Toheed Par Umari Molviyon ko Jawab | Hassan Allahyari Urdu | shia vs sunni | shia sunni differences
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 01. 2023
- To Support Allahyari:
abtv.org/en/?page_id=639
paypal.me/ABTV
/ allahyari
bit.ly/3bX6VJs
For Further Information On How To Donate Email: paypal@abtv.org
Hassan Allahyari Direct Contact Information:
info@abtv.org
wa.me/+19177832536
To Schedule a Call During Live Show Please Contact:
Brother Jafar Ali Kazmi: Operators Available
wa.me/+17187101138
Short Clips Channel: / @allahyariclips
Zindabad MOLA ALI AS apko slamat rkhy 💗👍
اللہ آپکو سلامت رکھے۔۔ حق پر قائم رکھے اور حق بیان کرتے رھیں۔
ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب،خدا لمبی عمر عطا فرما ئےالھم صل علی محمد و آل محمد
100 sy zayada wahabi chanel shiat ki takfeer karty thay sirf ap hain jo jawabat daity ho on ko, hum ap sy bohat khush hain r tamam momono sy youtuber, vlogers sy guzarish karty hain k ap ko mazboot karny main ap ka sath dain.
Moula Imam e Zamana ap sy razi ho Ameen
Mola Qaim A.s
ZAHOOR Farmaaae.....
Apko Abad rakhen
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.
در پناہ امام زمان علیہ السلام با شی
Looking at this day and age when Dearest Hassan Allahyari Sahab has led a marvelous defense and offense like the historic Islamic warrior or shall we knight him by calling him a Knight, we notice how far he has amazingly come. Similarly, his evolution of bringing proofs upon proofs is truly commendable. One of the major driving forces behind this is his immeasurable love for the Prophet of Islam PBUHAHP and his progeny. It makes you think about the wonder of how he has challenged the scholars of this era openly and how he is proving to be a boon in the lives of all Muslims both Shia, Sunni and others, even non-muslims. Most importantly, he has recorded a great number of lectures on his website which all seekers of truest knowledge can go to and listen to at their leisure and must ponder over in solitude. All the advancements that he has made in his popularity, which is by no means is his aim, is through the original Arabic sources and books of the opposing parties that he quotes at every opportunity. It won’t be wrong to say that he has now created a storm, a tsunami if you will, and if once, a seeker of knowledge gets to listen to his lectures and/or his youtube sessions with scholars of opposing sects, he or she is bound to be glued to watch him over and over again. His presence on youtube comes with its own set of advantages for truest seekers of the absolute truth about Islam and its teachings and disadvantages for all the opposing sects who are in deep waters now wondering how the people they have revered and looked up for so long over the centuries could possibly hold ill-feelings about the Ahlul Bayt. But it happens to be in their most prestigious books and that too with the righteous chain of narrators according to them so there is really not much room for them to argue. It is amazing that once they do find out they seem very disturbed and perturbed. I guess anyone in that situation is bound to be in extreme discomfort. Allahyari Sahab's mastery over Arabic and Persian in translating things as and when he reads them in sync is a treat to watch. I guess for a person who has challenged scholars of his time, young and old, from all sects including Shiism, if once a caller is answered adequately, the listener must then stop the argument and say goodbye. Asking unnecessary details and restating and repeating the question with contrary to intelligence shade of meanings makes the integrity of the caller weaker by the minute. And then it becomes a matter of personal pride and integrity in proving his or her intelligence as the caller knows the entire Internet audience is watching and listening whenever this particular video session is seen, they will be introduced to the world too. If it were up to me, I would recommend only people with a mastery of Arabic and knowledge of all the most eminent books in Shia and Sunni Islam to bother to make a call to argue at all with Hassan Allahyari Sahab. Those who are not knowledgeable can call and ask non-arguable questions, but if they want to argue they must be adequately knowledgeable about the fact. Hassan Allhyari Sahab responds with a couple of proofs to certain queries. But those who listen to his lectures know that for certain queries he has an abundance of references which he cannot show in the limited time. To many queries in a particular video session we have seen that he has responded through a particular set of authentic narrations but in his many other lectures we have seen yet many more additional sets of authentic narrations he has quoted at those times which he did not or could not mention, due to shortage of time probably, in this particular session of queries. If he brings all the existing narrative evidence from all books then each question's answer will take half hour or so if not longer. I advise and highly recommend all callers to first visit his website where he has recorded a ton of lectures for all to watch. If after watching and then subsequently double and triple checking on their end through books and sources in their own sect that he mentioned, one comes up with a set of queries about a particular topic, only then take the time out to call him in person. Most of what people ask has already been answered in his video lectures on his website. And remember he spares no one, not even Shias.
