Space Opera unlike any other in the medium | Legend of the Galactic Heroes
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- I just love Engrrish in anime but I never knew I would love germanish just as much if not more. Hearing Reinhard say Brunhildr or Schwarz Lanzenreiter was honestly one of the best things ever.
_______________________________________________________
credits:
Picture Source: / 1041uuu
#anime #Lotgh
The reason reuenthal takes on reinhard is the conclusion to the struggel inside him. In one scene reinhart tells hildegard that he doesn't want his heir to take the throne but instread the person that can beat him in battle. That fires reuenthal up and this then reaches the climax. It makes even more sense if you remember reuentals upbringing and his relationship with power and especially risk.
I came to watch you die....
how kind of you!
Also, when you have a bunch of people who view that army and the soldiers as nothing more than statistics and thigs that are granted, like almost all imperial admirals, regardless of the dynasty the fought for, you are bound to have conflicts out of pride and perceived insults.
Reuental always had kingly ambition but but couldn't bring himself to actually challenge Reinhard purely out of respect until he was pushed into a corner by schemers
Reunthal rebelled for many reasons. He was backed to the corner by political enemies of the empire who framed him. He was also very proud and refused to apologize twice after dedicating his life to Reinhard. The challenge that Reinhard gave him was also something Reinhard wanted (having worthy enemies to fight against) but can never ask for since it would be politically damnation for a new ruler to have a thirst for war. But for a loyal vassal, that was the one thing he would give to Reinhard, a ironic act of loyalty to give Reinhard the battle he wanted. But the most important one was that he was always similar to Reinhard in both ability and ambition. He recognize Reinhard as his better but they were two men with the ambition to take over the universe so it was inevitable that they would clash, especially when Reinhard favored him, Oberstein and Mitenmyer as the most loyal and powerful retinue.
The best sci fi fight ever was when they used the Geiersburg fortress to disable Thors hammer on Iserlon through the gravitational pull.
Fun fact: that scene was purely the creation of the anime's producers. In the novels, the two fortresses just continue to duke each other out.
@@AnakinSkyobiliviator yeah the anime is really the best way especially for westerners to experience the story
Agreed. It blew my mind when that happened
That was absolutely incredible, cought me really off guard when it happened, yet it made total logical and sense.
@@AnakinSkyobiliviator It was a massive improvement.
The ship thing can be explained by the high command wanting to protect their admirals so they get better ships.
In the empire it makes even more sense. The class struggle between the aristocrats and common folk is very hard and real. So many admirals would have far better and experimental ships then any other branch of the army to show that the guys on top rule.
Also the ships of the FPA are more cramped to reduce costs while the Galactic Empire ones are super luxurious to showcase wealth and power.
Also Reunthal and Myttermier start of in similar ships like the others in their fleets then change them with rank.
Also !! FPA ships are smaller and can’t land on planets, they use shuttles instead. I thought this was a great explanation as Imperial ships can enter atmosphere in order to “conquer worlds” FPA can’t, but this helps explain how the FPA can put up a fight with fewer resources. They are fighting with a minimum spec fleet to fight off the empire space only worthy batteships.
Keircheis's first flagship is just a Fast battleship, not even an Oversize Fast Battleship like Bittenfeld's Konigstiger. He only gets Barbarosa after solving the embezzlement rebellion with 0 friendly casualties and a single enemy one
The remake covers like 26 episodes, 50 is very exaggerated
LOGH is not necessarily unpopular; the people who've seen it rate is as one of the best anime they've ever seen. It's just that on the distribution end of things, LOGH never was picked up by the 'west'.
Not wrong, and I feel like Die Neue These could do really well with non-anime streaming audiences that slurp up serial stories…like on Netflix or HBO. One has to wonder if someone owns the rights to western adaptation and distro, and the translations we get kinda skirt whatever contract is walling things off.
Idk why they say that it's unpopular, it's constantly in people's top 9 grid and is currently ranked #10 on My Anime List
“Alcohol is a friend of humanity. How can I abandon my friend?” Need I say more?
