I’m quite upset that Guerlain has changed the sizes of Guerlain Rouge G lipsticks and cases, as well as the formula. It’s a ripoff for the consumer, an act of pure greed. Guerlain had had the best lipstick formula on the market, imho, and the coolest cases. I wish they’d heed to the old Ann Landers axiom: If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!
Totally agree on the Guerlain lipsticks, just gifted my mom one and specifically asked her to keep the case... what a disappointment to see such obvious corporate greed. We all know it's the main business motivation but don't make your regular customers angry!
Haven’t finished watching yet, but I have to respond to the Guerlain issue! I feel very betrayed and made a fool of, because I trusted that these lovely cases would be refillable collectibles - just 11 months ago I gifted my daughter one (the beautiful summer floral one) and told her how she’s be able to continually refill it, which makes me feel like an idiot. This is clearly a case of rampant greed and, like you, I have not bought either a new lipstick nor a new case. I feel by boycotting them, we might be able to send the message we are displeased, since the bottom line is all they care about apparently. I am a really old time customer, having bought my first Mėteorites in the early 1980s and my first fragrances even before that (I lived in Europe then). I really hate feeling this way. Oh, and don’t get me started on their concern for their impact on the environment and championing sustainability! Leaving people with loads of unusable lipstick cases is not sustainable! Ok, back to watching and thank you for addressing this issue and doing so at the beginning of your video!
@@elenapolshakov3837 I’m sorry you’re having to deal with this as well. Clearly, the powers behind Guerlain didn’t give any thought to their existing clients, or worse, they did and couldn’t care less….
I’m so angry about the Guerlain relaunch of Rouge G because it’s not just a waste of money, but it makes the old cases junk. It’s a disgrace. And you’re 100% right that the new case could have been retrofitted.
I too am upset/disappointed about the Rouge G lipstick case change. I was a collector of them, as well as gave them as “forever” gifts to others. Knowing what they are able to do to their loyal customers leaves a bad taste in my mouth and I will absolutely not buy the new ones and feel Guerlain let us down. Knowing that, I am not entertaining really picking up anything new from the brand. I am sure that will fade, but I will absolutely not buy any Rouge G lipsticks and cases. There are too many great alternatives out there. Guerlain just had an edge with the cases on top of a good lipstick formula. 💔
I am a mechanical engineer who designs hardware day in and day out, hw can be made to retrofit even using new materials that are resourced in an environmentally sustainable way. Guerlain pissed me off a lot. All of my hard earned money spent over the years collecting the cases and now I can’t use them, what do these companies think? customer always has the power of not purchasing which is what I am going to do.
I have collected the Rouge G cases since they came out. For every sentimental occasion, my husband has purchased a lipstick and case, and engraved them with something meaningful. Now those precious memories will end of in landfill once the lipstick finishes, or expires/goes off. How sustainable is that? I won’t buy these. Maybe a special holiday case or colour, but I am going to lavish my love and attention on the cases and lipsticks that I already have.
I too am upset with Guerlain lipsticks and for that reason I will not be purchasing. The consumer’s only way of sending a message is by not buy that particular product. I hope they change it back 💚
I bought a new Rouge G case and a newly formulated lipstick. The case (tortoise/gold) is beautiful and is a tad smaller, but when you open it and set it down, it won’t sit flat. The weight of the mirror tips it over onto its side. As for the satin formula, it is superb. I bought shade 518 which is a midtoned warm pink. You can put a new lipstick in the old case, but not vice versa. Rouge G has always been a favorite, but I think I’ll just buy the lipstick without the case from now on and keep the black plastic tube cover.
I am furious about the Rouge G cases. I have around 30 of the LE. This is a slap in the face to loyal customers. So much for their environmental credentials. This is pure greed.
I agree with you 100% about Guerlain! I'm so disappointed in the lack of advanced notice/transparency about the Rouge G changes. They were still producing the old cases as recently as this spring when I bought the sakura case. If I had known, I never would've purchased it. It feels like a slap in the face to say they are all about sustainability and the environment when they make a change like this. Many brands have done this over the years - I have so many fancy cases, including the collectible Meteorites pressed powder compact and other fragrance cases from Guerlain, where they stopped making the refills, so you were just stuck with empty components. However, the difference now is that they claim to be producing these components in the name of sustainability as well as the collectible aspect, so it's a huge turn off. This is definitely strike 2 for me with Guerlain this year after they changed the fragrance of the Meteorites powder. I'm getting tired of stockpiling makeup that is being discontinued, it has an expiration date so there's only so much you can pick up.
I recently ordered the entire Addiction Tokyo seashells collection for summer and I was so happy with it all, except for the Glitter mascara which I don’t recommend. I loved everything, esp eyeshadow formulas. It reminds be of old Suqqu and Surratt, but more pigmented. Wonderful product. Check out the blushes! I loved the lip tints that look like a shiny, smooth stain, but weren’t drying on me. With Virginie Viard leaving Chanel and rumors Hedi Slimane taking over, we can guess how makeup collections may look going forward. I’d guess a bit more subdued. I just want better formulas whatever the direction. The R2W will probably be a drastic change if you loved Viard’s designs. Agree a you on the Mario bronzer and the fair is an excellent contour that truly looks natural on fair skin.
