Starmer Deals With Dumb Questions From Beth Rigby!
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2024
- As Keir Starmer took over as Prime Minister, it seems the type of questions he will face are not unlike those that the likes of Boris Johnson, Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak would deal with...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @maximilienrobespierre1
Patreon - / maxrobespierre
Amazon - amzn.to/2QoRauj
Facebook: - / maximilienrobespierre1794
Twitch - / max_robespierre
Merch - maximilienrobespierre1.live/m...
Twitter - / maxfrobespierre
Buy Me A Coffee - www.buymeacoffee.com/Robespierre
#keirstarmer
#primeminister
#labour
Credit: Sky News
You got rid of Tories but not Tory media.
There next
They're*, but yes they are, we desperately need media reform @@chrissanders1027
You will never get rid of right wing media, we’ve always had one
You need some left wing media 👍
Just need to try and be polite to them, engage them, but effectively let their toshgo overyour head. I've been doing that for years with the kids!
What is all this 100 days crap?. Why do we find this need to use Americanism in our politics?🤷♂️
because brexit. the grand sale of the uk to the usa
You got Johnson, that's pretty American...
And new legislation can't be passed in the UK in the first 100 days.
@@MikePhillips-pl6ov But you can change how to deal with legislation, and i think it can be passed in 100 days (as long as it is in the manifesto and not against the law)
I would have said, I haven't said anything about 100 days, where did you get that from?
It's going to take journalists a bit of time to get used to dealing with intelligent adults instead of spoilt public school kids.
Now now. As an American public school kid, this statement is inaccurate. The Tories are way too spoiled to go to school...
@@heavyhauler426 "public school" in the UK = "private school" in the US.
@@Aethid Did I stutter?
@@Aethidpublic school in England, not UK = private school everywhere else.
Yep
They have been loosing under the same rules for 14 years, and now they are expected to apologise for winning under the same rules..
It’s bonkers..
With the Tories and their client media it all boils down to Some Animals Are More Equal Than Others. Hypocrisy, bigotry, arrogance. Voting for them is not a political decision, it is a character flaw.
Guess they are no better then, might as well stuck with the Tories. Your argument is why we never get real change.
@@Sbwarwickand you are both wrong. Political illiteracy is the scourge of this country. Do better. Educate yourself.
@@Lynnefromlyn I think you're the one that needs to do better and stop being so patronising. There are multiple reasons for the issues we have, political literacy is one but so is an attitude that is being displayed by the original comment. If you believe it is a single reason causing this then you need to do some serious educating yourself.
@@Sbwarwick It hasn't been 72 hours, ffs.
Media bias against Labour will continue
And towards Reform
@@edwardvickers5506 shocking!
I suspect there will be some much needed media reform especially with the Gbeebies and Talk TV news channels.
Bias against Labour? You're joking right?
He's already had meetings with Murdoch....don't you get it?
She's an embarrassment lately.
She a Tory with a sense of entitlement and superiority........in her head.....sounds familiar and look where its landed the UK.
TRYING TO OUTSMART STARMER.....SHE HAS NO CHANCE.
She's as thick as a brick
Lately 🤔🤣
I agree. She's not always be as crap as this. She's well and truly lost her mojo.
What's happened to Beth Rigby? This election period has really exposed how bad she has become.
I think she has orders from others on Sky these days. Same with Kay Burley, although sometimes she goes off her script.
Couldn't agree more!
Issue is, no one publicly sees the script, so they think it's her asking the question
Started to believe her own hype and became massively self important.
She sees herself as untouchable now
@@Todischo really? She was worse in 2019. You likely just like Starmer so there's inconsistency in your assessment as he's had it easier than any labor leader in history
First 100 days? How about outlawing foreign ownership of newspapers and news channels etc.?
On some levels I would love that, but it's also terrifyingly close to what Putin has done to the media in Russia. "Foreign Agent" media is basically a death knell for any independent voices.
@@CountScarlioni The US insists that the media owners are US citizens.
Starmer has already acted. Rwanda cancelled. Border Command Centre instigated. Both within 100 hours not days.
👍
I noticed that the media are misquoting him. He said that the plan had been "dead and buried for months". (And also that even the gangs knew that it wasn't a deterrent due to numbers).
Has he stopped arms sales to Isreal? And will he ever?
