Sam Harris on the Dangers of Religion
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2011
- New videos DAILY: bigth.ink/youtube
Join Big Think Edge for exclusive videos: bigth.ink/Edge
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ABOUT BIG THINK:
Smarter Faster™
Big Think is the leading source of expert-driven, actionable, educational content -- with thousands of videos, featuring experts ranging from Bill Clinton to Bill Nye, we help you get smarter, faster. Subscribe to learn from top minds like these daily. Get actionable lessons from the world’s greatest thinkers & doers. Our experts are either disrupting or leading their respective fields. We aim to help you explore the big ideas and core skills that define knowledge in the 21st century, so you can apply them to the questions and challenges in your own life.
Other Frequent contributors include Michio Kaku & Neil DeGrasse Tyson.
Michio Kaku Playlist: bigth.ink/kaku
Bill Nye Playlist: bigth.ink/BillNye
Neil DeGrasse Tyson Playlist: bigth.ink/deGrasseTyson
Read more at Bigthink.com for a multitude of articles just as informative and satisfying as our videos. New articles posted daily on a range of intellectual topics.
Join Big Think Edge, to gain access to a world-class learning platform focused on building the soft skills essential to 21st century success. It features insight from many of the most celebrated and intelligent individuals in the world today. Topics on the platform are focused on: emotional intelligence, digital fluency, health and wellness, critical thinking, creativity, communication, career development, lifelong learning, management, problem solving & self-motivation.
BIG THINK EDGE: bigth.ink/Edge
If you're interested in licensing this or any other Big Think clip for commercial or private use, contact our licensing partner, Executive Interviews: bigth.ink/licensing
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow Big Think here:
📰BigThink.com: bigth.ink
🧔Facebook: bigth.ink/facebook
🐦Twitter: bigth.ink/twitter
📸Instagram: bigth.ink/Instragram
📹CZcams: bigth.ink/youtube
✉ E-mail: info@bigthink.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- - Věda a technologie
"Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful" - Seneca
Only after Cicero does this sentence make sense. You should really study history instead of cherry picking quotes from Google.
Just because you are wise does not mean you are susceptible to lies
*Any/all Religion.
President Sunday you should study a science book
@@PresidentSunday against cherry picking and quote mining. How hypocritical. Religion lives on cherry picking, misrepresentation and quote mining
Teaching people from birth to believe and accept things without question is pretty much the reason they do crazy violent things in the name of it
Lets use the people's *H* ardships *I* n order *T* o make them follow b *L* indly and *E* liminate undesi *R* ables!
@@Niemand-o_O we are worth nothing. In the eyes of everything beyond us. Don’t think that we are special
@@brumhelldah917 literally, if you haven’t already, you should watch this short video showing the size of the entire universe AND more, there’s so much and it makes us SO little. it makes me question life itself, what are we? and the fact that we’re given up to 70 and sometimes 100 years of life just to be forced to believe in a religion is so weird to me. why can’t we just do whatever we want to do?
What parents teach their kids is none of your business.
THIS is precisely why ANY kind of 'religious' indoctrination is child abuse (even if the law doesn't see it that way).
When one person suffers from delusions its insanity, but when many suffer from the same delusions its religion.
social contagion and the need to belong
some religions/sects even excommunicate their members, so the need to go along to not lose your family is ever greater
It's atheism*
@@seeker4trvth it's Christianity.
@@ashleyspurling5701 we have evidence for all the claims regarding Jesus' resurection, so no.
@@seeker4trvth and there have been plentiful of historical and scientific evidence proving otherwise, so yeah my original comment still stands.
Critical thinking is SO very important.
I never had critical thinking in public or christian scholl
That same critical thinking led me from agnosticism to Christianity
@@seeker4trvth your thinking but just backwards
@@ray_x6959 shush, it’s his first time.
Logic is what we need,
Not belief.
Facts too and evidence.
Facts and evidence can be faked too so best to just think for yourself
Facts and evidence are man made therefore most likely a lie
@@waltercagle1028 Dude, u had too much crime movies.😂😂😂 Have a break
I pity people who believe intelligence is the only way of life that there is such a thing as useless things. They have a sad look at life.
non religious people are more intelligent and open minded then those who believe in an invisible man who lives in the clouds
It’s that religion makes them close minded.
