Elden Ring's STRONGEST Weapon is... a Shield?! | The SCIENCE of Elden Ring

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 04. 2022
  • SUBSCRIBE to NEVER miss a Theory! ► goo.gl/kQWHkJ
    Theorists, the channel is FINALLY covering the most popular game right now... Elden Ring. Austin is OBSESSED and had a topic he needed to cover. What is the strongest weapon in Elden Ring and why is it the shield? Get ready to boot up your Soulsborne game and start whacking your enemies to death. Take it away Austin!
    Join The SCIENCE on Patreon ► / thescienceyt
    Want to join in the SCIENCE discussion? ►► discord.gg/theSCIENCE
    Game Theories:
    The Tragedy of Deltarune (Undertale) ► bit.ly/2PxobaR
    Mario's LUNAR APOCALYPSE!! ►► bit.ly/2FRgd4Y
    How DEADLY Is Mario's Bob-Omb? ►► bit.ly/2GnkRLK
    What is a Kirby? The SCIENTIFIC PROOF! ► bit.ly/2GnPP6t
    More The SCIENCE!
    How To SURVIVE A Nuclear Fallout! ► bit.ly/2Aaeo1s
    MONIKA: Google's Newest Creation! ►► bit.ly/2G3uifh
    Minecraft Diamonds DECODED! ►► bit.ly/2IHqk0n
    The Move That BROKE Pokemon! ►► bit.ly/2JCwEHP
    #EldenRing #DarkSouls #Bloodborne #Souldborne #EldenRingWeapons #EldenRingTips #FromSoftware #Theory #TheScience #GameTheory
  • Hry

Komentáře • 2,6K

  • @unironicallylikesranger7122
    @unironicallylikesranger7122 Před 2 lety +1287

    The better solution you asked for: the player character model is listed as 1.7 meters in game. Ask Zullie the Witch

  • @potatochipclips
    @potatochipclips Před 2 lety +1125

    I like how Austin has taken up the mantle of how old game theory was. Not as much ARG and deep dive into lore but more based in math and real world physics. I like both and I think both forms are crucial to game theory but it is nice that there is still a space for science as well as lore based theories on this channel.

    • @Amrylin1337
      @Amrylin1337 Před 2 lety +38

      I mean...at the end of the day the "science" based stuff is just an excuse to play with math. Because no single observation about a fictional world is relevant. At all. To anything. Where as lore is investigative of things that actually can be confirmed or denied and failing that, at least are within the realm of possibility. It's like, "The secret father of X is Y!" while "This thing is secretly a nuclear bomb's worth of energy!" with the latter being....well....random, frankly.

    • @TheUltimateMachineGod
      @TheUltimateMachineGod Před 2 lety +2

      @@Amrylin1337 You mean the former not the latter.

    • @arkanforiusdaemyar662
      @arkanforiusdaemyar662 Před 2 lety +53

      @@Amrylin1337 "An excuse to play with math" is one of the oldest and most sacred motivations for doing anything.

    • @whisperinwind87
      @whisperinwind87 Před 2 lety +4

      this coment is making me want to rewatch old matt pat videos, he is one of my first subscriptions and the only one I'm still subscribed to

    • @Amrylin1337
      @Amrylin1337 Před 2 lety +1

      @@TheUltimateMachineGod No, I mean the latter. Because I chose the latter thing as being random. Because it is the most speculative and random thing between the two.

  • @tiktokgirls9001
    @tiktokgirls9001 Před 2 lety +395

    Imagine how broken the Hylian Sheild would be if a normal one is that broken.

    • @clampfan101
      @clampfan101 Před 2 lety +6

      @S0cksnD0gs I think that was the point.

    • @Zenoferrum
      @Zenoferrum Před 2 lety +7

      I'd guess the stats would be something on par with the fingerprint shield. But magic based instead of pure physical resistance. It gives a bit less melee blocking power but like the fingerprint, gives a 90-100% block against magical attacks. You probably couldn't use it as a weapon like the fingerprint but it has a much more versatile block.

    • @nenmaster5218
      @nenmaster5218 Před rokem +1

      @@Zenoferrum Can you recommend me Matpat-like Channel where i can learn while having a Blast?

  • @NashiHeartSoulSpirit
    @NashiHeartSoulSpirit Před 2 lety +434

    Question: If Radhan learned how to use gravity magic to ride his horse, does that mean that his swords could potentially be lighter? or worse, heavier?

    • @Zakariyasen
      @Zakariyasen Před 2 lety +69

      What if he makes them lighter while he is holding it and then when he gets them moving fast he made them heavier?

    • @arnowisp6244
      @arnowisp6244 Před rokem +21

      Weight is simply Mass Pulled by Gravity.
      Swinging a Sword is about Momentum and Inertia and those are affected by mass not weight.

    • @rasputin2750
      @rasputin2750 Před rokem +5

      well more likely than not, while the weight would be reduced making it easier for Radahn to wield them, the mass/density of the blades would still be as big and therefore it would carry the same punch regardless.

