The most DIVISIVE Muslim YouTuber
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 09. 2024
- ABOUT ME:
Hello and welcome! I'm a Sociologist at the University of Warwick, UK where I explore social issues and find ways for people to resist, heal and flourish.
My publications and other creative projects are on my website williambarylo.com . To get in touch, email me at hello@williambarylo.com
This channel will NOT be monetized so:
1. I can have creative freedom and
2. Offer ad-free videos to my viewers.
Anticipating the wave of hate coming from some Muslims, Shisha lounges and the Saudi Government, I am leaving the comments open. Hate comments are always welcomed as they boost the visibility of this channel.
I don't think why you would assume that. There's also a difference between 'hating' and 'advising' people. If she were to insult Allah or his messenger ﷺ, or lied big time about something in the religion in a way that makes Islam looks horrific. Then I could see it happening.
@@JEAGERlST Sadly, the way many people "advise" others is nothing like what the Prophet would teach ignorants. I seriously don't know who would listen to people threatening them they will go to hell if they don't do X, Y, Z - that's a very Middle-Age Christian Catholic Church way of thinking.
@ForinNeim I made a video about Mohammed Hijab and Andrew Tate. It doesn't mean I need to debate everyone and buy a Bugatti.
@@williambarylo- thanks for such a great review. I had already seen Paloma's channel and found it inspirational as well as wonderful. It shows how Islam can be practiced authentically and pluralistically as it was during the early Muslim period.
@@JEAGERlST SMH. Lets not pretend theres no polarization within the Ummah, especially when it comes to the topic of muslim women not wearing the hijab
Hi William. Thank you so much for this wonderful video.
It was sent to me and it was a great surprise. Thank you for your work and comments ✨
Muchas gracias hermana! tu trabajo es único, admirable y necesario en este mundo de divisiones. Rezo para que Allah te dé la fuerza para continuar y te proteja de los juicios negativos. inshaAllah espero que podamos vernos la próxima vez que mi esposa y yo vayamos a Órgiva.
I am from Scotland 🏴 and I love her voice and the rich history. She talks about Gaza and feels like I am home ❤️🕊️. I like her character and respect her
It is refreshing to see the genuine face of Spaniard Muslims on her channel and a legacy of Al-Andalus. May Allah Subhananahuwatala bless her & you too good doctor with good health and keep you with all rest of Muslims steadfast on the righteous path of Islam. Ameen. Stay blessed and stay safe.
Thank you! Ameen!
Ameen
I love her channel. Gives you a glimpse into Andalusian Muslim culture.
Andalusian Muslim Culture has been WIPED OUT, and only the weak ones like her remain.
That culture is unislamic as hell. We need a HARAM alert for these people.
Her channel reminds me that being Muslim is not always about debating
@@williambarylotrue, as indonesian seeing islamic channel about debating is just sad, islam is way of life and is supposed to help people happy in this life, and islam as religion is very simple but some group of muslim make it difficult and complicated
As a Moroccan Muslim, this channel seems very nice and unique. It's always nice to see different muslim channels.
May Allah bless her and keep her in the straight path. Ameen
Ameen
I'm "native musilm" & I found her far more muslim than me! May god protect her.
😢 very sad you consider these people proper muslim
Everyone is on a journey
@@enacausmembrane At the end neither my "consideration" not yours will count! Isn't it ?
@enacausemembrane
Please focus, concentrate on what you are reading, people say & what it means. More Muslim than me does not equate to saying or meaning 'proper muslim'.
@@enacausmembranecan you define what a proper muslim is?
A lot of the Arab wealthy upper class Sheikhs commits every Haram they can possibly find, they are just very good at HIDING it!
I don't consider her as "Proper" Muslim, but she is my sister in Islam.
i discovered her channel about 2 years ago and instantly loved it. when i saw the word "divisive" i thought you were gonna dissed her, i'm glad you didn't.
Lol that's for the UK debate scene. Anywhere and at any times, there's always something Haram!
Her channel is utterly charming. Her videos take viewers to another place. She is a genuine person who is showing her everyday life and her surroundings. I believe she is secure in her identity as a Spanish Muslim and she has nothing to prove to other people, particularly other Muslims who think she must look a certain way and refrain from music. She is very blessed to have such a supportive community. When I watch her videos I want to be there and meet likeminded people. I’m better off without the negativity of other people, and in my little circle of family and friends, I have peace, and for that I am truly blessed.
It's not other rando Muslims who say this. Music is haram, and she isn't even wearing hijab. She's literally a mutabarrija.
That's exactly it!
Thank you so much 🙏🏽
@@ElCanaldePaloma salaam sister. You’re welcome. 😊
@@williambarylo salaam brother. Thank you. 🙏
I am from 🇧🇩. Love her channel so much. May Allah bless her. Aameen.
I love her channel and she has an aura of calm. I would love to be in a community that cherishes Islam and nature over buying and selling and brand names. May Allah bless the community of Granada and all of Spain.