Nice video. Regarding the space battles of the original series, from a strategic perspective they are among the most coherent and satisfying battles of any kind ever depicted on screen, IMO.
The different between FPA's flagships and Empire's flagships are explained even more in the original novel and I wish the OVA would have explain it :p.
If I remember correctly, many of the Empire's admirals got their ship custom-made from a special dock, while FPA's ships are so streamlined that most flagships are mass-produced. Yang's Flagship is even worse than any of them. His ship, Hyperion, is an old battleship that was assigned to a border patrol group but was quickly reassigned to 13th fleet and refitted by slapping a command room and some antennas. The FPA has too little time to refit that they didn't even bother to repaint the hull and change the pennant number. That's why the Hyperion has the number of 144M and painted blue instead of green.
Well wasn’t the Hyperion was one of the prototypes for what was to become the ajax class
@@dazooej5785 Yup, It precede Ajax-class flagship but it wasn't a prototype ship. The design was dated back from the UC 760 and was considered to be outdated at that point. But I'm not sure if it fought a lot of battles before or was newly-built before being reassigned to Yang.
You kind of right about the battles. I think Moltke once said "No plans survive a contract with the enemy.", but in most anime it does.
0:25 - And actual opera (style) music. Can't be a space opera without it.
Exactly. The soundtrack is classical orchestra, as it should be. Not synth techno stuff.
Reuenthal betrays Reinhardt out of a mix of loyalty, ambition, and competitiveness. Reinhardt also baits and pushes him into it.
Loyalty: he knows Reinhardt wants rivals and is less satisfied with ruling than he was with conquering. The war with the Alliance is over, so Reuenthal gives Reinhardt one last enemy to overcome, if he can. This challenge is a gift.
Ambition: there is a chance that Reuenthal might actually prove victorious. That would allow Reuenthal not just to grasp power but to wield it in a way that he considered just. These were always the reasons he supported Logengrahm, but only because Reinhardt was the person best positioned to achieve them. At the end if the war, there's a slight chance for Reuenthal tondo so himself. More, this will let him achieve the nobility his father denied him.
Competition: Reuenthal is just as interested in fighting worthy opponents as Reinhardt is. With Wenli out of the picture, who's left to fight?
The show spends a long time building this up. But confusion is still a fair reaction. Mittermeyer, Reuenthal's best friend, is also confused by this turn.
A true jewel of a space opera is the Expanse.
One thing, original was not against war, it explained the place that war occupies in history, in the life of people, nations and civilization. Neither less nor more.
For the guy who betrayed the kaizer it’s kinda different.
1) he was accused before for betraying the kaizer before. So his words were not trust worthy
2) he is Botha very brilliant tactician and politician. Which makes him dangerous
3) he was the one that heard from the kaizer that if you have the ability to take him down. Do try. (Meaning well in some ways he does have some ambitions to do so)
4) he was framed to be trying to kill the kaizer. So with all those added up he can’t say he’s innocent. Consider the circumstances and his pride the situation can’t make him say that. So instead he just accept that and decided to fight the kaizer
Lols totally agree about incompetence. That’s why i really love this show!
This is my Favorite anime. Once I started I had to limit myself to 2 episodes a day so as not to finish it too soon. It surpassed Steins;Gate for my Favorite anime. I haven't seen the remake.
Have you started Gundam yet, it’s the inspiration for this anime. You will recognize immediately
@@guttss2353 I've started the manga for thunderbolt.
My Japanese is definitely NOT there to be able to take my eyes off the subtitles for even a minute-so I can’t manage more than 2 episodes because I’ve got, you know, I got, responsibilities
@@The_CGA I work and go to college, I just have free time during the summer semester since I don’t take summer classes
19th century Prussia likes 40th century Prussia. FPA is basically France+UK. Iserlorn corridor basically is Alsace-Lorraine minus the coal mines. The fortress is the space Maginot. Fezzan corridor is the lowlands. What's not to like in this setup.