    • @k1ng757
      @k1ng757 Před rokem +3

      @@Zakariyasen theres an anime character that use gravity he made his weapon light but when hitting you he can make it heavy

    • @diakounknown1225
      @diakounknown1225 Před rokem +3

      So either way, the shield is a god

  • @jstar3382
    @jstar3382 Před 2 lety +663

    I would say that a gargoyle leaping attack with halberd is probably the hardest hitting thing. Not in game, but real life-wise

    • @VergilBratwurst918
      @VergilBratwurst918 Před 2 lety +10

      @Willy on Wheels shut

    • @Crabgar
      @Crabgar Před 2 lety +6

      maybe that flying dragon attack where it swoops down at you

    • @burritojoe5040
      @burritojoe5040 Před 2 lety +5

      Funny comment bro. But dammmm there are so many bots.

    • @matthewwriter9539
      @matthewwriter9539 Před 2 lety +8

      No, the hardest hitting thing in real life is when your family doesn't want you to come to Thanksgiving dinner because they like your ex-wife more than they like you.

    • @matthewwriter9539
      @matthewwriter9539 Před 2 lety +3

      @Tsuchinoko!? I didn't even have to make this up, this is just my life.
      The day I came over to my wife's house to sign the divorce papers was the day she told me that she was going to start dating my youngest sibling...also the only members of my family who love me are my nieces and nephews, but I am not allowed to talk to them because their mother, my sister, hates me, and when I tried to apologize for what I did wrong, she took the apology as a personal attack.

  • @magic3734
    @magic3734 Před 2 lety +543

    Imagine how broken the Hylian Sheild would be if a normal one is that broken

    • @benito23453
      @benito23453 Před 2 lety +1

      Жжжжжз

    • @benito23453
      @benito23453 Před 2 lety

      Шшшшшшш

    • @bazzfromthebackground3696
      @bazzfromthebackground3696 Před 2 lety +23

      The mirror shield would be godlike in the Soulsborne verse.

    • @nexidal9656
      @nexidal9656 Před 2 lety +12

      @@bazzfromthebackground3696
      Average physical defense
      Complete magical defense
      Unique skill: Reflect
      →for a while, blocking a sorcery/incantation will automatically bounce it back at the caster.

    • @bazzfromthebackground3696
      @bazzfromthebackground3696 Před 2 lety +2

      @@nexidal9656 average nothing, that thing blocks At LEAST 90% physical. It's only a little smaller than the hylian shield

  • @TheAdvertisement
    @TheAdvertisement Před rokem +77

    Love how the character model actually is 1.7 meters and Austin just managed to guess almost on point.

  • @LordBloodySoul
    @LordBloodySoul Před 2 lety +127

    This just makes me consider doing an "only-shield" run xD

    • @dizzyx7
      @dizzyx7 Před 2 lety +10

      Surprisingly a maxed shield has a decent attack rating, they’re probably amazing

    • @Guardian_Arias
      @Guardian_Arias Před 2 lety +3

      @@dizzyx7 they are, in many ways, some of the most broken weapons. there has been several patches trying to fix them. starting with fixing, barricade, then erdtree greatshield, followed by the greatshield talisman, carian retaliation. fingerprint shield can do more dmg than a colossal sword plus it inflicts madness and can be infused with any infusion with zero loss to madness build up

    • @HexagonThatReallyLikesVinegar
      @HexagonThatReallyLikesVinegar Před rokem +3

      Shield Crash + Bleed infusion.

    • @danielcofield8869
      @danielcofield8869 Před rokem +2

      THE WALL

    • @bimorepolish6866
      @bimorepolish6866 Před rokem +1

      proceeds to die to the parkour for the finger print shield

  • @Kaspertje
    @Kaspertje Před 2 lety +53

    Don't ever forget the actual final boss, William Afton.

    • @MbitaChizi
      @MbitaChizi Před 2 lety

      Dont read my name!!!

    • @remuslebeau6570
      @remuslebeau6570 Před 2 lety

      How many times do we have to teach you this lesson, old man?!

    • @appol2584
      @appol2584 Před 2 lety +2

      I have never seen three bots attack a single comment all at once

    • @Kaspertje
      @Kaspertje Před 2 lety +1

      @@appol2584 im under attack

  • @L337N1NJ4L1NK
    @L337N1NJ4L1NK Před 2 lety +134

    I'm just gonna point out that Radahn's swords are made of a metal that fell from the stars and is presumably harder than iron or steel. Additionally, Radahn uses gravity magic to enhance the weight of the sword when he swings them; that is what the purple effects on the swords are and why swings coated in the purple effect deal more damage/break more stamina.
    As for a ruler? I've got an easy one for you. The model for the Bastard Sword appears to be a reproduction of the Hanwei Bastard Sword designed by Paul Chen. It looks exactly like it, down to the little bump in the handle that would help you with a two handed grip. This is a physical object you can buy and as such comes with very specific measurements.

    • @Lissa2355
      @Lissa2355 Před 2 lety +5

      I was so sad when he said he was using Radahn as mesurement... that man just ignores physics

    • @douglasmarshall6949
      @douglasmarshall6949 Před 2 lety +1

      so basically, you're just a smear on the ground at that point

    • @L337N1NJ4L1NK
      @L337N1NJ4L1NK Před 2 lety +6

      @@douglasmarshall6949 Based on the calcs assuming they are steel and just going off of regular speed that is already a given.
      With the addition of gravity magic and more dense metals? You aren't a smear on the ground, you're a cloud of mist in the air.

