Gotland: Visby’s Last Stand | Medieval Dead | Timeline

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 07. 2024
  • Midsummer 1361. In Gotland, Sweden King Valdemar and his Danish army attack the walled town of Visby. While the town’s rich merchants look on, a hastily recruited army of feudal peasants is quite literally cut to pieces by the Danes right outside the main gates. 1800 of the townsfolk are killed in the most brutal and clinical way.
    In 1905 the first mass grave at Visby was found and so far more than 1185 bodies have been recovered - many more are awaiting excavation. In this episode, Tim Sutherland - a battle expert and one of the country’s foremost medieval archaeologists - travels to the battle site to unearth the chilling story of the Gotland Militia. Malin Holst inspects the extraordinary collection of bones found buried outside Visby, many of which were buried in full armour - something that was almost unheard of at the time. And the team searches for the ‘Fourth Grave Pit- of Visby legend - can they locate the site?
    It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service, at a huge discount using the code 'TIMELINE' ---ᐳ bit.ly/3a7ambu
    You can find more from us on:
    / timelinewh
    / timelinewh
    This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries, please contact owned-enquiries@littledotstudios.com

Komentáře • 322

  • @theiowan5429
    @theiowan5429 Před 2 lety +55

    Rich mans war, poor man's fight.some things never change

    • @OdysseyK
      @OdysseyK Před 2 lety +4

      It will always be that way.

    • @1991beachboy
      @1991beachboy Před 2 lety +2

      War never changes

    • @joeblow1748
      @joeblow1748 Před rokem +1

      Slave and king

    • @mzeewatk846
      @mzeewatk846 Před rokem

      But maybe we at least staved off MAGAQ for a couple more years. : l

    • @warriorsheartcosplay3016
      @warriorsheartcosplay3016 Před rokem

      @@1991beachboy you're right. The only differences are the technology, the strategies and tactics.

  • @wildplumbeauty
    @wildplumbeauty Před 4 lety +166

    I can’t imagine being in a battle that you know that you are never going to make it out of alive. That’s a special kind of bravery

    • @juanleahy2202
      @juanleahy2202 Před 4 lety +1

      tavisxavier i

    • @evacelik6857
      @evacelik6857 Před 4 lety +6

      HM theyvwere men made of the land Gotland. They are still of the same mind. Gutar the salt of the earth

    • @evacelik6857
      @evacelik6857 Před 4 lety +1

      @Paul deTorch 👍👍👍👍

    • @aidanrosier47
      @aidanrosier47 Před 4 lety +7

      And that is why it is important to honour the dead.

    • @criticviking
      @criticviking Před 3 lety +12

      They rather died than paying higher taxes.

  • @birchleaf
    @birchleaf Před rokem +11

    I’ve heard it argued that the Gotlanders were used to that in a battle you’d fight until one side surrendered, and then you’d negotiate terms, but the Danish army did not stop to negotiate, they just finished them off to the last man. If that is the case, they may have thought that just showing up and showing bravery in battle might give them better terms, but instead they got slaughtered.

    • @hampusdahlborn9203
      @hampusdahlborn9203 Před 7 měsíci +1

      Probably not, the Gotlanders were a peasant army of ca 1800 troops, wich was almost the entire male peasant population of the island (fighting age: 15-60 years old, with some getting left behind incase they lost the battle, wich shows that they did know that they might get destroyed). Every gotlander was forced by law to have armor and weapons at home, incase of an inavsion. However the peasants relations with the city of Visby (the only city with conections to the mainland) was really bad, wich is probably why they were left outside without support from the city. They also had a real plan for the battle. They were suppose to make the terrain really bad and clayey (not sure if it's the right term) so the danish would get stuck and not have much mobolity, causing a retreat. However the days during the battle was unusually hot, causing the ground to solidify causing the plan to fail. With this along with other more minor reasons, the gotland-peasant army was pretty much obliterated, with ca 1800 cassualties vs the 300 danish ones.
      here's some sources: SVT: Sverige genom tiderna (documentary supported by the government of Sweden).
      Gotlands Museum, state supported national museum about Gotlands history.
      wikipedia (mainly for cassualties)

  • @varschnitzschnur8795
    @varschnitzschnur8795 Před 2 lety +10

    The title is a misnomer. Visby did not make a last stand--the local farmers did. The Gute, local farmers, made a heroic last stand.

    • @svennielsen633
      @svennielsen633 Před 19 dny

      They stood and looked at the slaughter. Since the peasants were their enemy too, the inhabitants of Visby were happy about the outcome, and they welcomed the Danes.

  • @carlhassler5336
    @carlhassler5336 Před 4 lety +129

    I do not understand why this video is called "Visby's last stand", Visby didn't stand up to anything that day. They let the Gotlanders get slaughtered and then opened the gates to the danes.

    • @AlxzAlec
      @AlxzAlec Před 3 lety +1

      HAHA DENMARK WINS🇩🇰🇩🇰🇩🇰🇩🇰🇩🇰

    • @bandiriatraveler8343
      @bandiriatraveler8343 Před 3 lety +20

      @@AlxzAlec Go play with your legos.

    • @AlxzAlec
      @AlxzAlec Před 3 lety +7

      @@bandiriatraveler8343 Go play with your funiture

    • @bandiriatraveler8343
      @bandiriatraveler8343 Před 3 lety +6

      @@AlxzAlec Nah bro, I'm too busy eating burgers and shooting guns.

