UPSC CSAT प्रदर्शन के बीच Mukherjee Nagar पहुंचा Lallantop, कागज दिखा अभ्यर्थियों ने क्या आरोप लगाए?
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 08. 2023
- LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
A group of candidates who appeared for the 2023 CSAT approached the CAT, seeking a reduction in the qualifying cut-off for CSAT paper from 33% to 23%. According to the applicants, the CSAT exam, as per the UPSC syllabus, is intended to test candidates' general aptitude and basic knowledge at the Class X level. However, they allege that the questions in the CSAT were beyond the prescribed syllabus and required a level of proficiency similar to that of the CAT and IIT JEE exams. The Lallantop went to Delhi's Mukherjee Nagar to talk to UPSC aspirants and they have shared their demands from UPSC and the government.
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Rahul
I am an engineer, but I think its unfair for non-engineering students if they are asking CAT level questions. I have seen a lot of students who were intelligent but couldn't take engineering due to their economical background....So indirectly its discriminatory against poor students.....
You know ground reality 🙌
Baki sab ka kisa number aagaya tab
Kya 😂😂😂 I am also Engineer but apko agar ek IAS officer banna hai to apko ye sab b ana hi chahiye haad hai yaar ab ni bana to hat ado ye kaha ka logic hai 12 me basic mechanical engineering subject ni padha to hata de usko b semester se gajab logic 😂😂😂😂
what do you mean "couldn't take engineering cause of their economical background" so my friends had nice financial condition right half of them are from bits pilani and vit vellore 😂😂😂😂
@@nilabhjaiswal7036 vo tho thik bola vaise bhi sala upsc kon karta ajj kal😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is how a protest should be. Speaking with sense..everyone is speaking with so much of patience and waiting for the other's to complete their words. Take a camera and a mic to political crowd and hardly any word will be clear. This is how education draws the line. Stay strong champs!!
Because these are well mannered and degree holder students whereas political parties have mostly illeterate people
Really kudos to all the students
Aese discipline students ko neta bnna chahiye neta to sansad mai maar pit chalo kr dete Hain😔
भाई इंडिया से ही हो
मैं तो हिंदी में कॉमेंट खोज रही हूं 😢😢 यहां to अंग्रेज बैठे हुए हैं। बहुत सही कहा भाई आपने , इसका दर्द केवल वही समझ सकता है जो अपना पूरा जवानी पढ़ाई में झोंक दिया हो और हमारे साथ उसके बाद भी धोखा हुआ है।😭😔😔😔😔😔
Mai v Hindi medium wale hi comment khoj rhi hu
अंग्रेज की औलाद होना जो गर्व समझते है, वे हिंदी में comment क्यों करे
Haan yaar me bhi
@@bpscgirlmotivated6382
क्या करोगे हिंदी माध्यम वाले की टिप्पणी देखकर,
कोई Skill Master करके
Private Job करो।
Same😂
Dear the problem is not Hindi or English, the main problem is the increasing number of IIT aspirants. And those who are from English medium are smart enough if UPSC changes everything then situation may not change, the root cause is our different education system.
Bhai iit walo ki koi galti nahi hai
,,
Absolutely correct answer
iit wale ka man vo jo kare agar ap main zyada kabiliyat hai toh ap unko hara ke dikhaye
I Fully stand with these aspirants ..Even I appeared in 2023 prelims Paper 1 was good but in CSAT I couldn't able to solve majority of question of mathematics..
This is unjustified and against the principle of proportionality....
Thank you
I think you should have tried the comprehension part from CSAT. If you have done justice with your civil services preparation, you will feel comfortable with the questions.
@@user-xj7ge1lk9gu can't wholly depend upon one topic buddy.. even english was not that easy as well
I totally agree that in some paragraph English was not that easy but if you go through the whole paper you can easily clear the cutoff mark...I think so and most of the aspirants I met they have the same review
@@user-xj7ge1lk9gyes comprehension was easy but one is not sure about the answer ,out of 27 questions,4-5 questions can be wrong ,so one can't skip mathematics portion.we need to solve atleast 40 questions to qualify csat.this year it was difficult to find questions after solving all the comprehensions.
Corruption is everywhere but justice is no where.
Bjp chuno phir rndi rona kro😂😂
Difficult paper so how is ut corruption??
@@ganeshmandalopscaspirant8511 tum Pakistan mai ho kya? Mere paas already job hai aur kisi ko koi pese nahi diye. Ur highly qualified and talking like fraud degree holder. Upse and ssc mai merit basis pai job milti hai baki logg ko college ke campus se mil jati hai.
Right 👍
@@pathfinder745so apke hisab se students ke protest ke khilaf sarkar ke police ne sahi Kiya????
सरकार को मामले का जल्द संज्ञान लेना चाहिए , और दिल्ली पुलिस को जवाब देना चाहिए इस बर्बाद के लिए
I have same feelings...but two points here
...1)most questions from pyq ..
2) csat is difficult for engineer and non engineer especially..
But u also admit it that arts gets more advantage in GS..
Although respect for both
..
questions not from previous year
gs lambe samay ke liye yaad nahi rehta uska benefit aap baad me nahi le sakte hai
or phit bhi IIT WALE HI SELECT HOTE HAI
हमारे आवाज उठाने के लिए आपको बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद 😢
J😊 uu
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the elder aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603grib aur gav me rhne vale logo ko dekhe ho nhi....Amir bap ke bigde aulad ho grib aur mehnt ko kbhi nhi smjhoge tum😡😡😡
@@drstrange9603 👈fake account spotted. Writing same message so many time.
