Hahnemühle Photo Papers Compared
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- In this video we compare five popular photographic papers by the German company Hahnemühle. We take a close-up look at:
William Turner
amzn.to/3qunjD2
Bamboo
amzn.to/30NPsdi
Photo Rag
amzn.to/3arecOa
Fine Art Baryta
amzn.to/2OtYlpU
Photo Rag Baryta (13 x 19 inches)
amzn.to/3qS4Y26
#Hahnemühle #comparison #photography
This video is not sponsored but the links provide are Amazon affiliate links. I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
This is exactly the kind if video i have been looking for for months! I really wanted to see the paper up close to see texture, colour and details. Thanks so much for posting this! I have been looking for a watercolour texture paper to print my watercolour paintings and I’ve wasted money on papers and cardstock other people have recommended but to me look cheap and don’t reproduce colours accurately.
Thanks for this outstanding video!
I'm so glad you found this useful!
Hahnemühle
German Etching 310 g/m
That's what I am using and I am very satisfied.
Wow! I have looked high and low for a decent comparison video of popular papers without success. Then I unexpectedly stumbled on this. Thank you for the time and effort in producing this video - it is an excellent resource.
Thanks so much. This was an outstanding presentation, one that took lots of work by you. Really nice job.
Thanks for this comparison, very useful! I wish there was a video with colour photos of these papers!
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
I am beginner photographer, and this is very helpful for choosing my print paper!
Thank You very much. I was searching for this information. Very helpully!
Great comparison, thanks for your hard work.
I hope it was helpful.
This was so helpful. Thank you
IMO the best video review for photo paper. Concise, close-up, edge-view, paper movement and direct comparison. Excellent ideas!
Thank you! I’m really glad you found it helpful
This was extremely helpful, thank you!
I'm so glad!
Instantly subscribed! Thank you very much
William Turner is one of my favorites also.
Thank you. Excellent video.
Thank you! I'm glad you found it useful.
Brilliant! This is great for me to see a direct comparison between the Photo Rag Baryta and the Fine Art Baryta. I currently use- and love- the Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Metallic for half my work but the yellow cast of the paper doesn’t work for certain images. Now I can see that the Fine Art Baryta is what I need. Thank you very much for this!
I appreciate the nice comment! I'm glad you found the video helpful. -- Keith
The William Turner sharpness is impressive. It goes well with the texture emitted from the old cars in the photo.
I recently posted a video showing a large landscape print on William Turner if you’re curious to see more
Very helpful Keith. I just dove into the deep end of printing my work myself with the purchase of a Canon Pro-1000. I am doing as much research as possible before it arrives, so that I don't print a lot right off the bat on the wrong papers and regret it later. I had already ordered some Hahnemühle paper before understanding all the varieties they offer and the paper properties that differentiate them. I ordered the Torchon Matte paper. After watching your review, I now understand more how the weight, brightness, texture and other qualities of the paper affect the prints. I see the Torchon is very textured and so may not be great for many of the prints I'll want. From you descriptions, I can see I'll want to also get some Baryta and some Photo Rag. I wonder how the Torchon compares to the William Turner, which looks great in your presentation. Thanks for taking the time. Your presentation was very informative and easy to watch.
Hey Art -- thanks for the nice comment. I'm glad you found the video helpful. Welcome to the wonderful, maddening world of printing :-)
Unintentional ASMR, thank you!
This was an amazing resource! As a long-time Baryta printer myself I can't wait to try the Henry Turner (not included in their sampler unfortunately). Ordering from a lab today and next time from your link! Thanks!
Hey awesome! I'm glad you found it useful. All the papers are top notch.
I would have loved to see the side by side of this with others.
thanks for this video brother - as a beginner in fine art printing, this is exactly what I was looking for!
I'm glad it was helpful! Good luck and have fun!
Holy, William is impressive
I created some prints using William Turner (via Whitewall) and the paper is INcredible. Fantastic texture. Will have to check out Photo Rag Baryta.
I totally agree with you. If you haven't seen it, I posted a recent video featuring a very large print on William Turner -- also made by WhiteWall. They are typically my go-to print shop. czcams.com/video/0RRp4szBeow/video.html&ab_channel=KeithDotsonPhotography
Can't go wrong Photo Rag Baryta really Dom, it's basically a standard in the industry.
Great job
Thank you
i love william turner. even with nothing printed on it. something about it.
I didn't expect to love it so much but seeing it printed convinced me. It's a favorite now.
lol you made my day :D
super helpful man ! Thanks :)
Hello. Which Epson printer would you recommend for home printing on this paper?
great video, but after checking different papers, and never seen photo rag in person, i noticed i needed a size reference when you do the close up, to figure it out the texture size.
