France, Germany and Poland: A New Alliance Against Russia
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 03. 2024
- Macron, Scholtz and Tusk have announced a new alliance designed to prevent Russian victory. Behind the facade of unity, there are long historical animocities, past misdeeds, deportations, massacres, and distrust. Here I discuss official policy against the background of popular attitudes, views of Germany in France and in Poland, the ways the Germans perceive their neigbors and the way the Russians see the French, the Germans and the Poles, as well as animocities between the Poles and Ukrainians.
Dr.Brovkin is an American historian, now retired, born in the Soviet Union and educated at Georgetown and Princeton, an emigrant who became a Harvard Professor of Soviet History, the author of many books on the history of Russia, the latest being: From Vladimir Lenin to Vladimir Putin: Russia in Search of Of Its Identity 1913 - 2023. All his books are available on Amazon books.
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
How come Putin was the only one to call for negotiations in this senseless, stupid waste of human life?
He is the only leader who understands suffering.
Nato is the team of dacoity organization
Russia did not start that war they don't want Ukraine but the usa/ cia started the war to destroy Russia economy but it back fired ! Russia is doing great and the usa is going broke!
The other guyz are fanatical dumbshirtz.
This is a Oil War
Its against Western Profits to make Peace
Putin is to naive.
He belives stupid false notrious Liars will be reasonable
The world is getting sick of these non stop trouble makers,including full NATO.
thank you for your comment
smartest russian bot blaming nato for the war which you caused 😂
There is inly one troublemaker in europe who invades his neighbours, hugs with Taliban, hamas and Iran and threatens to launch nukes. And this isn't NATO. Everyone praising Putin i invite you to live in Russia
@@krissu706 An incomplete thought.
@@krissu706 Th3 dumbest western olocharicy regimes bot calls everybody bot. Projecting much brainwashed 🐑? 😂
Micron is not eager to send French troops to Ukraine. Micron is eager USA send USA troops to Ukraine.
@@amitranaware9356hiding behind his manwife/granny like Jill Biden controlling their whimpering husband. Welcome to a brave new world where women like cookie lady nuland spreding chaos globally 😅😅😅
And they're all eager for more Ukrainians to be sent to the front in Ukraine...
A deliberate misnaming I assume… or just a Freudian slip?
@@fieryfredthebeaconlighter2259 Probably deliberate - and my own comment half an hour ago to the effect that they all prefer fighting till the last Ukr-ian was immediately m*ted by YT of course..
And the US is eager to get French fries out of the Ukraine.
(That being a metaphor of the massive US investment into Ukrainian agriculture)
Poles will not die for Bandera Land !!!!!No way !!!!
Ale zrobimy wszystko aby ostatni Banderowiec wybil ostatniego putlerowca
But we will do everything to ensure that the last Bandera player knocks out the last putlerian
Everyone trying to make it this way....
Sadly, it's upon the USA Neocons to decide, and the lobby I can't name here if I want my post not to be deleted.
They been dying since end of summer 2022.
@@chanpasadopolska@chan. It used to this way. Neo n..is out. Enough. NATO has no industrial base to compete. This is over
Hello Vladimirr.
I am an australian citizen but born in Europe of Dutch, german and maybe a bit of Hungarian background, I have visted Europe on and off and found exactly of what you described in your Realpolitik video.
My daughter lives in France and on a visit we interacted with her French friends, I have a broad Australian accent so all was very friendly until one of my young grandsons called me Opa, this happened on a number of different occasions, I asked a Dutch friend about this antagonism between europeans, she replied it is a fact of life and it will never disappear, I made the mistake twice, of mistaking the polish accent for being Russian (you would think I would learn after the first time) the hostility directed against me was palpable.
The good thing is Russia is standing up for herself and by extension for the global South who sees Putin and Russia as their champion and a chance for sovereignty.
best wishes.
Where's your ball and chain?
