tripleS - Girls Never Die (Line Distribution LIVE Ver.)
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 05. 2024
- #tripleS #SeoYeon #HyeRin #JiWoo #ChaeYeon #YooYeon #SooMin #NaKyoung #YuBin #Kaede #DaHyun #Kotone #YeonJi #Nien #SoHyun #Xinyu #Mayu #Lynn #JooBin #HaYeon #ShiOn #ChaeWon #Sullin #SeoAh #JiYeon #LineDistribution
![tripleS, THE SHOW CHOICE! [THE SHOW 240514]](/img/n.gif)
you can leave your corrections here!!
2:31 Hayeon?
video based on this performance: czcams.com/video/fDAd2YEMbg8/video.htmlsi=yBVPINR-vY-XBSON
I’m planning on making an updated version later where I include every ad-lib! I had trouble especially with the final chorus.
oh! would it be possible to have a version where the girl singing is highlighted in a different colour separate from white (maybe their assigned colours?), it was kinda hard to see who was singing when since everything just kinda blended in. tysm tho! i was waiting on a line distribution ver
@@lvdteeagreed
@@lvdtee I’ll keep that in mind for my next video, tysm for your feedback!! I’m working on a solution that will go with my phone (which I unfortunately still edit with) asap
@@ttokkichesom no problem!! good job tho bae
@@ttokkichesomtake your time❤ thanks for making a really nice line distribution so fast💗💗
Honestly, this is good, 24 members but they all sing, even if it's short. The main focus of this song is the chorus anyway. And obviously the main vocal will showcase her power vocals. Dahyun slayed and Yooyeon's part is iconic during the choreo
i can't imagine you requesting this on random_k😭
I think it is better if they make each part to have 2-3 people sing together instead of just 1 person, since they have 24 members. That way the line distribution would then be slightly more diversely even. If not it just looked like some members are actually the back up dancer. ; my opinion
@@reinaolisversion someone requested already! But unlikely the distribution will have the member icon since I think it will not have space to insert it, we saw it on the cheer up video distribution before.
@@reinaolisversion actually, i was going to, but some other patreon was faster than me haha. it will probably be out in a couple days
@@Crystaaaalize i'm ok with that because ot24 comebacks will be rare. the focus of this group are the subunits, which allows each member to shine more
Honestly it’s pretty awesome how good modhaus did with distribution.. (considering high notes always go to dahyun and most of her time was high notes instead of actual lines lmao)
That’s the weird thing though. Wasn’t Shion supposed to be there other main vocal?
@@DatVideoDoe jst accept it, it is hard for 24 people
@@DatVideoDoe she definitely can't be compared with dahyun.
@@DatVideoDoeshion shouldve definitely had some singing lines. but no, there's way better vocalists like jiwoo, mayu, hyerin, nakyoung, & hayeon
@@DatVideoDoeyeah wish she couldve had some adlibs
and everyone sing more then haseul in hi high lol
This comment… is giving. Hahahahahahuhuhu
JAIL
"어떡해!"
WILD ON THIS
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I love how some people say they don't like the line distribution, as if anybody in this line up can get more than 5s with 24 members 💀 (except for two or three members)
Yes, some Kpop fans always scream for "fairness" and dont even know what fairness is like in a Kpop group singing. This comes from a fan of Loona Vivi and G-idle Shuhua.
@@LouisSaver2012 that is true but there's no way vivi deserved to basically only have ad libs or say one (1) word on almost every title track....
@@pigeondance I agree. I'm not familiar with Loona, but I've listened to their new songs. Vivi isn't the best singer it seems, but that doesn't mean she deserves little to no lines lol.
I don't think she or Shuhua should get the same amount as the main or lead vocals, but parts that can make them stand-out without it being out of their skill range.
There are different ways to achieve fairness, but some companies and netizens just refuse to even ponder about it.
@@demonsdelight yeah, my thoughts exactly!!
the line distributions being 100% equal would harm the quality of the songs, but of course all members should still have their moments. like why even debut them if they're just filling the role of a glorified back up dancer? that's not nice and unfair.
yes, it's hard to highlight all the members equally in big groups. but it's definitely possible, seventeen do that very well recently, for example
Actually very fair distribution given the number of members
My God, it'a like a character select screen from fighting games!
