Excellent. Being a Native New Yorker, I loved how both games captured the essence of NYC. Rockstar at one point was based in NYC, so it only made sense that they'd draw from there immediately surroundings. Their offices were south of Herald Square if my memory serves me correctly
It's cool! Can I ask a question? People say New York is dark much as GTA IV, but when I look at the videos of there it doesn't looks like. Is GTA IV's atmosphere realistic or just too dark?
@@DarthErdogan realistic of when the game was made which was 2007/2008. Some of the pictures are doctored up, but what real estate developers don't get is that there was a beauty to the city's grime
In GTA V they keeped Grove Street of San Andreas. In GTA VI they'll keep Ocean Views of Vice City But in GTA IV they didn't keep anything from GTA III 😢
I wish they kept emblematic places like Malibu club, cine studio, the golf club and Diaz/tommy's mansion. I mean not the exact same mansion but the same zone design like grove street in GTA V.
No like Rockstar used New York as a base for GTA3's Liberty while the city itself is like a mixture of North Jersey cities, Baltimore and among others just like Rockport(the setting of Need For Speed Most Wanted '05) takes inspiration from NYC for the Downtown area, New England-ish style towns for the residential area and Camden for the Industrial area(the borough is even named Camden Industrial)
It's not a remaster dude it's just a definitive edition I don't know why people don't understand, do you know what is a remaster Mafia 1 remake is a remaster that is what we called a remaster
@@JJ-ev9uzdude is a fool that just lets you know how good gta 3 was & is still lol I have it on mobile & I enjoy whenever I have the chance whenever I'm not tired from work lol gta 3 is so much fun to play with
Nice video. GTA 4 LC has more of a small town/cosy feel to it albeit being much bigger and more detailed than GTA 3 which, to me, captures the NYC atmosphere better somehow.
I see what you mean regarding the vibe of GTA III. It looks like a part of NYC you never knew existed. Which says a lot for me being from NYC and in my 50s
I love liberty city so much. I like it because it forces the devs to make a walkable city that is still fun to drive on, which means that the devs had to become more intentional with their map design and also it means we get loads of different alternative transportation methods. Also the small map size means much more detail on the actual map and interiors. And that is probably why GTA IV has better interiors than GTA V.
GTA four is way better than GTA three because it have more realistic graphics and it’s in New York. The only thing that GTA 3 has is Brooklyn not New York City just like in GTA4
Funny cause 3 doesn't actually follow 4 . Crazy how all the gta since 3 I'm sure other to but for me I've been playing since 3 . Missed the dlc on 4 to be a Spanish guy? And some of the psp ones 😭
The irony is the DeFinitive Edition of the Grand Theft Auto 3 rendition of Liberty City has more realistic graphics than the Grand Theft Auto 4 rendition of Liberty City!
i like how you had the claude costume for niko
I always thought that GTA III looked a lot like Seattle. The city is relatively small, has diverse architecture, but feels giant when you are in it.
Na it still felt small 😂
I mean GTA 3’s liberty city isn’t exclusively based on NYC like GTA 4’s is. It was actually meant to be based on various American cities.
@@VOTE_REFORM_UKI did not know that at all.
But I don't disagree -- do you know any sources to read up on that though?
Excellent. Being a Native New Yorker, I loved how both games captured the essence of NYC. Rockstar at one point was based in NYC, so it only made sense that they'd draw from there immediately surroundings. Their offices were south of Herald Square if my memory serves me correctly
They're still here. On Broadway near Houston so basically on the border of Noho and Soho
@@germain83 for some reason, I thought they'd moved. Thx
It's cool! Can I ask a question? People say New York is dark much as GTA IV, but when I look at the videos of there it doesn't looks like. Is GTA IV's atmosphere realistic or just too dark?
@@DarthErdogan realistic of when the game was made which was 2007/2008. Some of the pictures are doctored up, but what real estate developers don't get is that there was a beauty to the city's grime
@@avace917 Thank you for the answer :)
1:53 look like liminal space
Nah you have watch to much liminal space videos to think your gas station in your town is a backrooms level
I cant wait to see GTA Vice City vs GTA 6 comparisons. Its gonna be a huge huge difference, bigger than gta 3, 4 and sa, 5
In GTA V they keeped Grove Street of San Andreas.
In GTA VI they'll keep Ocean Views of Vice City
But in GTA IV they didn't keep anything from GTA III 😢
@@agustin009 Thats cause GTA 3 is barely accurate to New York
@@agustin009they kept francis intl airport
I wish they kept emblematic places like Malibu club, cine studio, the golf club and Diaz/tommy's mansion. I mean not the exact same mansion but the same zone design like grove street in GTA V.
@@agustin009 They kept Times Square
I like to think that, instead of being the same city in a different canon, they're just two separate cities with the same nickname.
Like New York and New York, New York
don’t forget about New York, we can’t forget that
Dude, this video deserves more, you have the got the detailed locations, and etc. great job!!! Respect ++
Good job also i love how both have the same clothes
3D LIBERTY : GOOD
HD LIBERTY : NAILED IT !!!
3d liberty was 2001 they were ahead of it's time
This is basically North Jersey (Newark, Jersey City, Patterson) vs New York City
Nah they the same
Bro I Thought This Was New Jersey
No like Rockstar used New York as a base for GTA3's Liberty while the city itself is like a mixture of North Jersey cities, Baltimore and among others just like Rockport(the setting of Need For Speed Most Wanted '05) takes inspiration from NYC for the Downtown area, New England-ish style towns for the residential area and Camden for the Industrial area(the borough is even named Camden Industrial)
@@AnimeGaming-od1nf
Portland in GTA 3/LCS is definitely Newark
@@RhodesianSAS-gn4qpDo you live on the east coast?