Thankyou Hassan Allahyari Sahab for providing us the greatest wealth in explaining the truest teachings of Islam.
Is there anybody else out there to counter this scholar who shows and justifies everything through authentic Arabic sources.
Everybody who comes to Allahyari Sahab's channel must think of one thing deeply with mind and heart. He is out there to set things straight only through references and sources. No personal opinions matter. Even people who may seemingly sound very formal and scholarly will have an extremely hard time conversing with him if they are not backing up their argument with solid original authentic sources. All Allahyari Sahab asks for are sources, and if the caller doesn’t have them then its just a waste of the most precious time of Allahyari Sahab. Please be aware that he has challenged all the eminent scholars of a religion that has 1.97 billion or so followers, so he has to deal with people who absolutely genuinely call him for guidance on original traditions about the family of the Prophet SAWW and his SAWW's Sahaba. If people are taken by the biggest surprise of their entire religious lives that certain Sahaba acted in an oddly way, then, nothing can be changed. Its all in original Arabic sources. Its all in black ink. And cannot be denied even by the most honored, civilized, scholarly or highest in official ranking individual of any cast, creed, or religion of any nation. Its just there. When Shias and Sunnis read these, when Allahyari Sahab is showing all the original sources, very uncomfortable feelings are bound to happen. But what can Allahyari Sahab do, when these original sources of books contain just exactly those things that people don’t want to hear and believe.
This response by Allahyari Sahab cannot be contested! What can one possibly reply! All Shias and Sunnis are in deepest trouble, Shias know why and Sunnis too. Is there anyone out there amongst millions of Muslims who could furnish an adequate reply to Allahyari Sahab that listeners and viewers like us could think about. My Lord, every single topic has been defended by him and there is just no one in plain sight for miles to confront him. He has challenged millions and no one stands a chance. What has the Ummah been busy with that not a single soul could respond in a manner that we viewers could look up to. Hundreds of videos have been watched and due to his mastery over Arabic and exhausting research in original sources Allahyari Sahab roars like a Lion or soars like an Eagle in all of them. That is no easy feat, although certainly that is not his motive. His love for the Prophet SAWW is evident in all his lectures and video sessions.
Love you my Indian friend! Allahyari Sahab is setting things right between Shias and Sunnis! But believe me if he had enough resources and time, he would try his very best convincing our Dear Hindu brethren in humanity to know the truth about one God. We are so thankful that you took time out to cover an important subject in Islam. Please note that if you must know what Islam is all about, its all about the 12 Imams headed by Prophet Muhammad (SAWW) in Shia Islam. If you probe into Shia books you will find out that these 12 and Our Prophet (peace be upon him and his progeny) and his daughter Syeda Fatima (Salam Ullah Aleiyhaa) are the wisest and purest beings on earth. The sayings of these 14 infallible beings and their life history will surely Insha Allah convince you about their truthfulness. Please note that the 14 infallibles in Shia Islam are meant to guide the whole of humanity and not just Muslims. Just read about the 14 infallibles one by one in Shia Books online and you will be glued for an entire year reading about their most pious lives ever to be found in the history of mankind. Please note that once you chance upon the life of any of these pious beings, your nights will be spent searching pages after pages online for the most amazing and mind+life changing days ahead. So, proceed with caution. Remember, only Shia sources must be searched to read about them, strictly Shia sources only. And finally compare them with your most respected deities and beings in Hinduism, and subsequently with any religious and pious beings in any religion. One hundred percent guaranteed these 14 are like none other, starting from the first human on earth till the last human to appear. This is the claim of Shia sect in Islam. But like I said, only Shia sources. Its your priceless treasure waiting to be unearthed by you. I just happen to know where it is, but you have the key, as it is yours, so Dearest kind-hearted Brother, you ought to dig it and see for yourself.