    • @AlxzAlec
      @AlxzAlec Před 3 lety +1

      @@bandiriatraveler8343 so you are texan or what

  • @bodhranlowd
    @bodhranlowd Před rokem +9

    This a cautionary tale to always maintain a highly trained professional military, especially if you have wealth.

  • @matereo
    @matereo Před 2 lety +15

    The peasants and fishers, the countryside folk on Gotland were predominantly Swedish, while Visby and its townfolk were largely of German and Danish descent.. Valdemar Atterdag in Denmark is mentioned as Valdemar the great, but in Sweden he went under the name Valdemar the tyrant. Later Vasa dealt with both the German hanseatic league and the Danes.

  • @eken81
    @eken81 Před 2 lety +16

    I was born on Gotland and still live here, not very far from the mass graves. I always have thought that those graves were closer to the wall. Also I have never seen the armour before. That the Danes buried it all to prevent an uprising makes sense to me.

    • @lowkey_gaming5956
      @lowkey_gaming5956 Před 2 lety

      I heard it's getting bad there now cz of all the Russia stuff . Is that true ?

    • @eken81
      @eken81 Před 2 lety +2

      @@lowkey_gaming5956 Depend on how you define bad, I think. I have heard that specifically American cruises skip Visby, because of a belief I think that its worse than it is. Others are stoping by. More military sure. Stuff cost more, as for the rest of the world. Outside of this its largely business as usual. For now.

  • @FuzzyKittenBoots
    @FuzzyKittenBoots Před rokem +5

    I'm so impressed with their pronunciations during the whole documentary. Perfect, well done.

  • @lordship988
    @lordship988 Před 4 lety +72

    Very glad to see a documentary about Swedens medieval wars! Swede here btw

    • @andygaras
      @andygaras Před 4 lety +6

      Omg a real life swede

    • @mihjq
      @mihjq Před 4 lety +4

      @@andygaras Genuine Suede?

    • @dennislindqvist8443
      @dennislindqvist8443 Před 4 lety +9

      Interesting but sad though. A professional army against farmers. War was brutal back then, and it's still brutal.

    • @therrastrial
      @therrastrial Před 4 lety

      @Wroger Wroger the chef is from the netherlands

    • @cronulla70
      @cronulla70 Před 3 lety

      @@andygaras 😂🤟

  • @marlon1171
    @marlon1171 Před 3 lety +10

    The cuts dealt with thoses swords are absolutely so horrific and gruesome, it’s truly mind numbing.....

  • @craemac
    @craemac Před 2 lety +6

    The Gotlanders were betrayed by Visby. I hope the people of Visby lost a lot of sleep because of their betrayal.

    • @svennielsen633
      @svennielsen633 Před 19 dny

      The inhabitants of Visby were happy about the outcome, since the peasants were their enemy too, so they welcomed the Danes.

  • @mikkelnpetersen
    @mikkelnpetersen Před 4 lety +29

    Back then, that island was worth more than any landmass of the same size, anywhere in Scandinavia, maybe even Europe, it was a *MAIN* trade hub, and the one who controlled it got the taxes, if I remember correctly, Valdemar took a loan from German bankers to hire mercenaries, and they only said yes because they knew how much money it generated, so they were sure he could pay them back.

    • @Mukation
      @Mukation Před 2 lety +5

      Yup, it was the main hub for the entire northern part of the Hanseatic league. Goods from both the northern parts of Sweden, Finland down towards the mainland europe.
      The closest comparison to Gotlands importance is what Crete was for the ancient agean sea was for trade between the greeks, persians and egyptians etc.
      An Island hub, resting place for travelers and traders etc.

    • @snb6642
      @snb6642 Před rokem +2

      Thank you for your comments here. They helped me to understand why the Visbians didn't offer assistance to the Gotlanders in that moment of great need. Thanks

    • @lisacraig1894
      @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

      Sort of like our American presidents’ son; having 8-12% of his holdings in a company that loans money to people illegally and legally crossing the American border…. Including the trained militia that is crossing!

  • @TheSlyngel
    @TheSlyngel Před 3 lety +19

    They weren't feudal peasants. Sweden was never feudal, the farmers were always landowners.

    • @issyd2366
      @issyd2366 Před 2 lety +2

      But an aristocracy existed and still exists.

    • @issyd2366
      @issyd2366 Před rokem

      @Marcus They couldn't prevent the peasents from moving away from their lands if they wanted to, but they ruled the land from an administrative point of view as well from an agricultural one. As for the modern take , nobility is still nobility and the royal family for example is not just empty titles but the real deal.

  • @johnbatt9796
    @johnbatt9796 Před 11 měsíci +1

    this is actually the most badass documentary on yt on the subject.

  • @ps2hacker
    @ps2hacker Před rokem +4

    They said they found lots of treasure troves around the area. That’s because everyone tried to bury all their money before the invasion, so the invaders wouldn’t find it, intending to retrieve it later, but were too dead to do so.

  • @huddless50
    @huddless50 Před 4 lety +38

    If I had been a Dane then after the slaughter at the wall, the town that shut their own people out would have been next and without mercy.

