Hillel Neuer, as a fellow Canadian, I am sure you share my anger at Trudeau for his caving in to the Muslim voters here. Very soon after the Muslim groups publicly stated that they would vote NDP next election, surprise-surprise- funding for UNRWA from Canada is resuming. Israel needs new allies. USA, Canada, NZ, AU, UK are vulnerable to public opinion. Israel needs allies who understand the ideology they are facing. The enemy of my enemy is my friend. UAE, Bahrain and Saudi Arabia will not be fair weather friends and they do not want Islamic jihad in their states either.
Love the clear morality of this man. One of the best resources for the background information spanning years of UNWRA corruption. I thought it was “absurd” that Iran was part of the “Human Rights Council” {with a long list of torturing, rape and murder of women because a head scarfs}! What’s next? Putin appointed to the “Free Speech Committee”?? The UN has been totally corrupted; as it’s doing the opposite of The United Nations Charter! UNRWA has been a major contributor, supporting Hamas. Both must be dissolved. All funding must stop. Let the Palestinians build their own houses. Then they will be busy with rebuilding their “home “. No more “refugee” status. (That gravy train is closed)!
UNRWA got about $343 million just from the US, and around $400 million more from Europe. The Plastilin The wealthiest miser in the world and best actors chose to use this fortune for terror rather than welfare.
I remember my older brothers taught me, "Never give in to (appease) a bully, who demands you hand over your lunch money." We teach our children to speak out against bullies, unfortunately we have far too few adults like Hillel, with a good measure of intestinal fortitude. Thank you for creating and posting this video, and thank you Hillel for your tireless labours on behalf of the human race. Un grande Canadien.
The biggest problem is the western democracies doesnt understand this simple principle that UNRWA is Hamas. Its so easy to see that this problem is not solved after 75 years, then there must be a problem with the methods.
@@mikelundmikel4006that is blatantly false. Israel has tried FIVE TIMES since their formation to give the Palestinians their own state. They have refused and chosen war each time……
@@Glenrok in order to even implement 2 states the occupier must define its borders.Israel still hasn't.all the we have offered is usual double speak Israeli bullshit.u.n said ok let's do 1967 border then and Israel has refused every time
I think the chaos we are in is largely due to America's weakness and wokeness Best for Israel to start depending on itself but i have faith in Israel and warriors like you.
@Hillel Neuer I didn't know you were Canadian. It makes me proud as a Canadian that you are speaking out so loudly against the rotten mess that the UN has become. You probably share my disgust at how our craven Prime Minister refuses to speak out against evil because he knows it will cost him votes. I look forward to a change of government. Hopefully you will be invited to speak to the House of Commons and tell the new government how things really are in the UN and UNRWA. Please stay safe.
Re Palestine's bid for UN membership, let's see Palestine's charter, just to make sure it aligns with standards of modern civilized nations. Article 7: That there is a Palestinian community and that it has material, spiritual, and historical connection with Palestine are indisputable facts. It is a national duty to bring up individual Palestinians in an Arab revolutionary manner. All means of information and education must be adopted in order to acquaint the Palestinian with his country in the most profound manner, both spiritual and material, that is possible. He must be prepared for the armed struggle and ready to sacrifice his wealth and his life in order to win back his homeland and bring about its liberation. Article 8: The phase in their history, through which the Palestinian people are now living, is that of national (watani) struggle for the liberation of Palestine. Thus the conflicts among the Palestinian national forces are secondary, and should be ended for the sake of the basic conflict that exists between the forces of Zionism and of imperialism on the one hand, and the Palestinian Arab people on the other. On this basis the Palestinian masses, regardless of whether they are residing in the national homeland or in diaspora (mahajir) constitute - both their organizations and the individuals - one national front working for the retrieval of Palestine and its liberation through armed struggle. Article 9: Armed struggle is the only way to liberate Palestine. This it is the overall strategy, not merely a tactical phase. The Palestinian Arab people assert their absolute determination and firm resolution to continue their armed struggle and to work for an armed popular revolution for the liberation of their country and their return to it . They also assert their right to normal life in Palestine and to exercise their right to self-determination and sovereignty over it. Article 10: Commando action constitutes the nucleus of the Palestinian popular liberation war. This requires its escalation, comprehensiveness, and the mobilization of all the Palestinian popular and educational efforts and their organization and involvement in the armed Palestinian revolution. It also requires the achieving of unity for the national (watani) struggle among the different groupings of the Palestinian people, and between the Palestinian people and the Arab masses, so as to secure the continuation of the revolution, its escalation, and victory. Nope, it's belligerent, terroristic and chillingly threatening of armed violence against Israel, the nation whose deity they shamelessly co-opted. If Palestine is admitted to the UN it will only prove how dangerous the UN actually is to humanity.