@MC … whatever :
It appears your imbecility & stupidity go hand in hand together!
However …
Dear Dutch Aussie, we lived for 5 years in Down Under, our son lives in The Blue Mountains. A fortnight ago my wife and I returned to France, where we live, after 3 months staying with our son. We are Dutch. I agree with you!
""Russia as their champion and a chance for sovereignty" - tell it to Chechen, Georgian, Czech, Romanian, Polish, Hungar or Austrian. And last two years to Ukraina peolpe "Russia as a chance for sovereignty" More people will be surprise, cause Russia was mostly oppresor to them long, long years!
Most of Poles DO NOT hate Russians. They’re our brothers. We share the same DNA, we are Slavic.
Today’s Russophobia was created by media, it’s been progressing since 1989 to manufacture consent for future war Anglo Saxons have been planning against Russia. 30% of the nation fell for it. You can’t even imagine the level of propaganda and historical revisionism taking place in Eastern Europe. Do not put the rest, normal Poles, so 70% in the same bag with those easily manipulated and poorly informed minority. Loud minority but it’s still a minority. I’m a Polish Russian and I grew up in Poland, so I can assure you that I never experienced anything like hatred while speaking Russian being out and about and I lived in Warsaw and spent every weekend at my grandma’s place in a masovian village quite far from the big city.
Polish government ≠ Polish people and that’s not even me saying that, that’s what president Łukaszenka says all the time.
I’ve noticed now The dehumanization of Poles, so when the government pushes people into this war, nobody will feel bad for them. Stop spreading this made up madness; it really doesn’t help, Poles living in the west (like me now) now experience a lot of bs, because of alleged Russophobia. I was called out on it and that person was really sure of himself, not knowing one bit about Slavic brotherhood, shared culture and customs. I responded that actually I AM RUSSIAN as well. They didn’t know what to say and finally apologized.
Stop generalizing PLEASE.
Surprisingly, the most russophobes indeed live in the west, but they hate Germany, Ukraine, Lithuania and themselves, because they have always been marginalized and used as cheap labor. They’re also not that big in numbers. It’s also caused by huge competition in finding a well paid job. This issue is not as easy as it seems and I’m really saddened when people try to pour more gasoline on this already huge media and c*i*a* created drama.
Not only Germans are memorable for their WWII time feats. Romania is remembered in Ukraine and Crimea for that as well.
especially in Odessa
Whenever people talk about that, and WWII in general, they forget to mention how scared people were of the soviets and the "freedom revolution" that were "liberating" the people. It always starts with the rise of the far right in the retelling. Not even sure if you are being ironic or not, it basically depends on who's propaganda you believe. @@vladimirbrovkin4052
@@vladimirbrovkin4052Oh yeah, a system where if your last name is not Putin you can't be president and steal money from the treasury and sends soldier to slaughter like in Ukraine, is better. And treats its neighbors like potted plants,bombed,just there to beautify Russia.Thats for sure.
What about the Baltics.
And yet the people of ukraine and especially Odessa worship the aryans as a superior race.
For what? To die together? They forgot Russia have also Iran North Corea and Chine?
Nah Russia can take all three of them, no problem. None of their armies are currently capable of defeating Russia
..and if push comes to shove most of Afrique and the Arab world including Turks
@@izajahmed8863Russia is invincible, but wait: the plan was never to beat Russia in the first place. The American plan was to attrition Russia and bleed their economy into weakness all the way using Ukis as cannon fodder, then adding more poles into the meat grinder. Then France never understand anything and they will spoil the whole thing.
Russia doesnt have China XD China doesnt have allies. You have no idea what you are talking about. Even recently chinese banks stopped serve Russian customers. 😂 China wants Siberia. They will wait for best moment.
@@izajahmed8863 Only with the help of the USA, but they only want Europe fighting with Russia while they watch.
A wonderful lesson for those who know nothing of historical facts, which is majority in the WEST!
