What's The Best Mascara? Comparing 16 High-End Mascaras from Sephora, Shopper's Drugmart and More
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 08. 2024
- Ok so ive been obsessed with mascara for years and I'm always on the hunt for the best one, so I decided to do a little tournament to help me find it. So what I did was collected all the samples I could, and purchased all the mini mascaras I could get my hands on from top brands from shoppers drugmart, sephora and a few other places. Now were going to compare them round robin tournament style untill we find the best one. I hope you enjoy the video, Here's a breakdown:
Intro: 00:00
Contenders: 01:41
Round 1 Results: 14:22
Round 2 Results: 18:00
Round 3 Results: 19:41
Final Results: 20:32
Contenders:
Stila xxx Magnum Mascara - $30 CAD
Lancôme Hypnose Drama Mascara - $36 CAD
Lancôme Lash Idole Mascara - $35 CAD
Nars Climax Mascara -$32 CAD
Milk Makeup Kush Mascara - $33 CAD
Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Mascara -$26 CAD
Clinique High Impact Mascara -$28 CAD
Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Mascara - $30 CAD
Tarte's Sugar Rush Lash Smoothie Mascara - $30 CAD
Clarins Wonder Perfect Mascara 4D - $33 CAD
Benefit Bad Gal Bang Mascara - $34 CAD
Benefit They're Real Magnet Mascara -$34 CAD
MAC in Extreme Dimension 3D Black Lash mascara -$33 CAD
Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara - $33 CAD
Lise Watier Dramatique Intense Mascara - $25 CAD
Buxom Lash Volumizing Mascara - $28 CAD
Drugstore Mascara Competition: • What's The Best Drugst...
Drugstore vs High End Mascara Competition: • Drugstore VS High-End ...
Thankyou so much for watching!
My channel: / unorthodoll
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @unorthodoll
Instagram: / unorthodoll
TikTok: / unorthodoll
Sources: www1.shoppersdrugmart.ca/
www.sephora.com/ca/en/
tartecosmetics.com/en_CA/lash...
www.wellandgood.com/benefit-t...
www.instyle.com/beauty/rare-b...
coveteur.com/kush-high-volumi...
www.bigapplebuddy.com/product...
cornershopapp.com/en-ca/produ...
www.boxycharm.com/too-faced-b...
www.chickadvisor.com/item/lis...
www.walmart.ca/en/ip/Buxom-La...
Music: Bensound- Cute, Ukulele
CZcams Audio Library, Mr. Sunny Face- Wayne Jones
Edited using Wondershare Filmora
#bestmascara #mascara #tournament - Jak na to + styl
Thank you for doing this on a bare face! You did a wonderful job for all of us that DON’T wear falsies!🥰 Time to go shopping now lol
Thank-you❤️
Thank you so much for such a detailed review. This is the best mascara comparison I’ve seen so far.
Thank-you so much for watching!
Great comparisons. But next time don't wear any eyeliner it blocks the eyelashes from being seen.
Fantastic comparison - the best!! Thanks for taking the time to put this together!
Thank-you!
Wow, this is the best mascaras comparison that I've ever seen in my life. Keep going ✨💕
Thankyou!
This is a great video to watch!! Especially when I'm shopping for mascara! This helps a lot! 🤗
I'm glad I could help! Thanks for watching!
Such a fun video! Loved it❤
This is SO detailed and helpful. I really appreciate this video. Going to check out all your other videos now! (:
Thank-you so much!
Feeling vindicated by Lash Idole being my mascara holy grail. I have short lashes that point straight down but this is the one that somehow holds a curl and fans them out. Great stuff.
Thankyou so much for this! So much effort🥺🙌your video is the best on comparing these mascaras
Thank-you! And thanks for watching!
You took so much time with this video. Thank you!! So helpful.
Thank-you so much! I enjoyed making it
Awesome review. Just got the Lancôme thanks to your recommendation.
This is the BEST review of mascara I have ever watched and was exactly what I needed (end of the day look and if they smudged!!) I will be purchasing 3 of these in the trial size for myself including the winner to find my first favorite mascara! I have only ever worn drug store brands and I watched that video you did as well and I have tried almost all of those and while a few were super pretty when first put on I was not satisfied by the end of the day so onto the more expensive higher end mascara it is. 😊 Thank you so much for your time, money spent and dedication to this video!