Wess streetings meeting with the drs this week the bma has already sent a letter saying they will work with labour .ive not heard anything from reform other than pat themselves on the back for winning 4 seats lol .best thing was seeing Galloway go .he never lasts long .and labour have always got better of him i suppose he can put himself up for election in gaza .
@@am1156 Would any of the other parties do it? (I think they should, at least as long as Netan is Pm)
And this is something that will not be easy accomplished, and by voting in those independents (without influence) doesn't change a thing, oh wait now you still have Ian Duncan Smith.
I don't give a crap about the polls or about the emotions resulting from it. I do care about what happens next. And this journalist utterly failed to engage with the real questions.
She seems to be falling into the Robert Peston world of journalistic nothingness these days.
She should have asked if he used the FPTP to get this majority, and will he support PR in the future?
I like how Phil explained it, don't campaign (or not that much) in seats you already win, go to the marginals to get those seats, it's FPTP after all.
They can't accept that their favourite political party has been given the elbow. They all appear to be in shock still!
Regardless of Labour vote share, nice to see that Tory efforts to manipulate results through boundary changes and mandatory voter ID didn't bear fruition.
Good point.
Boundary changes are done by an independent commission and were aimed at reducing the advantage Labour had. Do some basic research and stop acting so anti-democratic
@@SbwarwickBut the ID requirement was an attempt at gerrymandering - even Jacob Rees Mogg admitted that fact on TV.
@@Sbwarwick Are you naive enough to believe that there would have been no attempt from the Tories to influence what action was taken by the commission?
Actually feeling proud of a politician is a strange feeling isn't it?
I thought I would dislike him but…. I’m in shock. I think the Ming vase strategy was genuinely just… A STRATEGY?!💀💀 wtf he sounds like a human being here 😭 I’m actually hopeful for the country
I really like him in feeling positive, he is centralist or a soft left which is what we need
@amigos2841 he's more right wing than Stanley Mathew's.
@@bigchristie tbh he is more centralist than right wing or like I said a slightly centre left leader
I don’t think it matters if he’s Centrist or left of center. What matters is that he’s not blatantly corrupt like the last lot.
I voted for a moderate and centrist party to begin the enormous and glacial task of rebuilding our country. I don’t want quick fixes, i want well planned LASTING CHANGE.
❤❤❤❤❤
Hear hear hear!
Well done, Keir. Great attitude.
Perfect Response Well done Keir 👏❤
"How do you feel," seems to be the number one favourite question that the media ask. Its vacuous and tiresome and lazy.
Exactly, what do the feelings matter.
Should be asking Shapps, Mordaunt, Rees-Mogg, Liz Truss, from Dylan's Like A Rolling Stone, "How does it feel?
To be without a home? Like a complete unknown?"
I am very feel
@@o0oLukeo0o0o Winner.
@@o0oLukeo0o0o i wish they said that!
Journalists are going to need to raise their game, Starmer will run rings around them if they keep on this juvenile attack lines. He's not walking on broken glass anymore, he's in charge and confident. Everything I've seen so far suggests the country made the right decision.
Of course they made the right decision that was never in doubt
Laura Kuennesberg must be crapping herself......
The country didn't make this decision though 😅
@@Sbwarwick if that's the way you feel, campaign for proportional representation. Please.
@@Sbwarwick Indeed, Labour got 34% of the vote share and only about 20% of the total electorates vote. I get it, I want Proportional Representation too.
But, and this is the big BUT, a lot of people didn't vote, and if none of them wanted a labour majority, all of them could have got off their butts and tried to vote for someone else, and there was enough of them to make a difference even under our unfair system.
If people don't vote, they don't have the right to complain.
Regardless, It's so refreshing to see adults in politics for once.
So refreshing to hear a straight answer and not a pre prepared response that were delivered by incompetent Truss and Sunak
I totally agree, I was so tired of Sunak constantly giving meaningless buzzword answers like "I promised to deliver and we're going to deliver", no substance at all.
Sir Starmer talks like a competent adult.
Beth Rigby has been performing really badly recently
Depends what one understands as "performing". Performing Journalist, yeah, poor. Performing Monkey, pretty darn good! 👍
Sky may no longer be part of the Murdoch Empire, but its machinery and mindset (and minions) remain in situ.
