Rome's homeless refugees at the heart of European law row
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 06. 2024
- Europe's refugees face a growing crisis -- they cannot escape poor living conditions in Italy because European law doesn't allow them to leave their first country of entry. Britain's right to remove refugees and asylum seekers under the so-called 'Dublin regulations' is being challenged in the courts. Harriet Grant investigates
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Go home. Stop expecting Italians to pay for you.
yess
Agree but they can't go home cause war
mark anderson in Britain in WW2, young men joined the army and fought, not run away. Women took on hard labour to keep the country going,. Women worked the land, no farm machinery then.
@@annemcniell6956 Tell it!
True... They expect the UK, Italy, Euorope to pay for everything. They aren't Italians why do they feel so entitled...
The simple truth is you are not welcomed in Europe.
I'm an immigrant and the fact that these countries accept us alone is enough. They do not owe us anything but rather we pay back their kindness
The Dali Lama said "They have to go back". He said European Nations cannot be allowed to become Islamic. The End.
Oh! You haven’t been given a house? I’m so sorry for that! Italy hasn’t given me a house either 😂😂😂
italy small country ya more people its problem for italy
IT amazes me how people think they should get free money and houses! Nothing is free! Someone worked for that money!
What he means is Italy won't hand out benefits like the UK does. I'm from the UK and I'm glad they are gone! I've paid thousands into the system over the years and have been employed since I was 15! I don't want my hard earned money going to these scrounging wasters. Housing, healthcare, benefits and other services are pushed to the limits so why should they get them over someone who was born in the country? -And who's parents have contributed as I have? Forced labour for the unemployable would soon see them disappear. Get them to join the army, do something good for the country they are invading.
it's not Italy's responsibility to feed house and cloth these economic migrants!!!
Hes a refugee. He has asylum. Did u not listen before ur hate. Are ukranians ok cos they are not brown.?? ++
Take them back. No hesitation or delay. Their human right is to go home.
Italy should take care of it's own people firstly.
Oh, my god, disaster......only a one bedroom flat. I wonder how many young Italians are given the same by their own country.
So they believe they're entitled to housing? I thought they were fleeing all kinds of horrors back home. They should be grateful to be alive.
They wont be alive long without shelter and food. Ukraine knows that right now. Racism so vile
In reality, the way Europeans drew their borders and treated then during decolonization and colonization led to this mess.
Why does he think Italians owe him a house?
They are welfare hunters.
Maybe cause Italians destroyed n invaded his home in Africa once upon a time.
Italy has not been at war since 1943 , I'm sure his Hut was not built after that.
John Smith well the French colonies in Africa still pay taxes to France , money that could have gone to his hut is now being stored in French reserve bank.
This guy wants Italy to set him up not France. Even though he enters a country Illegally.
The entitlement and ignorance is too much to handle. I can't even watch this.
The chap that wants to go to England , but if gets deported he wants deported to Afghanistan not Italy , so Afghanistan is safe .
It's a shame the migrants don't fight like that from the Country they fled in fear, not.
Very simple Go BACK HOME !!
John Howard yes for those who are from safe countries. But real refugees need to be helped, ...... as long the war goes on. Those economic ones destroy everything for the real refugees. 😕 meanwhile I also feel sorry for them, not for all but some of them.
@@froggylegspeople Froggy Legs. Real refugees that are fleeing countries that are at war normally act very grateful. This bunch are not from countries who are at war, they are a bunch of hooligans.
Build your country educate yourself fight for your rights I feel sad for you but Europe cannot take every one especially if you are a Muslim they cannot live in peace we need educated GOOD people please do Good in your own lands create beautiful Lovely things our men and women went through wars to get what we have now Please do Good God be with you
John Howard , go home, just stay home 😉
Gula roos Stop judging. You don’t know their situation neither what they been through.