It sounds a lot like Palestinian "liberation" is exactly the type of imperial conquest (colonialism, ethnic cleansing) that Israel is being falsely accused of. The Hamas charter of 1988 is similar, although more theocratic than simple pan-Arab nationalism imo.
@@dr.g3860 It just shows that they have made no attempt to reform since '88 and are not rehabilitatable. They are also openly inciting other Arab nations to support them in their goal of conquest. "Article 15: The liberation of Palestine, from an Arab viewpoint, is a national (qawmi) duty and it attempts to repel the Zionist and imperialist aggression against the Arab homeland, and aims at the elimination of Zionism in Palestine. Absolute responsibility for this falls upon the Arab nation - peoples and governments - with the Arab people of Palestine in the vanguard. Accordingly, the Arab nation must mobilize all its military, human, moral, and spiritual capabilities to participate actively with the Palestinian people in the liberation of Palestine. It must, particularly in the phase of the armed Palestinian revolution, offer and furnish the Palestinian people with all possible help, and material and human support, and make available to them the means and opportunities that will enable them to continue to carry out their leading role in the armed revolution, until they liberate their homeland."
There is no Palestine or Palestinians. These displaced Arabs, who have no ties to that land, other than Israel giving up the Gaza Strip to them for peace, callas Israel, the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, etc "Palestine." By their claims that the Israelis are "occupiers" they are saying Israel belongs to them. The reason they want to eradicate the Jews to take "their land." These people created chaos and death to every country that allowed them in. A two state solution has always been delusional. We saw that on 10/7. No, do not reward terrorists.
Absolutely ! Why does no one believe in history or truth it seems these things are not important to people any more no one wants to study or think for themselves
I would love to see Hillel in the same room with the likes of Abby Martin or Norman Finkelstein and watch them try to shout him down as he cites to actual facts because that's the only way they can communicate.
Hillel your courage and incredible dedication are a shining light. Thank you for demonstrating how it’s done and giving me a great sense of Jewish pride! Am Yisrael Chai 🙏🏼🇮🇱🎗️✡️💙
Just started to think about it when there was this issue that NATO wanted to make sure that there would not happen genpzides on the Balkan wars but (of course) there was a veto of the permanent heading member Russia so they had to do it withput a UN mandate. They happened to be a little for some genozides but at least could manage to end the war for good. But certain nationalist people still angry about that keep bringing it up all the time (because "the West bad, therefore Putin good" or so)
Same story happened again whe Ukraine was invaded and UN council was going to condemn the invasion but Russia vetoed against it. And next month even happened to start its head of the council period and of course wasn't decent about lobbying for nationalistic BS in the UN parliament. Maybe UN is the best option we have to be a more peaceful species but it doesn't really seemto work 🤷♂️
Netanyahu and the Israeli government need to be proactive. I wrote this to the Embassy of Israel: ---At this juncture Netanyahu would be well advised to boldly appeal directly to the American people who are sick and tired of the farce that is the United Nations and a foreign policy that refuses to confront the evil that is Islam i.e. withdraw from the Israel hating United Nations and make it clear that if the effort to provide Hamas and exit from the field is pressed, Israel will (threaten to?) sever diplomatic relations with the United States for cause…lack of moral and ethical clarity. Israel has everything to gain and nothing to lose by doing so. How hard would it be to cite the number of resolutions and votes against Israel as compared to every other nation combined? If Netanyahu does so Israel can be sure American patriots, the sleeping giant, will rise to fight the good fight as they have so many times in history.--- Doing so would be a courageous and liberating act on the part of Israel…and to it I would add some common sense that for average Americans would represent a red line Israel can stand behind hand in hand with Americans i.e. there is nothing to negotiate until Hamas provides 1) the names of every hostage, and 2) proof of life…and until the information is provided Israel will continue the offensive to destroy Hamas sans negotiations. As difficult as it will be, it is time for Israel and Americans to embrace the horror…Hamas has refused to provide any hostage information because most or all of the hostages are dead. If so then the idea Israel should be willing to exchange terrorists for dead bodies other than one for one should be shelved. Go to adlervonpfingsten.net and read Pamphlet No.1 Obama Preempted, No.2 Mankind’s Final Test of Reason and No.22 Israel; America’s Very Reason to complete the puzzle before you.