18:14 The Imperial admirals eventually almost all had unique ships, it's just that they weren't THAT different visually.. BIttenfeld's was just the Fast Battleship but 30-50% longer with an extra engine. Lutz, Farenheit, Mittermeyer and Reuenthal all have unique ships but they're subtly different. The previous supreme admiral had a special flagship that was three of a kind (And it, and the two sister ships eventually all wound up with the rival nobles
there is an interesting idea I would like to point out:
in the earliest days of the Roman republic, Rome had a provision in law that in times of emergency the senate can elect one man as Imperator for the duration of the emergency then he steps down.
this was centuries before the dictators rome would become.
its a mix of empire and republic
The betreyal you talked about was foreshadowed for so long.
Its kind of like Tanaka extrapolated what our world is like in the 20-21st centuries and applied that to this show, where its often difficult to tell who the good guys and the bad guys are
I am really enjoying younger people’s perspective on this show-which is to say, y’all kids whose analogy for understanding war is (arena/moba Gaming). Love that you’re getting stuff out of it.
The custom ships (almost overwhelmingly empire characters) -that’s a reflection on the nobility and their stuff is all bespoke. It seems like a stretch to you, coming from a Democratic and more egalitarian society, where mass production makes stuff for everyone because nobody is “better” than others. In the Empire, the leaders are literally regarded as better people.
How does bad maintenance happen? Everything happens for a reason. One character’s anger doesn’t control the scene in the OG. instead they explained both.
Anyway, the experience of veterans, the actual experience of those who fight at the enlisted level, I agree with you that’s not there in Die Neue These. I think it comes down to broadcasting and ratings. It’s hard to put gore and R ay Pe EE on TV.
Also, do not forget the remake treat space battles like they are flying ships inside the orbit of a planet. Thusly it has G FORCES IN SPACE. Most notably at the first battle of the series, where the armies form a ring. And that is not even getting into the stupid haircuts which a lot of characters have. You would think that vision obstructing hair would not be allowed in the military, especially not on communication and liaison officers, but apparently no, it is completely allowed.
Friendly correction, G forces do exist in space exactly like as portrayed in the Expanse, but they have artificial gravity on their ships so they should be able to mitigate if not outright ignore those g forces.
You made one mistake in your analysis: for you the imperials are the bad guys. They are not. No side get to call themselves the good guys or the bad guys.
I mean, the Goldenbaums are the bad guys. "Let's combine the worst parts of the aristocracy and eugenic national socialism" with the nobility fulfilling fewer and fewer of the requirements of Noblese Oblige, other than a couple very rare exceptions like Hilda's family, or the one man who refused to evacuate to Odin during the Alliance invasion, even if he knew he would take the blame for Reinhardt'a forces leaving with the food.
To be fair, those maintenance guys were probably underfed, slept little hours, and work almost 24/7 to get everyone of those vehicles out in a small amount of time. It doesn't absolve them of sin but shit happens all the time like that in the real military. Especially dealing with 20+ year old equipment. Its easy to say that in the civilian world but those mechanics were probably conscripted in the military, given little mechanical training (probably most of them were learning hands on), and when in the middle of a battle, they are literally worked 24/7. Its easy to get mad at them but at the same time, Soldiers who have been there with the mechanics know that it is not entirely their fault the mission set is almost impossible.
reunthal was talking about betraying reinhard for quite a while and reinhard put him in a position to do so after hearing about his ambition because he wanted someone to challlenge him, they both were just looking for an excuse
If someone si starving to the point they can't stay awake they're going to make mistakes.
28:00 I gotta say the original anime also made the incompetent guys appearance like they were incompetent, it was just that the style was different
i had this series on my computer for five years and i JUST watched and finished it finally over the past 3 weeks. its SO GOOD. you're right about the dialogue being dense. i had to pause a lot to read, too. it was all so well written. the characters felt a lot smarter than me thats for certain. oh and the beautiful soundtrack ofc. they used all of that great classical music so well
NO SPOILERS but i dont think an anime has ever broken my heart the way this series (the original) did. i will say no more
Since I listened to the end, I will make a follow up comment about Reunter’s betrayal.
