For Joe to understand it better, there is also some life stories of the lyrics composer: her name is Tang Tian. In 2012, she wrote these lyrics for Eason the singer because she is his fan. She was diagnosed as cancer patient and she wished to hear her favourite singer Eason to sing the lyrics she wrote before she died or lost her hearing. Then her parents brought her lyrics to a reality show called Chinese Dream Show to help her realize her dream, and Eason responded her and promised that he would do it. She has been fighting against cancer since then, her wish is to die after her parents. She also has many other very popular songs in the past 17 years. And after 9 years, Eason finally matched her lyrics with a famous song composer Qian Lei. At the first day of launching, this song hit 200 million views.
When "Something just like this" was so popular on the streets in China, I was hoping to see some Chinese singer can produce a same powerful song. Now, Eason's 孤勇者 has made it and he did it even better.
This is great, and thank you very much! 感謝桑德和九爺！By the way, where can I find the link to the video Joe plays in this video? The offical MV I found on CZcams doesn't come with the English subtitles. Thank you in advance!
Hi, Sanders. Awesome videos about music. Had watched basically half a day without stop. Damn, good shit~! Joe's fantastic too. I mean, i dabble in music in my youth (and chased those 中国好声音videos later), but still missed quite a few stuff that without pointing out, I'd have missed them. (In my defense, no earphones because i was simply listening to songs earlier, ha) ... ... Anyway, just wanna reply here about Mandopop. Or Chinese pop, which is different from Eason's roots (he's technically Cantopop, and there are differences. More on Eason later). This video is a good place to explain this, because Joe had brought up the music arrangement and production. China has managed to catch up to the West in this sense, in short. In detail, well, Joe is able to hear them all, so let's all just continue watching your videos to learn, yah? :D And, also, Chinese vocalists are catching up. When we said Chinese here, we have to be strict here and say that these mean those mainly based or HQ-ed in China. Because China pays top dollar for the best talents nowadays. Again, your videos had showcased some of the very best right now, so ... watch videos, wink wink. Eason is quite literally the best Mandopop vocalist right now, because he managed to combined his head "voice" 腔 with the other parts. 3 parts at the same freaking time, I believe, which is why when you heard Eason, you know it's Eason. Because, it is not that easy to do. Jacky Cheung can do that too, but personally disliked the arrogance in his voice. Eason's had no such thingy ... DISCLAIMER - love Jacky Cheung songs, but not a fan. Not even a fan of Eason (he dislikes "normal" Mandopop songs, and Joe has pointed it out actually, that Eason prefers such high-production shit. With meaning.) Finally, it's just great that Joe is learning Chinese bit by bit (and actually catching on the fact that we use the ahs and mas as expressions, pros to the fellow), because the language ... well, has 4000 years of culture behind it. We all had seen (again, on your videos, wink wink) that when the Chinese lyrics are translated into English, actually you need more than double the amount of words just to TRY to convey the scenic meaning. In one line of lyrics, just in one line of lyrics. Because, yes, the context is so important. Damn. All and all, if you have read this wall of text, I thank you. In fact, I should be thanking you for these videos anywayz. Cheers, man. P.S. Oh yah, the story of the lyricist is ... wow. Some artistes are genuine human beings who are indeed heroes~!
As a Chinese Canadian, this song both lyric and theme particularlly hit me hard, there had been series of successful song that has multi language version adopt to the same theme. Imagine Dragon's Enemey is a very good song, but it does not hit me at the core like 孤勇者. It is the same theme, it had the same story to tell, but Eason told it better thru just his vocal and the good lyric and music compuser.
Eason -200 分 because I love Eason Chan 😁😆😍 Joe - 90 分。 他学中文了， 很棒，加油💪🏻 Sander - 100 💯 thank you for produce such a good video to promote Asian music. 希望下一次你会 介绍 李克勤 from HK and people have call him Hi-Fi Vocal Sound. His have a very good voice. You may watch 我是歌手的《我不会唱歌》
Especially those who came out when it started in the beginning like 2020....you really dunno what u were facing with but can easily get infected...heros👍
這個Joe很厲害，可以觀察出很多細節，還能用豐富的詞彙表達出來，聽過他的分析，感覺整個表演更立體了
第一次聽對"戰嗎 戰阿"這句特別有感，完全烘托出孤身奮戰無須質疑的決絕，後來知道了唐恬，才了解到這是一個別無選擇又不願認輸的吶喊，一種曾經拚盡全力的人特別能被點燃的共鳴。
唐恬,她還寫了那麼多好歌給我們 給人們力量 很了不起!!
