Hello hi :) I wanted to say to y'all that THERE'S AN OFFICIAL DISCORD SERVER FOR THE "UNDERMENTIA PROJECT" In there you can help us to recreate the ENTIERETY of Undertale (as in Music, Art, Programming, etc) just BY MEMORY!!!!! Oh just u know talk to some pretty cool people, like me :) discord.gg/ESUpRVxbKx Thanks a lot to the really cool people that made the discord server
is it okay to just be a spectator in the server? im no musician, programmer or pixel artist but the thing of recreating WHOLE GAME from memory sounds just so cool!
Now we just need someone else whose never played Undertale to listen to this a few times and then create it from memory and on and on it goes like a game of telephone
Not all of them, though with all the leitmotifs it feels like it, only Finale, His Theme, The Choice, and Undertale (main theme) were made from Memory.
Considering how vast and different the results of this game turn out depending on how you play and what path you take, hell this is pretty much a reality
this is actually true except its actually every playthrough is different and lots of stuff happens depending on your actions in previous playthroughhs and such
That's the power of *Being so bored that you decided to memorize the entire soundtrack or just too addicted to undertale even after it's golden era, which I say it's still pretty good but lost somw relevance these days but we still have deltarune chapter 3 going to come out soon. tough Undertale it's still a total banger and probably no game can recreate that type success, the same could be said about SpongeBob lmao*
@@nicolaslinopereira677It’s played on a real guitar in a laid back feel, so yes, the timing was less straight. Edit: The other person is correct. Home is played on the SGM soundfont, while “Undertale” is the one that is played live.
The thing that I find the most interesting about this is how often the first part that slips from your memory is any sort of harmonization of the main line. In general there's a solid grasp on the actual main melodic line, but in songs that feature a prominent harmony line, like ghost fight and snowy, it's more often just a doubled up version of the main melody.
Oh fun fact!: Toby (at least I believe) wrote all of his songs as they appear in Undertale without any major additions or changes to his first writing! All except for the song, “Undertale,” which I think he rewrote like… 5 times? I think? (And also Megalovaina which he wrote years prior but I think most people know that one…)
@@dylandoesstuff5463 you forgot he also remade Spear of Justice because he felt like the first version didn't sound enough like "getting heroically punched in the face"
You don't even have to mod: it's just ogg vorbis files. You can replace them. Heck, you can even make them lossless by replacing them with ogg flac files.
@@cosmicline, "ogg" is the file format, "vorbis" is the format of the audio itself. What I am saying is, you can just replace those with any other .ogg files and it will work. It doesn't even have to be vorbis, it can be pcm or flac as well.
@@rosesapling72 True, but most of this person's problems were with where each melodic segment starts and ends. The main pitch problem is going from F#-D instead of F#-C# in the beginning tho, which is almost definitely related to the song being out of tune (I made the mistake myself when first playing the song from memory) Edit: the left hand is a total shitshow, but it's not a problem of being out of tune, more forgetting what note goes where
I love how it starts off so strong and then it gets to Fallen Down and really does feel like you fell and bumped your head a little too hard Heartache is giving me Somari vibes
@@Finity2010-ud2rl its a common theme for most of the ruins themes to be in 3/4 like Ruins, Heartache and Fallen Down. Either it was intentional or Toby just really liked 3/4 when he made the ruins.
As a person with a dogshit memory, I’m like 90% sure that all of these are almost exact. In all seriousness, all of these comments saying you got things wrong are so stupid. These people have the actual soundtrack on standby just to compare and are so upset that you got something wrong, when the whole point of this is it’s supposed to be a little bit off, it’s FROM YOUR MEMORY! This is very impressive, I think you did a great job!
@@Luce55555 I made this comment after seeing a few comments complaining about how Home was in 4/4 and not 3/4. One of them even insulted this guy’s intelligence, and used a slur, and I just felt like that was completely unnecessary for a video in which the entire point is that it isn’t 100% accurate
I’ve never played undertale in my life but “fallen down” was so obviously off idk how you’re calling people stupid for not being stupid lmao. It’s like “you’re smarter than me therefore you’re dumb”
@@Mona-.- I’m not calling people stupid, I’m saying the comments people are making are stupid. The whole point of the video is that it’s a little off, and people that are genuinely upset about it are a little annoying.
Don't assume that people are literally listening to the original tracks so that they can point out the differences lol. I've just listened to the soundtrack enough in the past that the differences stand out to me, and some of them are pretty noticeable. I'm not complaining about it though, I do think the fact that they did this at all, with some of it being pretty close, is impressive
What surprises me is how well you remembered the sounds going on in the 'back' if that makes sense... like I'm pretty sure that's the perfect low droning sound in 'Once Upon a Time' for example
@@__aa__ well they said “low droning sound” which leads me to believe they’re talking about the bass But I guess the harmonies would be a more fitting way to describe it.
I see a lot of negative comments, I think they missed the point here. This is really well done and I want to give it a try now to see how well I remember them
It’s honestly impressive how many times fallen down manages to switch between 4/4, 3/4 and 2/4 within such a short time. Falling down the time signatures fr 10/10
"i only listened to the originals 2 or 3 times maximum" if that's true, you're exceptionally skilled and talented, damn. i haven't listened to undertale's ost in a good while, but there aren't many places in this recreation that strike me as being off. bravo!
