Atheist in Tears, Why you Bringing the QURAN? Shamsi Speakers Corner
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 09. 2022
- Subscribe Our Channel, Like and Promote, Barakallahu fiekum!!
This channel will Bring you High Quality (4k) Sound and Video, Please Subscribe For us inshallah.
Disclaimer: The Viewers and Opinion of Speakers or Debaters In The Videos Do Not Represent THIS Channel In Any Shape Or Form, The Channel Only Represent The Actual Image At Speakers Corner.
**COPY RIGHTS RESERVED!**
There’s no need for the click bait title, it’s actually a very interesting and pleasant discussion I enjoyed watching it thanks for uploading 👍🏼
Lies for views . It's a shame
this is not his channel, its a repost. his channel is called dus dawah
@@alizahouani9260 it’s not lies it’s just exaggerating
@@mountainleopard5370 bro did the athirst cry at all? Was he close to crying? No...
Did the title of the video say 'crying christian'? Yes
It's a lie! Stop defending a lie bro, fear Allah... but u probably will keep defending it which is sad
@@3aeren lol bro calm down if somebody says I’m dying of laughter does that mean they’re literally dying? 😂
Clickbait is haram since it’s deception which is a lie.
Islam is an ideology founded on lies, so I guess they're consistent in that way.
JazakAllah khair brother Shamsi
PLEASE don't make your titles insulting to participating debaters. You were nice to each other, how is he going to feel when he sees the title?
He wasn't 'in tears', he wasn't rude. Now he will be angry when he sees the title.
Bro, plz first know the owner.
The owner of this channel is not that muslim brother(Shamsi). His channel is DUS Dawah.
People are putting cameras around to make money and say doing for “Islam” can’t deny we are benefiting but it’s the purpose tbh
@@mohamadbilal5769- So, the owner is lying on a man to make a profit! Seems a fine character. 🙄
@@mohamadbilal5769- Please let Shamsi know, if you have way to reach him, about liars using his efforts to achieve the opposite.
@@autumnicleaf
Yeah your so righ, no one is in tears here, they are just talking calming, so even if someone is lying on the Brother
Then this Brother should clear his name.
I've been watching Shamsi since he started. Shamsi is Getting better & better. Alhamdullilah
U fool learn from a real Muslim. An imam not some money maker CZcamsr fame seeker. What's wrong with people like u
Ahçent brother Shamsi
الحمدلله على نعمة الاسلام
أشهد أن لا إله إلا الله وأشهد أن محمد رسول الله ❤
عليها نحيا وعليها نموت
الحمد لله سبحانه وتعالــى على نعمة الاسلام السنية
Yeah I haven't seen anyone in tears, whoever edited the clip make big mistakes, but usually this Brother used to be honest, but today something is not right.
Are stopped sister ? He is between people he cannot lie about some thing and he talked about it when he was there with them didn’t you hear or see what he said? This man is honest more than you will ever be ✋🏼in ALLAH willing
Alhamdulillah for Islam ❤️😊
This atheist obviously don’t understand fact from ideology or theology. The questions he asked was so far from the points Shamsi was making
Like, Allhamdullilah 👆🏼💓👍🏼
subhanallah
As a Muslim I hate the clickbait
True the hadith of umar ibn Khattab is a very good example that shows not to call dead people otherwise umar would have done it
I read the comments and left. That’s what we do with clickbait
ALLAH UAKBAR is guiding u
ALGUMDULILA
La ilaha illallah Muhammadun rasulullah
2nd law of thermodynamics. If there is no control over an event in tends to be chaos tumult.... The Big Stretch coined as the Big Bang is in control in harmony in peace and no bang as bangs leads to terror and chaos...
_" no bang as bangs leads to terror and chaos..."_
Sigh. The big wasn't actually a bang. It was a rapid expansion. The 2nd law doesn't mean you can't have life in the universe.
The way he said dog he thought he had a point
What was the situation 15 bn years ago?
I’m proud of you shamsi ❤may ALLAH swt guide them
Also when it comes to Islam, there’s nothing but proof and evidence for it
Yes
Can you explain extinction and how they are replaced..