Maybe more open minded, but not always more intelligent.
@@c-doga9579 generally more intelligent tho
No not necessarily. But most are.
Religion does not make you less open minded. Faith brings us together. You’ve met strict harsh Christians. However in my family we are Christians and believe in God but are open minded to new thing like to have fun. My gf is amazing she goes to a rich Christian high school that my family can’t afford. She’s very intelligent and beautiful I don’t understand how you can come so quick to a conclusion if anything that’s not open minded right there to assume just believe you have faith doesn’t make us as intelligent as those atheists who live with less purpose
"Crushing the heads of the infidels and splitting their skulls with sharp swords, we continually thrust and cut at the enemy. Blood gushed from their deep wounds as the battle wore them down. We conquered bearing the Prophet's fluttering war banner. Our cavalry was submerged in rising dust, and our spears quivered, but by us the Prophet gained victory." - Ishaq:578
Totally peaceful.
Bruh 😂
Religions are against humanity
I want to say that religion is fine... That is until your religion effects other people.
And murders millions and destroys free will
@Breako Please elaborate
At best people stop asking questions, stop being critical and cause their families to stop thinking too.
Amen
Ethan French I completely agree
"Religion is tied to the deepest feelings people have.
The love that arises from that stewing pot is the sweetest and strongest,
but the hate is the hottest, and the anger is the most violent."
― Orson Scott Card, Children of the Mind
Lies did cavemen have religion when they felt anger?
@@rangopistacho6928 We could never know. They might've believed something caused this world to exist and attribute the happiness and folly of this world. So they might've had religion but not in a formal way. They probably never would've written it down or drew it.
@@rangopistacho6928 Also, how did you know that cave people's anger was "deep."
I love Sam Harris so much... Intelligence, knowledge, eloquence, all beyond genius.
I used to think that religion means following Jesus/God.
But now I know it's bondage.
religion can be harmful in a personal way, especially when it comes to relating to other people that do not share your views, because their religion forbids it.
There is no God.
My confirmation bias as a person who was raised in a religious family tells me otherwise. God DOES exist. JK.
God doesn't exist. You're right. Even if he did exist, the Bible wouldn't be his word. That book is full of silly mythology. Why would any God write that?
nuoipter termer As a former Christian that escaped a cult of Pentecostalism, I've seen God! What I beliebe is God anyway. Meditation is key. Nirvana is possible.
nuoipter termer .. What if you get that wrong?
I love how you feel the need to put a smiley face after condemning someone to eternal torment. What a sad state of affairs.
nuoipter termer um.. have you seen Harry Styles? I’d worship him any day.
How is this not the number one conversation in the world
Precisely because the vast, vast majority of people are in one way or another religious.
Because this and other absolutely MAD concepts are still being accepted, not questioned and put on a pedestal by society.
Can’t bash Religious people because I use to pray everyday but I hope they all wake up and do some research like I did.. The world is a big place with a ton of history 🤷🏻♂️
Ryan Antonio your prayers apparently don’t work. Cos there isn’t anyone listening
If god was truly a man of no sin then he would be selfless enough to not need the worship on millions of people. Relegion is the worst thing to happen to man. It tears people apart.
We need more people like you I agree completely it has murdered and hurt the lives of many more than Hitler and Stalin god in truth is more evil than the devil
Aether religion does not tear people apart, sin does, and so does people, atheists have done bad things too you know, we must accept everyone like how I accept you as an atheist, love everyone (except terrorists, alt rights, and Logan paul)
Rango pistacho you do realize hitler was anti Christian, Muslim,and Jewish, he stopped being Christian at age 18 even though he allowed them to practice their religion, but he was an atheist
@@jmartinez2005 You are invoking religious principles right after saying religion doesn't tear people apart. Thanks for proving his point, Mr. Oblivious.
the fact that this is under the radar speaks volumes
Nobody talks about the fact that the countries in Europe--Greece, Italy, Ire, Port, Spain--with the largest recent debt problems are also the most religious!
Feels good knowing I'm not the only one who doesn't fall for this religious bullshit first out of my whole family.
That 10 percent of people would downvote this is shocking.