@@Legendnewerthey said perfectly good, not perfect i swear some people in this comment section are acting like they're phd level conductors or something it's not that deep these are really good for being completely from memory
@@Legendnewer nah tbh I do know something about music since I finished music school, and most of those are pretty accurate. Tempo or extra instruments are a bit off in majority of them, but it still is impressive
Most of it is intuition so its honestly not that hard. I mean, you can hear if its wrong, so its just a lot of trial and error if youre doing it from memory
@@Kooczsiyes, and that ends up with the tracks that aren't the main one being often a little bit off from the original, but it's not that noticeable anyways is impressive
wait this is actually so well made. despite there being lil deviations from the original OST, you can definitely tell it’s undertale and which song specifically! your variation of ruins is so good tho omg- keep up the good work!!
The specifics got kinda muddied, but all the basic melodies are for the most part intact. Really speaks to how iconic and memorable Toby fox's work is.
this is close enough for me not to completely disassociate it from the actual soundtrack, but wrong enough in some parts to make me feel like I’m losing my mind. good job!
WHAT ARE Y'ALL BLABBING ABOUT??? BRO'S MEMORY IS MORE THAN FINE... well except for the fact that some songs were a bit "cranky", BUT STILL... THAT'S IMPRESSIVE AS HECK.
8:19 Hearing Ghost Firght with these sound fonts made me realize that the song REALLY sounds like a Touhou OST and now I can't unhear it lol. It's probably not even a coincidence considering how much Toby likes Zun's music. Very cool find.
You fall down and meet Flowey, who tricks you and then Toriel saves you. She guides you through the ruins until she abandons you but tells you to stay where you are. You venture through and encounter various monsters before making your way to Home. Toriel shows you inside and you go to bed. Then when you wake up, you ask her about how to leave and she goes to the basement. You go down to find out she is going to destroy the exit but you fight her and she makes you promise to not return once leaving. You walk outside and meet Sans, and then hide behind a lamp. Papyrus talks to Sans and then runs away after various jokes. You wonder around until you come face to face with Papyrus, who runs off. You then follow him and Sans, through his puzzles until you reach Snowdin. And I’m not doing this
@@MrGamerDoesVids You walk through the fog after Snowdin to battle Papyrus. After losing to him multiple times, he lets you go to Waterfall. In Waterfall, you need to avoid Undyne, while being followed by Monster Kid, a character really addicted to seeing Undyne. Almost nearly dying multiple times, you find yourself almost at Hotland, when all of a sudden Undyne appears and attacks you. After outrunning her, you escape to Hotland and pour water on Undyne. She leaves. You find Alphys. She states that she has been watching you and cheering you on the whole time, and then Mettaton enters and makes you do a gameshow. Alphys secretly helps you and then accidentally gets caught. Mettaton leaves and you go through Hotland. Mettaton does a sick music number before you reach the MTT hotel. All of a sudden, the floor breaks. You need to do Papyrus’ color puzzle. If you don’t finish it, you’ll be lit on fire by a firewall (HAHA FUNNY) Alphys disables the Firewall and you get to the hotel. You go through the core to find the exit and when you do you end up at THE HALL. Sans judges you and says that while you did some bad things, you’re in the clear. You go to battle Asgore and he breaks the Mercy button. After battling him, he asks if you forgive him. Either option, he dies from Flowey. You battle Photoshop/Omega Flowey and you win by using the souls power. You reach the barrier and win.
uhdeR talE, my favorite! i genuinely believe that if somehow all recordings of undertale and deltarune music disappeared, we'd still be able to recover them entirely just from our memory. this just proves it.
The fact you're able to piece together the basic elements of these soundtracks for memory is wonderful! Even if you get some things off it still sounds vaguely like I'm listening to the ost. People with a more trained ear definitely would hear the difference but this is honestly alot better than I could do honestly
It's almost as if the intro is carried heavily by the sample used and it's basic ass shit a three year old can remember. it's the rest of the song that takes some work.
@@yomama9390 Look, I don't really understand how to make music- I've tried and while I can get some sort of result, it's never anything that I would say is great or anything. I wouldn't personally be able to listen to that song, understand the different notes, and then be able to do that despite having learned a bit about how music is written. I'm impressed by the entire video, and my comment doesn't mean to say that the rest of it isn't impressive. I think you're frustrated that I'm impressed by something simple, and, well, yeah I am both impressed by the simple similarities as well as the many other more complex sounding songs that are replicated there. I wasn't making a mutually exclusive statement.
God, this really makes you realise how many times you’ve listened to the UT OST when you can say that “yeah, “Uwa!! So Temperate” is pretty accurate, but the dynamics are just a _little_ bit off” and notice when the tempo is even slightly wrong. Like, bro, I clicked on this video to enjoy the music someone made from memory, not to have my obsessed ass note EVERY SINGLE SONG. 8 years of this game is finally rubbing off on me. You’re just lucky I wasn’t there RIGHT at day 1, lol.
the slow attack/fadey notes in once upon a time, the lack of swing in ghost fight, it's all so apparent after hearing and obsessing over the originals so many times
Heartache: ❌️ Headache: ✅️ In all seriousness this was miles better than anything i expected and in no way could i have done anything better. Congrarulations on you and your memory and ability to make incredibly good sounding music.
@@byenovaeditsok? Do it yourself then if it pissed you off _that_ much. As a music nerd too it was still amazing he did all this FROM MEMORY. Idiots everywhere istg.