... and a community with no judgement on anyone's journey!
Brothers and sisters unite, its the time
The Hour is near
It's great to see this content, the difference in culture, and the diversity in Islam and Europe. Great share, Dr Barylo!
I love her channel. It is very calming, beautiful and give a different perpective/take on spanish muslim. I've been to Spain and spend time in the Andalusia region and it's really beautiful including its people. 😊
I found her channel last year, her channel is so soothing, simplicity, and watch her channel on every eid celebration. Immediately i subscribe
7:01 that was what made me subscribe to her channel
Even in real life I wish more Muslims in the UK would at least not be scared of physically/mentally challenged people. Her kindness is exemplary
Thank you! I never heard of her channel but I’m loving it seeing all kind of muslims and their cultures & traditions.
I found her channel years ago and love it to this day. There's a Ramadan series in my country, Jejak Rasul( sort of like a documentary vlog programme that talk about Islam and Muslims and Islamic history as well as sirah around the world). They will cover certain regions each year and one of unforgettable to me is when they went to Spain. It left deep impression in me as well as a bit of sadness that time. I admit that that time I wish Islam will come back there.
When I found Paloma's channel, I was so elated and I remembered that feelings when I watched Jejak Rasul it but this time I'm really happy.
Hers is not a history channel but I appreciate she tries to search a bit more about History too!
Those trigger warnings 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 The fact that those even needed putting up makes me want to actually cry. So nothing left to do but to laugh instead.
... And it's 2024 *sigh*
"Women"
"Black muslims"
"Cute animals"
I cant even laugh many of these are just sad 😭😭😭😭
@@ouffman769 precisely. Laughing at it for it's demonstration of *ignorance, outrageousness and stupidity* is just a reaction to preserve one's own sanity. Otherwise I will be at risk of depression. I would prefer not to suffer from that, lolz. We need to recognise the fools and refuse to engage (further). But then one need to put up these warnings to deter them away. Kinda like the garlic to shoo away the vampire 🤣
May Allah forever bless her (and you, Doc). Feels like a fresh breath of air from what usually dominates Muslim landscapes.
Paloma tiene un canal que engancha y sus videos siempre son agradables y dignos de ver,siempre con la impresionante Alhambra de fondo de mi querida Andalucia ❤️
You have made my afternoon much better, thank you.
thank you!
Salam 3laikum!!!
Me llamo Asunción y soy seguidora desde hace aproximadamente 2 años, y solo puedo decir cosas buenas de Paloma. She is the best in CZcams. Y gracias a ella yo he abrazado el islam. I love .
Allhamdulilah I discover this canal....❤❤❤❤
Thanks for this videos it's refreshing to see such Muslims who are diverse, tolerant and appreciate art and creativity. I think they are more Muslim in their spirit than the so called 'religious' Muslims who would invalidate her. They make Islam appear harsh, ugly and with very little to offer the world.
The Colonization through the Christians and their imported laws was the worst thing to happen to the Muslim world. And I am not afraid to say it, the Salafists and Wahabbists that were emboldened by Saudi Arabia and USA to fight the Soviets in Afghanistan and spread the harshest, ugliest version of Islam is not what we should carry onward. No wonder We are divided and weak, even though the Quran is less harsh in every conceivable way.
Allah is the loving and caring (Ar Rahman). All His advice is sincere and has valid reasons. If Allah Himself doesn't withhold forgiveness and doesn't measure by outward appearance, then I have no right to do anything other than what was commanded of me alone and to leave others to be true to Allah to the best of their abilities.
Thank you. There are many examples of the Prophet's pedagogy to correct people, and it looks like nobody follows it sadly.
I cannot watch any of her videos not because they are bad, but because I deeply envy her. To have the ability to practice your religion without fear of persecution, disowning, killing, being kicked out to the street, losing your job, or being forced to divorce your wife, is a dream I have that I know cannot be realized as long as I live in this hellhole of an Islamic country. Congrats to those who escaped to the west or anywhere else thats respects humanity, and good luck to the likes of me who live in secrecy.
Most Islamic countries don't allow you to be Muslims they want the people to semi submit to the government
@@ムカマドthat’s a bafflingly retarded comment That only a foreigner to the affairs, and lives of muslims in the real muslim world, would say. Its the sort of thing muslims say to cope with how much of a failure islam behaves when integrated into the political sphere.
I'm sorry you are experiencing such hardships. No one deserves being under such pressure
You sound like a Liberal degenerate filth that also happens to identify as a Muslim. I'm from Bangladesh, which is kind of a Sh!thole I must say. Despite that, I wouldn’t DREAM of moving to the West because the West has "sUpEriOR mOrALs", the ONLY reason would move to the West is for ECONOMIC opportunities, that's it!
The fact that you consider WESTERN LGBTQ land as a moral hub exposes who you TRULY are!
