Unerasing Erased People

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 05. 2023
  • Dr. Roy Casagranda walks into the minefield of race and representation! To erase to not to erase? How should Cleopatra VII be represented in film?
    Also how much do you love our new amazing background!?!?! Just looking at it makes me feel like inclusion exists.

Komentáře • 173

  • @Shamsulrosunally
    @Shamsulrosunally Před 7 měsíci +126

    Watching the Palestinians slowly being erased from history is depressing the hell out of me and making me incredibly anxious. Like a lot of people i feel helpless but your content, Roy, is the only thing helping me through this period. As soon as my children are old enough i will tell them to watch your content to counter the school history brainwashing. Your Brit bashing makes me laugh out loud and helps me forget the seriousness of life. You are the Dave Chapelle of academia. Big thanks from the UK.

    • @faiq757
      @faiq757 Před 7 měsíci +3

      Wow...that's an epic analogy

    • @Hayatt1
      @Hayatt1 Před 5 měsíci +1

      💯💯💯💯

    • @user-ft1ih2cb5z
      @user-ft1ih2cb5z Před 3 měsíci +3

      Same from libya 🇱🇾

    • @alanstone139
      @alanstone139 Před 3 měsíci

      They're just Arabs

    • @karlmuud
      @karlmuud Před 2 měsíci +1

      Probably slightly serious than DC I should think! 😅

  • @shanfeerpakarath1637
    @shanfeerpakarath1637 Před rokem +71

    If story telling is an art, Prof. Roy Casagranda is an artist!! May god grant you a healthy long life.

  • @ujjwaluprety3024
    @ujjwaluprety3024 Před rokem +79

    Always a privelege to listen to Prof. Casagranda and his beautiful story telling.

  • @sawsanzerarka5655
    @sawsanzerarka5655 Před 10 měsíci +19

    So, I'm an Algerian, currently living in Europe and I can watch prof Casagranda's lectures at home. Thank you Allah for the internet 🙏🙏❤️

  • @osamasamhan145
    @osamasamhan145 Před 10 měsíci +9

    Brother Roy Casagranda - From Palestine all love and respect to you and your family - Wish I meet you one day

  • @Tab3bah
    @Tab3bah Před rokem +33

    Literally makes my day when i see a new upload from Dr Casagranda.

  • @user-nv9sw3ns7c
    @user-nv9sw3ns7c Před rokem +10

    Dr Cassandra, you ought to be named the voice of the voiceless, I listen to you with passion and admiration

  • @Parsa_m
    @Parsa_m Před rokem +25

    Finally some Dr.Roy again
    You should post more often of him
    Man’s a legend

    • @ohara.
      @ohara. Před rokem

      is this an Iranian name ?

    • @Parsa_m
      @Parsa_m Před rokem

      @@ohara. what? My name ? Yes Parsa is Iranian

    • @ohara.
      @ohara. Před rokem

      @@Parsa_m oh nothing major i have a friend here in japan and his name is parsa i was wondering if its a name from iran or other countries have the same name too

    • @Parsa_m
      @Parsa_m Před rokem

      @@ohara. no it’s 100% Persian Iranian name

  • @expat13thuis50
    @expat13thuis50 Před 4 měsíci +4

    The only thing why Dr. Casagranda don't have millions of viewers is because he is honest and always speaks the truth, people can't handle that.

  • @Johnwick007
    @Johnwick007 Před rokem +9

    Wish I had a friend like Roy. Meet on sunday and listen to his storys ! Amazing guy !

  • @MuhannadDarwish
    @MuhannadDarwish Před rokem +20

    Omg Dr. Casagranda finally dropped a new video🙌🏼 plz upload more

    • @AudioPervert1
      @AudioPervert1 Před rokem

      Erased people? That is like saying Hey Hey what about all the barbarians, stateless, nomadic, tribal, indigenous, hill peoples etc etc?
      Folks like Casagrande as woke as they come, shamelessly ride and film fancy cars in Dubai, burning shit tons of petrol and then speak of erased people.
      This is such a jackass show, the academia of this kind. Cult worship as we clearly see in the comments below

  • @leylahjohnston
    @leylahjohnston Před 3 měsíci +2

    I love his talks. Watched all of them wish there were more. I love his ancient history ones.

