Absolutely excellent! Perfectly understood! No dead points! The thinking of the composer stands out very very well! Emotional, believable, inspired and intuitive.
This recording was gifted to me by a friend. It is the greatest interpretation of this work, and should be the first one that a person listens to if they want to experience the music in its pristine beauty.
The most exquisite recording of this piece that I've heard. Incredibly emotional without being the least bit sentimental - very few players like this today.
I am so pleased that this version and recording of the Rachmaninov Trio #1 performed by the Borodin Trio has been uploaded! This is the finest recording of this beautiful work that I have had the pleasure of hearing. The young 20-year-old composer was moved to compose this heart-rendering tour de force when he heard of the untimely death of his patron, Tchaikovsky in 1893. I think you can hear his grief at the sudden loss. I think that this work should be up there with all of the other great surcharged late romantic masterpieces by this composer, including the other Second Trio, the 4 Piano Concertos, the Isle of the Dead, the Second and Third Symphonies and his last orchestral work, the 3 Symphonic Poems! My apologies to any other Rachmaninov lovers out there who feel that I've missed something from this list!
I believe you were referring to Rachmaninov's Trio élégiaque No. 2 in D minor, Op. 9, composed 15/27 December 1893, dedicated to P.Tchaikovsky who died November 6, 1893 .
I was never a great admirer of Rachmaninoff, until I discovered his chamber work, especially the cello sonata in G minor, and now this trio. Absolutely marvelous music. Thank you!
Listen to the Bárta and Lapšanský performance. Also Menardi and Zecchi. They are both stupendous. I'll try Lugansky and Kniazev's. THanks. The sonata is out of this world, perhaps the most beautiful thing ever written .
This was amazing! By far this was the best interpretation I've encountered, others played either too fast or too rough(?). The world was a better place when people like Yuli Turovsky were in it. Thank you for uploading this.
You know what the sad thing is: they just dont make music like this anymore. To clarify, I'm an 18 year-old young man who loves this work beyond redemption. I listen to it in my car all the time and am learning how to play the piano part now. Such a soulful treasure this is, ESPECIALLY from 8:00 to 9:15
이곡이 차이콥스키가 죽었다는 소식을 듣고 라흐마니노프가 작곡을 했는데 피아노의 선율아래 현악기가 불안한 심장박동수를 표현했는데 남들에게는 보이지 않는 두려움과 떨림을 표현했어요 그다음 첼로가 두려움 속에서 흐느낌을 표현했는데 슬픔과 두려움을 극복하려는 그 의지도 나와있어요 참 아름답지요~?
I might be mistaken but I believe this piece was done 2 years prior to Tchaikovsky's death and Rachmonanov composed élégiaque #2 upon learning of Tchaikovsky's passing. It is extremely beautiful.
If you like this you will love the Borodin Trio performing Trio Elegiac no. 2. This doesn't appear to be on youtube but both Eligiacs nos. 1 and 2 are on a CD by the Borodin Trio that will become your favourite. By far the best performances of these beautiful Rachmaninoff compositions.
I have that performance on CD as well. It is magnificent. One does not need to listen to anyone else. The argument that Russians play Rachmaninoff as it should be is hard to refute.
Keine schlechte Aufnahme. Aber man merkt an vielen Stellen doch eine Art zu musizieren, die heute nicht mehr so gefragt ist. Zuviel Vibrato und Manirismen der Tempi, die v.a. im Seitensatz zu klebrig sind.
Es tut mir Leid das ist heute nicht nicht gefragt, sondern es wird einfach nicht mehr geliefert. Phrasieren war früher der Hauptfokus, während heute mehr auf individuelle Performances bzw. auf sehr auf einen Punkt fokkussierte Musikalität gesetzt wird. Große Phrasen, weicher Ton sind auch heute ein Verkaufsargument. Mann muss nur die Lehrer finden die es noch unterrichten. (Meist Die Schüler der alten russischen Schule) Allein beim Vibrato stimm ich Dir zu..
