not just animals but insects too, try to avoid killing any life unnecessarily. Sometimes with pests like mosquitos it's ok but other insects who don't pose a threat to you may Allah give mental strength to not squish it.
Same here sister. They are God's creatures. We can make separate rooms for them with access to the yard/garden making sure they have all their needs met.
I'm not Muslim, but I heard Mohammed had a cat named Muezza. He also cut the sleeve off his robe one day before prayer so as not to disturb the cat. She and her babies were asleep on the sleeve.
@@improvementology4011 do you know what does daef hadith means? If you don't, then i would like to tell you that it doesn't mean hadith is wrong or false, it means that might be the hadith was narrated in old age by narrator so, there is doubt on soundness. Ibn Hajar described the cause of a hadith being classified as weak as "either due to discontinuity in the chain of narrators or due to some criticism of a narrator." This discontinuity refers to the omission of a narrator occurring at different positions within the isnād and is referred to using specific terminology ... Have a look at this article, for more information. seekersguidance.org/answers/general-counsel/is-acting-on-weak-hadiths-an-innovation/
Humans are not animals. We were honoured by Allah and favoured. But I will say some animals are better than humans especially in these times.may Allah forgive me for saying this.
Thank you so much for your kind words about animals. I was born an animal lover. I love all animals. I used to live in Saudi Arabia. We had pets, yet saw many people do mean things to dogs. I keep dogs for companionship and protection. I have horses because I train them and teach people to ride. I have cats and birds. Cats keep water moccasin snakes out of my barn. But my favorite pet is my pot belly pig. He's the smartest animal on Earth, almost as smart as a person! And very clean, too!
Thank you brother for clearing the air about dogs in Islam. I did not think it was true! I was informed also by my teacher who is hafiz e Quran and a sayyid that dogs ARE NOT haram in Islam. May Allah reward you for spreading the truth.
I am a muslim and we have a dog. I am truly hurt whenever another muslim brother or sister looks at me with disgust every time I say that.. they always say its "haraam" but every time i ask them why, they cant explain why. "Its just what they we're told to" and yes, i may have transgressed the teachings but, it hurts me to see my brothers and sisters in islam treat these animals with so much hate, and disgust and what not... how about the very basic principle of being kind to animals? Only Allah knows best. And I pray he forgives me if i have sinned for having dog in our family 😒
BIGBOSSWHATITDO420 That is a bad argument. Allah created pigs...we can’t eat them. Dogs prevent angels from coming to the home, they do give off a small smell, drop saliva around, hump people’s legs (yes I’ve looked after dogs before), and they prevent angels from coming to the home... so this is why I understand they are forbidden. Remember, Allah will send a prostitute to heaven because she gave water to a thirsty dog. This story tells us we should be caring to them, but that doesn’t mean we should keep them in the home.
islam did not teach these animals with hate ok read Quran ashab e kaaf had dog and that dog will be in jannah ALLAH says what else you want know? it is just adviced keep dog away from rooms homes because we have to pray s nimaz solah
+swiftspy You can keep a dog but it shouldn't be in your house cause a Hadith says. "Angels will not enter a house in which there is a dog or pictures on the wall"
Hilary Thomas bro dont just read the words understand the context, im a born muslim dont have deep knowledge but trust me if you study the context you will be convinced . one more thing if you need authentic answer dont ask these muslim keyboards warriors, visit a mosque and a imam if your your intention is learning
all animals are Allahs creatures and the dogs are one of them..we have fresh incident last year in Turki a dog rescued 3 peoples under the rubbles of mosque and during that time the one of the leaders or sheh litrary kissed the paw of dog.and at the same time in Syria a dog was rescued from the rubbles after almost 12 days without food or water after rescue the volunteers and fire fighters offered this dog food and water the dog drank water but one piece of bread he carried for his owner who was dead under the rubbles all rescuers in tears. Allahuakbar. Love from Tanzania
I'm hanafi, we don't see dogs as a big najasa, we only consider the saliva to be najis but doesn't actually break your wudhu. All the madhabs and the whole of Islam promotes the best of character to all living things
Racks_rc how shallow is your understanding brother. Every great Imams have their own ways of getting "the Law" out of the al-Quran and Hadis (istinbat). Different Imam used different methods and the people who follow any one of the methods will introduce themselves as the followers of the Imam ways. That's why there are 4 Mazhabs in Sunni fiqh. That's just in fiqh. Not aqeedah or tasawwuf.
@@islamonlysolution461 very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE.
I had a dog for 15 years, half my life. My father at first really didn't like it, being from Morocco. They have this wierd thing with especially dogs, where they avoid touching it, are scared of it and consider it a filthy animal. You see it here in the Netherlands, youth from Morocco really do not like dogs. Now that my dog is gone, my father misses it a lot actually. He became very attached to the little animal, he fed him, walked with him, played with him. Dogs are Allah's creatures as well..
I am a muslim i and i have a dog in my house and when i see a so called educated muslim telling me this is disgusting i just tell him go to the mecca the house of your prophet and you will feel ashamed of hating gods creatures
There are so many Ahadith, which have been misinterpreted or misreported without proper context creating a lot of confusion and misunderstandings. That is why Ahadith can't be just followed blindly. Most of the differences and problems in Islam have been caused thru Ahadith.
Dogs are protectors of homes. I’d personally leave them outside with their own dog house...and I’d let the dog inside the home once in awhile but not during prayer.
I'm a Muslim and I would like to have a dog, but the sad part is that, if I adopts one, the people from my religion is gonna, you know complain and criticize like " 'is he even a Muslim',' oh look he has a dog and he claims himself Muslim'. That's so sad I think people should really understand Islam and use their brains and reach to a conclusion. That's why Allah swt gave you brain. Don't follow others just because others are saying like this and like that,use your brain. Understand Islam and think by yourself. Anyway I love dogs and like to keep one. I believe they are loyal and faithful companion. in fact a dog is better than most of the fake people out there. And I don't deny the fact that, dogs are not clean. I think their saliva and wet part aren't clean,and one should purify themselves from it, if came in contact. But I believe there no problem in keeping a dog, if it's cleaned and groomed properly.
In traditional Indian village, each house has cats and dogs . Dogs cannot enter the house and is fed in its own bowl. Cats on other hand are freely allowed to roam in the house.
Now india as changed lot because they love dogs very very much and started to adopt stray dogs. according to hindusim dogs are god called bairava and. Catss are symbol evil you saying wrong in village side they dont allow.cats
@muslim police is banning accounts on youtube maybe i am japanese ?? . Hehe jk yes am not and i dont love them, now all they air is crappy hareem Also thanks for calling me out and trying to advice You're kindness is very much appreciated my Allah grant u hidaya and In Shaa Allah we meet in jannah..Ameen
This is very simple. I live in NYC in an apartment and it wouldn’t make sense to get a dog; however, if crime got really bad or my family member needs a service dog then it’s up to the best judgment of the Hadith.