God! It's so refreshing hearing an adult Prime Minister talking for a change, rather than someone repeating meaningless slogans.
This is where the right wing media will go now, I'm afraid.
Looks like France have rejected the Far Right tonight, if so, it helps to make the Far Right media look badly out of touch.
yeah but will they still be allowed to swap licence fee money for advertising revenue. or will it be re-nationalised. :) they just lost their cash cow. ..got a huge awwwww from me 😂
It's seats that count, not vote share. The Tories made sure of that because they used to benefit from it. The low vote share is due in part to tactical voting.
Boris had 8% more than Corbyn.
Starmer had 10% more than Sunak..
Yet one is considered acceptable and the other intolerable.,..
@@JohnRussell-y3m Starmer's approach to getting elected also included showing how the Tories are less electable. Corbyn's approach encouraged people to vote for him, but also to vote against him.
@JohnRussell-y3m one had a majority of over 170, the other less than 80. One recieved over 43% of the vote, the other less than 34%. You know they are not comparable stop being so blatantly anti-democratic and biased.
@@JohnRussell-y3m the problem is that Starmer didn't win the election, the Tories lost it and that trick only works once. If we don't want another Tory government in five years' time (and we bloody don't) then he needs to pull some impressive stuff out. He fewer votes than both Corbyn elections and he needs to realise that no-one was excited to vote Starmer, they just wanted the Tories gone.
@@JohnRussell-y3m Because as the vote is split between more parties (because neither of the main parties appeals to more and more people) the election result doesn't produce a convincing mandate for rule. If you don't believe me, just try this thought experiment. Suppose the Tories (or whatever party you dislike) managed to win this many seats with 15-20% of the vote. A party with the support of so few in the country should not have near unlimited power to govern. They should at the least be forced into coalition with other parties, where between them they have 50% of the voteshare.
Beth Rigby reminds me of a spitting image puppet
Yes somebody else making their lips move
Dwane Dibbly
😂I was thinking, a gone to seed cabbage patch doll😂
Starmer looks like a proper PM instead of a talking clown head.
😂 you centrists base everything on looks and vibes but your heroes don’t have any ideas and no record of success in the real world. Come on down, Jacqui Smith! 😮
@@joetotale6354Who on Earth are you addressing in& what are you about?
Watching and listening to Starmer makes me physically sick. He is such a vile lizard.
@@joetotale6354 ??????????
@@joetotale6354 What a load of gobbledegook!
Beth Rigby is a terrible reporter.
It's a prerequisite for all Sky journalists.
She thinks she some sort of political heavy hitter, she is not.
Na she's half decent. What u on?
@@40yearoldvirgil15 not on the basis of the vapid questions she asked.
You can criticise her for a good many valid reasons, but you don't need to bring her voice into it, that's just tacky.
Labour are saying "Country first, party second". The Tories used to say "Money first, money second, money third, and then we break for a spot of lunch".
According to a BBC article on Cornish fishermen there was a Labour 'coup'. I thought they'd won an election rather than overthrown a Tory Junta.
“Labour don’t do anything, they have no plan!”
*Labour immediately start doing things and elucidating/enacting plans*
“Do you really have a mandate to do things and enact a plan?”
I used to think Beth Rigby was an objective journalist, but since her interview of the candidates for leadership of the SNP, i now know she has a hidden agenda behind every question,
I didn’t see those interviews myself, what do you think her agenda is? To me, she just comes across as a shitty journalist, the sort you normally see at tabloids.
Most journalists are Tory. The so-called unbiased BBC is packed full of them, I believe that Clive Myrie is a member of the Garrick Club. Laura Kuenssberg makes no bones about it, it's obvious. Her face when the exit poll was announced was precious. The Tory press was neutered by Starmer, no mean feat over 6 weeks.
Yeah, Rupert Murdock's agenda 🙄
Starmer is happy to talk to Murdoch's media@@daniellewis4226
Perhaps she is after Kuennsberg's job?
Yet another stupid and meaningless Americanism of '100 days'
Based on the Roosevelt administrations' publicity.
@@AndoCommando1000 yes in a 100 days we will have to see what has been achieved, but if would foolish to give answers to those question, before something concrete has been achieved, I for one would not gave the opposition the ammunition to shot me down on any endeavour that has not been bought to fruition at lest give them a 30 day start after all the country is a land of intelligent progressive politics? Isn't It??