I am so sorry that you are going through this. May Allah ease your pain 🤲🏾
I am from Algeria 🇩🇿 I also love her channel and the insight into Muslim life in and around the historic and beautiful Andalusian city of Granada.
Salafiyya cryig cause she is sufi and saying spain needs ahlu ssunnah wal jama3ah, but madhahib and sufism IS ahlu ssunnah. 😂
Her channel has been very useful for my muslim converts, may allah reward her work.
I love her channel so far from all the disgusting sectarian filth.
I still find it hard to believe she receives so many positive comments on her channel
@@williambarylono matter how many positive comments she and her channels get - Islam has nothing to do with desires or views of lunatic and culture oriented individuals. Islam is the culture that has its pillars and borders and these are immovable and finalized.
@@Bormond It would be awesome if there was only one true madhab and no conflicting opinions between scholars
The irony of that comment.
If division is sectarianism, than you’re literally doing what you consider as filth.
@@SayfumaniMyG get a fatwa from your fav celeb mulla.
El canal de Paloma is such a beautiful channel that brings me a lot of comfort, hope, peace and happiness. It reminds me what Islam is truly about. I hope her channel will grow even more insha’Allah ❤ Also it makes me practice Spanish 😂
Thank you so much 🙏🏽
Muchas gracias por valorar este precioso canal y a la artistaza Paloma❤
the fact that you have to say "people can be valid Muslims even if they are not rich" says a lot about society💀
I almost got to believe that to be accepted as a Muslim in the UK you must hang out in the shisha lounge. Thank God I never followed the crowd. My uncle once made me try a cigarette at age 5 and I almost suffocated. I was so traumatised that I could never smoke anything ever again. My uncle unknowingly saved me from the Shisha lounge.
Of the people in the thumbnail only Tate is rich
Define rich & rich in money, knowledge, deen? Rich in your eyes, others eyes? 🧐🤔
@@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1 have you seen the video to know what I'm talking about?
Ive been following her for a few months now .
I really enjoy watching her channel and her content. Its simple, honest and so refreshing to see Islam being practiced in such a beautiful way in Spain, Mashaallah
I agree!
I love her videos.
I am a young Muslim woman who got interested in Islam last year. I'm tired. People from all circles (Muslims and non Muslims) want to point fingers at Muslim women.
Had no clue she existed. Not my cup of tea personally but I don’t see anything wrong with her or her channel objectively. That short clip of the shisha lounge was beyond cringe. Thanks for covering this. Love the machine you’ve built in the back, the fans are mesmerizing. Keep up the good work!
Thank you!
Merci d’en parler William, j’aime beaucoup sa chaîne je la trouve apaisante. Et proche des valeurs de l’Islam.
Thank you so much 🙏🏽
Jazaka Allah kear for the share 🙏 It is always a pleasure to learn about someone new. It is indeed refreshing to see this explanation and rebirths to groups that we thought were lost with time ❤ Inshallah we too shall return as well 🙏. Arfa Mubaraka dear brothers and sisters and Eid Mubarak 🙏🌸.
Ameen and Eid Mubarak to you too
Jazak allah for letting me know about this channel - I've subscribed to her
thank you!
she is amazing
And she is just being herself
@@williambarylo there should be people like her too ,, its a refreshing content that she produce
Love the disclaimer at the beginning 😂 Great video
It's 2024 and we still need such disclaimers *sigh*
I like your approach and perspective
May Allah guide you to what is best for you and for the ummah
Thank you, Ameen
i see alot of her in myself, my mother and many of the women in my family. And we are from a totally different region; Turkiye. Although we dont wear the hijab, we never felt any less of being a muslim. We dress modestly, we love nature and music as well. We fast, pray and give charity. These are all things that are immensely more important than just wearing the hijab, or eating halal meat thats hand slaughtered versus machine slaughtered. Islam is not complicated, but people make it complicated by preaching and glorifying random rules that are poorly supported from historical context. Thank you so much for sharing her channel ❤
Maybe a bit Hudud will fix that.
Indeed, in the History of the revelation, good behaviour and helping those in need came very early compared to the ritual aspects
So basically committing tabarruj which is one of the greatest sins a vvoman can commit? Of course you're from 🇹🇷 lol.
@@enacausmembrane fix what?
@@enacausmembrane 🤣Nothing to fix. Clearly you don't know in what context to use Hudud. One can only pray for the hate in another's heart to be removed, such as yours.
Esta youtuber representa el islam del término medio, lejos de todos los excesos, en cierto modo es la cara de una España que ha abierto una nueva página con el mundo islámico y especialmente con su vecino inmediato Marruecos, por lo que ha privilegiado el equilibrio de poder cuando podemos dialogar con calma y pensar juntos en el futuro? ¡Sobre todo porque este vecino practica la gran mayoría del Islam de Paloma!
Thank you so much 🙏🏽😊
Got it. We need Ahlul Hadithé Hispania Movement.
That's a brilliant idea. For starters, let's send the best CZcams debaters to Andalusia.