    • @douglasmarshall6949
      @douglasmarshall6949 Před 2 lety

      @@L337N1NJ4L1NK I stand corrected

    • @RunicRasol
      @RunicRasol Před 2 lety +4

      @@Lissa2355 He doesn't IGNORE physics. He worked very hard, and studied like a madman at a magic college so he could explicitly tell physics to sit down & shut up. All so he could ride his BFF horse without crushing the poor thing.

  • @ezezezez5300
    @ezezezez5300 Před 2 lety +141

    “I’m sure there’s someone stronger than him that swings way faster”
    *I am Malenia, blade of Miquella*

    • @martinfossatti2626
      @martinfossatti2626 Před 2 lety +17

      For that to be true her tiny sword would need to be made out of black holes to be as heavy as raddan's

    • @lambdaphi8163
      @lambdaphi8163 Před 2 lety +12

      *roars in fire giant*

    • @Zakariyasen
      @Zakariyasen Před 2 lety +6

      Malekith, The Black Blade maybe?

    • @Mortomi
      @Mortomi Před 2 lety +13

      @@martinfossatti2626 sword isn’t as big, but does a 360* turn in 0.05 seconds.

    • @LOWB90
      @LOWB90 Před 2 lety +7

      Malenia just cuts you like sushi chef does to a fish, rather than crushing you with the gravity of stars (because during that fight, to his last breath, he holds up STARS). If Radahn became unblockable in a future patch, I would not be sad, I'd just go, yeah that makes sense.

  • @parleyeon7951
    @parleyeon7951 Před 2 lety +157

    For the measurements: you could've used size of your sword. Swords had usually very similar sizes. Just need to remember that, despite it's name, "longsword" in ER is definitely NOT a longsword. Heck, if you needed something less confusing in name, You could've used Flamberge (which I think historically has the least amount of length variation).

    • @erurainon6842
      @erurainon6842 Před 2 lety +2

      Theres still way too big diferences. Even 1cm will mess whole measuring.

    • @parleyeon7951
      @parleyeon7951 Před 2 lety +9

      @@erurainon6842 I'd argue it's still better than just approximation using human height which can vary even more.
      Also, upon further reading, it's perhaps belter to use zweihander as a ruler, since they had up to 213 cm of lenth and we know that zwei in ER is both very long AND very heavy (historically zweihanders weighed no more than 4 kilos), so it's safe ti assume that it is the aforementioned 213 cm

    • @TheMk114
      @TheMk114 Před 2 lety +2

      Same with the katana. They usually have less variance than the longswords.

    • @keeganwullaert4996
      @keeganwullaert4996 Před 2 lety +1

      @@parleyeon7951 to be fair human height approxomation works surprisingly well because in souls games the player character is 1.7m

    • @HexagonThatReallyLikesVinegar
      @HexagonThatReallyLikesVinegar Před rokem +1

      It's more like a mediumsword.

  • @sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep
    @sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep Před 2 lety +141

    The fact that Redahn knows gravity magic probably means that he can make his sword heavier when he swings and lighter for the recoil of the sword up his arm to a MASSIVE degree. How truly hard he hits, we'll never know, but all I know is that this is a HEAVY underestimate.
    Cool video, though!

    • @Ramsey276one
      @Ramsey276one Před rokem

      You reminded me of fantasy novel that had a sword designed with a ... sliding counterweight?
      The point is, that thing on the sword allows the wielding character to pull off some Fatality inducing swings!

    • @tandemcharge5114
      @tandemcharge5114 Před rokem

      Note: Gravity does not in any way increase or decrease the momentum of an object

    • @sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep
      @sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep Před rokem

      @@tandemcharge5114 Sure, momentum can help, but a heavy object with the same momentum as small object will have more kinetic force. My theory may be a little shaky at best (I am no science major) but I will try to defend it.

  • @whiled
    @whiled Před 2 lety +761

    If you want a measurement you can reliably take, death falls happen at exactly 20m in game, and damaging falls at 16m. You can use those as a point of measurement by finding a cliffside that is on the edge of being 20m. For more info, you can view: czcams.com/video/Fm-QA4rZPYk/video.html

    • @MbitaChizi
      @MbitaChizi Před 2 lety

      Dont read my name!!!

    • @ZMowlcher
      @ZMowlcher Před 2 lety +13

      Or use a rainbow stone

    • @fergusofdalibor4264
      @fergusofdalibor4264 Před 2 lety +3

      Yes this here. You are right

    • @snowylynx36
      @snowylynx36 Před 2 lety +1

      The goat has arrived

    • @MouseTC
      @MouseTC Před 2 lety +14

      Alternatively, Zullie has confirmed that the height of the player character is 1.7 m (which is super close to the value Austin uses here).

  • @darktimber13
    @darktimber13 Před 2 lety +38

    In terms of a measurement metric, I would suggest using wolves. Mundane wolves are common all over the lands between and they have nearly the same coloring as a grey wolf in our world.

  • @manvslife271
    @manvslife271 Před 2 lety +42

    In terms of measurement, modding is the way to go. Souls games give coordinates in meters, and the player character is 1.7m tall. So by using cheat engine you can freeze an enemy's AI and then teleport from one side of something to the other, and check the coordinates to measure a distance.

  • @moletack2937
    @moletack2937 Před 2 lety +56

    There might be multiple ways to get accurate measurements in this game.
    1. the waypoint markers use meters to tell you how far you are
    2. You could reference the previous souls titles if they have an accurate measurement and take the measurement from patches or the basilisk since they are the same in both series.