Thank-you for watching!
Omgosh! This was so great! I've been on a mascara hunt! Thank you so much!
Thank-you for watching!!
This was a fun idea and super helpful
Thank you for this video! I’m using the better than sex mascara since 2019 and I want to try something new, so i’m going to try lancome as well. A really good video!
Thank-you so much! And thank-you for watching!
What an interesting approach. This was very helpful, thank you.
Thank-you for watching!
That's so funny. You picked my three favorites at the end!
They are so good!
I so appreciate this video and your time you took.
Thank-you so much!
You did great! Thanks for this great review.
Thank-you for watching!
Best review of mascaras ever! Thank you so much! I’m glad you gave a mention to the Better than Sex Mascara at the end because I actually really loved that one when you first put it on and I was thinking… oooo all that needs is another coat and it’s gorgeous! So I’m off to buy it tomorrow! Thank you!
Thank-you! That mascara is really nice, it never clumps
@@Unorthodoll Bought it! Can’t wait to use it! Yeah that’s exactly why I loved it! Zero clumps ❤️ love it!
Such a clever approach! Great video!
Thank-you!
Thank you for an awesome comparison video!!
Thank-you for watching!
I have a dog named dozer also lol 💖 I love your video, I needed to watch a video with a lot of different mascaras. Thank you!
That's awesome lol, thank-you so much!
this video is soooo underrated!!!!!!
Omg thank-you so much!
You have the most beautiful long lashes ever!!! Thanks so much for your review!!
Thank-you so much, and thanks for watching!
I love it, I want the Lancome Lash Idole so bad 🤩
I do love that mascara, it lasts forever in the tube and works so well, but I compared it against my top drugstore mascara and you should see the results czcams.com/video/aEVJqvWVEC0/video.html
Former MUA here. I enjoyed your video. You did a good job comparing the mascaras. The only thing I worry about is your tendency to curl your lashes after mascara. Because the mascara can stick to the curler, you could possibly lose lashes. It’s safer to curl your lashes before applying mascara. Great video!
Yes I absolutely understand your concern, I make sure that mascara is perfectly dry beforehand so it doesn't stick.
Wonderful comparison video! Subscribed.
Thank-you! Much appreciated ❤️
I've been using Bad Gal Bang for years and always get compliments and people asking what mascara I use but I watched this video to maybe find a new one. Seems the one I use came runner up and so I'll stick with it. Thanks for the video
Thanks for watching! I might have a better mascara for you yet czcams.com/video/aEVJqvWVEC0/video.html
Thank you for sharing. This review made my life easier. Now, I don't need to sit on the fence at all. ❤️
Thanks. 😊
Thank-you so much! I love making these videos❤️
One of the best & most thorough comparisons I've ever seen! 👏u had some tough choices. I actually prefer sample size mascaras to full size due to the shorter brush which gives me more control.
Thank-you so much! I also agree about the mini mascaras!
Saaaame
The hardest working CZcamsr award is yours! Thank you for this! You’re a gem!
Thankyou so much and thanks for watching!
Thank you so much!! Your review is true and sincere ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ i will get the bad gal bang
Thank you for watching!❤️ I love that mascara it's so good!
this was super helpful thank you!
Thank-you for watching!
Great idea for a video!
Love this thank you🩷
U r amazing thank u so much its really helped me a lot
Thank-you! I also did a drugstore version of this video and one where I compared drugstore vs high end, czcams.com/video/aEVJqvWVEC0/video.html
I love both Idole and High Impact!!!!! I have them both. The minis are my favorites actually.
Lancôme hands down has been the best mascara I’ve ever had 😭😭
Thank you for this 💕
Thanks for watching!
The best video 🎉
You're soo pretty ❤️❤️ the one thing about other "influencers" I don't like is there fakeness and plastic, and you are naturally beautiful 💕☺️
That's so sweet, thank-you so much!❤️
@@Unorthodoll ❤️❤️
I've tried EVERY one of those except the Rare Beauty and MANY more including Dior & YSL- and my ALL time favorite is Loreal Lash Paradise with 2nd place being Rimmel London Lash Accelerator Mascara. The drugstore brands have the high end BEAT!