Bilkul 😊
Dude I m a CAT aspirant. So I just solved CSAT paper maths out of curiosity. I thought It was medium level but then I realized , this exam is not for aptitude and majority of students have no maths background. For someone who isn't from maths or prepared exclusively for highly aptitude based test like CAT , GMAT. This CSAT was not at all doable for a Normal kid
questions were directly copied from Level 2 /3 difficulty of Cat questions from Arun Sharma Book .
IAS/ IPS is anyway not for so called "normal kid" , only academically bright aspirants or people with high IQ are able to crack it anyway .
People who can't score even 33 percent in aptitude based test after years of practice ,should not aspire for CSE.
@@freakpills so? What is wrong in that?
@@tapeshchand5320people with vague and disturbed mindset as urs should refrain from poking nose in genuine comments ... Coz u come from a privileged society and digesting truth is beyond ur absorbing capacity neither mentally and nor physically possibly ... So sit down,relax and mind ur own business ... Don't get my words wrong ... I have done u a favour by giving food to ur mind ... I insist u being thankful to me thereby👍..... As u know that Responsible communication is highly essential in public platforms for becoming an IAS which accidentally isn't in bits available in ur small knowledge hub(m really sorry 4 u)😢...hence it would be kind of u 2 demarcate ur understandings within the periphery of ur vision ... ohh..plz do buy digene from the nearest dispensary ...it might be of some help(burnol will be free 4 u) 😊🙏
First of all people should stop with these appeasement and all that..Yeah the Quant portion is little bit tough on those who don't have a proper Maths background but considering that they only need 33% i.e. around 25-26 Questions to clear the CSAT, i don't see the problem...Also, not everything is too tough as there're some easier questions as well. And you're attempting a Grade A gazetted exam thus, what were you expecting? Typical arithmetic calculations?? I'd say it's just a way to hide their inabilities in the guise of the questions are out of syllabus...Above all reasoning portion was quite easy and not considering the free passages of English, people can easily clear it out...And if someone says otherwise then, I have some doubt regarding their degree of preparedness towards the exams They're preparing to.
I share some degree of agreement with all the students, although I have reservations regarding the specific standard the paper should aim to achieve. Simultaneously, this pertains to the elevation of educational standards in schools and colleges. It's acknowledged that this challenge is more pronounced when comparing backgrounds in Engineering and Non-Engineering disciplines.
If you anticipate that politicians will establish these standards, it's likely that their priorities and agendas differ from the concerns of the common citizen
Aap सभी के संघर्ष को सलाम, मै भी गांव से हु, आपलोग हमारे आनेवाले भविष्य के लिए लड़ रहे हो, बहुत बहुत आभारी आपलोगो को 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you Lallantop for raising the genuine issue 🙏. You have also raised the voice earlier for students.
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the elder aunty 👌👌
Thank you lallantop for raising this issue
UPSC should become transparent by Giving scan copy of OMR at the time of Exam & give Answer key after prelims only. ✋ UPSC Reform is must. UPSC should not ask Question Out of syllabus. UPSC has crossed all limit. Students fraternity are in anguish. Government should intervene. Hindi medium students selection has gone down from 50% to 6% shame shame.
I attempted UPSC 4 times in Hindi medium. I could not succeed. Many don't succeed. But they don't blame UPSC for their failures.
CSAT paper 2 was never an issue. Non in my group prepared for this paper.
@@Mussadi_Lal No one is asking your fact based opinion here. If you have anything emotionally charged response, comment else please leave. This is a group of failures and propaganda artists, who aspire to become IAS with zero aptitude. others entry is strictly restricted. Please showcase your facts where necessary, not here.
संविधान सिर्फ किताबो में ही अच्छा लगता है , बाहर सिर्फ पैसा और पॉलिटिक्स चलती है । जय हिन्द
Baat to sahi bhai,
Ha 😂😂😂😂😂
Agree👍👍
Copy Paste Samvidhan se kya expect karoge. Saara Bhrasht Neta aur Mafia Ateek Ahmed isi Samvidhan ki shapath leke MP ban gaya
Agree 💯
लल्लनटॉप से हमे उम्मीद है की इस मुद्दे को उठाये
they were completely right ....... they have full right to protest as an aspirant gives so many years of dedication and go through so much to prove themselves and to achieve their dreams but in the end are faced with such injustices and instances of discrimination . Hats off to them for raising the issue. Seedhi baat , no bakwas .
यूपीएससी अभ्यर्थियों की आवाज उठाने के लिए lallantop का धन्यवाद 🙏
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the older aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603
तुम्हारे इस कमेंट से मुझे अंधभक्ति की बू आ रही है, किसी ने सच ही कहां है की अंधभक्तों के दिमाग में गाय का गोबर नही सूअर का गू भरा होता है, जो ने लीपने के काम आए और ना ही का कंडे बनाने के।🖕🏻🤬🖕🏻
@@drstrange9603
दिमाग में गोबर भरा है, तुम्हारे लेवल का नही है ये वीडियो, इसको समझने के लिए दिमाग होना जरूरी है, मगर आप ठहरे चाटूकार। चाटते रहो यही औकात है तुम अंधभक्तों की।
Aap hi k toh Intezaar th
Spamer Mt baniye kuch kaam kar lijiye
@@drstrange9603 I know you are Upsc bot but one bot can't dominate thousands of aggrieved students .
This is facism of UPSC.... immediately High court and SC have to intermediate on the behalf of the student
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the elder aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603 mr..I request u to kindly observe d paper..this isn't today's matter only..in future upsc will do more diverse thing and ended with lateral entry... So dnt judge them ..they are on behalf of all indian student...