Your knowledge base is next level. Unparalleled, wow. No online speaker comes close to you in explaining things out so thoroughly through references.
Wishing you joy and happiness, you are an amazing explainer and you only deserve the best praise. You are the spark, the inspiration, the guide, the candle in Momineen's lives now. I am deeply thankful that you are putting your heart out and life in line to explain truest teachings. Books, old and/or new, you have searched them all and are now the pillar and a beacon of our understanding true Islam.
We enjoy and learn from every minute of your lecture as well as your marvelous sense of humor.
Absolutely mind blowing. Allama Hassan Allahyari explains everything with references and gives a top class reply to all questions from the other side. Each and every answer is always so comprehensive in reply and 100 percent rational in essence. His references are always right on the money and simply cannot be denied as he shows all references on screen. He references original Arabic Books and there is no way on earth we could deny these authentic original sources.
We appreciate you. You just don't just teach, clarify, and demystify-you have prepared all Muslims Shia and Sunni alike for the road ahead. Both groups have a lot to ponder now.
Your sacrifices will not go unnoticed.
You leave no stone unturned by giving references upon references for Shias and Sunnis to see for themselves and think deeply.
Momineen want to learn more about the real teachings by the Prophet and Imams.
You absolutely truly care about the Muslim Ummah.
You're making the biggest impact, there is absolutely no doubt about it.
Amid an ordinary day, sitting in a room of our own, Agha Sahab tells about the epic struggle for survival and the evanescence of life for the most pious Muslims and takes off the veil of the Munafiqeen. This session was truly power packed.
Your honesty in showing all original Arabic books as sources denotes the presence of probity and particularly the absence of deceit or fraud.
Agha will live in praise for eternity for upholding the cause of infallibility of Masoomeen Aleihumussalam.
All Momineen are full of laudatory emotions for you Dear Agha Sahab, especially at this not particularly loving time when such awful personalities' realities are being disclosed by you through the authentic historical sources.
Your shown proof is indisputable, ironclad, unassailable, undeniable, accurate, apodictic, certain, double-checked, evident, final, inarguable, incontestable, incontrovertible, indubitable, invincible, irrebuttable, irrefragable, irresistible, and obvious. What can one say now. Our Dearest Sunni brothers must ponder deep and come to a conclusion in their heads for they will definitely face Prophet Muhammad SAWW on the day of judgement. How will they be able to bear the questioning by and offer a reply to Prophet Muhammad SAWW, I wonder?
In praise of intellectual honesty of Sheikh Hassan Allahyari, I salute him.
Allahyari Sahab deserves an award, a privilege granted as a special honour for his proof, as an acknowledgement of showing references of merit from the books of opposition.
Allahyari Sahab, Masha Allah, you have showed the logical steps that take you from your hypothesis that the world is round to the conclusion that it is; you have thus formulated a proof through original and authentic Arabic texts. How could anyone possibly deny any of that!
Proven methods with Hassan Allahyari Sahab: Learn faster, remember longer with his authentic Arabic sources approach.
Personalized plan: Allahyari Sahab has customized our experience to maximize our learning by showing original sources of Arabic Books as well as translating and explaining them right on the spot.
Strategic studying: Allahyari Sahab has focused on the words/topics/Ahadees that are crucial for our success of understanding the top most contentious topics.
Diving into the ocean of countless original Arabic sources to save the drowning Ummah from falsehood is indeed praiseworthy. Thankyou.