Thank you Dr.Brovkin🙏
This is Russian view propaganda. Bandera as a Polish hero -really? Half of the belarus was a Poland not a occupied state. There was no Belarus before 1991. My famyli lived there for centuries. Now i live in Gdansk and bekive me no one in Poland want to change that. It is over. And it is Moskovia which is doing mess in Europe now. Who pledged to Ukraine ihat they borders will be safe after resigning from nuclear wepons?
Alliance of three stooges ..
he twisted the history on purpose, do not listen to him he "forgot" to tell you that Stalin took big portion of Poland in 1945 and made it part of USSR
Thank you mr. Brovkin. Always happy to watch your videos.
Wonderful to listen to recent history...pity no Americans will understand.
I do...and there are others. It's people in our government that either don't or care not to.
I’m Canadian and not buying the wests narrative….there are many of us too
I've done business in Germany and France. In France tech looks fancy but doesn't work. In Germany it looks bland, but it works.
The correct word for exiled is "Vertriebene".
Destroying the Eurasia of friendship and cooperation that was prosperous between 1990 and 2021....Europe is governed by the worst elite ever, fully submitted to atlantism....
No it doesn't.3.4% fiber optic coverage,and cashierless checkouts(which we've had in America,UK,etc for over twenty years Germany are promoting as new tech(maybe for those who come from eastern europe or other developing nations its high tech but for western nation not) I´ve lived in Germany and their tech is years behind even Polands(since getting billion from EU)and cannot even touch Turkeys advances in engineering and tech,medicine(Turkey has built two modern Airports and Bridges and the Berlin airports isnt even finished or up to standards for a modern airport).From wire card to Postbank software problems to other apps not working,Germany from VW to SAP have been caught bribing rating agencies,game developers etc for good press,ratings etc etc.Its the same way America and Germany pay to play when it comes to government ran or financed NGOs,institutions who always managed to criticize all but their pay masters.
well the "high standard and productivity of germany" is going down the tubes isn't it? because of no cheap russian energy. So what's the future for France then in light of that?
No enriched uranium from Russia - France closes down
Bleak. They wish take could take over, but they cannot. They're self-sufficient with energy from their nuclear power plants and that's about it. German economy going down means a recession in France just as well. Another curious thing is after Brexit, plenty of financial houses moved their headquarters from the City to the EU. Paris was one of the potential favourite destinations, but the French couldn't pull it off. Paris taking over London City would have been a coup in finance! It would be interesting to see the exact numbers how the financial emigres dispersed into Europe, but from what I know, some went to Frankfurt, others to Brussels and Amsterdam.
The propaganda of high standards Germany product is in large supported by cheap Russian energy and cheep Chinese technology. Both things have vanished so, there is a very dark future for Europe and specially Germany
This is the best commentary on the political situation in central Europe. I am an Indian living in Germany since over 50 yrs. I was a poltical science student. So I, too, follow the politics of Germany. I agree, very few Germans go to France for vacation and very few French vacation in Germany. Also the Germans I talk to look down at the French. But respectfully!!
good observation
All the EU countries (and the UK too) are rapidly declining in geopolitical influence and economic power. Europe is increasingly just a colonial outpost of the US. Basically, the colonisers of the recent past are rapidly becoming the colonised themselves. This has affected the entire European outlook on the world. They harbour bitter resentment against rapidly rising countries like China and India who they had dominated within the last 100 years. They resent their current status, and resent even more there is little they can do about it. Europeans look down on the rest of the world and also look down on each other. It is a complex situation brought on by its own decline, and the complete lack of any foresight by their elite to reverse the tide. To stem the decline would actually require Europe to drag itself by its own feet, quit being slavish colonies of the US, and start rebuilding economically and start asserting its independent geopolitical interests (which are very different from those of the US). But they are unwilling to do any of these things.