there’s just one catch: the whole narrative about the existence of some distinct Palestinian people in need of its own country where it will be able to be idependent and free was invented in order to eliminate the Jewish state. there is no such people, it’s a deceptive lie. so, if you really, truly deradicalize so called palestinians, it would mean them abandoning this delusion. and without the people there’s no one who might need their own country, or even any kind of political national self-determination in a form of a sovereign state. and as long as the delusion is upheld, giving them a state would be suicidal for Israel. you just can’t have it both ways, Hilel. with all the respect to your heroic work, you have to choose between reality and life or delusion and death.
Some were, some left under orders of Syria and Egypt. Either way, you cannot return to a state you left during wartime and continue to seek the destruction of
Actually, the majority of them fled at the advice of the Arab league before they attacked the newly formed Israel. It’s estimated 68% of those displaced never even saw an Israeli soldier…….
Everybody know the reason why you do not want unrwa. They are good for palestinian and they defend the rigth to go back for refugees. But i think that even if you debunked unrwa the rigths of refugees keeps on. These rigths from ginevar convencion does not prescribe.
They don't have to go back because they already live in Palestine. In the 1980's, hundreds of thousands of Cuban refugees were dumped by Cuba in Miami. Cuba purposely cleared out its jails and mental health hospitals and included tens of thousands of them in the refugee dump, and the US government cooperated with this, all without consulting with the people already living in Miami or caring what they thought. Many people who previously lived in Miami were uncomfortable with the changes brought by the new refugees, which included a foreign language, increased crime, drug smuggling, and new neighbors of a strange and unfamiliar ethnicity. Many of these existing citizens moved to places like Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, thirty or forty miles away, to get some distance from what was happening in Miami. For those not familiar with how tiny Israel is, this is about the same distance most Palestinians who packed up their houses during the Nakba had to move to get to the beach in Gaza or the river in the West Bank. Even though these Palestinians were still in “Palestine” and were adopted by new nations ( Jordan and Egypt ), they named themselves “Palestinian Refugees” and made the title an inheritance for their children, to memorialize eternal grievance. The reason you do not hear about the “Florida refugees” who fled Miami and are living in Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale today has less to do with a difference in the situation and more to do with a difference in the people. Go deeper: How the people of Miami perceived Cuban refugees at the time content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,924898,00.html The truth is, the Palestinian Nakba wasn’t a catastrophe. It was a bunch of people packing up their things and moving 20 or 30 miles down the road to the beach or the river, to still live in Palestine with their cousins. It’s not immensely different than the thousands of people who lived in Miami in the 1980’s, when hundreds of thousands of Cuban refugees arrived, about which they were not consulted and had no say, and so who responded by moving 30 miles down the road to Ft. Lauderdale and Boca Raton to get away from them and the perceived changes they brought ( including a foreign language, violence, drug running and crime ). Each Palestinian has received more compensation in foreign aid in the 75 years since than any Miami resident ever received for the house they sold, many times over. What turned this displacement from a temporary material setback into a metaphysical and eternal “catastrophe” is that Palestinians chose war, both at the time and ever since. Palestinians lie in a bed of their own making, and also lie about who made the bed.