我也是這句特別有感，一種絕望又不屈，內心拉扯和對話
这几个字，不知道用英文如何才能准确表达？
這首歌很有生命力
+1
我是知道唐恬的故事才知道孤勇者這首歌，聽了能感受到“戰啊”不對命運低頭的韌性。
Eason也很棒，答應他粉絲唐恬的心願，說到做到。
給九爺100分
給歌100分
給無名英雄們200分
說得太好了
不给up一个100分嘛～
我給狗狗500分
听完第一感觉是写给香港的
我是因為錢雷編的曲才喜歡上這首歌的
九爷 能够这么深入去了解中文真是太好了。继续加油！
牛啊
好仁的mjpop
中文系廣東話💪👌煲東瓜系滿清狗話丶滿清唔係漢人👌
看過很多關於歌曲分析的影片，無礙九爺的分析是最有內涵的，並非流於表面，聽一次便能剖析當中的深層意義，實在欽敬欽敬！
戰 是勇敢的
我額頭的傷口 我的不同 我犯的錯
都 不必隱藏
我破舊的玩偶 我的面具 我的自由
你們說 要帶著光 馴服每一頭怪獸
你們說 要縫好我的傷 沒有人愛小丑
為何民主 不可自由
人只有不完美 值得歌頌
誰說民主滿身的不算自由
愛我孤身走暗巷
愛我不跪的模樣
愛我對峙過絕望
不肯哭一場
愛我破爛的衣裳
卻敢堵命運的槍
愛我和你那麼像
百姓都一樣
去嗎 配嗎 這民主的披風
戰嗎 戰啊 以最卑微自由
致那烏克蘭中的嗚咽與怒吼
誰說站在共產的才算英雄
你們說 要戒了我的狂 就像擦掉了民主
你們說 要順台階而上 而代價是低頭
那就讓你 不可 乘風
我一樣驕傲著 那種民主
誰說對弈平凡的不算英雄
愛我孤身走暗巷
愛我不跪的模樣
愛我對峙過絕望
不肯哭一場
愛我破爛的衣裳
卻敢堵命運的槍
愛我和你那麼像
百姓都一樣
去嗎 配嗎 這民主的披風
戰嗎 戰啊 以最卑微自由
致那黑夜中的民主與自由
誰說站在共產的才算英雄
我的斑駁 與眾不同
我的沉默 震耳欲聾 (My are the hero)
愛我孤身走暗巷
愛我不跪的模樣
愛我對峙過絕望
不肯哭一場 (My are the hero)
愛我來自於蠻荒
一生不借誰的光
我將造我的城邦
在廢墟之上
去嗎 去啊 以最卑微民主
戰嗎 戰啊 以最孤單自由
致那黑夜中的民主與自由
誰說站在共產的才算英雄
真的要佩服填词人唐恬。。。这首歌的歌词填的真的很好。。。然后还要感谢她的父母为了替女儿实现梦想而参加节目让她女儿填的歌词给陈奕迅唱。。。然后才会有这么好听的这首歌。。。
我觉得应该是唐先写歌词给陈并希望他谱曲，陈谱的曲并演绎了这首歌。
這首歌背後有故事啦，是一位有癌症的女音樂人想陳奕迅唱歌給她聽才有的，因為康復了也會失去聽力，歌詞好像也是這位女生寫的，詳細資料上網可以找到，因為外國人聽這首歌可能不知道背後還有這個故事，希望可以介紹一下這位有才華的女生給更多人知道。
也不算少女啦，唐恬是很有才华的作词人，她在这首歌之前，已经有参与很多脍炙人口的佳作
@@maxchou4476
我改一下寫女生吧，另外我也知道她很有才華，不過在這首歌之前，包括我在內很多人其實沒有留意到她，所以才希望寫個評論希望多點介紹她給其他人也認識她。
@@neil170 真的，背后的故事也值得被人知晓！
末尾提到了
对，知道这首歌的背景和创作者跟癌症抗衡的故事会更感动。
這首歌最厲害的還是歌詞，而且敘事範圍非常廣，大白是英雄、環衛工人是英雄、養兒育女也是英雄，你在你的位置上打拼努力生活，每個人都可以是英雄，你也可以說它雞湯不尖酸諷刺不揭露醜陋，但社會確實需要這種正能量歌曲，對小學生群體也是一種很正向的價值觀引導
所以每个不同阶段不同地位的人听这首歌都有着不同的理解思路，这歌词生生把歌曲唱活了。
兩位的外國人都很棒，感覺上兩位都很老實表達出來他們的心理面的意思。解釋的很清楚。讚讚！
For Joe to understand it better, there is also some life stories of the lyrics composer: her name is Tang Tian. In 2012, she wrote these lyrics for Eason the singer because she is his fan. She was diagnosed as cancer patient and she wished to hear her favourite singer Eason to sing the lyrics she wrote before she died or lost her hearing. Then her parents brought her lyrics to a reality show called Chinese Dream Show to help her realize her dream, and Eason responded her and promised that he would do it. She has been fighting against cancer since then, her wish is to die after her parents. She also has many other very popular songs in the past 17 years. And after 9 years, Eason finally matched her lyrics with a famous song composer Qian Lei. At the first day of launching, this song hit 200 million views.
