I VISITED CULLODEN AND IT BROKE MY HEART | Culloden Battlefield in Scotland
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2023
- I knew that visiting the Culloden Battlefield would be a difficult task emotionally. But the depth of grief, sense of loss and heartbreak that I felt there completely floored me!...
💖 I hope that you love the video!
Make sure to like, comment and subscribe 🥰💋
😍 PLEASE SUPPORT ME ON PATREON: / helenanista
🥰 Where else you can find me:
MY MAIN CHANNEL: / helenanista
WEBSITE: helenanista.com/
Instagram: / helena_nista_
Facebook: / helenaniestroj
-----
I VISITED CULLODEN AND IT BROKE MY HEART | Culloden Battlefield in Scotland
Visiting the Culloden Battlefield was an extremely emotional experience for me. I hope that I was able to convey the profound energy of that place in my video... 💕
Nice video Helena. It also showcases how talented you are. I would think that battlefield videos are such a different category from sexology videos at every level ( setting, lighting, continuation ,etc etc ) and your shifting from one to the other seems very seamless, congratulations!
Also, I wonder if you have visited a Commonwealth War Grave Cemetary in, say, Gallipoli or France yet. If not, I think the impact of all those men lying in rest might have an even bigger impact on you. Culloden is like every other battlefield visited a long time after the battle. These places are often so ordinary one wonders how anyone could fight, let alone die there. Buit that is history, and unfortunately it always repeats. But I agree- having visited it, Culloden is like Glencoe- a dark feeling place.
Thank you so much for your lovely message! 🥰 And no, I haven't visited the war graves in Gallipoli or France.
It's a very moving place. I am from Clan Robertson. The clan is famous for its association with the Battle of Culloden, where the Robertson's fought on the side of the Jacobite's, and also for their role in the Highland Uprisings, which resulted in the suppression of the clan and the imposition of severe restrictions on its members back in the eighteenth century. ^^
Oh wow, so much rich history in your family! 💕
A friend uploaded an interesting video on Culloden over on his channel recently. at Eerie Edinburgh, if you wish to watch 🙂 ^^@@helenanistavlogs
@@_renaissance.girl_ Thank you! 💕
This reminded me when i went to the cemetery and museum of the fallen heroes in world war 1 and 2 in France. It described how each soldier died in the war or how they were sabotaged and killed. History can bring a tear 😢 to your eye. I can see how this in Scotland can bring us tears too. Many moons ago on this history is painful. Tragedies and occurrences that we never knew now take place in our hearts. It can be heartbreaking. Thanks for sharing. 😢
That is so true! Thank you, Robert! 💕
Thank you for posting this video. Culloden is a very important and holy place for my family...a few of my direct ancestors are buried there. When I last visited the moor over twenty years ago, I was overwhelmed with emotion thinking about them. Your video brought back all those connections and all those feelings.
Thank you so much for sharing this! I can only imagine the grief of having your ancestors buried there... 😔💕
INTERESTING AS ALWAYS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MICHAEL K
Thank you! 💕
Thanks for sharing this video. I hope to see Culloden someday but your video might be the closet I will ever see, it was very nice to watch and made me ponder my ancestors that would have been there. I have long lost my Scottish accent as my family left to Ireland after the battle, then to Canada in the early 1800's, but it was nice to hear yours and view that pretty area they now rest. Thanks and take very good care.
Thank you so much for watching and for your lovely comment 🥰
Went there decades ago before much of the infrastructure was built on a rainy winters day & the brooding chill does make you sad, history for deep thinkers does hit home on the senses Helena dear.
Couldn't agree more!