They were both Lions. Reunter is older than Reinhardt, and accepted him as his superior + his loyalty kept him as a loyal subject... but that one personal conversation he had with Reinhardt, after the Lipstat rebellion closure where actually after Kirechies’s death, it was Oberstien/Muller/Reunter’s forward action that conslidated Reinhard’s almost victory over the novels. (They secured the victory that almost unraveled from Reinhardt’s stupor after his lost of Kirchies)
So he not only saw his boss, as not infallible, Reinhardt even tells him 1:1. Power is taken by those who are capable, if you ever see the opportunity... and bates Reunter.
I agree it’s a little bit forced, but they planted the seeds. And it made for great drama
the og is why i hate most of the modern anime
The Republic isn't meant to be seen as "the good guys." The point is that both systems are technically neutral, but must rely upon the individuals who form and run its institutions, and that is what leads to good/bad outcomes. Granted, I'm on Team Yang all the way--autocracy, even a "good autocracy", remains an autocracy, and I'm firmly against that...not to mention Yang is just about the ideal person--but I would say that framing it as "the good guys aren't really that good and the bad guys aren't really bad" kind of misrepresents the intentions of the work. Eh, a bit of a nitpick, sure, but whatever. Great work otherwise.
Wars are about power. Whether it's good or bad depends on whether the people being ruled over by the system they are in are happy or sad about it. So a authoritarian who wants to take orders under a benevolent king living under a republic is always going to see the government as bad for being too corrupt. While a libertarian living inside a dictatorship will always see their government bad because it's restrictive and annoying as it makes them feel weak and dependent. But you place those people in the system they want and they won't complain. So 'good' or 'bad' in the anime worlds isn't really representative of universal ideas of good and bad. In the real world people flip their ideals when they get older and more mature. People living in a soviet russian times might see capitalism as evil but then realise that communism is ALSO evil in a different way. So they say they are 'neutral' now. They went from being on a side to being neutral but even the neutral is just moderate levels of the two sides in one person. What is good or bad depends on who the person is. People who have moral code that makes the most number of people happy (because it is productive) are the truly good ones. The bad ones are the ones that have moral code that is destructive. This is why anime that is preachy is not liked much as people assume the anime world's idea of good is not the universal good. Star Wars tackles the problem beautifully: the jedi are imperfect and so evil was able to sneak in due to relaxing of rules. Those rules are what define being a knight. Break the rules and you introduce chaos! Chaos then comes and takes hold to create a strict empire that lets the emperor do a he pleases but the people are held to strict rules that oppresses them. So it's not about good or bad but the loss of freedom. The jedi had their rules and broke them, the sith never had rules but became power crazy which caused the good guys to stop fighting for freedom which in turn meant more efficiency but more suffering. The universal good however is redeeming the bad guy so he can be given a second chance. Without second chance to make things right you can't undo a mistake. That is what the "good" guys were missing. They made a mistake by going soft on rules and thought it was game over. But the universe balances it out by giving the bad guys the belief that they already won but did they really? They can't obtain power if everyone hates their guts and will deliberately pretend to work hard but not like working under abusive conditions. So the bad guys can drop their guard just like the good guys and this allows them both to learn about their own weakness of character. If the emperor was perfect at manipulation, then he should have foreseen being betrayed by his student however he failed due to pride in thinking he can ever be beaten. This pride is the universal sin that causes empires to always collapse. Once you believe you are a god and can do no wrong you will not reflect on your decisions and question whether it was correct because you don't think you can make mistakes. Then you enemies exploit this character flaw and regain freedom from your system. True Good guys that are UNIVERSALLY good are humble and ready to admit the flaws and avoid mistakes while the bad guys assume there is nothing to question. This is why in martial arts the saying goes "it's not the move type that beat you in a fight but the move you didn't expect" - what that move is, is the thing you can't predict. Th emperor couldn't predict something simple like family bond defeating his mind control. Why? Perhaps not being familiar with how strong bonds are between people as that is not the way of the Sith. (which is like a robot: you do things to get the power and the power is what makes you ruler. However if nobody likes the ruler and the people revolt, the government is ruled by the people once the rules become unbearable. The ancient romans knew that to prevent any rebellion you needed to keep the population happy with Bread and Circuses. Feed them and entertain them with distraction and they will be too lazy and de-motivated to care about righteous rule and not think about it. What was the Emperor's weakness? Being focused on power, not looking at how happy people were under his boot. The assumption is if you are stronger and more wiser then you rule. But the missing factor is "Am I popular?" and so he forgot he only got to power through deception not reaching that power due to people loving him and agreeing. That allowed his student to take advantage of the blind spot.
