Singapore’s Littoral Solution

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
  • By Eric Wertheim
    July 2024 Proceedings Vol. 150/7/1,457

Komentáře • 89

  • @lingth
    @lingth Před měsícem +33

    Its intended replacement was for Patrol class vessels.. so its not intended to be heavily armed and not for Anti ship or Anti submarine roles.. probably more anti piracy roles and against small boats. The heli deck is a welcome addition, because in the past, the only Helicopter landing capable ship was the Landing Ship Tank in the RSN, but now helicopters can land on Formidable Frigates and now LMVs also.

    • @SPZ23
      @SPZ23 Před 20 dny +1

      They also have MICA launch capabilities so they are also capable of defending Singapore's airspace.

  • @tommytstang
    @tommytstang Před měsícem +49

    Being an ex Singapore Senior Naval Engineering Specialist, I have proudly served my nation for 11 years. Even back in the 90s the RSN was already considered one of the most modern and forward looking naval force in the SE Asia with all sorts of sophisticated technology and weapon systems of its time. Over the last 2 decades, it is now one of the most formidable sea military forces in the region surpassing my bigger countries in SE Asia.

    • @pringlessourcream9527
      @pringlessourcream9527 Před měsícem +1

      Tjing kum siah you😊

    • @kennethschlegel870
      @kennethschlegel870 Před 21 dnem +2

      When i was in the US Navy it was an amazing experience to Visit Singapore, both times we pulled into Changi.

  • @ding24_
    @ding24_ Před měsícem +84

    thanks for featuring my country 💪🏼

  • @eatdriveplay
    @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +28

    In its basic configuration, these LMVs are capable of providing littoral anti-surface, anti-air protection and 8 ships are on rotation to conduct 24/7 patrolling around Singapore waters. With an integrated bridge-CIC, options for less than lethal or lethal weapons + capacity for a secondary CIC + modular weapons and mission systems that can be fitted for any threat.... these are future proof vessels for decades.

  • @EricK-mj7kr
    @EricK-mj7kr Před měsícem +10

    In fact he LCS do work with the LMVs in the region. They regularly make port calls at Changi naval base.

  • @JoshuaC923
    @JoshuaC923 Před měsícem +8

    Pretty cool to see USNI feature the RSN

  • @NickyKDChaleunphone
    @NickyKDChaleunphone Před 14 hodinami

    This is something the USCG should be getting for the Pacific

  • @EricK-mj7kr
    @EricK-mj7kr Před měsícem +9

    Cool ship names!

    • @catland88
      @catland88 Před 8 dny

      I believe the LMV names were selected from public name submissions!

  • @thomasvilla6109
    @thomasvilla6109 Před 19 dny +1

    Those are fine-looking ships.

  • @Logic807
    @Logic807 Před měsícem +17

    I think the value is that Thales radar

    • @calvin6429
      @calvin6429 Před měsícem +1

      it looks damn awkward, how much better is the radar? we should just buy 2nd ships from other countries, why spend more money to build unless we are selling to other countries

    • @benktlofgren4710
      @benktlofgren4710 Před měsícem +7

      Jobs jobs jobs, better for the economy if you invest in your people instead of all cash going abroad. You also invest in capability and know-how.
      The know-how is the hardest and most expensive thing to replace if you let it go, that is why Sweden still has jets, subs, and warship programs.

    • @logic8673
      @logic8673 Před měsícem

      @@benktlofgren4710 I don't know what you mean, Thales is a major investor in SG. They are employing 1000 to add to their 2000. Furthermore, they are hiring high-value engineers. Typically Singapore's decision-making is multi-dimensional. For such sensitive cutting-edge r and d work, it is an achievement for SG. they are doing work here. Military equipment and men etc, means nothing without radar.

  • @khayramsyar554
    @khayramsyar554 Před 21 dnem +2

    Only one thing I hate about these ships, their wake is so strong it makes my vessel a theme park ride 🤬

  • @philipchan79
    @philipchan79 Před měsícem +9

    Singapore also have a similar type like US Navy Independence class LCS . Its the Singapore Navy's specialised marine craft.