    • @VikingsRBloodyAwsome
      @VikingsRBloodyAwsome Před 4 lety +15

      It's possible they were spared because a large portion of them were germans. The city people within the walls of Visby were largely non-Swedish while the farmers outside the walls were Swedish. This is relevant since the attacking "danes" were almost entirely made up by german mercenaries.

    • @dennislindqvist8443
      @dennislindqvist8443 Před 4 lety +2

      Yes, it was both cruel and stupid. They did not meet the same fate as the Gotlanders but Visby as a wealthy city was over.

    • @daneaxe6465
      @daneaxe6465 Před 4 lety +8

      This whole story is so ironic. Valdemar was there to extract booty from the merchants & city of Visby, a Hanseatic city. He had no beef with the Swedish peasants. But if you ask for a fight you will probably get a fight. I doubt we will ever know why the Swedish peasants got themselves slaughtered to defend a German/Hanseatic city, whose residents hated the peasants.

    • @t.j.payeur5331
      @t.j.payeur5331 Před 3 lety +4

      The town of Visby was a German Hanseatic League colonial trade city. They weren't Swedish at all and the Gotland peasants were Not their people.

    • @kentabrahamsson
      @kentabrahamsson Před 3 lety +5

      It was simple logic. Danish king Valdemar wanted the city to continue to trade and bring in taxable amounts to the Danish crown in the future as well. The Hanseatics in Visby counted on that. If the traders would be slaughterd, there would be no future trade to tax. Instead there was a handsome ransom paid to the Danes that kind of financed the whole venture. The island and the city ended up as Danish for some hundred years ahead with tax income until the turning point in the 17th century when the Swedes conquered almost all of Denmark east of Öresund.

  • @zetter13
    @zetter13 Před 4 lety +24

    I visited visby last year, incredibly beautiful city

  • @oscarernstell6214
    @oscarernstell6214 Před 2 lety +9

    I've been to these catacombs of bones in Stockholm and the people there then didn't talk so much of swords but of poleaxes or similar long weapons. First a hammer of crossbow bolt followed by this wall of long, heavy, things where the gotlanders simply couldn't reach the enemy. They described it as trying a fist fight against a modern harvester. The sword and Warhammer were just to finish things off. Never the pacifist per se, I can't help but thinking, had they just stayed at home, Valdemar would simply have cared only for the wealthy city.

  • @jeffreyhickman6787
    @jeffreyhickman6787 Před 2 lety +1

    Excellent just made my day

  • @niklas5547
    @niklas5547 Před 2 lety +7

    moment of silence for brave farmers who chose to fight rather than live under danish tyranny. Shame on the memory of the cowards shutting their fellow islanders out to certain death

  • @ShootingUtah
    @ShootingUtah Před 2 lety +7

    With ancestors from Visby and Denmark it's incredibly exciting to learn about this history!

    • @mzeewatk846
      @mzeewatk846 Před rokem

      I recommend keeping the Visby connection to yourself.

    • @marcusaurelius3487
      @marcusaurelius3487 Před rokem +1

      @@mzeewatk846 why

    • @mzeewatk846
      @mzeewatk846 Před rokem

      @@marcusaurelius3487 Now I'm not sure that I didn't confuse the battle of Visby with another Hanseatic City. The account I heard, was that the citizens locked the farming community out of the gates and left them to be massacred by a Danish army before ransoming themselves. It happened hundreds of years ago, in any case.

  • @whkmla6569
    @whkmla6569 Před 2 lety +6

    Visby was not the capital of Gotland, rather a city which had seceded from Gotland.

  • @Kenoshino
    @Kenoshino Před 4 lety +17

    Still waiting for Timeline to make a video about Battle of Kosovo field in 1389, now that battle was complete slaughter and if numbers mentioned online are correct more then 20,000 to 30,000 died in one day, maybe even more if the story are true which they should be considering both Christian and Muslim sources mention the battle in many documents.

  • @noproblem2big337
    @noproblem2big337 Před 4 lety +27

    The Danes were quite cunning, I can sense the pain and screaming from this battlefield even 658 years later, brave men all of them!

    • @heinedenmark
      @heinedenmark Před 4 lety +10

      I'm a Dane. Nothing we are proud of. But we have fought each other back and forward a thousand years or so. And things were brutal back then. Best friends today thou.. together with Norway. The idea of a united Scandinavia is gaining a lot of momentum these days.

    • @carlhassler5336
      @carlhassler5336 Před 4 lety +4

      For a long while the taxing of Visby was a historic item though to have taken place. However, recent theories makes it more of a propaganda play by Visbyites to deflect from the fact that they made a separate peace with the danes after the battle. It explains to some degree why still Visby today is seen as separate from Gotland proper by locals.

    • @TheFagerlund
      @TheFagerlund Před 3 lety +1

      @@carlhassler5336 nah Visby is just so different from the rest of the island so it just kinda feels off sometimes thats why

  • @chris.asi_romeo
    @chris.asi_romeo Před 2 lety

    Excellent documentary 👏👏🍿

  • @chris.asi_romeo
    @chris.asi_romeo Před 2 lety +1

    I love this kind of documentary

  • @FamilyPictures1984
    @FamilyPictures1984 Před 4 lety +6

    My 21 and 22nd GGFATHERs were Mayors of of Visby before and after this brutal battle between Danish King and Visby
    And my 29th GGFATHER was a Gotlander Johan Silkentopp born 1170.
    21. Köpman. Borgmästare Markward II Bretholt b. circa 1395, Visby, Gotland, Sweden; d. before April 14, 1476, Tallinna
    22. Borgmästare Markward I Bretholt b. after 1350, Visby, Gotland, Sverige; d. circa 1401, Reval (Tallinn)

    • @neulasia
      @neulasia Před 2 lety

      hello, distant cousin! these people are my supposed ancestors, too.

