Hegelianism: What Is Sublation?
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- Music:
Summer Mvt 3 Presto by John Harrison with the Wichita State University Chamber Players is licensed under a Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 International License.
Winter Mvt 1 Allegro non molto by John Harrison with the Wichita State University Chamber Players is licensed under a Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 International License.
Using Hegel’s expressions to explain Hegel’s concept doesn’t lead us anywhere
Really? So we are to use another concept? And what should that concept be justified as? What axioms do you allow to start from?
Mr Wolf, to express and illustrate a complex concept in terms of something familiar to most people is a vast and difficult task. I have seen that in Feynman way of explaining physics. It would be very helpful if we find a Feynman way of explaining to approach Hegel’s fundamental concept of sublation
1) Feynman is a conceptual idiot, and I'm not the first one to say this. Physicists who understand concepts also see this.
2) The purpose of my channel is to say it how it is. There is no shortcut, there is no *familiar* formal version of this, which is why I refuse to lie to you so that you can feel good about believing a lie.
This is philosophy, it's not edutainment. There are all the other channels thay happily present lies to you because it makes them money to make you feel smart because you believe you got something in 15 minutes that in the original takes a much longer time, and there is this channel which is meant to help and guide you through the real thing. I will never be popular, but I am OK with that.
Consider *why* you have an interest in Hegel. If it is because you like learning "new" ideas, forget it. Hegel is immune to familiarity and reduction. Why? Because it is entirely about how to think with your object. Forms are no use.
Okay just watched it. You did a really good job on the video man.
The particular also sublates the universal. Conceptually is constituted through the inter-sublation of universality, particularity, and singularity, i.e. the syllogism.
really great video
🔥🔥🔥
Thank you for the great work.
You have made some of Hegel's fundamental elements graspable.
mind linking the diagram from 1:57?
So is Life itself a moment in the self sublation of Freedom? I ask this because it seems like sublation itself is Freedom, and Life being this self sublating process means that it's process is the process of Freedom. Also, if this is the case, wouldn't that mean that sublation itself is a sublation of Freedom?
Am I just thinking about this completely wrong 😂?
Everything is fine except your last part on the sublation of freedom. All sublation is self-sublation, and this is indeed life and freedom itself. There is no sublation of sublation as such. Sublation is an infinite concept measuring from the Idea down.
Excellent video.
Of course, there is no chance master Hegel is correct about this. He never successfully justifies treating an insightful abstraction (at best) as an autonomous ontological entity.
It’s only for mysticism to understand how sublation leaps out of Logic and into Being.
Correct about what? Sublation is literally just an analytically derived concept from an established concept. It's as correct as a triangle having three angles and straight lines in 2d, or 3 having 2 and 1 within it.
I don't know why people like to quote Hegel all the time and I'm noticing more and more people write about him. When I look at the state of the world I don't see an advancement of self conscious beings on a journey to Absolute Spirit so I don't see why people are so fascinated. I think it's a form of intellectual showing off, so people like to talk about sublation to make themselves look clever but other than that I don't see what the point is. My point isn't about your video which is very good but people that quote him in general.
It's due to people feeling intelligent because they were told something by someone else despite being unintelligent.
Can you explain again without the jargon?
Hahaha haha..
No.
That's like asking me to explain calculus with arithmetic. It ain't happening because it's impossible.
This would be good if you lost the music
It would be better if you paid me for the education I provide.
If you're in such desperate need of money that you can't take constructive criticism like an adult man maybe you'd do better selling sublated hotdogs
@@AntonioWolfphilosophya person gives you constructive criticism and that's how react?
It would be better if you weren't a little baby douche too but that's sublation in the fast lane
Didn't realize that Hegel was a bullshit artist. Thought he was a serious guy.