Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
War and what comes after | Clemantine Wamariya
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 08. 2024
- Clemantine Wamariya was six years old when the Rwandan Civil War forced her and her sister to flee their home in Kigali, leaving their parents and everything they knew behind. In this deeply personal talk, she tells the story of how she became a refugee, living in camps in seven countries over the next six years -- and how she's tried to make sense of what came after.
Check out more TED Talks: www.ted.com
The TED Talks channel features the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more.
Follow TED on Twitter: / tedtalks
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / ted
She gave me chills. I also lost my parents during that same genocide. I am so numb about it. I wouldn't know what to say. I have decided never to make it part of the stories i share with the world. I applaud her courage.
The some for me,I really respect her courage
I’m really sorry about your parents...
Am sorry kevin
*hugs* a real hug... honestly i am sorry
wow , courageous .. to open yourself up to the world about an experience so traumatic .. I’ll definitely be buying her memoir !
T.K. her book is amazing
So powerful. And here it is in 2021, and we need this message more than ever.
She's was really emotional while giving us the speech..
rightfully so . it was a beyond traumatic experience
What an odd comment to make. Of course she was emotional. Who wouldn’t be if you witnessed something as horrific as the Rwandan genocide at 6 years old?
Europe Ruined the black continent of Africa. they drew boundaries on a continent without even looking at the cultures and different unique tribes and people. The European countries divided the Land in the black continent of africa like it was a Pizza plate. Each took their own to eat. EUROPE AND ITS DESCENDANTS RUINED THE BLACK CONTINENT OF AFRICA THROUGH COLONIALISM, SLAVERY, ANT THE TAKING OF OUR RESOURCES WHICH ARE STILL BEING TAKEN TODAY. AFRICAN COUNTRIES ARE IN MODERN SLAVERY TO EUROPEAN COUNTRIES, ESPECIALLY FRANCE. THE EUROPEANS ARE THE ONES WHO INVADED AND DESTROYED THE GREAT MALLIAN EMPIRE AND MASSA MOUSA. EUROPEANS NEED TO STOP DENYING WHAT EUROPE HAS DONE TO THE BLACK CONTINENT OF AFRICA. PEOPLE AND EUROPEANS AND THEIR DESCENDANTS NEED TO STOP DENYING THE CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY THAT EUROPEANS HAS DONE TO THE CONTINENT OF AFRICA AND BLACK PEOPLE AS A WHOLE. GOD IS A JUST GOD. GOD WILL JUDGE THESE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES INCLUDING USA FOR WHAT THEY HAVE DONE TO THE BLACK CONTINENT OF AFRICA. IN YESHUA S MIGHTY NAME. I THANK YOU TAKING, THE TIME TO READ MY COMMENT.
Your speech touched me on so many levels. Be blessed
Ooh what a beautiful soul! Well said our beauty. Imana ikurinde
The saddest part is people do understand destruction and its many noises. We all know what it is what it can do we have words for all of it. Same with mutual destruction. Its very much in our nature to destroy each other even without the struggle of survival driving us.
It's great though to remind whoever you can that war and dehumanization is still very much real no matter how much religious or governmental justification it may have. It just sucks that we have literally centuries of recorded history of geonicide, war, rape and death in the millions and we still don't learn (although we are in the biggest time of peace for our species in history, should be accounted for)
This sound so familiar as I heard her speak I can almost believe that she has been in my head
she is sooo beautiful
this is the best thing i eva reid!
Great talk
Great speech, BELGIAN AND FRNCE AND CDI PLOTED THIS
Watching it at 1.5 speed sounds better.
mhtinla hey not bad thanks
mhtinla 1.25 is best for me
Agreed fam she drags her sentences out tbh
I’m proud that my question sparked so many comments.Thanks.
Was it for you to be noticed that you asked a stupid inhumane question?
Heard that Stromae's father who was rwandese died in genocide hence the story behind Papaoutai ,sad story though , much love from europe
Beautiful soul
OMG how can you criticise this? To be a caring human being
It's not a civil war it is 1994 genocide against Tutsi, Kindly correct that description
she is pretty
Very meaningful talk
Sarah Bernhauer So, what meaning did you find?
