Are Zero-Drop Shoes Good For Achilles Tendonitis Or Can They Cause Achilles Tendonitis?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 75

  • @TreatMyAchilles
    @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

    👉 To avoid overtraining, keep track of your running mileage with a Garmin GPS watch:
    - Garmin Forerunner 45: geni.us/gnVF9
    - Garmin Forerunner 245: geni.us/FFtpiVZ
    - Garmin Instinct 2: geni.us/ArnELe
    More options at the Garmin store on Amazon: geni.us/U9eNrN
    If you buy anything via these links, we may get a small commission at no extra cost to you.

  • @cdahl
    @cdahl Před 2 lety +27

    I’ve worn zero drop shoes for 8 years and got Achilles tendinitis last year due to significantly ramping up my tennis game. The podiatrist blamed my zero drop shoes but I don’t wear them when I play tennis 🤷🏽‍♂️ I feel a little vindicated after watching this video 😄

  • @EricZuckerman1
    @EricZuckerman1 Před rokem +6

    Hi, thanks for the video. When I transitioned to zero drop, it took 6 months to return to my previous mileage. I started with no more than a half mile in the zero drop. On other days, I used my 6 mm drop shoes. Over time, I increased mileage and number of days in the zero drop. By 6 months I was 100% zero drop for both training and daily wear.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Thank you for sharing!

    • @hikerJohn
      @hikerJohn Před rokem

      I went strait to doing 15-20 miles my first day with zero drop. Young people can adapt faster but I was 65 but I think you had the right approach. I did get some achilles pain after 20 miles but it was not serious and it was always gone the next morning.

    • @EricZuckerman1
      @EricZuckerman1 Před rokem

      ​@@hikerJohn Indeed. I was also changing my running mechanics from an extreme heel striker to a mid-foot striker (with feet landing underneath me). So I was using the foot and calves differently in the stride, which made me be very deliberate in my switch.

  • @ramdom_assortment
    @ramdom_assortment Před rokem +11

    Heel to toe drops hurt my knees. Yes, your feet might have less stress with the elevation, but it just shifts the stress to your knees and lower back.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Yes - that is a good example how we are all different and what works for one person may not work for the next.

  • @pocopico7409
    @pocopico7409 Před 2 lety +6

    You are, without question, the best I have ever seen or heard on this issue. Everything you said is exactly correct and fits with my experience. I moved from regular drop shoes to zero drop shoes last year. Within 2 weeks, my Achilles started bothering me on both feet. I rested about three weeks, did my Achilles exercises, and then went back out. On the very first day, pain returned in my left Achilles. I did this same scenario over and over again, probably four or five times, until I finally gave up on zero drop shoes. Every time I went back out after resting, the Achilles pain immediately returned.
    I then did some research and it was exactly as you said. Moving to zero drop shoes too quickly can cause pain. But I never did get to a point where the zero drop shoes DIDN’T cause pain! So I gave up on them. I then bought some Brooks shoes, which have the highest heel to toe drop I could find. I haven’t had any problems since! I will never go back to zero drop shoes, not only because they aren’t comfortable and they caused me Achilles problems, but they tend to be extremely ugly (especially Altras)! It’s just not worth it to me. There are plenty of non-zero drop shoes that have a wide toe box. That’s good enough for me. 😀

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 2 lety +3

      Yes - I also tried zero drop shoes because at one stage they were the only ones that made shoes with a nice wide toe box. But my metatarsals very quickly told me that it was a bad idea as they didn't have enough padding under the ball of the foot. I now use Hokas wide fit and love them.

    • @ericyum6729
      @ericyum6729 Před 2 lety

      HOKA usually doesn’t has as much drop as some other brands. Do u think the difference of 4,5 or 6 mm makes some difference?

    • @pocopico7409
      @pocopico7409 Před 2 lety

      @@ericyum6729: I tried Hoka because I like the look of some of their shoes. I suppose it just depends on the person. Their shoes didn’t help my Achilles problems. Neither did New Balance.

    • @angelawillis6215
      @angelawillis6215 Před 2 lety

      @@pocopico7409 What shoes did help your Achilles pain?