@@williambarylo
Andalusia doesn't exist anymore.
Those remaining muslims are bunch of fasiq.
A mass dawah campaign is needed to fix those westernized muslims first.
@@williambarylo
Why debaters specifically? Why not daees like sheikh uthman, ‘Yani Spanish speakers of course. We don’t want the Spanish to think Islam is this watered down dilute religion.
@@enacausmembrane yes sheikh uthman is one great debater with proper qualifications
😂😂@@williambarylo
Oh dear. I have lived in the UK all my life and never once did I think you had to be rich to be a Muslim, nor do I hang around in "Shisha lounges" nor do I even like "Dubai" … there is obviously something wrong with me! My mother never wore hijab, she was the daughter of a sheikh from Al-Azhar (from the old pre-WWII days) and she is the most amazingly good Muslim. My father was a university teacher and he never made "big money". I am old now and my parents are old but I don't think I was that different (or maybe I am … I don't know). We were always taught to believe that you shouldn't judge other people by their religion or how they practice their religion. Maybe I have been taught wrongly. I hope not. I think not.
I think you're a miracle in this modern age! You were around the right people.
i know th brother mentioned the shisha lounge mybe a few times more than necessary. but take the bigger picture to understand where he's coming from - that helpful green ticks tally sheet, which many other muslim youtubers do, in fact, do.
@@williambarylo I think you are right. I suspect things have changed since I was young. I just turned 50 a few days ago and hate to think of myself as one of those rose-tinted glasses folks … I can't help thinking things are significantly worse in th modern age. (I have also seen some of your other videos and I have to say that you are an amazing fellow and I am sorry for any difficulties you have had in the UK. You to be a splendid and wonderful person.
@@aag24 thank you. I think you're right. People older than me recount times when people would invite each other at home, cook for each other, people would talk to each other in the mosque and people's ultimate car was a Toyota because it's reliable. Nowadays people of my generation find it hard to meet, mosques become utilitarian places and money (or the illusion of money) has become a priority. There are still a few places where it's possible to find the spirit of these old days, but I think modern British culture of individualism and materialism has imposed itself on many
Assalamualaikum! Thank you very much for this video. Paloma's channel is one of the best Muslim projects on CZcams. Paloma is a religious, modest and extremely wise woman. She is doing great work to popularize Islam in Europe. Her films have a lot of peace in them. My wife and I love them.
Greetings from Poland!!!
Wa alaykum salaam! Pozdrawiamy!
Thank You barakallahu fik 🙏🏽✨
Very inspirational, I’m off to her channel straightaway.
Sufism has been reason for transformations in our History, it needs revival. Where there is sufism , there will always be peace and serenity.
There is a reason sufis never give dawah and a reason why the dawah scene is dominated by salafis or athari ikhwanis which is still 10x times better than sufis . Imagine telling a non muslim that we have the purest monotheism and then telling them our prophet is from the literal light of Allah or that sufi masters have hidden knowledge. Authobillah
@@SlaveOfAllah1000 That is not what orthodox sufis believe.
Sufis come in various shapes and forms. I think that this particular image comes from its revival in Euro-America and centres of influence like Zaytuna and Cambridge Muslim College.
You make some good points. Some very good points.
However she is selling Sufism....
And whoever complains about haram police / bidda police, should remember that part of the duty of a muslim is to remind people of what is forbidden and what is good.
If you dislike people doing al wala wal bara maybe you should ask yourself why you dislike it.
Is it because you disagree with a particular ruling, or is it because you want to shape Islam according to your own desires?
I think people who dislike the haram police mostly dislike the pedagogy they use, which is often very confrontational and not prophetic at all. The Prophet (PBUH) has a particular way of educating people even with the most ignorant, like that time when someone urinated in the mosque, or that man reciting the adhan incorrectly, etc... there's a verse saying that if he was harsh, people would have turned away. It's about selecting the right approach that works for each person. Most people don't do things out of malice but often because they don't have the full knowledge about something
@@williambarylo Again, very good points, some of which I was advicing my son just yesterday (And that I should keep in mind myself)
Please keep in mind the other end of the spectrum as well.
You could call them the "Halal police", those who make everything halal.
Music = halal (If the lyrics are good).
Hugging the oposite gender = Halal (if the intention is right).
Smoking = Makruh (Essentially Halal)
And I could go on for a few hundred more lines.
With the majority of people you should be soft the absolute majority of the time, but there are exceptions to this, such as with some disbelievers and hypocrites.
@@williambarylo BTW, I enjoy your videos a lot so please do not interpret my comment as general hostility.
I especially identified with one of the videos where you talked about the heartbreak of being rejected because you are not the "right" kind/race/class of muslim.
May Allah join us in Jannah, Amin.
@@tally3018 Yes. Islam is the middle path!
@@BuffaloPros Actually looking at that upside down pentagram you have in your profile should have let me know everything I needed to know...
just another liar/manipulator, no need for me to waste my time on you.