Yang is NOT ideal! He is Idealic to an absolute fault. He is willing to kill people and let people die instead of waver on his own ideal or even make a compromise.
He literally let's his democracy die by refusing to try to take control of it. He JUST wants to retire, and the outcomes of nearly everyone else is of little matter to him.
Never liked Yang because he was portrayed as this larger than life genius who can do no wrong. A saint basically, never loses a battle, never even loses an argument, has foresight that is so precise one could think he's an oracle... Such people, unfortunately, do not exist. His sentimental approach to a mass of people being able to govern themselves, even into a corrupt bureaucracy as a morally absolute good. Him putting republicanism onto a pedestal as this sacred rite passed on from divinity rivals even the kaisers of old in terms of hypocrisy. Claim of divine sovereignty in one way or the other leads to moral self righteousness, never ends well. He is one of the most bigoted characters in the show. In contrast, Reinhard shows massive tolerance for change and capacity for reform. That is why this show will always be "The legend of a galactic hero" to me.
@@kingofmaiars It's also fiction. Jean Luc Picard is another kind of idealized moral actor in his stories, but as a work of fiction the purpose to to examine that kind of hypothetical (a perfectly moral actor) within fundamentally amoral and/or immoral systems.
@@courtneyvaldez7903 Then, even as a case study. Yang's story fails to convey a coherent argument. That, a perfectly moral actor is not enough to push society into the "right" direction. What has the iserlorn remnant really achieved, after Yang's death? People who are supposedly the inheritors of his will were unable to influence Kaiser's opinions. Something Yang himself has given up after his short meeting with the Kaiser. What was truly the point of Yang's whole arc? That he should be the convenient speed bump in Kaiser's way whenever he pushed too eagerly. In the end might proved right, the story. Sorrybut it wasn't all that interesting. Even the slight altercations between imperial fleet admirals were a more meaningful struggle, and a more enjoyable watch too.
you kind of misinterpret the remake scene, the maintenance worker’s bad working conditions was because they were prioritizing feeding the pilots instead, showing how the battle of armistar was going wayyyy too long
For me whenever a space battle happened in the show, I was just waiting for the show to get back to the talking honestly.
The reason I've always accepted as to why the guy turns on the Kaiser at the end is just that he snaps and goes crazy. He's portrayed as having bad relationships, a bad childhood and family life, abusive parents and generally a shitty life, so when he is doing a good job and was loyal to the kaiser and it keeps getting questioned he essentially snaps and goes crazy and decides to go through with the plan he was forced in to be Terraists anyways. It does seem a little forced, it would have made more sense IMO that he tries to take over after Reinhard dies in an ensuing civil war, but instead they have him fight Reinhard and it doesn't make as much sense.
It would have been cool to see Reinhard die or be on his deathbed and when the civil war breaks out Ruenthal decides to plea to the alliance to rebuild it and the imperial unity of the galaxy lasts all of like a year before the Alliance is back and fighting the imperials again, with the Gale Wolf and Ruenthal enemies on other side.
But I want some merch!
Making the show merch-thirsty in the remake might bring some more people to the well. I don’t mind that there’s two shows, and one of them is a little bit more able to suck teenagers into it.
It's Gelman not Germanish. The joke is that japanese people pronounce the L as R and R as L when it comes to western foreign words, that's why the term is specifically "Engrish"
Lol not spoiling who betrays Reinhardt in the end but spoiling the best "war is evil" moments of the show is quite the performance. I think I remember the general betraying Reinhardt is presented as unscrutable even by the narration, I feel they were trying to make a point by lefting his reasons so ambiguous in a manner of saying "History just doesn't know" which would be in line with the show being framed as a historical chronicle of this war.