Jen, I only started purchasing the Guerlain Rouge G Lipsticks and Cases last year! I have about ten? I did purchase these due to being recommended but also because I wanted to personally try the brand. I bought several different formula of lipstick and did so during the times we love best - Sales! So, imagine my disappointment with Guerlain after pulling this stunt and will be receiving a correspondence from myself as they are taking us for fools and I'm angry! I just started with these lipsticks and now the cases are redundant, only to be left with searching the secondary market for refills. Jen, it's not your fault that I bought these lipsticks, it was my decision and something I wanted to do. If you want to buy these newer ones, I will definitely not hold it against you. If they are eventually reduced, I may purchase myself. Its just the I've lost any trust in Guerlain due to this deception. Of course, they could gave made these new cases to fit the older lipsticks, they simply wanted to make more money on this marketing ploy. How naive to think that the customers wouldn't be upset! Prada! Everyone keeps buying the 'blue' balm that is always going to turn pink, (the initial green was universal), yet I want to see the coloured ones tried. I'm in love with this brand and own every eye palette and many lipsticks - but I want more! Due to having very dry lips, Id like to see how these perform, although I'll be waiting for the Selfridges Sale at the end of the year. I can't remember if you ever covered Rabanne. Another brand that I've fallen for and own almost every product. I have all four Quads and every Duo except for one that consists of two bright creamy textures. Their lip balms are something special and AU$20.00 cheaper than Prada's. Theyre so creamy and there is actually colour pay-off. They also have products that you can mix into other cosmetics or use alone. After buying all if these, I felt like the mad scientist of beauty. Yet, so much can be altered by using these. I also bought the gold/silver glitter topper to go over mascara. As I didnt need mascara, I can't speak on those. I also bought the three metallic lipsticks and a few of their regular ones. The packaging is beautiful and the prices very reasonable compared to other luxury brands. I cannot fault any of their products and I basically have the range. It was through YSL that I discovered your Channel, Jen. I had purchased the large Couture Clutch Palettes and was looking around for anyone else who had them. I found a great deal of products from YSL that I'm very happy with. It's such a shame that it took the new Quads to finally awaken everyone to the great products that they produce. Just like the four Burberry Quads, I feel that YSL are staying with colours that are conducive to all age groups. Although, the only palette I bought was the L/E Blue /Green. The others are beautiful and I would love them all but I have far too much now. YSL do need to expand on lip-liners, eye-liners and hopefully bring back blush and highlighter. Dior has pretty much lost me. It's run by the richest man in the world and they couldn't get something as simple as a reformulation correct. I love the Addict Lipsticks and Cases, yet not that much interests me anymore. I don't like the replacements of the Backstage Eye Palettes and have only purchased Smokey Essentials. I had been collecting every palette, yet not now. When you look at the original colour stories and compare the replacements, it's a no brainer that they've ruined the line. I have so many Maximisers that I don't need more, the same with Glow Balms and in future I'll be buying Rabanne's. I honestly have no interest in these new Duo Palettes as I just don't need them. Ah, Chanel. The first brand that I really delved into in my 20s. I so loved the products they released, their lip products hold a secret that actually treats my dry lips and they have surprised me with recent releases. The Byzance Quads blew me away! I love them. It was due to them being so different from what they normally release that I was so excited when I saw them that I purchased them all. I have no issue with the Balm Essentials, yet only tend to buy those that can be used over the face in many ways. I bought their Eye Quint at Christmas and even added the Duo Highlighter which I enjoy and added a liquid lipstick in Inflexible, a golden bronze. Their products can be rather hit and miss with me and these are usually the cash grabs of the over-sized products that no-one would get through if it was the only product used in a lifetime! Have always loved their mascara and bought their primer last year after not that thrilled with Dior's mascara. I only have a few lipsticks in iconic red shades as I don't need anymore - I'm swamped. They got me with the Highlighter early this year that shifts from pink to blue, something else rather new to Chanel. I added to this the Balm Essential in Mermaid Glow. I'm turning more towards some of Chanel's products, as I turn against Dior. I'm buying much more from Givenchy too, which is a brand that is very underrated, especially their eye-shadows. Please don't show that new Chanel release again as I won't be able to restrain myself! Id be happy with everything on the page, yet that won't be happening. I just love the compact with the Berry Blush and Pink Highlighter. I love the other too, yet one is the limit. I won't be getting a Balm Essential, yet if you feel you have to buy one Jen, despite not liking them, I hope its the deeper shade. I like the look of the neon-like green eye-liner which goes beautifully with the Natasha Denona Yucca Palette. I went out on a whim to try some eye-liners from the Sephora Collection. They had a sale of Buy 3 products, get one free. I went for some beautifully coloured retractable liners that applied so very soft and look amazing in the shades I choose. I also bought a regular pencil, yet only due to it being in a most incredible mint shade. I was so impressed by these, that I will be getting more of the retractable ones in particular. When it came to washing the swatches off only my thumb, they would hardly budge, even with soap and a tissue! Can't wait to wear them. I did go on a tangent to try brands I hadn't used before and NARS was one. I purchased the Stargazing Eye Palette, Face Palette and the L/E Audacious Lipstick. Great products all. I even picked up the Summer Unrated Eye Palette from eBay but I'm afraid I have so much, adding another brand is senseless. Unless they come out with something super special, I won't be buying anything else soon. Jen, why would you spend $6,000 on fashion jewellery from Chanel when you can invest in stunning fine jewellery that no-one else will own? I have a beautiful fine jewellery collection, even a piece that is the only one on the continent. Believe me, it didn't come close to US$6,000! I'd rather you be an individual and invest in antique jewellery or anything other than these pieces that are nowhere near the quality of what is charged. Why not go into Tiffany & Co. and buy something special there or another well known Jeweller? If only you could see what I have and Chanel's endless multiples wouldn't interest you so much. I'm only offeting up other options, if you are adamant you want Chanel, it's your money to do as you please. Well, that's it for my long run-down on each of these brands and may I add that Shiseido is another brand that's greatly overlooked, just like Rabanne. Thanks Jen for these discussions on what our feelings are about the brands. You're the only one that does this as far as I know and it's very much appreciated, Kris.🇦🇺💖👩🏼🎨
Thanks for the updates! Nice to follow someone who is not only savvy on many matters, but is looking for new creative brands that are branching out from the beauty space which I’m sure is not easy to break into.
When I saw the cases didn't fit I refused to buy any more Guerlain Rouge G lip products. All my old expensive cases are now garbage. What a waste of my money. I am not falling for it again Guerlain. I will stick with your disposable lip products. I was also upset when they changed the Meteorite scent. The new scent is nice (Samsara ish) but the original was iconic. Why not make all special edition shades in the new scent? I am done with the new normal....the unending parade of reformulations. Companies never used to tell us about a reformulation. They would do it. Now companies change the tiniest thing and use it as a means of marketing. A product would have to offer truly next level performance or something really special for me to buy it at this point. Your business is reviewing makeup so it is understandable for you to buy and compare items. I love your channel!
I have the ORIGINAL case the was reshaped, so the next version fell out. I thought they learned better Hashtag that company #DearReader: make them bleed 🩸 social media ire over this 💢customer SLAP💢
I hardly comment, but I am glad you mentioned Guerlain. I have been a long-time user, especially the Terracotta and Meteorites Perles. The first time they came out with Rouge G, I was smitten with the formula and shades. I was reluctant because of the case. I bought only one and was disappointed because it was big and bulky and was weighing down my purse! So that was it for me. Only one. And now, I am more disappointed where they raised the price on the perles, does not smell as pretty as it did and lowered the quantity, not to mention shimmer! I don't want to look like a disco ball! thank you!. Terracotta also does not smell 'pretty' as in the past in my opinion. So yes! disappointing (don't take us for fools Guerlain!). Thank you for the review.
I really enjoyed this discussion and video. I struggle between loving a fine quality beautiful luxury item and feeling like I’m being taken in by the hype. If anyone ever analyzed the actual cost to make a luxury palette and broke it down by packaging, product and advertising I think it would blow up the beauty community.