    • @pocopico7409
      @pocopico7409 Před 2 lety +1

      @@angelawillis6215: Everyone is different, Angela, but for me, the zero drop shoes are what caused my Achilles problems. I likely moved to them too fast and (they say) you’re not supposed to do that. Anyway, as long as I used them, I had Achilles problems, so I quit using them and moved to the highest drop shoes I could find…which are Brooks. I bought the Ghost 14s, and from day one, no more Achilles pain. That was nearly a year ago now and I still have no Achilles pain.

  • @daveyjoseph6058
    @daveyjoseph6058 Před rokem +2

    glad i found this before doing the bob and brad techniques lol. definite overuse on my part. flat sole running shoes and a poorly timed motivation to train for a marathon

  • @michaelalbrecht3395
    @michaelalbrecht3395 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Waking up steep steps with a weighted vest on helps tremendously as far as strength training

    • @cmd954
      @cmd954 Před 4 měsíci +1

      That’s a great idea & more functional than basic strengthening exercises. I’ll try that out

  • @mathews0618
    @mathews0618 Před 2 lety +6

    I switched to zero drop shoes for trail running. Climbing hills and going over rocks put strain on my tendons. My right foot gets sore after a run at the heel. I purchased heel inserts and that definitely helped. They are stackable so you can get as much support as you need. I have long runs in my training coming up so i am going to use them thicker until its cleared up and then remove them one at a time to transition. Just an idea for people that dont want to carry 2 pairs of shoes

    • @amandaball7116
      @amandaball7116 Před rokem

      Hi which heel inserts did you buy? Did you add them underneath the insole?

    • @mathews0618
      @mathews0618 Před rokem

      @Amanda Ball dr foot on Amazon. Yep, they stick to the shoe under the insole.

    • @benedictzilka7484
      @benedictzilka7484 Před rokem +3

      So you basically turned your zero drop shoes into regular shoes

    • @heythere6983
      @heythere6983 Před 11 měsíci

      I wonder if there are inserts to elevate the front of the shoe? To counter a shoe that has too high of a drop

  • @pete801
    @pete801 Před 8 dny

    I've run everyday for years. My Achilles was always a pain. I upped the stack every time to treat it right. Wrong. Injury is weakness and my Achilles was super weak from all the cushion. My vibrams and Vivo have made my Achilles completely pain free. Even after 30 miles runs. I wake up the next day and they feel no pain at all.

  • @captaincoyote1792
    @captaincoyote1792 Před 2 lety +4

    I’m a male, in my mid-60s, and retired from two careers that were often mentally and physically challenging (military and law enforcement). So I’ve always been physically active, both for my job requirements and for my pleasure and wellness. Soon after retiring, I attempted the Appalachian Trail in “zero drop” shoes (Altra was my brand). I did fine, as I had transitioned for six months prior to starting the trail. But (why is it, that the older we get, there is always a but,?!) an old Navy back injury brought me off trail. I currently hike 4-8 miles a day, 5-6 days a week. I’ve gone back to zero drop, primarily for the “toe spread”…and general foot comfort….but I am noticing some pain where my Achilles is. My question…..I guess…is, until I am fully “zero drop” capable, would adding an insert with some slight rise, be helpful? I really, really, - REALLY!! - don’t want to go back to traditional footwear! Your video presentation….and your obvious knowledge on the topic….is excellent! Thank you.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 2 lety +4

      Yes, I would give that a go. There are quite a few different options for heel raises on Amazon (for cheap) so perhaps try a few different ones and see what work best. I know the feeling - I also loved my zero drops but had to change as my forefoot did not like them. If you do find that you have to switch, I find Hokas useful (I know - total opposite!) as they also do wide fit but they are not quite as wide as the zero ones.

    • @captaincoyote1792
      @captaincoyote1792 Před 2 lety

      @@TreatMyAchilles you are outstanding! Thank you very much for that rapid reply. I did order some very comfortable (but equally weird looking) zero drop shoes off Amazon. They seem to be helping (I did five miles yesterday, with minimal pain)…..and the reviews that these inexpensive -- but make no mistake, very weird looking--shoes are getting are more than favorable. Oranginer shoes…my Aussie, when I put them on for our walks, really looks at them askance! Thank you, again…..my best to you.