LMAO so true
😭😭
seoyeon speaking in the beginning reminds me of heejin in the beginning of favOriTe, founders introducing their full groups
joobin and seoah is gonna be in vocal line for sure i can feel their vocal ability is able to do more!
I agree I really like Seoah’s vocal tone!!! Excited to see their vocals grow!!!
Thought the same thing! I was like WHO SANG THAT and then saw live performance and was surprised. They did amazing for their little part
All "lalala" and "girls never die... never cry" aside, the rest of the chorus could easily be split among the members
but we hardly hear all group choruses in kpop anymore and the point of this comeback/debut is that they are a full group of 24 together. having the group chorus emphasizes that
@@wok7152in this case all choruses sung in choir dont sound right to me. Imo the song would be way more dynamic and pleasing if each chorus was sung by 3 members, and then all "lalala" and "girls never die... never cry" in choir like a mantra. Not to mention that Dahyun is the only one I hear in the choruses.
@@wok7152 exactly..
@@thomhenri3179she is the one who is singing it with other three girls lol
GUYS, YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE 24 GIRLS AND THEY ALL OPENED THEIR MOUTHS, IN NCT THERE ARE 26, IF YOU PUT THERE ONLY THE 9 FAMOUS PEOPLE FROM NCT 127 THEN THEY WILL SING. MODHAUS DID THE MAXIMUM, AND YES THEY ALL SING TOGETHER A LARGE PART OF THE SONG, INTRO, CHORUS, Outro, "LA LA LA, NEVER DIE, NEVER CRY" THAT IS, OF COURSE THE TREBLE WOULD GO TO DAHYUN AND JIWOO, THEY ARE THE TWO THAT HAVE THE MOST FEATURE TO FIT INTO A SONG OF THIS TONE AND TRIM
It’s just impossible that each one of them get 5s or + (expect 2-3 for the ad-libs), it’s a 24 members grp so idk why some people complaining. If y’all want to hear more the voice of some members, go listen to the sub-units.
I think real official line distribution when they promote show in MCountdown
(If you notice point lyrics in left-down, they write lyrics and part member in Hangeul/ Korean Language)
honestly? this is way better than i expected
At the end of the day they all sang the chorus so this is good!
haseulification of shion 😭😭
No correlation whatsoever
@@fdp8193there are definitely correlation
@@fdp8193 cus shion is main vocal, but she did a short rap instead
@@sourgrapes7026songs also depend on what the producers intend with the members vocal tones. ShiOn wouldn’t have suited the vocal parts unlike the likes of Jiwoo and Dahyun. Atleast we technically got to see her do a joint rap with her, Chaewon and Jiyeon
@@FROZTYBAEEEEEexactly!!!! Plus they are the idols OF ALL possibility so her rapping is fine!!
for me, it’s not about the line distribution, it’s about the 24 members coming together and making something epic.
i’ll worry about the line distribution on the sub-units later 😂
thanks for the vid! ❤
Shion could have had one of those high notes that Dahyun did. I thought she would in the other songs, but she didn't.
Well it's hard to tell if she really can hit those notes as clean as Dahyun...
I think she didn’t because unlike Dahyun powerful soulful voice Shion is more clear and airy so the producers decided she didn’t fit that part!!!! This is what usually happens too!!!
@@thriftskull5549 I'm just stating my opinion. I wish she had parts because she's a main voice
i thought non scale would be her song but no lol i hope modhaus would give her proper lines as they introduced her as a main vocal. praying for next sub units!