All your talks deserve acclaim and celebration as well as it is equally heartwarming and praiseworthy to watch you treat everyone with kindness.
You have also shown in one of your videos that Urdu scholars in translating have not translated all the Arabic words contained within the Arabic text they were translating from. I remember seeing an Urdu version of Sahih Bukhari where you showed the words in Arabic on the right and on the left all the words were not translated because they were extremely humiliating against the person they were being talked about and were coming out from the mouth of a very Dear personality in Islam. So the Urdu translator skipped the translation of those words in honor of the Dear personality in Islam. If this is the standard, then, Urdu translations cannot be relied upon. You know Arabic inside out, and translate impromptu, as you read the script. You being well versed with Arabic grammar and script caught the omission of the Urdu translator of Sahih Bukhari. So, I guess the only text that can be relied upon is original Arabic text from original sources only. Those who call you, or argue with you, if they know Arabic well, then they must continue, otherwise they are just wasting everybody's precious time. That is, I am pretty sure, how the translation of Mola is misinterpreted too by those who fall short of understanding Arabic and the nuances it contains for each word. I have seen your lectures on 'Man Kunto' Mola as well. And you have quoted all original Arabic texts there and talked for hours upon hours and explained all the shades, flavors, facets, and nuances of its meaning. Those scholars who call; indeed they may be knowledgeable in their own right, but if they cannot translate at the level you do or any scholar of Arabic language expert then there is not much point talking to these scholars. You can open sources upon sources upon sources but they will not be able to comprehend, let alone translate at all.
May Allah accept the tears shed in love of Ahlay Bayt Aleihummusaalam. Ameen, Summay Ameen.
Mola AP ko Salmat rkhy
Those who do not pay any heed to Allahyari Sahab will Insha Allah realize someday in near future about the truest intentions of Allahyari Sahab that all he wants is for Shias and Sunnis to read their books for themselves. That is all he is asking.
World class performance by Allahyari Sahab. Allahyari Sahab gets very disturbed when the other side turns out to be devoid of any concrete evidence, knowledge or rationale. As always a standing ovation for Allahyari Sahab.
Allahyari Sahab believes that when Ahlul Bayt are mentioned and discussed then absolutely nothing must stand in their way. We are talking about the most pious, virtuous, and knowledgeable beings ever to exist in the creation of Allah. They are not ordinary beings in any definition of the word. They had all kinds of powers with them bestowed by Allah but their goal was to to convert the hearts only through best deeds and best words. Is there anyone in the entire creation of Allah who can match their words and deeds. They are only second to Prophet PBUHAHP and that's it. And their entire piety, virtue, knowledge and all that can be considered best has been endowed upon them by Allah through Prophet PBUHAHP. They are Prophet's progeny and the Prophet PBUHAHP is proudest of them foremost before anything else. Prophet's daughter Hazrat Fatima Salamullah Aleiha is the Queen of heavens for womenfolk. So the entire women gender is obedient to her and is below in rank to her. She is the best female creation in the entire Universe, yes, the entire Universe. Certainly if she is made the Queen then she is bestowed with limitless powers. But her goal like the other 13 Masoomeen was to conquer and convert hearts through wisest words and acts of wisdom. She is the daughter of the best, the top most honored personality ever to grace the Universe, our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUHAHP. And she is the wife of the wisest and bravest warrior ever to exist Imam Ali. And My God, she is the mother of 11 Imams who are all as virtuous as the Prophet PBUHAHP ( by the grace of Prophet PBUHAHP himself) and as brave as Imam Ali ( by the grace of Imam Ali himself). Need I say more. Suffice is to conclude that when the 14 Masoomeen are talked about, then the world must stop and bow in honor of them and obey them as ordered by Allah, the Master of the Universe.
