Insane work. I can't imagine how much time and effort you put into this transcription considering the fact that Brad is not like a typical bebop player.
I first heard this recording not long after I started studying jazz over a decade ago... I come back to it every few years, thinking I’ve learned a thing or two and that maybe this won’t shock me as much as it did when I first heard it. I’m always wrong. Nice job with the transcription!
this is an amazing solo by Brad Mehldau. The way he takes his time building a dialog and then swings like mad!!!! He akes it and doesn't stop, ON FIRE!!! Thank you for doing the transcription I can't tell you how many times I've listened to this and am learning from the transcription. Thanks for all your hard work Tom. Peace
Bryant Miano Wellllll yeaaaaahhh, but that’s not a useful comparison first of all because most metronomes stop at 208 so you’d set it to the half note, not the quarter note, but more to the point it’s not a useful comparison anyway because there’s plenty of jazz tunes at this speed (most of oscar Peterson and like all of phineas newborne, for example). So all you’re saying is this tune is similar to a lot of other ones. So let’s go with Half Note = 156. Or hell, if we assume he’s feeling this in 4/8, then in 4/4 the quarter note actually WOULD be 156. So, you know, whatever. Lol. Enjoy the music, I think is the moral of the story. It’s good shit.
WTF, most impressive Brad Mehldau Solo I ever heard 😮 Not sure if it's only thanks to the transcription. But I rather think that someone thought this had to be transcribed because it's so incredible 👏 Thanks for sharing the transcription!
I listen to this about once a week, after reading the News. The creative SPIRIT of mankind won't be subdued by tyrants after all. It's a force bigger than all the Evil. Extremely uplifting MUSIC.
Amazing transcription, thank you so much! This is an utterly baffling solo. The deliberate pacing and control are balanced with so many wonderful surprises and a feeling of "discovery" throughout the course of the solo.
Certain parts of this remind me of Brubeck, where he got way out on the rhythmic sense (4:56), while the drummer kept the train on the tracks; then everybody gets back together as the station comes into view. Extremely adventuresome! Meldhau has a kind of a weird rubato in the middle of a swinging monster.This is FREEWHEELLIN'
You deserve a medal for this. Absolutely incredible transcription of a genius solo. What's your analysis of his scale/chord usage over these changes? I noticed he was using that flat 9th a lot.
Sorry, meant the #9. Seems like he's using the Bb7#9 as a kind of pedal throughout the A section, giving the whole thing a very bluesy sound. In fact he finishes the whole solo on an Ab - the b7 of Bb.
@@bigmoish9363 are you the same person amending your own comment on a different account 3 years later?? and are you gonna reply to me ANOTHER 3 years later? and will it be with yet another new account? inquiring minds must know
Great job - that was a Herculean effort on a difficult solo, especially with the poly rhythms! I would be interested in getting the PDF of the transcription.
+Tomek Soltys Good on you. I always start on transcriptions all like, "I'm gonna make it this time and get some more language *20 minutes later*...... *door slams*". Can't believe you have the patience to complete a project like this. Seriously, how the hell do you do this? I want to know.
Those are just telling you what beat some of the notes should fall on to help you get a sense of how that weird rhythm should go. So the 3 above the g in measure 100 is telling you that the g falls on beat 3, and the 4a above the f in measure 100 is telling you to land on that f on the and of beat 4, and vice versa👍
Incroyable solo! Pour ceux qui seraient intéressés je parle de ce solo dans mon workshop sur la créativité rythmique: czcams.com/video/roPOXJzk68U/video.html
This is a Charlie Parker composition...yet someone else's name is in the spot that is reserved for the composer. Everyone is mentioned EXCEPT the composer...UNACCEPTABLE!
+haroun elnil Yes, and while we're at it, let's not forget to give a credit to the REAL composer of this tune - I Got Rhythm - George Gershwin. Strictly speaking, Anthropology is just a variation on that song.
