The question wasnt whether the clones had souls but rather the monsters in society like these two women and others who craft and implement such demonic practices like this and try to "normalize " it!
If you notice, madame is in a wheel chair in a world where disease is cured by using up the clones. She forwent those cures and treatments because she didn't want to participate in that evil.
They don’t have any chance out in society because they were never taught how to live amongst “normal people” - there’s a scene where they are in a cafe, terrified to even order food. They have no idea how to do anything like buy food, get an ID, find a place to live, and if anyone found out that they were a clone then they would be shunned, as stated in this scene they aren’t considered people. They could probably have run away to the countryside and lived together alone, but there’s also the element of how as children they were told that the donations were their obligation and they MUST go through with it. They only had the confidence to ask for more time, as not donating didn’t even occur to them. They are too mentally imprisoned as well as socially indoctrinated to go against the grain and live and love. That’s part of the tragedy.
I'm not heartless here and i cried and my heart broke watching this BUT: She has a car... why dont they simply leave that life to start a new one elsewhere? Or am i missing the complication somewhere?
This is one of the most heartbreaking movies I have ever watched. Tommy’s scream a few minutes later barely outranks this moment.
The irony is - in this moment the clones are more human than humans, as they grapple with their own mortality
Carey Mulligan is quietly brilliant in this scene.
She is my favorite actress
The question wasnt whether the clones had souls but rather the monsters in society like these two women and others who craft and implement such demonic practices like this and try to "normalize " it!
If you notice, madame is in a wheel chair in a world where disease is cured by using up the clones. She forwent those cures and treatments because she didn't want to participate in that evil.
I still wish a happy ending after saw this... stupid me
Same….
Why didn’t they try to run away
They don’t have any chance out in society because they were never taught how to live amongst “normal people” - there’s a scene where they are in a cafe, terrified to even order food. They have no idea how to do anything like buy food, get an ID, find a place to live, and if anyone found out that they were a clone then they would be shunned, as stated in this scene they aren’t considered people. They could probably have run away to the countryside and lived together alone, but there’s also the element of how as children they were told that the donations were their obligation and they MUST go through with it. They only had the confidence to ask for more time, as not donating didn’t even occur to them. They are too mentally imprisoned as well as socially indoctrinated to go against the grain and live and love. That’s part of the tragedy.
I'm not heartless here and i cried and my heart broke watching this BUT: She has a car... why dont they simply leave that life to start a new one elsewhere? Or am i missing the complication somewhere?
They’re socially indoctrinated.
how come the human woman is getting old and sick if humans are meant to be immortal
I assumed she did not want to use the cloning and donating system.