@@AndoCommando1000 That question has a similar quality to Rigby's. Yes, it is. The fact that 100 is a nice round number has nothing to do with the question. The only reason for her asking is that this is an American custom. Period.
@@garryferrington811 which has what to do with UK politics?
@@AndoCommando1000 Yes
Beth Rigby has a horrible grin when she thinks she is being clever.
She must be a Tory.
No she could never be that clever.
Brilliant Speech Bravo Keir ❤
@@DrMontagueoh and the z Tories did not 😮
@@DrMontague So, just to be clear, who were you hoping who would be elected who would be cutting less than you think Starmer's Labour will?
@@DrMontague There’s nothing left to cut, but they’ll be a few coffers from VAT on private schools 😂
Raising the taxes on the rich should be done ASAP...
Why?
@@independent-ts6ys starmer said no it's his friends
@@gdfggggg there's gonna need to be a massive investment to make up for 14 years of tories doing f all.
think about the lack of investment for 14 years all of that and a lot more to repair the damage will need to be spent in the next few years.
that is not cheap and the labour party plan to grow the country out of the problem is unlikely to do enough taxing the average/poor person at the moment would not only be a bad financial decision but terrible political one so that leaves the rich who can afford to see net pay go down not only because the rich are seeing their incomes rise in many cases but because any losses will not be felt
Credit where it's due Well done Keir ❤
Despite my previous cynicism , it feels like there is finally an adult in the room.
It's really quite refreshing. No grandstanding. No evasions. No performative cruelty.
Also it was gratuitous when the Tories did it a few years ago but we need to take back the union flag from the fascists & hooligans
Who are these fascists and hooligans you mention.
The fascists in America took our flag and altered it. Traitors.
He’s got 5 years, the next 3 months are not really what most give a toss about.
You're right, and even more right about 3 months and not 100 days. "100 days" comes from the same source as the "supermajority" - cause you're the 51 state of America, or some wish they were.
With in 100days it'll still be a shitshow.
Did the tories get these questions? I don’t recall that they did.
Just like America with Fox. Oh who owns Fox and Sky🤔🤔🤔🤔
WHO KNOWS? Maybe a rotten Australian womaniser? Last wedding @ over 90? How comes he didn't have the SUNKS' subscription, ACTUALLY (rishy washy copywrit)?
Silvester "Sly" Moorcock?
He won't live much longer, but the damage is done. His money will continue to do so
Journalism in the uk is extraordinary lame and has been for many years now, especially in the Cameron Osborne austerity when the media was very quiet.
Even through the bojo and farage brexit campaign with the media helping with the lies. Time for changing the media and press in the uk.
End the lack of credible journalism now.
I didn’t think I had much faith in Starmer but I am quietly confident now.
He seems competent and a potentially great asset for us.
Omg sounds like we have a decent pm with honesty honour and integrity
Let's get on with making this country decent again after 14 years of grift corruption incompetence and lies
honesty??? hahahahah are you serious? The man lies more than women who manipulate men for money....Ive never seen anyone flip flop answers as much as he does.. but time will tell whether he's good or not..
A journalist asking stupid questions? Surely not. This has never happened before!!!!
And one that works for Sky to boot!
She’s particularly pathetic , and that slow way of speaking like she’s speaking with depth 😂 like braverman , Mordaunt etc.. all irrelevant
None of these client journalists even attempted to hold one single Tory to task in 14 long years. The minute we've a Labour PM, "What can you concretely promise to accomplish specifically within 100 days precisely?"
Beth Rigby lost any credibility(?) she had during the recent mayoral and by-elections. She seemed to be in a competition with Laura Kuenssberg as to who could parrot the most CCHQ talking points.
I can’t believe what’s happening to her.She’s actually getting worse with her questioning! How ministers don’t lose their tempers with this type of questioning is beyond me,but I suppose you have to show who the better person is.If people remember,the Tories actually boycotted GOOD MORNING BRITAIN for a year during Covid because of the sort of questions that were put to them.Starmer seems to be the type that’ll tough it out instead of listening to advisors who say, ‘Boycott this reporter,or boycott that reporter’.