Logh for life 🎉
It's not really that complex to understand why the violence is toned down so much in the remake. LOGH was released as a subscription based ova series. Several VHS tapes were shipped to you over several years. The remake is being released on tv. The brutality and violence has to be toned down in such a case.
Overall, the remake is simply way too "clean"
I mean that’s what you are going to get with digital animation. There’s nothing that can be done
from old anime 26 episode to 24 new anime episode
The motivation for the betrayal you talk about was given long in advance but maybe so long in advance you didn't get it, that character has lots of scenes about loyalty and ambition and the like that show the kind of person he is, which explains why he did what he did in the scene. But he's an odd guy so it's easy to not empathize.
Oh the guy that betrayed the Kaiser. I think I know who you are talking about. I'm not gonna mention any names, but it was the guy the Kaiser sent a message to after kircheis's death. The guy betrayed the Kaiser because he believed the Kaiser wanted someone to fight, an opponent who is strong and smart. The Kaiser did say something along the lines (I'm just summarizing it, not accurate or true to the Kaiser's word), "If you got balls in the future, feel free to fight me". He wanted to fulfill his role for the Kaiser, to act as a scapegoat of sorts.
More than that, he KNEW he was the only person left who could compare to the Kaiser, and believed he had a chance at defeating him, even though the chance was always going to be small.
Good people and remarkable people are killed meaninglessly. That's war, and that's terrorism. The sins of war and terrorism, in the end, comes down to that. - Yang Wen-li
This is why I love the original! You see this horror and you understand why Yang thinks like that. There is nothing good or heroic in war. Haven't watched the remake yet, might check it out later, but the original is and will always be the best character-driven space opera ever and a timeless classic!
About Oskar betraying (spoilers I guess):
He was portrayed as second greatest admiral of their army right after Reinhard, very prideful and very ambitious. And he himself always thought that only thing stopping him from going against Reinhard is the fact that he witnessed the genius strategic mind of Reinhard and knew he couldn't win that fight. But Oberstain still saw him as a potential threat that could appear after everything was finished with FPA. So Oberstain played on his ambitious nature and gave a political opening for Oskar's rebelion. Oskar still knew he will lose, but 1. his nature and pride wouldn't let him back down and 2. in a way he decided to showcase himself for everyone else to see that even if the great Reuenthal couldn't do it, noone should try and go against Reinhard. Even his death he used to serve Reinhard. This is how I understood and how I remember it 2,5 years after watching. And also Oskar killed the worst person of the sroty Trunicht, which makes Oskar von Reuenthal my favorite character of the original series!
I think the remake definitely does highlight the horrors of war, but not to the extent that the original did. It the original the whole show seemed to highlight this fact and was one of the major flaws of the empire as they were extremely militaristic before and during Reinheart’s dictatorship. In the original with its focus on the battle they glorify it more though Yang has said consistent in being a voice of peace
I agree about Reunter’s betrayal, it was hard to understand his motivation for betrayal, but then he had a kid.., and then wishing to get the best for your child became a thing... it might be a biological turn due to fathership... regardless, they already cast Wakamoto Norio, and he deserves a dice roll for the top. Coolest voice in the universe empire or FPA
I am curious as to how did you come to the conclusion that Ruenthal's betrayal was for his son. It was the very argument Lang tried to accuse Ruenthal with and Ruenthal debunked it right on the spot. He literally couldn't care less about his kid since he didn't believe he should/deserve to be a father. Not even once did he ever take the existence of his child into consideration until the very very end when the woman brought the kid to see him. Even then it was more out of pity cause the woman was about to abandon the kid, so Ruenthal sent the kid to Mittermyer who could really use one.
Maybe I'm in the minority here, but the main thing I disliked about the remake was actually the space battles. The CGI space ships looked too slick and too cluttered at the same time, while in the original both Imperial and Alliance ships looked very utilitarian (yet distinct from one another).
CGI can bring a lot to the table when it comes to 3d objects maneuvering in 3d spaces, which is very hard to animate with traditional animation, especially on a series budget. But the potential pitfall is the tendency to just over do it by throwing too much stuff at the screen, and I think New Thesis fell into that trap - though not as badly as Yamato 2202.