Have u watched the documentary TRT did about their community "Resilient souls" I was genuinely surprised how much they were rooted in tradition.
I'll have a look!
Yeah you can find channels that better represent Muslims then them Dawah character channels. I'm sure a few are sincere, but a few are not, though most are a mix of both. People tend to convince themselves of the need to sellout a little here and a little there for practical reasons.
A good example from my own personal experience was when I went on hajj with a Muslim tour group who up sold their product. They made out that at Mecca we would have 3, 4 bedroom accommodation. Instead we got a 15/20 dorm room situation.
Well the pilgrims were rather upset, some rebelled and occupied some of the better private rooms hired for late comers. After things settled and the majority of the hajj was over, I got talking to the tour owner about the drama and he explained his stance.
Very nice guy, may Allah reward him with Jannah firdaws and forgive his sins. He claimed that if he didn't up sell and tell a few lies, his hajj tours wouldn't make enough to cover his costs. He believed it was necessary evil to keep the good of his hajj group going.
At the time his Hajj tours was a good deal, relatively cheap in comparison to others, offers were great and his motivations weren't money based, rather a need for survival. He was a good man, looked after his family but he was wrong here.
Very few Dawah channels will be sincere completely, but I'm sure their core intent would be good. Going to vloggers who aren't doing the dawah thing will give a better representation of Muslims for me.
That's exactly it. the problem for many dawah channels is that they rely on CZcams for income. From that point, it's hard for them to produce content they believe in VS producing content that will generate clicks. That's why Mohammed Hijab's and Ali Dawah's charitable initiatives struggle sadly.
Islam is about looking inward not outward.
Islam is about Allah Almighty and the Prophet (Peace be upon him)and connection with Allah and emulating the prophet SAW.
Criticising others is non Islamic
Not all tubers are the same
And can’t be painted with the same brush.
Best you study what Islam is about.
It is about faith not about criticising others.
Completely non Islamic.
Well said!
Underrated channel you.
thank you
Gracias 🍎
De nada
You may have to research and google, use that link for clues
No. If I want clues, I watch Scooby Doo.
For the sake of free speech, I'm gonna say that the only thing missing from her videos is YOGA sessions, preferably mixed ones, tantric ones would be best of course. I mean ... sufism is _new age spirituality_ ... they could literally adapt any religion to their "spiritual goal." It so happens that they added the word islam this time around.
She's not American lol!!
Kindly reminder Sufism has longer history than wobbler and deobandi
Большое спасибо за атмосферное видео.
I agree with your points. But I need to provide a warning for me and everyone: Deifying a human, like the Prophet even, peace he upon him is shirk, like replacing Jesus with Muhammad, some Sufis do that unfortunately. I hope they don't do that. May Allah guide us, ameen.
This is rather rare in Europe and North America
there are people with 250k subs that will never get the plaq - not everybody gets these I would assume
She got it, but she didn't boast about it
@@williambarylo ok, that is very modest then, but doesn't change the fact that people don't get those
Can you a video with pual whose channel is blogging theology he is in London same as you. He has discussions with intellectuals such as you. I enjoy our videos too.
I don't know him personally. Maybe one day if he finds this channel and finds it interesting
@@williambarylo I hope so.
Thanks! Will be subscribing to her channel 😁
yayy!
Ustadh , hamdulilah you highlighted many positive aspects of her channels and others should learn from her, its authentic and present a beautiful muslim community in a western country but please dont downplay the hijab part , all madhabs , all sunni scholars agree on the obligation of Hijab , the least you could have done is make duaa for her but saying "she may be following different madhabs/scholars implying that there is a madhab or opinion within sunni islam that allow women to show their hair is not correct
edit : im a maliki sufi from Morocco
You can't change his mind. Arguing with him will make you a hater and toxic Muslim and also sectarian filth. All we can do is pray for him.
He has a very unique and different perspective from Muslims and it's quite refreshing and educational and eye opening for me.
I have to say though both Hijab and Ali have shown sub-continental Muslims in their videos which we often don't see. Hijab even went to Bangladesh( My Country) once too.
Thank you. My comment on madhab was not referring to her hijab. Everyone is on a journey, maybe she knows about the rulings on the hijab and maybe she hasn't decided to wear it just yet but wants to wear it in the future.
@@williambarylo hamdulilah may Allah bless you
@@unknownpng650 and you too!
This is a good video.
Thank you
I hope biddah police dont find her channel . I hope her channel stays underrated
I hope too. At the same time I wonder if actually more people should see it and create similar channels, with no fear of being judged
I ❤ your y'tb channel n el canal dapaloma channel too
To Tell you the truth, I'm in love with paloma 😢😢😢
I think so many people are
Mashallah! 😊
[Con vuestro permiso, voy a expresarme en español que me resulta más fácil (perdón por las molestias de antemano).]
