Hadith Science Explained Through Quran.
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- | Surah Al-Baqarah | Section 5.2 | Verses 75 to 82 |
Hadith believers consider Quran and Hadith as two essential sources of guidance, calling it Quran and Sunnah. They often describe the process of collecting, compiling and grading Hadiths as "Complex" and "Deep Science". However, Hadith critics or rejectors directly call it “Hearsay” or “Art of Gossips”. In this video, we dived deep on this topic and explored the true “Hadith Science” through the lens of Quran.
CHAPTERS:
0:00 Intro.
1:55 Relevant Key Learnings of the Previous Sections.
5:14 Exploring Hadith Science through Quran.
23:49 Fabrication Examples.
31:47 Why Quran and Hadith has been more prevalent than Quran Alone?
45:01 Advice for Hadith Believers, Quranists, Reverts or Converts to Islam, and Ex-Muslims.
46:42 Problems with conventional translations of 2: 75-76.
51:05 Synthesis of Section 5 (2: 63-96).
53:20 Outro.
#Connect_Quran #quraniceducation #quranicIslam #Quran #Islam
Useful Resources:
Chapter 2, Section 3.0 (Verses 40-47): • Reminder and Path Forw...
Chapter 2, Section 4.0 (Verses 48-62): • Dismantling Superiorit...
Chapter 2, Section 5.0 (Verses 63-66 & 93-96): • Allah’s Warning To Ban...
Chapter 2, Section 5.1 (Verses 67-74): • Revealing Insights: Le...
The Meaning of Salat/Salah: • Is "Salah/Salat" in th...
The Meaning of Zakat/Zakah: • Is "Zakat" in the Qura...
Amazing
AlhamdulilAllahi rabbil aalaameeen
People need to ponder on the Quran while they are reading then they can reap out (reflect) benefits form this Quran. Some do read but they don understand what they read… how can they reflect on the Quran
Also people should run away from SUNNI mushroq or shia mushriq etc… there is no sects in religion 3:103-105
We have read what was revealed to prophet Muhammad and stay away from all the other books… then finally people can understand Quran so then they can obey Quran…
Now they are obeying what ever their scholar is saying and these scholar never being investigated if what they are saying in line with the Quran
Well said.
Powerful video
Thank you!
Salaamun brother,
I really enjoyed the diagrams. We definitely need a concise summary of the invalidity of hadith's authority over The Qur'an and doubt in its basis as a quick irrefutable rebuttal to any concept of hadith being necessary, scientific, or authoritative.
W salam brother,
Thanks for your feedback. These verses 2: 75-82 summarize the whole concept of Hadith by answering all related questions such as Who were the people spreading the Hadith? What were they spreading through it? Why were they doing this? and how were they doing this?
The message is absolutely clear for those who are seeking the truth.
They made rejection of the hadith of Bukhari as rejecting the Messenger and hence apostacy. They do not read or understand the Qur'an to judge what we are to follow and this allows them to do whatever they want, taking the mindless sheep with them to the fires of hellfire.
Agree. Bukhari and other hadees writers were clearly not aware, or totally misunderstood, that Quran is Ahsanal Hadees, the Best, most Insightful Hadees. Worse, that their hadees imply, that even Rasulallah and his close companions were not aware of Ahsanal Hadees.
Well said
Great presentation akhi! When will the majority (akthara) wake up and see the fabrications within their hadeeth books?
Thank you brother, and I don't think it will ever happen!
Thats depressing to hear. Cannot your message spread to more people??
brother please make a video on siyam or sawm. is it really something about refraining from eating & drinking! The traditional translations are very confusing
Peace brother and thank you for your suggestion. I am actually going in order on this channel so that full context of everything can be grasped. In Sha Allah, that topic will be covered in due time.
I think the words of Allah that were being distorted is the Torah. Allah is chastising the groups of people that were tasked with conveying the message before the revelation of the Quran and calling them to do the right thing and not hide or twist Allahs words.
At this point there could only be a handful of believers if that with the messenger.
Also at this point in the revelation only 90 ayahs or so have been revealed.
I agree the subtext is that this is indicative of what those with a disease in their hearts do with revelation. And as such it is what is being done with the Quran as well as what those before did with their revelation.
Great vid keep them coming!
I very much respect your thoughts but here is something to think about:
1. What was the point for these people, who had identified themselves as believers of Quran, to distort the previous scriptures at a time when Quran was confirming (retaining and carrying forward) the message of the previous scriptures?