❤
Well done
Too good
Thumbs up for being human.
Lol
😂
Gr8
Ted can u add russian subs if u can do it, sorry for question
Si cierto
After reading some of the comments to this video, I think it would be better to turn them off at all.
That's never the answer, if people have inappropriate comments then it could be a cry for help and then we have a chance to help them and make a real difference. Silence is a catalyst for corruption
Это выступление не для слабонервных. Очень сложно не разреветься.
😢 Ntibyari byoroshye
The most efficient words to stop war are the threat of greater violence. "Speak softly and carry a big stick."
Nope. The greater words are "love and brotherhood".
@@rashmit65 Everybody believes in love and brotherhood. Soldiers kill to protect their brothers. They love their counties and their people so much that they have gone to war to protect them for 10,000 years of near-constant violence.
With 1.5x speed it sounds normal
King omg thank you. I thought I was the only one thinking she talks too slow
if I were giving a speech in a language other than my native tongue , about a devastatingly emotional experience , I’d take my time too
T.K. That's okay. I don't blame her. It's just smoother to listen for me and maybe enjoy the talk and what she has to say instead of being annoyed the whole time
Tuff crowd
Here voice tones ☹️💔
Her voice tones annoy me
Clemantine Wamariya, I fully understand. I truly do. But I want to ask if you've gotten treatment for your PTSD (or complex PTSD).
Light-based EMDR, CBT and other emerging scientific methods are very effective for most.
where’d you get your medical degree ?
from playing doctor with your mom
War and genocide are two different things. You can have one without the other. A war can be civil but genocide is always uncivil.
Is large scale murder ever civil?
WTF lol
There is no such thing as a civil (or nice) war.
Civil War denier!!
2
You don’t have to see the other side as inhuman in order to kill them.
What are you even talking about?
11:32
War has changed
"War. War never changes." -Fallout 4
"War" has never changed. It is unchecked agression by governments that choose to jepoardize their own country's future i.e. it's people. For what? Oil? Land? Diamonds?
War has certainly changed.
This has always been what war was like. Mass rape, mass murders, rampant torture and all without point.
Apoco?
let's start spreading de word genophillia
Byararangiye hasigaye ifirimbi ya nyuma...Kurikirira ukuri ganza
czcams.com/video/lKoCMoSgOeY/video.html
Tears, put us (me my self and I) all of us into tears. The three of us would way rather cry tears of joy for humanity finely achieving" humanity", true world peace ; no crime of any kind , no blood shed, rather no one letting blood unwillingly. no un-consequential penetrations. Every time any thing inters your body against your will it is raping you. As a family, as a body, humanity as whole, has bin raping each other way to long. Killing for what ever cause to have a reason to kill, penetrating unwilling participants, raping with there bullets.
...............she's childhood is so scared and so..............
Not sure where she was going with this? She had a crappy childhood, not sure why that’s a counter argument to war.
Gizmomaster
Read Rwanda genocide to understand. The war btwn hutu and tutsi
significant talk.....😞😒
not a war it is a genocide
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwandan_Civil_War
I didn’t understand.
momo
Research it is all over youtube! "Rwandan Genocide" educate you're damn self
What she described and experienced did not begin in the first world war. The Armenian genocide preceded it.
Yet WW1planted the seeds from which WW11 sprang from. And that war planted seeds of hate and revenge that led to numerous conflicts that would come later such as Vietnam, Korean War and numerous other ones. In fact, some historians believe that even to this day, the world has not recovered from WW1.
this comment is more informative and more insightful than the whole talk.
I want to like this. Her message comes from her heart, her emotions seem honest and she painted a vivid picture.
Still, this talk basically goes nowhere. War and/or genocide cause great harm and we should avoid them - nothing new there. All we get to know is her story and the chaos that it has left in her mind.
War can feel very detached from reality without personal stories like Clemantina's to paint a more vivid picture . I think if History were taught this way growing up I would definitely have cared a lot more and payed more attention .
celestialcircledance
You are probably right there, thanks. I seem to forget that importance, as personal stories don't seem to make a lot of difference to my own understanding of world events. Many people might need her story to relate better!