You are correct my friend. I think Rigby feels that she is being upstaged by Kuenssberg and wanted to get her oar in. LK is an unashamed Tory fan girl and I suspect Beth Rigby is too deep down.
Seeing Laura K's face during the election coverage as the results came in was almost a Portillo moment in itself. She looked like she was trying to swallow a mouth full of live wasps.
I didn't see that but maybe I missed it. I seen her being one of the only ones willing to hammer the tories.
I have full confidence in Starmer.
Sorry Beth. You’re making a fool out of yourself.
I lost any respect for her on the day Johnson resigned when she made a fool of herself. As the press were waiting for him to come out of Number 10 and the staff were gathering, Johnson’s wife appeared and Rigby spent the next few minutes embarrassing herself ‘ooooh, the baybeeee, she’s got the baybeeee, awwww, he baybeeeee’. It was nauseating
The Conservatives did very little in their 14 years. Why do Labour get 100 days to fix the Conservative mess?
Different times than Blair, 5 national parties got a significant share of the vote, not 2 or 3 as per usual. Time for a change to the electoral system. If you add up Lib/Lab/Greens you get well over 50% of the public voting for a more progressive country.
And that's even with a lot of protest votes going to reform.
Amazing the lack of coverage the greens get compared to Deform UK
It's annoying that Reform managed to end up with 5 MPs. Nige will point to how they got more votes, but I think it is just that Green voters are smarter. They voted Green in large numbers where the Green candidate had a good chance of winning, and voted tactically in other areas.
Greens are an also ran. Not really newsworthy and never have anything to say.
What about Lib Dems? Barely mentioned! They got 14 times more seats!
The Government has changed overnight, but unfortunately it will take far longer for the Right Wing Media! I'm surprised she didn't ask him 'What is your favourite colour? Oh dear.....stick with it Keir!
Most of them had really dumb questions but i have to agree those were far the dumbest. The media in the UK is just ridiculous.
It's great to see Starmer finally be able to behave like himself - instead of carrying that ming vase!! He is intelligent, articulate, authentic - from this life long tory voter, it is music to my ears. This is what politicians and government SHOULD be. The journos better get used to it, and not show up their own stupidity by asking fool questions.
I'm warming to Starmer.
Yeah me too.
Beth: "Please dig yourself a hole into which we will push you when you fail."
Kier: "No thanks Beth, take your shovel and hand it to Cruella"
People care about having adults back in charge, not the juvenile antics of the last 3 prime ministers, enabled by the previous 2.
She's asked worse questions than that
So, in interviews with any Tory MPs (as at 3rd July) Beth and her colleagues will be asking them:
'How did you feel about the exit polls?'
'What do you think about the collapse of the Tory vote to the far right?'
''How will you reverse this and what are you going to do about it?'
Great to have the adults back in charge!
We now have a grown up government, next we need a grown up media.
You are quite correct, Max. The Tories never get asked this kind of trite garbage...
With great respect, I REALLY care about the vote share. I live in Wales. Plaid cymru got 0.7% of the national votes and got 4 seats. The green party got 10 times morw votes and have the same number of seats. I do think it's right to give Labour and the public a reality check that not that many people actually voted them in. Having said that, it's only been a few days but I'm impressed with what I've seen so far. Anything will be an improvement over the absolute circus that was the conservative government.
Regardless of political preferences, I think 90% of people would agree, competence has finally returned to No.10.
The attack lines from the Right are going to be 1) You're not doing very much ("first 100 days" question) and 2) You're cold and controlling ("What did you feel" question). She's not the only Murdoch mouthpiece using them.
This sort of spotlight is better than the narrator's simplistic call for professional journalism. The reality is the right wing media have an agenda, they have a strategy and an objective. No, less than the left wing media, but other than in Russia and China, these are amateur when compared to Murdoch's weaponization of the English speaking world's media. Continue to throw light on them.
Rigby should know better, poor form indeed.
Journos have gotten so used to asking dumbed down questions over the last 10yrs. This took them by surprise
Beth has her contract of employment to consider, she is not going to be Labour friendly when her employer is Murdock !
Rigby, like some other so called journalists is now much more concerned with their own image and looking ‘tough’ or clever rather than asking sensible questions.