@@drstrange9603beta ja tu padhai kar, paper dekh kar mut nikal jayegi teri, mai tuje janta hu sale, class 10 me fail hone se bcha tha😂
@@drstrange9603hehehe...I promise u can't get even 20 marks in actual paper...
bhai upsc ,,,,,,, sab govt ke mood ke anusaar change ho jaate h ,,,,inko pata h govt kya chaati h ,,
This is actually unfair with Hindi medium aspirants 😢
The paper is in both languages.....
@@STBCSPS yes,I know 🙋but problem is not this.
Hmari government itni unfair kyu h apne hi desh k citizens k saath 😢
Kyuki sab angrez banne ki koshish kar rahe pahle hi language problem solved karni chahiye thi like china 😊
go to china if everything is going to done through hindi, so how can we south indians clear upsc @@kushwahabhishek5348
I am not aspirant.. but my roommate is upsc aspirant. He came after exam and started crying like it was not his fault . He studied how it should be... He is an engineer than also CSAT was like that to him
UPSC is nothing but a life ruining journey for 99%.
Needs year round preparation
But only 0.1% get success
And failures don't get alternatives like lesser posts atleast for top 20% or something
#unfaircsat #upsc
😂 that shows how dumb your friend is
Why engineers are wasting time in non technical job😢
@@rohitnayak9952right bola bhai
I have qualified Prelims 2023...preparing for mains...Still supporting this movement....Suyash and others, if you are reading this comment...keep the movement on...completely legitimate demand...best wishes to all. ..!❤
Hi bhagat.. could you tell me from where did you complete your current section and did you join any coaching for the exam?
@@aradhyamishra5590 no coaching...
Current affairs- newspaper, own research, vision monthly magazine, mock test analysis...
Can't type things in detail...Apologies to others who would be asking anything here and if I couldn't respond to them after this comment...
Thank you...!
Ho jaye final kuch ban jao to kuch logo ko aware krna...help them in whatever way. Please.
@@bhagatsinghthakur2610thanks bhai ...aap padho mains k liye...all the best💪
bro what was ur stream in class 11 and 12 ?
Indian education system needs to give importance to humanities education as well.
Rest Giving out of syll questions is the responsibility of UPSE commission. Commission should give its clearification.
It is a real concern. The Supreme Court of India and Parliament should look into the matter.
Fighting with an arrogant, over confident institution is tough but not impossible. Thank you dear students and also lallantop for raising the much needed voice . The fight of todat will bear fruits for tomorrow. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@drstrange9603 kindly don't bark of your credentials in every comment. The way you are just spamming itself speaks a lot of your nallapan and undoubtedly your upbringing.
AHA mja a gaya.Aj chen ki nind sounga😂😂
BJP ko vote krne ka natija
@@drstrange9603abe loser bacche.tu nhi janta h to mat bol samjha. Wo upsc ka failure hota h na wo apni field ka topper hta h laude. Tu khud ko kya samjhta h loser.
Now above all those reservations, they'll decide on What UPSC should ask in the exam.... You're not giving any Board examination or some short of that where you'll claim that questions are out of syllabus, it's a Competitive exam... And if you cannot outrun others then, you're just one of the many who'll give plenty of excuses to hide their inabilities and those who're eligible will easily get the job while others squander around doing these idiotic claims.
@@GauravSingh-cx7jv every competitive exam, mind you every competitive exam from JEE, CAT, NEET, GRE, etc, have a prescribed syllabus. To make questions tougher, they can do innovation within the prescribed syllabus. UPSC exam too have a well prescribed, detailed syllabus. Kindly get versed with the matter in detail before passing judgements.
🖤UPSC को अपनी सीमाओं के अंदर रहकर कार्य करना चाहिए पाठ्यक्रम के बाहर से प्रश्नों को नहीं पूछना चाहिए क्योंकि यह सालों साल मेहनत करने वाले छात्रों के लिए जहर के समान हैं।🖤
Upsc ki koi seema hi nahi ha 😂
Each one of these candidates is a gem , know how to put across their points and absolutely went by the law and yet got dragged by their hair, police sensitization training sirf paper tak hi reh gayi.
Divyang aspirant ki baat sunke bahaut dukh hua, I come from an engg background and i barely made it across the line, there is no way a person with visual disability could qualify with even 23%. Their cut off should be separate and performance based on the pool of appearing disabled students. From an organization like UPSC which is highly revered ,itni kam rationality and insentivity expected nahi hai.
As an aspirant I'm completely demotivated to go on with the preparation seeing the arbitrariness of the process . major reforms are needed in the mains as well
Tough paper is ok but wrong questions and out of syllabus is wrong.
Well done Lallantop....!!
I'm also victim of CSAT ... I'm not that bad at maths but still I'm out ... Even after scoring 110 in GS1... This is painful... And against the principle of inclusivity...
Mja a gaya aur kro BJP ko vote😁😁😁😁
@@drstrange9603 Chacha ek hi reply kitni jagah chipkaoge. Kabhi kitab utha ke bhi dekhi h. Failed aspirants failed aspirants.
@@drstrange9603 I don't think if you're a upsc aspirant.... have some respect for rural aspirants... Indian language medium aspirants.... Inclusivity principle is also necessary....
@Jyaskumar next time acche se padlo, it is not a difficult task.. you will clear and become IAS.
