@@cababyboomerq6012You're exactly right. Many seem to suggest that Mo's passing was harder on Robin than Barry. Think they forget that Barry & Mo were very close, and lived close to each other in Miami for almost 30 years, when Robin lived in NY & the UK then. Their families did lots of outdoor stuff together....boating, fishing, backyard games, etc.
This song was sung by Maurice and Barry during the separation with Robin and today that Maurice is no longer there it is Robin who sings with Barry. It is all the more touching. It takes on another dimension so sweet and Robin's beautiful voice makes it vibrate like a painful echo reminding us of the past and Maurice. Oh Barry you didn't know then Robin's turn would come so soon. As we think of you three and today of you. Love you Sir Barry and all my thoughs !🎼🎵🙏💌. Tôn Nữ Tuong Vy
The sweet thing is that Robin had nothing to do with the writing or recording of this song back in 1970, as only Barry and Maurice worked on "Cucumber Castle." Yet, he essentially is paying tribute to his brother by singing the second verse.
Perfect harmony, and so talented. You can feel their sadness and pain because they sing from their hearts and their own experiences. I really feel for Barry 💔
Wow, this is amazing! You can hear the love and pain of their loss toward Maurice with this song. Such treasure as you don't see much of Barry and Robin singing together. Thank you for sharing and AG for filming!!!
So awesome that they sang this song until this time.. This was my father's favorite song everytime he sings in a videoke... I love u bee gees especially Robin 😍 😍 😍
When Robin sings you're the mirror of my soul. Tears. Barry looked pretty chunky here, that must have been hard on his back. Glad he slimmed down, for his sake. We love you Barry.
Incredible version. Barry sounds so much better here than on the original, and Robin sounds spectacular. They grew so much as artists over the span of their careers.
Me gusta pensar que esta canción se la escribieron Mo y Barry para Robin pues en ese tiempo estaban separados.... escuchen la letra !!! El era el espejo del alma de Mo, eran gemelos, y eran tan unidos los 3!! Por siempre bee gees
I heard Barry say that is where How Can You Mend a Broken Heart came from and Words came after there was a big fight among them and when they made up, they all realized what damage words can do. I have watched a lot of interviews that Barry has done and I've learned a lot about what went on behind the scenes.
Wish youre still here robin... you are now in heaven, no more pain and sadness... u re unite with youre twin bro mo and andy singing beautiful song in heaven... I miss u ...
This is the only decent live version of this song on CZcams which has Robin on it. He was always meant to sing this song with Barry. So beautiful. Just a pity Maurice is not in this version.
@ALongfo-5so This was practice for a tribute for Maurice from at that time the 2 remaining brothers. The words that Robin sings solo are really heart rending. "As I walk by the photograph of you, Though I try to forget you somehow. Your the mirror of my soul, so take me out of this whole. Help me try to go on living right now." How hard that must have been for him to sing those words to his twin. 😢💔
Originally it was barry singing with Maurice doing Harmony. Barry had done so much falsetto that it was hard to get his voice down to alto/baritone so Robin always had the same vibrato voice and can pick up the slack.
Even Robin looks so ill here tried to sing so sad words..luv u Gibbs brother ..may God always in ur side and imbrace ur suffering to ease the pain in ur body...
Isso é música, lembra minha juventude e meu ex cunhado q descansa em paz.Ele adorava os BG e sabia cantar todas músicas .R.I.P.Robin Maurice Em 05/22 ouvindo esse arranjo com Robin e Barry
Robin was never the same since Mo's untimely passing. Now they're together forever singing songs to entertain those in eternity. RIP Mo and Robin. 💔
You are never the same when you lose a sibling, twin or not. But when you also worked together it must haunt you at even more times.
@@cababyboomerq6012You're exactly right. Many seem to suggest that Mo's passing was harder on Robin than Barry. Think they forget that Barry & Mo were very close, and lived close to each other in Miami for almost 30 years, when Robin lived in NY & the UK then. Their families did lots of outdoor stuff together....boating, fishing, backyard games, etc.