Completely agree with the Guerlain Rouge G debacle, I think it is huge disrespect to the collector and their loyal base that those cases that all of a sudden can't be used. I never collected any, and have just 1. I like their cosmetics and am a huge fan of their fragrances, but the new meteorites scent has a cloying heavy aura, not the fresh violet of yore. I can't understand why a company would change their beloved bestselling products--it makes me want to hoard the things I love which is dumb because it'll go bad and be a wasteful act. On the bright side, I LOVE RMS beauty and Ms Swift is a great down to earth makeup artist and spokeswoman--who else can't stop watching her videos and shorts on how to apply her products??? I LOVE her bronzers, blushes, and the SPF 30 glowing tint. Also burgeoning with new launches --YSL, their products are stellar, from the lippies to the bronzers/powder/concealers...check them out! Thanks for a great video!!
This is the 3rd time that Fendi is releasing perfumes :) I really loved them, every time ❤️ They were really special and not mainstream at all, so I hope that this time it will be the same :) Ps: I loved loved loved Fan Di Fendi EDP, I miss it so much😢 ❤
disappointed with the new guerlain lipstick cases - i only have 2 of the old ones but that’s still two cases that i will eventually have to throw away. if i knew they would do this i would’ve just bought something else instead.
I absolutely agree with you on the Guerlain lipstick cases and i am certainly not buying the new lipsticks. Although there are other products from Guerlain that I love I am thinking about stopping buying any Guerlain products in the future.
I picked up the new Chantecaille blush and lip sheer and I think they are really pretty (and the blush is quite shimmery). I like the experience of Chantecaille. Nothing else stands out to me but I did repurchase the Lisa Eldridge mascara and grabbed one of her lucent lip colors, I love that formula so much. Really too bad about Guerlain esp because this is not a sustainable practice.
I agree completely with your assessment of Guerlain. I absolutely will not buy any of the new lipstick or new cases. I love Shalimar and some of their other perfumes. But, their makeup is far too fragranced for me. The Dior blushes/highlighters remind me of the Wayne Goss.
I have over 20 of those old Geurlain lipstick cases, and I feel screwed by the redesign that won't make new lipsticks coordinate with the old cases. I am never buying any more makeup from Guerlain. Period. What a slap in the face! My cases will be garbage when those lipsticks wear out. It was grossly insulting and I'm angry. I may try the Prada balm in Maple. I am glad you'll be getting those YSL palettes. The formula is a dream and I want to see those colors. I applaud you wanting to bring more brands into your channel. Haven't tried Sweed yet, but hoping you do Suqqu Fall 2024. I want to see the newest Moisture Glaze lipsticks, in particular. And more Japanese brands in general. If I'm paying for luxury, I want real luxury, like Cle de Peau. Thanks for the video!💚
I only have one Rouge G lipstick and case, so I'm not super annoyed at Guerlain. But I do like some of their new cases and might pick up a new shade in the coming months. It also looks like the metal color on the cases (and the lipsticks) has changed from a silver metal to a gold colored metal. I'm not sure even if the new lipsticks fit if the mixed metals would have looked as good. I'm definitely looking forward to Fall and whatever new brands you choose to show us besides selected pieces from our favorite brands.😁
Hello. Normally I do not comment on videos. But I have to say, I feel the same way about Guerlain lipsticks. I bought two lipcases for my wedding. And now, I can look at them, yes. But I will not be able to buy a lipstick, that fit into them anymore. And I will not buy new lipsticks and cases again from Guerlain just because I do not want to encourage this move. I am very disappointed. :( Dior also improved their lipsticks, but everything fits together. I love your videos.
I have this beautiful silver lipstick case from my great grandmother (probably bought in the 20’s)- it’s designed similar to the guerlain, with open mirror concept, but it is real silver and it is smaller profile (no plastic inserts, just a silver holder for a bullet) - it has the cutest red button - I wonder who made it, how,much it cost, and what the brand was. It still has residual red lipstick, though I remember as a child that it still had 1/2 the bullet; it smelled like that perfect,lipstick waxy scent, but kind of really *off* from age too - it was old even 50 years ago - I bet I could remove a bullet from another lipstick and use this case - it might be messy - it may be too small of a holder for modern lipsticks But actually, I won’t… bc the case is not as convenient or slick or secure as new cases - it is just a little bobble of memory for me and some makeup history - BTW, I bought the guerlain tortoise and a new satin - the case is beautiful, slicker, lighter, glossy - the formula is also lighter and smoother, with less scent - I like it - I remember a few years back finding these beautiful cases and lipsticks and then, for some reason, I found a bunch of comments on the internet about how the “old cases” were different from the “new cases” and people were mad - so, fortunately, I knew it would obviously happen again and I always just bought the “package deal” for the full price - I never finish lipsticks bc lipstick is my thing, so reusable is not anything that will ever be something that I can participate in - plus, things get scratched and messy and old - I baby my makeup and my Westman Atelier containers are trashed, no idea how, but I’ll never refill them (not like she makes refills????) I wish they had given us a warning first, especially for reusable and intricate packaging like this - but packaging will always change, which is all we can count on - any other claims are marketing tricks, unfortunately - or maybe “good intentions” but intentions are always replaced with ease of production and cost - I don’t believe it was a money grab … just normal turnover
Ok, I was researching “why did guerlain do this” casually on the internet Found a 2018 case about guerlain not being able to patent this specific shape (while it was allowed in a previous case) And most interesting to me is… I found my exact great grandmother’s lipstick case picture used online! On this site femmefashionforward I found that guerlain apparently made the lipstick tr 20:50 end more acceptable in polite society … then ‘Following this, in 1915, Maurice Levy invented lipstick with a lever that would push the stick up through a 2 inch, protective, metal tube for the Scovil Manufacturing Company. This American company was the first to mass produce lipsticks in a metal tube.” And a picture of my lipstick case! Could it be from my great great grandmother?! Well… change can be irritating and they’re always changing and marketing to get more money out of us… but the history is fascinating
Thank you for the Guerlain update-I had a new refill in my cart not realizing it would be a different size from my old cases. I’ve been collecting the cherry blossom cases but those stay home and I purchased them knowing they would expire-but I have a classic case that I carry around and change out the lipsticks. Well, I used to-I guess there’s no classic anymore. I was upset they changed the scent of the Meteorites (old Guerlain + Physician’s formula butter balm = new scent). Instead of this dumb cash grab, they could have increased their revenue by creating some innovative new products that their loyal customers would buy.
You should look at Besuty Pie. I believe they are available in the USA now. The products are amazing quality, all made by the same manufacturers that make products for all the high end brands, but at factory prices because all the middle men have been removed from the equation. One of the lipsticks I have from them is identical to my Charlotte Tilbury ones, but cost 1/3 of the price. Their eyeliner pencils are just as good as my VBB ones too. ❤
I have some of the old Guerlain cases that I was saving to put on newly released shades of lipstick, so I'm very disappointed as well. I am interested in the Chantecaille blushes, would love to see them on you! Another fantastic video, thank you!