2. These verses are primarily addressed to true believers so what message these verses convey to them?
3. Why can't there be wrongdoers among handful people?
4. How did you conclude that there were only 90 verses revealed at that time? Order of revelation isn't the same as it is arranged today beacuse revelation order must have resulted in random arrangement of topics but the current order has systematic arrangement of topics. I eleboated this point in this video: czcams.com/video/dysq3E8afbk/video.html
I agree with your last point, with the distinction that the wrongdoers began to treat the Quran through Hadith in the same way they had treated previous scriptures. This is what Allah has warned believers about.
@@Connect_Quran Peace thanks for taking the time to respond
1.It seems to me that the original believers Allah is addressing are those people that were true believers but because they were believers before the Quran they were either apart of the jews or the christians. I think this because this is the first group Allah addresses (after the general address to mankind). They were the “believers” on the earth at the time and they were also the keepers of Allah’s word ie the torah. And before the Quran they were distorting the path by changing what had already been revealed. So the beginning ayat arent establishing a new religion rather telling the holders of the previous revelation, which at the time was the current revelation, to do the right thing with their revelation. That is to not twist things and change halal and haram. The true believers understood that they were receiving a message from Allah through mohamad so they followed it and him. But until the qibla was changed they would have gotten their law from the torah.
2.I dont think these ayat are exclusively for the believers in that there was this separate group that had the true religion. Its addressed to mankind first and foremost. almost as a call to the believers from amongst mankind like a magnet over a pile of sand and metal will exert the same force of the whole pile but only the metal is pulled to the magnet.
We can read between the lines and see that there was big contention between the jews and the christians before the revelation. The revelation seems to be a response to that contention. We can see that the jews and christians at this time were expecting God to judge between them and both groups were surprised that judgment this time came in the form of revelation. Even though the leaders of the two groups on earth that could represent Allah’s revelation to the world were corrupt, there were still regular people on earth that would submit to Allah. It seems like Allah is calling them with the message to worship Allah alone, without son or partner and not to follow the rich and powerful who are trying to deceive with Allah's words.
4.I am 100 percent convinced that the quran is in the order it is revealed in. and its very logical to come to that conclusion and then Allah seems to reinforce that conclusion asyou read on. I think that is a part of the miracle. We can see that parts of the revelation are in clear response to an event in the messenger's immediate life. If we can see that in parts its easier to see that the whole revelation is in response to whats happening in his life and the mission that he is sent on.
If we were to take the quran in order as following mohammads life. Before its revelation I can see him just like all of us, lost and wanting to know the truth. We know that life in europe n. Africa and the middle east before the quran was a buffet of different religious ideas. Paganism had just fallin and Christianity was on the rise as a break away from juedeasim. With all the different ideas in circulation around him surah al fatiah makes sense as the first revelation that he receives as someone lost and looking for guidence. Al fatiah gave him the contract between Allah and him and taught him how to ask for guidance. Then the 2nd surah must come after the first because where al fatiha taught how to ask for guidance the 2nd surah begins letting him know that this is the guidance requested. And then filters mohamads immediate environment. answering for him what the right path is and what paths the primary influences of his time were on.
Here Allah is also answering the most fundamental questions we all have which i would assume pre quran Mohammad would have too, which is where did we come from and why are we here.
After this Mohammad is send to the descendants of bani israel. This is because Allah has a message for them, to remember the contract they have with Allah. Here is where some people start to understand that mohamad is a messenger and they believe in the message and uphold the revelation given to them past and present. In this process the true believers were being pulled away from the teachings of the different religious authorities. At the same time those religious authorities were being given the answer to the argument that they were having (who has the divine right to law, jews or christians).the answer was neither of them. The only one that have divine right to Allah's law and His house are the true believers who dont twist the words or take a son or partner for Allah.
At this point Allah begins to give the believers who heeded Allah's message given through mohammad a group of their own. This is when these people are exiled and then the first battles happen and Allah begins giving laws.
There is a structure in the revelation and its mohammads life. The arrangement of the different topics is a sign of Allah’s mastery of everything because each different topic fits into what everything Allah is addressing during mohammads immediate lifetime. This is why Allah can tell us what seems like the same story multiple times because in each place the story addresses a different thing happening in mohammads lifetime.
35:57 i want appreciate your work. Just want to ask that in Quran 2:223 i recently read this "farmland" word for wives. Kindly ponder it and guide me. I read , and listen to many schoolers but still confused.