They have more nerve than a bum tooth. No one has given them houses!! Did Africa give them houses?? No one has given the citizen of Italy anything. They have worked very hard to have what they have. 😑
Even I am from Asia and currently living in Europe. Every month I pay big amount of tax and can't even imagine to get any service without paying! And those people want houses. Great
Where are women n children that really need help with that war stuff. These are military aged men ... clearly economic migrants
And who paid for the dam college? Cuz ur broke azzes dont get financial aid so who paid for ur college and apt??? This is what bothers me. Many americans cant even afford rent! Yet u show up. NOT UNDER DURESS. Get money apt and college degree!!! Do u realize how many people have college debt!!!! Bums. Go back and help build up ur own country. Work with ur gov to get all these same free azz programs. Stop using my got dam hard earned money for ur lazy azz
@@tempgirl00711 somalia is now peaceful and if there is any war still remaining, it's their ignorance and 'religion of peace' they love that cause people's adrenaline to boil higher than their ability because of oppression of freedom of choice.
You are stupid for saying this because the ones they interview in this video are all from countries with war
Exactly
Like JAPANESE KNOTWEED
"He has been given a refugee status, but nowhere to live." And..? Did someone forget to send him a memo about how the World isn't all sunshine and rainbows?
Ukrainians???? Or are white people ok.
Nobody forced them to migrate there. They chose to do it.
But they should be forced to unmigrate there!
ll l hahahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 u are so funy You have no idea whats going in the world
And they were not invited either
@8:33 "deport me back to afganistan'? would rather back to afganistan than italy? did he just admit that he lied about claiming a refugee status? his life is not in danger in afganistan?
Hence why his face isn't seen
They are resposible for themselves why the hell they expect Italy to look after them?
Entitlement mentality gone rampant.
Zio-Sorosism gone mAAAd!!!
Insanely mad!
WeekNightGaming I agree with you completely. However they wouldn't be entitled to a damn thing in their own country.
And who paid for the dam college? Cuz ur broke azzes dont get financial aid so who paid for ur college and apt??? This is what bothers me. Many americans cant even afford rent! Yet u show up. NOT UNDER DURESS. Get money apt and college degree!!! Do u realize how many people have college debt!!!! Bums. Go back and help build up ur own country. Work with ur gov to get all these same free azz programs. Stop using my got dam hard earned money for ur lazy azz
I can't believe how dumb they are to think they will get a house just like that!!
5:44 you are not from England,you are somilian.
Whoever told these people they were owed something lied to them. They arent owed a damn thing.
We send millions in aid to these countries, what do they think we are😡
I haven't heard one of these guys mention work they just keep saying we want our money and our house
1:35-6:09
They meant exactly what they said.
Why they expect so much
.....finding work is difficult in Italy, you really think they haven't tried...
@@barbara4670 Why should they try? Word goes around that in Europe one can get money for free. That attracts masses of profiteers, whose elementary vocabulary is: “Give me.”
I don't get the point of these black guys wanting to come to great Britain because I met enough men from Zimbabwe and they complain about the council in England and the weather and how rude all the English are so why not just live in Africa?
Calling people "black guys" is not just offensive and superficial, but shows deep ignorance from your side.
We all have the rights to complain, If someone complains does not mean he is not in right for the subject of the complain.
Following your (sick&ignorant)logic, all black guys are ungrateful then?
All white are good?
What if a white man gets a dark tan, to which group he belongs then?
BikeTravelTheater.org
He will still be a white man with tan skin.
which is better than being a black for your logic?
Mysterious Sniper True.
They will gladly use tagiyya.
Also, look what they have done with Iran? 1979. A single year later. Disgusting.
Iranians want freedom again and the moral police are shitting their pants and arresting ppl for flashmob protest which used watergun fight among the activists. I know, those horrible decedents. How dare they.
During the Ottoman rule they took children for the janissary. Yeah, seems like there haven't been anything generally messed with the ideology.
The fellow from Ivory Coast is in shock that he would be provided with papers to stay but no free housing. Where does this mistaken belief come from? I keep hearing that the illegals EXPECT jobs and free housing. Who told them to expect that? So many disappointed people. Does no one research the country they are fleeing to? They all seem to have smartphones.
flightless butterfly good talk bro it pains me when they talking like this. No job, no house like he has those benefits back home.
flightless butterfly
*Open sociiety foundation..George Sorrows* additional watch out Calergi Plan,
In Sweden I seen a video of Somali women and men protesting because they have to give a portion of the welfare money for their rent , They said that they want their apts. to be completely rent free.
