What's My Line? - Joan Crawford; Tony Randall [panel] (Oct 14, 1962)
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 12. 2017
- NOTE: This is a repost of an episode that CZcams inexplicably removed due to "inappropriate content", without even sending a notice when the video was deleted. What could even conceivably have been judged by anyone as inappropriate content in a 1962 episode of What's My Line is anyone's guess, but there's no apparent way to appeal it, so I'm just re-uploading the video. Hopefully this won't get removed again.
MYSTERY GUEST: Joan Crawford
PANEL: Dorothy Kilgallen, Tony Randall, Arlene Francis, Bennett Cerf
---------------------------
Please click here to subscribe to the WML channel if you haven't already-- you'll find the complete CBS series already posted, and you'll be able to get notifications of new video posts: / @whatsmyline
Join our Facebook group for WML-- great discussions, photos, etc, and great people! / 728471287199862 - Zábava
![What's My Line? - Edith Young & Phyllis Cerf; Joan Crawford; Peter Ustinov [panel] (Dec 8, 1957)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V_W37pXavkY/mqdefault.jpg)
![What's My Line? - Edith Young & Phyllis Cerf; Joan Crawford; Peter Ustinov [panel] (Dec 8, 1957)](/img/tr.png)
![What's My Line? - Vaughn Meader; Martin Gabel [panel] (Dec 30, 1962) [UPGRADE!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mFL2Xn0uaro/mqdefault.jpg)
This is one of the cleanest, most wholesome shows a person can show. Such almost unspeakable CLASS. This was America's Finest Hour. Never again will we live like this again.
Hi Chris, you’ve said it all. So true.
if they revived this show today, the guest would come out twerking in a sequin thong and her line would be that she led a twitter campaign to cancel a problematic actor.
@@chunkysocks8121 With purple hair and tattoos head to foot.
Assail your ears when Groucho Marx was on, but even his material was fairly calm.
Absolutely. Interesting that the Cuban missile crisis was imminent.
“Is your picture about a prize fighter?”
“Yes,” said Joan, referring to Bette Davis.
You can see why Dorothy was such a good journalist. She is so smart and knows what questions to ask almost instinctively.
Exactly.
Young Henry Makow continued to write his advice column until 1964, then continued his career as a freelance writer afterwards. In the mid '80s he designed the card game "Scruples," and today he seems to publish books about conspiracy theories.
I think I know why this episode was once pulled by CZcams. I just read an article by Mr Makow and a synopsis of one book. It is the Illuminati-- Rothschild--Free Masonry--Globalist conspiracy stuff recycled. Mr Makow may be on a list that CZcams will automatically flag.
Only 13 days earlier, Joan Crawford was one of the first guests on Johnny Carson's opening night as permanent host of "The Tonight Show" on NBC.
Ah!! I sure wish we could go back to those days!! I remember watching this show with my grandmother when I was just a little girl!!
Every single one of the players, the host, and the contestants are SO classy and respectful of others! Their use of eloquent, refined conversation seems to exist no more. The ladies are absolutely beautiful and dress so lovely and tastefully. What happened to society?!?!?! It breaks my heart!!
The best response to your question is for everyone to read one of the classic books on the decline of the Roman Empire, or the Greek, such as : “The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire” by Gibbon; 2. “Our Ancient Heritage,” by Durant ; “Caeser and Christ,” also by Durant. There are others. Our time is very different technologically, but socially there are many parallels. Thus it goes with all Empires. The American Empire is more an economic empire, or has been. But we *do* even have possessions. We still have much to learn.
Arlene was wearing a gorgeous dress tonight. I wish we could have seen it in color. Love this show and wish the panel and most of the mystery guests were still alive today
Tony was a great player. Took it as seriously as Dorothy
Yeah, not casting time like most of the fill-ins do.
And he was often funny too.
What could possibly be unsuitable or such with this show? Class acts. Such a young man with a column! Hope he went far in life!
i LOVE john daly"s "clarifications'!!!...
those beautifully erudite, concise and extremely FLUENT rantings of his.
instantly conceived and absolutely accurate.....99% of the time...always delicious!
haha yes. Daly has to toe a narrow line. He has to clarify & express the position,without giving anything away. He was a great host!
genius mchaggis Most of the time they're brilliant. Some times they can be rather indulgent though and you do get a bit tired of his voice.
@@davidsanderson5918 yes its true...they are "east coast" intellectuals after all and they rarely let you forget it...i DO love JD for his pure scholarly nature...and his charm of course.