    • @eeshmegeesh8245
      @eeshmegeesh8245 Před 2 lety

      There is also boars in the game that would probably be an acurate size compared to the real world.

  • @nintendope8837
    @nintendope8837 Před 2 lety +207

    You know what they say.. the greatest offense is a great defense

    • @R.MaxumOff
      @R.MaxumOff Před 2 lety

      Creepy Videos are here my friends, 😱😱😱 come and see ↖️...

    • @EchoVA
      @EchoVA Před 2 lety +2

      The best defense is an even better defense

  • @protagonistical
    @protagonistical Před 2 lety +70

    Austin: *excitedly talking about numbers and mathematical terms*
    Me: *just nodding along like* "I like your funny words, magic man."

    • @DragonfireSL
      @DragonfireSL Před 2 lety +3

      Me who is just proud that I know what Radians are

    • @iciclecold2991
      @iciclecold2991 Před 2 lety +1

      He taught me what Newtons are! Again. I kinda forgot for a while there ...

    • @WorldWeave
      @WorldWeave Před rokem +1

      Me: “I don’t know what you’re talking about…I’m just here for the inevitable shoe drop”

    • @WorldWeave
      @WorldWeave Před rokem +1

      Me: “I don’t know what you’re talking about…I’m just here for the inevitable shoe drop”

  • @allynpierson3128
    @allynpierson3128 Před 2 lety +21

    I’m always so happy to see Austin’s videos pop up. The science and math is so interesting! And a nice change of pace for the usual LOOOOORE.

  • @fnf9607
    @fnf9607 Před 2 lety +3986

    I’ve always thought that Austin should record a regular game Theory video and MatPat should record a The Science of video. I think that would be cool.

    • @benito23453
      @benito23453 Před 2 lety +10

      MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):
      czcams.com/video/cAQxPSwM4h0/video.html

    • @kagephenex
      @kagephenex Před 2 lety +169

      It would work as an april fools joke

    • @R.MaxumOff
      @R.MaxumOff Před 2 lety

      Creepy Videos are here my friends, 😱😱😱 come and see ↖️..

    • @SoggyCoffeeAddict
      @SoggyCoffeeAddict Před 2 lety +73

      100% calling it now, if this gets seen. You'll know because they'll do a double release to make this happen

    • @MrMemelord00
      @MrMemelord00 Před 2 lety +31

      That'd make a fun opposite day

  • @FlyntofRWBY
    @FlyntofRWBY Před 2 lety +1015

    “Spoilers for one boss in the game.”
    Me who’s only beaten 2 bosses cause I suck: Dammit 😩

    • @dvotion5819
      @dvotion5819 Před 2 lety +23

      Me whose never played a souls game and never plan to,
      bring it on

    • @R.MaxumOff
      @R.MaxumOff Před 2 lety

      Creepy Videos are here my friends, 😱😱😱 come and see ↖️..

    • @Bragemaster
      @Bragemaster Před 2 lety +1

      ayyyyy

    • @pootisgaming9095
      @pootisgaming9095 Před 2 lety +7

      Me who has no money to buy any Dark souls game: bring It on

    • @f0olk94
      @f0olk94 Před 2 lety

      Hey, never thought i'd bump into you here. I've known your channel since i started watching rwby lol

  • @logomorph3493
    @logomorph3493 Před rokem +3

    Rip austin

  • @obfirmoviatorem
    @obfirmoviatorem Před 2 lety +17

    About the pixel measurements Austin
    I think you should focus on the roads
    Specially the bricks of said road
    Some of the architecture in this game have real world inspirations

  • @goosegamer8969
    @goosegamer8969 Před 2 lety +68

    according to lore radahns swords are likley made of magic meteorite not iron because the sword art is gravity magic and it has an int requirment. interestingly radahn himself also knows gravity magic he learned so he didnt crush his own poor horse so its also likey he is using gravity to manipulate the weight of his sword as well your estimates are likely a little under but im sure you knew all this >_< cause you just mention the gravity magic while i was typing... good vid

    • @believe2000
      @believe2000 Před 2 lety

      ah, Leonard.

    • @russiancheems2275
      @russiancheems2275 Před 2 lety +1

      Still keeps mass. The equation for force uses MASS, not weight

    • @ttchme9816
      @ttchme9816 Před 2 lety

      @@russiancheems2275 physics students just face palmed their face so bad lol

  • @nemisisarcher8213
    @nemisisarcher8213 Před 2 lety +65

    I beat Rodahn pre patch with a pair of daggers (before I knew bleed ashes of wars buffed the bleed stat) and quick step. I died many many times. But I did it!

    • @tangytim6699
      @tangytim6699 Před 2 lety

      www.youtube.com/watchrickroll it is here finally phew

    • @vhalrougelarfouxe
      @vhalrougelarfouxe Před 2 lety

      It is fun! I also did my own with just a Caestus and it's so fun. It was after he was restored to his old glory. Here's my gameplay, if you want to see it.
      czcams.com/video/qHjR0lOxn_4/video.html

    • @Staramitas9027
      @Staramitas9027 Před 2 lety

      ..Sorry, *Pre* Patch?

  • @joss247
    @joss247 Před 2 lety +1

    We NEED a book theorists channel

  • @Sdogofdoom
    @Sdogofdoom Před 2 lety +7

    Sadly, radahn abuses gravity magic and even has it imbued in his swords. Any weight attributed to his swords could change according to his will, just like how he uses his magic to allow his horse to hold him up.