I’ve been an Undertale fan since the beginning and Fallen Down gave me this feeling of, like… imagine you’re about to jump and you realize your feet are glued down. If that makes any sense to anyone else
Suprisingly not bad. Honestly i expected it to be a meme, but you did an awesome work. Even from memory they sound nice. Now i want to mod undertale with this ost, so someone playing would have this "something is wrong but what?" feeling :)
there should be an undertale au where the entire game, including ost, characters, dialogue, map and story are all recreated by memory edit: wow, at this point, my comment's probably gonna be on one of those "how it was made" videos of how Undermentia was made and where it all started O_o
Everything in Undertale is memorable. Their characters, the music, the sounds, the plot, the mysteries... It just sticks in your mind. It's been 9 years since it released and I still remember everything. I'm dying to play Deltarune once it's fully released. Nice video bud!
The whole time listening to this I'm like "NO YOU'RE SO CLOSE" or "ADGEH WHAT IS THAT" but sometimes I do the face you do when you bite into a lemon. I enjoyed the video!!
THIS LEGIT GOES SO HARD. This is such an interesting idea for a project and I love how the vibes of the songs are generally the same but it feels so refreshing to listen to with the parts that are different...love this so much, keep it up youre awesome
Being able to replicate sans is a big skill, I can never remember how that song goes for the life of me. ....which means that this one might be wrong and I completely missed that.
This is exactly what i've been needing.... i've been thinking about an undertale from memory project for months but never committed to making more than one or two tracks
it cannot be stressed enough how iconic and phenomenal the soundtrack (the whole game tbh) really is. like legit it’s been years since i watched or played anything undertale related and i can still hum or pick out any song you throw at me from this ost. it’s actually insane.
![[TAS] Undertale: Genocide Ending speedrun in 57:56.83](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2clzSf7dI8I/mqdefault.jpg)
Hello hi :)
I wanted to say to y'all that THERE'S AN OFFICIAL DISCORD SERVER FOR THE "UNDERMENTIA PROJECT"
In there you can help us to recreate the ENTIERETY of Undertale (as in Music, Art, Programming, etc) just BY MEMORY!!!!!
Oh just u know talk to some pretty cool people, like me :)
discord.gg/ESUpRVxbKx
Thanks a lot to the really cool people that made the discord server
does your save file also occasionally get deleted while playing undermentia?
is it okay to just be a spectator in the server? im no musician, programmer or pixel artist but the thing of recreating WHOLE GAME from memory sounds just so cool!
@@x1ere yeah pretty much
Now, I dont know the context of this project but strictly speaking, is this legal?
@@user-ib1ir1co1lI’m not sure on context either, but I’d assume it’s like a fangame/au for Undertale, they’re pretty common and seem legal
Undertale but someone moved all my furniture a centimeter to the left when I wasn't looking
this is so funny
This is it, the funniest undertale comment
you just took away my ability to breathe from laughing
actually accurate, confused because it's different but even more confused because it's terribly familiar
we were taken to the same place friend
fallen down several flights of stairs
omori refernece
@@qiuxinyunb i never even played omori lol just thought it sounded like that
Mari?!
@@qiuxinyunb It was something
@@Raadidas something... wicked? (i have now turned this into an ultrakill reference)
Now we just need someone else whose never played Undertale to listen to this a few times and then create it from memory and on and on it goes like a game of telephone
does such person even exist
@@marusiaskrynnyk7489 One can only hope not, but almost assuredly they do
@@marusiaskrynnyk7489 im only here cause my brother likes undertale- never played myself
@@marusiaskrynnyk7489I know a guy dw bro
@@maevesmith948hey guys, i have not played undertale but i unfortunately also suck at piano. onto the next hunt
Hearing fallen down in 4/4 sounds like when you’re trying to remember a word that’s on the tip of your tongue
That one really messed me up lol
ohhhh so that's the thing that was messed up there, I couldn't put my finger on it
@@Eagle-Flyit's also off-key
@@tamoozbr main thing is that they put a "d flat" instead of a "c" in the "f c f c" pattern
Can you explain what should I try to listen for the diference ?
Undementia
oh no i forgo
* by the way...
* ... i was going to say something, but i forgot.
* it's a day outside
* flowers. birds.
* days, these.. kids should be hell.
*so.. wanna have time?
@@ButterscotchCinnamonPIE 😂
@@ButterscotchCinnamonPIE BIRDS???? (yes im a pm sleeper agent)
Fun fact, Toby fox too made all his songs from memory
Lmao this actually got me exhaling
Gad dammit
Not all of them, though with all the leitmotifs it feels like it, only Finale, His Theme, The Choice, and Undertale (main theme) were made from Memory.
oh now this one took me a second
what!?!?!??!...
i dont know how to explain this, but this feels like the undertale soundtrack made in the style of the undertale soundtrack
yeah that makes sense
checks out, yeah
undertale²
Why does this make sense 😭😭
This shouldn’t make sense but it does, how did u do that-
When they said don't forget, they were talking to you pal
When they said "I'm with you in the dark" they were talking to you pal >:)
this is genuinely the most funny joke here
Had me cracking up omfg
LMAO
😭😭😭😭
I don't know why in comments many people write about the bad memory, because this almost perfect
Same I'm almost disappointed with how close it is 😅
@@YellowSabrefr
No I was so confused because they all sound almost 90% accurate.
@@noahlani6480 as a musical nerd it was so close i was disappointed
@@noahlani6480 exept fallen down
Every copy of Undertale is personalized
Jeez, I want this to be real creepy pasta
Considering how vast and different the results of this game turn out depending on how you play and what path you take, hell this is pretty much a reality
this is actually true except its actually every playthrough is different and lots of stuff happens depending on your actions in previous playthroughhs and such
@@rebett0 how a game can become a pasta that scared?
