Apple Pencil vs cheaper alternatives
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 05. 2024
- Do you really need the expensive Apple Pencil 1 or 2 or would a cheaper ipad stylus do everything you would need? Here I test review and compare a variety of cheaper ipad stylus alternatives to see whether they offer value for money compared to the official branded apple pencil.
Sanfant stylus amzn.eu/d/4r0HLl7
Quadence stylus amzn.eu/d/8WVks0h
Quadence advanced stylus amzn.eu/d/gyhQDv5
KXT stylus amzn.eu/d/hWMKpNs
Xiron Stylus amzn.eu/d/1RLlP63
Penyeah stylus amzn.eu/d/3QpSInn
Lezun Stylus amzn.eu/d/icusJMV
Greneric Stylus amzn.eu/d/htyAu74
Logitech Crayon amzn.eu/d/ckFljsZ
Support me here / jamesjulier
Facebook groups/10578...
Instagram / james_julier
HOW TO PAINT LANDSCAPES: • LEARN HOW TO PAINT LAN...
TEXTURE SPHERES: • Texture tutorials
HOW TO DRAW THE HUMAN BODY: • HOW TO DRAW THE HUMAN ...
HOW TO PAINT FIRE: • Apple Pencil drawing t...
HOW TO PAINT WATER: • HOW TO PAINT REALISTIC...
HOW TO PAINT SKIES: • Apple Pencil drawing /...
One thing to keep in mind, Procreate developers have already announced that they are removing pressure sensitivity support for non-Apple Pencil styluses. So the the other brands won’t be able to be used to full potential very soon.
None of these have pressure sensitivity anyway
there is literally no excuse for it other than money.
@@herbertnatanael did you not read the first comment or something?
people who have to use Procreate for their work won’t mind spending few dollars to buy an Apple Pencil
@@LindsayHajin-kf9hi Agreed! The Apple Pencil is all I will use, it’s the only way I can get my pieces to look the way I want them to.
Thanks for this review which is helpful since I will be doing a presentation concerning digital art in a class where most of the participants have mild cognitive impairment which includes me as well. Art is proven to help those with MCI. Since I use Procreate I will be recommending your drawing videos and reviews such as what you have done concerning using different pencils. I pIan on doing a simple drawing where I will have differed participants doing aspects of it on different layers so they can see how simple it can be to do a drawing. I so appreciate your in-structural encouragement as you suggest not to get to bogged down with doing it at your proficiency but to do it the best you can. You are such a good ambassador for Procreate and iPads which have encouraged my purchases in these areas.
thanks a lot for your great effort by showing us all practically
Very helpful. Still Apple Pencil 2 for me and it's useful to see it was worth me going for it from the start.
Great review! For me, the largest drawback of the Apple Pencil is that I can never seem to get a secure grip on it. I’ve tried a couple of sleeves, but got my best results with masking tape.
Personally use the squishy grips, got them from some mechanical pencils I had laying around. I have 2 on my gen 1 Apple Pencil
Fun fact, you can get grip-tape (the stuff usually used for raquettes etc) and use it with the pencil, it makes it alot more comfortable and is super sleek
If you're going to tape it to your hand, I'd think that medical paper tape would be more comfortable!
;)
For the price they charge for the damn thing, you'd think they would actually make it more tactile to hold, look cool or something- but no. It's a mass produced made in China product, and you need to ADD to it to make it more usable.
Thanks James, great review! I use a UOGIC and am very happy with it. I used to have an Apple Pencil but it didn’t last very long before it stopped working and at that price, I wasn’t going to replace it. However, I had forgotten that my stylus isn’t actually an Apple Pencil when I got it back out a couple of weeks ago, so it just goes to show that the other styluses are great alternatives 😊
Is the uogic compatible with Samsung?
Hi, yes, it’s a universal stylus. My only disappointment would be that it doesn’t respond to pressure, but then most don’t
Thanks a lot. This was very helpful.