    • @lagrangewei
      @lagrangewei Před měsícem +5

      no, LCS is trash. Singapore does not build trash.

    • @Logic807
      @Logic807 Před měsícem

      @@philipchan79 are you referring to something in the future?

    • @philipchan79
      @philipchan79 Před měsícem

      @@Logic807 No.

  • @capespring
    @capespring Před měsícem +7

    add 4 ASM and it becomes a corvette.

    • @eatdriveplay
      @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +15

      It can... because of its modular arhictecture. It can fit several 20-foot standard containers under the heli deck - each station with pre-configured cable points to integrate any kind of systems/weapons/sensors, for whatever mission needed.

  • @josephwielinski4383
    @josephwielinski4383 Před měsícem +4

    Please do a video of the Endurance-class landing platform dock

  • @ziq2188
    @ziq2188 Před měsícem +1

    Well presented, 👍👏

  • @lukex19
    @lukex19 Před měsícem

    Little Singapore used Galvanized Industry and innovational veneers to expand its defense fleet.

  • @chandrachurniyogi8394
    @chandrachurniyogi8394 Před 17 dny

    off shore patrol vessels should be regulated worldwide in terms of it's size & foot print . . . for e.g. the maximum displacement of OPVs should be no more than 630 ton (900 ton loaded) . . . armed with dual tube 553 mm torpedo launcher . . . RIM-162 ESSM 4-cell canister launcher . . .

  • @nonamenoname9468
    @nonamenoname9468 Před měsícem +5

    Please have the AI pronounce "littoral" correctly just once I beg

  • @logicae4096
    @logicae4096 Před 25 dny +1

    Only the US Navy in 2024 cannot build an integrated mast....

  • @bokwoon
    @bokwoon Před měsícem +2

    I do not wish to see any AI generated videos like this in my feed

  • @timodee_art
    @timodee_art Před měsícem +1

    LiT-TOR-AL!!! LIT-TOR-AL!!! “Say my name!” It’s LIT-TOR-AL, not LIT-ER-AL. ReCaptcha should honestly use this as the “are you a robot question”. Every single one of these bots gets it wrong. Every. Single. Time. 😂

  • @syang1116
    @syang1116 Před 28 dny

    who is supposed to be potentisl enemy of Singapore?

  • @leon-z6r
    @leon-z6r Před 9 dny

    Philippine Gov. Eintein watch here!

  • @Serai-l7z
    @Serai-l7z Před měsícem

    Props for the Gundam inspired names

    • @iatsd
      @iatsd Před měsícem +8

      They're all Royal Navy names

  • @pikminlord343
    @pikminlord343 Před měsícem

    Wow!

  • @vicbanks9079
    @vicbanks9079 Před 4 dny

    nice info, although your voiceover is clearly AI generated. LITTORAL is not pronounced 'literal'.

  • @ropeburnsrussell
    @ropeburnsrussell Před měsícem +11

    Why couldnt the US build 30 of these?
    Why dont we buy 6 now as a stopgap for the frigate?

    • @NewmaticKe
      @NewmaticKe Před měsícem +19

      This is a corvette sized vessel. I don't think the US operates such class of smaller vessels.

    • @eseetoh
      @eseetoh Před měsícem +22

      Tks for the compliment. But i believe as good as these LMVs are, they were not designed for long-range ocean conditions, something the U.S. Navy might need. Perhaps something like the Gowind class convettes might be a better fit.

    • @Wick9876
      @Wick9876 Před měsícem +11

      They're unarmed. Not absolutely, but 12 point defense AA missiles and a basic gun isn't a serious threat to a warship. They have no helicopter. No ability to self deploy from San Diego to Singapore. On the plus side, they're almost unmanned (23 vice 115 for a Freedom class or 200 for a Constellation). They're nice for what they are but that's more coast guard than combat vessel.