The Ivory coast isn't a war zone thus he is an economic migrant there is already enough homeless and unemployment in Europe we don't need more!!!
Smartphones supplied thanks to George Soros.
I dont understand why these people dont understand that they dont just deserve everything and they shouldn't get everything for free! We have enough poor people and old people to take care of in Europe! Sorry to say but reality is reality, you aren't entitled to everything just because you made it to Europe
AKACG they aren't entitled to Anything.
My first thoughts are don't welcomed them by accepted financial gains, on their backs, pretending to help them by letting them believed that they're welcomed to them lives them in dissaray.. Better kept them in their countries and help them to help themselves.
Honestly, why do you think you deserve to live in wealth? because you were born in the right part of the world? Its not that they ask for money for free, but a chance to build up their life in peace together with family and of course also work for it.
I don’t understand why they think they are entitled to HELP.....??? What is help? A free ride it sounds like to me 🙄🙄🙄😡
....if i come to italy without a visa or passport, will i be given entry and free accommodation ? ....what about my human rights ?
"Even though we have papers, we live on the street" Ummm, what did you think would happen? Did he really think they would get free houses too??? Really?
They are war immigrants!! Why are they complining if they are out of war???
Instead of staying in Europe for years, they should have build a future in the countries they come from. It is easy to come to Europe and hold your hand up. Stop complaining
and back off.
@Unorthodox Behaviour Maybe if we stopped invading their country for oil, then they would've build their country more.
Molhedim you make no sense IDIOT.
They never get along with each other.
I never invaded for oil.
Your brain in destroyed !
That's what Europe did to each other 70 yrs ago not anly Hutu and Tutsi
5:40
Guy1: IM FROM NORWAY
guy2: IM FROM ENGLAND
GUY3: IM FROM ENGLAND
THESE PEOPLE ARE FROM LIBYA, GHANA, KENYA.
Don't claim something that you are not.
I would say they are rather from an eastern african country, most probably from Somalia, Eritrea or Sudan.
Imagine how dangerous it is in that building for the very few girls or women or even boys!
Even if they are given homes they will still complain.
As an italian, i'm very glad my country is discouraging these people from staying here. Honestly, i think we're one of the most racist country in europe and i'm okay with that. Just leave us alone : )
Aldo Manu thumbs up for honesty
YOU are racist, not Italy
Sono nata in Colombia , Ma mio nonno Era Italiano.......I am with you all the way!
La Italia e bella e dobresti essere soltanto per gli Italiani e basta!
Italy for Italians !!!
just like it should be........Italy does not owe anything to the Africans
yes Italians are racist......its ironic cause they love black women--
But they are racist, that is their problem--just leave them alone
if u do not like how they are , do not visit Italy
in italy there are racists like anywhere else, i am italian, not racist and i know hundreds of non italian racists, therefore stop talking by putting labels on 60mln people. the irony of this video is that at least italy gave them asylum while UK expelled them, therefore in this video is mostly UK being the racist one.
Italy is in a deep economic crisis if there is no jobbs for Italians then how will it be work for unskilled refugees? it becomes a evil circule with no end.
@ Leo. Its very true. Economic and jobless are epidemics in Italy. When the truth is said I do agreed. But to forget the facts that Italians are immigrants themselves, and their saucy stories worldwide need to be remembered, cause its been encrypted.
@@birdyelke775 Italians who live in Italy are not immigrants
@@MrPinbert Are you that dumb, idiota!! Am referred about Italians residing every corners of the world. In every cornerstone of the worlds , there are Italians..
How do u know they are unskilled????? My doctor is a refugee from Nigeria
@@birdyelke775 Did you make that one up all by yourself?
The problem would be solved easy if we would make the law that everyone who support "refugees " would has to support them with THEY OWN MONEY . And share THEY OWN APARTMENTS with them .
Leo Sebastian Good idea.
Such a great idea, these people need to leave they using the Hague as their savior, Italy should place a law that automatically deports all these immigrants. They need to leave, I could only hope that Europe wakes the hell up and realize what's going on. Europe will be filled with immigrants in the next 30-50 years figure around 60-70 percent of a typical European country will be immigrants.