  • @EgyKarNLFR
    @EgyKarNLFR Před rokem +5

    I like his material, he does not vilify North African, Middle Eastern and southern European culture, but put it’s into context. I am half Egyptian, half Karelian, Dutch and French educated and have been called many names or cultures… but the reality is mostly in the middle. It should not be cheap tribalism, the reason why is that Western civilisation does not start after Rome or the renaissance, it started much earlier in the Mediterranean area and western Asia and it was wide color pallet and much more inclusive, albeit for various wars (but hey that’s humanity for ya)
    Looking forward to more lectures

  • @pivoine96
    @pivoine96 Před rokem +9

    Thank you Dr.Casagranda for being so awesome! and teaching us something which matters. It's nice to see someone rational and learn something real.

  • @Salah.K.A
    @Salah.K.A Před rokem +7

    Always great to listen and learn from Dr. Roy

  • @christiannem5578
    @christiannem5578 Před rokem +7

    I totally agree. His passion, amazing knowledge and memory are very inspiring.

  • @helveticaneptune537
    @helveticaneptune537 Před rokem +5

    Dr Casagranda is a breath of fresh air

  • @andreselectrico
    @andreselectrico Před rokem +25

    This guy is gold.

    • @AudioPervert1
      @AudioPervert1 Před rokem

      Erased people? That is like saying Hey Hey what about all the barbarians, stateless, nomadic, tribal, indigenous, hill peoples etc etc?
      Folks like Casagrande as woke as they come, shamelessly ride and film fancy cars in Dubai, burning shit tons of petrol and then speak of erased people.
      This is such a jackass show, the academia of this kind. Cult worship as we clearly see in the comments below
      Gold for Woke Turds Who Knew Even Less Earlier

    • @wflip1745
      @wflip1745 Před rokem +1

      We got Top G. Now this is the Real G 💯

    • @cloudfloat4179
      @cloudfloat4179 Před měsícem +1

      One of the sane in an insane world.

  • @zeeshanbandawal5703
    @zeeshanbandawal5703 Před rokem +3

    I could listen to his lectures forever

  • @user-mv7zf9pi4s
    @user-mv7zf9pi4s Před 27 dny

    You're such an amazing and intelligent teacher! Always enjoy listening to your talks. Thanks, Roy.

  • @fuado5750
    @fuado5750 Před rokem +7

    What is the name of the book that you read about Arabic history? Thanks

  • @Wisdomseeker1028
    @Wisdomseeker1028 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Always a pleasure listening to your lectures. I do it to and from my commutes to work.

  • @mennaelbatal6754
    @mennaelbatal6754 Před rokem +5

    The amount of information in this lecture is astonishing! I just hope this video could reach out to more people

    • @ibatan7243
      @ibatan7243 Před rokem

      But most of it is based on lies.

  • @MH-hl4ug
    @MH-hl4ug Před rokem +6

    Im from saudi arabia and dr roy has really surprised me with how much accurate info he has. Keep it going dr!

  • @NFZ138
    @NFZ138 Před 3 měsíci +2

    A Mighty Heart!!

  • @c.kainoabugado7935
    @c.kainoabugado7935 Před 5 měsíci +1

    This topic is revolutionary and controversial💯 THANK YOU Dr. Casagranda for making it happen🙌🏽❤ Inspiring!

  • @snakejuce
    @snakejuce Před rokem +17

    Just made a post about this the other day. This is an oft-neglected part of continuing genocides, by erasing their histories, rewriting their histories, and deliberately obfuscating them for nefarious reasons.
    It's vile and lowly but it's real and it happens. In any situation of the oppressor vs the oppressed, you can see this dynamic being played. It's mad.

  • @filiplazz
    @filiplazz Před rokem +3

    where is the regular program? Also, BIG yes to the Iroquois lecture!

  • @yourhealinghome8812
    @yourhealinghome8812 Před 2 měsíci

    I can't possibly imagine a more perfect background treatment to reinforce the intent of the message - just look at that - it's just wonderful.

  • @salmanjets718
    @salmanjets718 Před rokem +6

    Has this professor ever explained how Sunni and Shiite situation happened? His storytelling is amazing. Crystal clear. I don’t get bored 5 mins in. I can watch for hours

    • @mrfarax4944
      @mrfarax4944 Před 8 měsíci

      He did in his lectures on islamic civilization

  • @ssn215
    @ssn215 Před rokem +2

    Love the lecture
    Im still waiting for the 1st part of a lecture you did last year dr 😢 please upload it and dont forget the crusades please please post

  • @karwanraza7047
    @karwanraza7047 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Thank you Dr Casagranda for highlighting these. Love listening to you and trying the truth.