I really love these vlogs… the filming, the music, your respect and curiosity handling the places and people, makes them so good to watch 😊
Thank you so much! 😃💕💕
Visiting a battlefield is something very special and getting emotional is a way of paying respect to the fallen soldiers RIP
You're right! 💕
Culloden is the most atmospheric place in Britain.I know it well and first visited when I was 7 yrs and remember my parents said I walked around in hushed awe.I clearly remember looking at the headstone of Mcdonald of Glengarry - where the clan chief and can still feel the tingle that went up my spine.Culloden moor used to be calles Drumossie moor at the time of the battle.I have a vivid imagination
Oh wow, what a beautiful memory you must have from that place! 😍
Helena - some places are magical - Scotland, Canada and Norway .You will never forget your visit to Culloden as long as you live❣❣@@helenanistavlogs
Helena, I have watched many travel blogs over time. I have to say how incredibly moved I was watching your video. I was actually in tears during your phase in the field hospital. Yes, the world is crazy but you are quite amazing and truly beautiful. Thank you. I’ll be watching your videos from now on. Smile 😊
Oh wow, thank you so much for your kind and lovely comment! It means the world to me to hear from people like you! 😃
And I do my best to portray the real experience that I'm having while filming. It's great to hear that not only images but also emotions come across in my videos 🥰💕
It’s a place full of souls, like all battlefields. The lives cut short, the energy remains and often, you can feel it. there were 1500 dead in a brutal hour long battle
Exactly! So true... 😥💕
Hey Helena ; How are you since your visit here ? This one was difficult to watch..I wanted to just give you a big hug...tell you " it's gonna be ok"....but there are no words for these emotions...they have to come out 😔 I won't insult you with cliches'... really touched me deeply ...so sad. .You've a young heart..and "old soul"..thank you Helena 🌷❤️🌷 Cf
Thank you so much, Charles! It wasn't easy to feel so deeply in Scotland. But ultimately it really enriched me and I'm so glad that I went there... 💕
In 1746 the 18-year old Donald Livingstone (Domnhull Molach) rescued the Stewart of Appin regimental banner at the Battle of Culloden and lived to tell the tale. Even though he was shot various times. My father was a 'Livingstone'. 🤔
Oh wow, thank you for sharing this!
This was not a war between England and Scotland but British red coats versus a Jacobite force. Even Lowland Scots had joined the British redcoats to defeat Charles Edward Stuart.
In some ways it can be regarded as another tentacle of the interminable wars between Protestant Britain and Catholic France. Heretics were already damned so their corporeal welfare was entirely irrelevant and they could be slaughtered without remorse or censure.
Yet most of the redcoats were English
@@janice506 yes but Scotland was divided about joining against government forces!
Tam absolutnie trzeba jechać!
💕
It’s truly heartbreaking my family was directly affected by this tragedy after the battle the highland clearances began and the highlanders like my great great grandfather were kicked off their land and forced to go to Canada
The heartlessness and brutality against the Scottish people back then was shocking and inexcusable... 😔💕
What a beautiful trip. Thank you for taking with you to experience something new to me. You are amazing and I wish you so many more great adventures.
Thank you so much! 😃😃
from a Saint, it is best not to trouble your heart ❤ or mind with such things but live your life in happiness 💖 through trial and tribulation the worlds 🌎 history will crush your spirit so take care of each individual self along the path to come forward as it always does with Love 💕
I think that it's important and enriching to learn history and to visit different places in the world 😉
Thank you for your sensible handling to walk there. Culloden (and some more of this battlefields) radiate such a sad and dark energy esp. when you´re alone and other people have gone
That's so true! The energy of grief and loss was very present 💕
Powinnam się zainteresować historią Szkocji🤔
Jest bardzo ciekawa!
If you are Scottish like me, Culloden Field is a sanctuary of grief we feel we need to burden upon ourselves with at least one visit, however hard it is and wow the place hits you first time. You conveyed amazingly, I thank you. Alba gu bràth
Oh wow, thank you so much for your lovely comment! That placed touched me deeply. I can't wait to be back in Scotland 💕
I visited Culloden in 1996 while on a Rotary Friendship tour. I was the only 1 of our party of 4 who walked part of the Battlefield. The wind was so strong that day I battled to walk. Was never sorry I walked that field.
It's an incredibly touching experience to be there in person! 💕
This battle was not between the English and Scots, it was over who ruled Britain, the Hanoverian or the Stuarts; personally I think the Stuarts had more of a claim, however the better army won. Many Scots fought for the Hanover King and many English fought for the Jacobites.
An uprising not a battle !
@@user-cz7kc1qs1w No mate; pretty sure it was a battle, even the name "Battle of Culloden"
So sad Helena I'm lost for words 🙏❤️
Thank you so much, Steven! This was a really difficult video to make... 💕
Holy cow, the minute this video started, I began crying out of nowhere, and I’m still crying, even though the video ended! I felt the loss, the sorrow, sadness and grief. It was overwhelming!!! Grateful I had tissues available.
Oh wow, what a powerful response! Thank you so much for sharing this! It sounds like this video really touched your heart! 💕🥰💕
At 5.26: The look in your eyes matches the thumbanil. Thank you for making this beautiful vlog.
Thank you so much for watching it 🥰💕
These videos are very relaxing, although I'm sorry it made you sad, human history is mainly just the story of us killing each other for stupid reasons.
That's so true!... Thank you so much for your kind comment 🥰💕
a genuinely spooky place to visit for sure !
I didn't find it spooky. Just full of sadness and grief for all the suffering and all the lives lost.