The United Nations should finally be held accountable for all the damage it has done. Thank you Hillel for documenting this.
I stop my donations long time ago. Don’t trust any of them.
UNRWA wants to keep "refugees" forever so the cash can keep flowing. And not mentioning the "peaceful" teaching to the children.
It's crazy isn't it that UNRWA has more employees than the UN has to support all other refugees
It’s an outrage……
Spot on Mr. Hillel. The West fell asleep 🇫🇷.
Hillel Neuer, as a fellow Canadian, I am sure you share my anger at Trudeau for his caving in to the Muslim voters here. Very soon after the Muslim groups publicly stated that they would vote NDP next election, surprise-surprise- funding for UNRWA from Canada is resuming. Israel needs new allies. USA, Canada, NZ, AU, UK are vulnerable to public opinion. Israel needs allies who understand the ideology they are facing. The enemy of my enemy is my friend. UAE, Bahrain and Saudi Arabia will not be fair weather friends and they do not want Islamic jihad in their states either.
Hillel Neuer
A true champion for the free world
Great job Hillel!!
Love the clear morality of this man. One of the best resources for the background information spanning years of UNWRA corruption. I thought it was “absurd” that Iran was part of the “Human Rights Council” {with a long list of torturing, rape and murder of women because a head scarfs}! What’s next? Putin appointed to the “Free Speech Committee”?? The UN has been totally corrupted; as it’s doing the opposite of The United Nations Charter! UNRWA has been a major contributor, supporting Hamas. Both must be dissolved. All funding must stop. Let the Palestinians build their own houses. Then they will be busy with rebuilding their “home “. No more “refugee” status. (That gravy train is closed)!
I stand for Israel and praying for you
UNRWA got about $343 million just from the US, and around $400 million more from Europe. The Plastilin The wealthiest miser in the world and best actors chose to use this fortune for terror rather than welfare.
Garbage
It's sickening to see & hear about the corruption going on in the world.
How does one fight wilful ignorance? Hope for this situation to somehow resolve in favour of Israel.
Dialogue and giving the opportunity to learn and unlearn.
... on both sides.
I remember my older brothers taught me, "Never give in to (appease) a bully, who demands you hand over your lunch money." We teach our children to speak out against bullies, unfortunately we have far too few adults like Hillel, with a good measure of intestinal fortitude. Thank you for creating and posting this video, and thank you Hillel for your tireless labours on behalf of the human race. Un grande Canadien.
🎗️ Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. 🎗️
Thank Hillel for EVERYTHING!
The biggest problem is the western democracies doesnt understand this simple principle that UNRWA is Hamas. Its so easy to see that this problem is not solved after 75 years, then there must be a problem with the methods.
I agree 100 %
It's the opposite of peace
They all conspire together. For Israel’s Misery but no matter how hard they try 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱will Rise 🇭🇳♥️🇮🇱
"UNRWA is the opposite of the two state solution" - Obviously yes, you see it in the education they give to the next generation.
Israel was never going to let 2 state ever
@@mikelundmikel4006That's a lie. Look up for history.
@@badivia8402 what's a lie?I know history
@@mikelundmikel4006that is blatantly false. Israel has tried FIVE TIMES since their formation to give the Palestinians their own state. They have refused and chosen war each time……
@@Glenrok in order to even implement 2 states the occupier must define its borders.Israel still hasn't.all the we have offered is usual double speak Israeli bullshit.u.n said ok let's do 1967 border then and Israel has refused every time
I think the chaos we are in is largely due to America's weakness and wokeness Best for Israel to start depending on itself but i have faith in Israel and warriors like you.
2:45 very good point and 100% true
Incredibly important work! 🏆
@Hillel Neuer I didn't know you were Canadian. It makes me proud as a Canadian that you are speaking out so loudly against the rotten mess that the UN has become. You probably share my disgust at how our craven Prime Minister refuses to speak out against evil because he knows it will cost him votes. I look forward to a change of government. Hopefully you will be invited to speak to the House of Commons and tell the new government how things really are in the UN and UNRWA. Please stay safe.