Namaste. You picked wrong stuff to educate about history of Europe , just check how Poland was presented here and compare of map of Europe from 1000 CE . Do you see any Germans there ? Look at the borders closely and try use history based on facts which are missing in this video
@@WitcherDADThe map of many countries would look very differently if you back a 1000 years. Many states did not even exist then.
@@pineapplesareyummy6352 - difficult to either disagree with your assertion or believe the onslaught of cultural change and mass immigration in Western Europe has not been orchestrated
Also difficult to envisage any "slavish colonies of the US reversing the decline" while they remain slavish colonies of the EU elite, owning nothing and being happy seems to be the preferred option for most of the electorate
Germany has committed economic and cultural suicide, the EU is a few yrs from finished and any pact between France, Poland and Germany against Russia would not be so much an alliance as a suicide pact.
thank you for your comment
God bless Rossia.
It was 💩 MOSCOVIA 💩
@@elzbietaanna1921 RUZZZZIA 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🤣😂🤣😂 РДК 🤣😂🤣😂🇺🇦🇺🇦💪💪💪💪
You never know with the 3 Stooges
Thanks for your programme. Great analysis of the situation.
thank u
Subscribed just after your first words. Thank you Dr. Brovkin.
Welcome aboard!
Congrats! You have subscribed to listen to biased interpretation of history. This guy spreads Putin's version of history , which is a lie.
You escalate this war, people will suffer greatly. Governments are suppose to offer order, not death.
The US and UK still feel they are sitting safely behind their ocean moats and can move other countries around to fight their wars for them. The American experience of war is fundamentally different from the Russian one, or even the German one (but Germany is more or less an American vassal state, eighty years after WW2)
Governments are manipulated, by those who always profit and gain power, mostly clandestinely.
@@louise_rose Why is the US war experience different from the Russian one?
@@panxd26 Because geography (and a measure of geopolitical superiority) protects the US from military invasions. No part of the regular US homeland (the 48 states at the time) was invaded, or even risked invasion, during WW1 or WW2 - Hawaii was still a colony of sorts in 1941, not a full part of the US, and tere were no Japanese landings, just a wave of bombings. Not a single US city or factory district was bombed, occupied or exposed to artillery fire. The US hasn't been exposed to a regular war within its borders since the Civil War 160 years ago. When the US joined WW2 in 1941, they had the option to wait with launching any offensives across the Atlantic until they felt they were ready and had built up enough armament, ships and supplies.
The Russian experience was opposite on all those accounts...sorry I can't be bothered to delve deeper into explaining what it meant. (no, I'm not Russian myself, I'm from Scandinavia)
Tak, putin szykuje się do ataku na Europę.. Rosja od lizbony po alaske. To cel putina.
As an Englishman, watching last week those three nations leaders meet, felt forced and rather weird.
☢️
Destroying the Eurasia of friendship and cooperation that was prosperous between 1990 and 2021....Europe is governed by the worst elite ever, fully submitted to atlantism....
as an Englishman find better Norman Davis "Gods Playground" and read about History, do not listen to old soviet who is repited Putin-Stalin -soviet version of history.
What is the reaction of the English public?
@@vladimirbrovkin4052from what I can see, many are baffled at the audacity with which the military heads call for mandatory military service and forced conscription when they are at replacement rate by migrants.
@@vladimirbrovkin4052 Zero reaction. It wasn’t reported on a single news channel. Just Y.Tube.
Polish people don't want any war!!!!
thank you
Does any nation want any war???
@@Mario-xr3jo Russia loves invading and annexing ts neighbours, not the opposite.
@@vladimirbrovkin4052 Putin wants war.
@@Mario-xr3jo Americans have been at war pretty much constantly since their inception ...maybe a couple of years excluded. But they have the gall to call anyone "a threat" to democracy ..or whatever. Hypocrites.