I love cat & dog i am animals lover i give love to help animals from abusives but theres no way i keep dog, i do have three cats not to watch the rat i dont have rat my cats are inside home clean trained they dont eat anything only cat food facy food treat them like my children cost me a lots of money to keep them feed them takecare of them is worth it if i dont they'll be shot or on the street with out food is Ok to have a cat, but dog is nice to be with them & i love to support animals frome My bottom of my heart❤🐰🐹🐼🐯🐶"
If the dog serves a necessary utility depending on circumstances versus you wanting a chihuahua to cuddle and play with are two very different things; moreover, we shouldn’t breed wolves down to chihuahuas for our own fun and amusement.
In Islam there is a reason for almost everything...if you were to ask the right people for advice or even investigate it yourself in the correct manner and correct books then am pretty sure you will find answers to everything...it's an amazing religion the best that I have studied so far...always amazes me however you've got to make sure the source of the information you are reading upon is right otherwise there are many sources out there which are unreliable baher....
Can someone clarify this for me is possible, if the Hadith says angels do not enter a house with a dog inside, then does that mean the writing angels on our right and left go on holiday if we are at home and have a dog inside? Serious and genuine question please do not reply disrespectfully or with hateful retoric, it is unbecoming of a Muslim to speak this way.
it makes no sense that how dogs saliva is necis, but if it goes and fetches something you shoot and brings it to you, then you can eat the animal that the dog brought to you.
This is very simple. I live in NYC in an apartment and it wouldn’t make sense to get a dog that needs more; however, if crime got really bad or my family member needs a service dog then it’s up to my judgement.
A o a yes I agree with busta... I also read the same story I love cats myself shaikh humA plse google the prophet ( SAW)'s cat and you will see. Jazakallah khairen
I really like dogs and I want a dog for guarding me and my family. My concern is what is the definition of guarding. Is it enough to say if someone in the outside want to harm me and my dog is protecting me ? Does that count as guarding? The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Angels do not enter a house that has either a dog or a picture in it." Sahih al-Bukhari 3322 I am concerned about this hadith because my question is if the angels are not entering who is entering?
Im a muslim and I personally believe that as a muslim, we should believe Allah created all animals, and all the rest of His creations for a purpose. And in the case of animals, we dont have to condemn and be unkind to dogs. They are Allah's creation too. Its just because the angels that came down to earth to send Allah's message to Prophet Muhammad did not like the dog being inside the house since it is dirty with how you know dogs usually leave their tongue out and the saliva comes out...Its considered unhygienic and Angels are clean pure creations of God. So they prefer not having to deal with them. Thats why Prophet Muhammad decide to keep dogs out side the house. But he still gave a good example and taught us, his followers, to treat all animals kindly. I will folloe his example, and even if I may not be able to touch dogs freely because of the stigmatism that comes with being a muslim and No-Touching-Dogs-concept strong around me, I will always be kind to all of Allah's creations when they are in trouble, that including dogs. ❤
geishaShisha it is Not angel that said that. Angel don't have any feeling or anything to like or dislike thing. Their only purpose is to obey Allah command. Angel convey a message or what fron Allah to propeth Muhammad pbuh.
The blessed Prophet (Peace be on him) asked us to be kind to all animals. The order to kill animals is relevant only when humans are being attacked by a wild animal or when they are a threat (such as dogs with rabies). The only thing to be kept in mind is generally dogs are impure and do not have the same hygiene levels like a cat. So we just have to make sure dogs are not allowed inside the house. Otherwise there is no harm to have dogs around the house and neighborhood. We need to ensure that they are not petted and treated like humans. Dogs live in packs in traditional non-urban neighbourhoods and that's the way they should be. Cats on the other hand are clean dignified animals who can and prefer to look after themselves. So there is no harm in having them indoors. Otherwise there is no difference in the way we should treat them. The point is animals, even when domesticated should not be treated in the way how we treat fellow humans! Being kind to all animals and having empathy towards nature and the environment and Allah's entire creation is what is expected in Islam.
Did you know there are sahih hadiths saying that dogs used to pass through the masjid, they would urinate and water wasn’t even put over it. I personally don’t agree that dog are unclean, in surah maida Allah says that whatever your trained animals catch is halal for you to eat, the prophet said in sahih Hadith when you release your dog say bismilla, then you can eat whatever he catches, so if a dogs saliva was impure why is it halal to eat the food they catch with there mouths?
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Dear Mr. Hamza Yusuf. I am really feeling good that you talk so differently about the Koran and Islam. I am not a Muslim nor do I want to be one. I was an atheist, I am reading quite a lot of stuff on religion and spirituality. If you want to advance spiritually, read and assimilate the teachings of Bhagwad Gita. The wide spectrum of wisdom will help get all the Muslims of the world to understand and follow the path that the Prophet wanted Muslims to take.
Daniel Westberg I don't think we can live based on evidence s alone, can we scientifically prove a bread made out of stolen money and one made from working is better or equal? or a child born through rape and one that is born through a civil marriage, can we scientifically prove their the same? we don't need proves for everything in life. prophet Mohammed has never lied, even his enemies say so. it is recommended the growing a goat and having clay pots for cooking are all beneficial.
Yeah it's totally normal to have dogs according to Islam and yes Islam doesn't teach us to hate these being even pig just don't consume them it's haram thats it but dogs r only allowed to be kept only when it is necessary and u having farm so he doesn't enter ur home now in these days people keeping thier dogs clean and everything but we talking about those days when all these dogs r street dog and no one actually guarantee about who is taking care of their hygeine so over and all for ur takwah don't have dog in home in case bcoz all three emaan also considerable thought and I don't why Sheikh is talking about specially particularly about dogs bcoz as a pet they r big deal in west so I guess it is not easy for them to leave a pet and revert to Islam and about asahab e kafh people they don't have the dog they actaully being followed by the dog like Allah almighty specially sent that dog as gaurd and not only that according to Dr sheikh ul Islam Tahir ul Qadri that dog even have ability to talk with asahab e kafh people and according to them that only dog will enter in Jannah as well but Allah swt replace his soul with a human soul so Allah ho alaam bcoz it is only Allah who have all the knowledge and for the sake of takwah don't raise dog in home in my opinion but don't hate Allah any creature just for no good reason
See.. all animal are not najis including canine families and pig. There is wisdom why we are not encourage to keep and touch or eat them. Only Allah know the real reasons why we should do that. Do not think ill of Allah commands. All His commands are for the benefit of human being. But if they (haram animal) are in danger or distress, we must help & save them. It is human responsibility to help and keep them save and let them live. We should not hatm, hurt or kill them.