Soy una española que volvió al islam hace unos meses. Durante mi investigación sobre el islam los meses anteriores a hacer mi shahada, descubrí el canal de Paloma.
Como española que no conocía ningún español/a musulmán, verla en CZcams fue una ventana abierta por donde entraba un rayo de luz y esperanza✨. En ella vi el ejemplo de que se puede ser española y musulmana a la vez, que no es incompatible. ¡Ahora sé que esto es algo demasiado obvio! Pero quienes hemos crecido toda la vida en España hemos escuchado demasiadas veces que "ser español es lo contrario a ser musulmán" porque "gracias a Los Reyes Católicos en 1492 se unificó el Reino de España al derrotar el último reino musulmán nazarí de Granada (sur de Andalucía)". Cuando llevas toda la vida escuchando esto, creedme que es una lucha interna muy fuerte porque sientes que al abrazar el islam te estás enfrentando a toda tu cultura y renegando de toda tu identidad, cuando no es así del todo... El islam acepta lo bueno de cada cultura y rechaza lo que es malo (como comer cerdo, que aquí en España es bastante habitual, como el jamón ibérico que se considera "muy español", por desgracia).
Entonces, fue para mí muy hermoso ver que no era la única española que quería ser musulmana, pues sólo conocía africanos musulmanes (de Senegal -como mi marido-, Malí, Guinea, Marruecos...) o asiáticos.
Para mí, Paloma fue una inspiración...ella nunca presumió de ser "buena musulmana". Es más, yo creo que cuando empezó su canal aún no era musulmana (aunque no estoy 100% segura...o quizás estaba empezando su andadura). Si os dais cuenta, en los vídeos más recientes ya no hace retratos humanos, eso era antes. Ahora está más enfocada en editar sus videos y expresar su arte de esta manera.
Además de esto, creo que es la única persona de su familia que ha abrazado el islam por lo que es una inspiración para quienes nos debatimos con dar el paso y nos llegan pensamientos de miedo al pensar si seremos aceptados por nuestra familia... Entonces, ver todo el amor que le tiene a su padre, y cómo él la ama, es muy muy emotivo y nos da corage su ejemplo.
En momentos en los tenía muchas preocupaciones en la mente, escucharla hablar era un gran alivio. Tiene el don de transmitir mucha paz al narrar su experiencia de ir a la mezquita, sus emociones al leer alguna sura, sus momentos de servir comida a la comunidad, etc. Es más, sin ella pretenderlo, gracias a su sencillez y su forma de ser, ha inspirado a muchas personas a tomar su Shahada y hay ejemplos en su canal. Es algo digno de admirar. Y personas como ella son necesarias porque desde su humildad y dulzura, vemos que el islam no es tan difícil como parecía, sino que es una religión para todo el mundo. Y que cualquier persona puede abrazar el islam. Obviamente, los primeros pasos en el islam son como los de un bebé👶🏼 todo es nuevo y hay que ir aprendiendo. Paso a paso👣
Parece que ella se inspira en el sufismo, pero se nota que está haciendo su camino por aprender del Corán y la sunna. Es impresionante destacar su esfuerzo y dedicación. Incluso veo que practica más el islam que muchos musulmanes de nacimiento que he conocido.
¡Simplemente le estoy muy agradecida! 💜 Que Allah le bendiga y le guíe. Y que nos guíe a todos por el camino recto, in-sha-Allah🤲🏽 Muchas bendiciones para tu canal, Dr William, haces una gran labor! De nuevo, Mashallah!😊
¡muchas gracias! ¡Tiene una forma original de transmitir el Islam en CZcams!
What is the spinning wheel device behind you. Is it a PC?
Yes it's my desktop
I love that channel..
Andalusia is a lovely place
What is this pc setup??!?!
It's just an open frame design
🤎Eid Al-ad'ha Mubarak🤎 (Blessed the great Sacrifice of the Prophet Abraham commemoration feast)
May Allah Almighty extend your life to witness it again and again, and give you a good health and prosperity, and forgive your shortcomings, and grants you access to his Gardens in the hearafter, Ameen.
Ameen and to you too
Why everyone is her fanboy here? She is not even doing proper hijab....
May Allahguide us All
That's because people understand that everyone is on a journey and telling people what to do/not what to do actually drives people out of Islam
ماشاءاللہ ، محترم بہن پلومہ کی ہر ویڈیو میں دین اسلام سے محبت پائ جاتی ہے اور ان کی ویڈیو ز دیکھ کر ایمان تازہ ہوتا ہے۔ وہ غرناطہ میں موجود مسلمانوں کی دین اسلام سے محبت اور کھانے پینے اور باحیا لباس اور عبادات کے طور طریقے بہت پیارے انداز میں پیش کرتی ہیں ان کا تسبیحات پڑھنا الحمدللہ ، بسم اللہ الرحمٰن پڑھنا اور خوشخطی میں نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے اسم گرامی کو بہت خوب صورتی سے لکھنا اور ان کی نعت پڑھنا اور قرآن کریم سکھانا اور نمازی دکھانا مختصر یہ کہ انہوں نے ہر ویڈیو میں شرافت اور اسلامی تعلیمات کو ظاہر کیا ہے ۔ ڈر ہے کہ مسلم دنیا میں بڑھتا ہؤا بیحیائ اور بے دینی کا طوفان غرناطہ کے باحیاء اور نیک مسلمانوں کو متاثر نہ کر دے اللہ پاک ان کو دین اسلام پر استقامت دے
👍🤲☝️❤️
🐈🐑🐔 🇪🇸
Lovely mashallah
Assalamu alaykum sir William, I am writing you this comment in hopes of you reading it and perhaps reconsidering your stance on the situation.