I have the KXT and for what I need it for, I would say it’s really good! As said in the video, it’s accurate and smooth, but there are a few things to consider. One is that for me, I keep accidentally clicking on the power button and switching it off. I might just be clumsy but it’s quite annoying. The battery life is excellent, it lasts a long time and I don’t feel like I have to constantly charge it. The final thing for me personally, is since the tip isn’t the absolute finest, it’s sometimes not as accurate as it could be. It is still accurate, but if you’re an artist I honestly think you’d be better off with an Apple Pencil. I am in no way an artist, but I do like to do sketches and research using it, mainly for fun. I think this review was really good and helpful, but this is my opinion on the KXT.
I’m a beginner using Procreate to learn how to draw. I have one of the £20 stylus’s and the only problem I have is that a lot of the tutorials out there are of course done with an IPencil. Because of that fact some of them can’t be followed closely, even the beginner ones as a lot use the fact that the IPencil tapers or they use a lighter or heavier pressure. Now for beginners I guess we shouldn’t worry about that but I find it stresses me out as I have to keep stopping the tutorial to alter the width or opacity of the line. Is there an alternative between a compatible stylus at around £20 and the IPencil at £100+ that has a version of the pressure sensitivity?
This will definitely help people make a more informed decision if funds are low.
I’m personally very happy with the Apple Pencil 2, it offers so much more to me pairing with my iPad Pro magnetically charging as you said, and the features it affords me like pressure, drawing with angles it’s just perfect.
If you can afford an ipad, then I’d definitely suggest going with apples own proprietary pencils for ease of use.
I agree but I suppose not everyone is an artist or creator.
I got a stylus for about 50-60$, worked perfectly. Dropped it in a parking lot and it got ran over by a truck/car. Found it squashed but still working. My iPad literally broke before it did.
I bought my pencil from SHEIN and paid £10 for it. It’s a great pencil does everything except pressure sensitivity.
I love being able to watch such a great video with an easy-on-the-ear English voice... thank you so much for this, very helpful :)
You're so welcome!
If you are an artist, there is no replacement for an Apple Pencil. I have an Apple Pencil one I bought in 2017 along with my 12.9 iPad Pro and they both work perfectly to this day, although I am kind of ready to buy a new iPad with an updated pencil. I have dropped my pencil several times but it still works perfectly and holds its charge well. I used Wacom tablets for several years and hundreds of dollars! They can’t hold a candle to the Apple Pencil! So for me the Apple Pencil is cheap by comparison. I’m not saying other Styluses don’t work because they do but they just don’t do everything most Artists would need (most importantly Pressure Sensitivity). However, I do also have alternative styluses such as the mesh one and it works perfectly fine (when I’m NOT doing calligraphy, sketching or detailed artwork). So, if you’re looking for something like that, this video is very helpful. Thank you for your informative video!
I’m an artist who uses those stylus. And I’m going pretty much fine with it without pressure sensitivity
I'm an artist, and for me, there is no replacement for a sketchpad and drawing pencils.
Not everyone is gonna pay 200 for a PENCIL
This is perfect!! I’m looking for an alternative for my daughter! She’s almost 6 (in April), loves drawing, and is very good at it, so I want her to have a stylus to use on her iPad. She has 6th Gen iPad, and even tho it would be the 1st Gen pencil, idk if I wanna spend the money. She’s 5, and may lose it 🤷🏽♀️. This gives me some good alternatives to check out!! Thanks so much!! Oh, I didn’t hear it mentioned, but is scratching the screen ever a concern? She’s not particularly heavy-handed, but anything is possible. 😅
Not so much scratching the screen, as the nibs are plastic and the screen is harder. I’d stay away from the penyeah as that would scratch if she uses the normal pen.
Awesome review, thanks 👍🏻
Thanks for watching!
I have the Quadrants one and it works great!
Time to test again. I have one that does the pairing.
I love my KXTs for teaching and note taking.
12:48 i have this one and i LOVE it. My least favorite part is on my new ipad. It does NOT connect to the part of the place meant for the apple pencil. Edit: except mine is white and looks nothing like that one. I have the twist off ones for replacement and needs a bluetooth pairing and the pairing is called *pencil*
edit
i lost it and can’t find it…
What app are you using for the drawing demo?