The Best bee Gees in the world
This is so beautiful and sad at the same time.Robin sings it with his whole heart and soul and so did Barry. What a wonderful duet. RIP dear Mo.
Robin, we will not forget you...
This was a tribute to Mo they were singing.
Love this song,the Bee Gees were Amazing,loved Robin and his Amazing voice and his lovely smile.missed.💓🙏xx.
This was one of Barry & Mo's songs from Cucumber Castle.
I will always luv and missed u all bee gees ur now out of pain with singing to our Lord in heaven! Rip 😢 I luv u all!
There will never be another sound like the Bee Gees. Love them all but love Robin more. 💕
Love them all & to be fair, this is a tribute to Mo.😪
Last man standing Barry Gibbs... Be well my last bee gee...
Ohhh The sadness on his face when he did the solo just rips me up!!!
Remember Robin Gibb 😍❤😔
This was Mo's tribute.
Robin sings his verso so well - it hurts to listen.
They are so great together
TRIBUTE TO MAURICE ERNEST GIBB FOR ROBIN AND BARRY. GREAT SONG👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Again beautiful
2:24 Robin's looking at his elder Brother, ... Beautiful Brotherhood...
I terribly miss you rob....
December 2021
😢😥
I ❤ BEE GEES
Robin is so sad. Missing mo terribly....
To be fair, I'm sure they both were. After all, Barry & Mo lived close to each other for 30+ years.
So touching !! You can see the pain and sorrow in Robin's face ... We miss you Maurice and Robin ...
Marta M ‘. Tyrs
A minha canção , preferida , só saúdades .
Miss you always
This is so sad. Seems like he’s avoiding looking to his right, where Mo used to be. Sounds like he’s ready to cry too. 🌹🌹🌹
@@juanita6479 It was difficult to watch. I cried too. Love you, Robin. ❤️💖💜
RIP Robin. You are always on my mind.
I can't stop my tears ..don't forget to rember Maurice..they sang for their belove, Mo. so so sad 😥😥😥😥😥
BEE GEES FOREVER
Lovely lovely lovely Song. But what a wonderful, sad and unique version it is!
This song was sung by Maurice and Barry during the separation with Robin and today that Maurice is no longer there it is Robin who sings with Barry. It is all the more touching. It takes on another dimension so sweet and Robin's beautiful voice makes it vibrate like a painful echo reminding us of the past and Maurice. Oh Barry you didn't know then Robin's turn would come so soon. As we think of you three and today of you. Love you Sir Barry and all my thoughs !🎼🎵🙏💌. Tôn Nữ Tuong Vy
One of the most beautiful songs ever. Love always. Bee Gees Forever. BRAVO Barry.
Mum had this 45. Robin never sung on the original recording. That is what makes this a beautiful moment.
Robin Gibb amazing voice
The sweet thing is that Robin had nothing to do with the writing or recording of this song back in 1970, as only Barry and Maurice worked on "Cucumber Castle." Yet, he essentially is paying tribute to his brother by singing the second verse.
love Robin ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Wow how beautiful
Robin looks so ill and frail ..you can feel his pain and sorrow at the loss of his Twin..But his voice is still angelic...RIP xx
Rest in Peace
Provavelmente foi uma de suas ultimas aparicoes. 😢
This was 2006 & their tribute to Mo.
Perfect harmony, and so talented. You can feel their sadness and pain because they sing from their hearts and their own experiences. I really feel for Barry 💔
U will not be forgotten... Missing rob
This poor, man. So sad. His voice was like an angel. Breaks my heart there is only one Bee Gees, left.
Brano stupemdo ,struggente ma molto sentimentale. Non dimetichiamo i Bee Gees!!! Adorato Robin i love you forever ❤❤❤🙏🙏👄👄🌹
Wow, this is amazing! You can hear the love and pain of their loss toward Maurice with this song. Such treasure as you don't see much of Barry and Robin singing together. Thank you for sharing and AG for filming!!!