Corruption has appeared throughout the land and sea by what the hands of people have earned so He may let them taste part of what they have done that perhaps they will return [to righteousness] Quran
And there is no creature on [or within] the earth or bird that flies with its wings except [that they are] communities like you. We have not neglected in the Register a thing. Then unto their Lord they will be gathered. Quran
As ayat clearly indicates, when a corruption happens in nature, it eventually begins to harm humans. What goes around will come around.
لا إلهَ إلا اللهُ وَحْدَهُ لا شَرِيكَ لَهُ ، لَهُ المُلْكُ وَ لَهُ الحَمْدُ
يُحْيِي وَ يُمِيتُ وَ هُوَ حَيٌّ لا يَمُوْتُ بِيَدِهِ الخَيْرُ وَ إليهي مصير وَهُوَ عَلَى كل شيء
قادر
وأشهد أن محمدا عبده ورسوله صلى الله
عليه وسلم اللهم صل على
سيدنا
محمد النبي الأمي
وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم
speaker should request to visitor read meaning surah fatiha. ahlas and kaferon.
These camera mans are making the dawah brothers look bad with the clickbaits! Pattern up
Shaikh shamsi is ver knowledgeable
Please guys let us see the other person picture not only shooting camera to SHAMSI only please saw us picture of to debate guys in order to see the viewers the exact event.
is this supposed to be london or afghanistan?
the clickbait messes up with the whole concept of honesty and credibility. You should reflect on that. This is not how a Muslim should give dawa.
People actually crying over a title lmao bunch of 🤖s. Watch the video, take the benefits and move on.
Do you see a need for clickbait ???? I dont get it
I would have watched this video irregardless of the title. But because of the clickbait, this channel has left a sour taste in my mouth. There is no need to employ clickbait tactics. Unfortunately this made me think twice about watching future videos from this channel.
Evolution is just a theory like gravity or the shape of then Earth
evolution is in quran ' mankind created in stages from the earth ' perfect definition
don t lie just to get views....
There's no need for clickbaiting. The man didn't cry therefore you are slandering him.
I can see, majority (or all) of the non-Muslims (and some Muslims unfortunately) believe that Science and Religion contradicts each other.
Thats why the Irish person was asking "then why do you use science to prove Islam?"
Took me some to think why he said that but yeah!
May Allah guide him and all of us Amin
why dont u blur this gentleman? brudda respect this guys decision, in few scenes he is visible, dont lemme talk to you face2face.
Will the atheist increase his interest in islam if you mock him with the title?
On point brother.
@@ahmedeus7354 literally doing the opposite of what the video is meant for. Smh...
🤔you telling me there can't even prove dinosaur's, subanallah.
Guys, pls don’t give silly titles to your conversations. It takes away your credit
Why is he still rolling out the whole Fitrah/innate belief in deities argument? It was vague and inconsistent to start with and it's been debunked too many times to mention.
Really? Well give me a article or something talking about debunking it
Where is the tears?
Shame on you for using clickbait and deceiving people….The IRONY is you are trying to spread Truth through a deceptive title…
Kindly change the title
It is lie
كيف تكون كذبا ؟ هل اتفق جميع الحضور ان يكذبوا بما يرون في ذاك الوقت ؟ الم يتكلموا عن دموعه في المقطع امام الناس والجمع كله ؟ اتقي الله فمن حقكي طلب الدليل ولك لا ترجمي بالغيب وتكذبي ما يقولون فلا دليل معك يثبت ذلك غير انك لم تشاهدي عينيه تدمع اطلبي ولكن لا تكذبيهم فقد قال الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم ( إن بعض الظن إثم) /انتهى
Salem, some Advice for you brother. If you want ALLAH to bless this channel then don't use false click bait as it's technically lying. 😉
Guys please we don’t need clickbaits to gather attention I don’t think this is good
Change the Heading
No.one was in tears
Good conversation
WRONG WRONG TITLE
MUST CGANGE IT
Did allah command in the Qur'an the recitation of the Shahadah by anyone who wants to become a Muslim?
Which Shahadah did Jesus recite and whose name was on that Shahadah when he became a Muslim?
3:79 No man, to whom GOD (ALLAH) gives the Book, wisdom and Prophet hood, would say to the people: “Worship me instead of GOD (as Christians attribute it to Christ.)” Such person (Jesus) will surely say: “Worship none but the LORD (Matthew 4-10.) Be sincere Rabbis in teaching the Scripture as you have learnt (and do not falsify it.)”
