Why did Jesus curse a fig tree when it wasn't yet the season for figs? (Mark

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
  • You can eat paggîm (brebas), but you might not like them ...

Komentáře • 57

  • @ericaskinner5833
    @ericaskinner5833 Před 2 lety +19

    That was probably the most impactful 2 minutes of Biblical teaching I have heard in a very long time. Thank you for sharing!

  • @meebling99
    @meebling99 Před 5 měsíci +6

    I needed this specific insight, THANK YOU so much for taking the time to make and publish this video. I felt that God was very unfair to curse a tree for simply functioning according to its design, but now it makes sense. God bless you.

  • @fengjiezhou3949
    @fengjiezhou3949 Před 20 dny

    I was reading Mark 11:12-21 and wondering how a fig tree bears its fruits, and I found this video. Later I went to Cultural Background Study Bible to understand the temple cleanse, and I noticed that Dr. Keener is the NT editor of the Study Bible. Wow! Thank you for loving and teaching God's word.

  • @Valhalla369
    @Valhalla369 Před 6 měsíci +3

    I had searched and watched so many videos on this topic. This is the ONLY one that makes sense.

  • @LearndingLife
    @LearndingLife Před 2 lety +6

    So beautifully put! We have a fig tree in the neighbors yard that hangs into ours, it produces those little fruits before it ever produces a single leaf, still stands, if we aren't bearing fruit in season, are we planted beside still waters? Thank you so much for posting these! I've always wanted to go to the Holy Land, not sure I will ever get to go though so it means a lot to have videos like this with pairing lessons that help with the understanding ever better, thank you Dr. Keener. ^.^ Be blessed with HIS abundant shalom in your life brother!

    • @CraigKeenerPhD
      @CraigKeenerPhD  Před 2 lety +2

      Thanks for your corroboration about the little fruits! Blessings!

  • @ecstasy8261
    @ecstasy8261 Před 6 měsíci +2

    This also symbolizes the day of judgement. No man knows when it is going to come, so we have to be ready for it to come at any time. Just like the fig tree, we have to produce fruit on and off season.

  • @ecstasy8261
    @ecstasy8261 Před 6 měsíci +5

    I was so confused before watching this video. But as always, the bible isn't wrong, I just didn't know enough about fig trees 😅

  • @RealBelisariusCawl
    @RealBelisariusCawl Před měsícem

    The cursed fig tree has got to be one of the funniest moments in the Bible, as well as a good lesson.

  • @brianringham9745
    @brianringham9745 Před 23 dny +1

    The old Rabbis believed the tree of good and evil was a fig tree, when Jesus says, May no one ever eat from you again, he is for telling us of the cross, where he will pay the ransom to free us from the curse of death, which was brought on by Adam and Eve eating the fruit and the penalty (curse) was death. The truth will set you free! Truth is not a thing ….Jesus is Truth…

  • @fcomolineiro7596
    @fcomolineiro7596 Před měsícem +1

    My personal theory, he really wanted some figs and was a little bit mad that it wanst the season

  • @Proverbs31_25
    @Proverbs31_25 Před 7 měsíci +1

    i would read the whole chapter 1st - yet i believed he wants us to be ready & have the Holy Spirit at all times in all seasons or be cursed ... i think that i was close 🙏🏼
    Thank you for sharing

  • @jewishbride5010
    @jewishbride5010 Před rokem

    Praise God for not accepting an empty harvest! I therefore bind one to recognize God by carrying fruit for God his kingdom in order to be recognized by God in my life, the lives of my family, friends, colleagues, neighbours, acquitances, opponents and the body of Christ while binding to hell one to accept any empty harvest that is not for God his glory, binding to hell every unequal yoke and common share with anyone lacking to carry fruit for God his kingdom in order to be recognized by God, in accordance with this word and mark 11:13-14, 2 corinthians 6:14-18 in the name and blood of Jesus Christ, amen and hallelujah ❤!