Believe or not Beth Rigdy's question wasn't the dumbest one Starmer faced at that conference because two so called asked if Starmer was willing to make tough decisions and raise taxes.
Both Sky News and the BBC then made articles about this question.
Why is it a dumb question to ask a Labour leader if they are willing to raise taxes? Specifically at a time when public services have been decimated? It's an entirely valid question because spending (and borrowing) is one of the most viable ways of repairing our broken public services. Whereas acting like the NHS and other services can be significantly improved by finding "efficiencies" and relying on non-existent private sector capacity is not a realistic solution.
No chance, the client media will keep asking questions like "Sir Keir, what is your favourite spoon and is it a woman? If not, what IS a woman?"
Give the man his time to work, it don't matter if it take 100 day or 4 years as long as the results are good for the country and its moving in the right direction,
that is what the people care about. Real change takes time and especially cleaning up the sh^tshow the tories have left after 14 years of ripping the UK to bits.
Come on KS, you've had 3 days now, and you haven't solved anything yet!
To quote New Model Army, "Dont ask any more stupid questions you already know the answers to".
Beth should be sharing a house with laura, Tory cry babies!
I thought he was polite to answer. Her question was so meandering and instantial she looked out of her depth.
Give 16 year olds the vote asap. Coupled with PR we would never again see another right wing government.
Our Media needs Reform!
Don't encourage Nigel !
Was that a deliberate capitalisation? Our media has more than enough Reform in it already. Agree about media reform though.
She's utterly odious and clearly voted for Tory
The 100 days thing comes from America. For some reason, they think that doing things in a mad rush is better than doing things properly.
I don't know who's worse - Beth Rigby or Robert Peston both dreadful journalists.
She embarrasses herself in every interview. What a weapon!
The first 100 days is a US thing. And it is partly based on that after 100 days you already start campaigning again for the mid terms so it is your most effective period. This isn't a thing in the UK. Such a stupid question.
I wish they'd get rid of the unnecessary flags. We know where we are.
The vote share to seat ratio is the most disproportionate ever! Totally valid question!
Sort out the NHS pay dispute. They could do that in 100 days. Get conflict over and start repairing Tory damage.
Let’s not get complacent of Starmer doing this & turning into people that say “STARMER OWNS SKY NEWS AND DRINKS THEIR TEARS!!”
We got a mandate in all four nations? I don't remember Labour getting any seats in N. Ireland.
The adults are now running the country Thank goodness.
Labour won get over it.
I cringed when I saw it. Embarrassing.
Theres nothing dumb about that question, its a legitimate question. So she should just sing Labour praises in her questions now?
You´re right there, Max: a different style of government requires a different approach to journalism.
Beth Rigby is full of herself, the government has changed but not the quality of media reporting.
Not only does Beth struggle to ask any party leader sensible questions, barking at them, never letting them give a complete reply and, like Fiona Bruce, pretend not to know what Labour's plans are, she only lets Conservatives talk without questioning or correcting their lies. For someone so well paid, I do wonder why Beth refuses to add a g to ing words.
Yes! The missING part of words…drives me crazy!😂
Did she prevent Starmer giving a complete reply? Was she barking at him?
Can’t listen to her anymore. The former Home Secretary did the same. Mercifully I can’t remember her name.
@@Gordon.Pinkerton She found some old scripts from down the back of a filing cabinet and cobbled together some nonsense as if thinking she could treat Starmer like a child. Asking ridiculous questions as if he were still in opposition.
Can the media stop with these meaningless questions
You’ve not held Starmer to account in 4 years.
I usually like Beth, but she has to have an enemy 🙄
You like her because she usually goes against the right wing.
Go Kier
Yeah, go Keir !
Jacqui Smith is coming back into government, but coming via the David Cameron route of being stuffed into the House of Lords and therefore being made a minister in a completely undemocratic way, plus, just as we saw with David Cameron, being a peer means she cannot ever be questioned in the Commons.
A lot of people who voted for Reform are very concerned about the vote share - only 4 MPs from over 4 million votes is bizarre to explain to people. I don’t think these are ridiculous questions at all. Your suggested questions are all in the manifesto.
Those Reform UK Party Ltd MPs will be gone long before the 2029 GE. Farage just isn't cut out for UK politics. Neither is Tice or Anderson for that matter.