3:80 Nor would he (Jesus) command you to take Angles (such as Holy Spirit/ Angle Gabriel) or Prophets (such as himself) as your Lords. Does it make sense to you that he would try to invite you to disbelief after having invited you to Islam (meaning submission to GOD in Arabic).
@@Fear_ALLAH_and_speak_the_Truth your million words did not answer my questions, you're just another Dodger and runner.
@@Fear_ALLAH_and_speak_the_Truth you muslims have a very poor understanding of language comprehension skills.
If you're going to respond to a post, then respond to the post according to what has been posted, otherwise don't.
@@penitoanikeve7288 2:177 'Godliness (and virtue) is not that you should turn your faces in the direction of the east and west; but he is godly who believes in GOD and the Last Day, the angels, the Book, and the Prophets, and gives away of his property with pleasure, although he loves it, to relatives, orphans, the destitute, the wayfarer, and those who have to beg (or who need a loan), and for the liberation of slaves, and establishes the Prayer and pays the Prescribed Purifying Alms. And those (are godly) who fulfill their covenant when they have engaged in a covenant, and who are patient and persevering in misfortune, hardship, and disease, and at the time of stress (such as battle between the truth and falsehood). Those are they who are true (in their faith), and those are they who have achieved righteousness, piety and due reverence for GOD.' (Surah Al-Baqarah, chapter 2, verse 177, Al-Quran)
@@Fear_ALLAH_and_speak_the_Truth your allah doesn't command you to recite the Shahadah.
Your prophet Muhammad didn't even submit to allah but allah submitted to Muhammad.
Proof of allah submitting to Muhammad:
1.allah allowed Muhammad more than 4 wives.
2. allah reduced the mandatory prayers from 50 to 5 upon frequent requests from Muhammad.
3. allah allows sex with slave women whom your right hand possess.
4. allah allows you to lie about your faith shirk to save your life because cannot guarantee you your life in this life or the next.
Etc
Etc
The clickbait is just another example of the growing desperation among Muslim apologists 🤣
In tears? Seriously this type of hype shouldnt be necessary to truth tellers. A gold pot needs no adornment
That's why it's called Theory of evolution and not Fact of evolution. These atheists are just weird lol
Don't write with fake title.
Get Shamsi authorization before you cut and paste his video, this is unacceptable. All your are only about drama.
shamsi playing smart but not being clever
Clickbait is lying and I always thought Muslims were not allowed to lie. So why do you lie Dawah 4k?
Clickbaits show that you’re not trustworthy.
Not only it's a clickbait
They didn't even blur his face as he requested even tho shamsi assured him that they will
Worst dawah channel 👎
origin of quran
2 Muhammad and Waraqa bin Naufal
Narrated 'Aisha: Volume 4, Book 55, Number 605:
"..The Prophet returned to Khadija while his heart was beating rapidly. She took him to Waraqa bin Naufal who was a Christian convert and used to read the Gospel in Arabic Waraqa asked (the Prophet), "What do you see?" When he told him, Waraqa said, "That is the same angel whom Allah sent to the Prophet) Moses. Should I live till you receive the Divine Message, I will support you strongly."
a Christian convert and used to read the Gospel in Arabic Waraqa asked (the Profit mu ham mad) Should I live till you receive the Divine Message, QURAN.
do you know injil is greek for good news.
why al lah copied from injil into quran if it has errors in it? my friend.