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Emi Mahmoud I live in the west and keeping a dog here is like a fashion accessory. Of course all dogs should be treated humanely and cared for but this mentality I’m talking of is different. Now its becoming a worldwide phenomenon of keeping a fluffy little dog like its a baby or small child.
@@DC-wp6oj I know I live in the west too (California) but I am speaking of being able to still have a dog, treat it with kindness. You can accommodate your home to fit their needs, such a room close to the yard. Etc. To many animals are suffering in shelters due to high irresponsibility of selfish human beings, at the end they are who suffer. It is our obligation to protect God's creatures anyway we can.
Emi Mahmoud the ruling in Islam is clear and equivocal. I would love to have a dog but i put the ruling of my faith above my desire to have a dog. Islam is the only religion that makes such a prohibition and its interesting al other religions allow it. Islam also specifies the kind treatment of animals including dogs. I understand what you say but the ruling is clear. Muslims are prohibited from keeping dogs as pets unless in a working capacity.
@@DC-wp6oj I am sorry i am not a scholar but i have read enough where I feel these hadiths are questionable. There are other stories where a dog broke off his chain defending the prophet when he was attacked. Other stories such as they serve as companions for travelers for protection. I have great respect for the prophet may peace be upon him. He treated animals with great respect, so I don't take just one opinion. Allah tells us in the quran, to ponder, analyze and question. God doesn't make mistakes, and he mentions dogs in quran with much respect. QURAN IS THE WORD OF " ALLAH" and although I understand hadiths are the prophets sayings, i believe since they are man made; common sense, logic and rationality of what's infront of us, takes precedence. I don't follow like sheep and Allah knows my heart and mind.
"The Prophet, peace be upon him, said: 'Whoever keeps a dog, his good deeds will decrease every day by one qeeraat [a unit of measurement], unless it is a dog for farming or herding.' In another report, it is said: ' …unless it is a dog for herding sheep, farming or hunting.'"-Bukhari Sharif "The Prophet, peace be upon him, said: 'Angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or an animate picture.'"-Bukhari Sharif
very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
I dont know either this hadieth is authentic or not but it definetely fitts the prophet muhammad(puh) just like when somebody hold his hand he never pulled his hand back first and in islam it is not allowed to cut down trees (large amounts of trees) not necesary . The muslim is commanded to have mercy on creatures otherwise Allah will not be mercifull to him/her. We are out here as vicegerents and we have responsabilities .
no problem of keeping dogs as a guard & hunting dogs.keeping pets and giving more importance than humans is prohibited.dog has been made by GOD for men service,not for this purpose that u being a supreme creature of GOD almighty continue to serve dogs and dont utilize the talent &skills of a dog.
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
The argument that dogs are dirtier than cats always seemed weird to me. Cats constantly have poop stuck to their fur, they even sometimes step in their pee and poop and spread it around the house and furniture. Not to mention them always throwing up.
Every page is written by the hand of man. Miracle appearances only happen in movies or by experienced magicians. People search for answers compulsively and the religious answering service make a lot of money. Always have and always will. Mohammed stated that no man needs an intermediary between himself and Allah.
It is an indictment that man must provide mercy in the first place. Blood lust and joy in killing and the words sadist and psychopath come to mind. Programming of babies is not the will of Allah.
All the hatred with dogs comes due to rabies...which is acceptable especially when we have an infected rabied dog............but what about a healthy vaccinated dog? It’s sad how all dogs are treated so bad in Islam and the mentality makes me dislike Islam ......because really Allah knows this ....dogs are very innocent creatures
show me in the Quran or in the Sunnah or in the doing of the companions or the Tabi'un or Tabi'in ... in that they used to do these practices ~ No, they did not do it!! but you said -> it's a good thing (subhanallah|l you just follow your whims and desires) then seek refuges! you know more than them you're more righteous than the Prophet Sallallahu 'Alayhi Wa Sallam?! said No for Allah... then you are innovating in the religion whatever innovation What you're doing is rejected!! Allah will not accept it!! Allah will punish you for it!!
Moonman Moonman as far as I know, he's Sunni Maliki. In an interview he stated he studied Shi'ism at the beginning of his journey of Islam but he's Maliki, not Shia.
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Emi Mahmoud If you have yard you can keep them there to protect your safety. But if you don’t have yard, learn the way the Ottomans dealt with the dogs or cats, birds in the streets.
@@furadhawkan you know furad, I have no problem if dogs lived on the streets if only muslims did what they are suppose to do by following islamic law towards animals. But 99.9% of people are so ignorant and don't think for themselves and follow traditions instead of true islam. We are suppose to feed them, give them water, clean them and take them to the veterinarian for those that can. If society really understood that, I would be the happiest person on earth. But it pains me to see so much injustice by everyone that is evil in this world towards dogs and other animals. But specially I am angry with my brothers and sisters in islam who do nothing to protect God's creatures. We have a lot to answer in our day of judgement. :(
Emi Mahmoud Yeah brother, you are right. A lot of Muslims nowadays don’t care about animals. Keeping dogs inside a house doesn’t mean to be rude towards them. May Allah forgive us!
*Muhammad hated dogs, particularly black dogs.* Abd Allah B. Mughaffal reported the apostle of Allah as saying: Were dogs not a species of creature I should command that they all be killed; but kill every pure black one. (Sunan Abu Dawud, book 10, #2839) Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar: Allah's Apostle ordered that the dogs should be killed. (Sahih Bukhari, vol. 4, #540) Ibn Mughaffal reported: Allah's messenger ordered the killing of dogs and then said, "what is the trouble with them (the people of Medina? How dogs are nuisances to them (the citizens of Medina)? He then permitted keeping of dogs for hunting and (the protection of) herds. ...[and for] for the protection of cultivated land. (Sahih Muslim, 3814) Abu Zubair heard Jabir Abdullah saying: Allah's messenger ordered us to kill dogs and we carried out this order so much so that we also killed the dog roaming with a women from the desert. Then Allah's apostle forbade their killing. He said: "It is your duty to kill the jet-black (dog) having two spots (on the eyes) for it is a devil. (Sahih Muslim 3813). ...He [Gabriel] said: Yes, but we [angels] do not enter a house in which there is a dog or a picture. Then on that very morning he [Muhammad] commanded the killing of the dogs until he announced that the dog kept for the orchards should also be killed, but he spared the dog meant for the protection of extensive fields (or big gardens). (Sahih Muslim, 24:5248)
Well if we think about it, it makes sense that the order to kill the dogs was because there was a problem with the dogs at a particular time such as disease, when the prophet entered Medina he gave the order to kill all dogs except for hunting, guarding dogs, shepherds dogs. Later on he forbade the killing of all dogs except the pure black dog with two white spots, the prophet also told two stories, one of a prostitute who saw a thirsty dog by a well and she used her scarf and shoe to draw water out of the well, another time a man gave water to a dog who was licking mud out of thirst and Allah forgave both of them and put them in paradise because of there kindness to the dog. So here we have the prophet saying to kill all dogs but then again he is telling us to be good to them, there’s a contradiction here, it seems there was a context behind the order to kill all dogs, also he later forbade killing all dogs except the pure black one with two white spots, so why would he order them all to be killed then later on order for them not to be killed. Also in the Quran Allah said whatever they catch for you is halal to eat, in other hadiths the prophet said when you release your dog say bismillah (in the name of God) then what they catch for you eat. So if all dogs were impure or there saliva is impure why can we eat the food they catch with there mouth?, I’m not a scholar, just trying to think logically.