  • @sadeknight9112
    @sadeknight9112 Před 2 lety +472

    Just to note: the Radahn we fight is significantly weaker than his true strength as he is riddled with Scarlet Rot, half starved, insane, and holding back LITERAL STARS with his gravity magic. Also his swords are made of Tungsten because I say so

    • @suchapoet6504
      @suchapoet6504 Před 2 lety +15

      Yeah wish he thought of this

    • @mementomori3665
      @mementomori3665 Před 2 lety +22

      Isn't his "holding back stars" thing a casual and passive feat? Always thought this way, considering that, you know, he is insane.

    • @stormshadow5382
      @stormshadow5382 Před 2 lety +22

      His swords are made of same meteor rock that gravity stone, gravity fan, and other gravity based things are made of and it's way tougher than iron or steel

    • @ForeverOdd
      @ForeverOdd Před 2 lety +19

      @@stormshadow5382 Be fair, most meteors are just made of iron, or iron-nickle alloy. Steel made from it would just be steel.

    • @ThePcHeadedGuy
      @ThePcHeadedGuy Před 2 lety +6

      @Ben 🅥 go back to gmail and spam random emails instead of youtube comments

  • @SirKrrrapsalot
    @SirKrrrapsalot Před 2 lety +57

    could you use one of the small crab enemies as a "ruler" by comparing it to a large earth crab like the coconut crab?

    • @savvythedivineyethuggable7493
      @savvythedivineyethuggable7493 Před 2 lety +6

      As it turns out: commenter Whiled said that a fatal fall in game happens at 20 meters, and a fall that only damages you starts at 16 meters.

  • @calebborah1404
    @calebborah1404 Před 2 lety +1

    7:51 I heard the background music and thought it sounded familiar, THATS BECAUSE I WAS JUST LISTENING TO MARS THE BRINGER OF WAR RIGHT BEFORE I OPENED THIS VIDEO. I love Gustav Holst and I love Game Theory and Austin, great addition to the video

  • @Nivolasy
    @Nivolasy Před 2 lety +1

    Nothing hits harder then being told you are maidenless.

  • @DarkRevolution
    @DarkRevolution Před 2 lety +148

    Well if you really think about, a shield can defend you AND you can use it as a weapon. So I would say it's a perfect item to use against the orphanage children.

  • @karmaaddiction9356
    @karmaaddiction9356 Před 2 lety +100

    Oh yeah, you also have to remember that in the lore, he mastered gravity magic, so they probably weigh next to nothing for him. That is also why he can still ride his horse and why he becomes a live meteor mid fight

    • @activeaxolotl2746
      @activeaxolotl2746 Před 2 lety +8

      And I was just thinking that the horse was god incarnate

  • @mopthemop3319
    @mopthemop3319 Před 2 lety +1

    Austin back with SCIENCE (and blue thumbnail text)

  • @thedepression950
    @thedepression950 Před 2 lety

    8:11 thats one way to compliment someone for their training

  • @minecafe
    @minecafe Před 2 lety +5

    11:54 "It get's ripped from it's socket! Just no arm now! It's over there!"
    This is why I watch Austin! XD love it!

  • @tale7955
    @tale7955 Před 2 lety +11

    This gave me "Bofuri: I Don't Want to Get Hurt, so I'll Max Out My Defense" vibes.

  • @lionelhutz4186
    @lionelhutz4186 Před 2 lety +22

    I love how you included Holst's Mars. That's probably my favorite "not imperial march, imperial march".

  • @AaronXCVI
    @AaronXCVI Před 2 lety +5

    When the sword connects with the shield, radahn would also absorb some of the kinetic energy.
    Also Radahn's gravity magic allows a giant to ride a half dead horse. (that gravity magic must be reducing the weight of him and probably his swords by 50 - 100x)

  • @gatchu2246
    @gatchu2246 Před 2 lety +13

    4:35 Measure using the Zweihander as a frame of reference. That seems like a very specific sword with a direct real-world counterpart and uniform length.

    • @kitcw
      @kitcw Před 2 lety

      yeah i was gonna say that, a zweihander is much more specific than just ‘longsword’

  • @ChEeSeInYoUrEpAnTs
    @ChEeSeInYoUrEpAnTs Před 2 lety +214

    I think the only reliable measurement the game gives you is with fall damage registering. At a 16m fall you'll lose 30% health increasing linearly to 50% loss of health as you approach 20m. At 20m death is instant. You can hop of a brick wall or something, register the damage taken to find the height of the wall, and then work from there.

    • @lautimartinez6341
      @lautimartinez6341 Před 2 lety +5

      Doesn't your dex stat modify your fall damage resistance?

    • @gatchu2246
      @gatchu2246 Před 2 lety +12

      @@lautimartinez6341 It changes how much damage you take, not the height at which you actually take damage.

    • @user-iq3jn2vk2f
      @user-iq3jn2vk2f Před 2 lety

      @ronza 3 war

  • @Zaney_
    @Zaney_ Před 2 lety +10

    you could take a sword like.. the zewihander that exists and real life and approximate the size of radahn's sword like that. Might not be 1:1 with the irl and in game version but probably more consistent than the average human height metric.

  • @ShowEmDigits
    @ShowEmDigits Před 2 lety +1

    The Rising of a shield hero Crossover??