Thank-you so much for the suggestions! I want to do a drugstore version of this video
Lol. Dior and YSL make my lashes crazy long, feathery soft full, no clumps, no spider legs, no smudging or flaking.
@@Unorthodoll My blessing! NO ONE talks about Rimmel & it's STILL one of my top 2!
@@Kindlyone777 Oh my gosh- have you tried the BURGANDY YSL?? It is GORGEOUS! I get SO many compliments on my green eyes when I wear it- but they don't really realize why!
@@UNREDACTEDTRUTH I’m going to try that next for sure. I need to start saving my coins for Food and gas. Lol. But seriously 😳. Thank you!🙏🤩
I’m literally watching this trying to figure out what I should buy lol
Idk if I should get the Lancôme or suger rush. I’ve tried badgal bang but it made my eyes a little itchy… but it was so amazing in the look lol
They're both so good! I grab for the Lancome the most though
Very helpful! Thanks
Thanks for watching!
Fantastic video! So helpful! Could you please do a comparison like this with drugstore brands as well?
Thank-you! I did one a while back, so I might have left out some new mascaras.
czcams.com/video/sWCKNX6y8dQ/video.html
Thank you so much! 🤗 I will check it out!
anybody gonna talk about how CUTE her glasses are in round 4? like those are so cute.
Thank-you!
it's interesting that most of round 1 apart from a couple you mainly picked your right eye as the winner
Yes I noticed this too so I made a tally of which eye I chose throughout the competition to make sure I wasn't flavouring one eye. In the end it came out almost exactly 50/50
Good video
I love my LANCÔME Monsieur Big Mascara before this one my fav was Bad gal bang. Now i really wanna to try Idole😁
I'll have to try that one! I'm really loving the Lash Idole right now.
I would love help with my mascara… So you actually wait till the mascara dries and curls your lashes afterwards versus curling your lashes before you put on your mascara?? How long does it take for your mascara to completely dry before you curl it?
I find curling my lashes afterwards rather than before makes the curl last way longer, but that's just my preference. I usually wait about 5-10 min for my mascara to completely dry, I'll do my lipstick or other makeup while I wait.
My fave, if you haven’t tried it, is the Fenty mascara. It makes my lashes super long and doesn’t clump too much.
I'll have to try it!
thank u very muchhhh
Thank you for watching!
Also love Better than sex but, that one's tends to have flakes that end up on my eyes. Also No 7 makes a great primer. You can almost use it by itself.
I have a mini version of the Lancome lash Idôle and it definitely doesn't give me much volume or hold curl... and the clumping is terrible for me. it doesn't smudge at least
I guess its different on different people, I found some really good drugstore mascaras that I actually think are better here's the video czcams.com/video/aEVJqvWVEC0/video.html
I hate clumping of the eyelashes, and even on these friends that you chose in most of them have climbed a little bit. it could be the applicator brush but whatever it is clumping is a no go!
I think I like a little bit of clump because I like the thick spidery look. I bet you would love the Better Than Sex mascara, it is absolutely clump proof
Hello there!
How do you curl your lashes? Just with a curler?
And if you do, do they break or fall of curling them after mascara instead of curling before mascara.
That's a good question, I've never had any trouble with my eyelash curler or any eyelash curler actually, just make sure the rubber part is still in good condition. Sometimes if I don't wait for the mascara to dry enough first my lashes will stick to the curler a little, but I just wiggle them off gently. I hope this helps.😊
Yes I just use a regular curler from Sephora
This is great! Any chance of a concealer contest? ❤️
That's a good one, I should try a bunch for oily skin
what lash curler do you use. I can never get my lashes to stay curled. my lashes are stick straight
It's a good one! The brand is called Shiseido from Sephora
Hi!!! How do you keep your lashes so healthy??
I think my lashes are just naturally long and full, but I do take care of them. I don't use extensions ever, always remove my mascara, and I am very very gentle with them. I also try to be very careful when applying false lashes and glue. I have tried lash sirum and vitamins in the past but didn't notice a difference.