Thank you!
Unfortunately, I haven’t come across a single interpretation of 2:223 that isn’t criminally misunderstood being degrading and humiliating to women. By no means Allah referred women as “farmland” of men.
The Aya 2:223 actually reads: (imagine) Your women tilled (a process of land preparation for seeding) for you, then your tilled lands came exactly how you wanted and would have produced for yourself (if you had done tilling instead of your women doing it), …
So men are told through this example that they have no role to play during menstruation of their women and they just need to wait as women go through this discomforting experience. Once they are purified from this discomforting experience (so women will dictate when it’s over), men can have physical intimacy with them with the consent of their women.
@@Connect_Quran thank you for explaining, I recently read English (even Urdu) translation of this ayat , but was confused about it . and from your video I got the chance to ask about it. You are explaining very well. The way you ask questions and ponder on coming ayat really amazed me and gave me some answers to my unanswered questions. I am from Pakistan, and trying to improve My English language as well,so if there is any mistake just try to understand what I have said.
I am glad I could help. Unfortunately, most translations and interpretation are just surface level readings of the Qur’an and it requires much deeper reflection to be understood.
I don’t see problems in your English language skills but I can always answer questions in Urdu if you feel more comfortable.
@@Connect_Quran I am trying to understand Quran from many years and listened to many scholars and other teachers. But I still have questions. As I saw your pattern of explaining the Quran ayat I hope to get them all very soon. May Allah give you wisdom, health , peace and long life to explain His Quran to his people. Ameen.
Thank you for your kind words and beautiful prayers, very much appreciated!
Thought provoking lecture. Traditionalists hv distorted true message of Quran Majeed
Thank you for your comment.
how can you reached?? email ?? any Qand A ??
No Q and A for now and I can be reached at connectquran114@gmail.com
Truly impressive presentation brother!! Allah reward you with all the goodness in both worlds for your efforts.
I will be studying this properly again and sharing it insha'Allah. I knew Surah Baqarah had the answers when looking at context to Harut and Marut verses.
Your recitation and delivery as well as presentation slides are very good mashAllah.
Thank you brother for your feedback. I am truly humbled with your kind appreciation and beautiful prayers. I reciprocate these prayers for you as well. Yes, take your time to critically evaluate it.
7:185
Who gave Bukari the permission to write the Hadiths???
That I don't know but what I know is that he spent lots of his energy on something which he was supposed to ignore and avoid.
Right answer for your GREAT question is: Iblis gave permission to Zoroastrian Hadith forger Bukhari to fabricate hadiths and to concoct Chain/Isnad in order to send sect followers to Hell 14:22.
If we honestly analyze contents of Book of Bukhari, it becomes 100% clear that he was INDEED a Munafiq of hidden Sabaite Baatni tehreek.
*Several stories of his Book badly insult Great man 68:4 Mohammad, and attack and discredit Noble Quran repeatedly. And it is very clear, that a True Muslim can never stuff his books with such blasphemous concocted tales*
@InnocentBigWaterfall-uq7cx
Actually the first book "named" Bukhari came in market in 15th century when Ibn Hajar (died 1449 CE) compiled hearsay fairytales which were attached to the name of Bukhari.
1- Prophet Mohammad returned to his Lord in year 632 CE.
2- Bukhari died in 870 CE
3- Notes of Bukhari were collected by Firabri died 932 CE
4- Notes of Firabri were collected by Khushaymani died 968 CE
5- Then those notes were compiled as book by Egyptian Mullah Hafiz Ibn Hajar Asqalani (died 1449 CE)
Book Bukhari is full of fabricated blasphemous tales which mock Quran and badly insult Rasool
Contents of book Bukhari CONFIRM 101% that author of that book was a Munafiq
The Qur'an was written down in the life time of the prophet. We know this because Allah says 2:2 ذَٰلِكَ ٱلْكِتَـٰبُ Dalica-L Kitabu "That the Book". The only way this could be true, is if the Qur'an was written in the time of the prophet.
Thank you for bringing this point up. Very much appreciated. I mentioned this with reference in Quran’s structure video on this channel that Quran was rearranged from its chronological order to its present form by All-Wise, All-Aware. Thus, the claim that Quran was compiled after the death of the prophet is nothing but clear lie.
@@Connect_Quran Another sign of this is Surah 87:6 where Allah states he "Will" make the Prophet recite. Ie something that is to come. Then 96:1 where Allah instructs the prophet to recite.