Muslim always say Quran say this say that but never get reference or taksir on it...it is all his own tafsir and try to get more people to agree on it ... This is why Islam fall and divided into endless sect, muslim doesn't care what is in the Quran no more , it only listen and being lie by those who talk loud .... This is authentic islam 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
First there is only one Quraan second you said all his own tafsir tell me where? or stop laying third the we unterstand the Quraan haw prophet unterstand it because he is the messangers by scholars forth you said islam devided to sects true but still we have one Quraan and the correct way is easy the Quraan and the way of the prophet ( sunnah ) nobody can argue with that and who don't follow that they are misguided is that simple and you said islam is fall that a big lie islam is the fastest growing religion and that fact if you deny it then you are delusional
@@user-xz1yk7cq1k r u blind in sight or blind in heart.... So many version of Arabic Quran in the market and you don't see it? Your present Quran printed in 1924... Where is the original Quran ? Where is the Quran that already memorize by you that goat ate it? It's really a shame to believe in something that you don't even not what is that! Allah Allah Allah , who is he?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@user-xz1yk7cq1k Allah said: you want big boobs? Come to mama 78:33 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@pauldingkh by the way allah means god in English but ofcourse you don't know semthing that easy this allah:
Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “He is the One Who brought you into being and gave you hearing, sight, and intellect. ˹Yet˺ you hardly give any thanks [surah mulk ]
Verse (23)
@@pauldingkh this is allah
And indeed, We created humankind1 from an extract of clay(12)then placed each ˹human˺ as a sperm-drop1 in a secure place(13)then We developed the drop into a clinging clot ˹of blood˺, then developed the clot into a lump ˹of flesh˺, then developed the lump into bones, then clothed the bones with flesh, then We brought it into being as a new creation.1 So Blessed is Allah, the Best of Creators (14).
[Surah al muminoon]
Asalaam Alaikoem brothers. Stop this bullS... clickbait. The video's are good enough without clickbait. Clickbait is just a lie and you know what islam says about lying. Lying is forbidden.
Greets from Amsterdam.
İf again any clickbait accures, we will unfollow you
I'm an adherent Muslim who loves Allah and his Prophet (PBUH) and who studies the Quran in depth and to be honest, I see no problem with evolution. If that is how Allah wants to create his creation then who are we to deny it exists? Furthermore, the Quran's verses indicate indirectly and sometimes directly that Evolution exists. Life itself indicates that. When a couple wants a baby, the baby doesn't appear out of thin air in their living room, he goes through the natural process, after all, Allah created nature so why would HE bypass it ?
So you assume that Adam was a monkey?
🐒 DEUS VULT
Clickbait
Change title thank you. We are better than this.
Why you lying and click baiting
Dear athiest, just look at my name and give answers to what's inside
Don't worry a humen has a digestive system in which God HAS to exists for a humen to have that
Unsubscribed because of the title. This isn't the first time your channel make a title 'a clickbait'. My brothers, islam isn't okay with this behavior because it's deception.
Please stop, we're watching your videos anyways so why do you have to put things in the title that didn't happen?
What a shame.
CLICKBAIT
Clickbait. I'll select "do not recommend this channel".
Poor Shamsi clueless....
"You will understand that the Father is in Me, and I am in you."
Oh, if muslims would understand...
Through Christ, God gave us back the divine life mankind lost in its fall. Hence the divine healing miracles and casting out of demons, we experience up to this day.
To not see God in Christ.... is impossible.
"The Father and I are one!"
"If you see Me, you see the Father!"
"Don't you believe that the Father is IN Me?"
"ALL (!) AUTHORITY in heaven and earth has been given to Me!". (Only God has all authority).
At healing the paralytic: "Your sins have been forgiven you!" (Only God can forgive sins).
"I am THE (not a) light of the world"......: God.
"I have come to give you Zoë (=divine life) in abundance".... Only God can give Zoë life.
"I am from above, you are from beneath. You are from this world, I am not from this world".....
Etc, etc, etc,
When He explained these things, healed the sick, casted out demons, raised the dead, controlled nature for 3 years, they all worshipped Him as God/Messiah.... except for the critical scholars and farisees!
He NEVER said: "Don't worship Me, I am just a prophet!". The Jews wanted to stone Him because: "You claim to be God".
So Jesus is God manifesting in Human form. Period. Glad He did. So now we finally know the sayings and actions of God.
Next step.
To not see Jesus bringing the divine life of the ages back to you-manity.... is impossible.
"I will send Holy Spirit, the same as Me, He will be IN you, guide you into truth and give you explosive power to heal the sick, raise the dead, cast out demons, etc, etc"
"Follow Me, the miracles I do, you will do too"
"God is IN you"
"The Kingdom of God is IN you"
"He who meets you, meets Me".
"You and I are one"
"You will understand that the Father is IN Me and I am in you"
"See, I have given you power over all the forces of the enemy"
"I have come to give you Zoë (=divine life) in abundance!"
Etc, etc, etc.
Hence the divine healing miracles and casting out of demons with His first 12+72 friends.
As i understood these things, i experienced healing miracles and the casting out of demons already thousands of times and many other true believers do too. Yay!