Now, let me start off by saying that the way many Muslims react when they see channels like Paloma's (i.e. not full hijab, music, etc.) is unacceptable; not only does this behaviour deter people away from Islam, which can make them be held accountable (and Allah knows best), but it is not how the prophet peace be upon him would ever speak to another Muslim, no matter how "un-islamic" they might be. Yes, he would get angry at times, but only at the right time and in the right place (e.g. when someone makes a major mistake).
Furthermore, I've come across your channel through your video "the social hierarchy of Muslim converts", I thought it was a great work, and I can see how you have integrated the idea of that video into this one, many Muslims unfortunately have this attitude of "wrong Muslim" and "right Muslim", they fail to understand that "Muslim is Muslim" (unless they're very clearly deviants but you can spot those very easily thankfully), and that we're supposed to bring Muslims closer together, not divide them even further through race, religiousness, or any other factor, ESPECIALLY in our time where the Ummah has never been this divided before. So all in all, I think you deliver a great message that a lot of Muslims need to hear nowadays, and I personally thank you for this.
Now with all this being said, to present Palona's content of revealing her hair, including music etc. as perfectly acceptable, is problematic as well, because remember what I said earlier? Our job is to bring Muslims closer together, but to what exactly? To Islam itself, of course, the religion of Allah! And what does Islam teach us? To avoid musical instruments, drawing humans (I'll say drawing is disputed but the most authentic opinion is it should be avoided), spare our beards (i.e. not shave them), but more importantly, protect our modesty! Guard ourselves, especially our sisters by covering up their hair, treating their bodies as valueable treasures, not as a cheap product for any man to see, and to seperate herself from the non-muslim woman, who does not look after her modesty or dignity and holds herself for a cheap price, this is how we tell apart the Muslimah from the Kafirah, our sisters cherish themselves, they dignify themselves. So with all due respect mr. Barylo, when you present Palona's uncovered hair as if it's no problem at all, you are also in a way deterring people away from Islam, not through faith of course, but through practice. I don't know what your intentions are, and I'm not going to speculate over them, but it would be kind of you to at least include a small heads up like "note: I am not saying it's okay for women to not cover themselves, but the hatred people are directing at her is unacceptable". For all you know, maybe a sister who's trying to wear her Hijab watches your video and uses it as an excuse not to do so.
So with that being said, please brother, let us all practice and preach Islam as the prophet peace be upon him practiced and preached it, and let there be no division between us like the West with their radicalized left and right wing, let us all come back to the religion of Islam, a religion meant to be moderate, neither strict nor loose, a religion meant to bring peace and harmony to people.
May Allah guide us
I guess you didn't pay attention to the trigger warning at the start of the video.
It is not my job to tell people what to do and what not to do, I'm not a theologian or a jurist. I'm here to analyse what people are doing. There are many different fiqh opinions about music and covering the hair. Also, as a new Muslim, she is on a journey. Maybe she wants to wear hijab but she is not ready yet.
@@elif9124 I did notice it, but it felt like it was pre-emptively mocking people who thought what I thought, rather than saying "I'm not saying these things are okay but you need to hear me out"
@@williambarylo you are neither a theologian nor a jurist, I am well aware of that and I respect you for not wanting to dive into the fiqh of things, if someone doesn't know, then they shouldn't speak up, and that's fine. But respectfully, if you're going to tell the people who attacked her to quit their toxicity, then you also need to talk about the other side of the issue, you can't just criticize one side and leave out the other. Influencer or not, every Muslim is obligated to remind others when they do evil and encourage them to do good and you did the former, so why not the latter? I'm not asking you to give a full detailed explanation on the matters, just speak common sense, like for example how not a single one of the four madhaheb said it's permissible to show a woman's hair, you don't need to study Fiqh to know this, it takes a minute to look up. You especially can't say the sentence "maybe she's following a different Madhhab or scholar" without acknowledging that pretty much all of them have agreed upon Hijab being a must, I really respect your approach to this situation and I don't want to discourage you or be rude to you in any shape or form, I just think your presentation was a bit biased regarding this case, though this is in the end just my opinion, if you think it's not your buisness to remind people of the Haram (as much as I and most scholars disagree), then I respect your opinion and will not further bother you.