So Much effort put inside!
GTA 3 Definitive Edition feels so much more empty than original, GTA IV, a 2008 game has surely better graphics than a bad 2021 or 2022 remaster
cuz it's a HD game
@@danoni2696 good explanation
It's not a remaster dude it's just a definitive edition I don't know why people don't understand, do you know what is a remaster Mafia 1 remake is a remaster that is what we called a remaster
@@bilal6865 🤦♂️
@@bilal6865 no that's a remake
man my favorite gta with the remaster version brings a nostalgic
Both of these games were ahead of their time
3 is trash. 4 looks ahead of it's time
@@eternallife8898compare GTA 3 with other games in 2001 😂
@@JJ-ev9uzdude is a fool that just lets you know how good gta 3 was & is still lol I have it on mobile & I enjoy whenever I have the chance whenever I'm not tired from work lol gta 3 is so much fun to play with
@@eternallife8898
For real, GTA 4 is still better than some games coming out today.
GTA 4 liberty city still the best location in GTA games
nah bro it is the worst
@@superone-lu1lr damn i personally agree with the other guy but i kinda wna hear your opinion about it
Los Santos and vice city is far better ❤
@@ompachpind7106Los Santos feels vanilla and bland for me. Vice City rocks.
I love the vibe of GTA 4’s liberty city. It feels so much more alive to me than Los Santos.
What is the song of 2:45? It sounds really good
What is the background music at 4:06 pls
We got comparing GTA 3 MAP to gta 4s map before GTA 6
That beat is SICK! Where can I find it?
I thought they’d at least remake time square in gta 3 definitively edition
The Booth tunnel also has some nice realtime shadows.. on consoles.
Nice video. GTA 4 LC has more of a small town/cosy feel to it albeit being much bigger and more detailed than GTA 3 which, to me, captures the NYC atmosphere better somehow.
i think gta iv captures the realism of nyc. the people the props and mostly everything even the locations so imo gta iv
I see what you mean regarding the vibe of GTA III. It looks like a part of NYC you never knew existed. Which says a lot for me being from NYC and in my 50s
GTA 3 gives me more of a classic 60's/70's feeling of New York with a dark atmosphere. Like in the movie Taxi Driver.
@@GhostRider-uk3xvi need to watch that
Nope, not at all lol.
Looks like gta 4 lc is elder brother of gta 3 lc❤❤❤
I love the vibe of GTA 4’s liberty city. It feels so much more alive than even Los Santos.
Idk why people call it the triangle building, it’s obviously the daily bugle👀
is the mod GTA III Rage Classic?
Naw that house for the don is that abandoned house with the sultan rs behind it
I feel that the LC from GTA 3 to GTA 4 are officially canon due to development changes
How
@@BosniaNewsNow They develop through the years making it to expand
@@agnesfruto7686I agree and I always assumed that
Different verse bro, gta 3 Vice City and San Andreas are the 3d universe. IV and V are the HD universe. They don’t have any ties to each other
@@kebobarmageddov2110 idk some events happen around the same time in both universes which line up nicely, like the takeover of grove st by the ballas
1:36
typical gta. i haven't noticed that 😂
great 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Well done Mr luiz lopezzzzz
background music?
aint no one gonna talk how gta 3 chinatown is in brooklyn
I love liberty city so much. I like it because it forces the devs to make a walkable city that is still fun to drive on, which means that the devs had to become more intentional with their map design and also it means we get loads of different alternative transportation methods. Also the small map size means much more detail on the actual map and interiors. And that is probably why GTA IV has better interiors than GTA V.
The scaling is so wrong in the Defective Edition.
sad that the 2021 game looks worse than the 2008 game, rockstar what happened to you
Which game came in 2021
@@Bee_Bomgta trilogy the definitive edition which includes the remaster of gta 3
Not like the 2021 game is a remaster or something
Brights lights in the big city
What’s that music called? 3:46
Gta 4 remake or remaster?
Claudes safehouse doesn't exist in gta 4
Noice
I think that he is polish just like me😂
GTA four is way better than GTA three because it have more realistic graphics and it’s in New York. The only thing that GTA 3 has is Brooklyn not New York City just like in GTA4
Mafia house and Pegorino house aren’t the same mafia house in gta 4 is the old mansion in New Jersey
how did you make the graphics in gta 4 worse than in gta 3
No it isn’t
Кто придумал это безумное сравнение 3-ка не достойна 4-ки да и карты разительно отличаются
No exaggeration. it's just a comparison.
Funny cause 3 doesn't actually follow 4 . Crazy how all the gta since 3 I'm sure other to but for me I've been playing since 3 . Missed the dlc on 4 to be a Spanish guy? And some of the psp ones 😭
Gta 3 definitive edition looks better than gta 4 in gta 4 is everything dark
Liberty City itself is dark😂
Salvatori's House on Gta 3 and LCS > Gta IV
Mafia house in gta iv is abonded actually u showed the wrong location
M
The irony is the DeFinitive Edition of the Grand Theft Auto 3 rendition of Liberty City has more realistic graphics than the Grand Theft Auto 4 rendition of Liberty City!
Wow they sucked thats the saddest nyc ive seen in a videogame😂 really did better in gta 4
It was supposed to be like that, its like the american nightmare
GTA 3 wasn’t just based on nyc, but multiple cities
Not only is it supposed to be like that, but how about you check when the game was released?
I ain't going to lie even though Grove street games kind of messed up the trilogy but at least they added GTA v you can see it got better features
😂i
Time square 3:33