So awesome that they sang this song until this time.. This was my father's favorite song everytime he sings in a videoke... I love u bee gees especially Robin 😍 😍 😍
I wonder how long it’s been since Barry’s played this live. This was a really painful time for him and Maurice when they recorded this.
this song makes me cry...
Me too
Me too still...😞
As much as the beauty of the song, the depth of these brothers' love for each other is heart wrenching. Barry and Mo sang it first when Rob left
@@raelene101 they make you cry, they make you dance and they take you to heaven for three or four minutes.
Uuh se ve la tristeza de Robin, esta canción me da mucha pena, sin duda, jamás serás olvidado, mi querido Robin, jamás.😥
This is so heartbreaking
I love BeeGees
You can feel Robin's pain. I wanted to hug him when he hugged himself he was hurting so much.
Beautiful.
Very good 👍
Essa musica originalmente era cantada pelo genial Barry e.o magico dos arranjos Maurice..ficou dolorida na voz do robin cantando pars o irmao
This is so touching. I cry ever time I listen to this. I will always remember the Gee Gees and Andy!!
2020. The Bee Gees, my eternal idols.
Non ti dimenticherò caro Robin❤❤
Nessuno lo dimenticherà. Una persona speciale, una voce che va dritta al cuore.
This was a tribute to Mo.
Robin Gibb eterno!
When Robin sings you're the mirror of my soul. Tears. Barry looked pretty chunky here, that must have been hard on his back. Glad he slimmed down, for his sake. We love you Barry.
Barry may have been chunky but Robin was very thin.
Una de las más bonitas canciones que existen. Especialmente emotiva esta versión de Barry y Robin. R.I.P. Maurice & Robin Gibb.
one of my favorite songs, Bee Gees Miss you much
Me apacionan como me gustaria conseguir una foto linda de los tres como puedo hacer mil gracias.
Well now, wasn't that lovely. Thank you!
The best musicians known in this unniverse with a big heart....the Bee Gees.(barry,robin,maurice and andy)😍😍mae
Incredible version. Barry sounds so much better here than on the original, and Robin sounds spectacular. They grew so much as artists over the span of their careers.
What a beautiful song to remember Mo.
RIP Mo!
@@helainenatko I like the original
@@phillygirl06 never heard the original
So beautiful
I prefer to watch performances when they were all here. Too sad. 😭
Wow 💔💎🌟🌟🌟🌟
Не понимая в полной мере текста , но всё чувствуется через музыку и исполнение !!! Низкий ПОКЛОН Барри и Робину !!!❤❤❤❤❤👏👏👏🌷🌷🌷🌷💥🇷🇺
Escucho a un Robin nostalgico siempre serán amados todos.
Beautiful ❤
Barry & Robin
Me gusta pensar que esta canción se la escribieron Mo y Barry para Robin pues en ese tiempo estaban separados.... escuchen la letra !!! El era el espejo del alma de Mo, eran gemelos, y eran tan unidos los 3!! Por siempre bee gees
Es verdad, del album "Cucumber Castle" que grabaron sin Robin.
A MÚSICA JÁ É MUITO TRISTE... MAS A TRISTEZA DO ROBIN ESTÁ ESTAMPADA NO ROSTO E NA VOZ DELE...
Realmente e triste demais esta musica mals e linda demais
Na verdade quem cantava essa musica era o Maurice. 😢 💔
The Best Bee Gees Song!! "In my heart lies a memory, to tell the stars above." Robby's voice touches me so much. He probably sang this for Maurice.
I can't say for certain but this song was written during the break up and I think that it was written for Robin.I miss the twins so much.
Yes, that's what I've always heard.
I heard Barry say that is where How Can You Mend a Broken Heart came from and Words came after there was a big fight among them and when they made up, they all realized what damage words can do. I have watched a lot of interviews that Barry has done and I've learned a lot about what went on behind the scenes.