  • @Paulygoku
    @Paulygoku Před 2 lety +1

    Love your videos

  • @noosphericaltarzan
    @noosphericaltarzan Před rokem

    They definitely cause pain that I guess doctors would call tendonitis. But there is a little knot in the fascia behind my knee that, if I work it out, the pain immediately releases. I have been running zero drop for a few years now, but my volume and intensity are ramping up significantly and I think I need to alternate my shoes with something supported every now and again.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Yes, if you're ramping up your volume and intensity, it is likely about how fast that change is happening and that your body is perhaps more tired so your own ability to control the movements reduces and the zero drops can't pick up that slack. FYI - if you increase volume etc. too quickly even normal shoes won't be able to help so don't overdo it and try to work in a recovery week every 4th week where you drop the intensity and volume a bit.

  • @dodororo2791
    @dodororo2791 Před 2 lety

    Many thanks
    Really you are the best
    But please, the pain return again after marvlous improvement , waiting for your advice to minimize this annouying pain 😍😍

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 2 lety

      This is something you need to discuss with your physio as it may require an adaptation to your rehab plan. Alison has also discussed flare-ups in this video czcams.com/video/xQAGTXhMZjA/video.html

  • @benjaminlavin533
    @benjaminlavin533 Před 9 dny

    I've been running (maybe twice a month) in Altras for a year or so and they're really comfortable and enjoy them, however I did have some ITBS issues initially and now more recently the Achilles tendonitis. But after this video and what you said about doing other activities for periods of time in between runs has made me realise that me wearing ankle supporting hiking boots everyday over long distances in steep slippery terrain (for my job) has probably not helped my feet, ankles and legs adjust to the zero drop running!
    Would some barefoot running (on your toes) help strengthen the feet/ankles/legs for zero drop shoes or should I switch back to conventional shoes?

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 7 dny

      You've been using the zero drop for a year, so I think you just overdid it a bit. You will first have to allow the Achilles to calm down and settle so regular running shoes might help you stay active while you treat the Achilles. But then after that, you need to just think about how you are managing your training load week on week and ease back into the zero drop. But I would also add in regular strength training for the Achilles as soon as it can tolerate it. I don't see the point of barefoot running if you're already using zero drop. But I can't really know if my advice is safe for you if I don't fully understand your situation. If you want help figuring out a best plan, this is something that our team of physios can help you with via video call. You can read more about how the online consultations work here: www.treatmyachilles.com

  • @Yonisaj12
    @Yonisaj12 Před 3 měsíci

    Echo ruins the sound a bit.

  • @christopherlee1376
    @christopherlee1376 Před rokem +2

    I switched to zero drop for the first time and got a partial Achilles tear

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      🙈Good luck with your recovery! This video about partial tears may also be useful: czcams.com/video/O9E-PkGPZrM/video.html

    • @comeupmove
      @comeupmove Před rokem

      Same 😢

  • @SuperIceTeddy
    @SuperIceTeddy Před rokem

    I wish I saw this video before I got over excited and decided to sprint in my Zero Drop shoes on the first day and tore my achilles 😢

  • @believeinjesus8300
    @believeinjesus8300 Před 13 dny

    Recently started walking more than I normally do on consistent basis in barefoot shoes noticed my tendon hurting then it got worse,then I didn’t even want to walk at all. I had an old pair of crocs in the closet so I busted those out started wearing those and walking with them noticed my Achilles felt so much better, now I’m kind of nervous about barefoot shoes.

  • @alabi2k542
    @alabi2k542 Před 2 lety +2

    So switching to Birkenstocks 100% caused my Achilles tendonitis, and in turn contributed to my ruptured Achilles . They should warn you 😠 Now my foot is swollen , my Achilles is likely permanently damaged, and I'm out several hundred dollars on shoes I can't wear. I'm 62 and I don't have months to transition into a pair of shoes. I guess it will be running shoes for the rest of my life, and maybe even walking with a cane as well. I can't even fit into my old Blundstone .😔

    • @akashmakkar7187
      @akashmakkar7187 Před 5 měsíci

      They do warn. They recommend wearing them initially only for a few hours each day and slowly transitioning.

  • @martink8080
    @martink8080 Před rokem +1

    I've been wearing those flat wooden Dr Scholl sandals around the house for more years than I remember. Basically zero drop platforms with a slight ridge under the toes for them grip as I walk.
    I recently bought a pair of Altra Olympus 5 trail runners which have a zero drop and after several multi km practice hikes have not had any issues with my Achilles. In the past I used regular hiking shoes with small drop.
    I wonder if my sandal history helped make the transition to zero drop trail runners so smooth?