Wonderful Thank you so much for posting this. God Bless you.
Glad you enjoyed it! 🥰🥰
After watching this video I fully understand how you are feeling. It is so sad that even in those days men felt they had to kill others so they could be in charge. And now we have this idiot called Putin who still thinks the same way. In his mind it appears that it does not matter how many of his own men or those of another country die as long as he is in charge (power). Thank you for sharing these emotional videos with us.
Thank you so much for watching, Ray! And for your thoughts and insights... 💕
I feel the same way about Putin 😡
very good vlog. love the historical nature of this vlog
Many thanks! 🥰💕
Looks like you needed me there to comfort you. Let me be your travel companion
Thanks Tony, but I was fine on my own... 😉💕
You are so breathtaking baby! 😘
I knew the self-obsessed emotion and soppy music would reveal historical inaccuracies... The Jacobites weren't fighting the English. It wasn't Scotland vs England.
Very touching video presentation of your visit to Scotland. I was blessed to have visited Scotland twice in the early 80s . On one trip I did some hill walking in the Highlands with our local hosts and it was then I fell in love with this country. The most beautiful place I have ever been. Helena, I also play the piano and would love to learn the pieces you used as background music on this video. What were they? Thanks!
Thanks for sharing! I'm so happy to hear that you enjoyed my video! 😃💕
I absolutely loved exploring Scotland and I'm sure that I'll be back.
And all my background music is sourced from Epidemic Sound 😊
Pamięć jest bardzo ważn
Dokladnie! 🥰
In Dumfries there is a plaque on a building commemorating Charles Edward Stuarts journey North. They were not welcomed 0:44 in Dumfries
Also in Carlisle a plaque commemorating his journey North.
The presenter seems to be describing Culloden as E gland v Scotland. Not so The Campbells for instance stayed away. A nd re.ember the Highlanders got as far as Derby in England, The presenter seems unaware of this.
You must have missed it when I referred to the Jacobites a few times throughout this video.
The guide at Culloden was careful to point out to anyone who was listening, that the British Army did not consist entirely of Englishmen. I appreciate that there are some who would wish the narrative to be otherwise.
Yes, that's very clear to anyone. Why would you "wish the narrative to be otherwise"?... 🤔
Yet, the British are the ones who oppressed the Scottish nation for a very long time and that's undeniable after visiting Scotland even now after all these years.
@@helenanistavlogs "British"? You must mean English surely.
💕😔💕
💕
Why u sad ur a brave lady and lioness
I explain in the video why I'm sad.
A very moving video and I know I would feel the same.
The only thing I could even compare this feeling would be visiting Gettysburg in Pennsylvania
Yet I know I had ancestry at both 😢
This place touched me deeply... 💕
Haunting, and deeply moving. While the Jacobite's did lose the battle, they may have won the war. About 40 years later, a substancial number of Highlanders had already begun to immigrate to American Shores. And no doubt as Americans, they fought for the freedom of a new independent nation. Just saying the old adage of keeping ones enemies close, was not observed here.
Yes, indeed... 💕
Very glad you fought off the Brits in the now USA
.you were a rable and the Brits only lost because they had scurvy. Thank God we have Canada and no,you yanks can't buy or steal our water . We are the 2nd largest country in the world.(after Russia)
You ,the U.S. are the 4th largest (after China)
BE. WORRIED! ! !
You deleted my reply.
I felt every ghost there and an incredible deep sadness
Yes, such a deeply touching experience to be there... 💕
Beautiful moments to share ❤
Yes, absolutely! 😍
@@helenanistavlogs ✨❤️
If it did, well, it goes to show what beautiful warm heart you have Helena! The English are famous for making widows and orphans of children not just in Scotland but in Eire too as with the rest of the globe!
That's sadly so true... 😞
The British army was filled with Scots, Irish and Welsh willing to take the kings shilling
Highland Coo's not Cow's
Oh, I see... 😉
I suppose I'd say, in terms of disliking the english. I am English, but my ancestors on these Islands are Scotish, and further back they were Nords who settled far in the north. This was an internal thing, northern-western europeans were in a way a single peoples that were made up of many peoples. To dig into the indigenous world of Britain and general western-northern europe I imagine you know well enough yourself, it's endlessly layered and connected in so many ways.
Yes, so true!
I was really taken by surprise that I found Culloden a very difficult place to visit. It seemed full of sadness and sorrow and somehow Godforsaken.