Nobody talked about copyright or law,so there's no need to be rude. You can't copyright harmony of the tune, only melody, so legally you're correct. But the tune and solos are based on a harmony and form written by Gershwin and without him there wouldn't be Anthropology or many other jazz lines using these chord changes. That's all I meant, ok?
There are only two things that the ALL the musicians in a band have on common...the tempo and the melody...NOT the harmony! By convention there is a place on the music for the composer's name. Just like meter and key. It's on every piece of music you've ever seen. The pianist could have just broken in playing running chords, but he didn't he chose to play Charlie Parker's melody. On the recording, that fact must be properly documented. ...and it was NOT properly documented on the music. Good Day.
I'm sorry to disappoint you, but you don't seem to know the most basic thing about jazz. In jazz we improvise on harmony of the tune and NOT on melody.The tempo is also optional and is usually decided by the leader. Bud chose to play this particular Parker' "line" because it's a good one and he liked it, but he and his trio still improvised on "I Got Rhythm" chord changes originated by George Gershwin. That's that in a nutshell!...... On the second matter, I fully agree with you that composers (Parker and Dizzy Gillespie*s) names should have been stated and share in your disgust over the people responsible for failing to do so. We have no argument on this account. Good Day to you as well!
Story has it that Brad got up about around 9pm, had breakfast, then opened the gig with this...
just Brad being Brad
Tomek Soltys i fucked brad!
Where'd you hear this?
Insane work. I can't imagine how much time and effort you put into this transcription considering the fact that Brad is not like a typical bebop player.
thought i forgot the high speed on my youtube settings
Miaris Vasilis same here, hahah went to the comments section just to make sure I wasn’t the only one
Faster than light
LOL🤣🤣
I first heard this recording not long after I started studying jazz over a decade ago... I come back to it every few years, thinking I’ve learned a thing or two and that maybe this won’t shock me as much as it did when I first heard it.
I’m always wrong.
Nice job with the transcription!
this is an amazing solo by Brad Mehldau. The way he takes his time building a dialog and then swings like mad!!!! He akes it and doesn't stop, ON FIRE!!! Thank you for doing the transcription I can't tell you how many times I've listened to this and am learning from the transcription. Thanks for all your hard work Tom. Peace
Agreed!
This is one of my favourite piano solos of all times, thank you for sharing this! Congrats on your work.
Craziest rhythm changes ive ever heard
Clocked at 316 bpm. I tried to practice this but my metronome caught fire.
Bryant Miano lol insanity
Bryant Miano Wellllll yeaaaaahhh, but that’s not a useful comparison first of all because most metronomes stop at 208 so you’d set it to the half note, not the quarter note, but more to the point it’s not a useful comparison anyway because there’s plenty of jazz tunes at this speed (most of oscar Peterson and like all of phineas newborne, for example). So all you’re saying is this tune is similar to a lot of other ones. So let’s go with Half Note = 156. Or hell, if we assume he’s feeling this in 4/8, then in 4/4 the quarter note actually WOULD be 156. So, you know, whatever. Lol. Enjoy the music, I think is the moral of the story. It’s good shit.
Matthew Newton people use their phones for metronomes nowadays and they clock in at 500 BPM for the max most of the time
HAHAHAHAHAH!
Imaging having to walk through this😂
This is one of the most interesting solos I have ever heard in my life, incredible stuff from Brad here. Thank you for sharing!
WTF, most impressive Brad Mehldau Solo I ever heard 😮 Not sure if it's only thanks to the transcription. But I rather think that someone thought this had to be transcribed because it's so incredible 👏 Thanks for sharing the transcription!
I keep coming back and being inspired year after year,still sounds fresh today.
I listen to this about once a week, after reading the News. The creative SPIRIT of mankind won't be subdued by tyrants after all. It's a force bigger than all the Evil. Extremely uplifting MUSIC.
When he stops doubling he basically writes another tune over the original changes. What a beast!
Amazing transcription, thank you so much! This is an utterly baffling solo. The deliberate pacing and control are balanced with so many wonderful surprises and a feeling of "discovery" throughout the course of the solo.