Thanjs a million for the historical update,,,, I'm sure 90 % of the current population in the West, most of the ones born 1970 and later havw no clue what you just said,,, Thanks again,,
Thank you. You have a great channel. I hope you’ll get more and more subscribers
Уважаемый господин Бровкин, Ваш ресурс достоин большего внимания. Приятно слушать человека, понимающего суть происходящего и происшедшего и к тому же проживающего колл. "Западе". Желаю Вам дальнейших успехов в Вашей работе.
ОРК 😂🤣😂🤣 БЕЛГОРОД И КРАСНОДАР 🔥🔥🔥🔥😂🤣😂🤣😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🇺🇦💪
@@4981t как там на украине сегодня? очко подгорает? из за таких как ты, и случаются беды. прыгайте выше во имя западных интересов
@@4981t Эльф из польши выглядывает?
wspaniałe bajki Andersena i Braci Grimm.
@9:30; Polish nationals have not forgotten that and also have not forgotten that Stalin took more Polish territory on the East.
Those territories on the East has nothing to do with Poland
@@nathanhiggers4606 Wrong! Have more to do with Poland than with Soviet Union or Russia.
@@robertcudny1839 Then why don't you ask Yukraine to give those back to Poland?
@@robertcudny1839 Then why don't you ask to give those back?
Outstanding discussion
Destroying the Eurasia of friendship and cooperation that was prosperous between 1990 and 2021....Europe is governed by the worst elite ever, fully submitted to atlantism....
Monologue is in no way a discussion.
@@nygus3835 spare us bozo.
An individual can discuss a topic by himself when before an audience.
Your channell is excellent. I learn SO MUCH listening to you. Thank you.
The nsdap nazis were left brown not right wing
Very interesting analysis Mr. Brovkin. I learned many things that I was not aware of about the politics of this area.
thank you for your comment
If you want to learn about politics of Eastern Europe you should listen to the lecturers of Dr. Snyder. This guy being Russian is biased and I am positive that he would not teach this version of history at American university. Dr. Snyder is an American and therefore he is objective in his view of European history.
15 minutes well spent thank you.
happy to hear that
There's also the issue of the British and French trying to get Ukraine to secure Crimea. Remember 1854-1856 Crimean War when the Anglo-French forces killed thousands of Crimean/Russian citizens especially at Sevastopol?
Check the previous video I discussed the Crimean war. You are right.
Thank you for the video!
I have only just discovered this channel - pure serendipity 😀 It is the clearest, most informative and soberly presented channel I have encountered. Having subscribed I look forward to more videos from the third Vladimir !
thank you
The three stooges won’t be leading the troops, that’s for sure. Micron would be better suited to keeping his hooter in a wineglass!
@hughmcdonnell. My post agreeing with your sentiments was swiftly censored.
@hughmcdonnell
You must mean Moe,Larry, Curly . Those three " leaders " ressemble the Three Stooges in all respect except one . The Three Stooges were smarter .
😂😂
As an Anglo-American, I trust this man's analysis. I'm subscribing now! I know ALOT about history, which is more than can be said of our so-called elites!
that "history" is disgusting , lies about Polish land "given" by Stalin from Germany while in fact this land occupied by Prussians for centuries is a fucking joke. This is the same "truth" about "accident" of crash plane with gen.Sikorski in Giblartar holding files with Katyń Massacre done by Soviets on 12K Polish Officers. So, tell me how was your "so-called help" promised by British to Poles before war started?
Man you opened my eyes,, the situation is far more complexed than I thought.
thank you
Yes, this war isn't only 'black & white'. It's very complex and started long time ago only now we can see the 'manifestation '...
Thank you very much.
welcome
I was in Berlin in Dec89 when the Wall was coming down. What an exciting time! We met kids from all over Eastern Europe and we drank and smoked in cafes and talked about art and the future. We had decided that the only people worried were the Joint Chiefs at the Pentagon and that Thatcher woman... that aside,
During this thaw, there was a move for Germany to reunify. Helmet Kohl took the Initiative. It all seemed to happen over night. The 4 power pact that presided over Germany at the end of WW2 was still in effect. Russia still had veto power and could have stopped the reunification of Germany, It didn't use its veto. In 2923, I thought about this when Germany was sending tanks and arms to Ukraine.... What must the Russians think?