May God bless you to success in doing this not easy job
Re Palestine's bid for UN membership, let's see Palestine's charter, just to make sure it aligns with standards of modern civilized nations.
Article 7:
That there is a Palestinian community and that it has material, spiritual, and historical connection with Palestine are indisputable facts. It is a national duty to bring up individual Palestinians in an Arab revolutionary manner. All means of information and education must be adopted in order to acquaint the Palestinian with his country in the most profound manner, both spiritual and material, that is possible. He must be prepared for the armed struggle and ready to sacrifice his wealth and his life in order to win back his homeland and bring about its liberation.
Article 8:
The phase in their history, through which the Palestinian people are now living, is that of national (watani) struggle for the liberation of Palestine. Thus the conflicts among the Palestinian national forces are secondary, and should be ended for the sake of the basic conflict that exists between the forces of Zionism and of imperialism on the one hand, and the Palestinian Arab people on the other. On this basis the Palestinian masses, regardless of whether they are residing in the national homeland or in diaspora (mahajir) constitute - both their organizations and the individuals - one national front working for the retrieval of Palestine and its liberation through armed struggle.
Article 9:
Armed struggle is the only way to liberate Palestine. This it is the overall strategy, not merely a tactical phase. The Palestinian Arab people assert their absolute determination and firm resolution to continue their armed struggle and to work for an armed popular revolution for the liberation of their country and their return to it . They also assert their right to normal life in Palestine and to exercise their right to self-determination and sovereignty over it.
Article 10:
Commando action constitutes the nucleus of the Palestinian popular liberation war. This requires its escalation, comprehensiveness, and the mobilization of all the Palestinian popular and educational efforts and their organization and involvement in the armed Palestinian revolution. It also requires the achieving of unity for the national (watani) struggle among the different groupings of the Palestinian people, and between the Palestinian people and the Arab masses, so as to secure the continuation of the revolution, its escalation, and victory.
Nope, it's belligerent, terroristic and chillingly threatening of armed violence against Israel, the nation whose deity they shamelessly co-opted. If Palestine is admitted to the UN it will only prove how dangerous the UN actually is to humanity.
It sounds a lot like Palestinian "liberation" is exactly the type of imperial conquest (colonialism, ethnic cleansing) that Israel is being falsely accused of. The Hamas charter of 1988 is similar, although more theocratic than simple pan-Arab nationalism imo.
@@dr.g3860 It just shows that they have made no attempt to reform since '88 and are not rehabilitatable. They are also openly inciting other Arab nations to support them in their goal of conquest.
"Article 15:
The liberation of Palestine, from an Arab viewpoint, is a national (qawmi) duty and it attempts to repel the Zionist and imperialist aggression against the Arab homeland, and aims at the elimination of Zionism in Palestine. Absolute responsibility for this falls upon the Arab nation - peoples and governments - with the Arab people of Palestine in the vanguard. Accordingly, the Arab nation must mobilize all its military, human, moral, and spiritual capabilities to participate actively with the Palestinian people in the liberation of Palestine. It must, particularly in the phase of the armed Palestinian revolution, offer and furnish the Palestinian people with all possible help, and material and human support, and make available to them the means and opportunities that will enable them to continue to carry out their leading role in the armed revolution, until they liberate their homeland."
There is no Palestine or Palestinians. These displaced Arabs, who have no ties to that land, other than Israel giving up the Gaza Strip to them for peace, callas Israel, the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, etc "Palestine." By their claims that the Israelis are "occupiers" they are saying Israel belongs to them. The reason they want to eradicate the Jews to take "their land." These people created chaos and death to every country that allowed them in. A two state solution has always been delusional. We saw that on 10/7. No, do not reward terrorists.
Absolutely ! Why does no one believe in history or truth it seems these things are not important to people any more no one wants to study or think for themselves
Hillel Neuer deserves a Nobel Prize. He will not get it because of globally institutionalized ignorance and bias but he deserves it.
I stand for Israel and praying for you!