Barry wrote the song.
lorna grace...Barry and Mo wrote this song during the time that Robin was on his own.
That's not ronin that's robin.i love it.
Wish youre still here robin... you are now in heaven, no more pain and sadness... u re unite with youre twin bro mo and andy singing beautiful song in heaven... I miss u ...
RIP. robin. love you.x
love Robin ..........
Primeira vez que ouço os dois cantando esta linda canção ao vivo. Parabéns.
A minha canção preferida dos Bee Gees.
One of my favorites ❤
Quando ouço e vejo esse vídeo, sinto a dor nos olhos e na voz do Robin.
This song was soon after Maurice died.there voices complimented each other.sang with such passion.bee gees forever.
This was 2006.
This is the only decent live version of this song on CZcams which has Robin on it. He was always meant to sing this song with Barry. So beautiful. Just a pity Maurice is not in this version.
@ALongfo-5so This was practice for a tribute for Maurice from at that time the 2 remaining brothers. The words that Robin sings solo are really heart rending. "As I walk by the photograph of you, Though I try to forget you somehow. Your the mirror of my soul, so take me out of this whole. Help me try to go on living right now." How hard that must have been for him to sing those words to his twin. 😢💔
Grandissimiiiii Barry e Robin ❤️❤️...con questa stupenda canzone. Da brividi.... , manca il mio angelo Maurice ❤️
Saudade eterna Robin 😔
Minha canção de amor ❤💙😘🇧🇷👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
2020. I'm come back, to see my eternal idols. Thanks from Brasil,
Originally it was barry singing with Maurice doing Harmony. Barry had done so much falsetto that it was hard to get his voice down to alto/baritone so Robin always had the same vibrato voice and can pick up the slack.
Linda música
Robin Gees vc será eternamente meu ídolo
Primera ocasión que la escucho en vivo, HERMOSA CANCIÓN!!!
Even Robin looks so ill here tried to sing so sad words..luv u Gibbs brother ..may God always in ur side and imbrace ur suffering to ease the pain in ur body...
This was 2006 so Robin wasn't real ill yet.
Co jakiś czas sięgam po ta CUDOWNA MUZYKĘ. DZIĘKUJĘ.POLAND ❤
Você.e..muito.bom
Que raridade que você encontrou muito bom !
Isso é música, lembra minha juventude e meu ex cunhado q descansa em paz.Ele adorava os BG e sabia cantar todas músicas .R.I.P.Robin Maurice
Em 05/22 ouvindo esse arranjo com Robin e Barry
A voz do saudoso Robin era mesmo diferenciada mesmo.
Ricardo Gibb Maravilhosa, inigualável, inimitável...Robin ❤️❤️❤️❤️
COMO A DO BARRY GIBB
Love !♡♡♡♡♡♡
Crying....
Love them forever and ever
I love this song as well as the artists
This is what I want to watch don't forget to remember me live so long I have been searching in CZcams
Que maravilhosa essa canção chega arrepiar.. traz uma nostalgia boa uma saudade de uma infância feliz Bee gees são geniais
E como se viajassemos no tempo.
환상적이다.... 진짜 너무 소중한 영상입니다
Linda mesmo com robi ainda com uma voz suave vai lá no fundo da alma
Grande ROBIN ❤🌷😘
Maravilhoso, simplesmente maravilhoso bate fundo no coração uma emoção única
Bee Gibb é para sempre
My favourite song since i was 7 years old. Now i am 62 still love this song.
essa musica è linda demais,com Robin cantando a segunda parte ficou mais linda ainda..
I love Robin e Barry. Saudades do Maurice. Love Bee Gees ❤❤❤
Eles são maravilhosos mais o Robin Gibb deixou mtas saudades...
Es hermosa estos hermanos eran maravillosos
Linda essa música 💖💖💖
favorite of my Late Husband he always Sing ....