son and I dont see eye to eye and I swear the first time I saw this video I saw us in it, hear our story in the lyrics and feel the all round message. I love this song. It is pure perfection. FFF I am following closely.
I wasn't really paying attention to the lyrics as my hearty was being smashed to pieces by the saddest vid I've ever seen, but to me the video symbolized sacrifice and love because it looked like the robot killed himself by giving his heart away. But at the same time I think the video was emphasizing that those few years with the kid was a fuller life than the life of solitude. Just my thoughts
This needs so many more views. :) I can't wait for more stuff from John. He is my favorite artist in a musical world where not many mainstream songs have meaningful lyrics and messages. Ahh I just love this video
+cancer sucks John? Who uses Middle names to refer to someone... Call him Vladimir if anything, John could mean anyone
Chris Davidson Most people call him John... All his social media uses his name John, in interviews people call him John, literally, the biography on his own website refers to himself as John. You should learn more about him. :)
cancer sucks Well I know his surname is Vladimir haha
Chris Davidson There is a lot more to him than his name.
this song should be in one of those heart warming disney movies (sobbing)
That unique element in their voice! LOL can't figure why I love this group so much, but I know that I'm for sure #Five4Fighting4Life!
why does five for fighting consistently make me cry? :,)
I reiterate my love for this song and shock that it's popularity is not in the million+ views category. To me, the song is about love being a verb, a choice, the giving of oneself. "You made your mind up before you knew me". A choice to unconditionally love and sacrifice before knowing someone. "What if I had your heart, what if you wore my scars?" This is all about everyone being spiritually connected. "I had a dream of a new tomorrow" "I took a step hoping you might follow". This could be about heaven or spiritual ascension. "If you don't get it, then you don't get it" means this: if you don't get that we are all connected and here to learn to unconditionally love each other, then you don't get what life is all about. Notice, in the end, the robot rises, it ascends, it does not go in to the ground. More symbolism. Incredible.
It’s got 2.5 mil now 😊
beautiful lyrics. beautiful music. beautiful meaning. beautiful video. only about 1M views. Best band I've listened to. Most underrated band I've listened to🤔
Five for Fighting has a super place in my heart- unique YES because he sings songs that aren't always about jilted love~
Great song, people no longer recognize great music , people just listen to music that don't male sense .. great song video says a lot
Hanging with my uncle and he just showed me this vid..........instant crying!
Beautiful. So beautiful. I just love Five for Fighting and this song is deep and gorgeous.
love, love, love this song!
there are people you reach out too...
final thought before giving up:
" if you dont get it, then you dont get it'
yep. I tired. Im done.
Whenever I really start to worry about today's music, talented individuals like John Ondrasik give me great pause for relief. Great song.
Omg the ending. I love that they say what I always do, 'if you don't get it, then you don't get it.'
I seriously cried when I watched this
my heart is breaking!! I want to cry and cry!!
I work at journeys and this song came on the tv and we all literally sat there and watched it. Customers too.
I can't believe I missed this one so long ago. The video imaging was so spot on and powerful I was in tears after the first 3 lines of the song. Beautiful song and very relevant for today.
This video has literally had and still got me in floods of tears! How on earth a robot could show such emotion in those eyes lord only knows. Simply beautiful. And v sad.
its still sounds so good even in 2020
No matter how many times I listened to this song I can’t stop crying inside and outside. Some ninjas must be cutting onions here way too fast!!! The feels! The feels!!! 😭
one of the best songs ever written. very meaningful. i could cry just listening to this song and feel the lyrics.
That was so beautiful and well done ;-; Why does this not have more views? This is amazing...
I cryed
me,too!! T^T
Corbin Crutchley sounds like a plan. I cried as well TT^TT
Corbin Crutchley sounds like a plan. I cried as well TT^TT
Which everyone brings out the most tears. T^T I could go for a cry right now
I did 3 minutes ago. TT^TT No matter how many times you see this video, it will still be just as sad as the first you watch. TRUE FACT
Like, I can't even describe how much I'm crying right now but I can't stop listening and watching.... theres so much love and meaning behind this song
it's been 7 years and i'm still wondering why in the world this song's only had 2 millions views so far :(
Com'on guys, this song deserves more than this
The robot is so cute :D
Oh god in the perfect time, I need to listen to this song million times ^_^
***** Just be happy my friend, Kisses ^_^
The most underrated band i have ever seen...
whoever directed this and came up with the concept you deserve an award!
I love this song!
why isn't this song popular??
this song is beautiful and so is the video. not gonna lie, I cried buckets watching this
Can't get enough of this..
I adore this song 🌹
💜
I really love the song,the words, the rytm and the video is just amazing it made me cry
My daughter just turned 2...i'm 40..i waiting a long time to have kids cause i didn't know if i could be a good dad. I love this little girl more than anything in the world. I will give everything in the world to her...i pray that God takes care of her always.
i've barely gotten through this song without crying
Such an amazing song and video! One of the best I have seen in a long while
Ikr!
Well finally some one doesn't say all music on the radio are bad, but no seriously just search up some artists you like/love/adore/WHAT EVER YOU FEEL ABOUT THEM, and find bands that are like them, I'm pretty sure they might interest you.
I'm happy I found this song
Amazing song. Wonderful lyrics. Just can't get enough of it. It's on replay.
This song reminds me of my little brother.. He was born with a genetic skin condition called EB. I love him so much and pray that he will be able to live a full and happy life.
directed by Romanhite, takes you into a desolate forest where a robot brings a little boy to life by giving him his heart. The touching video chronicles their life together, and as the two grow old, the boy eventually says goodbye to the "deceased" robot by tying him to a bouquet of balloons and sending him into the sunset.
I donated one thumb up to this thoughtful video. The song itself is inspiration.
Rodney Arcega im donating a thumbs up as well im im crying right now as well :"(
Dear my favorite band of all time:
I HAVE MISSED YOU. Now excuse me while I curl up in a ball and listen to this album obsessively...
This song never failed to make me cry. I miss my grandpa and cousin so much. They died together at the same time. :(