  • @Donnerwamp
    @Donnerwamp Před 2 lety +36

    Just out of curiosity, couldn't you extract the model of the sword from the game, use it as a .stl and push it through a slicer to let it calculate the volume at a certain scale? That way you'd get a much more accurate estimate for the true volume and weight of the sword.

  • @Mortomi
    @Mortomi Před 2 lety +691

    4:25 - Ok, so, for future reference, ask a souls modder. The souls engine actually has its units of measurement in meters.
    (also the player character is 1.7m)
    Edit - Also radahn’s swords are made out of “black steel”, you can read that in the description of the swords. (Ungalvanized steel)

    • @JetDarkKnight44
      @JetDarkKnight44 Před 2 lety +22

      1.7m is the average human height, so yeah

    • @Matt-dn5jc
      @Matt-dn5jc Před 2 lety +9

      And here I thought souls protagonists were all short.

    • @raggedy61
      @raggedy61 Před 2 lety +12

      And here I was thinking, could you just use the average height of a galpagos tortoise?

    • @LOWB90
      @LOWB90 Před 2 lety +11

      Wouldn't be surprised if the blades has some meteoric metal as well

    • @PlantFromDiscord
      @PlantFromDiscord Před 2 lety +2

      Dammit I was gonna suggest using the size of a zweihander and how long they are on average...even though thats the exacy same thing he was already doing...
      I really like the zweihander that would have been so cool

  • @Zuul-cv3xq
    @Zuul-cv3xq Před 10 měsíci +2

    Certain named swords like the claymore and zweihander are real. I'm not sure if they appear in elden ring, but still.

  • @BreakerX42
    @BreakerX42 Před 2 lety

    This gives me flashbacks to Mats theory about For Honor

  • @BlankPicketSign
    @BlankPicketSign Před 2 lety +283

    Suggestion for Messurement, There are modding tools that allow you to actually measure things in the game down to the Centimeter. Zullie The Witch, a very amazing CZcamsr of Souls-Games, has used these tools to measure all sorts of objects! I'm POSSITIVE She would be thrilled to help you if you reach out to her and give her some more exposure. For Example: czcams.com/video/tjDd2q2fcAw/video.html

    • @bnanaman7134
      @bnanaman7134 Před 2 lety +9

      I immediately came into the comments to say this, but you beat me to it! Zullie the Witch could totally find the size of them.

    • @Xedrie
      @Xedrie Před 2 lety

      wow

    • @h4ss4n25
      @h4ss4n25 Před 2 lety

      My idea was just to use the sword…

    • @mateter5097
      @mateter5097 Před 2 lety

      Would love to see these two collab, since Zullie does a bunch of this stuff anyways.

    • @SobeCrunkMonster
      @SobeCrunkMonster Před 2 lety

      after several years of working on these kinds of videos, you would think that he would know that. He probably got left on read by zullie irl and didnt wanna reach out for tech advice lol

  • @MarsBarszs
    @MarsBarszs Před 2 lety +48

    Interesting thought: for measurement, use the crab. What if you’re just incredibly small in elden ring?

    • @TheKnowledgeableGamer
      @TheKnowledgeableGamer Před 2 lety +5

      thats what i was thinking

    • @Zakariyasen
      @Zakariyasen Před 2 lety +6

      sheep, eagles, maybe some weapons that actually existed like the Uchigatana which is a real kind of katana that has a standard range of length (60cm to 70cm)

    • @tortillachips3911
      @tortillachips3911 Před 2 lety +1

      LOL

    • @Seraphim_1172
      @Seraphim_1172 Před rokem +2

      But... there's tiny crabs in the game too...

  • @sebastiansanchez4207
    @sebastiansanchez4207 Před 2 lety +1

    Pls do a theory on Tunic

  • @Jaricko
    @Jaricko Před rokem +1

    I feel like this is just Link blocking a Lynel but with an elden twist added to it.

  • @naruspheal1831
    @naruspheal1831 Před 2 lety +14

    Ya know austin the issue with science videos about Radahn is how his gravity magic affects the weight and speed of his swords, he may even use it to make it hit even harder

    • @victor_creator
      @victor_creator Před 2 lety +1

      The point still stands

    • @naruspheal1831
      @naruspheal1831 Před 2 lety +1

      @@victor_creator oh i personally love explaining it away with science, but Radahn uses a heavy amount of gravity magic at all times so it would be unwise not to consider the fact he might be using it with his swords

    • @victor_creator
      @victor_creator Před 2 lety

      @@naruspheal1831 I'm not dismissing that fact. I am simply pointing out that Austin's conclusion is still valid, whether or not Radahn uses gravity magic to hit harder.
      The only scenario where Austin's conclusion doesn't work is if his magic is being used to weaken his attacks, and at that point, Radahn may as well not be fighting.

    • @naruspheal1831
      @naruspheal1831 Před 2 lety

      @@victor_creator but it is weird he still can take fall damage lmao, prob just an oversight by the devs

  • @bplatinumpaladin
    @bplatinumpaladin Před 2 lety +70

    Your standard Longsword is 90 CM in length. Meaning that your character is roughly 210 CM (pythagorean), so that may help you.

    • @bplatinumpaladin
      @bplatinumpaladin Před 2 lety +3

      @Gioacchino Sessa very true.