Thank you. I have watched ten of his videos now. He is very intelligent and logical. I wish more atheists were like him. Let me give you a little knowledge of psychology that I picked up while I was getting my degree. When you try to win an argument by becoming louder or aggressive or by ridicule, you only cause your opponent to become defensive and cling to his opinion even more passionately. That is, the louder you proclaim yourself, the less people will listen to you. (cont)
Look like Ben Stiller
“Religion should unite all hearts and cause wars and disputes to vanish from the face of the earth; it should give birth to spirituality, and bring light and life to every soul. If religion becomes a cause of dislike, hatred and division, it would be better to be without it... Any religion which is not a cause of love and unity is no religion.” ~ Baha'i Faith
Good luck with that when we have different languages, cultures and beliefs. And religion is just belief anyway... There is no proof that anything off it is real!! It is all just belief. You have to believe that some guy 2000 years ago walked on water, healed the sick etc... Well good.. But thousands of years earlier the Egyptian god Horus did exactly the same thing!! Who is copying who!!! Dumbass humanity!!!
@@Bone74838 An orchard full of fruit trees is a delight; so is a plantation planted with many species of shrubs. It is just the diversity and variety that constitutes its charm; each flower, each tree, each fruit, beside being beautiful in itself, brings out by contrast the qualities of the others, and shows to advantage the special loveliness of each and all." ~ Baha'i Faith (1853)
As I said, they both have contradictions, where they sometimes tell you to kill your enemies, and sometimes tell you to love them and convert them. Despite all contradictions, they do claim to worship the same God (Yahwe), but have different opinions on what said God wants them to do.
My family hates it when i raise up the flaws in the bible absolutely hates it it is tearing my family apart
They are indoctrinated like the rest, it is often an exercise in futility to try and reason with people indoctrinated since childhood
It’s amazing of how clearly you see things when you stop pretending.
One instance of a few well-educated suicide bombers doesn't impress me much and it certainly doesn't prove that lack of education and a low quality of life aren't contributing factors to acts of terrorism in the middle east. It's not the whole reason, but it's part of it.
Education and common sense don't necessarily go hand in hand. I know of some educated people with no common sense whatsoever.
I believe organized religion is often necessary to teach moral ways. But once you "graduate" from religion, I think organized religion is really an obstacle to personal development. But to say God does not exist, in my opinion this is going too far.
Organized religion as 'training' wheels, that hopefully, as you grow and mature psychologically and mentally, you will no longer need. Or want.
The individual has been persecuted throughout time. Religious leaders would say that building yourself is evil, how can this be? How can loving and believing in oneself be a bad thing? What would happen if we had a society of kind, compassionate, and reasonable individuals. How can anything that is pleasurable be bad? If one knows themselves they will not lose themselves to hatred, perversion, ignorance, the group, and their own emotions.
Thank you for posting this, bigthink.
What the hell are you talking about lefties?!?
This channel is mostly based on rational thought rather than on political ideology... I don't see anyone being "left".
However if you believe that being peaceful and tolerant towards fellow human beings and promoting this kind of behaviour is "left-leaned" I think you should check your sources, as well as whether you dont suffer from the ideology that the common opinion (=>resulting from mostly rational thought) is always wrong
Sam Harris on one video + lounge jazz on another video = logic and relaxation
I'm okay with religion. The only time it starts to get toxic is when the other religions attack each other and then it gets very messy
A link to the news articles/events you are discussing in the video would be helpful as time passes and no one knows what you are referencing.
There are times when the concept of "Atheism" becomes blurred. Is Atheism an intrinsic reductionism of expectation? Do Atheist have a set of possibles that can not be surpassed? Are Atheists self-absorbed into their own assumptions of the world just as any religious person is? Is the self-assurance of the common not-scientifically trained Atheist as dangerous as the one of the religious type as both may act without considering any other point of view (self-righteousness). What do you think?
There have been countless cases where people have died from a heart attack or something, and then later brought back to life by a defibrillator. And they reported seeing absolutely nothing, they weren't even aware that they were dead. I think that's enough proof we need.
There is a more fundamental issue at stake here than the shortcomings of extremists. Religion fosters this idea that we are all being watched over by an all seeing eye and there will be consequences for our actions, regardless of whether or not we get away with something. This systematic approach to remedying human behavior is without a doubt important. Unless you think we're all fundamentally good at our core. I wouldn't say that we're all evil at our core, but we are all selfish.