Amazing background! songs like these really hit the heart and soul!
Yep. I didn't realise she wrote a few other songs which I absolutely love too:
1. 如愿
2. 体面
3. 追光者
唐恬
九爷真的有研究中文呐！厉害了！
我补充一下个人观点。
“去吗？去啊！”
“战吗？战啊！”
吗、啊的使用，除了押韵这个功能之外，还表达了一种毋庸置疑的坚定。在“缝好伤口”“破烂的披风”“小丑”“满身泥垢”这样的描述之后，尤其有冲击力。---即便是被形容成如此，如此破碎、破败，看起来更有理由沉沦堕落的人，在被问到，去吗？战吗？的时候，依旧是毫不犹豫的。在很多时候，用“啊”来结尾的回答里，暗含着一种，“不假思索”“不需要问”“早就做了决定”的意思。尤其是搭配了提问中的动词的时候。（你能想象在去吗？战吗？后面搭配的回答是：好、行、可以、看吧、去呗、战呗，这样的回答嘛？😊。）而且这几句歌词是对话的方式，一问一答。之前的陈述只是让你看到这个人、故事。但是对话，能把人一下子拉进一个场景中。再配上这么简洁的歌词。这个设计真是绝了。
深信ESON在唱這歌前有跟填詞人~唐括~這不幸斷了翼的鳳凰有深層次的溝通,把一隻斷了翼在深淵下，ㄧ步一步孤身的爬回天堂的鳳凰的會奮鬥史以歌曲帶出來,特别是副歌用了少有的搶拍方式表達那種焦躁和不甘！對曲，詞,意，唱都必須有一定的功力及自信才可以如此藝高胆大~贊！
這首歌是有故事的，這首歌本來就超級好聽，但是當我知道了這首歌背後的故事，再聽這首歌，再搭配上陳奕迅的聲音，我覺得特別好聽、特別有意義。
他也是知道故事之後而唱。
词作者是经历了一场生与死的考验,才能写出这么深刻的诗句. The lyricist has gone through a test of life and death to write such a profound poem.