Apparently majority of third party styluses are for new iPads. So far for my 1st gen air I’ve only found two proper ones on AliExpress (unfortunately one got destroyed by domestic accident) so I get my iPad is especially old and I’ll be looking up my next iPad with Apple Pencil support (I’d love 2nd gen but if not then this video has given me loads of alternatives)
I’ve been eyeing the Logitech one for a long while now (also I’d love to find something I can use on my iPhone too as the one I have now is slightly laggy and not always most precise but if I’m on the go or somewhere not home I’m on my phone)
Also I’ve never been able to use the ones with the squishy silicone top. For some reason I just tear those apart (or maybe it’s because of the screen protector which isn’t the paper type but regular one)
Ok I’m curious, did you upgrade your iPad or planning to soon? I have the first gen air too and I just bought a 3rd gen 12.9 pro, I’ll order a third party stylus from like amazon, one that resembles the Apple Pencil 2 cuz I have logo mania and want people to think I actually have the Apple Pencil lol. I think 1st gen air users like us need to finally move on, even as I’m writing this my keyboard is lagging a lot
@@AlvinaMuneer hi, I have iPad Air 2nd generation, any recommendations? Do you know if any of these stylus from the video such us the sanfant stylus are useful? I really only need it for taking notes for college so the only thing I’d need is palm rejection and decent precission. Thanks
I have the quadence one. And the tiny thing in the back, I always sometimes lose it
I have 5 quadence pens. I have lost 2 - kids. They are brilliant. Use it for engineering sketches and markups…perfect.
Yeah I can see how dependent on use they are perfect
@@JamesJulier-Artist you don’t get pressure sensitivity like you say, but I rarely rely on that as I use concepts app and GoodNotes and Drawboard for pdf mark ups. My ultimate wish is a pen with a inbuilt rubber tip and is moulded like a mechanical pencil with this tip…
I got my Apple Pencil gen 2 for $55 and the gen 1 for $50. On fb marketplace. Both were brand new basically with the box and everything. I only thing I had to get extra was the lightning adapter for the gen 1.
What’s the name of the app u use to draw? I use concepts but I wanna try other things
Does Sanfront pencil work with any tablet ? Looking for a good pencil stylus i can use for notes and stuff
Did I only watch this to see the KXT review yes yes I did and I’m so glad I did I think it must just be the drawing apps I’ve used since it does sometimes lag for me and there is no tilt
Hi James I just make comments on photographs but mainly engineering first draft drawings I also have purchased 3 apple pencils just failed due to what I would say through light damage though a lot of American travel plus making references in NOTES which would you recommend cheers BRIAN
My 1st gen pencil just got broken a few days ago so I'm looking for an alternative compatible with Ipad pro 9.7 inch.
Can someone tell me what's the best to buy pls? thanks a lot
i use the logitech crayon and tbh i love it.
I throw the package of my pencil in the trash
so i really don’t remember what was it but its none of these that were in the video,however it just doesn’t write when i put my hand on the ipad while holding it,it starts glitching and deleting what im trying to write,it basically only writes when no skin touches the screen,im a highschool student and i really need a nice one to only write notes with at least,what do u suggest me to get??
I have kingone upgraded stylus pen in 2000 rs which is roughly around 25$ and 20 pounds and it’s super responsive, been using it for 1 years and it’s working flawlessly. Highly recommended
Pakistani rupees or indian
Yes, it was in Indian rupees.
This video was exactly what I was looking for, thank you.
I know I'm a bit late to the party, but I'm wondering if anyone can help me with this:
I'm looking for a stylus for my daughter's iPad... she is going on 8 years old and is interested in video editing and just being creative with digital media. We've gone through a couple of cheaper pens (around $10 USD, no name brand worth mentioning...) that broke very easily when dropped.
I was wondering which of these would hold up to a kid's usage at a budget price... is the Penyear fairly durable, for example, because the price is right and seems to offer lots of utility, but if it breaks upon first drop, it's kind of useless.
Apple has apple care on everything if needed,aka warranty if needed be
I have a techbox pencil and it has both wireless charging and palm rejection and literally looks like the og ☺️
Can u grab me a link?
I am a college student. I mainly take notes and draw. My first pen was an Apple Pencil 2 gen. Later I bought an unbranded alternative. YEBOS T5X is enough for my daily use, and it is cheap enough!