I fought from within to break free from men telling me I was wicked and the life from my womb is sinful. That I need to invite in a male spirit. I am a woman not a man. Why would I need a mans spirit in me? I only need this seed love and respect. That creates a happy family.
The link doesn't work.
I met a muslim who said 911 was an inside job of people who wanted to make islam look bad... he then threatened to beat me up about 5 minutes after that topic. xD xD
If you follow your emotions too much, you will never know spiritual reality. Emotions are often an enemy of the spirit. Emotions like anger, fear, lust, craving, envy, indulgence and hedonism are all enemies of the spirit. We learn to control our emotions instead of letting our emotions control us. We don't become emotionally dead but we learn to do the right thing whether we feel like it or not. (cont)
@daddyrich3701 It's true that you can sue a newspaper for character defamation. But as someone who has actually tried to do that, it's really hard. They're well funded and proving intent is difficult. Also, they are protected, even in court, from giving up their sources. It's really hard to win those cases. But it does happen.
I think it's a matter of fear and a easy out for most, that's the only reason one would buy in to such silly ideas.
I think "religions" (though technically not religions) like Buddhism or Taoism are useful because they actually teach you things and they don't reject certain kinds of people. and they aren't really about forcing you into their ideas
They are philosophies that teach you to be a good person
The big question one must ask, and what many philosophers have been asking is “is there purpose, meaning, and value to life?” In an atheistic worldview there objectively isn’t. For humanity itself wasn’t created for a purpose, thus there isn’t any right or wrong way to live. Also what value is there to human life? We are all just cosmic accidents, truly no more valuable than a rock. Humanity will one day die out and whether you lived like Stalin or mother Teresa it won’t matter.
So is so called religion really that dangerous? No, but in denying God or a creator, atheists have destroyed foundations that humanity has built itself upon. If atheism is true, religious people are actually living it the right way, since there isn’t a wrong way to actually live your life.
but if atheism is true there is nothing objectively wrong with that. You shouldn't judge religions by it's abuse, but by its proper use. I am not denying people have done things and justified it in the name of God, but that has more to do with sinful people rather than what that religion actually teaches. At the end of the day if atheism is true and there is no objective purpose or meaning to life and humans don't have inherent value. What is objectively wrong with people living out whatever purpose they want? Hitler and Stalin lived out to what they thought to be their purpose and Ghandi and Mother Teresa chose their path. In the end it wouldn't matter, nobody did anything wrong or right. I have some videos you might like to watch or check out.
czcams.com/video/ZqNTT0E_T70/video.html
czcams.com/video/NKGnXgH_CzE/video.html
That says more about humans than religion. I could say the same things about people who aren't religous and that they needed it, such as Stalin or Mao. Again if there is no purpose in life there is no sense in calling religion bad, with no objective purpose everyone is allowed to create their own.. But to say it is a demonstrable evil also looks past great things people who are religous have done and great teachings, example Mother Teresas of the world.
I agree. There's a big difference between not participating in organized religion and denying that God exists. The first is okay, but the second is not okay.
No, purpose is conjured by us. We give ourselves meaning not fuckig god
@@c-doga9579 We can deny God exists and millions do. It's not ok with you but it's perfectly reasonable for the people who deny he exists.
@74BobLilly Indeed, it might very well be radical, but that doesn't change the fact that his style and presentation is much milder and gentler than Hitchens. Hitchens also proposes that we may have to strike first in such a situation. Hitchens proposes a MUCH more aggressive stance when dealing with those who wish to reinstitute the Caliphate. He says that it absolutely cannot be allowed to happen, no matter what measures have to be taken to stop it.
A radical idea doesn't make one harsh.
Yes, the teaching of love ad mercy ad forgiveness is a hindrance to the "survival of the fittest" , right?
Yet, it is written "Beloved, let us love one another, for love is of God; and everyone who loves is born of God and knows God"
(1 John 4.7)
It has always felt emtpy. Speaking in tongues never meant anything to me, perhaps because I spoke German, Spanish, and Sign Language decades before I ever "spoke in tongues". So seriously, I wasn't impressed by speaking in tongues. Much of the deconversion crisis he described, I went through when I was thirteen. I had to know the truth regardless of how it made me feel or whether I liked the truth or not. (cont)
As you said, people are willing to die for thwir belifes, as I am willing to. Though know that I DO NOT belive in violence. But belive what you believe. You are entitled to your beliefs.