And the reason Gabriel didn't appear to Mohammed had nothing to do with a dog being present.He was a false prophet.Had yah'shua ha'moshiach called upon Gabriel,he would have presented himself Immediately.Most Muslims i know are good and decent people but utterly decieved.
I know that this would be both controversial and heretical, but I always hated how the prophet Muhammad S.A.W just suddenly say “dogs are prohibited to be kept as pet, and those that does keep them as pet will lose the equivalent of two mountain of good deeds for every one day” , when you and I both know for a *fact* that there wasn’t even mentioned ANYWHERE on Quran that dogs are prohibited or haram or bad or impure or evil or anything. In fact, the ONLY verse that explicitly mentioned dog in Quran, says “That was from the signs of Allah. He whom Allah guides is the [rightly] guided, but he whom He leaves astray - never will you find for him a protecting guide. And you would think them awake, while they were asleep. And we turned them to the right and to the left, while their dog stretched his forelegs at the entrance. If you had looked at them, you would have turned from them in flight and been filled by them with terror.” (Quran 18:17-18) Which talks about how a child was protected by a dog that was guarding the cave entrance . The other verse that “kind” of implied toward it being a dog, doesn’t even mention that it was a dog, but just a smart “creature” in general. It always baffles me, on why our prophet just out of the blue says “dog is prohibited” , and if you think I’m an evil person for even daring to disagree with our prophet, then what say you of those imams that says dog are allowed to be kept as a pet? Because remember, Hanafi and Maliki is the two most followed teaching by the entire muslims in the world, so does that mean that all of the people that follow those two imams, goes to hell, because they doesn’t have any good deeds (Thawab) left since they keep dog as pet? This kind of dilemma is especially bad, when you live in a country where people follow madhab Shafi’i , and will legit straight up CURSE and condemn you to destine in jahannam , whenever you do something slightly off and not in-line with their understandings. Like the muslims in Malaysia have a REALLY bad sense superiority complex, especially when people kept predicting that Imam Mahdi’s black flagged soldiers would stem from South East Asian, so basically Malaysian and Indonesian, but unlike Indonesian, muslim in Malaysia feel like they have the justification of condemning other muslims left right and centre whenever they see a different form of practices, teachings or understandings
Dogs are beautiful and loving animals. Be kind to all animals.
Salam dear friends #artofmiyabhaitv
not just animals but insects too, try to avoid killing any life unnecessarily. Sometimes with pests like mosquitos it's ok but other insects who don't pose a threat to you may Allah give mental strength to not squish it.
@@darkwolf2343 insects are animal.
Not gonna lie that couch looks really comfy
Only cause he’s able to cross his legs and sit that way. It’s very low sitting furniture
I have a dog ( German shepherd) she actually tells me she loves me! Kind of goes '' woo woove woooooo! She means it too... i thank Allah for her 💝
Masha Allah 😊 and Subhan Allah 😃 May Allah keep her and make her more blessed for you 💝 Ameen
@@Lina.honey1 Thankyou Lina Honey 💝
@@redjulmar7391 sure thing 🙂 you’re welcome
Mashallah ❤ May Allah protect you and your dog.
i am a Muslim & I have dogs...all rescued. i ❤️ dogs so much!
Same here sister. They are God's creatures. We can make separate rooms for them with access to the yard/garden making sure they have all their needs met.
I'm not Muslim, but I heard Mohammed had a cat named Muezza. He also cut the sleeve off his robe one day before prayer so as not to disturb the cat. She and her babies were asleep on the sleeve.
Sallahu alayhi wassalam
WAW! So sweet! I didn't know that!
Thats a daeef hadith
@@improvementology4011 do you know what does daef hadith means? If you don't, then i would like to tell you that it doesn't mean hadith is wrong or false, it means that might be the hadith was narrated in old age by narrator so, there is doubt on soundness.
Ibn Hajar described the cause of a hadith being classified as weak as "either due to discontinuity in the chain of narrators or due to some criticism of a narrator." This discontinuity refers to the omission of a narrator occurring at different positions within the isnād and is referred to using specific terminology ...
Have a look at this article, for more information.
seekersguidance.org/answers/general-counsel/is-acting-on-weak-hadiths-an-innovation/
Dats true and documented
ALL animals are a blessing except humans!!!!!
Humans are not animals. We were honoured by Allah and favoured.
But I will say some animals are better than humans especially in these times.may Allah forgive me for saying this.
Thank you so much for your kind words about animals. I was born an animal lover. I love all animals. I used to live in Saudi Arabia. We had pets, yet saw many people do mean things to dogs. I keep dogs for companionship and protection. I have horses because I train them and teach people to ride. I have cats and birds. Cats keep water moccasin snakes out of my barn. But my favorite pet is my pot belly pig. He's the smartest animal on Earth, almost as smart as a person! And very clean, too!
I really trust Hamzah Yusuf
Sure, his goat beard is very "trustworthy"
Besides, he can't shave patchy beard either.
mr. one he condemned Assad and Isis Kharjwites (where the fitnah spread). I don't know why peoole judge people based on their looks!
sunnah.com/nasai/42/17
Im not a Muslim and i like him
Thank you brother for clearing the air about dogs in Islam. I did not think it was true! I was informed also by my teacher who is hafiz e Quran and a sayyid that dogs ARE NOT haram in Islam. May Allah reward you for spreading the truth.
I am a muslim and we have a dog. I am truly hurt whenever another muslim brother or sister looks at me with disgust every time I say that.. they always say its "haraam" but every time i ask them why, they cant explain why. "Its just what they we're told to" and yes, i may have transgressed the teachings but, it hurts me to see my brothers and sisters in islam treat these animals with so much hate, and disgust and what not... how about the very basic principle of being kind to animals?
Only Allah knows best. And I pray he forgives me if i have sinned for having dog in our family 😒
If you're a Maliki and that's fine. Follow one mazhab fully. Don't just take the dog part only. I'm a Shafiei.