Now that i compare with ur fingers i notice texture is really fine, smooth, so not sure if for my watercolors prints will be best texture. Maybe the turner has stronger texture
The Photo Rag has a very fine texture. William Turner is definitely more like watercolor paper.
Great info! Have you used Epson Cold press? I would like to know how it compares texture wise to William Turner? I use to use Epson Exhibition Watercolor but it was discontinued.
its textured but its way smoother. William turner is heavily textured but the print quality is superior to cold press
@@647vman Thanks, I got a roll of William Turner, Haven't painted on it yet.
Hi thank you very much for this great video! May i ask you what printer you use please? Thank you very much!
Thank you! I use the Epson SureColor P5000.
What kind of printer did you use to print the photos? Please and thank you. Do you think there’s affordable printers that print really well or leave it to another company to print my work. If so could you recommend the printers.
I would say unless you are very serious about printing and want to print often, it's better to let other companies do the printing. I use an Epson printer and the printer, the inks, the paper -- really everything about it is expensive. And if you let it sit for more than a week, it'll start to clog. Canon printers are very good too, and you can get a nice little Canon dye-based printer for under $100 if you just want to make test prints or prints for home. Dyes are not as permanent as pigments, but they look beautiful.
X-cellent product.
Do you think the Baryta paper would be suitable for coating your own emulsion and processing in a traditional darkroom? I just got some adox polywarmtone and am I looking for suitable papers. Thanks
Sorry just getting to this comment! I’m going to guess that the inkjet coating might cause problems
I am big fan of Photo Rag Baryta (especially for B&W prints) and the Photo Rag Metallic for color. I was slightly disappointed with the color gamust that pigment ink reproduces but I found with the Photo Rag Metallic it makes up for this in an exciting way. Thanks for the comparison. I have some Fine Art Baryta that I haven't tried but I will now for B&W prints.
I need to try the metallic paper!
@@Keithdotson Yes if you've got some design images that need to pop (well as much as they can with pigment ink?) metallic paper is very good. It would be very interesting to see what dye based inks would look like with metallic paper, great I'd say?
Great content! Did you end up switching to the Photo Rag Baryta? If so, are you happy with it?
Thank you! I’m using both the fine art Baryta and the photo rag Baryta. I love the quality of both
Hi Keith. Thank you for sharing your knowledge. I very much appreciate it. As I am shifting into fine art photography, understanding paper becomes even more important. Can you please share your knowledge about paper weights? For instance, how does the weight of paper, if at all, influence an image and what weight is best suited to what environmental conditions? I look forward to my continued learning journey with you. In kindness, T.
Thank you Toni! It's nice hearing from you. Paper weight doesn't really effect image quality, but it may have more of an effect on handling and framing. Baryta fiber-based paper in the darkroom was notoriously curly after drying and had to be flattened. Inkjet barytas are the same -- except it's the curl of the roll that you must deal with. But it relaxes if you let it rest, and it can be flattened. I make a lot of very large prints on heavy-weight barytas and they have to be handled very carefully or the paper will bend or crimp around your fingers and create a permanent half-moon scallop dent in the paper. I hope that helps -- maybe someone else will see this question and offer other advice.
@@Keithdotson thank you Kieth for your insight into using Baryta paper. Cheers
My favourite brand - note that baryta is not an optical brightening agent (OBA). OBA's perform a trick in that they convert UV light into visible light and this makes especially white areas brighter. But OBA fade over time and then the paper generally turns yellow. And, as indicated they need UV light to work, so in an environment without UV light they do nothing.
Baryta paper may be a bit warmer (tint) than paper without baryta layer, but that is not always the case. The effect of baryta is deeper "blacks" (we should say darker darkest greys) and in many cases lighter "whites" (we should say lighter lightest greys).
Great comment! Thank you. I have framed Hahnemühle papers with OBAs under UV glass and frankly it didn’t make much difference in their appearance that I could see
@@Keithdotson - thank you for responding. Interesting. Makes me wonder if that UV glass is from the Chinese manufacturer that makes 32MB memory cards called 4TB and Li-ion cells of 900 mAh called 3800 mAh.
If you look at measurement data of the reflectance of OBA papers, you see more than 100% due to the UV conversion. If the Hahnemuehle paper with their version of OBA is under 100% then I would assume that there is no UV conversion and so I would assume they found another way of getting nearer to 100%. The fun.