I really enjoyed this format of video. You are giving some really solid thoughts based on your experience on what you will and won't buy and why. I also love the Nerra body oil! It is amazingly good, and possibly better than my OG OSEA body oil!
Thank you, ITA with every word. It's called LVMH green-washing. I'm not buying new Guerlain Rouge G cases and lipsticks either. How is it sustainable to make all your loyal customers' Rouge G collections worthless and useless? And, I am angry, I've bought them as gifts for friends and recommended them. They ruined their foundations too, pretending it was all about sustainability with their new formulations and bottles.
I agree with you about the Guerlain lipstick cases. There was NO reason to change the case shape. It's just rude!!! I am not going to buy any more cases or new lipsticks. There are other brands of lipsticks that are just as nice.
Agree with you on Guerlain and about the Makeup by Mario bronzer. Splurged on higher priced cases and I still covet the denim case, which are all now useless :-( Love the fair shade and its staying power and how it sets. It pairs beautifully with TF Terra or Gucci bronzer imo, and bought a backup. Thank you for informing us about the upcoming releases and reformulations!
Thankyou for your sharing your thoughts on the guerlain lipsticks. Had purchased my very first case this year - the cherry bloom because I was so intrigued by the Japanese design story. Extremely disappointing to know I won’t be able to get a proper refill for it when the time comes.
Good morning. I’m to am very disappointed with Guerlain. I have a few of their limited edition cases, such as the cherry blossom and last summers denim Jean case that I absolutely love! The excuse that it was product sourcing for the reason to change is inexcusable….it is greed pure and simple. The cases were exclusively designed for Guerlain and were produce to their specifications and they owe the consumer an apology, imo and be responsible by offering a resource to have the older cases refilled. Will that happen…No, but it would go a long way to improve their relationship with consumers who feel cheated.
I don't know if you are interested in reviewing skincare brands but I have discovered one that I just love. The brand is Dr. Burgener and it's from Switzerland. Actually truly good for sensitive skin, I have no irritation at all from this line and it's the only line I've ever used that actually does reduce my facial redness and leave it calm and clear, even after cleansing. I am in my 6th decade and have been playing with high end skincare and makeup since I was 12 years old, so I know a thing or two. ( I probably should have been a dermatologist.) Very pure, very gentle, very pleasant to use and really treats my skin with respect, moisturizing it and protecting it by day and throughout the night, very effectively. That is the battle for me, finding products that do not irritate or cause an allergic reaction, that moisturize all day and again upon reapplication all night and are not heavy, greasy, oily, do not cause clogged pores, etc. and comfortable to wear makeup over. And no, I do not work for this brand and am not affiliated in any way, I'm just a customer, a very pleased customer. Also, Dr. Burgener makes these facial cleansing mitts that are extremely soft to wash with. They are pricy but effective in that there is no scratching, roughness, or irritation at all and I have been using wash cloths for baby's skin from many brands. My skin turns red from the slightest touch so I need the softest of items including makeup brushes. Anyway, if you are interested you may want to check it out.
Jennifer I couldn’t agree more with you about Guerlain. It’s so blatantly greedy. I liked the lipsticks but they certainly aren’t the only ones I favour and there are so many good ones available now I don’t feel that I want to support that greed further. Yes the cases are/were beautiful but a case isn’t a deal breaker for me. I will continue to buy Mitsouko and Shalimar because I have loved them for 30 years but lipsticks? Not important enough to me.
Jennifer, great update on what’s coming for our money 😱😳🤪😝 so Chanel always gets me. Even when I don’t rush to purchase right away, I digest slow…. And month later bum i am buying 😂 I said I am going to skip sun-kissed powders, and Medium coral is in the mail… especially it’s hard for me to resist everything bronzed/ sun-kissed/ summer corals . Was going to skip Dior blushes, but got poppy coral one. So as long as it’s summery I am probably getting it😂. So the big jewelry 80’s trend, I love it. But not getting Chanel costume jewelry. 3 factors why it’s crazy expensive ( I used to buy those very expensive ones from Bombay, Salzburg, dubai, etc.. collections) Quality is not there. And 3- not unique … I am craving more individuality, uniqueness and quality. There are so many vintage designs and architecture artist jewelry- most of them gold plated, , definitely unique. I just purchased old Celine archives Phoebe Philo, gold plated wide cuff. Was going to get Robert Lee Morris but the cuffs , that I liked, run so small… I am so over Chanel, right now. Still loving very discreet elegant, Chanelesque effect, no logos, Karl’s RTW, but I sold A lot, even handbags. And right now I am looking more at vintage bags also… But might Chanel become great again, VV just stepped down. Who knows which direction Chanel will go…. But for me right now, it’s Old Celine, PP brand, Jill Sander, Carven and Gabriella Hearst . Great quality… details, uniqueness…., fashion forward/ style Have a blessed day🙏❤️
Unfortunate about the New Guerlain Lipsticks because I was really excited to see and possible purchase new shades and use the cases I already own. 🖤😊. I agree with your thoughts on RMS beauty. I am excited to see where they are headed.
I own but one Guerlain lipstick case, it's a cherry blossom one from a few years ago. But I have the most perfect unique lipstick in it, 888M Noble Burgundy METALLIC, not the matte. A warm-ish red with gold foil undertone, like red foiled wrapping paper, Christmas in a lipstick. And it tends to blur around the edges of my lips and looks like an old Hollywood film with a filter. This Metallic shade is still available at Sephora in Canada, but nowhere else in the US. I guess if the cases are rubbish, at least I have the most fabulous lipstick in mine. Interesting Viard is leaving Chanel, I loved her tweed designs. I read an article that seemed to imply that the quality issues are what the house wants a quick pivot from. Not that Viard is necessarily at fault, rather the idea of a fast 180 is what the house wants to show. I too hearken back to 80s and 90s Chanel, mine would be a navy tweed suit on Vogue in like 93, cheerleader type mini skirt, bows. It was a young look, I couldn't wear it now. Instead I got a St. John navy boucle suit with detachable faux fur collar and cuffs. Doesn't fit me now. 🤷🏻♀️😂
Amen Beautiful Woman!!! I could suggest a place where everyone could put their of no use anymore lipstick cases.... 🤐 I personally, will never buy from them again .
Great video! What I enjoyed most this year so far was the Chanel spring-release makeup (Rivage) and the RMS Supernatural radiance serum. I have used that RMS serum everyday since I tried it months ago- I mix the lightest and medium shades- beautiful under makeup and blurring/ radiant worn alone. Very interested in seeing what both of these brands come out with.
Yes thank you! I was beyond upset that Guerlain changed their lipsticks and cases without notice. I feel so back stabbed by them a total money grab. 😡😤😤 I will not be purchasing their lipsticks in the future for sure!