Science is collecting and organizing knowledge. Religion never did that. Religions have packages of teachings that are ultimately true in their world view. It's not about knowledge but about how much you believe this world view is right. Religion has never been anything close to science. It just tried to do, what science today does. And because what science tells us sounds a lot more possible than what religions tell us, we trust in science, today and not in religion so much.
At the same time, I do see a few flaws that must be addressed. First, his former Christianity was based on emotion. Repeatedly he said, "I felt like God was real" or "It no longer had the same feeling that it had before". People often confuse the spiritual with the emotional. Therefore, I don't think that he was genuinely a Christian specifically because he had an emotional experience. He said that speaking in tongues used to feel meaningful but now felt empty. I've spoken in tongues.(cont)
good guy tells the truth
i know.
i'm an Atheist too, but a lot of atheists think that without religion there would be world peace.. that is idiotic to think that. Yes, the world would be better without religion, but not perfect.
Well religion caused 90% conflict in all our history...plus it closes peoples minds to just follow one book except do the thing we were naturally formed to do and that is question everything and find out and prove/disprove shit. Religion just closes people in a box and says this is how u live, dont question it and if u do and stop believing u go to hell and burn for eternity. The use of fear is what makes me not believe it's real because that is the most human thing to do.
Nobody said there would be world peace without religion, anyone with a braincell would know this. One can argue for less hostility and needless sectarianism, but never an outright utopia..far from it. It only equates to lesser problems to have to deal with.
It's has more to do with religious cults than anything else.
What's the difference either way people died because of them
Rango pistacho not all cults and religions are like that
Religion, cult. Same thing.
Please change your background color. Unwatchable.
Great words from a great man
The problem is religion. Time to wake up!!! Study the history of religion. Then think again.
Time + cult = religion
There is a difference between specialized knowledge at an advanced level (e.g neurosurgery) and the big picture / objective knowledge, which rationally undermines religious belief. These types of knowlege are both sources of power... the former produces money, the latter produces wisdom.
To John; I love my girlfriend and my family and my friends, and I've never met God. I don't know him. He has never addressed me in any formal manor.
To Eugene; Teaching love and mercy does anything but hinder "survival of the fittest". It increases the survival. But why need someone else to tell you to love?
the big 3 religions are about control. Get them to believe things that can't be validated, get them to focus on the past, get them to listen to others rather than their internal guide. Moral of the story? Listen to your internal guide, do good, learn the truth, focus on your future
Just think: Hundreds of wars were started by religion in some way. How many were started by science?
Zero
I think science comes in to explain human behavior and nature. Religion FEEDS that human nature by amplifying the conviction to hate and go to war. We men really are wretched things just like what Achilles said.
@@pepehorhae religions are technically un natural to the world we created them as a means of controlling the population, but then wars began because people believed in other things, fun fact a majority of Christian and catholic priests only joined because they got to do pedophilic stuff without going to prison still happens today, religions should just fade away they have caused more terrible things than satan has, we need to move on and innovate a better future together not bound by the rules of a false god
Actually, I have never seen mockery cause someone to research his faith. I've seen mockery cause angry backlashes.
Love this guy. Rapier whit and true voice of reason.
Still do believe society in the past created the concept of religion to prevent barbarism. By seeking truth and the only truth also justification for their own beliefs, each religion also gave birth to the concept of extremism indirectly.
I never said anything about a "spiritual experience". Also, conscience is different from conscious. Look them up in a dictionary.
My religion is based on help me help you help each other help everyone. The religion today cause division war and separation its puts a person psychological veiws on life in fear
My dear friend, it is wonderful that you have love in your heart. I just have to tell you that no one is perfect, and there would be some misunderstanding and arguments.