  • @jmu9969
    @jmu9969 Před 13 dny

    Thank you Dr. Roy for enlightening narrative of history and my appreciation for the Austin School. Please add more videos…

  • @annasproles9190
    @annasproles9190 Před 5 měsíci +2

    Thanks for being so awesome Dr. Casagrana! Also, about submarine movies - check out Das Boot if you haven't already. My favorite is the original with subtitles.

  • @gameofadages6847
    @gameofadages6847 Před 8 dny

    I live in New England. I live 15 minutes from where Metacomet was killed and the Pokanoket resistance to annihilation came to an end. In the small islands of forest left, you can find all kinds of indigenous stone works. I can only speculate on everything that was lost

  • @omayarushd6509
    @omayarushd6509 Před rokem +1

    Superior multicultural erudition and a keen sense of historical justice the overall Western sense of history is not familiar with, -- mostly deliberately--due to deeply rooted prejudice and the fascistic idea of denigrating what is relevant and enlightening about other nonwestern cultures such as the Islamic and Native American cultures among many others. I have so much respect and admiration for the integral character and impartiality of Professor Casagranda, whose heart, mind, and soul are truly a grand and open house for all to learn from!

  • @binlegend
    @binlegend Před rokem +2

    Love this guy, telling the story like it.

  • @MohamedElMeghallawy
    @MohamedElMeghallawy Před 29 dny

    this is golden. thank you Sir. i’m speechless

  • @inconvenient-truth99
    @inconvenient-truth99 Před 9 měsíci +2

    Ray tells it like it is! The TRUTH!

  • @cornells11
    @cornells11 Před rokem +5

    Wait, Roy said he had to do parts 3 and 4 of the Crusader series, that means part 2 has been done, please upload it🙏🙏🙏

    • @edwardjanuary1259
      @edwardjanuary1259 Před rokem

      You could read , Amin Maalof, امين معلوف in Arabic, I think, it is the main source of the whole Dr sources

    • @edwardjanuary1259
      @edwardjanuary1259 Před rokem

      Les croisades vues par les Arabes

  • @inconvenient-truth99
    @inconvenient-truth99 Před 9 měsíci +2

    Ray is the best ACC teacher!

  • @farzanasyed3627
    @farzanasyed3627 Před 10 měsíci +2

    He makes it so interesting, I want to do political science major now

  • @kuzwayopilati8413
    @kuzwayopilati8413 Před 4 měsíci +1

    This man is a treasure! Is there a podcast i can download these lectures?

  • @mesbahahmed1690
    @mesbahahmed1690 Před 8 měsíci +2

    This guy is absolutely amazing! I am a fan

  • @Zero-vt5qw
    @Zero-vt5qw Před rokem +3

    please do more videos u are a real teacher

  • @khanofcaledonia6413
    @khanofcaledonia6413 Před rokem

    I learned something new today. Thank you Dr.Casagranda.

  • @Inayat-pl9cl
    @Inayat-pl9cl Před měsícem

    While appreciating video lectures, I may request Prof. Roy to publish books with references adding to academics as William Dalrymple did.

  • @grow_up290
    @grow_up290 Před rokem +2

    waiting for the continuation of the crusader talks✝⚔

  • @Item0945
    @Item0945 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Thank you for the video, funny as always.

  • @cbbcbb6803
    @cbbcbb6803 Před 26 dny +1

    Very good.

  • @lassekristoffersen5906
    @lassekristoffersen5906 Před měsícem +1

    Roy? - Just a hero.

  • @Gehri_soch2.0
    @Gehri_soch2.0 Před rokem +3

    This was too short 😭

  • @ruffnerd
    @ruffnerd Před 3 měsíci

    i've always dreamed about traveling in space and being in a situation where we can't be detected for our safety and just,,, droping a wrench anyway omg the satisfaction

  • @End_Zionism
    @End_Zionism Před rokem +1

    Professor, FINALLY!!!!! I have been checking your channel almost every day for WEEKS waiting for you to upload again. We have so many charlatans uploading every day - you have a responsibility to upload more often. If I had your knowledge, wisdom, and charisma I’d be uploading lectures every day. DEFEAT THE CHARLATANS!!!!!!! God bless you.