Let us all stand in awe of Allahyari Sahab in our homes and clap for him for 10 continuous minutes for showing with beautiful hardcore proofs about the Imamat of imam Ali Aleihissalam from the books of the opposition. The tradition clearly shows that if the message was not delivered by the Prophet PBUHAHP then it was as if there was no TABLEEGH OF RISAALAT performed. I mean if our Dearest Sunni Brothers just ponder of this very tradition then everything comes to one single conclusion. There is no single tradition of this weightage in the entire life of Our Prophet Muhammad PBUHAHP about any of his companions. This proves the point that Imam Ali Aleihissalam is of highest eminence after the Prophet PBUHAHP as per Allah SWT as well as per The Prophet PBUHAHP himself and we all know that The Prophet PBUHAHP only says exactly what the divine message is. Why is it then so hard for all Musllims to believe in the authority of Imam Ali at a level that Allah and The Prophet want us to believe in? Remember we have to believe in Imam Ali at a level that he truly deserves and that is the highest in authority next only to The Prophet. Absolutely nothing less. Do not discount his authority against no one but The Prophet. So we have at the highest level our beloved Prophet PBUHAHP and then its Imam Ali and then period. This is the way it should have been as intended by the Almighty Allah SWT.
Yet another marvelous performance by Allahyari Sahab for proving the authenticity and validity of the narrator. Please note that only those who know Arabic thoroughly, plus have done an extensive and thorough research of all major relevant books, can prove this point. All the scholars who appear or whose representatives and believers that appear for questioning Allahyari Sahab from the opposing parties are below average in knowing Arabic; most of them cannot even read Arabic properly and subsequently resort to reading from the Urdu translation only; thus they hardly have any grasp of different shades and meanings of the Arabic words or the context they were used in. Allahyari Sahab proves his point in just a few minutes. His mastery of Arabic is too much weight on the opposing party. His comprehensive knowledge of all the most relevant books pertaining to the subject matter at hand is a treat to watch. He pulls out the original Arabic sources like an ace from a deck of cards and flips the card to reveal a winning finish. It is heart breaking for the opposing party if a point is proven so fast and quick.
بہت خوب، مولا خوش رکھے
mola salamt rakhe agha jan ko ❤😙
Aap kay bayaan peh qurban. Subhan Allah.
Zindabaad Qibla Hassan Allahyaari 👍👍❤❤❤❤
Yaa Ali
Yaa Ali as
Yaa Ali as madad
Bohat Alaa
ماشاءاللہ، در پناہ حجت امام زمانہ علیہ السلام باشید۔
Mashallah mola slamat rkhey
Allah salamat rakhe
Excellent
اسلام وعلیکم یا علی مدد
حسن اللّٰہ یاری صاحب سلامت رہیں 🌹🇵🇰
سدا خیر ہو
Subhaanallah
Subhallah Ali ul Azeem 🙏
Shaykh Hasan Yari seems to be compromising on Quranic Tawhid in his efforts to oppose the evil Salafi Wahabi ideology. This is a very serious problem. Quranic Tawhid as promulgated and taught by the Quran and our beloved Rasulullah should NEVER be compromised. There is NO Islam without Tawhid.
Geo Agha ❤
Para 20 sorah namal ayat no 62 parlain
Sir jo mozuu tha, wo to bayan nai kia
Bhai aap ki kisi manger contacted me but no more .explain. I sleep after zackary albat no namaz 2 hours zakar alabat
Qibla topic bohat aham select kya hai la jawab answer record karayen
Topic: umari debates
Ya Ali madad ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Trinity hinduism & every other shirk can be justified if anyone goes with same logic
I listen to your videos and I like them but I am not convinced by this lecture about Iyaka nabudu wa iyaka nastaeen......
Plz try to teach Touheed...
Pehli tauheed hai , phir imamat.
Imam Ali aur baqi sab imamo nay sirf Allah sey manga hai tu hum b sirf Allah he sey mangain gay , han wasila day kar mang sakty hain.
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.
How can ahle bait help us if we call them in ghaib.. Is it not shirk ?
Like number 600
Ummu osuu bakku
Nabi s..a ko chor kar bhaag gaey thy🏃♂️🏃🏿♂️🏃🏽♂️
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.