( CREEPY pasta.)
Sorry, I couldnt help it.
wait until they hear about Fun Value...
Lebron James reportedly thought Fallen Down was in 4/4 🤦🏿♂️
What is it?
@@Astatine16 3/4
@@Astatine16time signature?
@@MappingEnjoyerYeah
Lebron James reportedly did Not Swing Home
Remembering all these tunes is genuinely so fucking impressive, I’d have a stroke on sans theme
That's the power of *Being so bored that you decided to memorize the entire soundtrack or just too addicted to undertale even after it's golden era, which I say it's still pretty good but lost somw relevance these days but we still have deltarune chapter 3 going to come out soon. tough Undertale it's still a total banger and probably no game can recreate that type success, the same could be said about SpongeBob lmao*
@@paolaplana5957 peepoTalk
@@paolaplana5957do you possibly know when delta is dropping another chapter?
@@remy-hl1nr No. I'm just a fan.
@@paolaplana5957 ohh okay. sorry for the inconvenience!!
It's funny how the worse mistake in home is that the notes are way too well timed
yes, it’s not swing
@@lildarian Don't think the original was? If I remember correctly toby fox just purposedly mistimed some notes to make it feel authentic
@@nicolaslinopereira677it’s swung
@@nicolaslinopereira677It’s played on a real guitar in a laid back feel, so yes, the timing was less straight.
Edit: The other person is correct. Home is played on the SGM soundfont, while “Undertale” is the one that is played live.
fr
Bros memory: 😢
Bros music making skills: 😈
Quite the opposite
@@Scbalq Ouch.
@@Scbalq rude and for what
@@Scbalqinacurate
@@online2223double c actually
My favourite part of that is that it honestly *does* sound like it was made by memory and it's also totally recognisable.
Bro can cook without even readings the recipe
This is the most creative brainrot comment I've seen.
@@pancakeperson8905næh dud i? Maor ɓr6÷10=2
is that the black silence (i am immensely blind tl anything but project moon content)
update: checked your banner, it is indeed the black silence
grammar
@@SimpStuff he is a grade nine fixer im sure his grammar will get better
Enemy Approaching ❌
Rival Arriving ✅
Foe Encounter
@@autumn_sunday Villain appearing
Threat confronting
@@DishonorableMentions452 Hater coming
Op opposition
The thing that I find the most interesting about this is how often the first part that slips from your memory is any sort of harmonization of the main line. In general there's a solid grasp on the actual main melodic line, but in songs that feature a prominent harmony line, like ghost fight and snowy, it's more often just a doubled up version of the main melody.
Tbf, melody is real easy to get right. Correct harmonization makes me tear my hair out
nobody talkin about the fact Uwa!! So Temperate is spot on until the extra instruments come on
Same for Ghost Fight
i unironically prefer this version of uwa temperate than the og
@@omiaderaSame it's so groovy
@@aluni4045no but it’s close enough
Uwa so temperate might actually be perfect though. Ghost Fight is off if you listen for it
@@eyesackEfBoE i noticed that too it's just such a minuscule change i think we can overlook it
This feels like a beta version of the OST, like these are the very first versions of the songs before they were remade into the real version
Oh fun fact!:
Toby (at least I believe) wrote all of his songs as they appear in Undertale without any major additions or changes to his first writing! All except for the song, “Undertale,” which I think he rewrote like… 5 times? I think?
(And also Megalovaina which he wrote years prior but I think most people know that one…)
@@dylandoesstuff5463 except alphys, undynes and hotlands theme, we have the beta versions of those
@@ModdingskylandsOh shoot thanks!
@@dylandoesstuff5463 you forgot he also remade Spear of Justice because he felt like the first version didn't sound enough like "getting heroically punched in the face"
@@dylandoesstuff5463another fun fact Hearthache was supposed to be Jevil theme
i cant lie this version of uwa so temperate genuinely fucks so hard
And it genuinely sounds like it came from the game
It's the same for me, especially the beginning
imagine modding your friend's game replacing the soundtrack with this and then gaslighting them into thinking that's how it always was
You don't even have to mod: it's just ogg vorbis files. You can replace them. Heck, you can even make them lossless by replacing them with ogg flac files.
@@ApertureSciencePsychowhat does that last sentence mean? im not good at that kind of stuff so i don’t really understand
@@cosmicline, "ogg" is the file format, "vorbis" is the format of the audio itself. What I am saying is, you can just replace those with any other .ogg files and it will work. It doesn't even have to be vorbis, it can be pcm or flac as well.
@@ApertureSciencePsycho i see, thank you
i love myhouse.wad
Fallen down ❌
Stumbled up ✅
Great vid btw
lmao
Stood up ✅
@@LittleSans876 Ascended skyward ✅
@@Maglor97 fabricated into sky
@@Maglor97 rose to the sky
Okay but you did “uwa! so temperate” IDENTICAL
LITERALLYYYYYYY LIKE WHY IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT IT HELLO???????????