  • @sheikhtanveer271
    @sheikhtanveer271 Před 11 měsíci

    Thanks a lot for teaching ❤
    Love from india

  • @ahhu.
    @ahhu. Před rokem +1

    The problem is, they called it a "documentary"

  • @minatohid7855
    @minatohid7855 Před rokem +1

    Thanks!

  • @hollagonzalez7954
    @hollagonzalez7954 Před 2 měsíci

    Thank you

  • @jeremy-avar
    @jeremy-avar Před rokem +3

    29:15 A good example of practicing humility, and even repentance. Acknowledging that we are also doing the "gross" thing and fighting against those taught instincts.

  • @alibehrad
    @alibehrad Před rokem +1

    He is just great.

  • @eg6308
    @eg6308 Před rokem +2

    Very good drama series about the beginning of Islam: Umar (available with English subtitles on Islamicity).

  • @scottschauer7088
    @scottschauer7088 Před 4 měsíci

    The algorithm of CZcams actually works, because it led me here based on my interests.

  • @ramjebar936
    @ramjebar936 Před rokem +1

    😄 amazing👍👍👍👍👍

  • @ratatataraxia
    @ratatataraxia Před 3 měsíci

    If you grew up in CCTX in the 90s you definitely learned about the Tancahua and the Carancahua.

  • @Smlworld798
    @Smlworld798 Před rokem

    Can we get all his lectures recorded ?

  • @ism01717
    @ism01717 Před rokem

    Offtopic: I have a question- Is there any correlation between one side there was a protestant movement on the other hand in the Muslim community there was Imam Ghazali. What do you think about this.

  • @mohammadbinmahbub9160
    @mohammadbinmahbub9160 Před rokem +1

    I can relate to the greek-persian indistinguishability

  • @Shak-Agha
    @Shak-Agha Před 10 dny

    Long Live Dr Roy.

  • @aminadan4881
    @aminadan4881 Před 8 měsíci

    Roy casagranda podcast 🤝

  • @therobust
    @therobust Před rokem +3

    Reaction after 12:48. Ultimate and true to the fact.😂

    • @temporarybackup5077
      @temporarybackup5077 Před rokem +1

      😂 if you don't laugh, you cry 🙏

    • @therobust
      @therobust Před rokem

      @@temporarybackup5077 like where do you go from there? Absolutely stunning!!!

  • @wahyuindrasto8307
    @wahyuindrasto8307 Před měsícem

    What with the jokes about West Virginia (and Arkansas) when Roy was talking about inbreeding in Cleopatra's family?

  • @JoshuaBolwerk
    @JoshuaBolwerk Před měsícem

    Oh that means you HAVE to meet me I have everybody in my DNA

  • @adambadawy2509
    @adambadawy2509 Před rokem +1

    You’re a real g Roy

  • @moawiyaalrawas270
    @moawiyaalrawas270 Před 11 měsíci

    I dont think the Cleopatra media outrage is race related.. It's more national.
    If the actress was from Egypt, it wouldn't have mattered if her equilibrium was more back or more white
    Amazing lecture and letcturer. Thank you Dr. Casagranda.. I enjoyed both, the information and the story telling style

  • @wflip1745
    @wflip1745 Před rokem +2

    Professor Real G

  • @mudgreen2340
    @mudgreen2340 Před rokem +1

    he is Him.

  • @a3zan
    @a3zan Před 3 měsíci

    I like this guy

  • @aristotlejb82
    @aristotlejb82 Před 5 měsíci

    Fun fact: David Lean did try to cast Indian Great Dilip Kumar for the role of Ali but Dilip Kumar declined the role and it went to Omar Sharif. So, they did try to do it without any Arab.

  • @NazimQuraishi
    @NazimQuraishi Před 10 měsíci

    God bless you and bless the nation whose creed is "....self-evident, that all men are created equal, " .
    May God disable all those who undermine this creed.