很感謝柯桑德拍了這首歌的片子介紹了這首歌，我已經第二次看這片子了（一會兒再去看MV）！也很感謝九爺仔細的分析！個人也覺得醫生護士也得英雄！也很覺得讓人尊敬！感恩柯桑德的片子！
我覺得在每個人心目中都有一位英雄
,並在聽這首歌的時候引起了共鳴,讓人
越聽越沉靜在裡面
我很喜歡這個感覺☺️
我喜歡裡面的金句是
對峙過絕望卻不肯哭一場
明知世界的不公我依舊不妥協
這不就是孤勇者的最佳寫照。
是一位有10年癌症的女音樂人想陳奕迅唱歌給她聽才有的，，她叫唐恬，我也很佩服这个作词女孩，，有好多歌都火了
支持，我也很喜欢长听这首歌，支持
好人一生平安 希望唐恬早日 康复
@@donglinm6142 她已經康復了
九爺的講解，專業、簡單又易懂，100分！
陈奕迅这首歌已经超出了小朋友们能理解的范围。也谢谢joe的精彩分析。 这首歌的内容很多，配合精彩的动漫，这个作品已经超神了
真的很喜欢这么专业的分析，中文歌歌词尤其重要，如果能深入理解歌词我想一定会更好的效果，孤勇者这首歌我想到大白 消防员 抗癌患者 等等平民英雄，“谁说站在光里的才算英雄”写的真的棒，结合背景故事那个抗癌女士之手写出的这组歌词，又赋予了一种抗争命运的力量。
這個人對這首歌的理解太到位了吧❤️愛了愛了
我已經10幾年沒學新歌了，聽了這首歌，我重複播放，學了這首歌，真的好聽
我也是，10几年才肯认真学唱新歌
给九爷100分，以后只听九爷的歌评，别人的没得比! 谢谢分享，辛苦啦！
众生皆苦，众生亦皆佛。所有曾经咬紧牙关扛过去的人都会被这首歌深深打动，并不是因为都有英雄梦，而是面对避无可避的厄运和困境时，只有自己那一身孤勇才是唯一的支柱。
桑德，音樂家的評論很棒，但我更喜歡你的肢體動作、表情，你有很多可愛的地方，聽你說話的方式也讓人覺得舒服，我訂閱你的頻道，支持你繼續有好作嗯！
每一次听最后一段都特别激动，词真的太好了
Wow to Joe's Chinese!! Having keen ears really helps in picking up a foreign language too ...besides to appreciate music😉
以前評論的是一個個的音節音符~這次評論的是一首歌一個故事~一個人...給我的感覺~好多了~謝謝精彩用心的評論分享..
This song is my favourite song in the recent years. Well done Eason!
Great reviewing!!! as always loving Joe's comments!
很喜欢你跟joe对国内优秀的音乐创作进行点评，关注了。
只要做好自己 對家人,社會都有貢獻 和付出 都是英雄
Joe is simply the best!!! THANK YOU 桑德!
Click "Like" already on this video! OMG... I haven't watched Mr. Yang's videos for quite a while, and I didn't know he's such a good singer! 😀
很喜欢Eason和Jay，唯一从年少听到现在三十而立还觉得可以一直听下去歌手。经典永不过时
很早就知道NETFLIX有這劇~
但是因為工作+一堆瑣事一直無法開始看
直到2月左右突然在某平台看到一則新聞中國小學生一堆人傳唱的"兒童歌曲"??!
不乖老師還不給播音樂讓他們唱!!!?
接著影片一堆小孩在那邊嘶吼EASON的歌曲???
最後當自己在YT點開這首歌來聽時
老實說我被震撼到了!!
生活中的不滿.委屈彷彿藉由這首歌抒發出來了!!
我無法形容這樣的感覺
就有如我每次唱到副歌時
自己就會莫名的有激動想哭的感覺
這真的是一首好歌啊!!!!
感謝作詞人(另一個感人的故事~也是我在看了這影片後才知道)
感謝陳奕迅~
这是一代人找到自己共鸣点~~小学生没太多社会历练，但是同样被感染到那种不屈不挠的斗志
說得好，誰說站在光裏的才是英雄，在疫情嚴重之時，所有奔赴疫區醫護人員，所有緊守在疫症中心的大白們都是英雄.向他們致敬👍🙏💪
不止他们，世界上还有常身在黑暗服务于光明的英雄！例如缉毒员，卧底警察，军人和无国界医生！
大白就是自我感动的典型。全球都放开了，非要弄个清零给那么多大白发工资，然后自己感动自己。可笑至极。
我女儿说：我觉得Eason都快成为唱儿歌的歌星了。我：！？？然后她说：可不是么，他唱的《孤勇者》我们学校所有的孩子都很喜欢听，大家都会唱了。
希望我们的后代都是勇敢的
@@edd-600 勇敢要從自己做起
我家幼兒園的孩子也是好愛這首歌
他本來就好多兒歌
鋼之煉金術師聽過嗎？😂
其實，整首歌裡面讓我感觸最深的是那句：他們說，要順台階而上，而代價是低頭。 這，就是現實.....
你也可以不听他们说，这，是这首歌
“我命硬学不来弯腰”
中央不給予的就係沒有
原本是想回覆這句意思，但是每個人人生體驗不同，感受同一句話也會不同。
这也是一个角度。如果从另一个角度，也可以说谦逊使人进步。
Love the chemistry ⚗ between Joe and 柯桑德。🙌🏻
Mr. Yang，柯桑德叫你！😂
這首歌真的很好聽，現在一堆其他歌手也在翻唱
不知道背後的故事被感動，知道了更感動，加油👍
from first video of Joe, till now, i can see and feel that Joe is more enjoy...