6:02 I feel exactly the same way I will not be buying them it ticks me off for sure will not support that brand any more… I’m sure people will tho so they won’t care … I’m glad DIOR didn’t change them … that Mario bronzer felt so good when I searched it
I agree with you about the gulerian lipstick case change. It's is annoying because my cases are now worthlesswhen I run out of lipstick. I'm not buying new cases or lipstick from gulerian anymore.
People saying there old cases will go in the trash.....OTT !! If there "collectors"you dont have to use them ! Iv got some but love the new gold case and lipsticks
You want to collect items that completely lost their purpose? What are you gonna do w empty lipstick cases😂they're pretty but far from art to have sitting around pointlessly
Hi Jen, I live in Sydney, Australia and the makeup I am buying must be available in stores. I just buy luxury products and I need to see and try them before buying. So for me small indie brands or brands not available here are a hard pass. Since I started to wear makeup I always preferred to have less but very good products than to be a makeup hoarder with a lot of low/average quality products. The brands I am interested (available in Australia) are Chanel, Hermes, Tom Ford, Chantecaille, Sisley, Gucci and Guerlain (not lipsticks). I used to love Dior but not so much these days. RMS, Makeup by Mario, Rare Beauty, Fenty, Natasha Denona, Charlotte Tilbury, Pat McGrath, Nars etc are just average in the best case scenario and not what I am looking for on your channel. The only things I buy online are makeup brushes with natural hair. The brushes with synthetic hair I love are from Chantecaille and Rae Morris. I already have an extensive collection and I don’t need more. I might be interested only in Sonia G limited edition if it’s something exiting. Rae Morris will come soon with a limited edition set. The brushes are gorgeous but the set will be $1299 and probably I will skip it. Thanks for sharing!🙂
Sadly. They need to really change their lipsticks back. For those who can’t spend a crap ton to begin with. This bothers me Yeah. There are more problems. Any company. Upping their prices and then slapping us ? Wrong. I saw the Chanel runway as well. But their prices 😮😮😮😮they have really gone crazy with them.
Great video. Big big pass on the Guerlain new cases and lipsticks. I have the old ones that are now useless. I'm quite irked and it is nothing but pure simple greed. It will be a long time before I buy ANY Guerlain product which is a shame but I'm not ok with the direction.
By the way - has anyone seen in person the latest Tom Ford and Estee Lauder slim lipsticks? Was wondering if they're the same in a slightly different packaging, in terms of formula as well.
I didn’t get into the whole lipstick case thing but I think it’s a big mistake. Truly disrespecting their customers. I can’t wait for your Sweed video. I wonder if you’ve reviewed Yensa. I stumbled on few products that I like and didn’t hear about them. After purchasing, I searched around and seems like came on the scene a few years back but not sure why didn’t get too much traction. Love Chantecaille but thought the recent releases where meha. Package not to the standard I would expect at that price point. I totally love you point in terms of thinking about what we’re purchasing, a range which should have a spectrum. Great video Jennifer!
It is upsetting and confusing to me that Guerlain changed their so the new lipsticks do not fit properly the old cases. What is strange to me is that they claim to be more environmentally friendly, but what are we to do with the old cases… throw them out eventually? It seems very wasteful. They could have just made the new cases to fit and people would have still bought them
The only issue is that you have to be careful regarding authenticity. Don’t get me wrong most of it is great. But just be careful. Happy to discuss details in a DM 😊
Sarah Creal has started a beauty line aimed at women over 40. I am very tempted but waiting for reviews first. Hint hint. I ordered from SWEED beauty and folks should be aware they are based in the UK and shipping is slow. Next time I will opt for expedited shipping.
@@camelliainzurich1262 wow!!! It only takes 1-2 weeks to get to me. Although this week I’ve had USPS state a item was delivered to NY and then it arrived here 3 days later and DHL completely mess up an overseas shipment so I guess I should not be surprised
It would have been so easy for Guerlain to make the new lipsticks fit into the old cases. There's really no excuse. But it's not just the lipsticks. They've changed the formula for my favorite fragrance, Samsara, as well. And the new fragrance for the Meteorites isn't as nice as the previous fragrance. So, yes, poor choices all around.
I'm disappointed with the new Guerlain lipsticks. I have a lot of cases (20?) This is a terrible decision from the brand. I will not buy a new case. Loved the formulation of the "old" (!) lipsticks . I still have the ones in each case, and when they are gone... What a terrible decision from the brand
I typically agree with all of your takes on beauty but I am soo disappointed to hear content creators recommending the makeup by Mario serum. 😏 I’ve tried 3 shades and it was horrible. I think it’s disheartening to sell something for $40 to look like you put nothing on your face. I love the skin enhancing balm but this serum just took off my makeup or didn’t show up at all alone. I’m dry/combo skin, MAC NW20, for reference.
That’s so interesting. I absolutely LOVE IT and am buying more shades. I always say no product is for everyone and I’m so sorry it doesn’t work for you. For me it’s perfect! But I absolutely agree it’s subtle. Would it help if I did a demo with it on just bare skin so you can see how it looks on me? I can also buy some deeper shades . Let me know!
@gullor11 - can you tell me why you like the enhancing balms - I’ve been interested in the balms for a while, then these serums came out - I do think the serum wouldn’t work for me for a number of reasons (past bronzing serum didn’t work) - just not necessary for me personally - but I still wonder about the balm - the balm is very shear too, right? So,why do you like the balm and not the serum - I can’t figure out the differences from CZcamsrs for some reason - it’s not clicking with me 😅
@@vwiccy the balm isn’t much color either but I feel like it makes my skin look smooth with some color. It’s never patchy or takes off my makeup. But it doesn’t last long, sadly is my only gripe.
@@Allfeisty thank you so much for offering! I just saw your latest video and think it just might not be a product for me…luckily for me I have 28 other bronzers to use hahah 😜
The Guerlain lipstick and case has really irritated me. I have 3 of the older cases and love them. I will not be purchasing the new ones or any new lipsticks from them. It may sound petty but they have lost a client. I will look elsewhere.
Why all this fuss about the casings and new lipsticks that do not fit in ? That s ludicrous in my opinion ! Don t buy them ! There are other brands ! Nevertheless you might be disappointed as that s what most brands do with their refill ! More eco friendly ! That s what they all say ! You have to buy the whole casing and refill or not ? Your choice !
I’m quite upset that Guerlain has changed the sizes of Guerlain Rouge G lipsticks and cases, as well as the formula. It’s a ripoff for the consumer, an act of pure greed. Guerlain had had the best lipstick formula on the market, imho, and the coolest cases. I wish they’d heed to the old Ann Landers axiom: If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!
I totally agree. I am done with Rouge G.
Sadly I’m done with Rouge G as well. I have so many cases that are all useless once the lipsticks inside are done.