If you feel the impulse to hate when you hear "Trump" or "liberal", remember this talk. That hate, taken just a few steps further plus government power, is all that's needed for genocide.
This is why Antifa's attack on neo-nazis and klansman in Charottesville was so very concerning. Antifa put on display the sort of hate that makes for genocide. It doesn't matter that they attacked other people who might also feel that same depth of hate.
Nitpick that this talk is terribly misnamed. War and genocide aren't the same thing.
Right
战争是可耻的。
and yet, an anagram of her name is "Maniacal War Enmity"
42nd view and 18th like
czcams.com/video/mXo8EAptX2E/video.html
21st view and first like
I know about hutsi genocide in Rovanda,but the relevance?
mohammad mostafaii the relevance is that thousands of people were killed because their government told them to. Just like the Holocaust. Who knows if anyone of those individuals that died due to War, Genocide and the Holocaust would have made an impact on the world by curing a diease? A diease or addiction anyone of our family members may suffer from. Is that relevant enough?
And that it was so easy and was more horrific than a simple word can capture.
Myanmar
rwanda. its very relevant.
She is acting , not expressing just her true feelings.
that is the point.
We already knew that war causes suffering. What is your solution?
Why is this at Ted women, this is a human story not a woman story. Everyone should hear this not over 90% of women and that one guy who is "ally" or something. Could you sort imortant talks on general and period talks on Ted Women and ichy balls talks (or something similar :D) on Ted Men, thanks.
you know that it's not forbidden for men to watch tedwomens conferences, right?
Ar Mance yes. But if you call it ted blonde, mostly just blond people will come. Making it group specific alienates everyone who is not in that group. So if you decide to make it specific atleast have some "real" reason, like the talks would be more less useless to anyone outside of the group. Women dont "need" to know the thermodinamic property of foreskin or male hornonal cyckle (generaly) so those talks should/can be on ted men but genocide have no gender or race or age ect. Sorry for my english, its not my first language.
On CZcams the title just said TED talk , War and What Comes After . Not sure what your referring to but you are right that genocide certainly affects and should concern everybody .
@@celestialcircledance it says recorded at Ted Women, that's what he's referring to
yeah i feel for u , but too emotional though
Kigali Ruwanda is a hellhole where there are killings going on every now and then...WHY???Is Ruwanda an oil-rich area???Then sure there will be killing because oil is the thing ! Those in power kill for oil...imagine that???
Here come trumpists downvoting because she’s a black woman with a perspective different from their own. Like clockwork
im a liberal swede and i downvoted because she talks about feelings alone, which is something I don't like in TED talks. I want scientific basis and examples, not just a life story. Her only point was that saying words such as "other" can, under certain circumstances cause chaos and destruction. She has no basis or evidence for it. She just claims it.
I'm no trumpist and I'm not against black women.
drditup she might not have provided evidence but history has proven what she said. In order to murder each other in war and genocide we have to be committed to the idea that the people we are killing are other.
History has absolutely proven her point about wars. It's her point about words I don't agree with.
The whole words-thing is loosely tied to her speech. It's as if meaning of words was added to her talk afterwards to make it sound philosophilcal, but it fails to do so. "genocide" is a dehumanizing word? "Other" can cause destruction under some circumstances?? I disagree, and since she provided nothing more to it, the argument ends there. Surely I do not understand war, but I think her whole point is wrong. Having those words help us live together. On a more metaphorical level, using those words is not the root to a problem, just results from them.
Boring and ovedramatic
Do you feel that she said anything at all that was worth hearing?
I don't think it's physically possible to be too dramatic about the subject, in terms of what is warranted.
But I agree that her style could be developed to reach a wider audience.
It would help if she made the words less about what happened to her personally, and more about other people from recent events and what's going on around the world today (same topic; same lessons; different focus).
The reason it's boring is because she only appeals to our emotion. There's very little in her talk that requires any logic or reasoning.
Mike C You are sick. Please seek help
@Lucius. Apparently, neither you nor a family member of yours has ever been in similar circumstances. All you know about genocide is what you saw on TV or in the movies.
Really quite boring.
yawn
2