Not rants
@@geniusmchaggis yep, a fine Irish boy!
I absolutely enjoyed the personality and the obvious enjoyment that the race track announcer had. You could really tell by her mannerisms that she certainly enjoyed beating the panel!
I believe Arlene was filming” The Thrill of It All” with Doris Day & James Garner . Loved that movie & love WML ❤️
Even in 1962 Joan Crawford was one of the biggest stars on the planet ... and had been since OUR DANCING DAUGHTERS in 1928. We just don't have many stars like this any more.
drednm Thank God
Fun Fact: This episode aired the day the Cuban Missile Crisis began.
John even mentions the USSR in passing (in regards to the Space Race)!
Did the public know about it prior to Kennedy's addres on the 22nd though? In which case it's not until the 28th when we have a show broadcast while they know about it.
They certainly seem blissfully unaware here.
@That Guy You Hate - October 16 through the 28th. I remember because my father was placed on 12-hour call to report for naval duty and couldn't say where or what. I was a teenager whose birthday fell within that time frame.
Wow!
Oh, I enjoyed this episode so much! Arlene was making The Thrill of it All with Doris Day...my favorite Day movie!
The young man from Canada was adorable, he wanted to continue his conversation with Dorothy. I hope she took some time with him afterwards. It's always a great episode when Tony Randall is on. He is a great player of the game and such a fantastic guy (actor too!)!!! ❤️
I have to add that to see Mr Randall, stand & applaud Miss Crawford as she exited, made me love him even more! ❤️❤️❤️
Karen,
Google Henry .( the first guest)
He is an author and has written many books.
He's well into his 790s now
His intelligence is so obvious in this video .Even as a kid.
Had to look him up
And yes Karen,
Tony was my favorite too along with Dorothy
Only watch episodes with her in it.
Arlene was playing a pregnant woman in that film, at age 54, which was part of the gag. It was a wonderful film with great Jimmy Garner-Doris Day chemistry. You got me thinking, what was my favorite Doris movie. It's hard to say because like Joan, Doris was part of our lives, gave us so many hours of great entertainment over the years, each very different but both national treasures.
@@akrenwinkle It was not believable her being pregnant and she looked old and frumpy in it ---always looked stunning on WMl
So cool to see the legendary Joan Crawford ! Not only a great actress but a great businesswoman !!!
Harry looks and sounds wise beyond his years....and Arlene is so witty as usual! "Now we've got a jockey!"
I love the fact that Daily actually gave a hint to Arlene on the first contestant!
Yes, he'd do that now and then. And the more he could turn that hint into a pun, the more delicious it was!
“First time I ever heard of a filly calling a race”, unparalleled wit and charm has she...
I think she was just horsing around..
So fun to see Joan on this wonderful program!! ❤️💐
I never realized how pretty Arlene Francis was when she smiled. Love “What’s My Line”!
Good television. Brilliant panel. Perfect host.
I wish we would go back to wearing gloves. So classy. I had them when I was a little girl.
gloves are cool...
YOU should start a new trend!
i can see it now...
"message gloves"
gloves with graphics...YOU can do it girl!
Me too..... have some now still wear.....
Wow u old
Girdles too!
Way too hot where I live. People would have suffered a lot in a tropical climate. So I'm glad we don't.
Many people were distressed by Dorothy's death. According to wikipedia, Joan Crawford was particularly devastated, as they were very close.
Joan Crawford says, correctly, "Between Betty and me," using the objective case. Too many people would say, incorrectly, "between Betty and I." I am not surprised such a talented and erudite artist would use correct grammar.
YES! I teach English and so often students try to argue that it is, in fact, "between you and I". No, no, no!
An easy way to know is to reverse the Betty and me. You wouldn't say, between I and Betty
@@johnloudaros800 good idea but wrong example. Replace "Betty and me" with us or we. "Between we" doesn't work. It would be "between us".
How can you mistake Joan Crawford's voice, even when she tries to disguise it?
Crawford was a stunning talent.
No wire hangers! EVER!!!
Well!
We now know that Mr. Randall was an ENORMOUS Joan Crawford fan! LOL
Gosh, I wonder why.
Joan must have loved this show she was on it a lot
That generation is sorely missed today. What class they had. That generation is one of America's trophies. Life was lovely to them.
Yes, Jim Crow laws were very classy.
@@ethanedwards7557 Is that the only thing you can think about? And, miss all the rest? Look how we are now without celebrities having class. Its not going to get better. There is going to be a new kind of segregation. Your attitude will approve.