Eena Meena Deeka
Umari ulma are more faradi than shaitan,
سالوں سے رو رہا ہوں کے یہ ترجمہ غلط ہے، صحیح ترجمع ہوگا، ہم تیری عبادت کرتے ہیں اور تیری مدد چاہتے ہیں
So many times allah has remind us regarding shirk.. Is it soo difficult for u to understand
chawal hi maree hai bhai jan app nai
Jahil or ilam waley Ek Nahe ho sakty AP phely ilam hasil Karen warna chup rahen
جھوٹوں پر اللہ کی لعنت
sawal gandum jawab channa
Sawal TAUHEED par tha
To JAWAB bhi TAUHEED
par hi hai ab ye bat aur hai
Tumko nahi malum TAUHEED kya hai
یا علی مدد کہنا صریح شرک ہے۔۔۔اللہ ہم سب کو ہدایت دے
Pehanchod pthan qadiyani
بھائی اگر یا علی مدد کہنا شرک تھا تبھی رسول اللہ صل اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم نے امت کو فرمایا تھا کہ مین علم کا شہر ہؤں علی اُس کا درؤاذہ ھے
اب جُو جُو مولا علی بن ابو طا لب علیہم الصلوۃ والسلام پر زبان درا زی کرتے ہیں وہی گھر جا کر اپنی اپنی ماؤں سے اپنے اپنے اصل باپ کا پتہ پوچھین یاعلی مدد کہنا مز اق نہیں ھے ان کے پیچھے قیامت تک رسؤل اللہ ہیں اگر امامِ علی علیہ الصلوات والسلام کی مدد کے منکر ہؤ گے تو قیامت مین اللہ کسی کام نہیں آئے گا اِس لئے کہ وہی علی آور عظیم ھے آیت الکر سی
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.
Allah ka paon jahanum mein mana uss se bhi bara shirk hai jo bukhari mein likha hai 😊
عیسی علیہ السلام کا نام سنا ہے ،،،وہ مردوں کو زندہ کرتے تھے ،،،،اللہ کے فضل سے ،،،،اب کیا ان سے مدد مانگیں ،،،،اور میں جو بات کرہا ہوں یہ نہج البلاغہ یا بخاری اور مسلم میں نہیں بلکہ قرآن میں لکھا ہوا ہے
Aap Muhammad s.a.w ki shareyat k paband Hain ya ???
@@NaveedAliNaveedali-dp8nk توحید سب کیلئے برابر ہے ،،،،آدم ع، سے لے کر ،محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم تک،،،،اس میں کسی کیلئے کوئی گنجائش نہیں
@@dostkh1597Pehlay tu yae batao kay tumharay mazhab kay baray yani sahaba aor ama jaan aisha quran ko kamil mantay hein ya phir uss mein nuqssss
Agar nuqss aor Quran ko zaya mantay hein tu aap ko shia se tauheed par Quran ki ayat pesh karnay ka koi haq nahi
Aor jo log bukhari mein Allah ka paon jahanum mein aor Nabi saww ko nangha potty kartay hoe pahari se chalang laga kar khudkashi ki koshsish wo bhi kae bar karta dekhnay ko mantay hein bukhari mein sunni unke tauheed ka sawal hum sunein kyun ??????