    • @CrowXIII
      @CrowXIII Před 2 lety +1

      longswords in Elden Ring are on the stubbier side, definitely shorter than average

    • @bplatinumpaladin
      @bplatinumpaladin Před 2 lety +3

      @@CrowXIII so probably around... 85 CM, to prevent it from being considered a short sword?

    • @nexidal9656
      @nexidal9656 Před 2 lety

      And, according the the national jousting association: In Pluvinel's "Menaige Royal" of 1623, the proper size lance to use when jousting for rings or the quintain was 10 ft, 7 inches, much smaller than the lance used for man-to-man jousting. These lances were also equipped with aLance vamplate, a funnel shaped cup covering the area where the knights held the lance, protecting the hand.
      So the jousting lance found in early game could be used as measure.

  • @brxbrx_p
    @brxbrx_p Před rokem +1

    Is Austin getting his own channel!?? THE Science theory?

  • @DrRank
    @DrRank Před 2 lety +1

    "If you must make a choice between a sword or a shield, take the shield." - Gobber, How to Train Your Dragon

  • @AlbertusSalvatierra
    @AlbertusSalvatierra Před 2 lety +10

    I’m just happy duel-wielding maxed-upgraded Hand’s of Malenia with some life-sapping talisman 💅

  • @thaias9654
    @thaias9654 Před 2 lety +8

    Me: doesn't want Elden Ring spoilers
    Austin: "spoilers for 1 boss"
    Me: "oh no! Anyway"

  • @stealthcheck
    @stealthcheck Před 2 lety

    11:36 Swaggersouls?

  • @freeziac
    @freeziac Před 2 lety

    Nice, love the Mars music from The Planets in the background.

  • @wob_gaming1232
    @wob_gaming1232 Před 2 lety +13

    Huh. Never would’ve thought he would make a video on Elden Ring shields lol

    • @R.MaxumOff
      @R.MaxumOff Před 2 lety

      Creepy Videos are here my friends, 😱😱😱 come and see ↖️.

  • @zStarrrr
    @zStarrrr Před 2 lety +4

    There’s a sword that is unblock-able rip shields

  • @CrystallineLore
    @CrystallineLore Před 2 lety +15

    High melee damage reduction shields have long been one of the difficulty sliders for the game. Often a class starts with it and/or there is one very early in the game. That's part of the reason why the tried and true knight build works for a lot of players; other builds tend to be more risk/reward.
    Lately, however, a lot of the tougher bosses do punish reliance on shields and sort of nudge players to being more proactive or depending on dodge, and magic bosses in particular do that. Radahn isn't that big of a deal though. Most of the mainline bosses aren't.

  • @lamechseffects
    @lamechseffects Před 2 lety +8

    That reminds me: aren't weapons like longswords, broadswords, and claymores constant in every knight-age type game? I believe those sizes are normally static.
    Can you use those as a measurement?

  • @GamingwolfZJ
    @GamingwolfZJ Před 2 lety +65

    Rising of the Shield Hero fans: “You all are finding this out now?”

    • @troger6895
      @troger6895 Před 2 lety +1

      I was looking for this comment lol

    • @Zombie-so6yd
      @Zombie-so6yd Před 2 lety +1

      @@troger6895 literally same

    • @VonWoodhyll
      @VonWoodhyll Před 2 lety

      There is a guy who did shield only run with Incantations and one of his techniques was basically a full body burning.

    • @insanitystrikesback3194
      @insanitystrikesback3194 Před 2 lety

      100% agree and man was this funny the holy shield keeping you from dying to a heavy as hell, fast as hell, gravity using pain in the neck for fighting.

    • @trinity_frost
      @trinity_frost Před 2 lety +1

      bofuri fans: pathetic

  • @fatimapina811
    @fatimapina811 Před 2 lety +102

    Gotta love trying to explain the science behind the dark fantasy world of Elden Ring. Only on Game Theory.

    • @thetrashman559
      @thetrashman559 Před 2 lety

      @@benito23453 brain burner?

    • @damyenhockman5440
      @damyenhockman5440 Před 2 lety

      No, other places as well. Kyle Hill did an analysis on whether the tree could be that big.

    • @aminulhussain2277
      @aminulhussain2277 Před 2 lety

      Science is the process of understanding the world around you, the world of Elden Ring operates on consistent logic so understanding is therefore possible.

    • @amirattamimi8765
      @amirattamimi8765 Před 2 lety +2

      AND AFTER ALL THAT MATH AND PHYSICS HE FORGOT MOMENT OF INERTIA!!!!

  • @Colossal...
    @Colossal... Před 2 lety +1

    There’s the shields Ive been waiting for. 5 years after the for honor video

  • @josephtillou4815
    @josephtillou4815 Před 2 lety

    I like the intro greeting both mortal and immortal. Feels very inclusive, thank you

  • @thepurplebox380
    @thepurplebox380 Před 2 lety +10

    In terms of calculating the weight of the sword: You can probably calculate a conversion factor for converting "equipment load" to kilograms using the "Iron Roundshield" item and the density of iron as a proxy. Then you can likely scale it up for Radahn's weapons based on their load.
    That's just a hypothesis though, a material science hypothesis!

  • @pacocuhh
    @pacocuhh Před 2 lety +5

    Great video! You almost lost me at the beginning when you didn’t say “Greetings, Tarnished”.

  • @limhx-6734
    @limhx-6734 Před 2 lety

    The Shield Hero was onto something

  • @logomorph3493
    @logomorph3493 Před rokem +1

    Now rise, tarnished.