I can't belive that I have almost 60% of all these mascaras 😍😍😂
If anyone cares, my favs are Climax Nars, Armani lashes that kill, roller lash by Benefit and dior show mascara
I love my roller; but I'm looking for something new
I would like to try Dior show mascara.
For me it's the Stila XXX volume because at the beginning, it is thick but only for the 3 first applications after that it's the best one for me. You don't have to apply so many layers, I have to be ready in few minutes and I love it. But most people, like the sales persons at the drugstore hate it except one of them, who liked it like me, maybe because we are from the same generation when thicker was the better. The first few applications you have to use the comb for eyelashes, the Q-tips but after it's the best one. The Clarins 4D is a great mascara, very good quality. You feel you're applying silk on your lashes. Best quality product but very very difficult to clean at the end of the day. I read all the reviews afterward and it was a comment that was there all the time. So, you need a lot of makeup remover and especially a lot of coton pieces. Expensive mascara like most of them but I bought the trials size before I got the one free. The other one I like a lot and is very good quality is Hypnose by Lancôme. Again, it's a thick mascara but you have to work a little bit with it at the beginning and after, it's one of the best. Nars a hated it. Benefit I didn't like the brush. Benefit are not good quality mascaras for the price but they are very popular. Most of them I've tried it too but some of your choice I didn't know. Idole is a good quality mascara but didn't do it for me. Neither Better than sex I prefer Stila XXX volume. There is another one by Clarins that I loved, can't remember the name and it worths it because Clarins is a very good quality mascara. My best ever because I'm a little bit older than you was Bad Gal the first edition from Benefit, in those days I didn't care about the quality, that mascara curled the lashes without the curler one layer and voilà, at the end of the day it was perfect. This year I tried the box again, here it's call Pharmaprix, there is a Yves St-Laurent, so far not impressed. Again the Better than sex not crazy about it, I wished they had the Stila XXX volume. The one, at this point, because I didn't try it all is Benefit Fan Fest. Not crazy about the mascara quality compared to Lancôme or Clarins but the effect is perfect. I used to love thicker mascara but this one is just very nice. The effect is nice. So, I will keep you up to date because I didn't try it all. I think we have the same obsession with mascaras but I have less patience than you when I apply it. It has to be right from the start when I apply it but I will give a chance to a mascara for the first 3 applications because I like thick mascara with a lot of volume. Now, I might change my mind because Fan Fest is very nice. Lighter but I like the effect.
I'm glad someone else is an enthusiastic about mascara as I am lol I've been trying tubing mascaras lately but haven't found a great one yet. After I made this video I really got into trying drugstore mascaras and I think I've been turned! My favorite for a while now is L'Oreal lash paradise you should try it, starts fairly fluid but gets thick quickly and then you can really build it up
@@Unorthodoll I don't know where you live but where I live we have expensive mascaras in our drugstore's chains. We have a box of trial mascaras for around 40$ and you get one free. It's different ones each year but you have Lancôme, Clarins, and most of them are not cheap mascaras. Benefit and Lise Water are not cheap mascaras but Benefit for my taste is not the same quality than Lancôme or Clarins. This year in the box of trials there was a Yves St-Laurent mascara. Not impressed. But I'm sure it's a very good quality mascara.
I feel like one of our eyes always has the “better” lashes, ya know? :)
I thought so at first as well, but looking back at the results it was pretty much 50/50
Do you curl after you apply the mascara?
I know people have very strong opinions against this lol but I swear it works amazing if you curl your lashes after the mascara has fully dried. As long as you are gentle, the lash curler is not damaged or dirty, and make sure the mascara is completely completely dry, like wait a whole half an hour if you have to.
Thanks for the video, however, I have to say the thick eyeliner makes it very hard to notice the difference between the Lancome and the other one.
Agreed, the next video I made I didn't wear any eyeliner and it was much better
Covergirl n max factor makes bomb mascaras. I used to have some max factor mascara n till date Ive not found anything that matches that quality drugstore or high end.
I'll have to try the max factor
My lancome lash idole is my top pick followed by lancome monsieur big third choice is tarte maneater
I'll have to try them out!