Conclusion of Paul after having revelation and healing all on Malta: "Jesus, the exact image of the invisible God. The fullness of deity dwells in Jesus bodily" and you have been made complete IN Him (the last Adam), who is the head of every principality and power".
John (who had seen, touched, heard Jesus and walked in the same power and love): "the invisible God manifested in human form, in Christ and now in us".
Thomas having revelation saying to Jesus: "My Lord and My God!". Jesus being God did NOT correct Him.
Etc, etc, etc.
His life totally proves He is God in human form. Begotten by the Spirit of God, filled with the spirit of God, healing all, raising the dead, casting out demons, controlling nature, raised from the dead, pouring out His Spirit for us to be indwelled by to be empowered to heal the sick and cast out demons, etc, etc, etc.
Way to much to degrade Him to "just a prophet".
So... Jesus is the manifestation of God in a human body.... "the Son" of God. He came to take the alienation away mankind got trapped in after the fall. He came to give us back the divine life Adam/mankind lost in its fall.
Because of this fall, a perfect Holy sacrifice had to be made. That is what God did in Christ! It shows His deep, pure, affectionate passion from Him to you/His creation, to restore you back to origin: Christlikeness. Walking in divine power and unselfish divine love.
Jesus walked flawless. Muhammed on the other hand....
Muhammed came after Jesus. He unfortunately never understood God's resolve for mankind's fall, wrote another story, called it the only truth, cutting of the real truth, leading millions astray from their godly identity in Christ. Heartbreaking.
But for those who take Jesus for who He is and ask to be filled by His godly Holy Spirit.....: divine life. Tangible presence of God, healings, demons running for cover, etc. Just as with His first 12+72 friends.
God will make you experience the full (godly) Life made possible through Holy Spirit.
So don't be afraid to leave islam. God can only be found in/through Jesus Christ.
Ask Him to fill you with His/God's Holy Spirit so He can guide you into truth and transform your life. You and God/Jesus are finally one again. He will open your eyes and give you Zoë (divine life). You will be growing into Him in all things. The life you see in Him and His first 12+72 friends.
I experience it since 25 years and so will you.
Muslims
Arevfunny
A bunch of nonsense.
What a stupid title. Shame on you. Fear Allah.
Lying is a sin brother. I dont see any tears in this video. Disliked!
Muslim corrupted torah and injil
translation of hebrew names into arabic in quran
The 25 Prophets of Allah in quran
1. Adam meaning in Arabic is Ecstasy?
(Adam) : red earth, man in hebrew
2. Idris: the mouley?
(Enoch); dedicated; disciplined
3. Nuh
(Noah): consolation
4. Hud
(Eber): region beyond
5. Salih
6. Ibrahim
(Abraham): means father of a multitude.
7. Ismail
(Ishmael); God Hears
8. Ishaq
(Isaac); meaning "to laugh"
9. Lut
(lot); Meaning Covering
10. Yaqub
(Jacob); holder of the heel or supplanter
11. Yusuf
(Joseph); he will add
12. Shuaib
13. Ayyub
(Job); persecuted, hated
14. Mussa
(Moses); drew out
15. Harun
(Aaron); high mountain or exalted
16. Dhul Kifl
(Ezekiel); God will strengthen
17. Dawud
(David); beloved or uncle
18. Sulaiman
(Solomon); peace
19. Ilyas
(Elijah); my God is Yahweh
20. Al Yasa
(Elisha); my God is salvation
21. Yunus
(Jonah); dove
22. Zakariyya
(Zekariah); Yahweh remembers
23. Yahya
(John); Yahweh is gracious
24. Isa
(Jesus); Yahweh is salvation
25. Muhammed
26. Al lah
all name have meaning in hebrew,
but no meaning in arabic except 5, 25, 26 , my friend
therefore quran is not arbic origin.
you muslim lost the meaning of torah and injil.
muslim corrupted torah and injil, my friend
what a one donkey al lah can not protect the his word.
what is the meaning word al lah, my friend?
what is the meaning word quran?
so my friend ur quran is not pure arabic, al lah lied!
s16;103 We know indeed that they say, "It is a man that teaches him." The tongue of him they wickedly point to is notably foreign, while this is Arabic, pure and clear.