@@ethanedwards7557 Today the Jim Crows are the socialist democrats. They still have no class.
Class was for show my dear. Fake class.
@@ethanedwards7557 Just as classy as demanding government funded abortions? And, many running around not knowing what sex they are? Come back when you're ready to know who you are.
I was and still am in love with mr. RANDALL..
Henry, "if the parents are okay, the kids will be okay too". what wisdom and truth!
Congratulations and good luck on your book about what's my line and hope that it becomes a big hit
Two weeks earlier, WML had a challenger who sold hot dogs at Yankee Stadium. It was the last day of the regular season. On the day this aired, the World Series still had not been completed. The field was still unplayable due to continued rain at Candlestick Park (as opposed to the tactic that Giants manager Al Dark used to try to slow down the Dodgers Maury Wills and his base running exploits, on his way to become the first player in "modern times" to steal over 100 bases in a season: he flooded the base path for the first few steps between first and second base).
The World Series finally resumed on Monday, October 15 with a Giants victory to even the series at 3 wins apiece. The Yankees won Game 7, 1-0 with Ralph Terry (the goat of the 1960 series) outdueling Jack Sanford. Terry was almost the goat again. In the bottom of the ninth after Matty Alou bunted for a base hit, Willie Mays hit a two-out double to right and only a great throw by Roger Maris kept Alou from scoring. Willie McCovey then blasted a wicked line drive that would have brought home at least the tying run, but with Mays great speed possibly the winning run as well. However, it was hit straight at Yankee second baseman Bobby Richardson who managed to hold on to the ball and seal the victory. McCovey has said that it was the hardest ball he ever hit in his career. czcams.com/video/FZ4o7PVdWFU/video.html
The event spawned two iconic "Peanuts" cartoons by Charles Schulz, one that appeared about two months later; the other about a month after that. Schulz, a transplanted resident of Northern California had been hoping for a Giants victory and showed his anguish through his alter ego, Charlie Brown, that the Giants had come so close and fell short.
giantspologrounds.wordpress.com/2013/04/18/was-charlie-brown-wrong-about-the-1962-world-series/
As for me, a die hard Dodgers fan, I hoped it would keep raining so long in San Francisco that they would eventually cancel the World Series and neither team would win. But I had my moment of satisfaction the following season when the Dodgers swept the Yankees in the World Series.
Great entertainment! Used to watch with my mom and dad as a child in the fifties!
Perhaps one of the most entertaining and charming ones!
It would have been interesting to know what young Henry discussed with Dorothy as he exited the stage. Dorothy was amused enough that you see her lean over to mention it to the rest of the panel...
Probably something along the lines of “I hope one day to have as many syndicated papers carrying my column as you have.”
Thanks for reposting , to remove any of the WML shows is like an act of vandalism.
It’s because the 12 year old kid became an “anti Semite” even though he’s Jewish, when he turned 50.
@Jeff, the God of Biscuits No, not a kook, just thinks outside the box the mainstream media has been imposing on people. The mainstream media could be said to be guilty of producing people who act like "kooks" fhouvh, because they will believe, without verification, anything those 6 corporations tell them. www.businessinsider.com/these-6-corporations-control-90-of-the-media-in-america-2012-6?op=1
Even when it has the wicked Joan Crawford?
I think his adult writing probably caused CZcams to flag this episode, if his name is associated with it. He spins the kind of conspiracy yarns that social media likes to censor.
I loved seeing Dorothy spend time with the young columnist. I rarely saw her spend that much time with a contestant as they were leaving.
I don't care what anyone says, Joan Crawford was one of the greatest actress of her time. Mildred Pierce was brilliant. I love Joan Crawford.
What happen to decent people.? We need them back on television.
I'd like to know too.
You have the Kardashians. What more do you want?
@@SymphonyBrahms ikr lol
pathetic
@@SymphonyBrahms gag
I smiled the whole time watching everyone. Such intriguing and talented guests and an incredible panel. My mom always tuned in and she bought all of the Kellogg cereals for us as kids as treats!
I really love to hear Dorothy's laugh and Arlene's voice. Arlene looks just like Jennifer Aniston when she laughs.
What an insult to Arlene in my opinion
It's always worth watching an episode of WML, even again as a repost. Thank you!
Glad you enjoyed it, lori lori-- thanks for leaving the comment!
What's My Line? As a Canadian viewer, it was delightful seeing a 12 year old Canadian prodigy. Loved his incisive reply to Bennet Cerf's question. ☺Thanks for posting!