  • @AC-rt1vw
    @AC-rt1vw Před rokem +6

    This is pretty illogical. How can God curse a tree for not going out of its way to bear fruit for him.
    *READ THE ENTIRE ARGUMENT BEFORE RESPONDING PLS*
    That’s like God catching a fish then cursing the fish for not recognizing him and instantly cooking itself or not immediately coming to him and saving him the time of having to catch it.
    Or cursing the sun for not recognizing him and becoming cooler so he won’t sweat or get thirsty, fatigue or have any difficulty traveling
    Not to mention it’s a tree. How can anyone expect a tree to be able to know a persons status. That’s like a king getting mad at a tree for not knowing it’s a king and immediately bearing the sweetest fruit.
    And trees also cannot just instantly grow fruit and have it ripe that instant. So seems kinda selfish, arrogant and obnoxious of this “god” for getting mad at a tree for not being able to do something it simply cannot do.
    It’s like getting mad at a chicken for not being able to just at will lay an egg whenever u request. That’s not possible,it all takes time and an entire process. If his interpretation of the verse is true then the biblical god seems to be very unreasonable.
    And dude. If Jesus is god them u use your own powers and make the tree bear the fruit u need. If he can turn water into wine, walk on water and raise the dead making a tree grow the fruit u want instant should be no big deal.
    Does this “god” expect the tree to be able to predict the future and know
    “god is going to come here next month and hes going to want to take some fruit from me so I better start growing fruit early so it can be ready the same day comes and idk get a gun to scare off anyone who might try and get some fruit before god can get some”
    This is nonsense and even if Jesus is truly God this is a mockery of God just to come up with some argument as to why he curses a tree. And this is just assumption. It isn’t back by any actual scholarly work it’s just you coming up with your own interpretation of the verse and assuming it’s right.
    Imagine going to a tree and being so unreasonable expecting a tree to somehow notice that u are God when even human unless told aren’t able to and even some who are told still require some supernatural miracle before they can accept it, u expect a tree to instantly know this and not only that but some how instantly have fruit ready for u or grow fruit in a way unnatural to it.
    What next is he going to get mad at a baby for not recongnizimg him as God and instantly going out of the laws of nature/biology and become an adult or a teen and know how to speak and bow down, so it can bow down and praise Jesus.
    Well he next expect a mentally challenged person to be able to know he’s God and bow down and praise him.
    Will he next expect food to know he’s God and instantly become sweeter or hell cut itself up to the shapes he likes
    Will he expect clothing to know he’s God and instantly become his size when it some how is able to notice that he has a liking to it.
    This is sheer nonsense and quite literally a arrogant mockery of both Jesus and God regardless of your biblical beliefs of them
    And in this same chapter he goes and tells the apostles to go and untie a colt.
    Was he secretly in his mind cursing the colt for not knowing he’s God or unlike the tree predicting that God is coming so it untie itself 😑
    And I’m a bit confused on why u said it was in fact of season when the verse itself says it wasn’t. Fig fruit is the only fruit to my knowledge that grows on figs. That fruit u were showing is literally a fig fruit.
    So this makes him even more obnoxious and unreasonable (at least in your interpretation of the verse) expecting a tree that’s not in season to bear fruit.
    That’s like cursing a apple tree in the heart of winter for not having fruit.
    And no when he goes to Jerusalem in chapter 12 he’s not mad at anyone for not recognizing him as God.
    That parable had nothing at all to do with implying Jesus being divine or not divine.
    In the parable the people the owner of the tree he put in charge didn’t want to hand it over to him or listen to his instructions . Same way God the people he put in charge didn’t want hand over the temple to him or listen to his instructions. Instead they chose to make it a market and make money instead of it being a place for God.
    This has nothing to do with anyone being divine 😭and nor is it even related to the story in mark 11. Just because one chapter had fruit tree in it and the chapter after it also does it doesn’t mean they are linked in any way. Cause both stories don’t share many of any similarities other than a fruit tree being there.
    And let’s say I am wrong and he is right about this part. It doesn’t change anything.
    It’s still “god” cursing a fig tree for not bearing fruit when it’s not even in season and made at it for not recognizing him as “god” and going against the laws of nature and growing fruit when it’s not even in season.
    And if anything HE IS TO BLAME for the tree not being able to bear fruit not the tree itself;
    Fruits typically grow in response to seasonal changes in temperature, daylight length, and other environmental factors. When conditions are favorable, such as during the spring and summer months, the plant will develop flowers and then fruit. However, when conditions are not favorable, such as during the winter months, the plant will not produce fruit.
    This is because the growth and development of fruit require specific environmental conditions and the availability of certain nutrients. For example, the plant needs sufficient sunlight and warmth to support photosynthesis and the production of energy for growth. In addition, the plant requires the right balance of water and nutrients to support the development of the fruit.
    When environmental conditions are not suitable, the plant will go into a dormant state, where growth and development slow down or stop altogether. This allows the plant to conserve energy and resources until conditions become more favorable. Therefore, fruits cannot grow when out of season because the plant is not able to undergo the necessary growth and development processes required for fruit production.“
    So if this is a just and fair honest god he wouldn’t curse a tree for it not recognizing him and “showing it’s fruits” because the tree cannot do it on its own nor does it have any control over what helps it grow fruits.
    So if he is a just and honest god he should go and curse the sun, the weather, the soil or hell just the entire environment and ecosystem the fig tree is in. Or curse himself, the father, the holy spirit or just the godhead in general because that’s the god/persons that are in control of all of this.
    Fig tree cannot control the weather and the environment it’s in so it can grow fruit in preparation when Jesus is coming even when it’s out of season.
    This whole 2 minute video is a mockery of the Abrahamic God and even the biblical God and Jesus himself.