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem +1

      It very likely has. Also, if your regular shoes used to have only a small drop, then the change was likely not too drastic.

  • @nagillig
    @nagillig Před rokem +2

    Great video, thanks for the information. I’ve been reviewing the zero drop shoes but have a question about how they would effect my metatarsal. I noticed that you mentioned they bothered your forefoot. I’m not a runner but I do a lot of hiking and have used Hokas a lot, but there wide sizes for hiking shoes are very limited. I was thinking of trying the Altra Olympic 5 mid for waterproof hikers. Do you think they would bother my metatarsal? And I would use a custom orthotic that puts more of my weight on my arch. Thanks again for the video.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Not sure - it depends on your feet - if your metatarsals often hurt if you walk barefoot or in flat shoes then they may not be a good idea.

    • @pgreenx
      @pgreenx Před 4 měsíci

      How did you fair?
      I started in zero drops hiking and ruined my fore foot. curious at work for you

    • @nagillig
      @nagillig Před 4 měsíci

      The zero drop is not good for my feet. Over the years I’ve discovered that a 4mm drop works best for me, and best with a lot of cushion. My best walking shoes on city streets is the Hoka Bondi 7 and my favorite trail hiker is the new balance trail more version 3 I think it is, the newest one.

    • @pgreenx
      @pgreenx Před 4 měsíci

      @@nagillig thanks. Still recovering from zero drop foot problem. Will check those out

  • @lukeingham4262
    @lukeingham4262 Před 2 měsíci

    Hi. I switched to a barefoot running shoe in January and immediately noticed a big difference for my toes. I have Freiburg's disease which effects the blood flow to my metatarsals and I've had much less pain since then. But on the last 3 weeks I've been experiencing bad pain in my Achilles tendons. Sometimes one side, sometimes the other, or sometimes both. It's hindering my performance. I'm not a big runner. I do CrossFit and usually only run around 1-2km at a time, around 3-4 times a week. Do you think that this recent issue could be caused by the shoes? Until that point, I hadn't had any issues in either foot with the Achilles.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 2 měsíci

      It might be but it might also be changes in your training habits or something else you've done.

  • @LukeCarson-ob5qd
    @LukeCarson-ob5qd Před rokem +1

    I had Achilles tendonitis for almost a year, but have been good for at least three months now, running without issues a few times a week (being cautious not to overdo). I have always worn running shoes with a heel drop, but have also had some issues with shin splints and knees. I see reforming my running form as perhaps the best option to be injury free and run happily. Zero-drop shoes seem a good option for good running form. For someone like me, with past but not current Achilles tendonitis, what do you think?

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem +1

      I would suggest 3 things:
      1. First get used to walking in those shoes without restriction - ease into it but get used to doing at least the same distance walking that you would run normally
      2. In the meantime also start strength training calves (just 1 or 2 times/wk) with weights over a step -- but be careful where in the week you add this in as if you are doing high mileage running and then lump +++ strength training on top, that in itself can cause overload on your Achilles - so ease into this and figure out what your body is telling you with regards to rest periods etc.
      3. Once you've ticked both the above boxes then I would consider easing into running with the shoes but only for the shorter and slow runs to start with. Both long or fast running will place more strain on the tendon so leave them for later.
      Remember, I don't know you so this advice may not be right for you. If you wanted more specific rehab advice and help with doing this, this is something that our team of physios can help you with via video call. You can read more about how the online consultations work here: www.treatmyachilles.com/

  • @applerunner1184
    @applerunner1184 Před rokem +1

    I irritated my (back of) heel spur during a race in Oct '22. I have been rehabbing as you suggested. I have also been strengthening my feet and recently incorporated minimalist shoes for non running activities to help with that. My issue now is the heel spur lump rubbing against the heel counter when running. I have tried taping gel (I cut up gel heel cups) to my heel and cutting out the plastic heel counter from my running shoes to minimize the friction. It works, but not perfect. Would be interested in any suggestions...

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Compede plasters can be useful but as a long term solution I think you likely require a different style running shoe.

  • @Serinia4melodic
    @Serinia4melodic Před rokem +1

    Hello! What about heel bursitis? I have been running for almost 2 years in zero drop shoes but in the last 6 months I have been dealing with heel bursitis. I did a scan and the tendon is fine I guess it is strong enough, but still I have pain in my ankle due to the left over liquid. Did some fizio rounds, the pain is down, but I can still feel the ankle stiff. Was thinking on going for 5mm drop shoes temporarily. Would it help?