I was wondering what size do you resize your images for 8.5x11 paper. What are the size of the margins on these?
Hey good luck with the test prints. I seem to recall I printed those images at 6 x 9 inches or something in that range
@@Keithdotson oh i do see the part in the video where you show the size now. good to know. just wanted to compare notes. thanks!
how does these do with color? I tend to shoot subjects with heavily saturated colors on film of course. thanks
I can’t personally answer this but hopefully another person can help
Mmm if you're using pigment ink opposed to dye you may be very disappointed with color saturation.
Nice video. I would like to go with photo rag baryta and photo rag matte. ive ordered a printer but its out of stock so gonna brush up on things as much as possible. will finally have prints for sale. 🙂 at some point.
Good luck with it! Both of the Photo Rags are soooo nice! You'll enjoy making prints on them.
@@Keithdotson Thanks so much. Im about to order. Printer shipped. Canon 2100. I tried to change it to the 4100 but it shipped already too much trouble to change. Am ordering rolls of rag baryta and rag matte. i think the baryta looks better though. maybe will delay the rag matte. i rewatched this a couple of times. i could see the yellow tone on some for sure. 🙏🏻thanks again for the video. forgot i had commented before.
@@Keithdotson Do you recommend any cheaper paper to use for experimenting so I dont use the good stuff on practice?
@@jdg6336 Why don't you look into a pack of 8.5 x 11 paper from Epson or Canon or whatever cheaper brand? Maybe one of their baryta surface papers or even just a luster paper or something like that?
@@Keithdotson I got a 24” roll of hahnemuhle cotton rag baryta and matt cotton rag but was just thinking i should have a cheaper roll to experiment with / leave in the printer for maintenance. printer arrives next week. i was looking at rolls of canon / epson as you said as they are cheaper. 🤔
I use regularly Photo Rag Baryta. The paper results are great. It produces a predictable outcome with crisp color and rich blacks. Only drawback it’s really expensive
Agreed
Are you happy with the color using pigment ink?
yes@@Neil-Aspinall
@@irenedp4947 But are you aware of the color look of dye based prints?
Hello, please could you tell me what printer you used to print these images?
I print with an Epson SureColor P5000
@@Keithdotson Thank you for replying. Can I also ask how you find the ink levels on the printer. I am looking at that one or the Epson P900. Do you know roughly how much it might cost in ink for a standard A2 print?
There's no way that I know of to measure that exactly, but one print doesn't really use that much ink. Also, inks are consumed at inconsistent levels, for example since I print "black and white" images I use more blacks and grays than magentas or cyans, so I replace those cartridges more often.
Excellent video! Out of interest, what were your personal conclusions? Did you make the switch to Photo Rag Baryta?
Thank you! Yes, I have made the switch to Photo Rag Baryta, occasionally still using the Fine Art baryta too, while I still have sheets left. Both are fantastic papers.
@@Keithdotson The Photo Rag Baryta is the most beautiful paper I've ever used. Do you tend to stick with gloss papers for all your prints or are there certain images you'd choose matt papers for?
I stick with the same papers for all prints, with the option for customers to select a matt paper if that's their preference. Most don't do that, though. In my opinion, the gloss papers are good for every subject matter. And I agree about the Photo Rag Baryta -- top notch. And with Hahnemühle, there's never a variation in quality.
@@Keithdotson I ought to add that your photographs are fantastic, particularly the Abandoned Places series. How would you say an inkjet print on Photo Rag Baryta compares to a silver gelatin print in terms of dynamic range and texture?
Hey thank you very much! I have specifically tested the papers to answer this same question and in my opinion the Hahnemühle baryta papers are very similar to darkroom barytas. Some other coated papers fail because of gloss differential, but you can't see the inks on the surface of Hahnemühle barytas as much as some other papers. Canson baryta papers are pretty good too from what I have seen. I'm a big fan of their Platine Fibre Rag. A UV spray coating will minimize that problem on a lot of the other papers though.
Why are they all yellow exept for fine art baryta?
The Fine Art Baryta includes optical brightening agents
im curious about hahnemuhle photo rag metallic
I haven't tried that one but I've read a lot of good reviews
@@Keithdotson i may buy 25 sheets of 8.5x11. sounds like its good for bw landscapes.
Works a treat with color images.
Great info! Have you used Epson Cold press? I would like to know how it compares texture wise to William Turner? I use to use Epson Exhibition Watercolor but it was discontinued.
Thank you! I have used some of the Epson papers but never the Cold Press. If you try it, let me know what you think.
@@Keithdotson Cold press is nice. Much smoother than Exhibition WC.