    • @CraigKeenerPhD
      @CraigKeenerPhD  Před rokem +5

      Did you bother to watch the entire 2 minute video before responding??

    • @AC-rt1vw
      @AC-rt1vw Před rokem

      @@CraigKeenerPhD yes I did. I even went back and watched it multiple times over after I posted my comment and went back and edit it multiple times.
      I even went and read the the full mark 11 and mark 12.
      So I’ve done more than watch the entire video before responding 👍😁

    • @AndMakrid
      @AndMakrid Před rokem

      @@CraigKeenerPhD Give us the opposite example in the Gospels Mr. Keener, where a tree recognized its Lord and bore him fruit out of season.

    • @susannahfox7188
      @susannahfox7188 Před rokem

      @@AC-rt1vw Have you ever heard of a parable? The bible is full of parables.......just like this explanation. Newsflash, the weather and everything else on the planet including the planet itself is/was created by our great God, Jesus Christ. He can do whatever he wants in order to produce the "fruit" he is looking for, whether vegetable or human.

    • @AC-rt1vw
      @AC-rt1vw Před rokem

      @@susannahfox7188 have you actually read the entire thing I said. No doubt the Bible is filled with parables, but that doesn’t make this whole thing make sense at all.
      You cannot tell me God insulted a fruit tree that wasn’t in season for not somehow being able to recognize him and not only that but go out of its nature and grow fruit instantly even thought it’s not in season and tell me this is all just a parable. It doesn’t make any sense at all. So God now just goes around harassing trees and cursing it for not doing something it simply isn’t capable of doing (growing fruit instantly when it’s out of season) just to make a parable. That doesn’t make any sense at all.
      I don’t see how you telling me God created everything on earth addresses anything in my comment, I’m not an atheist I believe in God too.
      Ur not even addressing anything I said. Just because the guy in the video is wrong doesn’t mean anything against the Christian faith. It just means he is wrong. So you don’t have to defend him so hard even though he’s wrong

  • @lanabowers5332
    @lanabowers5332 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Here is the correct & historical meaning of this event. There were 2 political parties, one was called the 'Figtree' & the other party was called the 'Vineyard'. The Figtree party wanted war with Rome, & the Vineyard party wanted peace. In addition to the missions of the Essenes & the ruling Herods, there was another mission in Rome. This was the one called the'Figtree'. From 4BC, the disputes about the Herodian succession that had been fought out in Rome between the brothers Archaelaus and Antipas had led to a splitting of Herodian loyalties. Antipas must have established a different house, and the mission that continued from his house continued to be hostile to the ruling Herods. This mission which looked to the Therapeuts of Egypt rather than to Palestinian Essenes for its ascetic discipline was called the Figtree because Therapeuts did not drink wine and were skilled in the medical arts. The Vineyard & the Figtree were associated but had separate organizations. As a parable in Luke says, " A Figtree was planted in a Vineyard". Simon Magus was a subsequent leader of the Zealot Figtree mission, closely associated with the tetrarch Antipas. On Monday, March 2d, 33AD, Jesus went to the temple treasury (in Qumran) at the time for money collection. No fulfillment has occurred for those expecting a Restoration at SS3969 ( 1st position, Samaritan 31st). Jesus says it is because of the financial corruption and overturns the furniture for the banking system. The next day was March 3. When there was no fulfillment at the regular 31st, Jesus attacks the Herodian form of mission, including that of the tetrarch, the Figtree. When he 'cursed the Figtree', he was condemning their financial exploitations, zealot ambitions & their methods which were compromising the mission, & he expelled them.

    • @CraigKeenerPhD
      @CraigKeenerPhD  Před 10 měsíci +1

      This is not found in the primary sources from antiquity.

  • @christiandavis5332
    @christiandavis5332 Před rokem +1

    To me it means that whenever you end something, you only need to say it once.. not twice, not 20 times in the duration of months and years.. but 1 time…

    • @cesarbst8170
      @cesarbst8170 Před 2 měsíci

      No it means that you cut down everything that doesn't bear fruit in your life.

  • @lucasmiller664
    @lucasmiller664 Před 4 měsíci +1

    @CraigKeenerPhD - I would like to use this clip in my church, but we stream on CZcams. Would that cause copyright issues?