I totally agree
Totally agree on the Guerlain lipsticks, just gifted my mom one and specifically asked her to keep the case... what a disappointment to see such obvious corporate greed. We all know it's the main business motivation but don't make your regular customers angry!
Haven’t finished watching yet, but I have to respond to the Guerlain issue! I feel very betrayed and made a fool of, because I trusted that these lovely cases would be refillable collectibles - just 11 months ago I gifted my daughter one (the beautiful summer floral one) and told her how she’s be able to continually refill it, which makes me feel like an idiot. This is clearly a case of rampant greed and, like you, I have not bought either a new lipstick nor a new case. I feel by boycotting them, we might be able to send the message we are displeased, since the bottom line is all they care about apparently. I am a really old time customer, having bought my first Mėteorites in the early 1980s and my first fragrances even before that (I lived in Europe then). I really hate feeling this way. Oh, and don’t get me started on their concern for their impact on the environment and championing sustainability! Leaving people with loads of unusable lipstick cases is not sustainable! Ok, back to watching and thank you for addressing this issue and doing so at the beginning of your video!
Well said!!!! 🎉
@@farrahmoldover5517 Thank you!
I bought a beautiful case for my daughter as well and engraved it, and just like you feel absolutely horrible now! Sooo disappointing!
@@elenapolshakov3837 I’m sorry you’re having to deal with this as well. Clearly, the powers behind Guerlain didn’t give any thought to their existing clients, or worse, they did and couldn’t care less….
I’m so angry about the Guerlain relaunch of Rouge G because it’s not just a waste of money, but it makes the old cases junk. It’s a disgrace. And you’re 100% right that the new case could have been retrofitted.
I too am upset/disappointed about the Rouge G lipstick case change. I was a collector of them, as well as gave them as “forever” gifts to others. Knowing what they are able to do to their loyal customers leaves a bad taste in my mouth and I will absolutely not buy the new ones and feel Guerlain let us down. Knowing that, I am not entertaining really picking up anything new from the brand. I am sure that will fade, but I will absolutely not buy any Rouge G lipsticks and cases. There are too many great alternatives out there. Guerlain just had an edge with the cases on top of a good lipstick formula. 💔
NO!!!!, I have multiple cases & gifted the cases
I’m fucking enraged
I was a huge Guerlain fan and collected the meteorites, lipstick cases, etc. With the changes made to both categories, they’ve lost me as a customer.
I am a mechanical engineer who designs hardware day in and day out, hw can be made to retrofit even using new materials that are resourced in an environmentally sustainable way. Guerlain pissed me off a lot. All of my hard earned money spent over the years collecting the cases and now I can’t use them, what do these companies think? customer always has the power of not purchasing which is what I am going to do.
I have collected the Rouge G cases since they came out. For every sentimental occasion, my husband has purchased a lipstick and case, and engraved them with something meaningful. Now those precious memories will end of in landfill once the lipstick finishes, or expires/goes off. How sustainable is that?
I won’t buy these. Maybe a special holiday case or colour, but I am going to lavish my love and attention on the cases and lipsticks that I already have.
I too am upset with Guerlain lipsticks and for that reason I will not be purchasing. The consumer’s only way of sending a message is by not buy that particular product. I hope they change it back 💚
I bought a new Rouge G case and a newly formulated lipstick. The case (tortoise/gold) is beautiful and is a tad smaller, but when you open it and set it down, it won’t sit flat. The weight of the mirror tips it over onto its side. As for the satin formula, it is superb. I bought shade 518 which is a midtoned warm pink. You can put a new lipstick in the old case, but not vice versa. Rouge G has always been a favorite, but I think I’ll just buy the lipstick without the case from now on and keep the black plastic tube cover.
I am furious about the Rouge G cases. I have around 30 of the LE. This is a slap in the face to loyal customers. So much for their environmental credentials. This is pure greed.
I agree with you 100% about Guerlain! I'm so disappointed in the lack of advanced notice/transparency about the Rouge G changes. They were still producing the old cases as recently as this spring when I bought the sakura case. If I had known, I never would've purchased it. It feels like a slap in the face to say they are all about sustainability and the environment when they make a change like this. Many brands have done this over the years - I have so many fancy cases, including the collectible Meteorites pressed powder compact and other fragrance cases from Guerlain, where they stopped making the refills, so you were just stuck with empty components. However, the difference now is that they claim to be producing these components in the name of sustainability as well as the collectible aspect, so it's a huge turn off. This is definitely strike 2 for me with Guerlain this year after they changed the fragrance of the Meteorites powder. I'm getting tired of stockpiling makeup that is being discontinued, it has an expiration date so there's only so much you can pick up.
Looking forward to seeing what Marc Jacobs comes back with, and Burberry.
I recently ordered the entire Addiction Tokyo seashells collection for summer and I was so happy with it all, except for the Glitter mascara which I don’t recommend. I loved everything, esp eyeshadow formulas. It reminds be of old Suqqu and Surratt, but more pigmented. Wonderful product. Check out the blushes! I loved the lip tints that look like a shiny, smooth stain, but weren’t drying on me.
With Virginie Viard leaving Chanel and rumors Hedi Slimane taking over, we can guess how makeup collections may look going forward. I’d guess a bit more subdued. I just want better formulas whatever the direction. The R2W will probably be a drastic change if you loved Viard’s designs.
Agree a you on the Mario bronzer and the fair is an excellent contour that truly looks natural on fair skin.
I am excited to learn about new brands. I don't mind spending for quality, but I hate overspending for meh. This was a great video!
Jen, I only started purchasing the Guerlain Rouge G Lipsticks and Cases last year! I have about ten? I did purchase these due to being recommended but also because I wanted to personally try the brand. I bought several different formula of lipstick and did so during the times we love best - Sales! So, imagine my disappointment with Guerlain after pulling this stunt and will be receiving a correspondence from myself as they are taking us for fools and I'm angry! I just started with these lipsticks and now the cases are redundant, only to be left with searching the secondary market for refills. Jen, it's not your fault that I bought these lipsticks, it was my decision and something I wanted to do. If you want to buy these newer ones, I will definitely not hold it against you. If they are eventually reduced, I may purchase myself. Its just the I've lost any trust in Guerlain due to this deception. Of course, they could gave made these new cases to fit the older lipsticks, they simply wanted to make more money on this marketing ploy. How naive to think that the customers wouldn't be upset!
Prada! Everyone keeps buying the 'blue' balm that is always going to turn pink, (the initial green was universal), yet I want to see the coloured ones tried. I'm in love with this brand and own every eye palette and many lipsticks - but I want more! Due to having very dry lips, Id like to see how these perform, although I'll be waiting for the Selfridges Sale at the end of the year.