  • @sebapiotr6736
    @sebapiotr6736 Před 2 lety +4

    This archeologists should have asked any historical reenactor about the wounds. Leg wounds are mark that Gotlanders were fighting in shieldwall. Upper body was protected by shield, helmet and armour but legs were easy target.

    • @kajsan760
      @kajsan760 Před 2 lety +1

      Thomas Neijman, the guy who showed the sword cutting in the documentary, is a 14th century reenactor. So they did ask a reenactor. (But maybe they only asked him very leading questions, I don't know.)

    • @adamconnolly4620
      @adamconnolly4620 Před rokem +1

      I like your thoughts on the shield wall. It's really the only strategy that the peasants and farmers would have. Protestors today form shield walls against a stronger force.

  • @willow_8842
    @willow_8842 Před 2 lety

    great video _

  • @jayl5009
    @jayl5009 Před 2 lety +3

    I don't understand why the peasantry fought to defend Visby? The invaders were after the riches in the town. The militia could have just stood back and minded their own business. There has to be more to the story.

    • @lisacraig1894
      @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

      Jay15009, it is possible that the wealthy were part of the financiers to the Danish and German army; as the locals had just had an uprising and civil type war earlier in that century. If the town let the militia in, they might have been able to last… but then they also might throw another uprising if they lived.

  • @amycrumedy6586
    @amycrumedy6586 Před 3 lety +3

    I love this kind of stuff very interesting.

  • @TheLucasdms
    @TheLucasdms Před 3 lety +10

    The audio lvl is too low. I had problem watching on my phone

    • @Dr.Instabil
      @Dr.Instabil Před 2 lety

      The music is to loud so the voices drown

  • @pellman87
    @pellman87 Před 3 lety +1

    Great audio mixing

  • @guyfaulkes3035
    @guyfaulkes3035 Před 4 lety +30

    Sure would be nice to hear the voices of the people speaking in the video. The audio mix is horrible (as usual) and the narrator & music is 10 decibels louder than everything else. The captions help a little but get much of it wrong since the dialog is so faint. Why can't the producers fix this persistent problem?

  • @danielkarlsson156
    @danielkarlsson156 Před 4 lety +11

    Valdemar Atterdag was the danish king, not the Swedish king.

  • @celticman1909
    @celticman1909 Před 3 měsíci

    The unique findings of armor and the personal effects of the vanquished from a time when looting was standard operating procedure in war and on battlefields could support the ascertain that the attacking force were highly experienced professionals and couldn't be bothered with the inferior equipment of the local militia.

  • @jimmyjam5109
    @jimmyjam5109 Před 3 lety +8

    I was shocked to see the skulls filled with healthy teeth. People in Gotland must have had a proper and truly nutritious diet.

    • @iamjsams755
      @iamjsams755 Před 3 lety +6

      They had better teeth than me and I've never been hit in the face with a battle axe.

    • @suspicioustumbleweed4760
      @suspicioustumbleweed4760 Před 3 lety +12

      They didn’t have much sugar to rot them.

    • @DrArku
      @DrArku Před 2 lety +1

      That's because people around here used to live mostly on vegetables, fish and meat. Everything was natural and sweets were more of a rare treat than anything. Also some dental care was taken. Scandinavians would have special picks for cleaning their teeth, I've heard that Estonians used to chew pine sap to clean their teeth. It was basically like medieval gum.

  • @an_evening_star_rose5991
    @an_evening_star_rose5991 Před 3 lety +2

    Here because of Elin Abrahamsson’s @sewingthroughthepast Battle of Visby vlog

  • @perimele6
    @perimele6 Před 4 lety +1

    Why is the sound so quiet? The same problem on Amazon too. I give up.

  • @controlfreak1963
    @controlfreak1963 Před 5 měsíci +1

    They were buried with their armor because the Danes didn't want it used against them and it was inferior to the victors armor.

  • @nicolaivedel5067
    @nicolaivedel5067 Před 4 lety +19

    King Valdemar was Danish, not Swedish

  • @kevinpaul1847
    @kevinpaul1847 Před 4 lety

    Finally!

  • @lisacraig1894
    @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

    It’s amazing that the spurs look like the modern day spurs we can buy at my local Tractor Supply.

  • @DianeHasHopeInChrist
    @DianeHasHopeInChrist Před 2 lety +4

    I wonder about the women and children.
    Were they slaughtered, also. Or hidden in another country.
    How sad.

    • @hermanspaerman3490
      @hermanspaerman3490 Před 2 lety +1

      The women and children were , as far as we know, left relatively unscathed. I have never heard or read of any particularly brutal acts committed by the Danes against non combatants, but then again, this is medieval times and sources are scarce. What we do know is that the Gotlanders buried their wealth all around the island , to prevent the Danes getting their hands on them, and many of these treasures are found still today. One would think that these treasures would have been recovered after the battle by the surviving family members but they weren't, so we can only speculate of what happened to them.