  • @thecrazies4587
    @thecrazies4587 Před 2 lety +5

    Elden Ring, officially brought to you by Shield Hero.

  • @tobiasflohr3417
    @tobiasflohr3417 Před 2 lety +4

    4:35 i think using a sword that also exists in the real world as a ruler would be the best thing to do

  • @videoboy033
    @videoboy033 Před 2 lety

    my guy playing Mars Bringer of War!!! 7:45

  • @thelegendofzeeboix6970

    the editor did an amzing job! for never playing a soulsborn game. all support!

  • @jamezzz0035
    @jamezzz0035 Před 2 lety +3

    *”You are the shield behind which the city stands tall.”* - Commander Zavala, Titan Vanguard

  • @TacoTime2006
    @TacoTime2006 Před 2 lety +5

    I just started playing elden ring with my stepdad a week ago… This channel is terrifying.

  • @phantomda4kness415
    @phantomda4kness415 Před 2 lety

    You should talk about the meteor after the boss fight

  • @pyroshock3834
    @pyroshock3834 Před 2 lety +1

    Would have been lit if he used a Longsword or one of the weapons grounded in reality for his measurement

  • @LSDireWolf
    @LSDireWolf Před 2 lety +7

    Zullie the witch just released a video going over the size of the erdtree. She goes over some measurements from in game files so that may be worth looking into for future videos

  • @joaogarcia6170
    @joaogarcia6170 Před 2 lety +6

    About measuring, fromsoft measures in meters inside the game, zullie the black witch (youtuber) has a video where she determines the height of the Erdtree using that.

  • @EATMEGUD
    @EATMEGUD Před 2 lety

    ¨Im sure there is like someone more terrifying then him with bigger swords that are swung faster¨
    The foreshadowing to Maliketh

  • @karsten69
    @karsten69 Před rokem +2

    Since every action has an opposite and equal reaction, when you block one of these blows, the boss also experience that force.

  • @jimthegentleman2446
    @jimthegentleman2446 Před 2 lety +9

    The special collector's edition for Elden Ring comes with a real SWORD that exists in the game, look it up and you will find how big THAT sword is, and you can compare it to your ingame character's sword and thus height

  • @nevogolan6505
    @nevogolan6505 Před 2 lety +4

    One of the short swords in the game is an exact copy of a sword you can buy on Amazon. I can't remember which one but it can probably be used for pixel measurements

  • @estebatron9867
    @estebatron9867 Před 2 lety +1

    10:38 Then, are you sure that 20,000 newtons would be enough to launch a pineapple into space?

  • @bogdandamaschin9381
    @bogdandamaschin9381 Před 2 lety

    The greatsword is a reference to the sword from Berzerk. You find out bow big is that sword, you find out how big the elden ring sword is

  • @jaychirps
    @jaychirps Před 2 lety +5

    Ooo, nice! A theory video on Elden Ring? Yes please :)

    • @benito23453
      @benito23453 Před 2 lety

      MatPat is a brain burner!(Правдивое видео):
      czcams.com/video/cAQxPSwM4h0/video.html

  • @rynisthatboi4126
    @rynisthatboi4126 Před 2 lety +4

    I immediately thought of Galahad’s Shield. Ah yes, Mashu.

  • @omershaik6374
    @omershaik6374 Před 2 lety

    4:02 you have the complete works of shakespeare on your shelf? My man!

  • @menyatarigeny6833
    @menyatarigeny6833 Před 2 lety

    this week on Eldin Space Program, Radhan attempts to to catapult a fowl tarnished into the sun but fails due to a tiny iron plate he was holding

  • @govermet
    @govermet Před 2 lety +9

    Considering the height comparison, what about the eagles that can be found near cliffs, or mayb the sheep/goats.
    Otherwise in terms of even bigger bosses you will encounter one later, an enemy so big it will break the calculation on Radahn!

  • @VonWoodhyll
    @VonWoodhyll Před 2 lety +10

    I always wanted to see Austin do a video estimating what would be needed for the science to work. In that game reality.
    A shield that small can in reality not handle the force mass weight or speed of Radan blade or Radan himself. So for it to work at base level using humans as a standard means both the shield and human are superhuman but how much so?

  • @lukedavidson1505
    @lukedavidson1505 Před 2 lety

    For pixel measurement, I believe there are normal bears in the game (NOT runebears)

  • @thesavagebeast5846
    @thesavagebeast5846 Před rokem +1

    You could have used the sword as a pixel measurement ruler, idk if you can match a sword with the real world but its just a theory,
    A GAME THEORY!

  • @Crimson_Sun2486
    @Crimson_Sun2486 Před 2 lety +5

    From what I know, shields can actually be a sick strat if you combine a particular weapon skil that basically makes the shield much tougher with the guard counter attack that takes a big chunk out of a boss' invisible posture meter and equip an item that restores FP after a critical attack

  • @GunRunner106
    @GunRunner106 Před 2 lety +4

    radahan is shouted as the strongest of the demi gods, so take that as ya want.

  • @larynx46
    @larynx46 Před 2 lety

    8:36 "Garsh."

  • @HexagonThatReallyLikesVinegar

    Fun Fact: You can actually get a Ash of War called 'Cragblade' that replicates Radahn's move where he makes his swords have stone on them and then.