Yeah I was impressed by how close it was
Ghost fight was pretty close too
Most of these are spot on but bro forgot how Fallen Down sounds
its also placed deliberately out of tune which probably helps the confusion
@@rosesapling72 True, but most of this person's problems were with where each melodic segment starts and ends. The main pitch problem is going from F#-D instead of F#-C# in the beginning tho, which is almost definitely related to the song being out of tune (I made the mistake myself when first playing the song from memory)
Edit: the left hand is a total shitshow, but it's not a problem of being out of tune, more forgetting what note goes where
Actually i think unnecessary tension is worse
It was pretty close until 2:50
But honestly… it kinda slaps anyway. Not something I’d give Toriel though.
Right? I love this but fallen down physically hurt me
Human, i remember you're undertale ost
human, i forgot
Human
@@howisthis8849 human, i forgor 💀
Human, I remember you was conflicted
It's like he's in some sort of snowgrave
I love how it starts off so strong and then it gets to Fallen Down and really does feel like you fell and bumped your head a little too hard
Heartache is giving me Somari vibes
This version of Fallen down does sound kinda good tho
I was not ready for 4/4 fallen down but here we are.
Here We Are would be a bit later
Wait, Fallen Down isn't in 4/4?
@@Finity2010-ud2rl its a common theme for most of the ruins themes to be in 3/4 like Ruins, Heartache and Fallen Down. Either it was intentional or Toby just really liked 3/4 when he made the ruins.
Every song is in 4/4 if you're brave enough.
@@talentneeded3003my songs are all 1/1
the fact all the compositions are almost accurate, just goes to show how memorable the music from undertale is
And to an even greater extent, how great the music skills of this creator is
As a person with a dogshit memory, I’m like 90% sure that all of these are almost exact.
In all seriousness, all of these comments saying you got things wrong are so stupid. These people have the actual soundtrack on standby just to compare and are so upset that you got something wrong, when the whole point of this is it’s supposed to be a little bit off, it’s FROM YOUR MEMORY!
This is very impressive, I think you did a great job!
the comments you're talking about are just pointing out the differences between the two
@@Luce55555 I made this comment after seeing a few comments complaining about how Home was in 4/4 and not 3/4. One of them even insulted this guy’s intelligence, and used a slur, and I just felt like that was completely unnecessary for a video in which the entire point is that it isn’t 100% accurate
I’ve never played undertale in my life but “fallen down” was so obviously off idk how you’re calling people stupid for not being stupid lmao. It’s like “you’re smarter than me therefore you’re dumb”
@@Mona-.- I’m not calling people stupid, I’m saying the comments people are making are stupid. The whole point of the video is that it’s a little off, and people that are genuinely upset about it are a little annoying.
Don't assume that people are literally listening to the original tracks so that they can point out the differences lol. I've just listened to the soundtrack enough in the past that the differences stand out to me, and some of them are pretty noticeable. I'm not complaining about it though, I do think the fact that they did this at all, with some of it being pretty close, is impressive
ok... ruins isn't too accurate but holy FUCK does it go hard you COOKED with that version. seriously dude its SO GOOD
Fr. The ruins theme sounds better than the original!
it kind of feels like if ruins was in celeste??
what do you mean by not being accurate tho? the melody is the same, but obviously is a different rendition of the song. Very recognizable
@@sierranicholes6712ruins in Celeste yea
It's pretty good, missed a whole phrase in the verse and a couple turnarounds in the chorus, but got the jist of it
Everywhere at the end of Mt. Ebott
lollllllll
What surprises me is how well you remembered the sounds going on in the 'back' if that makes sense... like I'm pretty sure that's the perfect low droning sound in 'Once Upon a Time' for example
You would be referring to the left hand (if referring to a piano) or the “bass” part of the song
u mean the harmonies????
@@__aa__ well they said “low droning sound” which leads me to believe they’re talking about the bass But I guess the harmonies would be a more fitting way to describe it.
I see a lot of negative comments, I think they missed the point here. This is really well done and I want to give it a try now to see how well I remember them
I dont think theyre negative. They jest, but its in good humour
I see literally zero negative comments.
@@tinycandleman6020 sort by new
he did ghost fight without the swing rhythm which destroyed the whole groove tho
@@byenovaedits swing can be tricky
0:00 “On one occasion”
1:24 “The beginning menu”
1:53 “Your top mate”
2:22 “Dropped downward”
3:23 “Catacombs”
5:00 “Uwu!! Very Mild”
5:58 “Expectation”
6:20 “Unneeded Pressure”
6:39 “Foe approximating”
7:45 “Spirit Battle”
8:45 “Decisiveness”
9:28 “House”
11:07 “House (Musical chest)”
12:45 “Cardiac Pain”
14:36 “saness”
15:26 “Nya-ha-ha!!”
16:05 “Frosty"
17:44 “Uwu!! Very Festive”
18:10 “Houndbasso”
18:18 “Mystical spot”
Cadiac pain ahahgahahagagagagag
@SoThisIsMyCat nice cat
dying at cardiac pain lmao
Frosty instead of snow 🥶
“your top mate” 😳
"Uwa!! So Temperate" is LITERALLY THE DAMN SAME, YOU'RE INSANE WITH IT!!!
RUINS IS ACTUALLY FIRE THO
RUINS IS INSANELY GOOD
Fr
SERIOUSLY!!!!
literally was just thinking this!!!
fr
It’s honestly impressive how many times fallen down manages to switch between 4/4, 3/4 and 2/4 within such a short time. Falling down the time signatures fr
10/10
I don’t think 10/10 was a time signature in there
@markbark94 you'd be shocked lol (I'm joking)
Touhou time signatures
"i only listened to the originals 2 or 3 times maximum"
if that's true, you're exceptionally skilled and talented, damn.
i haven't listened to undertale's ost in a good while, but there aren't many places in this recreation that strike me as being off.
bravo!