@@Dontreadmycomment151bjp ka kya hai is isme yr
Dekho bhai paper set krne wale officers ki galti hai ye sab and next time se level theek rhega ab 😊 dekh Lena
And jo bol rhe ki csat should be removed to ye glt hai , because you can't ignore mathematics and reasoning after becoming a officer as well
Haa level should be decreased 😊
I completely agree, it's disheartening to witness such instances of discrimination within the UPSC. These occurrences highlight the pressing need for reforms and a more inclusive approach to ensure that the selection process remains fair and unbiased for all aspirants. It's crucial that steps are taken to address these concerns and promote a level playing field, fostering an environment where every individual has an equal opportunity to showcase their potential and succeed based on merit alone.
discrimination in terms of?
This is where we need the cooperation of whole India. Indians please understand we will grow only when we will be united or else politicians know very well how to divide and rule.
Thankyou for this video, thankyou for letting us know these problems,and thankyou for spreading awareness regarding government issues
सिविल सेवकों को चयन होने के बाद सेवा भारतीय भाषाओं वाले लोगों की करनी होती है लेकिन चयन अंग्रेजी भाषी लोगों का ज्यादा है। तो लोगों को न्याय कैसे मिलेगा??
Ji bhaiya ,men and women vale kya samjhenge ,bhan bhaiyo ka dard 😢😢😢😢😢😢
3:11 very intelligent objection
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
This should be raised
गरीब के लिए नही है IAS 😂😂 सविधान में लिखा जाना चाहिए 😂
Hasi Majak mat manao yar ...
yaar tum has rahe ho, Sharm aani chahiye
हिन्दी भाषा के लिए 30% सीट आरक्षित की जाए
Thankyou The Lallantop for keeping the journalism alive,🙏
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the older aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603
तुम्हारे इस कमेंट से मुझे अंधभक्ति की बू आ रही है, किसी ने सच ही कहां है की अंधभक्तों के दिमाग में गाय का गोबर नही सूअर का गू भरा होता है, जो ने लीपने के काम आए और ना ही का कंडे बनाने के।🖕🏻🤬🖕🏻
This time UPSC published name wise list of successful candidates in prelims.many of these failed aspirants are exposed (in previous year they claimed to have cleared pre) so they need excuse this time.
👍👏👍 barabar sahi hai bro... Kisi v news channel ka dam nahi ki esa reality news, Government and system k against bol sake ya dikha sake.. thanks to 🎉Lallantop..
Problem dikhe to Aaj nahi to kal solve sure hoga..
@@drstrange9603 bhagwaan bhala kare aapka ...bhai sab acting hi kar rahe h ....manipur me bhi acting hi ho rahi h .... covid me jinke relative marr gaye wo bhi acting hi kar rahe rone ki ......bhai itna bhi mat giro ki jab baad me khud k comments padoge to sharam aa jaaye ...compassion naam ki chiz bhi hoti h dost .....agar support nahi kar sakte to bura kyu bol rahe ho ....yaad rakhna karma fal jarur lot k aata h ....jis din aapke saath hoga tab aapke hi bhai bandhu aake bolenge ki waah kya acting thi ........thoda sa emotional intelligence k baare me padho or aise comments karne se bacho ...jo galat h uske khilaaf awaaz uthao ....kyuki jab aapke saat galat hoga tab koi nahi aayega .......
No one is above the law not the upsc, gross breach of justice
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants 👌👌, especially the older aunty who doesn't know what IIT is in her 6 years of preparation but her dream of becoming IAS is crushed by UPSC due to CSAT 😭😭
Law kha se aagya😂😂
@@sanjaysingh-ez2tt Constitutional values and Prescribed syllabus of Upsc se...jara padh lijiye
@@drstrange9603you must be very aware, then you must know that the cast 23 question paper was out of syllabus as there questions questions based on PnC which is way beyond class 10th std. Hope you can judge clearly.
@@user-qf6ui5fm1hProbability in itself uses the Permutation and Combination functions and it literally gives the leeway to use it...But yeah those are some good level questions but still they're part of it and you're attempting a Gazetted level exam so obviously, it was meant to happen at some point. Also, if you cannot do the Permutation& Combination doesn't entail that you'll fail cuz that's around 5-6 questions max and you only have to score 26 out of remaining let's say 70....It's not tough considering the free points from those English passages and Reasoning section was quite easy....Some quant questions are also doable...So in my opinion, it's just a way to hide their inadequacy and Lallantop is quite good at considering these useless topics and slowly their credibility is also degrading.
Thank you sabhi ko Awaz uthane ke liye,,,😢 ye dard vhi samj sakta hai jiske bachhe tayari kar hai
from 1947 to 2023 ..none topper score more than 60% in UPSC final marks😊😊
29:28 यह सच्चाई है इस देश की. बहुत आगे बढो तुम बेहना. आप पर मुझे बहुत अभिमान है. 🇮🇳
Hats off to girl 31:11 her courage to follow dreams.
UPSC should grant compensatory attempt for the blunders it has created past few years.
#UPSCExtraAttempt
Yr kch ni hone wala tribunal ne decline krdiya case infact cat is saying cuttoff to 50percent hona chyiye 33 percent is too low for qualify
@@himanshujoshi4904cat has gone mad..
@@himanshujoshi4904did they really say it😂😂😂
@@himanshujoshi4904thy r approaching HC. CAT to vaise v rubber stamp h govt ki. It was expected frm there
@@uttarakhandi14kuch nhi hona. Maths and English zindabaad
Kudos that they raising voices but there is no solution to these problem, Better to offer these jobs on short term basis only.