Лучшее на мой взгляд исполнение данного произведения. Браво!
Absolutely excellent! Perfectly understood! No dead points! The thinking of the composer stands out very very well! Emotional, believable, inspired and intuitive.
I thought I knew this work. But one day I listened this version... and I realized that I have just discover it.
This recording was gifted to me by a friend. It is the greatest interpretation of this work, and should be the first one that a person listens to if they want to experience the music in its pristine beauty.
Just 2 words. I cried.
BORODIN TRIO:
Rostislav Dubinsky, violin; Yuli Turovsky, cello; Luba Edlina, piano.
Thank you for posting it!
Mit abstand die beste interpretation!!! Die musiker stellen sich in den dienst des komponisten🌺
The most exquisite recording of this piece that I've heard. Incredibly emotional without being the least bit sentimental - very few players like this today.
Thanks so much for sharing..... This interpretation is my favourite... It's a gem of a recording......
I am so pleased that this version and recording of the Rachmaninov Trio #1 performed by the Borodin Trio has been uploaded! This is the finest recording of this beautiful work that I have had the pleasure of hearing. The young 20-year-old composer was moved to compose this heart-rendering tour de force when he heard of the untimely death of his patron, Tchaikovsky in 1893. I think you can hear his grief at the sudden loss. I think that this work should be up there with all of the other great surcharged late romantic masterpieces by this composer, including the other Second Trio, the 4 Piano Concertos, the Isle of the Dead, the Second and Third Symphonies and his last orchestral work, the 3 Symphonic Poems! My apologies to any other Rachmaninov lovers out there who feel that I've missed something from this list!
I believe you were referring to Rachmaninov's Trio élégiaque No. 2 in D minor, Op. 9, composed 15/27 December 1893, dedicated to P.Tchaikovsky who died November 6, 1893 .
Best version I’ve ever heard 🎼
I totally agree with you! See my own comment!
I was never a great admirer of Rachmaninoff, until I discovered his chamber work, especially the cello sonata in G minor, and now this trio. Absolutely marvelous music. Thank you!
Listen to the Bárta and Lapšanský performance. Also Menardi and Zecchi. They are both stupendous. I'll try Lugansky and Kniazev's. THanks. The sonata is out of this world, perhaps the most beautiful thing ever written
.
Rachmaninoff Trio elegiaque 2 is much better than this one
@@Berlinchesmusic Actually, both Trios have the ineffable in them. For novice listeners, G Minor is an excellent starting point.
@@SonicDykstra Yes, that's true
Luba Edlina - her sound was unique. No one else makes this music cry like she does.
Luba Edlin - unique pianist was student of famous musicians and pianist -
Yakov Flier!!
The sound she gets is so indelibly perfect! @@user-ne6zh5ux4f
Это ошеломляюще красиво!
I too love the slower tempo. Wonderful!
This was amazing! By far this was the best interpretation I've encountered, others played either too fast or too rough(?). The world was a better place when people like Yuli Turovsky were in it. Thank you for uploading this.
The Beaux Arts recording is even slower -- too slow I think.
This is a fantastic performance. Rachmaninoff's music needs to be by performers who understand. And these wonderful performers understand!
Very beautiful! And an excellent interpretation. Thanks for sharing!
Magnífica interpretación de esta sublime obra, inspiradora y emotiva. Mil gracias
Fantastic music written from heart!
Maravillosa e intensa interpretación de Rachmaninov excelentemente ejecutada por este prodigioso Trio Borodin.
beautiful music!
Many, many thanks for posting!!!
¡Maravilloso! Se queda dentro del alma.
fantastici!!
Antonio Ramous fantastici...
Thanks for uploading!
I like this version. Some of the others play it a little too fast and kinda miss the meditative mood.
The tempo here is incredibly important.
It has to roll along, but it cannot be rushed. It also cannot drag.
This tempo is spot on, in my opinion.