  • @ThisTrainIsLost
    @ThisTrainIsLost Před 2 lety +1

    Doesn't the date of this battle overlap with the time of the Black Death?

  • @j.b.4340
    @j.b.4340 Před 2 lety

    @26:00, it makes more sense that they were buried in their armor as an honor for fighting, and dying, well.

  • @shibmobileverse468
    @shibmobileverse468 Před 2 lety

    Why the volume so low? :(

  • @evil_regal
    @evil_regal Před 4 lety +26

    "Nearly all the skeletons had signs of trauma" Facepalm. Its a huge battle. Most obvious statement ever.

    • @jim8310
      @jim8310 Před 4 lety +4

      And we know it was a huge battle because?
      the skeletons, and the trauma on them..

    • @pansprayers
      @pansprayers Před 2 lety +2

      @@jim8310 well, and historical records. You just confirmed that the floor is made out of floor.

  • @gunnerbhb50
    @gunnerbhb50 Před 5 měsíci

    The cut off foot I would think might have been an attack from behind while the gotlander was occupied with one soldier another came from behind and struck the man in the leg with a downward strike amputating the foot which would have rendered the man immobile on the ground and easily killed at a later time

  • @MegaWunna
    @MegaWunna Před 3 lety +11

    I have been in Visby and seen the wall myself it was so impressive to see.

  • @AceHardy
    @AceHardy Před 4 lety +1

    👑

  • @blackmanogco
    @blackmanogco Před 4 lety +2

    One best sources for reactors doing this era and generaly about battle of militia againts pro soldeirs of that time how quick it could be and general likely battle injurie. I use it as a great source do in a neutral stand point as not to bias anything. Great documantay.

    • @blackmanogco
      @blackmanogco Před 4 lety +1

      Do it was more of a slaugter then battle.

    • @noproblem2big337
      @noproblem2big337 Před 4 lety

      @@blackmanogco totally agree, it would be great if we knew the casualties sustained by the Danes but I suspect very few if any, still that's how it was back then, a close and personal bloodbath...

    • @blackmanogco
      @blackmanogco Před 4 lety

      @@noproblem2big337 Ye. Do fron talhofens manuel standpoint a fight would lasted e blows or 30 sec and also a train mercenary army in line formation with best gear and training. I suspect very few mecenaries from danes died most would been first timers or less experiance and armoured of the danish mecenaries as not all had full gear. Some would just had gambeson and little else then spear or axe and shield.

  • @thorbeorn4295
    @thorbeorn4295 Před 3 lety +1

    Born, raised and lives in Visby;)

  • @pagedown4195
    @pagedown4195 Před 10 měsíci

    A very violent Island historically.

  • @jturtle5318
    @jturtle5318 Před 4 lety +4

    Not to nitpick, but hitting the shield with the edge of the sword will dull the blade. They should be using the flat side.

  • @2coryman
    @2coryman Před 2 lety +1

    RIP Heroes

  • @lisacraig1894
    @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

    1215 was the English Magna Carta signed after 17 years of civil war. And King John hired the Danish mercenaries to come and kill all barons who had won the war and any Knights Templar that had fought with him. Luckily they were defeated at Rochester when the French backed up the winners. So if “freedom” was allowed, but only 100 years new in the peasants-the peasants had just fought against their Lords for the equivalent of “fair trade” for their goods. And the nobles could have easily hired the Danish mercenaries to kill those who had “dared rebel” against their rulers choices. Or they could have purposely locked them out(?). But why would they sell everything to the Danish later on? Maybe they did have no choice but to sign a treaty after this slaughter?

  • @duncanidaho2097
    @duncanidaho2097 Před 3 lety +2

    These German mercenaries, Landsknechts?
    I don’t know exactly when they were known by that name.

  • @ivandenisovichshukhov
    @ivandenisovichshukhov Před 4 lety +9

    Usually enemies rob the dead for weapons and armor. However, the Swedes gear was so out of date they left them alone. And that rarely happened in the medieval period or before.

  • @ladycharlenegrace8023
    @ladycharlenegrace8023 Před 4 lety +1

    658.4 years ago.

  • @simonbannow3905
    @simonbannow3905 Před rokem +1

    why on earth didn't they remove the armour? Everything metal most have been valuable back then!
    *edit(I should have finished watching before asking questions!)

  • @Foundry_made
    @Foundry_made Před rokem +1

    It amazes me that all those Visby dead weren't stripped of their armor before they were buried. I thought that was common practice in medieval times. All that armor would have been made by hand, and things like chain mail hauberks were worth a lot of money. Even if the armor had been damaged in the battle, it could have been repaired and re-sold, or scrapped and re- forged into tools or farming implements.

    • @marcuscorder
      @marcuscorder Před rokem +2

      According to historian, John Keegan, the hot weather (late July), and great number of the dead meant they began decomposing before the Danes had a chance to strip the majority of them of anything besides their helmets.

  • @nightrunner3701
    @nightrunner3701 Před 2 lety +1

    If they were peasants… why did they have armor and such?

    • @1991beachboy
      @1991beachboy Před 2 lety

      Because Visby at the time was one of the richest cities in the world upon a time during the hanseatic league

  • @zencat999
    @zencat999 Před 3 lety

    "give me a war, not a cause"...said no one...