I can't remember if you ever covered Rabanne. Another brand that I've fallen for and own almost every product. I have all four Quads and every Duo except for one that consists of two bright creamy textures. Their lip balms are something special and AU$20.00 cheaper than Prada's. Theyre so creamy and there is actually colour pay-off. They also have products that you can mix into other cosmetics or use alone. After buying all if these, I felt like the mad scientist of beauty. Yet, so much can be altered by using these. I also bought the gold/silver glitter topper to go over mascara. As I didnt need mascara, I can't speak on those. I also bought the three metallic lipsticks and a few of their regular ones. The packaging is beautiful and the prices very reasonable compared to other luxury brands. I cannot fault any of their products and I basically have the range.
It was through YSL that I discovered your Channel, Jen. I had purchased the large Couture Clutch Palettes and was looking around for anyone else who had them. I found a great deal of products from YSL that I'm very happy with. It's such a shame that it took the new Quads to finally awaken everyone to the great products that they produce. Just like the four Burberry Quads, I feel that YSL are staying with colours that are conducive to all age groups. Although, the only palette I bought was the L/E Blue /Green. The others are beautiful and I would love them all but I have far too much now. YSL do need to expand on lip-liners, eye-liners and hopefully bring back blush and highlighter.
Dior has pretty much lost me. It's run by the richest man in the world and they couldn't get something as simple as a reformulation correct. I love the Addict Lipsticks and Cases, yet not that much interests me anymore. I don't like the replacements of the Backstage Eye Palettes and have only purchased Smokey Essentials. I had been collecting every palette, yet not now. When you look at the original colour stories and compare the replacements, it's a no brainer that they've ruined the line. I have so many Maximisers that I don't need more, the same with Glow Balms and in future I'll be buying Rabanne's. I honestly have no interest in these new Duo Palettes as I just don't need them.
Ah, Chanel. The first brand that I really delved into in my 20s. I so loved the products they released, their lip products hold a secret that actually treats my dry lips and they have surprised me with recent releases. The Byzance Quads blew me away! I love them. It was due to them being so different from what they normally release that I was so excited when I saw them that I purchased them all. I have no issue with the Balm Essentials, yet only tend to buy those that can be used over the face in many ways. I bought their Eye Quint at Christmas and even added the Duo Highlighter which I enjoy and added a liquid lipstick in Inflexible, a golden bronze. Their products can be rather hit and miss with me and these are usually the cash grabs of the over-sized products that no-one would get through if it was the only product used in a lifetime! Have always loved their mascara and bought their primer last year after not that thrilled with Dior's mascara. I only have a few lipsticks in iconic red shades as I don't need anymore - I'm swamped. They got me with the Highlighter early this year that shifts from pink to blue, something else rather new to Chanel. I added to this the Balm Essential in Mermaid Glow. I'm turning more towards some of Chanel's products, as I turn against Dior. I'm buying much more from Givenchy too, which is a brand that is very underrated, especially their eye-shadows. Please don't show that new Chanel release again as I won't be able to restrain myself! Id be happy with everything on the page, yet that won't be happening. I just love the compact with the Berry Blush and Pink Highlighter. I love the other too, yet one is the limit. I won't be getting a Balm Essential, yet if you feel you have to buy one Jen, despite not liking them, I hope its the deeper shade. I like the look of the neon-like green eye-liner which goes beautifully with the Natasha Denona Yucca Palette. I went out on a whim to try some eye-liners from the Sephora Collection. They had a sale of Buy 3 products, get one free. I went for some beautifully coloured retractable liners that applied so very soft and look amazing in the shades I choose. I also bought a regular pencil, yet only due to it being in a most incredible mint shade. I was so impressed by these, that I will be getting more of the retractable ones in particular. When it came to washing the swatches off only my thumb, they would hardly budge, even with soap and a tissue! Can't wait to wear them.
I did go on a tangent to try brands I hadn't used before and NARS was one. I purchased the Stargazing Eye Palette, Face Palette and the L/E Audacious Lipstick. Great products all. I even picked up the Summer Unrated Eye Palette from eBay but I'm afraid I have so much, adding another brand is senseless. Unless they come out with something super special, I won't be buying anything else soon.
Jen, why would you spend $6,000 on fashion jewellery from Chanel when you can invest in stunning fine jewellery that no-one else will own? I have a beautiful fine jewellery collection, even a piece that is the only one on the continent. Believe me, it didn't come close to US$6,000! I'd rather you be an individual and invest in antique jewellery or anything other than these pieces that are nowhere near the quality of what is charged. Why not go into Tiffany & Co. and buy something special there or another well known Jeweller? If only you could see what I have and Chanel's endless multiples wouldn't interest you so much. I'm only offeting up other options, if you are adamant you want Chanel, it's your money to do as you please.
Well, that's it for my long run-down on each of these brands and may I add that Shiseido is another brand that's greatly overlooked, just like Rabanne. Thanks Jen for these discussions on what our feelings are about the brands. You're the only one that does this as far as I know and it's very much appreciated, Kris.🇦🇺💖👩🏼🎨
Thanks for the updates! Nice to follow someone who is not only savvy on many matters, but is looking for new creative brands that are branching out from the beauty space which I’m sure is not easy to break into.
When I saw the cases didn't fit I refused to buy any more Guerlain Rouge G lip products. All my old expensive cases are now garbage. What a waste of my money. I am not falling for it again Guerlain. I will stick with your disposable lip products. I was also upset when they changed the Meteorite scent. The new scent is nice (Samsara ish) but the original was iconic. Why not make all special edition shades in the new scent? I am done with the new normal....the unending parade of reformulations. Companies never used to tell us about a reformulation. They would do it. Now companies change the tiniest thing and use it as a means of marketing. A product would have to offer truly next level performance or something really special for me to buy it at this point. Your business is reviewing makeup so it is understandable for you to buy and compare items. I love your channel!
I have the ORIGINAL case the was reshaped, so the next version fell out. I thought they learned better
Hashtag that company #DearReader: make them bleed 🩸 social media ire over this 💢customer SLAP💢
I hardly comment, but I am glad you mentioned Guerlain. I have been a long-time user, especially the Terracotta and Meteorites Perles. The first time they came out with Rouge G, I was smitten with the formula and shades. I was reluctant because of the case. I bought only one and was disappointed because it was big and bulky and was weighing down my purse! So that was it for me. Only one. And now, I am more disappointed where they raised the price on the perles, does not smell as pretty as it did and lowered the quantity, not to mention shimmer! I don't want to look like a disco ball! thank you!. Terracotta also does not smell 'pretty' as in the past in my opinion. So yes! disappointing (don't take us for fools Guerlain!). Thank you for the review.
I really enjoyed this discussion and video. I struggle between loving a fine quality beautiful luxury item and feeling like I’m being taken in by the hype. If anyone ever analyzed the actual cost to make a luxury palette and broke it down by packaging, product and advertising I think it would blow up the beauty community.