The fact that a lot of these are perfectly good covers is a testament to how catchy and memorable Undertale’s OST is.
It’s “perfect” if you don’t know music theory, but yeah they captured the main essence of the songs
@@Legendnewerthey said perfectly good, not perfect
i swear some people in this comment section are acting like they're phd level conductors or something it's not that deep these are really good for being completely from memory
@@Legendnewer nah tbh I do know something about music since I finished music school, and most of those are pretty accurate. Tempo or extra instruments are a bit off in majority of them, but it still is impressive
@@Legendnewermost normal listeners don't know music theory so it's fine.
Also it's kinda repetitive too. Let's not forget all the times Toby used Napsta's song
This is honestly really impressive. I can memorize melodies, but full on polyphonic scores is a whole different world of difficult
Most of it is intuition so its honestly not that hard. I mean, you can hear if its wrong, so its just a lot of trial and error if youre doing it from memory
@@Kooczsiyes, and that ends up with the tracks that aren't the main one being often a little bit off from the original, but it's not that noticeable
anyways is impressive
@@cretkrat i wonder if he listened to each song before remaking them, or if he just remembered them all from the start
@@Kooczsi You can hear if its wrong, until your memory is replaced by what you are composing.
wait this is actually so well made. despite there being lil deviations from the original OST, you can definitely tell it’s undertale and which song specifically! your variation of ruins is so good tho omg- keep up the good work!!
The specifics got kinda muddied, but all the basic melodies are for the most part intact. Really speaks to how iconic and memorable Toby fox's work is.
Seeing this wall fills you with DEMENTINATION
Deterdemention 🙏
Deterdeterdeterdeterdeterdemendeterdetermination
i forgot the word
The temmie nation 🥰
dementia nation🔥🔥
in 2025 undertale will be 10 years old. let that sink in.
STOP DONT SAY THAT STOP STOP STOP
fml dude im nostalgia-diseased as fuck
@@therealaji 😈
WHAT??? THERES NO WAY
this is close enough for me not to completely disassociate it from the actual soundtrack, but wrong enough in some parts to make me feel like I’m losing my mind. good job!
Real
WHAT ARE Y'ALL BLABBING ABOUT??? BRO'S MEMORY IS MORE THAN FINE... well except for the fact that some songs were a bit "cranky", BUT STILL... THAT'S IMPRESSIVE AS HECK.
yeah i do not get what people expect. The attempt here is incredibly impressive
@@liaspooked4980maybe I'm just autistic but I could've remade these way better if I had knowledge of music software 😭
@@chimmychuck humanity's hubris will always lead it back to its downfall
@@liaspooked4980 realest reply
@@chimmychuckalright sure
8:19 Hearing Ghost Firght with these sound fonts made me realize that the song REALLY sounds like a Touhou OST and now I can't unhear it lol. It's probably not even a coincidence considering how much Toby likes Zun's music. Very cool find.
Fallen down in 4/4 is cursed af 😭
fr, it hurt me to listen to it
i liked it tho
Well kid this sure was a beneathadventure
You mean "Cave Story"?
@@wowalamoiz9489no I replaced under and tale with beneath and adventure
“Well chum you could say this was a deep-narrative”
-Ariel the Meatman after beating the forgiveness route
Don't you mean UnderTail?
@@Hadeth_a_stepa Heck no. Go away
Okay dude remembered the Earthbound Your Name Please in the background of Ghost Fight that's an awesome detail good job bro.
Determination sounds like what an unlicensed NES port of Undertale would sound like
Someone made a game boy version of the ruins area which is the closest to this idea.
@@Red_Chicken_Gaming so the undertale demo?
NESS port⁉️
funny cus toby made nes and snes rom hacks before he made undertale
SANS?!1?1!1!?
After the ost from memory you make the whole game's story from memory and then put both together to get an eerily familiar but completely unknown game
I dunno I don’t think a flower turning into a goat and trying to destroy the universe would be completely unknown
You fall down and meet Flowey, who tricks you and then Toriel saves you. She guides you through the ruins until she abandons you but tells you to stay where you are. You venture through and encounter various monsters before making your way to Home. Toriel shows you inside and you go to bed. Then when you wake up, you ask her about how to leave and she goes to the basement. You go down to find out she is going to destroy the exit but you fight her and she makes you promise to not return once leaving.
You walk outside and meet Sans, and then hide behind a lamp. Papyrus talks to Sans and then runs away after various jokes. You wonder around until you come face to face with Papyrus, who runs off. You then follow him and Sans, through his puzzles until you reach Snowdin. And I’m not doing this
@@MrGamerDoesVids fun fact: if you don’t hide, papyrus says “IS THAT A HUMAN” or something and sans says “yeah” and papyrus says “COOL” and leaves
@@MrGamerDoesVids You walk through the fog after Snowdin to battle Papyrus. After losing to him multiple times, he lets you go to Waterfall. In Waterfall, you need to avoid Undyne, while being followed by Monster Kid, a character really addicted to seeing Undyne. Almost nearly dying multiple times, you find yourself almost at Hotland, when all of a sudden Undyne appears and attacks you. After outrunning her, you escape to Hotland and pour water on Undyne. She leaves.