Jazer me also i have a dog and trust me god loves animals he wouldn't created them if it was not to live with them
BIGBOSSWHATITDO420 That is a bad argument. Allah created pigs...we can’t eat them. Dogs prevent angels from coming to the home, they do give off a small smell, drop saliva around, hump people’s legs (yes I’ve looked after dogs before), and they prevent angels from coming to the home... so this is why I understand they are forbidden. Remember, Allah will send a prostitute to heaven because she gave water to a thirsty dog. This story tells us we should be caring to them, but that doesn’t mean we should keep them in the home.
If maliki have a better proof, then follow it. If shafai have better proof follow it. Do not follow one madhab blindly.
islam did not teach these animals with hate ok read Quran ashab e kaaf had dog and that dog will be in jannah ALLAH says what else you want know? it is just adviced keep dog away from rooms homes because we have to pray s nimaz solah
There is no problem with dogs since at least one dog is mentioned in sourate el kahf living with a group of believers.
Ya but not in the house
Why?
+swiftspy You can keep a dog but it shouldn't be in your house cause a Hadith says. "Angels will not enter a house in which there is a dog or pictures on the wall"
The hadith is from Hureira, he used to hate dogs and women. Salam.
swiftspy come on. That's the consensus of the learned men in the Shafei Mazhab. No dogs allowed in home. Outside of home can.
Here are some of the beautiful teachings of Islam.
Propaganda should always be replaced by propagation.
Aptly said!
sunnah.com/nasai/42/17
Hilary Thomas bro dont just read the words understand the context, im a born muslim dont have deep knowledge but trust me if you study the context you will be convinced . one more thing if you need authentic answer dont ask these muslim keyboards warriors, visit a mosque and a imam if your your intention is learning
Hilary Thomas Found the racist, wheres my cookie?
Arabs are backwards
Lack of culture
This dog issue its within their culture
all animals are Allahs creatures and the dogs are one of them..we have fresh incident last year in Turki a dog rescued 3 peoples under the rubbles of mosque and during that time the one of the leaders or sheh litrary kissed the paw of dog.and at the same time in Syria a dog was rescued from the rubbles after almost 12 days without food or water after rescue the volunteers and fire fighters offered this dog food and water the dog drank water but one piece of bread he carried for his owner who was dead under the rubbles all rescuers in tears. Allahuakbar. Love from Tanzania
I'm hanafi, we don't see dogs as a big najasa, we only consider the saliva to be najis but doesn't actually break your wudhu. All the madhabs and the whole of Islam promotes the best of character to all living things
in the hanafi madhab, touching the fur of a dog wont break your wudhu but saliva does.
Only have dog if protection an outside
Racks_rc how shallow is your understanding brother. Every great Imams have their own ways of getting "the Law" out of the al-Quran and Hadis (istinbat). Different Imam used different methods and the people who follow any one of the methods will introduce themselves as the followers of the Imam ways. That's why there are 4 Mazhabs in Sunni fiqh. That's just in fiqh. Not aqeedah or tasawwuf.
iam hanafi and keeping dog in houses considerd not good and it is recommended to keep dogs away from home
@@islamonlysolution461 very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE.
I had a dog for 15 years, half my life. My father at first really didn't like it, being from Morocco. They have this wierd thing with especially dogs, where they avoid touching it, are scared of it and consider it a filthy animal. You see it here in the Netherlands, youth from Morocco really do not like dogs. Now that my dog is gone, my father misses it a lot actually. He became very attached to the little animal, he fed him, walked with him, played with him. Dogs are Allah's creatures as well..
I love dogs and i really want to have one and keep it inside they are so loyal and cleaver
I am a muslim i and i have a dog in my house and when i see a so called educated muslim telling me this is disgusting i just tell him go to the mecca the house of your prophet and you will feel ashamed of hating gods creatures
Allah made them, end of.
We need to care for *all* of his creations!
There are so many Ahadith, which have been misinterpreted or misreported without proper context creating a lot of confusion and misunderstandings. That is why Ahadith can't be just followed blindly. Most of the differences and problems in Islam have been caused thru Ahadith.
I believe it to be true. I have a quran and it says so much about his love for all creation.
Dogs are protectors of homes. I’d personally leave them outside with their own dog house...and I’d let the dog inside the home once in awhile but not during prayer.
Alhamdulilah. I have a dog. Love is all she does.
I'm a Muslim and I would like to have a dog, but the sad part is that, if I adopts one, the people from my religion is gonna, you know complain and criticize like " 'is he even a Muslim',' oh look he has a dog and he claims himself Muslim'. That's so sad
I think people should really understand Islam and use their brains and reach to a conclusion. That's why Allah swt gave you brain. Don't follow others just because others are saying like this and like that,use your brain. Understand Islam and think by yourself.
Anyway I love dogs and like to keep one. I believe they are loyal and faithful companion. in fact a dog is better than most of the fake people out there.
And I don't deny the fact that, dogs are not clean. I think their saliva and wet part aren't clean,and one should purify themselves from it, if came in contact. But I believe there no problem in keeping a dog, if it's cleaned and groomed properly.
sonu Mohammed be a Maliki, not a Hanafi.
sonu Mohammed Do you want angels to come to your home? If you do, then don’t have a dog. Be good to them though
Muslims follow quoran and Hadith. Do you? Because I read something different in it. sunnah.com/urn/1273090
sunnah.com/nasai/42/17
None of those hadiths about dogs being Haram are Sahih.
Sheikh-ul Islaaaam ibn 'Abdullaaah!...Sheikh Hamza! Maa salaam habibi. May Allaah preserve you, ameen.
In traditional Indian village, each house has cats and dogs . Dogs cannot enter the house and is fed in its own bowl. Cats on other hand are freely allowed to roam in the house.
Now india as changed lot because they love dogs very very much and started to adopt stray dogs. according to hindusim dogs are god called bairava and. Catss are symbol evil you saying wrong in village side they dont allow.cats
A dog is eyes to a blind person.
A trained guide dog is..not just any dog
this is so true I'm a converted Muslim and I hv a dog
Nice
@muslim police is banning accounts on youtube 😂😂😂lmao yh cause u said it ..
Baaaka
@muslim police is banning accounts on youtube maybe i am japanese ?? .
Hehe jk yes am not and i dont love them, now all they air is crappy hareem
Also thanks for calling me out and trying to advice
You're kindness is very much appreciated my Allah grant u hidaya and In Shaa Allah we meet in jannah..Ameen
do you wash your hand seven times after he licks you?