Heres the thing, Dahyun is way too strong of a vocalist to not give the high notes to. I believe in triples, the gap between her and the others is high, while the 2nd to 8th best vocalists in the group are in a similar level. Basically the other main vocalists will get their shine on the subunits but when it comes to the ot24 cbs, its always gonna be dahyun
s17-s24 desperately need a sub group after this sub unit because we barely have seen them and they couldn't really show much during this release
I mean if you think about it, some members from 11-16 also havent been given a chance to show much. In particular, the ones in the evol subunit. The song is great, but it didnt show much of what yeonji, kotone and mayu are capable of because of the song's style/genre (invincible). Id also say nien haven't been given much chance to shine as well, in lovelution, even though she got the chorus parts, it was not really that talked about as much by wavs because, I mean, sohyun and xinyu's parts in the song, in particular the mv was so impactful that nien didn' t get to shine as much. I feel like modhaus need to do more of the 4 member subunits, which makes multiple members shine. And they dont even need to do it one subunit at the time, they can have like 6 songs with 4 members in each song, with all songs getting its own mv. I know its ambitious to do so since making music videos is expensive, but its honestly gonna be beneficial to balance out the popularity of the members. Also, I think modhaus have a plan for glow, i mean they wont give triples glow a name if they wont have any plans for them
Also, its only been a few months since s17 was revealed, and they had a perf video already which showed a lot of what nxt could do, give glow a few more months and they will be able to show their capabilities, i just think they needed to release assemble24 already since they are already complete, then after this cb, they can give more focus to the newer members.
Not the Android ViVi taking over Yooyeon 😭
i love that every single one of them sing. that's hella difficult when you have 24 members
Yall saying yall dont like the line distribution need ti be fr, 24 members and a 3 minute song = each member singing once. Plus they all sing the chorus so this is actually really fair
thank u
I like how everyone gets to sing at least. With a group of 24, 1-2 seconds is doable. I also like how they all get to sing the chorus as well. I feel the choreography is where a lot of members shine.
The "kkeutkkaji..."(s) "Sarajyeodo..."(s) and "we go..." (s) in the choruses should've been given to the members...
love song❤❤
dang the girls have ample amount of energy for the choreo since they’re singing for just a few seconds. song still sounds cohesive despite the number of members.
This is amazing how everyone got a part and it doesn’t sound like they just threw parts in. Yes most girls have under 3sec but for 24 members that’s amazing. The chorus is long so having even 2sec is crazy.
Jaden jeong knows how to distribute lines
Have you heard of the girl group LOONA?
@@HaseulFromLoonaFOUL 😭😭
LOONA
@@HaseulFromLoonacan you please explain? I've seen multiple people said this 'loona' thing at tripleS are they somehow connected or similar?
@@hefactmesogoodbasically orbit likes to hate on triple s before cause they think triple s are a copy of loona… but then loona get disbanded and some of the girls join modhaus, so they kinda stop hating triple s but now instead they bring loona to every triple s topic lol
This song slap so hard omg
Lmao huge props for doing this
My baby and bias YUBIN is the center so many times in the choreo, so im so happy
DAHYUN BEST VOCALIST
S10 Dahyun 16.9
S3 Jiwoo 7.0
S6 Soomin 5.1
S1 Seoyeon 4.1
S5 Yooyeon 3.8
S19 Hayeon 3.4
S17 Lynn 2.9
S18 Joobin 2.9
S7 Nakyoung 2.8
S16 Mayu 2.7
S9 Kaede 2.6
S15 Xinyu 2.6
S23 Seoah 2.6
S11 Kotone 2.4
S14 Sohyun 2.2
S4 Chaeyeon 1.9
S2 Hyerin 1.8
S12 Yeonji 1.8
S24 Jiyeon 1.8
S8 Yubin 1.7
S13 Nien 1.4
S20 Shion 1.4
S22 Sullin 1.3
S21 Chaewon 1.1
yall are so negative omg its not even bad its actually decent
debuting to just sing 1 second 😭😭😭 crazyyy
The camera having to film their music shows deserves a raise
this actually is pretty fair
all 3 minutes and yooyeon only sang random line like 😭😭. also all the member have more lines than haseul in hi high :))
it's the killing part tho;)
it's the most iconic part. besides, she's in the center a couple times in the choreo. and she had plenty of screentime in the MV. as a yooyeon bias i'm satisfied. like imagine how other wavs feel for not seeing their bias just as much. yooyeon stans are pretty blessed so please let's not act selfish
this is better than loona’s line distribution
I think they should release songs whey the chorus is devided by members, so more people get to sing
That’s the point of the sub unit releases every season!!!
im pretty sure yooyeon mightve did the opening like then higher now part but i might be mistaken
As a Dahyun stan I won ❤
It’s impressive that each member has more lines than Haseul in High High
24 member group line distribution > 12 member group line distribution
TripleS the new LOONA, the girl version of NCT and will remind me of IZ*ONE (#rhodanthe)
how come no one is singing the hook part? the lalala girls never die… it doesnt sound like multiple voices so why arent those parts included in the line distribution?
all of them seem to sing it live. I personally think Dahyun leads to chorus
@@ttokkichesomshe be singing the whole song 😭
I'll never be complaining about my bias' lines anymore...