Hey James! My KXT pencil only works while it’s on charge, it’s been on charge for 2 days but when I took it off the charger the light isn’t coming. However when I charge it and turn it on it works? Any suggestions?
Bad battery?
I just need something cheap to take notes occasionally on my iPad in Uni, when not typing notes.
Anyone knows if apple pencil tip can be used as a replacement for momax pencil tip?
I have the Quadrants stylus and I love it!
As someone that had to use the Logitech crayons, DO NOT buy it if you go to school. The battery goes to shit after maybe a year of use, it breaks apart very easily and the tip isn’t very robust, meaning it stops working partially after some time of heavy use.
thank you James, I had no idea there were backup products ,as mentioned I'm new to ipad digital and procreate. Question? When I purchased the ipad I use, ipad pro 12.9 the apple store said it would only work with the apple pencil 2. Considering the cost I'm a little paranoid about losing it. Will any of these products work with the ipad pro, besides the apple 2 pencil? Thank you in advance. Excellent comparison video.
All the pencils I tested on this video we demoed on my iPad Pro
Superb vid… definitely subscribed!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I do have the apple pen but I also did have a cheaper fake one so they both work the same so if you want something cheap then the fake one is better
I purchased a compatible one for my iPod it works like a charm and cost $21.99 my friend recently got it for $14.99.
what app do you use for colouring???
I bought the IPenbox from Amazon for $29 shipping and handling and it has palm rejection, charges on the iPad, came with extra points, and it comes in different colors. I chose yellow to help me keep track of it. My Apple Pencil died after not being used regularly and that PO’ed me… how can that be fair?
ir's not
Hey James, what do you think about Apple Pencil Hover feature?
Personally it has no appeal to me but I know some people used to other formats like a Wacom it will appeal more
wait what u can use what generation apple pencil on anyipad?
So now one sees an issue with restricting pressure…it’s mean…and after dishing out money on an ipencil that stopped working….Apple has a nerve. But they don’t care about my feelings, just my money.
Heyy do you hear Any tap sound with the real Apple Pencil? Like the fake ones?
I have the ipad mini 4 would u recommend me penyear stylus 🙂
i was quite skeptical of the apple pencile. i love how long it is, i can hold its rear side easily and sketch and shade like how i do in real life. i have to give apple credit for this
Is there a Apple pencil 1 alternative with palm rejection?
How do you charge the Sanfant
How many of these will work on a smartphone?
I have one that actually charges just like the Apple Pencil 2 - I wish you had tried one of those bc I’m curious to hear what you might think of it. It was only around $32 usd.
Wich one?
Apple pen vs Smasung pen that comes with the notes and ultras
Hi, which one can be compatible for ipad 9th gen?
Which app are you using bro
I have the same silver and orange apple pencil
I am a Student and I need an apple pen for my school but I think the real one is too expensive so I need one that is like yknow fake or cheap one that have palm regestion and have flat edge that can stick to the iPad and I don’t need it to draw I just need it to write some work so I don’t need some Apple Pencil that is gonna be able to change the tips or something
Which is best alternate
Non of the cheaper works with CAD programs like shapr 3d.
Great video! What app are you using?
I think he’s using procreate.
So really,
Can you tell me the app that you used to test the iPad pencils to draw please 🥹🥹🥹
Procreate!
Fantastic video
Thank you
I do believe procreate is going to stop supporting other pens besides the apple pencil (I don’t know when, and in what way)
I have one of those!
I’ve seen this video on my recommended for literally 10 times, and I’m finally watching. CZcams, STOP!
I’m tickled that in 2023 there’s still a question of whether there are legitimate alternatives to the Apple Pencil 😅 (yet, here I am, watching another video on the topic😂)
I’d probably have at least two spare Pencil 2’s if I’d saved the money wasted from all the 3rd-party styli I have bought since my first iPad Pro in 2015. In fact, I ended up ‘gifting’ the several I still had left laying around to my sis, who recently bought an iPad model that doesn’t have Pencil support, so she could decide which type she preferred.
Also, considering that popular apps like Procreate are discontinuing support for 3rd-party styli*, I’d stress buying the Apple Pencil even more, particularly for artists (who I imagine comprise the majority of your YTube audience). If you’re going to spend hundreds (at least) on the iPad _Pro,_ do yourself the favor and just add that $130 into the cost of the device and get the Pencil.