@Ryan Shuman what if he lives in a apartment in the middle of the city
This is very simple. I live in NYC in an apartment and it wouldn’t make sense to get a dog; however, if crime got really bad or my family member needs a service dog then it’s up to the best judgment of the Hadith.
mashaallah brother
I love cat & dog i am animals lover i give love to help animals from abusives but theres no way i keep dog, i do have three cats not to watch the rat i dont have rat my cats are inside home clean trained they dont eat anything only cat food facy food treat them like my children cost me a lots of money to keep them feed them takecare of them is worth it if i dont they'll be shot or on the street with out food is Ok to have a cat, but dog is nice to be with them & i love to support animals frome My bottom of my heart❤🐰🐹🐼🐯🐶"
If the dog serves a necessary utility depending on circumstances versus you wanting a chihuahua to cuddle and play with are two very different things; moreover, we shouldn’t breed wolves down to chihuahuas for our own fun and amusement.
Discerning the Eye's Delight
before i have cat,his name is Hunter and my Neighbor was poison him but now he was pass away when i was kids .
I'm sorry but what is the english traduction Hamza used for "waraa - of that man" ?
warraa' translation plz
***** Thank you : )
Waraa means the quality of being devout , pious or fearful of Allah .
Yes I think he did, it would be a sound translation.
In Islam there is a reason for almost everything...if you were to ask the right people for advice or even investigate it yourself in the correct manner and correct books then am pretty sure you will find answers to everything...it's an amazing religion the best that I have studied so far...always amazes me however you've got to make sure the source of the information you are reading upon is right otherwise there are many sources out there which are unreliable baher....
Can someone clarify this for me is possible, if the Hadith says angels do not enter a house with a dog inside, then does that mean the writing angels on our right and left go on holiday if we are at home and have a dog inside? Serious and genuine question please do not reply disrespectfully or with hateful retoric, it is unbecoming of a Muslim to speak this way.
Mashallah! i had a cat when i was 10 called tommy, it died.
May Allah renunite him with you in jannah
it makes no sense that how dogs saliva is necis, but if it goes and fetches something you shoot and brings it to you, then you can eat the animal that the dog brought to you.
he sounds like Owen Wilson.. :P
wow
1 cat and i am love them and i am a muslim
Exactly.
This is very simple. I live in NYC in an apartment and it wouldn’t make sense to get a dog that needs more; however, if crime got really bad or my family member needs a service dog then it’s up to my judgement.
A o a yes I agree with busta... I also read the same story I love cats myself shaikh humA plse google the prophet ( SAW)'s cat and you will see. Jazakallah khairen
👍
i have 3 dogs
I really like dogs and I want a dog for guarding me and my family. My concern is what is the definition of guarding. Is it enough to say if someone in the outside want to harm me and my dog is protecting me ? Does that count as guarding?
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Angels do not enter a house that has either a dog or a picture in it."
Sahih al-Bukhari 3322
I am concerned about this hadith because my question is if the angels are not entering who is entering?
Make a separate room for them with access to the backyard. You can even play with them and was afterwards. It's that simple.
Yes security
Im a muslim and I personally believe that as a muslim, we should believe Allah created all animals, and all the rest of His creations for a purpose. And in the case of animals, we dont have to condemn and be unkind to dogs. They are Allah's creation too. Its just because the angels that came down to earth to send Allah's message to Prophet Muhammad did not like the dog being inside the house since it is dirty with how you know dogs usually leave their tongue out and the saliva comes out...Its considered unhygienic and Angels are clean pure creations of God. So they prefer not having to deal with them. Thats why Prophet Muhammad decide to keep dogs out side the house. But he still gave a good example and taught us, his followers, to treat all animals kindly. I will folloe his example, and even if I may not be able to touch dogs freely because of the stigmatism that comes with being a muslim and No-Touching-Dogs-concept strong around me, I will always be kind to all of Allah's creations when they are in trouble, that including dogs. ❤
geishaShisha it is Not angel that said that. Angel don't have any feeling or anything to like or dislike thing. Their only purpose is to obey Allah command. Angel convey a message or what fron Allah to propeth Muhammad pbuh.
The blessed Prophet (Peace be on him) asked us to be kind to all animals. The order to kill animals is relevant only when humans are being attacked by a wild animal or when they are a threat (such as dogs with rabies). The only thing to be kept in mind is generally dogs are impure and do not have the same hygiene levels like a cat. So we just have to make sure dogs are not allowed inside the house. Otherwise there is no harm to have dogs around the house and neighborhood. We need to ensure that they are not petted and treated like humans. Dogs live in packs in traditional non-urban neighbourhoods and that's the way they should be. Cats on the other hand are clean dignified animals who can and prefer to look after themselves. So there is no harm in having them indoors. Otherwise there is no difference in the way we should treat them. The point is animals, even when domesticated should not be treated in the way how we treat fellow humans! Being kind to all animals and having empathy towards nature and the environment and Allah's entire creation is what is expected in Islam.
Did you know there are sahih hadiths saying that dogs used to pass through the masjid, they would urinate and water wasn’t even put over it. I personally don’t agree that dog are unclean, in surah maida Allah says that whatever your trained animals catch is halal for you to eat, the prophet said in sahih Hadith when you release your dog say bismilla, then you can eat whatever he catches, so if a dogs saliva was impure why is it halal to eat the food they catch with there mouths?
There is one inhabiting a home in which they keep a dog but their deeds are decreased by one Qirat every day
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Maliki 4 lyf
Muizza
I think he said "scruples", to be more precise.
This is a common interpretation between Malikis and Hannafis I've seen.
Not so with the Sha'fi'i and Hanabali.
I have a dog and he knows when mail man comes
Dear Mr. Hamza Yusuf. I am really feeling good that you talk so differently about the Koran and Islam. I am not a Muslim nor do I want to be one. I was an atheist, I am reading quite a lot of stuff on religion and spirituality. If you want to advance spiritually, read and assimilate the teachings of Bhagwad Gita. The wide spectrum of wisdom will help get all the Muslims of the world to understand and follow the path that the Prophet wanted Muslims to take.
Ratish Shete strange our religion is an ocean it is sufficient
also, to shower dogs or put diapers on them or to treat them as toys is very mean to them.
The people in the cave had a dog😁Soerah Al Khaf.. 18:18
growing roosters at home can protect from evil eyes.
Jish Chatt you have proof of that?
Daniel Westberg I don't think we can live based on evidence s alone, can we scientifically prove a bread made out of stolen money and one made from working is better or equal? or a child born through rape and one that is born through a civil marriage, can we scientifically prove their the same? we don't need proves for everything in life. prophet Mohammed has never lied, even his enemies say so. it is recommended the growing a goat and having clay pots for cooking are all beneficial.