ShiOn has Vocal rank D- and she has been divided into such a great line, I'm always moved when it comes to the part she sings
Honestly.. Th is is pretty good
least - most lines:
1. s21 chaewon - 1.1s
2. s22 sullin - 1.3s
3. s13 nien // s20 shion - 1.4s
4. s8 yubin - 1.7s
5. s2 hyrein // s12 yeonji // s24 jiyeon - 1.8s
6. s4 chaeyeon - 1.9s
7. s14 sohyun - 2.2s
8. s11 kotone - 2.4s
9. s9 kaede // s15 xinyu // s23 seoah - 2.6s
10. s16 mayu - 2.7s
11. s7 nakyoung - 2.8s
12. s17 lynn // s18 joobin - 2.9s
13. s19 hayeon - 3.4s
14. s5 yooyeon - 3.8s
15. s1 seoyeon - 4.1s
16. s6 soomin - 5.1s
17. s3 jiwoo - 7s
18. s10 dahyun - 16.9s
Fair distribution all in all. My only one, very minor complaint is that we got, of all things, a RAP bar from Shion. As the second main vocal, that doesn't do her skill justice.
I completely and totally get that her voice doesn't necessarily match with this song, and having one main vocal anchor in Dahyun makes complete sense. But still, it is a shame we don't get to see too much of her skill in this title CB.
Wait is Sheon a main vocalist? When did they say that?
@@anderramirez8433 I thought I saw it on her profile (the one they fill up and upload personally). Additionally, she's definitely the main vocal of NXT, and is part of the vocal line as the company themselves have said when NXT met the OT16
I don't know how good an idea it is to make such a large group, the members cannot rescue or show their skills, I understand that that is why there are subunits but I don't see the point. Still, I'm glad everyone sings.
For real and with their ranking popularity system is worst. They're will be many sub fandom war
@@lolipop23138What ranking system? TripleS has a voting system but we have never had to rank girls through voting
I think they’re doing pretty well. They have a loyal fanbase and is one of the popular girl groups of 5th gen. The subunits have repeatedly been able to show and explore members’s skills and abilities. And they will also have solo activities in the future.
@@lolipop23138sub fandom war? The people who stan tripleS stan ALL of the members as a whole group. You’re never meant to just stan a subunit (you can do it if you want but it’d be pretty hard imo). The fanbase put members in the subunits the members seem interested in and love each and every member of the group. I have never ever seen a sub fandom war within the fandom
@@QueenQueen0824 actually some members already said this in an interview, Xinyu once said she doesn't like these ranking system. Like, members know where their ranks at, for example objekt sales, the number 1 rank is Yooyeon, Seoyeon, I forget number third, Sohyun or Xinyu. That's why there's thing called "popular members" within the group. Which would felt great if you're a solo stan of the popular member. All members knew how good their objekt sales and where they're sit at in terms of popularity ranking.
but anyway Jaden system is such a fresh for kpop but it doesn't come without risks, and time will tell if Jaden can keep manage everything well under control.
i thought they sang the chorus individually tbh
with this amount of members in a group, they couldve done some harmonies, and more adlibs as well!! but nonetheless, it's a very good song
la verdad esta bastante bien, tenia miedo de que alguna se quedara sin lineas
Wondered how they would distribute.
"Black on Black" only has a few vocalists.
Harmonies of two or three might be something.
Who’s the member in the thumbnail?
how did they outdo haseul in hi high with lines😭💔
impossible to recognize 24 voice
Dahyun Carrying the vocal just, wow
nauurr nunca volveré a quejarme sobre las líneas de otro grupo
2:27 last night is JiWoo
atleast they get more then haseul’s “eottokae!”
I'm not mad about this because they are 24 members! BUUUUUUUUUT MODHAUS... ShiOn deserves the main vocal treatment! she has some amazing vocal skills
ShiOn's vocals are really good, but its genre dependent, she would shine more in the subunits for sure, but her vocals would be hard to fit in a full group cb. Maybe if there is a song or comeback catered to her voice, she would be the main vocalist, like a soft ballad or a cute concept.