You find Alphys. She states that she has been watching you and cheering you on the whole time, and then Mettaton enters and makes you do a gameshow. Alphys secretly helps you and then accidentally gets caught. Mettaton leaves and you go through Hotland. Mettaton does a sick music number before you reach the MTT hotel. All of a sudden, the floor breaks. You need to do Papyrus’ color puzzle. If you don’t finish it, you’ll be lit on fire by a firewall (HAHA FUNNY) Alphys disables the Firewall and you get to the hotel. You go through the core to find the exit and when you do you end up at THE HALL. Sans judges you and says that while you did some bad things, you’re in the clear. You go to battle Asgore and he breaks the Mercy button.
After battling him, he asks if you forgive him. Either option, he dies from Flowey. You battle Photoshop/Omega Flowey and you win by using the souls power. You reach the barrier and win.
@@ezriha In the geno route?
undertale OST IS so rememberable that this whole thing sounds like cover for all undertale tracks
i love how either intentionally or unintentionally you put a lot more of gaster's motif into certain tracks! very fitting!
I was gonna say I've been checking through the comments looking for people mentioning it like "am I insane?? 😰 or am I actually hearing it" 😭😭
He has a motif?
@@rosiered6712it’s “Gaster’s Theme” from the sound test easter egg
Oh? Never noticed there's his motif hidden around, can you link some timestamps?
@@fernflowerss one i just noticed rn as i was listening is 4:38 !
uhdeR talE, my favorite!
i genuinely believe that if somehow all recordings of undertale and deltarune music disappeared, we'd still be able to recover them entirely just from our memory. this just proves it.
Though I'd rather Toby Fox be the one in charge of restoring the songs. You know, since he made them.
@@RadioactiveBluePlatypusIt’s a hypothetical
@@nintendovirtualboywastakenfsr good point.
Yes i sometimes wonder if I were taken on a magical trip back 200 years if I could recreate the soundtrack so I wouldnt have to live without it
@@RadioactiveBluePlatypus what if toby fox somehow disappeared too
The fact you're able to piece together the basic elements of these soundtracks for memory is wonderful! Even if you get some things off it still sounds vaguely like I'm listening to the ost. People with a more trained ear definitely would hear the difference but this is honestly alot better than I could do honestly
"ruins" is so freaking awesome, maybe I like this version more than original
very true
agreed!
It sounds almost exactly like ruins yellow for some reason
the intro to ghost fight literally sounded spot on
It's almost as if the intro is carried heavily by the sample used and it's basic ass shit a three year old can remember. it's the rest of the song that takes some work.
yo mama dropping the bombshell in this thread
@@yomama9390 bro who hurt you
@@yomama9390 Look, I don't really understand how to make music- I've tried and while I can get some sort of result, it's never anything that I would say is great or anything. I wouldn't personally be able to listen to that song, understand the different notes, and then be able to do that despite having learned a bit about how music is written.
I'm impressed by the entire video, and my comment doesn't mean to say that the rest of it isn't impressive. I think you're frustrated that I'm impressed by something simple, and, well, yeah I am both impressed by the simple similarities as well as the many other more complex sounding songs that are replicated there. I wasn't making a mutually exclusive statement.
@@chuuri4434 grow a brain
the fact u got the baselines so well is incredibly impressive
The audio being so faint adds to this being "from memory" as it literally sounds like its from a memory 😭
God, this really makes you realise how many times you’ve listened to the UT OST when you can say that “yeah, “Uwa!! So Temperate” is pretty accurate, but the dynamics are just a _little_ bit off” and notice when the tempo is even slightly wrong.
Like, bro, I clicked on this video to enjoy the music someone made from memory, not to have my obsessed ass note EVERY SINGLE SONG. 8 years of this game is finally rubbing off on me. You’re just lucky I wasn’t there RIGHT at day 1, lol.
the slow attack/fadey notes in once upon a time, the lack of swing in ghost fight, it's all so apparent after hearing and obsessing over the originals so many times
5:00 This is actually so accurate holy
Heartache: ❌️
Headache: ✅️
In all seriousness this was miles better than anything i expected and in no way could i have done anything better. Congrarulations on you and your memory and ability to make incredibly good sounding music.
It was SO WELL MADE
bro he literally made fallen down in 4/4
as a music nerd my heart literally stopped
ASPIRIN COMMERCIALS GIVE ME HEADACHES
@@byenovaeditsok? Do it yourself then if it pissed you off _that_ much. As a music nerd too it was still amazing he did all this FROM MEMORY. Idiots everywhere istg.
@@lovelysophxox i’m working on doing it rn
i’m also a music nerd
We need undertale but the songs, art, attacks, and dialoge are all from memory.
LMAOOOO that sounds like an amazing idea tbh
And item description
I've memorized most of the ost so hearing this is like a dream
I’ve been an Undertale fan since the beginning and Fallen Down gave me this feeling of, like… imagine you’re about to jump and you realize your feet are glued down. If that makes any sense to anyone else
My ass read the whole second half of the comment assuming you meant suicide
@@rosiered6712 I laughed so hard I started to choke on my own breath or however you say it
@@rosiered6712yeah same
@@rosiered6712 maybe we're subconsciously thinking of mt ebott
@@ampix4669 I too love choking on air XD
this is so fascinating to me. literally listening to this like watching my son's recital or something and cheering everytime he gets something right
THE WAY THAT UWA!! SO TEMPERATE WAS SO ACCURATE UNTIL THE HEAVY PERCUSSION PART
Uwa! so temperate is spot on
Uh okay?
@@ssamuueel ?