Right! These person are right, I am with them. I am too a IAS aspirant, what children would learn from this all....???? What about our indian's future..???? It is destroyed only due to politicians,.....?????
𝗪𝗵𝘆???
बस यही कारण है कि लोग विदेश भाग रहे है😢😢। खराब व्यवस्था
सही
100%
Literally I cried...
Never give up never🙂
Me too.... when i heard the misery of that Sister who has a rural background .
standard of asking question is not logical , its like that if you have power you can do anything no one will easily defeated you
Everybody fighting for jobs and exam 🤡
Meanwhile me who will demand a seperate nation for general category next year 💀
IAS banna hoga toh English medium se padhna hoga 😂
Paper difficult tha ya out of syllabus tha to sabhi ke liye tha isme ameer gareeb kahan se aa gaya ?
Exactly i agree
यह सभी घायल शेर शेरनियां हैं...... अपने अधिकार की लड़ाई के लिए मैदान-ए-जंग में उतर गए हैं....... हमारे सभी गुरुदेव भी सहयोग करें..🙏🙏🙏.......
इनको न्याय मिलना चाहिए 👈👍👍😢😢
Nyay nhi mar padegi
Being a neet aspirant, I can feel their pain... specially that gaw ki sister 🥺she is crying from heart....now im feeling my problem is sooo small in front of her.
CSAT should be either remove or add more comprehension, computer awareness and grammar questions and reduce the number of mathematics questions so as to give justice to students from every background. There are candidates who are much better than people with engineering background but cannot clear prelims due to CSAT that's the sad reality.
I qualified for 5 prelims including Indian forest service cut off. This time also expected to be qualified. But both papers were very vague in nature. CSAT was blunder by UPSC. And seeing answer key of 2022 where so many wrong answer given by UPSC, I can understand why serious candidates like me are not in. Those who are not able to clear in 4-5 attempts are in this time . This is because UPSC make exam as game of chance rather than game of skill and knowledge. But as we are small upsc community, our grievances are not heard. In last 2 years , quality of UPSC is not upto mark.
Exactly. Though there is always some luck factor involved in all exams. But in recent years, upsc is making CSE more luck based rather than more knowledge based like it used to be. R u appearing fr 2024??
Yup
What UPSC is trying to do with GS paper is levelling the field for the newcomers. Look at you, you have an experience of handling preliminary exams for 4-5 years. How can a person who is just getting into preparation compete with you? UPSC always looks for young people and that's why this vagueness appeared. No doubt the Paper-2 was out of the box, but the increasing level of GS is what was needed.
@@Rohit-ij7mb it was last attempt.... First time took long leaves for preparation,by so many requests it were approved.... But all these years preparation, now wasted .... As these knowledge is not going to utilise
@@mayank3526 really? It's vague paper .... GS1 was not tough but vague and those who have long preparation are getting above 100 . Even for me 62 que was easy and confident to qualify.... What matter is wrong answer Key by UPSC as 2022 answer key is showing many wrong answer.... I heard many people who are getting less than 66marks in GS1 by various answers key are in exam while csat need 66 marks ....I know many who are working in class 1 position and not preparing for this exam as not having time in work load, gave exam by random bubbling and it's miracle due to vagueness.... They are qualified... That's pity of country.... Serious candidates are left excluded while randomised people would qualify....
2023 का प्रीलिम्स जितना विवादित रहा है उतना यूपीएससी के इतिहास में कभी नहीं हुआ..... नॉर्मल सीरियस एस्प्रिंट्स के साथ नाइंसाफी हुई है..💔💔💔❤️🔥😭😡...🙏🙏🙏
Is government me hR cheej vivacity h
बिल्कुल सही कहा अपने। Serious Aspirents के साथ ना इंसाफी हुए है।
अब सिलेक्शन या तो भूतों का हुआ है। या Not। Serious Aspirents का।
@@Mussadi_Lal नॉर्मल सीरियस एस्प्रिंट्स...🙏🙏🙏... प्लीज नेगेटिव में ना लें...
Ji aap padhai kijea aap bhi select hoge zaroor .Jai hind .Par agar bina padhe exam doge to select to nhi hoge na madam ye bhi to dekho .
Kuch bhi ias banna hai lekin maths ka sawaal solve nhi kar pate
Free and fair examination of the youth of this country.. ..
i like reporter also..she is patiently listen all their problems
Thanks Lallantop for raising our voice. Thanks for keeping journalism alive.
CSAT was just a qualifying paper and GS-1 was for merit purpose. Making CSAT too tough, defeats its ultimate core purpose. UPSC need to select top appx 1000 students across India. If they make such vague and out of syllabus ques then it wastes the attempt and productive year of a student. It's killing the spirit of hard working UPSC aspirants. We (UPSC aspirants) work hard for years then we reach this level. Please don't let Hitler (dictator UPSC) kill our years long hard-work. We are living in free India not in British India. Still getting justice is so difficult and out of reach. UPSC and CAT (tribunal) are giving vague/ridiculous (same as this year PRELIMS paper) arguments instead of giving justice to UPSC aspirants.
Please make our voices reachable to ruling govt. Please help us to get justice. Mains is scheduled in Sept-2023. It's URGENT. It needs to be get resolved by this month (Aug-2023) only. Please Help to future of India.