That youngsters answer to Bennett question, "if the parents are okay, the kids will be okay too" is so dead on!
Time really wears on some people. That kid Henry Makow is now a 71 year old conspiracy nut and most of his writing career is around pretty much all of the conspiracies.
@@LightningSt0rmConspiracy "theories" + time = FACT, MANY times, whether you like it or not.
It's funny to see how quickly Joan changed the subject away from Bette Davis
Not if you understand the backstory.
@@TheCometHunter 21:30
@@TheCometHunter yes !
I am loving this show
I love this show and the clips and the just nature of it all . Such a refined presentation for a show .
"RIGHT ON THE TRACK" ANOTHER GREAT PUN.
Alas, the panel still finished out of the money.
"Whatever Happened To Baby Jane" -- one of both Joan's and Betty's best films.
Joan Crawford, what a class act to kiss the panel.
Joan Crawford 😍😍😍😍
You don't miss a thing, do you?.
Been following Henry Makow for years and have a learnt a great deal from him. A noble man of truth and compassion. He has a website by his name that should be everyone's frequent read.
He's Qanon.
@@2dance4Ulife no silly.
I love some of the words they use such as “informational”
I love Arlene's reaction at 13:48 she didn't expect that answer
Dorothy was a rare person
Joan doesn’t seem mean at all. I love watching these shows that happened before I was born.
I have watched a lot of these and cannot believe it was before I was born and to me I have got to know these people and it is as if they were still alive
I love hearing Miss Crawford's voice and I was so glad she said Bette and 'me' correctly instead of 'I' as so many people do because they think it sounds posh....She always spoke impeccably.
I noticed that Henry spoke to Dorothy the longest lol. I’m sure she gave him some good advice on his column as she was a newspaper lady herself 😎
Who knows for sure what was discussed between them. I can only surmise that it was columnist talk.
He turned into a Q-conspiricist.
And she didn't even wince when John said "Bette Davis." 😁
i was born in the 80s, but i relate more to this era of television than the trash today. i wish celebrities still had class.
3 days before my second birthday!🎉 not old enough to appreciate it at the time. Loving it now in my 60s.
It’s fun to watch these old shows and see contestants from my home state... Louisiana
"what ever happened to baby Jane " movie terrified me. I like knowing Joan Crawford went on to Pepsi cola jam. ✌️
It's one of my favorite movies.
Dorothy Kilgallen introduced Tony Randall as having just returned from Greece where he made Not on Your Life. It was retitled Island of Love for its 1963 release.
At the end he announces he is off to Paris to make a film entitled The Impatient Husband. Apparently never made, but I could be missing something that may have been retitled/released later ?
I found an old 1962 issue of Boxoffice online which referred to "The Impatient Husband" co-starring Lilo Pulver and being directed by Jack Arnold. I agree it was never made, although Pulver was in Arnold's 1964 film "A Global Affair" with Bob Hope. Don't think it's related however.
Here's the issue, page W3: www.yumpu.com/en/document/read/27362323/boxoffice-october011962
Very "industry" but interesting!
Thanks, I tried to look that up and couldn't find it under Not On Your Life. .
I could recognise Miss Crawford even if blind-folded. Sorry but I am one of her urdent fan.
Tony seemed to have an affection for Dorothy. Nice to see when she got so many put-downs. Maybe she wrote nice things about him.
That boy was awful cute. A young gentlemen.
Too bad that kid grew up to be a woman-hating, anti-Semitic conspiracy theorist: rationalwiki.org/wiki/Henry_Makow
Mars Magenta quit spamming this reply to two year old comments you fat bitch. Nobody cares, and Jem and The Holograms was a terrible cartoon.
@liberty Ann - Tony Randall was a cultured gentleman. He was properly brought up, married for 50 years to his first wife until her death, and he lived his life with a measure of circumspection to help prevent being typecast and to keep his slate clean. He and his wife were friends with people like Eva Marie Saint and her theater director husband who were also married forever and lived a decent family life in NYC. He did not hobnob in private with those whose private lives were sloppy and all over the gossip columns. He knew full well what Dorothy wrote in her column and crime reportage plus the tragedy her marriage was correctly rumored to be. He gave her no reason to write anything nasty about him. But he could also appreciate her game-playing skills, crime journalism, and probably pity her for the horrors of her family life, when she could be priggish. What impressed me about this episode was that she showed a real interest in the young columnist either to show a sort of professional appreciation or perhaps she got some information from him so that she could recommend him to King World for possible publication in their newspapers, as a unique column, differing from hers.