You know what the sad thing is: they just dont make music like this anymore. To clarify, I'm an 18 year-old young man who loves this work beyond redemption. I listen to it in my car all the time and am learning how to play the piano part now. Such a soulful treasure this is, ESPECIALLY from 8:00 to 9:15
Listen to the trio Golub, Kaplan, Carr.......
❤ Thank You very much!!
이곡이 차이콥스키가 죽었다는 소식을 듣고 라흐마니노프가 작곡을 했는데
피아노의 선율아래 현악기가 불안한 심장박동수를 표현했는데 남들에게는 보이지 않는 두려움과 떨림을 표현했어요
그다음 첼로가 두려움 속에서 흐느낌을 표현했는데 슬픔과 두려움을 극복하려는 그 의지도 나와있어요
참 아름답지요~?
I might be mistaken but I believe this piece was done 2 years prior to Tchaikovsky's death and Rachmonanov composed élégiaque #2 upon learning of Tchaikovsky's passing.
It is extremely beautiful.
Is there anything Rachmaninov wrote that I do not like? Simple answer, "No." Great stuff.
Have to agree on this one.
maravilloso como todo lo que hace rachmaninoff
Trovo questo pezzo struggente , mi piace molto, mi evoca una sensazione di un balsamo lenitivo per attutire inutili affanni
Beautiful work and performance.
Великолепно! Счастлива слышать настоящего Рахманинова!!!
Света Додарук это трио Чайковского)
@@rushana1956 это трио Бородина
@@luden6794 Попробуйте прислушаться к музыке.
@@rushana1956 это музыка Рахманинова которую он написал в память о Чайковском
@@luden6794 Имеющий уши, да услышит :)
If you like this you will love the Borodin Trio performing Trio Elegiac no. 2. This doesn't appear to be on youtube but both Eligiacs nos. 1 and 2 are on a CD by the Borodin Trio that will become your favourite. By far the best performances of these beautiful Rachmaninoff compositions.
I have that performance on CD as well. It is magnificent. One does not need to listen to anyone else. The argument that Russians play Rachmaninoff as it should be is hard to refute.
Thank You!! ❤
Really looking forward to that.
interpretacion magistral
Increíble
la vida es hermosa, aqui esta la pruebe
This is a par above the rest.
❤
they all drop into darkness at the end
3dislikes? World is getting crazy!
ou incultos ou cretinos!
They probably listen Jason Derulo & Justin Bieber, don't blame incurious people :p :)
Uncurious*
26 now lol
Thanks 71demy.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Keine schlechte Aufnahme. Aber man merkt an vielen Stellen doch eine Art zu musizieren, die heute nicht mehr so gefragt ist. Zuviel Vibrato und Manirismen der Tempi, die v.a. im Seitensatz zu klebrig sind.
Es tut mir Leid das ist heute nicht nicht gefragt, sondern es wird einfach nicht mehr geliefert.
Phrasieren war früher der Hauptfokus, während heute mehr auf individuelle Performances bzw. auf sehr auf einen Punkt fokkussierte Musikalität gesetzt wird.
Große Phrasen, weicher Ton sind auch heute ein Verkaufsargument.
Mann muss nur die Lehrer finden die es noch unterrichten.
(Meist Die Schüler der alten russischen Schule)
Allein beim Vibrato stimm ich Dir zu..
when im listening to this piece i just think about urumia lake.people will die.everything will damage.arid will be everywhere in that location.shit
Mussorgsky dawn on the river Moskva
they aren't rushers....they aren't dragers...they're playing this on Sergei's fukin time...
We will make that 18dislikes ...what a shame :(
Nidia Vega people are lost in the middle of a bland society.
If there is a God, those 18 (now 25) individuals will spend eternity locked in a closet with Tiny Tim.
That shit gay
when im listening to this piece i just think about urumia lake.people will die.everything will damage.arid will be everywhere in that location.shit
Ничего не понимаете ни в музыке, ни в чувствах Гения!!
Здесь Тоска!!!
Иностранцы не имеют этого чувства.
Отчасти, как Ностальгия!
@@user-ne6zh5ux4fмрак