2:32 oh, so cry is dahyun
...24 members...😅
"How do we distribute a 3 minute song to 24 girls?"
"What if we don't give lines during the chorus as well?"
👁👄👁
This song is too short for 24 girls
But the trend nowadays is short kind of song...3 minutes-ish long. The idea behind it is it will make audience keep looping the song without getting bored at it, Imagine you played a kpop song that more than 5 minutes, it may felt tiring and boring, but if you keep it short you can keep looping it again. That's the challenge of this Assemble24. And you gotta admit, the line distribution is fairly good already, there's much worse distribution in much less members in other groups
If the song is very good like Girls Never Die then 5 minutes will not get boring and will also be listened to many times. In my opinion, 5 minutes is better than 3min 44s, the girls would have more lyrics and it would be more fair in the distribution. Note that a lot of girls don't even have 2 seconds.
파트분배 어질어질하네.... 인원이 많으니 어쩔 수 없다지만 24명이 이러면 일본 48 애들은 얼마나 적은건지 상상이 되서 더 무섭네 거긴 개인파트 0.N초 대인가...
MY BIAS DOESN'T EVEN GET 5% THAT IS NOT ACCEPTABLE...oh wait
Who is this on the thumbnail?
Sohyun
s14 sohyun
Triples 5th gen leader
Wait whos the new member again?
What you mean by that?
@@revyodatsatsu5260 the new member of triple s
@@RWISE.ES17 - S24
Latest members are chaewon(s21) sullin(s22), seoah(s23) and jiyeon(s24)
@@orbitzen19 oh ok thx
I doubt all of them are singing the chorus tho
in the live performance it’s marked as “all” so I’m basing it off of that!! I personally think Dahyun leads the chorus.
This is a pretty good distribution but just one girl getting 17 seconds while the rest barely cross 2 seconds is way too much
so funny that 24 members only have 1 main vocal
They have 3-4 main vocals
They have a lot of vocals in the group, u don't know nothing
@@robbstark3795then why they only give vocal heavy part to dahyun only?
They have tons of good strong vocalist
S3 Lee JiWoo
S4 Kim ChaeYeon
S7 Kim NakYoung
S9 Kaede
S10 Seo DaHyun
S14 Park SoHyun
S16 Mayu
S19 Jeong HaYeon
S20 Park ShiOn (who’s also a main vocalist but idk what happened)
@w.g.m7029 san and hongjoong can belt but jongho handles all the high notes...
literally the whole song basically was the demo or someone singing? all the members could have +5s if they split up that post chorus
Dahyun and friends
1 Chuu and 23 Vivis
No way there's only one Main Vocal for this song 💀💀💀
What’s up with the ceo having majority of their title tracks having lalala in them instead of actual lyrics. I love the girls music but them saying “la la la” all the time is getting repetitive especially since they also say it in their bside 24. Also I want their company to release song h I definitely can see that blowing up in Korea for the girls.
I mean, we were given other options which didn't contain lalala, it's not their problem that fans chose the song😭 wavs also like the Lalala's so the company is obviously gonna pander to that and not change the lyrics.
You didn’t count the chorus
All members sing in the chorus
@@loversmultifandomno theres multiple part in the chorus where only one member sings
@@fdp8193they only dance in the center, all 4 choruses sounds the same
@@loversmultifandomits obviously that dahyun sing the chorus
i think is dahyun @@fdp8193
This looks like hell💀 9 members got below 2 seconds lmao wtf is thisss😭
1.1sec? 1.4sec?? this is not singer!
Dude it’s a 24 member song, they’re not all gonna get a lot of parts. That’s why there’s subunits
You want them all to get over 10 sec?? Lol
Well they ain't hybe idol tho, they can sing😂
@@Virtualangelheejin see why’re you bringing up Hybe singers? They aren’t part of this conversation
@@crystalbugboybut they can better sing than LE SSERAFIM
aah I don't like the line division
what did you expect from a 24 member group 💀
@@honeydwdwdw
I just want them to split the line in the chorus
@@TAPTAPLOVE12345 almost their entire discography is singing the chorus altogether so whatever you on cut it out