Poland is a different story. Poland would have considerable bitterness towards both Germany and Russia. It was if the entire Polish nation had been moved 200 miles to the West in an accumulations of German territories. German citizens had been expelled. . .The status of the lands had to be legitimized by treaty before the reunification could take place. As for the Eastern parts of Poland taken by Russia, they were attached to Ukraine. Poland still has a valid claim to these territories.
A great oppotunity to unite europe was missed. Responsible are those whowanted to unify europe as a part of nato
What I like about this channel is the fact that it brings up a lot of nuanced details of events of the past and the intricacies of international relations, every program I learn something new, thank you!
Very incisive and informative.
These three countries, despite their mutual hatred, have joined hands against Russia on the principle of "the enemy of my enemy is my friend". These are very callous people who periodically invent mechanism to keep Ukraine in the war till the last Ukrainian.
why not any word about : Tusk was just few days ago in Washington, and DC are giving orders in NATO, not Poland or germans
yes you r right
Respectable and knowledgeable analysis. Happy to find your cannel. Looking forward foe more. Thanks!
I shall try
Interesting analisys. This gentleman touchs human sentiments, humors, the real stuff in human interactions.
I like those maps, photos too.
Very interesting video, but I have an alternate theory about one point you mentioned. You suggest that the bourgeoisie in Germany want cheap energy, but in any bourgeois democracy like Germany or the US, the national policy tends to already represent the will of the bourgeoisie. Why is it then that German policy favors US interests in Ukraine? Is the German ruling class spiting their bourgeoisie? No: the German bourgeoisie are part of an international capitalist class and they are already moving their factories to other countries. Why, then, did German leaders originally work so hard to create a German dependence on cheap energy from Russia at the risk of German national interest? Because this is how they appeased their bourgeoisie in the short term, but now that the gig is up capital is fleeing Germany and the average German citizen is left holding the bag after the rich profited for years.
initially they wanted to kill the bear and share the trophies. something went wrong along the way 🤣but now they're in too deep
@@Zed.Leppelin:
Yes, initially all of them wanted to kill the bear and loot it, but here we what is call "Heterogonie des Zweckes" in German!
@@Zed.Leppelin looks like it
@@user-vh2qf2kv3l thanks for teaching that expression, I found it's called "heterogeny of ends" in English. As a German, what do you think about my analysis of Germany's situation?
Great lesson, thank you
Thank you very much. What a great class! I will certanly look for your books. History is fascinating. 😊
thank you
Brilliant analysis! Thanks for communicating.
If Macron was required to fight, his stance would change quick
This is one of your most interesting videos. I hope that you will have more in the future about the cultural differences in views as other new events develop.
Immediately subscriped. You are such a gem of knowledge. Thank you!
This is what I thought, too, having found his channel🙋♂️
Totally unobtrusive and very informative.
@love rov
I stumbled across your playlist Geburtstagsfeier, so I suppose you are German, too.
Your music playlist is really funky, I love it, especially the first song!
Thank you so much for your input! Very informative!
Thank you. Great explanation.
Excellent overview of topic , thank you
my pleasure
Great informations.
Scholtz, Macron and Tusk don't form a 'Weimar Triangle', but more what I would call a 'Davos Circle' !!!
may be
Wow, thank you very much for the extremely intriguing history of Europe. If I may, I have a question sir. I thought US gained Western European loyalty once the Russian crossed into Ukraine, that was before I heard your history lesson. What do American really gain from provoking the Russian SMO? WW3? Thank you for your time.
Excellent presentations, Dr.
well done, thank you
Very good analysis.