💙💙💙
One State 🇮🇱.
Thank you Mr. Neuer❤❤❤
I would love to see Hillel in the same room with the likes of Abby Martin or Norman Finkelstein and watch them try to shout him down as he cites to actual facts because that's the only way they can communicate.
Hillel your courage and incredible dedication are a shining light.
Thank you for demonstrating how it’s done and giving me a great sense of Jewish pride! Am Yisrael Chai 🙏🏼🇮🇱🎗️✡️💙
BS in regard to the lie of the moderate vs "radical Islam" go read the Quran. It's radical.
Why doesn't this man get any mainstream time? Who owns the media? Has to be Islam..
😢
I love how they both knew what to do and how they were going to do it but didn't need to communicate directly together
Good talk. Thank you. Though some audio dropouts that deletes the names mentioned.
The UN as well as UNRWA are supposed to be advocating for Peace, and both has been failing since Hamas became the governing body of the Gaza Strip.
Up until the Gaza war I did think that UNO was not part of thesolution and now I find out they are even part of the problem? 😮
@@neatwheat catch up, people around the world know about the troubling mess with the UN in the Middle East.
@@evilfingers4302 I know I'm kinda late to the party but I'm finally catching up 🤣
Just started to think about it when there was this issue that NATO wanted to make sure that there would not happen genpzides on the Balkan wars but (of course) there was a veto of the permanent heading member Russia so they had to do it withput a UN mandate. They happened to be a little for some genozides but at least could manage to end the war for good. But certain nationalist people still angry about that keep bringing it up all the time (because "the West bad, therefore Putin good" or so)
Same story happened again whe Ukraine was invaded and UN council was going to condemn the invasion but Russia vetoed against it. And next month even happened to start its head of the council period and of course wasn't decent about lobbying for nationalistic BS in the UN parliament. Maybe UN is the best option we have to be a more peaceful species but it doesn't really seemto work 🤷♂️
🙏🇬🇧🙏🇬🇧🙏🇬🇧
Netanyahu and the Israeli government need to be proactive. I wrote this to the Embassy of Israel:
---At this juncture Netanyahu would be well advised to boldly appeal directly to the American people who are sick and tired of the farce that is the United Nations and a foreign policy that refuses to confront the evil that is Islam i.e. withdraw from the Israel hating United Nations and make it clear that if the effort to provide Hamas and exit from the field is pressed, Israel will (threaten to?) sever diplomatic relations with the United States for cause…lack of moral and ethical clarity. Israel has everything to gain and nothing to lose by doing so.
How hard would it be to cite the number of resolutions and votes against Israel as compared to every other nation combined? If Netanyahu does so Israel can be sure American patriots, the sleeping giant, will rise to fight the good fight as they have so many times in history.---
Doing so would be a courageous and liberating act on the part of Israel…and to it I would add some common sense that for average Americans would represent a red line Israel can stand behind hand in hand with Americans i.e. there is nothing to negotiate until Hamas provides 1) the names of every hostage, and 2) proof of life…and until the information is provided Israel will continue the offensive to destroy Hamas sans negotiations.
As difficult as it will be, it is time for Israel and Americans to embrace the horror…Hamas has refused to provide any hostage information because most or all of the hostages are dead. If so then the idea Israel should be willing to exchange terrorists for dead bodies other than one for one should be shelved.
Go to adlervonpfingsten.net and read Pamphlet No.1 Obama Preempted, No.2 Mankind’s Final Test of Reason and No.22 Israel; America’s Very Reason to complete the puzzle before you.
The west isn't listening!
Why aren't the meetings televised through the west?
He is a true hero bordering on a Rock Star in my books! " Algeria, where are your Jews? "....classic!!!!
Well done, keep up the good work.
🇨🇦❤🇮🇱
Good work
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Hey! Moms matter, but audio technicians matter too 😂
Btw, thank you for your brave, invaluable and probably very frustrating work 🙏
🎗️🎗️🎗️
Hillel deserves more pixels. ;)
I don’t think the word democracy has a positive meaning these days. Most are corrupt or undermined from within.