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Going for shoes with a heel drop may help.
      Here's our video on heel bursitis, in case you haven't seen it yet: czcams.com/video/B1LMKwEZ5mo/video.html

  • @hikerJohn
    @hikerJohn Před rokem

    Do zero-drop shoes have anything to do with plantar fasciitis? I think Tendonitis and PF are both just over use injuries when you change what you have been use to too fast. I had Achilles Tendonitis for almost a year after switching to zero-drop but I also went from hiking 20 miles a week to backpacking 100 miles a week over night. The next year after taking it easy over the winter I kept wearing the zero drop shoes and never (even years later) had the Achilles Tendonitis issue again. The PF came from switching from trail running in zero drop to running on pavement for just a week. In just 4 years Ive had just about every overuse injury there is but I feel fine now . . . Now I'm afraid to ever run on pavement again least I get another PF

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      It sounds as if your feet were used to the zero drop shoes on trails - when you are on trails you tend to be a bit more on your toes (so softer landing) and the ground is softer as well so the force through the foot and plantar fascia is not so high - every step is also very different so you vary where you carry the forces with every step. When on a hard surface like pavement, the force going through the foot is much higher due to the surface but we also tend to run with less variation in our steps so the same areas carry the force. If you changed the surface slowly, it may have been OK but I think the change was a bit too sudden. And that is kind of the problem with the zero drops - because the shoe offers no shock absorption or support, they are very unforgiving when you do something that tires your feet or that you're not used to.

  • @TheDarklady28
    @TheDarklady28 Před rokem

    Went from vans to Nike air maxes and noticed a swollen painful Achilles when walking. Should I go back to vans?

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      It might help but, now that it is injured, you may also have to do other things to actually help the tendon recover - this video may be useful: czcams.com/video/H1nfgU1amvg/video.html

  • @heythere6983
    @heythere6983 Před 11 měsíci

    Do they sell inserts to counter a higher heel drop? I recently got a higher heel drop shoe and I’m use to a drop with half the mm.
    I went from a 4mm to a 8mm. I’m wondering in there are inserts for something like this?

  • @munmunlaha1464
    @munmunlaha1464 Před 2 lety

    Hello.. What happens when the Achilles tendon is completely removed.can a person walk without Achilles tendon if completely removed..? One of my relative met with an road accident. No skin grafting or muscle flap surgery is possible as the blood vessels there is damaged also that tendon has become dead so doctors are opting for complete removal of Achilles tendon. Can a person Walk without it as it the largest n strongest tendon in our body.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před 2 lety +1

      They will be able to walk but just not push off (not propel themselves forward using the calf) - so they will unfortunately walk with a flat foot. There may be orthotic devices that can help them but this is not our area of expertise so perhaps ask their doctor for a referral to a orthotist (someone who specializes in making orthopedic assistive braces).

  • @jacobtb1
    @jacobtb1 Před rokem

    I switched to barefoot and achilles tendons are sore. Trying to fix my duck feet at the same time. Facing feet forward feels harder on tendons.

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem +1

      "duck" feet can't always be fully corrected. The shape of our bones (especially the angle at the hip bone) often determines how far our feet point outwards. My advice would be to only attempt small corrections e.g. a few degrees towards forwards rather than go from very outwards to full forwards because that may be too much and not actually useful for you

    • @jacobtb1
      @jacobtb1 Před rokem

      @@TreatMyAchilles thanks, very helpful advice. I needed to hear that.

  • @trinichinee6426
    @trinichinee6426 Před rokem

    So the higher the drop .. the less stretch on the achilles tendon and also less stress on the plantar fascia

    • @TreatMyAchilles
      @TreatMyAchilles  Před rokem

      Yes - the plantar fascia is actually more affected because the thinner sole offers less cushioning

    • @trinichinee6426
      @trinichinee6426 Před rokem

      @@TreatMyAchilles so, I can use shoes with higher drops for recovery runs for my Achilles and fascia ?

  • @petercook7798
    @petercook7798 Před rokem

    My achillies feels a lot better when I walk in a boot rather than in my zero-drop shoes.

  • @slavasss2189
    @slavasss2189 Před rokem

    +