This clearly shows a procession of events.
This is not from me, but the good chap Samual Garrens.
Watch his vid about this for greater insite - czcams.com/video/4hGywG94pSM/video.html
Quran is the spreme not hafith what you are doing is wrong what does mean hadith in the context of quran.
I didn’t get it what you are trying to say!
What i mean is that the quran should explain the haddith.secondly the quran has a tafsiil in it self but creating a tafseer based on ahadith is an individual ideas which has coused the different sect that exist today instead one nation.thank you for your rrsponse but think about the best way.
I see, that’s exactly what i talked about in this video :) thanks for your feedback.
@@user-nm3fl6ps4vhave you even watched the video????
This man is attempting a complete distortion of the message of Quran and suggesting the teachings of Prophet Muhammed is wrong. Hence the compiled version of Prophets teaching should not be followed. He is boasting he and people like him are the true muslims. Remember without following the teachings of Prophet and the way he prayed, did fast, zakah and hajj you will end up in greatest of greatest hell and for spreading lies.
Thank you for your comment but there was no need to tell a lie. I didn't suggest that teachings of prophet Muhammad are wrong but rather I demonstrated through Allah's revelations that following evil practices of the wrongdoers and attributing them to prophet is wrong!
Teachings of prophet Muhammad = Quran Alone
Teachings of wrongdoers = Quran + Hadith
@Connect_Quran You are the master of lie. You are distorting the meaning of Quran by giving false meaning and calling it as truth. Shame on you. Your intention is to distort and create confusion. You won't be successful. Are you a jew or a Christian with an agenda?
@Connect_Quran You are a lier and promoting distorted meaning of Quran. You are uneducated in Islamic studies and also immoral to deface a holy book of Muslims. Stop your nonsense if not God's wrath will befall on you.
@@Connect_Quran Salaamun 3Alaykum. The Qur'an was delivered to Muhammad as he was a Rasul in Mecca for 10 years. A role as a Nabiy for Muhammad, he got it as he was in Madinah. So during in Madinah, Muhammad has 2 roles, one as a Rasul (to get the Qur'an delivered) and as a Nabiy to implement what was he got from the revelation. So, it is not appropiate to say that the teaching of prophet Muhammad = Qur'an Alone.
It’s sad to people associate Allahs kitab with man made books . No different to bani Israel with the talmuds
That is why Quran uses the term "Bani Isra'il" as symbolic representation of all those people who ignore, misuse or abuse Allah's guidance because of their superiority complex and majority of people who identify themselves as Muslims meet this criteria!
can you stop tajweed please . it's not from allah.
Thanks for your suggestion Martin but I don’t see any issue in it. Quranic Grammar isn’t in the Quran but we still learn it, don’t we? I see no harm but only benefit in Tajweed, making clear what exactly is being said.
@@Connect_Quran إنه لقول فصل وما هو بالهزل.
Quran 73:4 or a little more-and recite the Quran ˹properly˺ in a measured way.
Quran 73:4 or a little more-and recite the Quran ˹properly˺ in a measured way.
With out the the Hadith narrations , the number of Muslims on this planet would be about 5 million instead of 2 billion, and there would be Buddhist temples instead of Mosques every where from Morocco to Malaysia and giant statues of Genghis Khan all over the Middle East. Saudi and Egypt would be Mongol territory in 2024.
Hadiths are lies. That lies started to be fabricated after year 722 CE. During the era of Rasool and 4 Caliphs, there was ban on hadiths. Are you sleeping, Man!
With out the millions of forged Hadiths, today there could be 6 billion Muslims. Those are millions of hadiths which converted a Muslim Super Power into a weak power by creating several sects and divisions among Muslims
what does it mean. only hadith helped muslims to create a civilization??? how can you come to that conclusion?
So you are saying ALLAH’s book is worthless without human narrations and fake stories? Muslims really have a problem with upholding the Quran… yet the same one are the first to blame the corruption of the Bible.
Stop, think and reflect.
you a Muslim?@@BaniAadama
@@BaniAadama
*All books of hadiths, Sunnah, Asbab-Nazool, Seera, and tafsir were forged by Sunni and Shia sects after the death of Rasool and after the death of all companions of Prophet. These fabricated books have no any relation with Prophet Mohammad or Islam*
Standalone Quran is self-explanatory Book and is not in need of those fabricated books. Quran does its own tafsir through its own built-in Tasreef