Which country's name keeps getting edited out of the audio? Why? And by whom? This is America. We don't tolerate such nonsense.
AIPAC in drag.
unrwa funds hamas
No 2 state. It's so naive and dengues.
USELESS NOTHING
there’s just one catch:
the whole narrative about the existence of some distinct Palestinian people in need of its own country where it will be able to be idependent and free was invented in order to eliminate the Jewish state.
there is no such people, it’s a deceptive lie.
so, if you really, truly deradicalize so called palestinians, it would mean them abandoning this delusion. and without the people there’s no one who might need their own country, or even any kind of political national self-determination in a form of a sovereign state.
and as long as the delusion is upheld, giving them a state would be suicidal for Israel.
you just can’t have it both ways, Hilel. with all the respect to your heroic work, you have to choose between reality and life or delusion and death.
UN
Garbage
You are missing main point . They were forcefully removed from their original land . They want to return.
Some were, some left under orders of Syria and Egypt. Either way, you cannot return to a state you left during wartime and continue to seek the destruction of
They are old geezers now, if still alive. What's the average life expectancy in Gaza?
Actually, the majority of them fled at the advice of the Arab league before they attacked the newly formed Israel. It’s estimated 68% of those displaced never even saw an Israeli soldier…….
@@Glenrok This. You can’t leave hoping to invade and then expect to be invited back.
@@lrmry Right. Amazing if you think about it. This should be mentioned way more often in these discussions!
Du vet inte vad du pratar om
Everybody know the reason why you do not want unrwa. They are good for palestinian and they defend the rigth to go back for refugees. But i think that even if you debunked unrwa the rigths of refugees keeps on. These rigths from ginevar convencion does not prescribe.
They don't have to go back because they already live in Palestine. In the 1980's, hundreds of thousands of Cuban refugees were dumped by Cuba in Miami. Cuba purposely cleared out its jails and mental health hospitals and included tens of thousands of them in the refugee dump, and the US government cooperated with this, all without consulting with the people already living in Miami or caring what they thought. Many people who previously lived in Miami were uncomfortable with the changes brought by the new refugees, which included a foreign language, increased crime, drug smuggling, and new neighbors of a strange and unfamiliar ethnicity. Many of these existing citizens moved to places like Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale, thirty or forty miles away, to get some distance from what was happening in Miami.
For those not familiar with how tiny Israel is, this is about the same distance most Palestinians who packed up their houses during the Nakba had to move to get to the beach in Gaza or the river in the West Bank. Even though these Palestinians were still in “Palestine” and were adopted by new nations ( Jordan and Egypt ), they named themselves “Palestinian Refugees” and made the title an inheritance for their children, to memorialize eternal grievance. The reason you do not hear about the “Florida refugees” who fled Miami and are living in Boca Raton and Fort Lauderdale today has less to do with a difference in the situation and more to do with a difference in the people.
Go deeper: How the people of Miami perceived Cuban refugees at the time
content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,924898,00.html
The truth is, the Palestinian Nakba wasn’t a catastrophe. It was a bunch of people packing up their things and moving 20 or 30 miles down the road to the beach or the river, to still live in Palestine with their cousins. It’s not immensely different than the thousands of people who lived in Miami in the 1980’s, when hundreds of thousands of Cuban refugees arrived, about which they were not consulted and had no say, and so who responded by moving 30 miles down the road to Ft. Lauderdale and Boca Raton to get away from them and the perceived changes they brought ( including a foreign language, violence, drug running and crime ).
Each Palestinian has received more compensation in foreign aid in the 75 years since than any Miami resident ever received for the house they sold, many times over. What turned this displacement from a temporary material setback into a metaphysical and eternal “catastrophe” is that Palestinians chose war, both at the time and ever since. Palestinians lie in a bed of their own making, and also lie about who made the bed.
Exactly very sound explanation for the less knowledgeable
@@ghrosenblots of excuses here, but none are tangible. You are trying hard to justify the unjustifiable.
They are not defending anyone but themselves
With "Cousins" like the "Palestinians" - who can afford a family????