Yeah it's totally normal to have dogs according to Islam and yes Islam doesn't teach us to hate these being even pig just don't consume them it's haram thats it but dogs r only allowed to be kept only when it is necessary and u having farm so he doesn't enter ur home now in these days people keeping thier dogs clean and everything but we talking about those days when all these dogs r street dog and no one actually guarantee about who is taking care of their hygeine so over and all for ur takwah don't have dog in home in case bcoz all three emaan also considerable thought and I don't why Sheikh is talking about specially particularly about dogs bcoz as a pet they r big deal in west so I guess it is not easy for them to leave a pet and revert to Islam and about asahab e kafh people they don't have the dog they actaully being followed by the dog like Allah almighty specially sent that dog as gaurd and not only that according to Dr sheikh ul Islam Tahir ul Qadri that dog even have ability to talk with asahab e kafh people and according to them that only dog will enter in Jannah as well but Allah swt replace his soul with a human soul so Allah ho alaam bcoz it is only Allah who have all the knowledge and for the sake of takwah don't raise dog in home in my opinion but don't hate Allah any creature just for no good reason
In surah al kahfi dog is friend of human its mean not haram, Why hadits against quran. Hadits is below quran.
See.. all animal are not najis including canine families and pig. There is wisdom why we are not encourage to keep and touch or eat them. Only Allah know the real reasons why we should do that. Do not think ill of Allah commands. All His commands are for the benefit of human being. But if they (haram animal) are in danger or distress, we must help & save them. It is human responsibility to help and keep them save and let them live. We should not hatm, hurt or kill them.
Yes but the point is we are not eating Dogs.
Some people are desperate to find an excuse to keep a dog
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Emi Mahmoud I live in the west and keeping a dog here is like a fashion accessory. Of course all dogs should be treated humanely and cared for but this mentality I’m talking of is different. Now its becoming a worldwide phenomenon of keeping a fluffy little dog like its a baby or small child.
@@DC-wp6oj I know I live in the west too (California) but I am speaking of being able to still have a dog, treat it with kindness. You can accommodate your home to fit their needs, such a room close to the yard. Etc. To many animals are suffering in shelters due to high irresponsibility of selfish human beings, at the end they are who suffer. It is our obligation to protect God's creatures anyway we can.
Emi Mahmoud the ruling in Islam is clear and equivocal. I would love to have a dog but i put the ruling of my faith above my desire to have a dog. Islam is the only religion that makes such a prohibition and its interesting al other religions allow it. Islam also specifies the kind treatment of animals including dogs. I understand what you say but the ruling is clear. Muslims are prohibited from keeping dogs as pets unless in a working capacity.
@@DC-wp6oj I am sorry i am not a scholar but i have read enough where I feel these hadiths are questionable. There are other stories where a dog broke off his chain defending the prophet when he was attacked. Other stories such as they serve as companions for travelers for protection. I have great respect for the prophet may peace be upon him. He treated animals with great respect, so I don't take just one opinion. Allah tells us in the quran, to ponder, analyze and question. God doesn't make mistakes, and he mentions dogs in quran with much respect. QURAN IS THE WORD OF " ALLAH" and although I understand hadiths are the prophets sayings, i believe since they are man made; common sense, logic and rationality of what's infront of us, takes precedence. I don't follow like sheep and Allah knows my heart and mind.
"The Prophet, peace be upon him, said: 'Whoever keeps a dog, his good deeds will decrease every day by one qeeraat [a unit of measurement], unless it is a dog for farming or herding.' In another report, it is said: ' …unless it is a dog for herding sheep, farming or hunting.'"-Bukhari Sharif
"The Prophet, peace be upon him, said: 'Angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or an animate picture.'"-Bukhari Sharif
very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Stupid hadith
I'm Muslim I love dogs.. N I have dogs.. To me Allah wont tell like this rubbish Hadis... So many Hadis man made... If Allah true Allah loves dogs...
I dont know either this hadieth is authentic or not but it definetely fitts the prophet muhammad(puh) just like when somebody hold his hand he never pulled his hand back first and in islam it is not allowed to cut down trees (large amounts of trees) not necesary . The muslim is commanded to have mercy on creatures otherwise Allah will not be mercifull to him/her. We are out here as vicegerents and we have responsabilities .
Dogs n cats are pets !
no problem of keeping dogs as a guard & hunting dogs.keeping pets and giving more importance than humans is prohibited.dog has been made by GOD for men service,not for this purpose that u being a supreme creature of GOD almighty continue to serve dogs and dont utilize the talent &skills of a dog.
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
My wife and I never have to worry about dog or cat hair. We keep lizards and turtles reptile folks. Then again I never really was a mammal person
The argument that dogs are dirtier than cats always seemed weird to me. Cats constantly have poop stuck to their fur, they even sometimes step in their pee and poop and spread it around the house and furniture. Not to mention them always throwing up.
Is it permissible to spay/neuter cats in Islam???
So don’t lie to people
Every page is written by the hand of man. Miracle appearances only happen in movies or by experienced magicians. People search for answers compulsively and the religious answering service make a lot of money. Always have and always will. Mohammed stated that no man needs an intermediary between himself and Allah.
It is an indictment that man must provide mercy in the first place. Blood lust and joy in killing and the words sadist and psychopath come to mind. Programming of babies is not the will of Allah.
All the hatred with dogs comes due to rabies...which is acceptable especially when we have an infected rabied dog............but what about a healthy vaccinated dog? It’s sad how all dogs are treated so bad in Islam and the mentality makes me dislike Islam ......because really Allah knows this ....dogs are very innocent creatures
"Aisha had a Poppy Dog"lol
What happend to this Guy
Whata Joke.This guys gone crazy
show me in the Quran or in the Sunnah or in the doing of the companions or the
Tabi'un or Tabi'in ... in that they used to do these practices ~
No, they did not do it!!
but you said -> it's a good thing (subhanallah|l you just follow your whims and desires) then seek refuges!
you know more than them you're more righteous than the Prophet Sallallahu 'Alayhi Wa Sallam?!
said No for Allah... then you are innovating in the religion
whatever innovation
What you're doing is rejected!!
Allah will not accept it!!
Allah will punish you for it!!
is he shia?
Moonman Moonman is he?Can you provide a source?
Moonman Moonman as far as I know, he's Sunni Maliki. In an interview he stated he studied Shi'ism at the beginning of his journey of Islam but he's Maliki, not Shia.
Amato Ciciretti no why
Only guard and hunter dogs are permissible in Islam.