WOW what a play and what a transcription!
Fantastic work and thank you so much for sharing.
Whew! Think I just held my breath for 6 minutes!
Hey man YES You deserve a medal for this. Absolutely incredible transcription of a genius solo
Jumpy nervousness, fingers almost STUCK, followed by full bore swinging! Brilliant contrast!
Certain parts of this remind me of Brubeck, where he got way out on the rhythmic sense (4:56), while the drummer kept the train on the tracks; then everybody gets back together as the station comes into view. Extremely adventuresome! Meldhau has a kind of a weird rubato in the middle of a swinging monster.This is FREEWHEELLIN'
Incredible !
One of the best chorus i hear!!
Brad Meldhau is without limits...
both mehldau and the transcriber are on fire here; subscribed....
Absolutely insane
Unachievable
The speed of this embodies everything that can go wrong with musicians
You deserve a medal for this. Absolutely incredible transcription of a genius solo. What's your analysis of his scale/chord usage over these changes? I noticed he was using that flat 9th a lot.
Sorry, meant the #9. Seems like he's using the Bb7#9 as a kind of pedal throughout the A section, giving the whole thing a very bluesy sound. In fact he finishes the whole solo on an Ab - the b7 of Bb.
@@bigmoish9363 are you the same person amending your own comment on a different account 3 years later?? and are you gonna reply to me ANOTHER 3 years later? and will it be with yet another new account? inquiring minds must know
@@needlessnoise asking the real questions
@@needlessnoise lmao
@@needlessnoise lol
Fantastic interpretation, great tension... and i just love what happens at bar 156.... yeah!
Many thanks for this great transcription
Best thing ever. Thank you.
Amazing performance but also amazing transcription !!! Well done !!
Great job - that was a Herculean effort on a difficult solo, especially with the poly rhythms! I would be interested in getting the PDF of the transcription.
beast performance and transcription, thanks !
Thank you for this work !
Man! Genius playing and what an insane transcription - absolutely perfect! How long did it take you?
Edutainment Centre a labour week:)
+Tomek Soltys Good on you. I always start on transcriptions all like, "I'm gonna make it this time and get some more language *20 minutes later*...... *door slams*". Can't believe you have the patience to complete a project like this. Seriously, how the hell do you do this? I want to know.
+TFP 3141 i simply wanted to transcribe it, so i wouldn't stop before i was done:)
Wow. Awesome job. Was this done by ear? Must of took a looooooong time. Those polyrhythms are insane.
Hi. Thank you. I did it by ear, took 7 days to transcribe. Thanks for listening! Regards
7 days? wtf?
and on the 8th day he rested.
Fantastic Work !!! Thanks so much !!!
Hey Tomek nice playing!
bass player (im assuming larry grenadier) is a hero for holding it down so hard over those first couple of choruses
@@ViziaFilms That is correct sir. Live in Barcelona, circa 1992 i believe .
Very early material from Mehldau.
Nicely done!
Terrific, loving this
Amazing - thanks so much for sharing!
top notch transcription! thank you!!!
Great Transcription man!!! I think it would have taken my whole life to transcribe just this piece (not including sleep) :)
lol
So great! I'll try to send you a message to get the PDF, thanks for posting!
Yeah Tomek, great job!!
TomsRudzinskis haha, paldies Toms, let me know when you're in town! best
damn. I thought I was alright at piano but I just tried playing the head at this speed
with both hands?
Would kindly request transcription of Stanley Turrentine's "Don't Mess With Mr. T"
Nice job!💫
What do the 1, 3, 4a, and 2a written above the septuplets at 1:17 mean?
Those are just telling you what beat some of the notes should fall on to help you get a sense of how that weird rhythm should go. So the 3 above the g in measure 100 is telling you that the g falls on beat 3, and the 4a above the f in measure 100 is telling you to land on that f on the and of beat 4, and vice versa👍
amazing trancription!
Great stuff!