The Spirit teaches us the way of humbleness, forgiveness, because we naturally want our way, and the bible teaches us to seek what's best for others, not ourselves. It also teaches us the way of faithless, because after several years we naturally tend to be attracted to someone else, and only the Holy Spirit can bring its peace
Yeah you defineatly brought peace to gay people, Jews, and a bunch of non believers back then you so prevented wars that killed millions dude shut up you can be humble and kind without some god telling you to do so
Rango pistacho that is why I made a cult that is non biased
@iracundiarock I think he focused on that example so that Christians might grasp the point. He could have just as easily spoke of Christian crusades, or Christian American parents who have killed their children because "god told them to" or Christian American parents who refused to bring their children to the doctor and opted instead for prayer which resulted in great suffering and death of the child, or of the Christian Americans that protest funerals and rejoice in the suffering of Americans.
When you read Exodus 20, you'll notice that Moses created the commandments in order to control others. He didn't like what they were doing so he told them that God told him that they need to follow some specific rules (more than ten but the others are so obsolete that they're no longer mentioned by religious people). They believed him since they were ignorant. Of course, he broke his own commandments and then crafted new ones after destroying the original 12 tablets.
If you are a person who truly believes what you have just said, you would still believe these things regardless whether you had ever read the bible, or even heard of religion. There are good people, and bad people. It is human nature. As some animals are good-natured and some are not, humans are the same (as we are animals too of course!)
The Bible is a great book, with many amazing teachings. It is just a shame that many of it's readers do not live by the example they say we should.
@74BobLilly It's not a sudden admiration. I've always liked a well-turned vicious phrase. If it makes you pay attention, as it seems to have done, all the better.
Atheism is not a THING to find appealing. It's a non-belief. It's not a dogma or doctrine or creed. It's merely non-belief in gods. So if you find some arguments more appealing, fine.
I don't care who appeals to you as long as you give up your hate-filled dogma and use the intellect you possess for the good of the world.
well, I think it's quite the opposite.
One issue i have is i personally i see it that if you are well-educated, you don't follow faith. Ergo not religion. If I can outsmart you/make a point you believe in false easily+quickly, shows you weren't well educated.
"Religion breeds violence. And essence of violence stems from duality."
- . . .
@A and how many wars have been started because of religion?
@A Feel free to expound.
@A I typed in a quote. Feel free to elaborate on your argument. I'm interested.
@A I just wanted to read it from your perspective. But nevermind.
@M bruh- religion has caused crusades, and jewish people being hunted down, so hush
and it seems like justification of beating slaves, but i think its really a deterrent to keep slaves from "courting" out their slavery they owe the other person, if they know he can in fact beat them to a degree they are less likely to try to break their contract with him. he also tells slave owners to treat their slaves kindly and well and treat them as they would jesus. you have to looker deeper.
@pnarey He doesn't need to beat a dead horse that's already been buried as far as reason is concerned. Watch some of his debates with theologians if you'd like to see that.
You must seek the Lord with all your heart. (Said in a loving female voice)
The catch is... good plays hide and seek. And trust that he is really damn freaking good. That's why we have no evidence of his where abouts or existence.
God exists, but he is so far beyond us, it is our choice to "fear God" or pay the price.
What the fuck did u just say. That's the most cringey shit ever 🤣🤣 God plays hide and seek with all the starving african children *said in a loving female voice*
@hatter00 Thanks. I'll think about what u said over a cup of coffee.
@@c-doga9579 Hush, cult member
Atheists like Sam need to stop using the word "god" as a proper noun and just talk about "a god".. When we agree there are no "Gods" but then use the word "god" as a proper noun it kinda confuses the argument. Its making the christian god appear to own the title "god".
Well, given the context of a Christian-dominated culture he grew up in, then I would say, yes - he is addressing his more immediate audience first and foremost. It is the largest religion after all..at least for now. Sam still makes it clear that apart from monotheism, the idea of any god is silly.
wow, this a very Left leaning channel, but one of the few times I have actually heard someone from the left actually call out Islam,
Good Job!!
I know, he picked on Christianity at the beginning but ALL lefties do that, VERY few call out the Quaran as a book of violence.
We pick on Christianity because it's the dominant religion here in the US. Muslims only make-up 1.1% of the US population while 70.6% of the US population are Christian. Our society is not influenced by Islam while Christianity does
I bet you're american..conflating politics with everything. This has nothing to do with leftism. Sounds bipolar to dichotomize everything between left wing and right wing
it is not so much about religion, it's the fact that one person believes in something that is different. for instance raider fans stabbing charger fans at a game. same can be said for a group of hooligans fighting each other because manchester is playing liverpool! that's what's dangerous. down to the nitty gritty is that as long as there are humans left on this planet, there will always be conflict because no two people will ever agree on everything.