@blah blah He never said much about his private life, which is probably how he and his circle of friends stayed happily married in a weird business. He once said in his memoir about unusual show biz experiences he'd had that he and his wife had not been blessed with children and nothing further. I assume when he married again about 7 years after her death that he and his second wife could have children and he had the money to provide for them, so they went ahead and had a family. I admire that he never really spoke of this to make his first wife feel badly if she was the reason for that. They seem to have been happy with one another. For some that is enough.
love it. thanks
After watching episodes of Feud, a show about the professional & personal feud between Betty Davis and Joan Crawford, I am more interested in Ms Crawford. Her hair color is fascinating too, so unusual.
People really did worship movie actors in those days
It's such a tragedy that JC was smeared by her ungrateful daughter Christina in that horrific movie "Mommy Dearest". The wire hanger scene still gives me nightmares.
How do the second guy get so far along in guessing the kid was a writer so fast? It's so unusual it's crazy he could do it.
Nice Job, Henry! I see you had good smarts and thinking that has served you well!
@Jeff, the God of Biscuits
I was surprised to learn that too, when checking "Ask Henry" on Google. And then I saw he invented the game "Scruples" as well in the 1980s. Interesting dude, in any case, currently age 71.
@Jeff, the God of Biscuits Even more so a year later. He didn't turn out to be "my kind of guy," for sure.
He became Qanon.
Tony's question cited the opening of Requiem For A Heavyweight a few days later. A movie "about a prizefighter", he said.
Obviously the panel does not watch I've Got a Secret because that same kid was on that show a couple of years earlier.
Brad Torville Just manners unlike today
Dorothy introduces Tony Randall as just returning from Greece having just completed the picture 'Not on Your Life". I can find no such movie anywhere.
WOW, HENRY MAKOW !!! 🙏🧠💪💚
Joan Crawford was "Auntie Mame" ;-)
Forrest Tucker fell off the cliff,... and the little boy, (who's now a younger married).
Born today in 1903: 5'3" actress Joan Crawford.
Trog is an underrated movie. Love it!
Both ladies on this show are very pretty , and continued to stay beautiful through out the years.
Each panellist appears each week from behind the curtain and acknowledges the audience, face on, with a smile or a bow or both. Daly appears and he ONLY acknowledges the panel.
Strange how certain things on WML ie each regular member's foibles, habits and manners, become of note to each of us watching.
Thank you for re-posting! Wondered what the deal was the first time around, after watching it I have no clue.
Henry Makow is the 12 year old guest. He’s an ANNISEMITE OY VEY
Joan Crawford was so nice! What a shame they portrayed her as the devil in Mommie Dearest and Feud;Bette and Joan. God bless
“Inappropriate” is in the eye of the beholder
Note that the panelists speak in modified British English....NYEW instead of Noo! LOL. I think it was called "Middle Atlantic English" back in the day.
Henry makow went on to get a doctorate in philosophy. He has a website.
Henry Makow has an interesting website.
I was looking for this comment. Interesting turn that man took
I completely agree with wondering why in the world would they have EVER removed it in the 1st place. That was 1962 where they didn't cancel the culture. Nothing inappropriate here whatsoever!
congratulations on 36,000 followers on this series
DK referred to the movie title "Not On Your Life." It appears it became "Island of Love," based on its being set in Greece. It did not do well.
wow!
Google henry Makow,
He was a well known writer about The New World Order
It's amazing to see theses people as children
He's well into his 70's now
WOw!! Henry Makow!!
That kid invented the game Scruples.
oh, cmon! How neat! awww. He'd be 69 yrs old now.
And he grew up to be quite... a character. rationalwiki.org/wiki/Henry_Makow
@@marnie0512 If by "character" you mean a woman-hating, anti-Semitic conspiracy theorist. Yikes!
WELL, he was smart.
Im glad Bennett explained what Runaway productions were.
Runaway. Only the beginning of the trend of everything done here in the US: from manufacturing, to steel production, journalism and all things tech.
No wire hangers!
I wish Joan would have whipped one out!
Interested fact about runaway production, Bennett Cerrff gave
The people back then were so smart.
Might have been removed because of Henry Makow.
He was 12 at the time, he didn’t become “anti Semitic” until he was like 50.
CZcams is a pain in the Arse
Indeed it is.
Randy Sherry At times?
LOLOL......you're JUST realizing this, well, 5 months after the time of MY comment???
Randy Sherry than don't watch