Even better resolve would be to make an account of how much of resources the European countries have taken from the immigrant's home country, inflate it to current levels and then allott that amount for their welfare. Seems fair
or if people could decide to give or not to give. support financing someone from abroad? pay 15 percent more taxes to cover it.
I love how they demand everything as if it's a right. What would their countries do to asylum seekers? Give them money and housing? Ya.
Syria took many european refugees in ww2.
They think they are entitled to all these rights and free stuff because of colonislism. Of course I don't agree with that!
Same happens year on year till this day,
If you come go get a "hostel" like ppl have to here,
Ppl sleep rough,
Yet these expect it all.
Starting to come to am end tho.
"In England, I got a one bedroom flat, college education, and £55 per week". Unlike many EU nationals or British themselves who have to pay for that either using their own money or apply for a loan. Are they not aware that all that costs money? And England is one of the most expensive regions to live in.
Why dont you ask the ukranians fleeing war??? War and persecution is the same whether you are black or white
@@thelawisthelaw Are you trying to imply the Ukrainian refugees get a flat, college education and 55 pounds per week from EU or UK government(s)?
@@alexwinner3980 yes they do
If the European asylum system is to become "equal", it won't mean other European countries adapt the Nordic system, but the Nordic countries will adapt the southern system. Europe cannot afford to pay massive handouts to everyone who comes asking.
Another lie
@@thelawisthelaw Another brainless comment. You’re annoying.
@@thelawisthelaw Why is this a lie?
You sleep outside...
Preferably in your own country.
How can see sit there with a straight face expecting european governments to help you when your own government is doing nothing at all for you?! The balls!
Hewhoislikegod0.They have this expectation that is their right to demand and receive everything they want for free. Nothing can change this mentality of these people and it is going to cause a lot of problems for Europe.
Hewhoislikegod0 we have sent millions of aid to these countries
@@juliusmaehlich3138 We don't have such kind of mentality. First, I want you to understand that we have been broken by war, basic human rights, and economic hardship. we just want economic support until we can care our selves, start education and job. Furthermore, I don't know in your country but there is a culture in Africa that if some guest comes to your house and you don't have an extra bed or food, we prefer to give the thing we have to the guest first. So, please be human for this time it will not last long. I'm sure you can't resist if something happens to you as theirs and migrate putting your life at risk.
@@filmonokbu3360 I am from Africa therefor I know what is happening there. Address the African governments for they are the culprits creating the misery for their people and should fix it. The human aid donated by the West should not go into their own pockets but be used to impose all the basic needs of the people living there so that it will not be necessary for this problematical immigrating to the West.
@@juliusmaehlich3138 Ok, if you r from our continent, plss don't add to these comments saying they only need free meals, dormitory, or sth else.
Hahahahahaha , give you a house....
because.....? What did you give to society,to ask for a house...? I love to get a house doing nothing ,but doesn’t work that way.
We are scared for our lives back home but Italy is not good enough for us! Coming to a city near you folks!
I felt bad for some of the guys, especially the one in a suit (preparing for a interview?), but I thought most of them were arrogant. They seem to think that they're owed something by Europe. And where are the women? Did they just leave them behind?
It also would have been nice to see some interviewees presenting the other side's point of view, instead it was all very one-sided.
Of course it the Guardian, about as Left wing as the SWP newspaper.
How can they say they're from England, if they were from England, they would stay there! They are from Africa and should go back home and build up their own country instead of ruining the countries where they go to!
Giada Fallaci they're saying they migrated to england originally, but dublin forced them into italy. They would've stayed if they could've.
Dublin is not in England, it is in the Republic of Ireland. Sounds like they are country shopping for the best welfare but Ireland (or England) realised and kicked them out. These are migrants, not refugees.
They said they are refugees,from war torn country
Big L. They lie.
Geneva convention states refugees go to the nearest country, not the country of their choice. They should be in Africa, and the Middle East according to actual Law- Not anywhere in Europe.