Thank you, Dr.Brovkin, for giving historical perspective to this latest development. With this information I now have more hope, that we may not get to the global war, since the warring parties have no sympathy for each other. What a disaster, that we, the people, are held hostage to primal ambitions of a few individuals, aka ruling class.
well summed up
Nice context ! Thanks
I’m glad I’ve found you. You explain everything so clearly I’ve learned a lot!
I just stumble onto your channel and really like it a lot. Youre like a very informed, intelligent person one might strike up a conversation with on a park bench, or on a long train ride. Very calming voice too. I just subbed and look forward to hearing more from you. Thank you.
To many idiot's together 😂😂❤❤❤
World class opinion and historical analysis! I love your channel.
Well done, you made the analysis very simple.
Thank you!
Macrom wife seems to be jean michel.
Destroying the Eurasia of friendship and cooperation that was prosperous between 1990 and 2021....Europe is governed by the worst elite ever, fully submitted to atlantism....
Really useful information. Thanks!!!!
From your mouth to my ears! Excelent analysis!
thank you
Great insights into the conflict
thank u
Thank you. Thank you. I love all those details. Isn't it amazing that in school we never learned all these details. Too bad. I was born in Jicin which is what was called the Sudetenland Eva
Good messages educative excellence
Thank you for you a great channel! 👍
I just found your channel thank you sir.
welcome
thank you Mr Vladimir for deeper analyzing socio politico and economical status among these three countries which impacts so differently in ukraine russia war
my pleasure
Helpful information … Thank you!
welcome
Excellent presentation dr Brookings this info was sorely needed thank you
Little dogies bark the loudest, to make up for their small size and little power.
thank u
Latest approval poll for:
Macron: Approve: 29 % (-1) Disapprove: 67 % (+2)
Scholz: Support for Scholz's Social Democrats dropped to 17%, which is 8.7 percentage points less than their result in the federal election two years ago
Tusk: Too early to move beyond his party's percentage in the latest go round which was 30.7%
Helpful analysis…thank you
welcome
Continued thanks to you for your videos. Very informative.
With all that said, the abiding dislike/suspicions of Frane with Germany and vice versa, the historical memories of the Poles toward Germany and Ukraine……. would it make sense for the US to withdraw from NATO? Afterall, it’s happened TWICE where the US ended up in Europe fighting and dying for European interests. And where does the UK fit in all of this?
We should declare neutral like we should have done in 1914 when France allied with Russia against Germany and Poland fought on both sides at the same time.
Not that it will make much difference with the fallout from the Russian nukes.
Thanks to Putin's leadership the United Russia Party now has the necessary political numbers, nous and military productive capacity to do whatever it deems necessary to defend Russia's state borders, people and sovereignty. Neither NATO nor the EU are capable of diminishing either of these geopolitical and military facts. Apart from the two viable opposition parties ie; the Communist Party of the Russian Federation and 'A Just Party - For Truth'; there is a minuscule number of street protester types (less that 2% of the population) who are either pro Western pro Navalny liberal activists, or they are the relatively extreme Russian nationalist types who actually think Putin is too soft on the West.
Many thanks for thé history lessons wich are very important 👍
Thank you.
Great information and analysis.
thank you
Am always interested in history thank you for the brilliant explanation. 👏🏿
he have knowledge of History from stalin-soviet book/side. He is not objective! You want read about - find Norman Devis (englishman) about Poland. Do not listen to old soviet guy.
@tomaszser470 I will look it up bro thanks you for the information 🙏🏿 just love history .
pleasure
So much I learnt from ur video. Thanks.
Glad to hear that
Thank you for the insights.
this needs linking to on judge napolitano's interviews and on Ritter's vids and Moonofalabama and any Doug Macgregor vid, 'dialogue works' and so on. Every 'trying' channel/site you can find. for the sake of their audiences who'll all profit from what this guy tells us.