    • @ropeburnsrussell
      @ropeburnsrussell Před měsícem +14

      @@Wick9876 they are better armed than the LCS

    • @Wick9876
      @Wick9876 Před měsícem

      @@ropeburnsrussell The LCS is mostly a carrier. It has the helo and firescout, and loads of space and support for USVs or other flexible payloads. Also, it has 21 vice 12 point defense missiles, the 57mm is pretty similar to the 76mm, and, again, lots of space and support for other packages. So it's armament is sad but not worse.

  • @williamwatkins1849
    @williamwatkins1849 Před měsícem +6

    Better than the American navy.

    • @NoStressMarkets
      @NoStressMarkets Před měsícem +4

      lmao

    • @boonnamgoh8914
      @boonnamgoh8914 Před měsícem +1

      ​@@NoStressMarkets it's a low bar given all the issues the US navy littoral vessels are facing 😂 but Singapore did choose a good European partner to save on developing from scratch, and integrated good proven solutions to have a cost-effective solution (rather than try to push the envelope with inventions on all fronts).

  • @richardmeo2503
    @richardmeo2503 Před měsícem +5

    Nice looking ships. Surprised they have english names

    • @shawnc5188
      @shawnc5188 Před měsícem

      We were only a British possession then Crown Colony for 150 years, so most us still bow to white people and call you ‘sahib’ 🤪

    • @eatdriveplay
      @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +27

      hmm.. Singapore is an English speaking country. We grow up speaking English from nursery.. LOL!

    • @blackstorm6416
      @blackstorm6416 Před měsícem

      😂😂😂

    • @comedycord123
      @comedycord123 Před měsícem +2

      Singapore used to be British colony.

    • @eatdriveplay
      @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +9

      @@comedycord123 yes… which laid a foundation for us. But it was our policy post-independence that we decided to adopt English as our working and education language. Everything is in English. :)

  • @douglasang3527
    @douglasang3527 Před měsícem +1

    Why the old version 76mm OTO Melara Gun ?! Crazy ! 😅

    • @eseetoh
      @eseetoh Před měsícem +22

      @@douglasang3527 oh cause these guns were transferred from a previous decommissioned class of ships. Don't forget that these LMVs were not meant to be blue water combatants so weaponry are defensive in nature. These older oto melara 76mm guns will suffice.

    • @eatdriveplay
      @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +1

      @@eseetoh nah, they bought new guns for sure.

    • @eseetoh
      @eseetoh Před měsícem

      @@eatdriveplay nono, i remember reading somewhere that they repurpose the guns from the previous 12 ships Fearless-class Patrol Vessels (PV)s to the LMVs.

    • @eatdriveplay
      @eatdriveplay Před měsícem +5

      @@eseetoh obviously not… why? Because SIPRI records new gun purchases transfers. Also out of the 11 surviving PV - 2 were donated to Brunei, 4 are still in service as MSRV, meaning there are at most 5 unaccounted/scrapped. There are 8 LMVs. So how can it be? Singapore won’t be stupid to put old guns in a brand new ship.

    • @50centswarlord
      @50centswarlord Před měsícem

      @@eseetoh you get it wrong , they are all new guns from OTO . My 4th son serve in one of the ship as a gunner and a weapon specialist and I can confirm that .

  • @nicb.1213
    @nicb.1213 Před měsícem

    Why the respective authority did not address the loss of few hundred billion reserve that disappeared and also debts beyond 800 billion gone to. Why the authority still concentrates on its weaponry, for what? Preparing to go to war with the New King of Malaysia and the Future President of Indonesia, Probawa >>>????

  • @EnglishScripter
    @EnglishScripter Před měsícem +1

    US navy has already loss.

    • @iatsd
      @iatsd Před měsícem +3

      It looks like English, but there's no content in that sentence. Even AI's can usually do better.

    • @EnglishScripter
      @EnglishScripter Před měsícem

      @@iatsd Alright.