九爷这集走心了，老桑也值得点赞👍 这首歌👍
真不錯，歌也不錯，分析也不錯！加油！
谢谢你, 给我们带来这么好的评价
这首歌可以让沉默的心爆发，所以小学生听到后内心积攒的压力可以随歌释放，所以他们很喜欢。
When "Something just like this" was so popular on the streets in China, I was hoping to see some Chinese singer can produce a same powerful song. Now, Eason's 孤勇者 has made it and he did it even better.
這首歌詞跟曲都很好, 可是很多翻唱(例如視頻中的英文版)一過度用力就唱得~~~很油~~~~eason把這首歌唱出一個高度,想起了浮誇沈寂中的吶喊~~期待演唱會萬人合唱
演唱者问题，他那张脸跟调音本来就油
你的评论非常到位
是的 ！
陈奕迅内敛的爆发的演绎，完美的呈现悲凉的孤勇者！
分析很好！谢谢分享！
当我知道这首歌的词作者背后的故事的时候，我真的很惊讶，一个人的体内能有这么大的能量，写出这充满力量的歌词，对生活对人生充满了战斗欲望。真的不错。可能这也是中文的魅力吧。
戰嗎 戰啊
黑暗中 高舉手握白紙的你 就是英雄
Joe很棒，居然能注意到嗎的疑問跟阿的肯定二者的不同，每次聽完Joe的講解才能知道一首歌裡有這麼多的細節。
joe中文很好啊，孤勇者这首歌给满分，感人
鸡皮疙瘩都起来了，热血又感动！有爱又有趣。
九爺真心覺的他很棒，很想要在多聽他對音樂的評段
圈粉了！love your comments！
每次看都感慨，九爷，专业！
你做的非常好👍！
I will share this video in my class! 👍
歌词写的真棒！唱的也很好！
Joe creator真的把这首歌点评得深入浅出，好专业，赞赞赞！
很喜欢这个节目 很喜欢你们两个
Eason 本來就是一個很會唱故事的歌唱家
最喜歡這位樂評人的點評👍👍👍
你们的视频好棒，剪辑和分析都很精彩！看了腾格尔老师《天堂》那集再到这里，好奇Joe如果听腾老师版的《孤勇者》会有什么反应。
被圈粉了！谢谢！
我太喜欢这首歌了，第一次听到的时候是在《我们的滚汤人生》
“谁说站在光里才算是英雄”
“谁说对弈平凡的不算英雄”
This is great, and thank you very much! 感謝桑德和九爺！By the way, where can I find the link to the video Joe plays in this video? The offical MV I found on CZcams doesn't come with the English subtitles. Thank you in advance!
为什么这首歌听起来会让我感动，又很伤感，好想流泪。
因为是一个癌症的人作品所以感动无奈又悲伤
別誤會是因為你本身愛哭
@@user-wq1fw7mw3x 哈哈哈哈哈
Hi, Sanders.
Awesome videos about music. Had watched basically half a day without stop. Damn, good shit~!
Joe's fantastic too. I mean, i dabble in music in my youth (and chased those 中国好声音videos later), but still missed quite a few stuff that without pointing out, I'd have missed them. (In my defense, no earphones because i was simply listening to songs earlier, ha) ...
... Anyway, just wanna reply here about Mandopop. Or Chinese pop, which is different from Eason's roots (he's technically Cantopop, and there are differences. More on Eason later). This video is a good place to explain this, because Joe had brought up the music arrangement and production. China has managed to catch up to the West in this sense, in short. In detail, well, Joe is able to hear them all, so let's all just continue watching your videos to learn, yah? :D
And, also, Chinese vocalists are catching up. When we said Chinese here, we have to be strict here and say that these mean those mainly based or HQ-ed in China. Because China pays top dollar for the best talents nowadays. Again, your videos had showcased some of the very best right now, so ... watch videos, wink wink.
Eason is quite literally the best Mandopop vocalist right now, because he managed to combined his head "voice" 腔 with the other parts. 3 parts at the same freaking time, I believe, which is why when you heard Eason, you know it's Eason. Because, it is not that easy to do. Jacky Cheung can do that too, but personally disliked the arrogance in his voice. Eason's had no such thingy ... DISCLAIMER - love Jacky Cheung songs, but not a fan. Not even a fan of Eason (he dislikes "normal" Mandopop songs, and Joe has pointed it out actually, that Eason prefers such high-production shit. With meaning.)