Shianiy Maula Ali A.S wohi jo sahaaba ko bura bala na kahain... Awr shianiy Banu-Omayia wohi jo laan taan karaiy sahaba par
Na sahabi ko bura kaho na bury ko sahabi
ILM SAY FARIG HAY YE SPEAKER...inkay pas rafziat kay ilawa koi subject nahee....fitna baz---ager inki kitaboo ko kola jayee to pir inki patloon gelee hojaegee
Br umr bkr Usman hinda abusufiyan mavia yazeed shimr ibnezyad or ibne marjana kunfuz pr beashumar lanat
@@MohammadSaif110 muta ki awlad hay na to rafzee
Khulli ijazat ha Bhai. Karen na patloon gheeli! Laiken ap nhi krpaengay
@@rizaabbas5616 apkay aqaed to kolum kola zaher horahay ...ap kay or shia molvee to bara taqiyah or joot boltay hay laken yaha to apnee shalwar ap kay molvee nay otar dee ...ab mujay yaqeen agaya kay shia rafEe kio maloon hay or inka Aqeeda quran kay barey may kia hay or sath hee abu bakar wa omar kay RA kay barey kya sochtay hay or sath yahee to waja tee kay Hazrat Ali ko jub mutashadid shio nay GOD kehna shro kya to usnay unko jalaya or sath hay sub ko kofa janey ko kaha or iskay ilawa imam hussain kay sath munafiqat bee inhi kofa walo nay kee hay...to Shahadet e Hussain kay zimmadar kofa kay munafiq shia bee hay
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.
ALLAHYARI SAHB. GEO HAZAR SAAL..
the same style of jews schlors to convince some one for their meanings by tweesting of tongue,just to conceil the facts.
surely we take meanings what the prophet and his ture campanions not as mr.allah has taken yari.
This is a story about a truth seeker. He took rather quite a difficult route in his quest for knowledge by visiting in person to eminent and known scholars of all faiths. Not many get the opportunity or the desire to choose to take that route, but he accepted this challenge for himself and undertook it with a smile on his face and emanating best behavior at all times. It is very time consuming and difficult just to plan it out indeed as many would agree.
He was honest in his search and quest for knowledge and thus paid visit to scholars of all major faiths in person to hear them one-to-one and face-to-face. He continued visiting promptly and regularly. Aptly pounding and bombarding at them all possible thorny and controversial questions out there in the domain of comparative religions he sought to identify and discover as to how their faith uniquely identified them.
He believed in the purity and sanctity of the Sahaba (RTA) with all his heart and blood which was totally reasonable and fine. But when he searched deeper and deeper, peeling off the layers from the onion he started to question, in the inners of his heart, wondering, if all the companions were indeed virtuous, then why in the prestigious books of his sect there were to be found events and behaviors (WITH proper verified ASNAAD) of some companions that were contrary to the truest Islamic teachings as taught by the Prophet PBUH himself.
Initially, he simply could not believe his eyes. He would often rub his eyes and then open them wide with bewilderment. At times he even pinched himself to make sure he was not dreaming. He made his habit to remain awake at night to read and re-read, analyze and re-analyze, scrutinize and re-scrutinize if all he was reading was indeed true!. How he wished so hard it were not true!
He kept wishing hard for days and crossed his fingers that it was all untrue. But every time he flipped-open the most authentic and known books of his sect, those traditions of not-so-good behavior by some of the companions were right there in black ink staring at him. He had indeed been aware already of many good-behavior traditions about them for which he felt proud, but the bad behavior by the same ones were there too. Why were they there? He got confused! It must have dawned at his brains many times, that, while in an argument or discussion with the opposition, hopefully, somehow these not-so-good behavior traditions never came up. He won a few debates and arguments with the opposition indeed, but, he knew in his heart of hearts, that, if indeed he mentioned the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH honestly, then it would be extremely hard to win a debate or a MUNAZARA or any argument of any kind against the most opposing sect. There was simply no defense for that. One was helpless to defend, approve, or validate that kind of behavior against the Holy Prophet PBUH.
Upon being so disturbed and perturbed, he simply could not sit at home and decided to begin visiting people of his sects at first and have friendly conversations with them about this thorn of thorns i.e., about the not-so-good behavior of the selected companions of the Holy Prophet PBUH. It seems probable he was told to ignore those traditions or that the ASNAAD ( chain of narrators ) was weak for those not-so-good behavior traditions. But from a very young age he had always been a very keen person and an enthusiast when it came to finding the true original and correct source of all matters pertaining to traditions as well as the chain of narrators. On his own territory at home, with ample time at his disposal , he double-checked, triple checked, and quadruple-checked the source as well as the strengths and weaknesses of the chain of narrators. And he performed this ritual at several different occasions on different days over many years.