@@drstrange9603bro you are just spamming
Dude I m a CAT aspirant. So I just solved CSAT paper maths out of curiosity. I thought It was medium level but then I realized , this exam is not for aptitude and majority of students have no maths background. For someone who isn't from maths or prepared exclusively for highly aptitude based test like CAT , GMAT. This CSAT was not at all doable for a Normal kid
@@karansharma2738 Comeon it wasn't that hard , i am not even preparing for CAT but atleat 70% questions form aptitude and maths alone were doable. A 21+ is an adult and i guess he/she is supposed to have that much aptitude. EVEN you would agree that CAT doesn't ask IIT level questions. Its just basic questions that require a good aptitude and brain power.
@@karansharma2738 I doubt your CAT prepartion then
@@drstrange9603chutiya iit ka syllabus pta hai tujhe
Thank you so much lallantop for this genuine reporting for UPSC aspirants...❤❤❤
That's the line : upsc khuda nahi hai upsc ne galtiya ki hai lekin manti nahi hai 🔥🔥🔥
Bihariyo ka mujra
this is complete discrimination towards arts and humanities civil services aspirants..........UPSC needs to think on it.....
Only Indian News Channel that knows true journalism.
Only lallantop & ravish kumar official ❤
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the elder aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603 lagta hai tum hai is exam ke bare mein knowledge nahi hai
@@drstrange9603jiwan me aaj tk kuch kiye ho
Dharti ke bojh
@@AI108Ramaprabhulogical thinking time management betei maths jagaha hei bas tum jaise tuchei logou kou ise sirf ek subject ki taraha dekhtei hei 😂😂
Forward this
Best of luck to all for raising voice genuinely ❤
आपके प्रयासों के लिए धन्यवाद कहने के लिए शब्द नहीं हैं.......... बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद मैम हम asperients की दर्द को समझने के लिए😢😢😢😢
Upsc इतना टफ पेपर देगा तो गांव के बच्चों का क्या होगा जो बेहद ईमानदार होते हैं
Or jinhone qwalify kiya h unke bare m kya kahna h apka
@@user-lj7ne5lq2r
उनके बारे में हमारा ये कहना है की इंग्लिश मीडियम के है, हिंदी वालो का रास्ता और कठिन बना रहा है यूपीएससी , इसीलिए इनकी समस्याओं को सुना नही जा रहा है, क्योंकि गलती उन्ही की है, इसीलिए इनकी बात कोई सुनने को तैयार नहीं।
@@user-lj7ne5lq2r60 number gs per qualify kiya hai bara qulitiy hai pass bala ke amir bap ke hai
गाँव के लोगो चोरी भी ज़्यादा करते हैं
@@nathgoody5905 tum kya ho urban hiro english men ke beta behad neck jo british santan india janta hai tum kon ho
Like this video so that it goes more trending and in recommendation.
Hats off to LALLANTOP, and great job dear friends 🎉 #jai_bharat_jai_hindi
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the older aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603
दिमाग में गोबर भरा है, तुम्हारे लेवल का नही है ये वीडियो, इसको समझने के लिए दिमाग होना जरूरी है, मगर आप ठहरे चाटूकार। चाटते रहो यही औकात है तुम अंधभक्तों की।
@@drstrange9603Bot spotted 👈
@@mukulabulkod9236 😂😂😂
@@drstrange9603 and 1st ranker replying my comment 🤣🤣🤣
I still don't understand why our system only favours Engineering & Mathematics background students, & doing injustice with other stream people.. This biased system is not acceptable at all
Bhai duniya English and maths se hi chalti h. Accept the reality
@@Aman-nk5uq han fir baki subjects padhane ki kya zrurt hai.. Sab band kra dena chahiye.. Such a ridiculous comment.. Shame
why biology ,commerce, humanities students 11/12 ki maths,,, pade ,,,,,,dr jo neet clear karte h woh khud csat me fail ho jaate hai ,,
@@Aman-nk5uqHaan to fir upsc mains ka koi matlab hi nahi banta..gazab illogical insaan ho yaar
@@Aman-nk5uq😂😂 kuch bhi bol de bhai bata de kaun se chiz hai jo math se chalte hai tumhare life me ye Trigonometry ka kaha kaam diya batao
Thank you the lallontop for true journalism 🎉❤
Agar BTech Enginner wala Bacha Engeenring kurke aur MBBS Doctor wala Bacha Medical ke padhai karke
Ancient History
Medival History
Modern History
World History
Art and Culture
Environment
Geography of India
Geography of World
Indian Polity
Indian Governance
Indian Economy
Internal Security
Ethics
International Relations
Yeh sare subjects padh k bina roye bina kuch bole k maine to yeh sub kuch pehle kabhi nahi padha UPSC aisee syllabus mein see paper kyu lete hai pur wooh pura zoor laga k itne sare Arts Subjects ko padh k IAS ka paper clear kur sakta hai to yeh sub CSAT ko leke kyu protesr kur rahe hai ,?????????
Yeh to GS paper ko bhi galat bata rahe hai wooh to difficult hoga hii as the competition is getting tough hoga hi !!!!!
100% agreed
But they study the limited syllabus..
But these people are protesting because they got questions OUT OF SYLLABUS.
Kya engeneering aur medical background ka bachha out of syllabus question aane se paas kr lega upsc..
Think abt it.
Correct bro
हम पढ़े लिखे हैं, लेकिन सरकार नहीं
35:02
संघर्ष को सलाम दीदी जी
आज आपको सुनकर वो सीखा जो upsc की किसी पुस्तक से नहीं सीखने को मिला❤
Thank you lallantop for covering this, UPSC is playing with the career of students and promoting tukkebaji and there were 7 wrong answers in 2022 answer key
still say raising quality , damn . Upsc member sometimes think they are god but thanks to raise this matter.