I’ve had my Pencil 2 since late 2020 when I got the 4th Gen Pro, and haven’t lost nor broken it, but I don’t have kids or pets, and rarely transport the iPad/Pencil outside anymore, so I may just be an optimal-environment usage case. One thing I’m certain of is I’ll never use anything other than the Apple Pencil as long as I own an iPad ☺️
_(*) The Crayon was built w/Apple Pencil technology, according to Procreate’s FAQs, so that one should still be supported in the app._
Any chance you would give away any one these pencils for students?
I use a Logitech crayon and is an excellent alternative to Apple Pencil. This pencil work great.
Good to know!
What drawing app are you using during this video?
Procreate m8 it’s 13 pound on iPad but is well worth it it is used for professional use all the time
What us the name of the app? also this video is very helpful. 😊
Procreate 😊
I have the laser pen and payed $70 aud for it I had no idea u could get it that cheap😭😭
I got a £2.50 pencil and it does all of it without bluetooth power and batteries. It also can shade.
Tilt and pressure sensitivity?
Brother , Tell me the best Stylus for iPad 4 with 0% Delay ! I am an artist you know !
I got a Apple Pencil 1 for £94 on amazon a couple days ago
Thank you
My pleasure
What app are you using in the demo?
He seems to be using procreate,It does cost money but it's only a 10$ one time payment
Amazing video! Mabye I could buy one too!
Buy which?
Can you put your hand on the screen with all of them
Those pencil alternatives are great, but I’ve experienced a one problem
while using one of those. When you take notes or draw something I always hear how the pencil “knocks the screen” ( I hope it makes sense to you), which is quite annoying for me as I can’t take a pencil with me to school… So, is there the same problem while using an Apple pencil or not?
the apple pencil makes the same noise ur referring to
There are silicone tip you can buy to reduce noice
I use the Adonit Note. ($69 USD). Can’t complain. It does the job nicely.
And no Apple Tax😊
that's almost exactly what I paid for my Apple Pencil 2 ($79.99 at Best Buy on sale)
thank you James Julier
You’re welcome
So, just pressure sensitivity adds 120 dollars?
It also pairs and charges via the magnet, but essentially yes. For most artists pressure sensitivity is highly important though, for me it’s worth every extra dollar for that feature I use daily.
Even if Apple didn't bork competing products, Apple accessories are just more compatible with Apple products.
What is the app u use
Procreate it cost around 15€
The last one on the right is mine
Eu vendo o vídeo com uma caneta touch caseira
A friend of mine found a first gen apple pencil on the street and gave it to me. lol
Lucky
What kind of app is that like what is the name of it
Procreate art app
What app do you use for drawing?
Procreate
Whats the app you used!
Procreate
@@JamesJulier-Artist Thanks
The top piece is not for if the battery dies, cmon man. It’s for the functions your pen can’t perform like swiping home and accessing the control center.
Why would you not do that with your fingers? Makes no sense to me sorry
@@JamesJulier-Artist Because I have a pen in that hand and I’m holding the IPad in the other. It’s more natural to flip it like to erase than it is to readjust so I can use my finger.
I disagree personally i constantly use a combination of pencil and fingers on screen. Pinch to zoom, rotate, two finger erase, three finger swipe for copy and paste and more gestures are in constant use with fingers on the same hand that holds the stylus in apps like procreate. So flipping the stylus around for me would probably be less convenient 🤷♂️
@@JamesJulier-Artist I’m glad we both have opinions.
The Apple Pencil 2 at my Walmart is 80 dollars
If I were you, I would use the Apple Pencil is not the other pencils because it’s super smooth at the inside and the outside it’s kind of like you’re holding a real pencil
Oh I do
Sanfant stylus looks exactly (plus the packaging) to my Metapen A8.
I bought the clone Pencil. The only difference thatI have noted is the battery widget on my iPad 10 will not show the charge percentage of my clone Pencil. I will buy an Apple Pencil when funds permit. I did buy a clone magnetic charger for my Pencil and it works fine.
15:53 I knew something was wrong with this one, fifteen dollars for an iPad pencil???