    • @bradmiller2329
      @bradmiller2329 Před 3 lety

      Except every mercenary and camp follower, ever.

  • @gregwasserman2635
    @gregwasserman2635 Před 2 lety

    I am guessing they are underestimating the use of polearms, especially pole axes, by the Danes and Germanic mercenaries. Polearms, spears, and axes were far more common on the battlefield they is often depicted. Polearms, especially pole axes, would have had the reach to chop at the legs and shins of the Gotlanders.

    • @arnareriksson5077
      @arnareriksson5077 Před 2 lety +1

      German and germanic are not synonym with eachother, germanic are a people, not a nationality.. Us Scandinavians are also germanic

    • @gregwasserman2635
      @gregwasserman2635 Před 2 lety

      @@arnareriksson5077, of course, there was no "Germany" until 1870. The Germanic people had been around for centuries.

  • @eastcorkcheeses6448
    @eastcorkcheeses6448 Před 4 lety +2

    So the gottlanders stood, locked outside the city of visby, protecting it? Why?

    • @tracishea5053
      @tracishea5053 Před 4 lety +12

      No. The militia were Gutnish country yeomen. They were no friend to the Visby merchants, who, as mentioned, built that wall to make them pay taxes. The famers were fighting for their land, homes and families. Pretty much no one wants to be ruled by foreigners. When someone invades, you fight. The city inhabitants thought they could negotiate with the Danes instead, and that was the beginning of the end for them. Visby went for the richest city in the Baltics to a dot on the map in record time.

    • @dennislindqvist8443
      @dennislindqvist8443 Před 4 lety +6

      @@tracishea5053 You meant of course the Baltic Sea, not the Balkans. The invaders were Danes with German mercenaries. You talked about negotiating with the Dutch? Have I missed something?

  • @zencat999
    @zencat999 Před 3 lety

    if we did "war" this way, there would be a whole lot fewer wars.

  • @kristjanmartin9883
    @kristjanmartin9883 Před 4 lety +3

    Ide say they were buried in their arms and armour, as a sign of respect by the Danes and Germanics. The "why" is the true question.

    • @allengordon6929
      @allengordon6929 Před 4 lety +3

      That could have been an element, given that the armor had no worth to the danes themselves (used armor dealerships were a thing then). That, and the rancid conditions. Given that the Gotlanders fought to the death without any hope of victory, the Danes likely felt respect for the Gotlanders at some level.

    • @mace8873
      @mace8873 Před 4 lety +10

      Nobody piles their slain enemies messily into mass graves, out of respect, that's something you do when you want to get it over with quickly.

  • @Concetta20
    @Concetta20 Před 4 lety +2

    Why didn’t they let them in? The poor militia.

    • @lisacraig1894
      @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

      I think they didn’t let them in because the German/Danish military might have been partially paid by some of the ruling wealthy behind the wall. The ones that were angry the farmers had an uprising earlier in the century.

  • @hyperion752
    @hyperion752 Před 4 lety +9

    Valhalla greets them "Skål"

    • @elsakristina2689
      @elsakristina2689 Před 3 lety +12

      Sorry but by the time this battle took place in the 14th century, the Viking Age was over and they were Christians now.

  • @clarencemerritt5003
    @clarencemerritt5003 Před 4 lety +4

    By that time the pegan Vikings and their raids were long gone.

    • @TVTransmo
      @TVTransmo Před 4 lety +1

      Ya, Vikings were year 793 to 1066. This is 300 years later :)

    • @heinedenmark
      @heinedenmark Před 4 lety +3

      @@TVTransmo Vikings have never been gone. And they're on the rise again.. greetings from Fyrkat

    • @TVTransmo
      @TVTransmo Před 4 lety +1

      Hehe im Danish too, I have a friend who is a Viking re-enacter. He spend all summer at Fyrkat with his family :)

    • @FamilyPictures1984
      @FamilyPictures1984 Před 4 lety +2

      My 28th great grandfather was Viking from Gotland. Born 1170.
      He didn't have a very scary Viking name.🤣
      Johan Silkentopp

    • @TVTransmo
      @TVTransmo Před 4 lety +4

      @@FamilyPictures1984 The Viking age technically ended in 1066, so he was 100 years too late to be a Viking :)

  • @amristar736
    @amristar736 Před rokem

    Weren't they supposed to be laid to rest already, why dig them up from their resting place?

  • @jamesnorseman4863
    @jamesnorseman4863 Před 3 lety

    My land!

  • @amycrumedy6586
    @amycrumedy6586 Před 3 lety +1

    Please rebut those men in a decent proper burial with honors .

  • @lisacraig1894
    @lisacraig1894 Před rokem

    Wonder what will happen when the “Royalty and decision makers of Holland” kicks out or stops all agriculture? Can they travel to Gotland to reestablish agriculture in a land where the poor farmers were slaughtered? Or does the nobility not want to profit off agriculture?

  • @folkeholmberg3519
    @folkeholmberg3519 Před 2 lety

    Visby has never been the capital of Gotland, it was a solitary town state, run by the Hansa. The capital, if any was Roma, att the middle of Gotland where yearly courts were held. Not thal the Goths have choose to not have a king. And was therefore one of the oldest parliamentary democracies.