Very well....do you agree dogs just like other animals are God's creatures that have have needs and feelings like we do ? You said....keep them away from the house. You do realize there are all types of dogs right ? From very tiny to very big dogs. Now you since you suggested to keep dogs away from home, I have a question for you.....away from home means, on the streets. So I assume as a good Muslim that you must be or anyone reading here. When was the last time, you carry food and water for a thirsty hungry dog ? It is our responsibility to care for God's creatures correct? Any reader here of my comment? What is your solution for tiny and big dogs on the streets, who die of hunger and thirst on the streets ? Or worse yet, poisoned by suppose muslims in muslim countries? Are we just going to hide behind our comfortable homes doing our prayers, so God can forgive our daily sins ? Don't you think a BIG sin is neglecting God's creatures ? Think again ? And if u are going to keep one outside as a guard dog, make sure you understand the circumstances of weather outside your home. It is your obligation, the dog has clean water and food at all times and a shelter which is heated in winter and air conditioned in summer. Your restrictions to not want a dog inside the home, doesn't forbid you to REALLY CARE for the poor animal that better not be chained all alone outside. And I am sure Allah wouldn't mind if you pet it that dig and played with him. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO, IS CLEAN YOURSELF OR COMPLETELY SHOWER. IS THAT SIMPLE
Emi Mahmoud If you have yard you can keep them there to protect your safety. But if you don’t have yard, learn the way the Ottomans dealt with the dogs or cats, birds in the streets.
@@furadhawkan you know furad, I have no problem if dogs lived on the streets if only muslims did what they are suppose to do by following islamic law towards animals. But 99.9% of people are so ignorant and don't think for themselves and follow traditions instead of true islam. We are suppose to feed them, give them water, clean them and take them to the veterinarian for those that can. If society really understood that, I would be the happiest person on earth. But it pains me to see so much injustice by everyone that is evil in this world towards dogs and other animals. But specially I am angry with my brothers and sisters in islam who do nothing to protect God's creatures. We have a lot to answer in our day of judgement. :(
Emi Mahmoud Yeah brother, you are right. A lot of Muslims nowadays don’t care about animals. Keeping dogs inside a house doesn’t mean to be rude towards them. May Allah forgive us!
Dogs are unclean .And the Prophet prohibit having dogs as pets.
*Muhammad hated dogs, particularly black dogs.*
Abd Allah B. Mughaffal reported the apostle of Allah as saying: Were dogs not a species of creature I should command that they all be killed; but kill every pure black one. (Sunan Abu Dawud, book 10, #2839)
Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Umar: Allah's Apostle ordered that the dogs should be killed. (Sahih Bukhari, vol. 4, #540)
Ibn Mughaffal reported: Allah's messenger ordered the killing of dogs and then said, "what is the trouble with them (the people of Medina? How dogs are nuisances to them (the citizens of Medina)? He then permitted keeping of dogs for hunting and (the protection of) herds. ...[and for] for the protection of cultivated land. (Sahih Muslim, 3814)
Abu Zubair heard Jabir Abdullah saying: Allah's messenger ordered us to kill dogs and we carried out this order so much so that we also killed the dog roaming with a women from the desert. Then Allah's apostle forbade their killing. He said: "It is your duty to kill the jet-black (dog) having two spots (on the eyes) for it is a devil. (Sahih Muslim 3813).
...He [Gabriel] said: Yes, but we [angels] do not enter a house in which there is a dog or a picture. Then on that very morning he [Muhammad] commanded the killing of the dogs until he announced that the dog kept for the orchards should also be killed, but he spared the dog meant for the protection of extensive fields (or big gardens). (Sahih Muslim, 24:5248)
These dogs were rabid and that’s the context behind the hadiths of killing them during the prophets time in Medina
@@msr1836 where have you found the evidence for your statement? The hadith doesn't seem to imply anything regarding radib dogs.
Well if we think about it, it makes sense that the order to kill the dogs was because there was a problem with the dogs at a particular time such as disease, when the prophet entered Medina he gave the order to kill all dogs except for hunting, guarding dogs, shepherds dogs. Later on he forbade the killing of all dogs except the pure black dog with two white spots, the prophet also told two stories, one of a prostitute who saw a thirsty dog by a well and she used her scarf and shoe to draw water out of the well, another time a man gave water to a dog who was licking mud out of thirst and Allah forgave both of them and put them in paradise because of there kindness to the dog. So here we have the prophet saying to kill all dogs but then again he is telling us to be good to them, there’s a contradiction here, it seems there was a context behind the order to kill all dogs, also he later forbade killing all dogs except the pure black one with two white spots, so why would he order them all to be killed then later on order for them not to be killed. Also in the Quran Allah said whatever they catch for you is halal to eat, in other hadiths the prophet said when you release your dog say bismillah (in the name of God) then what they catch for you eat. So if all dogs were impure or there saliva is impure why can we eat the food they catch with there mouth?, I’m not a scholar, just trying to think logically.
And the reason Gabriel didn't appear to Mohammed had nothing to do with a dog being present.He was a false prophet.Had yah'shua ha'moshiach called upon Gabriel,he would have presented himself Immediately.Most Muslims i know are good and decent people but utterly decieved.
I know that this would be both controversial and heretical, but I always hated how the prophet Muhammad S.A.W just suddenly say “dogs are prohibited to be kept as pet, and those that does keep them as pet will lose the equivalent of two mountain of good deeds for every one day” , when you and I both know for a *fact* that there wasn’t even mentioned ANYWHERE on Quran that dogs are prohibited or haram or bad or impure or evil or anything. In fact, the ONLY verse that explicitly mentioned dog in Quran, says “That was from the signs of Allah. He whom Allah guides is the [rightly] guided, but he whom He leaves astray - never will you find for him a protecting guide. And you would think them awake, while they were asleep.
And we turned them to the right and to the left, while their dog stretched his forelegs at the entrance. If you had looked at them, you would have turned from them in flight and been filled by them with terror.” (Quran 18:17-18)
Which talks about how a child was protected by a dog that was guarding the cave entrance . The other verse that “kind” of implied toward it being a dog, doesn’t even mention that it was a dog, but just a smart “creature” in general. It always baffles me, on why our prophet just out of the blue says “dog is prohibited” , and if you think I’m an evil person for even daring to disagree with our prophet, then what say you of those imams that says dog are allowed to be kept as a pet? Because remember, Hanafi and Maliki is the two most followed teaching by the entire muslims in the world, so does that mean that all of the people that follow those two imams, goes to hell, because they doesn’t have any good deeds (Thawab) left since they keep dog as pet?
This kind of dilemma is especially bad, when you live in a country where people follow madhab Shafi’i , and will legit straight up CURSE and condemn you to destine in jahannam , whenever you do something slightly off and not in-line with their understandings. Like the muslims in Malaysia have a REALLY bad sense superiority complex, especially when people kept predicting that Imam Mahdi’s black flagged soldiers would stem from South East Asian, so basically Malaysian and Indonesian, but unlike Indonesian, muslim in Malaysia feel like they have the justification of condemning other muslims left right and centre whenever they see a different form of practices, teachings or understandings