Who’s talking about STALIN-Grad here..?
i fr got jumpscared i was like "Ok this is just the regular song"
Suprisingly not bad. Honestly i expected it to be a meme, but you did an awesome work. Even from memory they sound nice.
Now i want to mod undertale with this ost, so someone playing would have this "something is wrong but what?" feeling :)
Do it!!!! I'd love a mod like that lol
I would totally play with this mod fr
fallen down but cursed
ummmm
Yeah it was crappier than others
@@canahmets.8216 :(
@@canahmets.8216meanie
It isn't bad but the rhythm is weird@@talentneeded3003
there should be an undertale au where the entire game, including ost, characters, dialogue, map and story are all recreated by memory
edit: wow, at this point, my comment's probably gonna be on one of those "how it was made" videos of how Undermentia was made and where it all started O_o
Undermentia
@@user-je8jf2hu6c is that a thing that actually exists?
Does it exist yet? Want to make it now
@@Personn117 do iiiiittttt i can play it on my yt channel and finally have something to make videos about
@@Personn117 you should!
ripping my bong so hard to this great work dude
I can't be the only one whos amazed by Ghost Fight, literally identical until the extra instruments, and even then its still pretty faithful
Dude can't fucking Swing, 0/10 once the melody comes in XDD
Not "dapperblook" but "formalguy"
I actually can not sit through ghost fight it’s that repulsive
@@timcellar9021wdm
it’s still a banger tbh
Ok but anyone who’s ever seen the sheet music for “sans.” knows this was VERY impressive
This is such a unique and hilarious concept I can't I believe I haven't seen something like this before. Great job!
The three most accurate in my opinion were:
1._Uwa!!So Temperate
2._Home (music box)
3._Dogbass
Wdym dogbass???
@@ssamuueel18:11
dogbass is NOT accurate 😭😭😭
@@kagandizlek3878 you may notice how they said “in my opinion”!! ^^
@@kel53y_ and im saying that (in my opinion) dogbass was not accurate
kinda cool how some of them are right on the money! its like listening to Undertale's OST in an alternate universe
Everything in Undertale is memorable. Their characters, the music, the sounds, the plot, the mysteries... It just sticks in your mind. It's been 9 years since it released and I still remember everything. I'm dying to play Deltarune once it's fully released. Nice video bud!
The whole time listening to this I'm like "NO YOU'RE SO CLOSE" or "ADGEH WHAT IS THAT" but sometimes I do the face you do when you bite into a lemon.
I enjoyed the video!!
depends on how much one enjoys the lemon
@@zoinkerspoinker4326 I doubt one might enjoy biting into a lemon because of the bitterness of the peel
@@therobbu what are you talking about? the peel is the best part!
somebody cooked here
help its burning
@@unchok_985
Call an ambulance
BUT NOT FOR ME
He forgot the recipe😔😔😔
But he still cooked🔥🔥🔥
He left Fallen Down in the oven for too long
@@LolCat361 your opinion is wrong
THIS LEGIT GOES SO HARD. This is such an interesting idea for a project and I love how the vibes of the songs are generally the same but it feels so refreshing to listen to with the parts that are different...love this so much, keep it up youre awesome
That bass on sans. is heavenly
agreed
it does, despite being so bass-ic
@@radiatingplasmidwho gave sans internet access
@@someonessecondaltaccount6932 call papyrus rn
fr
there were genuinely a few times i forgot i wasn't just listening to the actual soundtrack
I'm impressed at how good this is for someone who only listened to the soundtrack a few times. You must have a good memory.
3:23 gives off undertale yellow ruins in the first half
Shoot you're right
@@teasonm3617”shoot” hehehe
Ayo, Kris Deltarune (real)
Number 6 sounds pretty accurate. (Especially the first part.) Also LOVE sans cuz it sounds pretty unique!
LOVE? oh no
@@abdillahahmad7025D:
LOVE?!?!!
Every Under At The End of Tale... [this is such an amazing project and it sounds gorgeous]
Being able to replicate sans is a big skill, I can never remember how that song goes for the life of me.
....which means that this one might be wrong and I completely missed that.
definitely not the same as sans. but it's very close with it's own unique touch and i love it
This is exactly what i've been needing.... i've been thinking about an undertale from memory project for months but never committed to making more than one or two tracks
Hehe, all of this makes me curious about what a Undertale, But the entire game is made from memory would be like.
i really liked your take on the music box version of home. its just so... pretty
it cannot be stressed enough how iconic and phenomenal the soundtrack (the whole game tbh) really is. like legit it’s been years since i watched or played anything undertale related and i can still hum or pick out any song you throw at me from this ost. it’s actually insane.
ghost fight is almost on point, it’s just like half of the swing rythmn is gone
Uwa!! So Temperate was also accurate, before the percussion ofc
Unironically goated, my memory is like swiss cheese, but i hope you have inspired many with these, you certainly have with me you spiffy gentleman!!!
This version of Uwa!! So Temperate is HEAT
it’s temperate
this ost is like if only temmie created the game. its good overall
The middle of heartache is the most I've laughed this week, thank you
UWA!! SO TEMPERATE MADE MY SOUL ASCEND. THIS IS A REALLY GOOD REMAKE!!!
bro home music box and home are amazing as well
yeah but ghost fight, fallen down, and a few others sucked
@@byenovaeditsghost fight was amazing wtf r u talking about
@@V1DE0-STARZ i agree ghost fight was really good but it he completely removed the swing which ruined the whole groove