Pcs is following same way and multiple wrong question although they eliminate marks but i do not think its good for everyone
Respect for lallantop for covering this genuine news 🫡
Its should be changed so most of the aspirants can get understand.
धन्यवाद लल्लनटॉप आपने हमारी बहुत बड़ी समस्या को उठाया है जिस समस्या के ऊपर सरकार ध्यान नहीं दे रही है सरकार के बर्ताव को देखकर ऐसा लग रहा है सिविल सेवा परीक्षा में केवल और केवल अंग्रेजी माध्यम वाले विद्यार्थी ही चयन प्राप्त करेंगे। सरकार अन्य भाषा वाले अभ्यार्थियों के साथ ऐसा व्यवहार कर रही है लगता है कि हम अभी भी अंग्रेजों के गुलाम हैं। सरकार से अनुरोध है की अंग्रेजी माध्यम के साथ अन्य भाषाओं के विद्यार्थियों का भी चयन हो इसके लिए अथक प्रयास करें धन्यवाद
Remove CSAT. It's a torture on Hindi medium students and humanities students. Thank you lallantop.
Kyu bhai math waale humanities pdh skte h lekin tm csat nhi.......math ka liye bhi equal ho
Bhai, mai khud Engineer hu but un logo ki peeda ko samajh skta hu !
@@gsghurye-kp5sv toh bhai jb tm humanities pdhoge na toh tmhe bhi bhut peeda hogi lekin tm complaint nhi kroge kiuki Engineer never complaint they find a way to do things aur esiliye engineering nikalte h bina kisi uss subject main background ka
Bhai, mai padh chuka hu humanities
@@amanpal7487Humanities koi bhi padh sakta hai, par Mathematics har koi nahi. Ye Bharat Sarkar kaa khud kaa kehna hai, Humanities kaa baccha further studies me Mathematics nahi le sakta, par mathematics kaa baccha kabhi bhi humanities padh sakta hai.
अक्सर सिलेबस जानबूझ कर इसलिए breach krte हैं ताकि एक विशेष वर्ग को फायदा मिल सके और ये चीज बड़ी बेशर्मी से की जा रही है
😢😢😢😢bahut dukh ki baat h .......... please justice.........
Thank you Lallantop for presenting this issue.. hope this reaches those deaf ears 🙏
UPSC should become transparent by Giving scan copy of OMR at the time of Exam & give Answer key after prelims only. ✋ UPSC Reform is must. UPSC should not ask Question Out of syllabus. UPSC has crossed all limit. Students fraternity are in anguish. Government should intervene. Hindi medium students selection has gone down from 50% to 6% shame shame.
Absolutely right. Exams like CAT, UPSC, Banking Exams and many others Competitive Exams. All these exams are basically for Rich Families Children.
When you guys are not able to do Maths of 10th and 12th class then So what will the government do about this?
Ok when you are in school, you are only concerned with the degree,only degree but at that time you do not think about which subject you want to do the degree in.
& now you people are complaining about engineering people, they have focused on studies, okay
When did you study Arts? You keep doing collage politic & you can't face any interview. Leave the interview. You can't even do 10th class maths.
But, I am not talking about that blind man, his problems are different from yours, his words are valid.
they released 2022 prelims answer key and aspirants like me were in shock when we saw upsc accepting some wrong options as correct. this gross injustice was never expected from upsc. i missed the exam by 3 marks. and beacuse of upsc's wrong answers i was at loss of 8 marks.
I was out by 1.5 marks mine was 86. Something and cut off was 88
😑@@damini2778
And collectively more than 2 years' efforts and time went into vain.
Happened with me in 2021 😢
Such blatant violation by UPSC of its own statutory guidelines is an absolute betrayal to the upsc aspirant community. It must be held accountable and answerable for such dictatorial behaviour in a democracy.
Appreciations to Lallantop for covering this issue !
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the elder aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603Not failed students,They are passed by great margin in GS paper, understand issue then speak,but for that u have to use brain,it will be hard for u as u may have never used it earlier💯
@@mukulabulkod9236
Do you have courage to Answer me:
1. How many Hindi medium aspirants in % give Exam
2. How many in % give exam in English Medium despite having Hindi as 1st language
3. What is the % of population in India with Hindi as 1st language? How many of them study in English medium?
4. What is the ideal % of Hindi medium demography students out of all languages students graduating in India?
@@drstrange9603 you must understand the issue before commenting in public.
@@drstrange9603
तुम्हारे इस कमेंट से मुझे अंधभक्ति की बू आ रही है, किसी ने सच ही कहां है की अंधभक्तों के दिमाग में गाय का गोबर नही सूअर का गू भरा होता है, जो ने लीपने के काम आए और ना ही का कंडे बनाने के।🖕🏻🤬🖕🏻
Do doubts it need to be better. Please think about it government.
Aap log protest Karte rahiye safalta Jarur milegi
Sare aspirant kitne well educated h.. Aisa lg rha h sbhi ias hain.. इनकी वाणी में कितना संयम है 👏👏👏👏👏
After watching some media houses i thought 4th pillar of democracy is still alive 🙌
What an acting performance by all the failed aspirants, esp the older aunty 👌👌
@@drstrange9603
तुम्हारे इस कमेंट से मुझे अंधभक्ति की बू आ रही है, किसी ने सच ही कहां है की अंधभक्तों के दिमाग में गाय का गोबर नही सूअर का गू भरा होता है, जो ने लीपने के काम आए और ना ही का कंडे बनाने के।🖕🏻🤬🖕🏻
@@drstrange9603bjp babashir jokhim party
400 lrko ki bhir thi mike camera uthaya , kuch sentimental questions puch liye , thik thak view aa gya.