Finally, it's just great that Joe is learning Chinese bit by bit (and actually catching on the fact that we use the ahs and mas as expressions, pros to the fellow), because the language ... well, has 4000 years of culture behind it. We all had seen (again, on your videos, wink wink) that when the Chinese lyrics are translated into English, actually you need more than double the amount of words just to TRY to convey the scenic meaning. In one line of lyrics, just in one line of lyrics. Because, yes, the context is so important. Damn.
All and all, if you have read this wall of text, I thank you. In fact, I should be thanking you for these videos anywayz. Cheers, man.
P.S. Oh yah, the story of the lyricist is ... wow. Some artistes are genuine human beings who are indeed heroes~!
好听 谢谢分享
我最喜歡聽他的shall we talk... 聽了會想哭，感動
專業分析 👍👍👍
thanks， A more deeply understanding way of this song
And I think you have a deep understanding of Chinese pop music, which also proves that you are a Chinese speaker and speak Chinese very well.
幼儿园专属歌曲了 我儿子和他的小伙伴都爱这首歌
For English version. Shaun Gibson has the best version so far in my opinion. A British singer who lives in China atm. Do have a look please …
任何一首经典歌曲，背后都有一个浸入灵魂的感情，致敬所有没有被光照到的英雄
字幕有英有中 已訂閱👍👍
我很欣赏这位joe的分析解白
结果跑去他频道却找不着完整视频😂
感谢上传
孤勇者 注定会成为新一代经典让人永远传唱。 因为满足所有的元素， 情感， 极具节奏感 ， 词曲配合，歌词富有哲理，这道歌就是一首现代诗。
意外了，这首歌曲很单调，注定口水😅😅😅
Joe 中文说的真棒👍加油
Joe很用心啊！！！！
As a Chinese Canadian, this song both lyric and theme particularlly hit me hard, there had been series of successful song that has multi language version adopt to the same theme. Imagine Dragon's Enemey is a very good song, but it does not hit me at the core like 孤勇者. It is the same theme, it had the same story to tell, but Eason told it better thru just his vocal and the good lyric and music compuser.
希望有機會拍一期
茄子蛋的 愛情你比我想的閣較偉大
閩南語歌曲 有九爺喜歡的吉他solo哦！
九爷诠释大白那段太到位，大赞
Eason -200 分 because I love Eason Chan 😁😆😍
Joe - 90 分。 他学中文了， 很棒，加油💪🏻
Sander - 100 💯 thank you for produce such a good video to promote Asian music.
希望下一次你会 介绍 李克勤 from HK and people have call him Hi-Fi Vocal Sound. His have a very good voice. You may watch 我是歌手的《我不会唱歌》
谢谢你用单车结束呀 瞬间泪目 在摆脱Paranoia和Truma的路上。哈哈加油！
不错啊！！！！谢谢
谢谢很喜欢
nice！非常棒的視頻製作，致敬🫡
Joe好厉害
3个100分，一个给奕迅，一个给九爷，最后一个给你，很棒的一集乐评！
我就不同意你的说法,你为什么不给杨家成评分,人家唱的时候还用电风扇在前面吹头发凹造型来着
@@user-zs5jg9gt1k 谢谢你看重我的评分，不过很不好意思，我不能受理你的“不同意”，因为你的杨家成不是这影片的重点。望谅解。
@@hts2196 格局🤙
@@fire-bn5hz 幽默👎
我喜歡高音的激昂、美聲的技巧，清澈乾淨的聲音。
但更喜歡，低沉豐厚，宛若細聲訴說故事餘韻的聲音。陳奕迅和Adele是我個人最喜歡的。
Especially those who came out when it started in the beginning like 2020....you really dunno what u were facing with but can easily get infected...heros👍
Joe爷看的总是特别细节，看他解说后，一首歌就更完整
感觉Joe就是那种懂得很多，有话就说，人特别真诚，分享自己的感受/评论的时候也是很有道理，而且每首歌都很认真，而且他特别说明了陈奕迅唱出了这首歌的感情，我觉得特别认同
满分，超级棒
谢谢你！
谢谢！！！