😂😂 what fantasy world do you live in
Because you don’t know the meaning doesn’t mean they have a meaning lol
Silly ignoramous. Get educated
@@ob1kendobe mu ham mad in bible
Gotham/Muhammad do you know how to write and read your name?
At 5 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 7 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 25 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 40 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 64 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
Wow that is a miracle of al lah.
only 28-6 letters, my friend.
The burden is yours.
You carry books on your back.
Read! Read! Read! your books my Muslim friends.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
if jews said that Al lah is a donkey, solomon had a fly carpet and a magic ring, Al lah created from the sweat of a horse, the punishment of the grave,
how your profit moe can verify them out
isaiah 29:11 And the entire vision will be to you like the words sealed in a scroll. If it is handed to someone to read, he will say, “I cannot, because it is sealed.” 12 Or if the scroll is handed to one unable to read, he will say, “I cannot read.”
13 Therefore the Lord said:
“These people draw near to Me with their mouths
and honor Me with their lips,
but their hearts are far from Me.
Their worship of Me is but rules taught by men.
14 Therefore I will again confound these people
with wonder upon wonder.
The wisdom of the wise will vanish,
and the intelligence of the intelligent will be hidden.
do u understand my friend?
@@virtualAviator159 so my friend ur quran is not pure arabic, al lah lied!
s16;103 We know indeed that they say, "It is a man that teaches him." The tongue of him they wickedly point to is notably foreign, while this is Arabic, pure and clear.
s(19:7)
[He was told], “O Zechariah, indeed We give you good tidings of a boy whose name will be John. We have not assigned to any before [this] name.
the dilemma of donkey al lah
@@seeki3315 😂🤣 you must be high or drunk. Keep it coming my friend.
"there is hardcore science and there is science based on assumption, one is evolution"
Sigh... no. There is science. You're just inventing a type of science that doesn't exist when you don't like what we find through science.
"can you give me an example that we have observed of a species becoming another species" - Shamsi is showing that he doesn't understand that the changes in evolution are incremental and typically happen over very long time periods. So we can't watch it happen in our lifetime. We can however not changes.
But the various lines of evidence for evolution show a changing what we call one species into another over time. An interesting one is the evolution of fish to tetrapods.
Shamsi doesn't bring any good arguments here. He just dismisses evolution because he doesn't like it and doesn't understand it.
Which part of science proofs parallel universes
We do not even know what dark energy is or if it exists
Learn some science
Ps alot of Muslimd believe in evolution
The quran does not speak against it
@@ahad1609
_"Which part of science proofs parallel universes "_
Where did I make a claim about that?
_"We do not even know what dark energy is or if it exists "_
We don't know what it is. We know something is there having an effect.
_"Learn some science "_
Where was I wrong? Show it. Go on.
_"Ps alot of Muslimd believe in evolution"_
So what?
@@markh1011 Peace be upon you
, we'll evaluate the most important pillars
of what is known as Darwin's 'Theory of Evolution'
Charles Darwin is an English naturalist who reported many observations
-some he had collected during his travels
and some observed by others-
like the morphological and anatomical similarities between different organisms
and their geographical distribution patterns
Based on these observations he assumed that all living organisms
come from a common origin
through processes of evolution and diversification
where the organism undergoes slight cumulative changes
then nature sifts and chooses
Thus, beneficial changes are preserved by nature
resulting in a new species;
over thousands and millions of years
According to Darwin nature has exterminated
an innumerable number of transitional forms
where harmful or useless changes occurred
In addition to nature's sifting role
He hypothesized that nature contributes
to the development of new traits in organisms
So, when an organism acquires certain traits
-in response to the environment-
it passes on these traits to its offspring;
in line with Lamarck's hypothesis:
that the long-necked giraffe
was once short-necked
but environmental changes
and the need to stretch its neck to eat from the tree tops
elongated its neck across generations
until it became what it is today
The crucial point here is Darwin's assumption that
living organisms resulted from these changes coincidentally
in other words: without intention
According to Darwin, There was no plan of creation
in the production of these numerous species
He emphasized this in many of his writings
Darwin published his ideas in 1859
in his book: "On the Origin of Species"
He then wanted to provide a detailed mechanism on how
acquired traits are inherited
So, years after "On the origin of species", he published
his hypothesis 'Pangenesis' where he assumed
that, when nature affects the cells of the organism
these somatic cells secrete small particles, which Darwin called 'gemmules'
that aggregate in the reproductive organs of the organism
and get passed to its offspring
But, where did the 'common origin' come from, Darwin?