Yup definitely works for me hopefully you too..
What eyeshadow do you use in the intro?
I actually just used my bronzer, I think it was from benefit
Guys you should try the size up mascara its from Sephora and i have it it makes my lashes sooooo long ❤❤❤❤
I'll have to grab some!
Whats the right name of the winner one ? I cant find it on Internet ❤
I have them all listed in the description!
Thank you. 🌻🌻🌻🌻⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thank-you for watching!
Great video always a like 👍👍 I'm sending out love to everyone 💙💛❤💚💜
Thank-you!
IDOLE IS PERFECTION
have you tried hourglass caution?
No I haven't! I will try it
colorpop lengthining is BOMB
I'll have to try it!
Too faced BTS or Clinique high impact?
Both are in the competition, I really like BTS for a more feathery natural look
I love the winner too
I go between the top three, but that one is amazing!
I want to know which had the least clumping
I'd say the top three were great, also too faced better than sex was one of the least clumpy
I don't know if anyone already mentioned it. But mini mascaras are going to want to be better than the normal length. Because they are trying to convince you to buy the normal size one .
I didn't know that, my next video is going to be full sized mascaras
why would they do that, they wouldn't get return customers
Lancôme hypnose drama is the best
My husband would say they all look the same too🤣
I’ve watched a couple of your comparing mascara videos, and I noticed you tend to show a preference for your right(? I believe I flipped that correctly) lashes. Just something to keep in mind when you’re comparing mascara’s like this: our eyes/lashes aren’t identical and don’t react to mascara identically. You may have a subconscious preference for how your right eye’s lashes react to mascara in general.
Yes I checked for that, it actually came out to be pretty even for each side
What about allergy tested.? You should mención the ingredients of the mascara. In USA there are a bunch of expensive products, but they are synthetic, just because the brand, you pay 25-30 bucks but it may have allergy reactions
That's a great point, I don't have sensitive eyes so I didn't even think about it. I'll look into it
I have eczema and you will be better with the French mascaras. The quality is better than the American ones.
Can you do drugstore mascaras please
They came in the mail today😊 should be up in a week or two
the best is Clímax Extreme (the black)
I'll have to try it
A huge component of mascara is removal. Many do not wash off easily which is a bitch.
Good point!
Yes, Clarins 4D for example but the quality is very good. It has a silky feeling on the lashes.
Benefit is the best
I do love that mascara! It never clunps
Dang she's still so pretty without makeup
Awe thank you!
You said: “they’re not luxury mascaras, but they’re definitely high end”, so I wonder, what’s the difference. Isn’t “luxury” and “high end” the same thing?
I should've clarified. I was referring to designer brands as luxury, and brands like the ones you buy at Sephora as high end.
@@Unorthodoll, thank you for replying! Where would you position MAC? It can be bought at either Sephora, Macy’s, Nordstrom, MAC Store, and even ULTA. The reason I ask is because this brand is still choice #1 for us cosmetologists when it comes to all makeup services regardless the occasion. So, I was wondering what your opinion would be.
That's a great question, 10-15 years ago I would have called it luxury because there really wasn't much to choose from other than drugstore, MAC, and Mary kay. But today I would consider it high end, kinda pricey but worth it for the quality.
@Unorthodoll , oh thank you. I wonder though, where were you 10-15 years ago, what country, that there wasn’t much to choose from other than drugstore, MAC, or Mary Kay? What country was it?! It buffles me when people say that there was not much going on, especially the young ones, who were pretty much kids 10-15 years ago, and didn’t really have any idea on what was actually going on in the world of cosmetics, and what you could actually find. From 2000 to 2006 I used to travel, so I still have some eyeshadows: Lancome - bought in Turkey, Chanel - bought in Russia, Dior - bought in Romania, also Dior, Ester Lauder, Clinique, and Yves Saint Laurent - all bought here, in California. All shadows are pretty used up but definitely not finished, and still in great condition. If I had an easy access to all that back then, where were you that you hadn’t?
I've always lived in Ontario Canada, I guess we used to have Clinique that I would see once a year or so at a booth in a mall. But as a young broke beauty addict I had only heard about fancy brands like MAC from magazines. I was excited to get my hands on some wrong colored dream matte mousse.