There thus remained immersed for a long time, in the back of his mind, subconsciously, the pinching thought that why when a person who has talked or acted negatively-on-purpose all the while knowing that it was wrong and contrary to the teachings of our Holy Prophet PBUH, is that person ( the companion ) still regarded high and esteemed in position. If he really committed non-Islamic acts of speech or action that were not part of Islam rather against its teachings, then why uphold him among the most elevated and superior at all? This really deeply and painfully troubled him. The most problematic part was that it was all written in black and white in the verified and validated traditions of his sect of Islam. He really wished it was not there. But it was all there. He then, finally, after a continuous battle with his soul started to feel bad for himself. Because he knew that praising a person when he or she deliberately performed negative sayings and acts that were present right there in his books and that too with the most authentic chain of narrators was really tough to live with as a truth seeker. This acceptance of the non-so-good behavior of some of the companions then turned into a nightmare for him. He could not swallow that reality. It became stuck in his throat
He then turned to start looking into the lives of the Ahlul Bayt AS. And there he found the names of those personalities that were respected and revered in all sects of Islam. There were good things written about them. And if he found any wrongdoing, he wondered if that were true. He argued with himself further that if indeed their misdeeds were true then it was just The Prophet PBUHAHP, the only being who was ever virtuous and others from his closest family through his blood failed time and again and submitted to worldly affairs as well as committed errors even though they were from his purest blood as well as spent maximum time with The Prophet PBUH himself in his house after his PBUH's marriage with his PBUH's first wife Hazrat Khadija SA.
He wondered in solitude, that, if such close proximity to The Prophet PBUH, and teachings by him all the time, by virtue of living with him continuously for so many years, cannot make a person free of all worldly errors and misjudgments, then what will. Also, his daughter who was made the Queen of heavens for all women folk made errors of judgement as per the traditions in the books of his sect. She remained with The Prophet PBUH, was from him PBUH, learned from him PBUH every single minute in his PBUH's house till her marriage, yet was prone to mistakes, and most especially after The Prophet PUBH's demise when she made a grave error or probably lied about claiming a property that did not belong to her.
This is what she learned from the highest being ever (PBUH) to grace the heavens and the earth, the CAPTAIN of every creature created with power to move heavens and earth with the tip of his holy finger. She remained with the Prophet PBUH till her marriage and all she learned was to claim a thing which did not belong to her right after the Prophet's PBUH demise for which she went in person to claim in the court of the Caliph of the time.
Since the subject of our story, this truth seeker, craved for a genuine win against those who contested with him about the piety and legitimacy of supremacy of companions of The Holy Prophet PBUH, and not a fake win, he started to lose charm of all his wins. He wanted to win by mentioning everything, hiding nothing, and then prove his point with a bang. But he became exhausted and tired in thinking for months how in the world could he possibly prove his point ( and win a debate ) when the not-so-good behavior traditions of some of the companions (Sahaba) of the Holy Prophet PBUH were there in the most authentic books of his sect. If these traditions were in the books of the opposing sect or sects only, then, it would have been an absolutely great thing for him as opposing parties are generally doubted ( and alleged/accused of writing false on-purpose ) to smear the honorable personalities of other party or parties. He did know the opposing party did have those not-so-good behavior traditions in the books of their sect and brought those traditions right away in a matter of seconds as a hardcore proof at every argument, debate, or MUNAZARA against his sect. But having the exact traditions ( or similar to them ) in his own sect were just a hands down loss. And he could not win any argument this way at all ever if he spoke about all those not-so-good behavior traditions about some of the companions. This was an extreme disappointment, which he thought about often for many years to have those not-so-good traditions in the sect he was born in. And he absolutely hated and detested that. He really hated why he was born in a sect that had not-so-good behavior traditions of those personalities since it was those exact personalities who were placed in the highest and top-most hierarchy of leaders from where he took the basics of what Islam was.
And finally after many years of meditating over the subject the truth seeker had a change of heart.