Where did this primordial form -upon which you built your ideas
and to which you ascribed all living organisms- come from?
Darwin did not explain that in his book
But, in his correspondence with the botanist Joseph Dalton Hooker
he conjectured that the primordial form originated in a warm pond
by factors such as light, heat, and electricity
Thus, Darwin endorsed the notion of 'spontaneous generation';
prevalent in his time
This notion presumed that living organisms
could develop spontaneously from inanimate objects
For example, it was believed that insects originated from leftovers
and maggots from rotten meat
These are, in short, the pillars of Darwin's theory of evolution:
1- A living organism somehow emerged from inanimate matter
2- A nature that grants living organisms new traits
that transform them to different species
3- Acquired traits are inherited 4- A nature that selects and
compounds complex biological systems through simple successive changes
The conclusion (the tabletop) is that: Living organisms evolved without
intent or will from an intending doer who knows what he's doing
And on this tabletop, Darwin loaded all living organisms in the universe
Now...What is the overall evaluation of these pillars upon
which Darwin established his conclusion?
As for 'spontaneous generation'
it is a myth that has been refuted experimentally;
most famously by Francesco Redi's experiment (200 years before Darwin)
Also, Louis Pasteur's experiment published five years after Darwin's book
proved that the organisms -once believed to be
spontaneously generated from inanimate objects like leftovers-
actually come from contaminated air and not from the food itself
Indeed, sterilization by 'pasteurization' and pasteurized milk
are derived from Pasteur's name
The truth is that it is rationally refuted
to imagine a living organism
spontaneously emerging from inanimate objects!
However, they insisted on testing it
and when they did the myth was refuted scientifically
as well as rationally
As for nature adding new traits to an organism through use and disuse
-like the example of the giraffe's neck-
it is also a myth; refuted by Gregor Mendel's discoveries
Mendel, years after Darwin
proved that genetic traits of offspring, no matter how varied
will not include anything outside the genetic pool of ancestors
It's also been refuted by findings in epigenetics
which show that external and environmental factors
can alter how genetic material is read in an organism;
activating certain traits and supressing others
but they cannot add genetic material that didn't exist in the first place
As for inheritance of acquired traits
it is a myth as simple observation proves
For example, the muscles that a blacksmith and a carpenter develop
in their work aren't inherited by their offspring
However, Darwin's disciples insisted on experimenting with this hypothesis
Weismann, for instance cut off the tails
of 19 generations of mice and their offspring
only to find out -after all that headache-
that the offspring of these mice continued to grow tails
In other words the acquired trait:
the severed tail wasn't passed down to offspring
Now, what's left of the pillars of Darwin's theory?
You will say, "Natural selection is valid."
My reply would be that the valid part of natural selection
is neither Darwin's invention nor his brainchild!
It's well known that it is harder for a weaker animal
to acclimate to difficult environmental conditions
But Darwin's 'natural selection' goes beyond this
to mean the emergence of complex biological systems
from simple random successive changes
Do you want to understand what natural selection means to Darwin?
His wild imagination
brought forth the idea that nature and 'use and disuse'
gave ancestors simple physical structures
that may have provided some benefit
So, natural selection saved them
without any foresight that the accumulation of these structures
would later produce a fully integrated organ;
like the bird's wing or the animal's eye!
To understand Darwin’s logic; imagine a scrap landfill
which is passed by huge numbers of blind people
and each of them randomly picks up a piece of scrap
Then, they enter a building via a one-way door
that shuts after each person gets inside
Millions of years pass by with blind people picking up scrap and
going into the building; where they'll eventually die
One day, you open the door of the building
and a giant Boeing plane bursts forth
piloted by a blind man and soars into the sky!
You wonder: "How could the blind man make the plane?"