    • @CraigKeenerPhD
      @CraigKeenerPhD  Před 4 měsíci

      I don't know how CZcams works, but I would hope it wouldn't be a problem. I post these for free, so anybody should be able to use them (I am glad for people to use it!)

    • @juggergabro
      @juggergabro Před 2 měsíci

      Shouldn't be a problem, God bless

  • @johnnyjoey1487
    @johnnyjoey1487 Před rokem +1

    Who else is here after seeing Louis CK's new standup?? 😅 He goes thru this story in the "Dolby" show if anyone is interested. I was really curious what the supposed deeper meaning behind this was going to be and this is about what I expected.
    Jesus kills a tree because it isn't bearing fruit when out of season. Then we have to find some sort of profound message behind it.
    Not buying it guys, sorry.

  • @rainygorges3403
    @rainygorges3403 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Halleluyah!

  • @yeahbuddy4712
    @yeahbuddy4712 Před 7 měsíci +1

    It say clearly he was hungry...why would he go to a fig tree hungry?..why would Mark make this point that hes hungry?..

  • @projectbirdfeederman5491
    @projectbirdfeederman5491 Před měsícem

    poor fig tree couldn't pull off a miracle

  • @michaelsabados3829
    @michaelsabados3829 Před 3 měsíci

    Because the type of figs Jesus cursed was supposed to bear off season fruit, look it up! God bless, Christ is God in the flesh. ♥️

    • @user-ds2ej3wn8p
      @user-ds2ej3wn8p Před 3 měsíci

      It was because the Jews did not bear any fruit. They rejected Christ and did not know that it was the time of their visitation. The scriptures no where teach that Israel would be a nation again, in fact Israel only existed as the intact 12 tribes, there are no 12 tribes intact now today.The northern kingdom was already defunct in BC 720, only the southern kingdom of Judea remained at the time of Christ's appearance and that was under a puppet king controlled by Rome. The US and Britain is awash with false teaching invented by John Nelson Darby that unsaved Jews are still God's people, this false teaching suddenly emerged in the mid nineteenth century, John Nelson Darby was the co founder of a sect known as the Plymouth brethren, his poisonous heresy spread across the Atlantic Ocean and is now enshrined as doctrine in almost every Baptist and charismatic Pentecostal churches in America, along with the false teaching of a rapture and an earthly reign of Christ on earth for 1000 years, this flys in the face of what Christ and the apostle Paul taught, that the resurrection takes place on the last day, in other words there are no more days after Christ's s second coming as the earth will be destroyed, rapture theology reverses the order found in 2 Thessalonians that THE DEAD IN CHRIST MUST BE FIRSTLY RAISED AND THEN WE WHO REMAIN UNTO THE COMING OF CHRIST will be taken up to meet the Lord in the air.
      As for the Jews still being God's covenant people as falsely taught by John Nelson Darby, that's impossible since Jesus himself said in the parable of the tenants of the vineyard that the kingdom would be taken away from the Jews (the tenants) and given to another nation that would bear fruit, that happened on Pentecost Day. As for Christ having an earthly reign for 1000 years, how so? Christ's reign is eternal and His kingdom shall have no end.
      John Nelson Darby misinterpreted the book of revelation. For example if God gives certain individuals the right to reign with Him for 1000 years is that the same as Christ reigning for 1000 years? I hope people can see the error here. We are supposed to be like the noble Bereans and read the scriptures to see whether these things be so.
      In the last days men shall not be able to endure sound doctrine

  • @taylorpike1191
    @taylorpike1191 Před měsícem

    So the (very real) tree was FIGurative.
    I'll see myself out.

  • @BB-my3bq
    @BB-my3bq Před rokem

    It must be a good video but voice is too low

  • @conwellboccia1004
    @conwellboccia1004 Před 10 měsíci

    All of these great swelling words and no one bothers to search the scriptures for the FIRST mention of Jesus being hungry, Matthew 4:3. Hmm. Jesus turned water to wine but no mention of Him drinking any! Jesus miraculously fed 9,000 men + women & children but no mention He ate any of it. Jesus provides 153 great fishes without breaking the net yet already has fish on the fire. What do all of these accounts have in common? Let's see, Jesus has the power to turn stones to bread, water to wine, multiply a tiny amount of food to satisfy multitudes, give His disciples the biggest catch of their lives without the net breaking, COULD HE ALSO HAVE THE POWER TO MAKE A FIG TREE BRING FORTH FRUIT OUT OF SEASON? I think so. I KNOW so. So why didn't He just command the tree to produce some figs instead of drying it up? Go back to Matthew 4:3 for the answer. "O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out!"