Mascara world cup be like
First 😉
not a fan of the way she applies it tbh
You gotta try it! works really well on my long lashes but just make sure the mascara is completely dry before curling
@@Unorthodollit's because you are brushing and not wiggling. I don't know why you aren't. You can edit and the content is great but your application is odd and makes it difficult to see how they will do if one applies them correctly. Also you should swipe off the wand before use on the edge of the mascara container to reduce clumping. I don't get why you curl afterward but I don't think that's as as much as an issue as just brushing instead off wiggling.
Now I just watched past 10:30 and you're mentioning you don't like it because it clumps, it's a great mascara and if you get rid of the extra product like I commented it would be a better test to see clumping
Thanks for the Match, this is helpful Information, since I used other Products. Well, I do have Lancôme Hypnôse at Home, it has a Scent of Roses! ❤️ 👍 👍
And I own a Benefit "they're real" Mini. Also from Urban Decay I have one with Primer. They are all not bad, but I like the Lancôme best from the 3.
Surprisingly I like one from Rituals theese Days, that comes in a golden Tube.
I do have few tiny Hair so I like a decent Amount of Product and a fine Brush with short Bristles.
😉 👍
One Question I have:
I thought it would be better to curl the Lashes BEFORE we apply Mascara! I wonder how you can manage to curl them later (maybe you are using another Method?) and not demage your Lashes?!
🤔
Please take care!!!
❤️🧡💛💚
Another Thing I just recognized: you are using another Technique for your Application: you come from one side only with the Brush and this is the Side towards your Eyeball, and you are using uplifting strokes only.
Also you do not brush them again with another Spooly! 🤔
In fact this is just Opposite to my Methode:
I am using the Brush with sidewise Moovement (maybe because I have fewer Lashes) and I also come from behind and I use the Tip of the Wand for the lower Lashline.
Also I love my extra Spooly Brush (it is from the Brand "Da Vincy", they have vegan and non vegan Brushes, also for Painters) to brush them thru again before they are dry, just to avoid Clumpyness.
I loooove them nicely seperated (maybe because of this the Lancôme Hypnôse is one of my Favourites, while you did not like it at all 😉 ).
😃 ❤️ 👍
Hm, I am curious: how would the Result have been if you would have always compared
A) two mascaras from the same Brand, and if you have just Singles left, than
B) compare two mascaras that have a similar Prize Point!
For Round 2 is would have been more of a Brand Match than?!
But anyway - I liked the Idea of the Bag and pulling them out too ❤️🧡💛💚💙 It is a really good Method to do a Mascara Ranking, also for us at Home as an Inspiration. Hm, I think I want to try the Drugstore Mscaras like that?!
How difficult it is to compare and compare to have best Results!
Ok, another Tip of mine for clumpy, almost dried-out Mascaras: add a little #Rosewater 🌹 ❤️🧡💛 ... than shake and stir ... tadaaaa!!!
Ahh, final Impressions: by the End of round 2 - when you had 4 Mascaras left, that was an Eye Opener! From this Point they were all Winners, f. E.
a) MAC Extreme Dimension is for Day Make Up Routine, guess your Husband like this Look a Lot. 😉 👍 👍
b) the Smoothy Mascara so looks like: relaxed Holiday Beach Lashes! So I would use it for this purpose!
c) Lancôme Hypnôse you can use for the Evening (I have to say, I liked your Lash with this Mascara, whenever you had it on the Start)
d) Benefit Bad Gal Bang is perfect for a Night out, it screems Party! 🍾🥂🍹
["They're real" for me is the 2nd Choice for Daily Wear, I guess it might be ideal for any Office Meeting.
The "Better than Sex Mascara": try it for Winter Holidays please! ]
P. S.: nice Greets from Vienna, Europe (Mozart, etc.).
From Europe that's so cool! Thank-you so much for the comment. I guess I should try some different applications and see what works best, I loved your thoughts on the final four. I did another video comparing them to my favourite drugstore mascaras and the results were pretty shocking 😊 czcams.com/video/aEVJqvWVEC0/video.html