May Allah guide us all to the straight path.
May Allah bless you and reward you for the manners you've portrayed in these comments. May Allah guide us all.
Leave sufi communities for sufis, there are such in the u.k. too but you choose to compare paloma with aisha rosalie or others who have zero creativity
Who is Aisha Rosalie?
@@williambarylo blocking theology recommends her as role modell for reverts
Que dios te bendiga Paloma ❤
Oh All mighty Allah 😭😭😭. Please give this people knowledge. This people gonna destroy my religion 😭😭😭
Comment moved to the "Hijra to Saudi" discussion thread
Are you jealous, mate? Focus on yourself.
Hey it's my job to analyse society. That's what brings me food on the table.
Love her videos, she's an inspiration. You're deluded
Yes, I love her channel!
Sir, isn’t your title click bait also. Are you not trying to grow your subscription base as all CZcamsrs do ? And your ‘trigger warning’ indicates you have had some negative experience of Muslims which is unfortunate but now you have a chip on your shoulder.
Indeed! My real life job is to challenge ideas. If you have experience with kids and students, for people to be receptive, one needs to catch people's attention. And sadly, too many of my friends and family have had harmful experiences with other Muslims. If it was people being honest saying that they don't respect religion, I think it would be fine. In France, you have Muslim drug dealers but they are honest they act against Islam. In the UK, lots of people justify their harmful behaviour with religion or pretend to be religious. If we want a better Ummah, we need to address these issues. Elon Musk once said: "it's better to have a chip in your brain than on your shoulder". I think he's wrong. Chips don't belong in the brain or on the shoulder, they need to be eaten.
No matter how many positive comments she and her channels get - Islam has nothing to do with desires or views of lunatic and culture oriented individuals.
Islam is the culture that has its own pillars and borders and these are immovable and finalized.
Allah had decided WHAT IS our religion and HOW it must be followed, and even decided which differences are allowed, and He sent his beautiful messenger Muhammad and aided him with his beautiful companions - Allah, by their lives and examples, had shown us how Islam must be followed the best way possible - and that's the only way and example we muslims look for to.
All other ways are in hell, no matter what people call them and how people describe them, so it is better for everyone to constantly pure and correct their faith and lifes, which means constantly compare their path with path of Muhammad and his companions, and correct our religion while we can and death isn't standing in doorsteps of our lives.
May Allah cover every sincere human and jinn with his mercy, and His mercy is the grandest and He forgives those who ask forgiveness and correct their lives, and make it easier to follow the path that he decided for muslims and make all other non-muslim paths worthless and needles.
Our Lord make it easier for us to obey You in hearts, words and deeds the way You decided to us and make all other ways of no need.
Protect us from all sects, blasphemy and heresies no matter how they look and what they contained of.
la ilaha illallah muhammadur rasulullah - there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is His messenger.
la hawla wala quwwata illa billah - There is no power and no strength except with God.
inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un - Indeed, we belong to Allah, and indeed, to Him we return.
All bida'h leads to perdition and to hell. (bidʿah, in Islam, any innovation that has no roots in the traditional practice (Sunnah) of the Muslim community)
Exactly, maybe she follows very specific jurisprudence opinions
From a salafi household, but she seems charming.
I think she's so different from what the internet has to offer nowadays. She just seems so in love with Islam
Music
No Hijab
Sufism
Freemixing
Ticking all the boxes to bring as much misrepresentation of islam.
Not hating on her, just saying, she would have been LASHED many times had she (and these people) lived in Caliph AbuBakr's or Umar's times.
When was somebody lashed for listening to Music?
@@alijahalilovic32
It’s really every single they did in combination. It’s not just her. Even my people (Al-Hind) would also get lashed for even worse. Very sad.😔
When I see something I don't agree with, I remember the story when a man came drunk and urinated in the mosque at the time of the Prophet; or when made mistakes when reciting the adhan. People are on a journey and learn constantly; when they make mistakes, it's about finding the right approach to correct them. To make things more complicated, there are different rulings regarding music, covering of the hair or freemixing in public spaces. For example, she hasn't mentioned whether she wants to wear the hijab at some point and working towards it, or if she follows a particular religious opinion.
You're an intellectual eunuch. Go back to sleep
@enacausemembrane you seem to have an obsession with violence and causing harm to others. I already saw your hateful reply to my comment. Claim and call whoever and whatever a misrepresentation of Islam. Others will do the same to you and say you're a misrepresentation as well. Allah swt knows best.
The blind leading the blind. The misguidance is great. I hope you and her repent to Allaah.
Everyone needs to repent
Dear brother, the reason you find the majority of muslim influencers on the offense, or quite different to Paloma, lies in the inherrent fear with which most of us are brought up, as subjects of the colonizers, who branded their marks in our minds and culture. We are not used to a life that explores nature to see the print of Allah in it. So how can we not be slaves.
Spot on!
👍