It's like growing JAPANESE KNOTWEED in your garden..letting these free loaders in
They need to go home and work with people to make THEIR OWN COUNTRY better!
If Europe is to survive it needs to rediscover its heritage and morality and ultimately to repatriate these people, by force if necessary.
WAHHHH HAHAHAHAHA LOL. ROFL
Why does this person think someone else owes them anything? They have been allowed into the country which is far more than they deserve.
European men fight for their country, these people leave their families and run away rather than fight
So they figure that once you have the papers IT COMES WITH A HOUSE. Since when?
Why can't they look for work and find a place? they have papers. they are gonna just sit there on the curb till someone gives each of them a house? I don't understand why they want to blame someone else for not looking after themselves once given status.
I feel sorry for these people. It’s same here in the UK. We are full. Not much work and no housing no school places and NHS is breaking. Best off staying where you are.
I am English and I expect to be refugee in my own country in 20 years
Yes just financial scroungers .
So this fellow left his home in the Ivory Coast and went to Libya and from there to Italy - Is there not one country on the continent of Africa where he could have sought asylum ? The answer would seem to be ' no '.
In the 1990's, the Hutus in Rwanda murdered 800,000 Tutsi in a matter of days by hacking them to death. There is only a small difference in the shape of the noses from one tribe to another. Yet, Italy is suppose to let these same people in and if they have problems with them--the Italians are called racist.
If these two tribes can't get along with each-other--how are the Italian suppose to get along with them--plus Italian men want to see beautiful Italian women, not Africa women.
Africa is for Africans. And Italy should be for Italians and their children.
Dario Ghidoni your logic leads us to the conclusion that nobody should leave the frontiers of the state they were born in - ever. Eventually, that will result in accute endogamy, and the disastrous effects of intra-familiar breeding are well known. Your aesthetical view of human bodies is culturally shaped. You see others as essentially different although they are just different in appearence.
I agree
Actually it was the europeans who made the division when they colonised it
Jus machetes. Wait till u start getting the suicide bombing terrorrists then u have urself a real dam problem. The gov is to blame!! Pile them all onto a plane n drop them all off. Listen 2 the people!!!!
Europe is for Europeans!!!!
Migrants who are not happy how they are treated in Europe... Well they can always go back to their own home country, surely they do better in there. European countries need to tighten their border controls. Schengen contract doesn't mean the border control should be non-existent even between the Schengen countries. Seems like there is no more DISCIPLINE in Europe.
Schengen doesnt apply to africa lol. Did u not hear him say hes a legal. Asylum seeker??? But its easy . Pay properly for the cobalt or lithium in yoyr warrior phone.
where is my money, and where is my house, oh sorry i lived here all my life
don't look like there starving to me to be honest I don't want them here
Saudi Arabia is in position to help the African countries their wealth can provide water , grow plants jobs schools to educate.etc. Europe should contact the government of Saudi Arabia for help
Carol M
They want to spread their idealogy, religion, around the west. Years ahead when numbers are much greater they want be tolerating westerners.
🎤🎸🎶 love Memphis
they already do over 30 percent of saudi arabia are immigrants more than all European countries apart from russia
They do contribute
Free house, free college, free money every week... no wonder he was happy in England!
Being poor does not qualify for being an asylum seeker.
How entitled they are, Italian homeless sleep on streets , some have to beg, these just wander in and expect gold plated services 🤬
It’s a pity to those immigrant, they think that when they came to European country, there is food in the tables waiting for them and shelter, they don’t know that even the legal citizen were out of jobs and living in the street.
How can they have same equal as the as the legals?
lol what do they want? once they arrive everything is given to them for free? :D :D
That's what thrive been told !!
really, when my parents immigrated there were no free handouts. Find a job, bring a skill, adapt to your new country. They had to make it on their own.
Why should he just be given a free house? Many who are born & bred in a country are denied such things & have to work very hard for them.
This guy thinks he is entitled to a luxury flat and a welfare income. And this belief is the fault of Brussels. VDL in chair is insane. First of all Europe must boot her out.
Something that I see in this video and others is that the areas these men stay in are always dirty. Just because you are poor or homeless doesn't mean you have to be dirty or put graffiti on the walls.
wow, they all love UK !!