Yes, I felt the same! 💕
Remember those poor highlanders were fighting for the restoration of an absolutist, anti-anti parliament monarchy
@@helenanistavlogs
If they were fighting British rule why were wanting to put a Stuart back as a king of Britain
@@johnbaird4912They we’re also fighting for their way of life . Not to be uprooted by a bunch of corrupt cretins from Westminster who used every piece of anti Highlander propaganda at their disposal to eliminate them and to ultimately use the highlands as a playground for their rich and venomous lying lords and to use as how they wanted . It’s actually bemusing that regiments like the black watch get to walk away from this unblemished when in truth regiments like that were absolute traitors to this great country . Absolute fools who put religion and English gold in line before their own Scottish brothers . Time has now shown how much these traitorous red coat scots were used as well as many other reasons and outcomes . Imagine going against your own folk because of some bull shit propaganda about religion and corrupt politics from down south. In a way things haven’t changed in the world because people are either so gullible or easily frightened
@@helenanistavlogsI am dissapointed to hear your misguided comments about the English. Unfortunately, like many people including many Brits, you don't fully understand the history behind the battle of Culloden. If you had read the information in the exhibition and listened to the guide in your video you would have known that this battle was NOT about Scots fighting against British rule, it was about who was on the British throne. The government army was not English it was British and included many Scots. The Jacobites wanted to overthrow the Hanovarian King and restore the Stuart dynasty by making Bonnie Prince Charlie the King of Great Britain.
Absolutely missed the point. Not a battle between english and Scottish. The battle was between Government troops and Jocobean troops (I've just visited today). There were Scottish on both sides. Why could a battle over 250 years ago between two sides neither of whom had a single nationality break your heart?
Well, it seems that you absolutely missed the point of my video! How would visiting a massive grave NOT break your heart?
And I've been shown many spots all over Scotland that were kept as reminders of the brutality that the British were showing to the locals. P. ex. many, many burnt homes that were actually execution sites because all the inhabitants were locked inside.
Are you sure you understand the meaning of compassion if you're not seeing an issue with people killing each other on such a scale??... 🙄
@@helenanistavlogs Hello Helen, don't wish to start an arguement just dofferent opinion. Visiting a battleground 270 years after the event doesn't break my heart. Makes me reflect but doesn't break my heart. If my wife and kids died tomorrow that would break my heart.
I agreee that a lot of local Scots were shown brutality by their countrymen- not forgetting that Scot and British are the same. How far back do we go for us to be compassionate? Going to Bannockburn Saturday, 12,000 men killed over 700 years ago, will I need to be heartbroken?
We not change history god change history acept history result plz i beg u do not fiieght with god ok be brave always be happy
Nobody can change history. And it's normal and human to go through different emotions. I'm not a robot. Sometimes I'm sad and that's ok.
Sun rise from east and down in west u intelegent lady understand what I say
I don't see u sad because u know I love u
I know u hate me
I don't know why u hate me
Very nice ❤
Thanks 🤗
Are area is not good?
This area is gorgeous!
I love you!💖
😊😊
Who break ur heart
History 😉
lovely video of my country 💙
Thank you! 😃💕
@@helenanistavlogs ❤️
Thank you Helena for your love for Scotland.
It was so easy to fall in love with Scotland! 😍💫
The last battle on British soil! Not so long ago.
I didn't realize it was the last one. Interesting!
@@helenanistavlogs The Battle of Britain of course in 1940 but that was in the skies above Britain!
It was an uprising not a battle !!
From the descriptions, it looked very much like a battle and that's how people keep referring to it 😉
Helena thank you for visiting my country. Some special people like you can feel the sadness in walking the Battle field were so many young men died for their country.
I loved visiting Scotland and I'm sure that I'll be back! Thank you for your kind message 😊💕
Family.
Outlander is a fictional story
Of course it is. But the battle of Culloden really happened.
Free Scotland
😊💕
Thanks
My clann fought there and there's a mass grave for them. It gives me the creeps being there. After Culloden a social and cultural genocide began, which is mildly going on today. The illegality of the Gaelic language, the ridicule of the ability of the Scottish people, the clearances, Highland and Lowland, the divide and rule of sectarianism the destruction of Scottish troops in wars. Free Scotland, back in the EU, Alba gu brath agus Saor Ucran
Yes, it's absolutely heartbreaking! I love Scotland and I hope that it becomes free soon 💕
How does the political stability and peace that led to the Scottish Englightenment fit in to all this ?
@@kumasenlac5504 Does it? The clearances, and mass deaths of WW1? Ah political stability 🤣 get a government you never vote for, aye, thats the way to go 🤣
@@McConnachy Thank you for not even addressing, let alone answering, my question.
@@kumasenlac5504 edit, aye, right enough didnt answer your question, because I dont know the answer