24:00 You're joking....? ... Hungry?
Almost starved because the crews were last priority. Yang's fleet didn't pillage the locals, and the order for food put maintenance crews on a nearly nonexistent ration.
I'm with you.
I think that Reuenthal rebelion didn't end up making so much sense. There was build up, right when Reinhardt taunts Reuenthal into rebellion after they defeated the High Nobles, but I dunno, he ended getting trapped/framed and just accepted it. It would have been fine if he fully did so for his own ambition, but no. He got manipulated, and he stays quite ambivalent about it
Honestly, I always really disliked the Terraist plotline as a whole, and their big impact on the story, in getting Yang. So that was annoying when they managed to get him too, and went on to cause even more trouble at the end of the series. It's like B-movies villainsjust decided to keep stepping in and interrupting the masterpiece.
Also, he ended up losing due to 1/Julian helping the Kaiser, which isn't even good. That's just negotiating/deference. They are just not a player at this point, but the story insists that they are, and it didn't work for me and 2/to the betrayal of his own men.
If he had lost to another character of his level/imortance in the story, it would be much better. Losing to Mittermeyer or better, Reinhardt, that would have been good. But it just ended up being dissapointing
Even the battle I prefer the old one, the new one kinda downscaled (the spaceships in the neue one is about tenths instead of thousands)
I really enjoyed alot of your insight on the two "diffrent" versions, but I need tp say that I feel you miss the point on some of the differences between the older version and the newer one. I don't have the time today to get into the specifics but I will come back to my comments here and edit it so as to bring into a more full view of what I mean.
28:00 No. Physiognomy is real.
Great analysis
It's interesting that this series blurs the lines between "good guys" and "bad guys". A major theme of the books is whether it's better to have a corrupt democracy or a benevolent dictatorship. However, there is a clear distinction between competent and incompetent people. My only real complaint about the series is that almost everyone is either a genius or a complete moron. There's very little in between.
Mittermeyer’s division isn’t faster because his flagship Beowulf is any faster than the other ships. He drills his men harder to be fast because he believes this to be important.
You're cool
You clearly didn't watch all of the original OVA if you think the reboot has better space battles 💀
Yes yes yes love this video
Heldensagen vom KOSMOINSEL
Good video
I like both old and new equally, but new definitely have too much "ugly bastards" as bad characters.
Actually, each season as far as i know adapts 1 volume per season, so new adaptation will probably be 120 episodes long. + another 48 or so if they will adapt Gaiden.
You are talking about Reuenthal? I think he was just disappointed that Reinhard didn't believe in him after all they were been through and didn't wanted to be treated as a criminal/traitor. He was too prideful to ask for forgiveness or explain himself when he personally did nothing wrong and Reinhard should have known that.
I think what happened to Reuenthal happened a lot throughout of history. Between Aurangzeb and his brother when his father got sick or between Aurangzeb and his son Akbar. Akbar was such a nice guy, honest and faithful ally, i do not understand why Aurangzeb didn't believe in him. Probably cared too much about his power or life.
And even if he will try to explain everything to Reinhard he can end up like Mustafa (if i remember right) son of Suleiman the Magnificent. He came to him to prove his innocence, but got killed anyway.
Sorry but if you got the impression that this anime was about "good guys' and "bad guys" and the both sides represented one than you got the wrong impression. This anime far from something like that. This isn't Star Wars.
but he said that it isn't about good vs bad
One piece has a decent over arching plot line
Your take on the betrayal arc is so bad. You literally just dont get it
But the plotarmor is too strong in my opinion. I mean the Yang guy und Rudolf-kun are also mentioned by every oportunity...This just isn't the way normal people talk or behave..
Redo this script, you could probably make a good video out of this
the remake is trash, but yes I agree with this for the most part.
lots of layers and reasons to like the show...may not agree with all of them...
is this JOJO
No offense, but you have some bad and kinda uninformed takes in this.
once you said star wars as a space opra i knew you are full of it you could have said Ender's Game or even Star Trek
Star Trek with the arguable exception of DS9, aren’t space operas.
Star wars is a space opera