  • @love2roam831
    @love2roam831 Před 2 lety

    why would a wealthy place as this one not have a standing army or at least paid group of mercenaries.

  • @niceguy1891
    @niceguy1891 Před 3 lety +5

    The people fighting were Swedes, and the people inside of the town were Russian, German and Danish merchants, who of course didn't have the balls to fight so they locked out the Swedes and let them defend the city, and when they were dead, they just opened the gates... Swedes are real fighters.

    • @jensapaulsson2769
      @jensapaulsson2769 Před 2 lety +1

      Well.
      Gutar, not swedes.

    • @niceguy1891
      @niceguy1891 Před 2 lety

      @@jensapaulsson2769 gutar are swedes

    • @jensapaulsson2769
      @jensapaulsson2769 Před 2 lety +1

      @@niceguy1891
      Belongs to Sweden yes.
      Most of my Gotland friends,including me.
      If People ask, we ate Gutar.

    • @jensapaulsson2769
      @jensapaulsson2769 Před 2 lety

      We are gutar.

    • @niceguy1891
      @niceguy1891 Před 2 lety

      @@jensapaulsson2769 inte om du frågar varenda gotlänning jag känner, alla kallar sig svenskar från Gotland, Gutar är en gammal benämning ingen använder sig av

  • @tphvictims5101
    @tphvictims5101 Před 3 lety +4

    And yet we’ve learned NOTHING. We have become more efficient killers.

  • @FamilyPictures1984
    @FamilyPictures1984 Před 4 lety +2

    Those are the bones of my ancestors family members 😯

    • @ReginnKunnr
      @ReginnKunnr Před 2 lety +1

      Bit late for an apology I know, but either way, a big heartfelt sorry from Denmark.

  • @drpravda
    @drpravda Před 4 lety +4

    Hellre en rövare på *RAUKEN* än en *RAUK* i röven!

  • @keysmithgr
    @keysmithgr Před 3 lety +1

    Very good, but I disagree with some statements.. At 38:30 this cut foot no way this was done by a sword. Or both feet as mention cut of with one hit?!? No way with a sword blade. Something else was used. Maybe a heavy battle axe but not a sword.

    • @bradmiller2329
      @bradmiller2329 Před 3 lety +1

      A great sword?

    • @TheFagerlund
      @TheFagerlund Před 3 lety +1

      A heavy sharp sword would've done it
      (Edit: have you handled a super sharp sword before?)

    • @adamconnolly4620
      @adamconnolly4620 Před rokem

      Think about it. How easy it is to chop through a fresh steak bone? Just using a small cleaver. A good heavy sword would have no problem taking legs or feet off.

  • @howardwest2707
    @howardwest2707 Před 2 lety

    I imagine the majority of the leg cuts are defensive cuts. Maybe a person was knocked down and then was struck. Or another possibility is they are just blows upon men already struck and either dying or dead. They may have been collateral damage as two men fought each other and missed their targets striking men already down.

    • @jarkoer
      @jarkoer Před 2 lety

      A trained warrior will never strike where his opponent is most heavily armored. Those plates made the torso invulnerable to attack. A simple chain mail coif or sleeves are effective against slashes, but weak against piercing and concussive damage. Legs are often just an after-thought because of mobility concerns, sometimes left to a tower or kite shield to protect. Without eyewitness testimony, it's possible to speculate many things. One thing I do take issue with is the assumption that one handed long swords caused most of these horrendous cuts. Medieval warriors also used axes, pole arms, and two handed swords and any of these would have been more than capable of performing these ghastly cuts. Particularly the one that sheared straight through that one man's foot from the shin to the ball of the foot.

  • @benchalmers8757
    @benchalmers8757 Před 2 lety +2

    Is this show about some archaeologists or the battle?

  • @MegaWunna
    @MegaWunna Před 3 lety +2

    The Danes sold Scania to king mangus of Sweden and Norway. The Danes and King valdemar used the money gained from selling Scania to hire a big mercenary army to take back sacania and possibly also take the island of Gotland. Valdermar was the older brother to Mangus.
    The war went so well for valdemar and the Danes that whole of Scania and Gotland had be all ocipied most of mangus army had been cruched so mangus had to sue for peace with valdemar and the Danes giving up all of Scania and the very strategic island of Gotland.
    The three crowns which is the the Royal coat of arms, Stockholm city Hall, the national ice hockey team and many coins came from king mangus being king of Sweden Norway and that he bought Scania from the Danes.

  • @aleksejjovanovic986
    @aleksejjovanovic986 Před 2 lety +1

    Just moved from Visby after 10 years on the island i can tell you that the hate between peasants and townfolk still exist. Personaly, i could not stand the mentality of city people in Visby. If anything similar happend today they would do it all over again. Shame, it`s such a fine town.

  • @byzantineblue7330
    @byzantineblue7330 Před rokem

    In my humbe opinion i think more professional army of Danish and German decent left armor on defeated army because they didn't have respect for defeat army, inferiorif you will, made an example of them or point. Evidance for my opinion is they finish them off not leaving anyone alive. Proves lack of respect and compassion. Ruthless battle and medieval life on an soldier

  • @jenniferbowen2081
    @jenniferbowen2081 Před 2 lety +1

    did they ever get DNA from the Skeletons?