You know what? In more than two years of following the best sources I can find on this war this is the ONLY ONE that starts with the people. The people.
thank you I try
@@vladimirbrovkin4052 And I think you do very well. I don't know how you measure up to your own aspirations but from here you do wonderfully well. And because, as I said, you speak of People.
No one else does, sadly.
In all the earnest, profound and scholarly discussions nation names: Russia, France, England, Germany, etc. all turn out to mean when you look at what they're talking about, who did what they say the did or will, govts, or claques. Not the people.
They carry this nonsense so far that they make scholarly predictions of what these nations MUST do because of their history and their 'essence' etc,, etc..
All of which the populace are largely unconscious of.
Or when they are conscious of it they certainly don't mean it to go as far as for instance what is happening now in Ukraine or Israel. Do Kiev Ukrainian people want half a million of them to die for the sake of ethnic cleansing of Donbas in order to build a brave new Ukraine? I think not. Do ordinary working Israelis want babies and children etc. crushed to death, blown to pieces in order that they might 'teach the Palestinians a lesson' ? I think not.
To me the missing thing is the voice of the people.
The machinery is in place: democracy. Imperfect as that machine is still it can be used to good purpose.
But the people never could. Too difficult, in truth, and insufficient interest and honestly not enough information.
Now is 2024. All those constraints are gone. Or on the very edge of being gone.
Let 'digital democracy' or 'popular democracy' or 'online democracy' appear and suddenly we're up and running.
I really hope you see what I mean and see the merit in it:
abrogard.com/blog/2023/12/25/dont-write-to-congress/
In the same time tons of lies about history by 1946. Good luck to beliving what said Stalin must be only "truth" . Poor German lost their occupied terrytory on Polish soil for centuries and bad Poles "occupied" Bielarus because they "wanted" not because of Versal Treaty. Here we are.
Wow, a nuanced view on the current state of affairs. I'm glad the algorithm sent me here. Subbed.
Dear Dr. Brovkin, thank you for sharing your experience, courage to tell the truth, and elegant oratory. Greetings from São Paulo, Brazil.
We deeply appreciate your wealth of knowledge and in particular broadening our horizon of thinking.
welcome.pleasure
Accurate video. I was born in Poland, but moved to the US a long time ago. Subbed.
you moved to Stated and you lost memory about history of Poland to believe in this crap?
@@WitcherDAD Instead of posting an empty comment, state what you disagree with.
@@WitcherDAD go ahead, state what you disagree with. Or are just a simpleminded anti-Russia biggot.
THANK U FOR YOUR TRUTHFULL ANALYSES. SPASIBA
My pleasure
thank you!
Same here for infographics. Please upload high resolution images.
I'll try
Wonderful speech.Teach the truth rather than western propaganda.
We need a friendly environment.
Thank you.. subscribed..
Now that Germany is severely weaken economically, diplomatically and internal politics is a mess... it would be interesting to see if EU experiment breaks up .
that has been the playbook of the British from the start, I do not understand that so many Experts do not see beyond their nose...BREXIT is the elephant in the room that nobody is seeing.......how Johnson stopped the Peace talks and are the drivers of more and more war, which is breaking the economies and social harmony among EU states...this has been their plan......they are suffering Brexit, they cannot go back to the EU as their people have demanded to leave...so they need the union to collapse and create a new union where they can be the top dog.
No, it will take a lot more than disastrous political mismanagement by the Germans to totally destroy the European Union. You write like an English Brexiteer who predicted the collapse of the EU donkey's years ago when it was the European Coal and Steel Treaty. ha! ha! Glad to see the back of the malcontents.
God willing! Amen
Cheers from Australia
@@cameliaburdusel5766 Do you think the German farmers would allow their government to do a deal with Australia like the English did since Brexit? Welsh sheep farmers are livid. ha! ha!
Seat back n learn
Very interesting historical/political analysis. Thanks a lot
welcome
Thank you very much, Professor! 🙏 Subscribed!
welcome aboard
Thanks , very educational and enlightening.