The UK has the most generous refugee program, but it's full. All of the most recent refugees try to get into Britain and fail.
why dont they hold their countries responsible...
I don't see them doing any thing. Cleaning up, cutting hair, nothing.....
Most of these are not refugees.
They are economic migrants.
What if everybody did this?
“Where is the help?” Lol why do we owe you help? Get real. If I go to Afghanistan, which help would I receive? I might be killed.
They haven't given us houses. This is the problem.
THIS IS GOING TO HAVE SERIOUS POLITICAL AND SOCIAL CONSEQUENCES.
Level of entitlement: over 9000. The first dude is asking for things that not even most of native Italians could ask for or get. His attitude is that of a celebrity who booked a month suite in a 5 star hotel and paid it all in advance with the tips! No wonder reports like this one made Trump win.
LOL they want FREE HOUSES???
lmaooooo GET THE FUCK OUTTA HEAR!!!!!
No shit, Joe. These people always have their hands out looking for free shit. BTW, where are the woman? Home to suffer as victims of war. Man up and fix your own country and stop looking for strangers in strange lands to feed and house you. Italians have enough to worry about financially, they don't need to worry about people who can't contribute.
You’d be a fool to think these guys are telling the reporter the truth.....
It's time all Benefits are Stopped For Asylum Seekers and Immigrants that try and come to the UK
How can the world combat terrorism, and corrupt dictatorial leaders?
If we can solve those two problems, people won't need to flee their countries due to poverty.
In certain EU countries citizens fall always behind in the list for free apts, and will never get one, even if they pay taxes... Why? Because immigrants who never paid taxes and want to work illegally get them.
My cousin lives in Italy there is a family of Africans that live next to him that have been living in Italy for fifteen years in that time they have been living in Italy the family have never worked one day they have been on welfare the fifteen years they been in Italy
you want a house, then you must get a job to pay for housing, plain and simple
I can resolve this problem in 3 years
I find it difficult to feel compassion for these people.
Understandable given imbecile Biden's lack of action on your Southern border.
Sounds like my entire life..
They need to fix their own country.
You have no right to any house, you have to work for it, go home.
Next time I go to Italy, I'm going as a refugee: Free housing, free food, and free weakly money. Of course, since I live in Italy, I am going to vote for fascism so as to stop my tax money going to Africans who want free housing, free food, and free weakly money.
Africa is for Africans. Asia is for Asians. And Europe is one giant soup-kitchen?
If anybody lets strangers to set in his own property he must be total IDIOT!!!
Then U need to stop starting wars in those African countries and Asian countries then you see who will want to come there.All Europeans and American they go to Asia and Africa and come up with stories of dictatorship leader and Nuclear weapon, at the end they disturb peace in that country in order to take resources for free, and when people start to migrate to their countries , you nonhuman human being start saying we come for benefits in your country while your government is busy stealing oil and other minerals in Asia and Africa for you to have that luxury life in your country.Mostly the UK and the son USA.
You white started this mess when you first migrated from your in continent and started making colonies to steal resources from Africa and Asia.
I have never seen any country in Europe which was colonized by an African or Asian Country.
We will come to Europe and demand for benefits whether you like or Not cause those benefits come from our land that you steal by fueling war.
@@ceonawiri7797 did you forget the ottoman empire buddy? It was ruled by an asian ethnic group, the turks.
@@tobiasboston7795 just like the way Egyptian's ,Tunisians, Libyans and Moroccan's are in Africa continents? Are they Africans or Arabs from Middle East .you tell me.
@@ceonawiri7797 yes, just like that. Turks aren't european. And no, north africans aren't middle eastern.
It is not Italy's responsibility to take care of these people. We need to help these people in their home country not in ours.
They flee war. Do u want ukranians to stay where they are.
It makes you wonder where all the foreign aid over the past 50 years from European countries has gone to.
The Europeans do not owe illegal migrants a house; were do people get these ideas? This fiasco will impact tourism.
What entitlement! I came back to my country and no they did not give me an apt. I had to get a jobe and roommates till i was able to move on my own