  • @2coryman
    @2coryman Před 2 lety

    Ughhhhh. Rest In God’s Eternal Peace

  • @MultiMetaldemon
    @MultiMetaldemon Před 4 lety +11

    Danish army was for sure professional but i think german mercenaries helped a lot. from where in Germany were those mercenaries? Maybe Prussia, German crusaders of north. Who Knows?

    • @FamilyPictures1984
      @FamilyPictures1984 Před 4 lety +7

      This might answer your question
      This is my great grandfathers., they were Mayors of Visby.
      They came from Germany.
      There was trade routes between Germany and Visby.
      So I am sure the "mercenaries" were brothers and cousins defending each other.
      The numbers represent X Great Grandfather.
      26. Herman Hiddink Swerting, Borgmästare i Visby b. circa 1280, Visby, Gotland, Sverige; d. 1342, Visby, Gotland, Sverige
      27. Simon Swerting, Borgmästare 1307 b. circa 1245, Rostock, Pommern; d. August 9, 1307, Visby, Gotland, Sverige
      28. Tidrik Swerting b. circa 1215, Rostock, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany; d. circa 1265, Rostock, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany
      29. ? Swerting, (aka lat. "Niger") b. circa 1185, Rostock, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany

    • @FamilyPictures1984
      @FamilyPictures1984 Před 4 lety +6

      My 21 and 22nd GGFATHERs were Mayors of of Visby before and after this brutal battle between Danish King and Visby
      21. Köpman. Borgmästare Markward II Bretholt b. circa 1395, Visby, Gotland, Sweden; d. before April 14, 1476, Tallinna
      22. Borgmästare Markward I Bretholt b. after 1350, Visby, Gotland, Sverige; d. circa 1401, Reval (Tallinn)

    • @erikpetersen-chinguacousys1943
      @erikpetersen-chinguacousys1943 Před 4 lety +2

      Hanseatic mercenaries I should think.

    • @jturtle5318
      @jturtle5318 Před 4 lety

      @@ivanbiskic4364 Ancestry.com is great. I have gone more than 40 generations if they were famous, or infamous which was more common.
      The quiet, law-abiding merchants and tradesmen were only documented in the church records and are harder to find.

    • @daneaxe6465
      @daneaxe6465 Před 4 lety

      My 14th great grandfather was an official with the Hanseatic League, born 1485 in Lubeck, Germany. He was sent to the Danish island of Bornholm to be "mayor" of the town of Nexo. He was really there to collect taxes for the League since Nexo was very small. This was in early 1500's. Some of his children and descendants ran the fortress of Hammershus. The "contract" with the Hanseatic League ended in the mid 1500's if I recall correctly.
      Bornholm island and its fortress were in the middle of constant wars and now forgotten bloody squabbles over forgotten problems. Whatever was happening in the Baltic, Bornholm was involved in some way. What surprised me was how many times Bornholm/Hammershus teamed up with the Germans to invade or raid somebody (pick a reason, any reason). Occasionally throughout history they would team up with the Dutch and even the English.
      So on the question of who the German mercenaries were the most logical source would be northern Germany/Prussia. Maybe a few stray Germans from other parts of the Germanic kingdoms.

  • @joeblow1748
    @joeblow1748 Před rokem

    This isent glorius its just terrible and sad. If they were wariors they would fullfilled their desteny but this was just terrified people trying to do their best.

  • @AlxzAlec
    @AlxzAlec Před 3 lety

    DANMARK 🇩🇰

  • @guyplachy9688
    @guyplachy9688 Před 7 dny

    Not overly keen on the overly melodramatic presentation. A calmer, more nuanced approach would have been much more effective.

  • @plurplursen7172
    @plurplursen7172 Před 6 měsíci

    The Danes were 100% Christian on 3rd generation at this time. The massgrave could have been protected by some holy decree. Probably dictated by Valdemar.

  • @DarthMayers
    @DarthMayers Před rokem +1

    Medieval Alamo 😬

  • @JFB-Haninge
    @JFB-Haninge Před 3 měsíci

    Connected story --> czcams.com/video/XMov6PeUal4/video.html

  • @Tipi_Dan
    @Tipi_Dan Před 3 lety +7

    If it makes no sense to you that the indigenous Gotlanders wanted to fight the invading army without any regard the potential baleful consequences to themselves, consider that these people were of the blood and lineage of Beowulf. Perhaps then, their choice will make more sense to you.
    I am of that blood. It makes perfect sense to me.

    • @tryggizz1482
      @tryggizz1482 Před 2 lety +1

      First of all, beowulf was said to have been from götaland and not gotland, secondly its a saga with no proof of him even existing. Altough i bet the geats was just as ferocious.

    • @Tipi_Dan
      @Tipi_Dan Před 2 lety

      @@tryggizz1482 Well, yes. But, still.

    • @jensapaulsson2769
      @jensapaulsson2769 Před 2 lety

      @@tryggizz1482
      Fel.
      Nya rön tyder på Gotland.

  • @angaudlinn
    @angaudlinn Před 2 lety

    Funny that Malin Holst is British. I could bet quite a lot that she has Swedish decent with that name. :)

    • @vanefreja86
      @vanefreja86 Před 2 lety

      She is for sure not British. She has still has her accent. I think they speak English together because of the documentary.

  • @jvs9467
    @jvs9467 Před 2 lety

    Why not loud background music… 🤡