  • @nonozebra4196
    @nonozebra4196 Před 6 měsíci +1

    OMG Dr Roy, be careful people from WV and Arkansas might be listening to you or not lol😅

  • @TooToo246
    @TooToo246 Před rokem +2

    Ok, let's be clear here, all this historical talk for or against the portrayal of Cleopatra, does not matter!.... Jada Smith herself admitted she wanted to pull off a Marvel's "What If!" on Cleopatra, that's it!.....Tina Gharavi and Jada Smith are in no way historians and they're not nearly as sophisticated as required of a director and producer for such a series!....They're simply a couple divas, playing to their woke feminist-afrocentric fantasy, and passing it off as real history. And they got the woke corporate mob backing them up!
    And before you accuse me of being a white supremacist, I'm a Muslim arab, with part African and part Turkish btw, I don't even live in the US!

  • @Zero-vt5qw
    @Zero-vt5qw Před rokem

    can you do carthage since om from north africa id like to now the history of the land

  • @PabloFlores-hs4wu
    @PabloFlores-hs4wu Před 8 měsíci

    Where’s the unedited version?

  • @maryamtariq5228
    @maryamtariq5228 Před rokem

    Can someone please elaborate the West Virginia and Arkansas reference?? 🙂

  • @oluwoleolubajo3340
    @oluwoleolubajo3340 Před 9 měsíci

    Ensuring that the details of realism are depicted in Hollywood movies.

  • @stevesmith4901
    @stevesmith4901 Před rokem +1

    Is he pronouncing the 'P' in the name Ptolemy?

  • @JamesPeach
    @JamesPeach Před rokem

    LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @temporarybackup5077
    @temporarybackup5077 Před rokem +2

    24:21
    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @lutverwilt4794
    @lutverwilt4794 Před rokem

    Love submarines too 😀

  • @Imraz__Khan
    @Imraz__Khan Před 7 měsíci

    🔥❤

  • @centurionguards3819
    @centurionguards3819 Před měsícem

    Two questions didn't the Roman Empire morph into the Catholic church. have you done any research into many of the Africans placed in slavery who were Hebrews.

  • @Defalt91
    @Defalt91 Před 10 měsíci

    i have a very little question from you and that is : if you invented calendar (re invented from persian sun calendar ) 3,4 or century ago , then how could you give us these numbers ?? from wich calendar this 2023 came from !?
    when your ancestors had no idea of counting years ,base of sun movement (the arabs at least were and are counting moons with their eyes) then from where these numbers are comming ?!!
    another question is that , what is exactly carbon dating !? is it correct or it just tell us that observed object can dated back to for example 200 years from now and more , and this more can be 20 milion years or more .
    from which books you are bringing these year numbers ? which calendar they were using ?
    as a iranian i know the feeling of defeat and wins and more defeat in our very long history , but i dont know what is like to live a beatiful lie ?
    i wanna know what is like to live emptier or hollower (if its a correct word) than vaccum

  • @CrimsonLair
    @CrimsonLair Před 5 měsíci

    This guy never been to Turkey

  • @zv8135
    @zv8135 Před rokem +6

    Dr. Casagrande, always a pleasure to see that you’ve uploaded. May I please ask, what mindset should I have when I read the bloodthrone of caria? And can we please get part 2 of the crusades. Thankyou, and trust you stay in good health Dr. Casagrande

  • @jeffjefferson1827
    @jeffjefferson1827 Před rokem

    Caria you say... and the queen was the sole ruler? Had to make sure I wasn't listening to a vaatividya video about elden ring and raya lu*caria* and their queen.

  • @milesnugent5916
    @milesnugent5916 Před 3 měsíci

    I’m not a trained historian but I’m pretty sure the P in Ptolemy isn’t pronounced lol, it’s just tolemy.

  • @Sol53155
    @Sol53155 Před rokem

    It's so refreshing to learn history and so much more from, in a manner that it doesn't feel like studying. Love from Pakistan, it's very common to stereotype in hollywood, for example Homeland series, which is basically about us 'cave dwellers' and there is an actual scene where they show pakistan people, in a village and there is no law/security and it was hilarious to us but of course it's very dangerous to the minds, who already see anyone with a different culture/skin color as their enemy. It's a fear machine, giving them their new enemy in a form of entertainment.

  • @doubledose3650
    @doubledose3650 Před 3 měsíci

    @12:58 😂

  • @nobaso620
    @nobaso620 Před 4 měsíci

    I'd love to see what he has to say about Africa

  • @IF18a
    @IF18a Před 6 měsíci

    Lets hear a lecture on the Arab Slave trade.