I did not say ALL Atheists. I said most.
Also, I would like to hear what you think about faith. I'm not speaking for others but I won't be offended by what you think about faith.
people justify religion by obscure, irrational and complex references from religious books, then others get easly satisfied, and so on
I wonder which religion he always defends?
Think about it.
You and I have different definitions of faith. You define faith as believing despite the evidence. My definition of faith is a combination of loyalty and trust. I don't just believe that God exists. I trust God.
Do you sometimes doubt gravity? Do you ever fear that one day, gravity will stop working?
God is not "hiding". But humans often approach God with bad attitudes and expect God to respond. God is under no obligation to do as you expect him to.
The first crusade was a defensive conflict the pope sanctioned only after the desperate christian rulers of middle eastern lands had sent him letters asking for help. The Islamic empire was formed through a series of brutal conquests of formerly christian and jewish lands. The history of christian/muslim conflict didn't begin with the crusades. Also, it should be borne in mind that while the sacking of Jerusalem was a terrible atrocity, it was nothing unusual for the time.
You forgot the word "most"
Telling religious people there is no God isn’t working, as they are inherently dogmatic. Their dogmatism comes from the fear of there not being a God. So we need to address their fears. That’s the tough one.
@IvanAndreevich
He doesn't use "reason and logic" to prove his points. He uses anecdotes. I don't expect anyone to be convinced by that. It will only appease the atheist existentialists who already believe (or at least want to believe) it. You can make anything sound dangerous by linking them to terrorism but that doesn't make it so.
An excuse? War doesn't need an excuse - that is to say - in the eyes of the people doing it. Their cause would already be 'right' and need no further justification such as religion. It does appear that religion is the reason. Even 'normal' people have abnormally strong beliefs - it's not hard to imagine the extreme!
Also, it sounds to me like you're claiming that the excuse of religion is almost obvious or readily clear. So how an earth is that a good excuse if it's so transparent?
I wasn't saying that people don't kill in the name of religion. I was saying that people kill for a wide variety of reasons and many of those reasons have nothing to do with religion. If you think the way to peace is by getting rid of religion, than you also have to get rid of money, natural resources, pride, all races and sexuality because these also cause violence. Humanity is violent, with or without religion.
Unfortunately something I think a lot of Atheists don't seem to make a distinction between is giving up a certain religion and giving up god. Yes these are actually two different things.
Nobody said otherwise. Also, you can never lump all atheists as they are not the same. They literally only have one thing in common.
We should have listened to him...
Now it's too late!
guilty too, which makes it so she has more incentive to tell everyone rather than her being able to be manipulated by the man and quieted. if you look deeply. theres wisdom in these seemly weird laws God talked about. you cant just read a verse you have to take the whole book into context together. but i can totally see why that would seem so cruel and unfair of God because i too have thought the same thing and gone through this.
Yep.
I understand where you are coming from, although Harris does not advocate extreme action. As the younger Atheists become more experianced they will more than likely become more like Dennett and Stenger.
A belief in a monotheistic god is called self-dishonesty. There is only virtue in honesty. To lay the foundation of self-dishonesty is to align oneself with vice.
All theisms are deranged, but monotheism - at least I would argue similarly to Neil DeGrasse that there's a charm to animism or spiritualism of sorts, and that monotheism is more troublesome in its premise and application.
As you may have guessed I am not Religious, but I certainly have morals. I am kind to people I meet, even if I don't know them and of course I love my family; I can't say I LOVE my neighbours but I certainly like them, they're nice people, and also non religious... And to think that you only abide by your moral code so you can win your place in Heaven... Are you saying that the only reason you don't steal, rape and murder is because you are worried of the consequences in the next life??
@MurderousMarta "Like some people say the bible is a book of stories bit it doesn't make them not true."
Take out the "not" and you have a similarly legitimate argument for the other side. It's bad because some/most believers have faith that there is a God to enforce the stories as legitimate, or else...
We are to investigate and explore about what the religions say.We must question and enquire about their gods.But this spirit is never allowed in the educational institutions.Some religions claim that their religion is for peace.But their aspirants turn out to be terrorists.A big WHY?