Thank you so much!
So rad thanks!
AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!!
+SGelovani AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!! indeed.
AAAAAAAARRRRGHHHHHHH
AMAZING!!!
Very good
Shit I thought i was the one who made that transcription !
Hi Phil !
+Dexter Goldberg you should meet my man Tomek!!!
+Dexter Goldberg I did it too
+Phil Maniez already starts to sound like a plan to me
What record is this recording on
the phrase 02:30 to 02:45 OMG wooooowww
I sent you an email. I really hope to receive the pdf.. Thank you for your video
this is insane wow
wow , dude good job
Yeah!!!
okay now for real what is that flat natural unison.
Crazy as hell, I will feel the same if i meet an alien
Wow! I sent you an email and asked questions regarding transcribing. I hope you have time to answer me and send me the wonderful pdfs.
How do we really know that this transcript is indeed performed in this tempo?
Because he does it live. My piano teacher studied in New York, got to hear him do this piece. Unreal.
slowed it down to 1/2-much better!
Well crap. Just when I feel like I've pulled my stuff together, I'm humbled beyond words. Time for me to take up another profession.
Is it a real speed?? :O
Where can I get the rest of this album? What's it called?
Mehldau & Rossy Trio - When I Fall In Love
Who are the rythmics ??
I would love the PDF to this if you can send it to me, thanks!
please email me at tomsoltysjazz@ gmail.com, I'll reply with the PDF attached
Hi tom! Congratulations. You can send me the pdf?
2:10 2:10 2:10
Is this his regular trio?
Mario Rossy on bass and Jorge Rossy on drums, so almost
Can you send me the pdf?
2:31
Reminds me of michel camilo 😍😎
bye
@@1czechchick huh?
Incroyable solo! Pour ceux qui seraient intéressés je parle de ce solo dans mon workshop sur la créativité rythmique: czcams.com/video/roPOXJzk68U/video.html
Omg..
미치겠다
Asu mareeee
1:28 the lick
This is a Charlie Parker composition...yet someone else's name is in the spot that is reserved for the composer.
Everyone is mentioned EXCEPT the composer...UNACCEPTABLE!
+haroun elnil Yes, and while we're at it, let's not forget to give a credit to the REAL composer of this tune - I Got Rhythm - George Gershwin.
Strictly speaking, Anthropology is just a variation on that song.
He didn't play 'I've got Rhythm', he played the Parker song. The copyright would read 'Anthropology'.
If you want to practice law...get a license...
Nobody talked about copyright or law,so there's no need to be rude. You can't copyright harmony of the tune, only melody, so legally you're correct. But the tune and solos are based on a harmony and form written by Gershwin and without him there wouldn't be Anthropology or many other jazz lines using these chord changes. That's all I meant, ok?
There are only two things that the ALL the musicians in a band have on common...the tempo and the melody...NOT the harmony!
By convention there is a place on the music for the composer's name. Just like meter and key. It's on every piece of music you've ever seen.
The pianist could have just broken in playing running chords, but he didn't he chose to play Charlie Parker's melody. On the recording, that fact must be properly documented.
...and it was NOT properly documented on the music.
Good Day.
I'm sorry to disappoint you, but you don't seem to know the most basic thing about jazz. In jazz we improvise on harmony of the tune and NOT on melody.The tempo is also optional and is usually decided by the leader.
Bud chose to play this particular Parker' "line" because it's a good one and he liked it, but he and his trio still improvised on "I Got Rhythm" chord changes originated by George Gershwin.
That's that in a nutshell!......
On the second matter, I fully agree with you that composers (Parker and Dizzy Gillespie*s) names should have been stated and share in your disgust over the people responsible for failing to do so. We have no argument on this account.
Good Day to you as well!
Transcriptions done by computer software not by ear.. your a con .. got to be
I'm grateful he took the time to do it regardless.
Jesus Christ, that was ridiculous
Hey man YES You deserve a medal for this. Absolutely incredible transcription of a genius solo
2:31