Journalism 😂😂😂
@@drstrange9603garami english men ke chatukar uncle tum harare pure bihar ke
5:30 7:20 time stamp makes me feel that they want to make it clear that they are not to be labelled as anti Modi by Godi media (urban Naxal etc.) thus a disclaimer sort of attempt.
they are fighting for their rights...we are with u🎉
आप सभी मेरे प्रिय बहन भाई बहुत अच्छा कार्य कर रहे हम जैसे भविष्य के उम्मीदवारों के लिए हमारे पास शब्द नहीं की किस तरह आपको धन्यवाद दे। पर दिन व दिन UPSC के बदलते पैटर्न को देखकर वह भी बिना बताए तो कही न कही हम अपना कॉन्फिडेंट खो रहे हैं।
As a humanities students. We are facing huge problem in csat paper😢
Upsc is giving preference to IIT students by giving hard questions on csat (math) pper
As a humanities it's difficult to face those questions
As a science students we are facing more difficulty as mains paper has become more tough and analytical than previous papers.
Also they are asking so much facts in prelims..
I think upsc should stop taking prelims and mains and rather select by measuring cheast.
@@kumarutkarsh6713 only IIT are getting preference
This is the best standup comedy after Bassi about UPSC 😁😁👌👌 full drama from failed aspirants especially the elder aunty who doesn't know what IIT is in 6 years of her preparation for the country's highest job IAS ✌
@@kumarutkarsh6713upsc should give voice notes on syllabus as illiterates like u are not able to read it
Csat syllabus clearly says basic numeracy ,data interpretation class 10 level but the questions asked in pre were of CAT level
@@rohanparashar atleast upsc should freely volunteer some mind and common sense for people like you then only u can figure it out that a tough questions on average doesn't mean that it automatically becomes class 11th syllabus.
Questions were a level high not were out of the syllabus..
Avg, si, ci, 😂 are taught in class 7th, and ppl like u will hope in exam the qsn should be of class 7 ! Oh my God!
I will pray upsc for my proposal of mind 😂
Are Arts students not getting more advantage in GS papers and essays ?? IITians don't study History, Sociology, Geography, Polity etc. in IIT.
# ISSUES/LOOPHOLES in nutshell-
1-15 months long recruitment process
2- Ambiguous,pathetic&out of syllabus Qs
3- Answer key& marksheet after 1 year
4- Judicial delay&inconclusive judgement of CAT
5- Police brutality in peaceful protest.
Hf
@@kingKhan-iu8ifWhat Hf??
Perfect 👍
Only 15 months! R u serious dude? HV u ever seen the reality of State PSC exams? They conduct exam after so many years after filling the form. I HV just appeared such an exam after 2.5 years of filling the form! UPSC is damn so fast, respect that and don't weep!
@@RahulKumar-wx6jz1) you are comparing UPSC with State PSC...it is absolutely bullshit to do...the former is analytical and highly competitive in terms of no. of candidates and seats while latter is based on rote learning
2) You have to emphasize on "vicious cycle" that leads to uncertainty.
First,Pre is very dicey ,if not qualified again 1year,cleared but not mains again at same level....and finally not in the list.
You are in a single room,look on the ground what is happening.
"If you think you are smarter in a room,you are in the wrong room".
I had a score of 95+ in my previous two CSAT attempts but couldn't score 66 this year. I have scored 98-99 in gs 1 which is more than cutoff of 75-76. I prepared what UPSC asked for but had no idea UPSC would breach their own syllabus
Reality hai bhai
Same 😔
This question is not from iit 😂😂😂
Prepare for ssc and cgl
Maths for csat
Every year upsc is playing the gamble with each & every aspirant.
ललनटॉप से हमें बहुत उम्मीद है की हमारी बात सरकार ओर Upsc तक पहुँचे , csat को लेकर
Same with me
I am Karnataka , came from Kannada medium. When i started to prepare upsc even i couldn't understand classes in English. But i didn't give up , i did lot of hardwork since 4 years . Because i couldn't understand questions easily. So, i have to read in English. When my parents told me this was last attempt. But i couldn't clear. Now i have to join some other job. As a rural background , even i am able to put more efforts for next attempt also,but time is not there for me, but for some aspirents who have good economic and educational background, their parents understand the situation and they will encourage.But poor people cannot afford lot of time and cannot afford money. I am not blaming upsc , but our youth situation and our education system. They thought us regional or own languages are important. But when we grow society make us to understand English is important. Not only this field in every field now happining in India. If it is true why they don't teach English. Only rich kids learn English and join good colleges.these political members says that mother toung is important but they send their children to English medium. Especially this south political leaders use us as weapons. They don't agree Hindi or else don't teach English. But they thought their children both languages. I think language is a big barrier in our life.
I am from English medium, believe me English is itself very difficult like the person who is very well versed in English grammar , could able to solve it .or also many options were subjective ..they were not objective .....
Bro your English is good
I myself was scoring 97 in gs 1
But only 61 in csat
And the fun fact is that I scored 108 in csat 2021 but missed gs by 0.6 marks
It hurts bro. Your situation is worse than me but my situation is similar. I score 80 in gs last year and 111 year before that. Both time I had more than 110 in csat. This year I am scoring 104 in gs but 61 in csat :(
4 number se ruk Gaya 😢😢
bhai ne apni baat bahut sahi tarike se rakhi hai .........dhanywaad lallantop garib baccho ki awaj uthaane ke liye