You are told that he did not intend to make it
but what happened is that a blind person before him
picked up a piece of scrap that was useful, survived longer,
and passed it on to those who followed
One picked up a cloth which protected him from the cold
Another picked up a flat piece of metal that shaded him from the sun
One picked up a plane control stick and used it to stir his food while cooking
Another picked up a sheet of glass and used it
as a shield in his war against blind enemies
So the blind across different generations passed on scrap to their descendants
Then -unintentionally and without anyone's intervention- the pieces came together
to form this great plane that simply took off
Don't you dare harbor the illusion
that someone intended the plane to be built or flown!!
By the same logic, Darwin considered that natural selection
blindly patched up the structures of living organisms
So, for example, saying:
"Wings help birds fly" is describing their pseudo purpose;
an imaginary purpose, not real!
Also, to Darwin, sight is a pseudo purpose for the eye
because there is no willing, intending doer
who intended for the eye to see or the wing to flap
Rather, all this resulted from accumulations of blind chance!
This is the 'blind natural selection' joke that Darwin came up with
Apart from sounding absurd to every sound mind
it's been invalidated by the scientific discoveries
of 'Irreducible Complexity' in all
detailed structures (of organisms) and their relationships
In other words, the structures and organs of living organisms
are so complex and integrated
that all parts need to exist at the same time
for the system to function
Thus, gradual evolution of the different parts is not possible
even at the level of the smallest unit of life: the cell
which Darwin saw as a mere smudge under the microscope of his day
Therefore, the natural selection portrayed by Darwin is also a myth!
Upon such myths -refuted by mind, senses, and experiments-
Darwin built the most ridiculous and stupid idea in history:
that this finely-tuned and magnificent creation
came by unintentional chance events
and that it requires no knowledge or wisdom!
@@markh1011 Now, what's left of Darwin's theory?!
His delusions which seem like an entry
into a 'Wildest Imagination' contest
where natural scientists compete to make the audience laugh
What's left is his imagination which is like bedtime stories
of the Frog Prince, the Swan Princess,
and Cinderella's mice turning into beautiful horses!
But with one addition: the conversion into horses required a very long time!
An imagination that puts feathers
on mosquito-chasing dinosaurs then they fly
An imagination where a black bear swimming for hours
with its mouth open to swallow as many insects as possible
is likened to a whale that opens its mouth to swallow fish
and -based on this 'similarity'-
Darwin wove a tale of a whale evolving from a bear;
as in the facsimile copy of the first edition of 'On the Origin of Species'
page 184
Some might say: "But what about Darwin's knowledge?
What about the numerous observations he collected
in his book and the accuracy of his observations?"
My reply is that Darwin was like a program with a large amount of input
but with the wrong equation to link this input
thus resulting in a wrong conclusion!
Therefore Darwin's substantial information
wasn't of much benefit to him
It is very important to understand that these observations
of birds, reptiles, insects, etc.
are not part of the theory of evolution
We're here discussing the theory itself
that Darwin put forth to explain his observations
Apart from his observations and his coinage of the term
'natural selection' -with the wrong meaning-
Darwin's 'innovation' was invalid while his valid input was not new
Yes, Darwin's 'innovation' was invalid
while his valid input was not new!
Therefore, it's a mistake to say: "Darwin's theory has errors."
because Darwin's theory is essentially a combination of errors:
Myths refuted by mind and science,
logical fallacies, and absurd fantasies
to reach the conclusion that the fine-tuning and precision in organisms
does not require intent, will, or knowledge!
Here I want to remind you that our episodes
offer a methodology to adjust your compass
The methodological rule we learned today is:
Falsehood can only be founded on falsehood
It can never stem from correct knowledge or a sound mind
Wherever you apply this rule you'll find it to be true
We saw an example in today's episode: Darwin's myth
that 'organisms are a product of chance'
Some might wonder: "Didn't scientists after Darwin
fill in the theory's gaps and correct its errors?
How do you account for the fossil evidence?
the molecular biology evidence?
The embryology evidence? Vestigial organs?
Can't we reconcile Darwin's theory with Allah's existence?
If it is a myth, as you say, why do most Western scientists believe in it?"
We will answer all these questions methodically, Allah willing
starting with the claim that the theory's gaps have been addressed
and its errors corrected in our next important episode
So stay tuned!
Allah is the Granter of Success
Peace and Mercy be upon you
@@user-es2bq2bf1b _"Now, what's left of Darwin's theory?!"_
What's left? The theory of evolution by natural selection has been supported over and over again. It's the cornerstone of biology and critical to many fields of science.