Marlene Stell has actually done multiple videos talking about the costs of make up. You don't necessarily get full budgets but very eye opening
Completely agree with the Guerlain Rouge G debacle, I think it is huge disrespect to the collector and their loyal base that those cases that all of a sudden can't be used. I never collected any, and have just 1. I like their cosmetics and am a huge fan of their fragrances, but the new meteorites scent has a cloying heavy aura, not the fresh violet of yore. I can't understand why a company would change their beloved bestselling products--it makes me want to hoard the things I love which is dumb because it'll go bad and be a wasteful act. On the bright side, I LOVE RMS beauty and Ms Swift is a great down to earth makeup artist and spokeswoman--who else can't stop watching her videos and shorts on how to apply her products??? I LOVE her bronzers, blushes, and the SPF 30 glowing tint. Also burgeoning with new launches --YSL, their products are stellar, from the lippies to the bronzers/powder/concealers...check them out! Thanks for a great video!!
This is the 3rd time that Fendi is releasing perfumes :) I really loved them, every time ❤️ They were really special and not mainstream at all, so I hope that this time it will be the same :) Ps: I loved loved loved Fan Di Fendi EDP, I miss it so much😢 ❤
I have an “old” fendi perfume as well that. I love!
disappointed with the new guerlain lipstick cases - i only have 2 of the old ones but that’s still two cases that i will eventually have to throw away. if i knew they would do this i would’ve just bought something else instead.
Yes, absolutely, Guerlain was wrong to change the shape of the lipstick case. Thanks for speaking up.
I absolutely agree with you on the Guerlain lipstick cases and i am certainly not buying the new lipsticks. Although there are other products from Guerlain that I love I am thinking about stopping buying any Guerlain products in the future.
I picked up the new Chantecaille blush and lip sheer and I think they are really pretty (and the blush is quite shimmery). I like the experience of Chantecaille. Nothing else stands out to me but I did repurchase the Lisa Eldridge mascara and grabbed one of her lucent lip colors, I love that formula so much. Really too bad about Guerlain esp because this is not a sustainable practice.
I agree completely with your assessment of Guerlain. I absolutely will not buy any of the new lipstick or new cases. I love Shalimar and some of their other perfumes. But, their makeup is far too fragranced for me. The Dior blushes/highlighters remind me of the Wayne Goss.
I have over 20 of those old Geurlain lipstick cases, and I feel screwed by the redesign that won't make new lipsticks coordinate with the old cases. I am never buying any more makeup from Guerlain. Period. What a slap in the face! My cases will be garbage when those lipsticks wear out. It was grossly insulting and I'm angry.
I may try the Prada balm in Maple. I am glad you'll be getting those YSL palettes. The formula is a dream and I want to see those colors. I applaud you wanting to bring more brands into your channel. Haven't tried Sweed yet, but hoping you do Suqqu Fall 2024. I want to see the newest Moisture Glaze lipsticks, in particular. And more Japanese brands in general. If I'm paying for luxury, I want real luxury, like Cle de Peau.
Thanks for the video!💚
I only have one Rouge G lipstick and case, so I'm not super annoyed at Guerlain. But I do like some of their new cases and might pick up a new shade in the coming months. It also looks like the metal color on the cases (and the lipsticks) has changed from a silver metal to a gold colored metal. I'm not sure even if the new lipsticks fit if the mixed metals would have looked as good. I'm definitely looking forward to Fall and whatever new brands you choose to show us besides selected pieces from our favorite brands.😁
Hello. Normally I do not comment on videos. But I have to say, I feel the same way about Guerlain lipsticks. I bought two lipcases for my wedding. And now, I can look at them, yes. But I will not be able to buy a lipstick, that fit into them anymore. And I will not buy new lipsticks and cases again from Guerlain just because I do not want to encourage this move. I am very disappointed. :( Dior also improved their lipsticks, but everything fits together. I love your videos.
I have this beautiful silver lipstick case from my great grandmother (probably bought in the 20’s)- it’s designed similar to the guerlain, with open mirror concept, but it is real silver and it is smaller profile (no plastic inserts, just a silver holder for a bullet) - it has the cutest red button - I wonder who made it, how,much it cost, and what the brand was. It still has residual red lipstick, though I remember as a child that it still had 1/2 the bullet; it smelled like that perfect,lipstick waxy scent, but kind of really *off* from age too - it was old even 50 years ago - I bet I could remove a bullet from another lipstick and use this case - it might be messy - it may be too small of a holder for modern lipsticks
But actually, I won’t… bc the case is not as convenient or slick or secure as new cases - it is just a little bobble of memory for me and some makeup history -
BTW, I bought the guerlain tortoise and a new satin - the case is beautiful, slicker, lighter, glossy - the formula is also lighter and smoother, with less scent - I like it - I remember a few years back finding these beautiful cases and lipsticks and then, for some reason, I found a bunch of comments on the internet about how the “old cases” were different from the “new cases” and people were mad - so, fortunately, I knew it would obviously happen again and I always just bought the “package deal” for the full price - I never finish lipsticks bc lipstick is my thing, so reusable is not anything that will ever be something that I can participate in - plus, things get scratched and messy and old - I baby my makeup and my Westman Atelier containers are trashed, no idea how, but I’ll never refill them (not like she makes refills????)
I wish they had given us a warning first, especially for reusable and intricate packaging like this - but packaging will always change, which is all we can count on - any other claims are marketing tricks, unfortunately - or maybe “good intentions” but intentions are always replaced with ease of production and cost - I don’t believe it was a money grab … just normal turnover
Ok, I was researching “why did guerlain do this” casually on the internet
Found a 2018 case about guerlain not being able to patent this specific shape (while it was allowed in a previous case)
And most interesting to me is… I found my exact great grandmother’s lipstick case picture used online! On this site femmefashionforward I found that guerlain apparently made the lipstick tr 20:50 end more acceptable in polite society … then
‘Following this, in 1915, Maurice Levy invented lipstick with a lever that would push the stick up through a 2 inch, protective, metal tube for the Scovil Manufacturing Company. This American company was the first to mass produce lipsticks in a metal tube.”
And a picture of my lipstick case! Could it be from my great great grandmother?!
Well… change can be irritating and they’re always changing and marketing to get more money out of us… but the history is fascinating
Thank you for the Guerlain update-I had a new refill in my cart not realizing it would be a different size from my old cases. I’ve been collecting the cherry blossom cases but those stay home and I purchased them knowing they would expire-but I have a classic case that I carry around and change out the lipsticks. Well, I used to-I guess there’s no classic anymore. I was upset they changed the scent of the Meteorites (old Guerlain + Physician’s formula butter balm = new scent). Instead of this dumb cash grab, they could have increased their revenue by creating some innovative new products that their loyal customers would buy.
You should look at Besuty Pie. I believe they are available in the USA now. The products are amazing quality, all made by the same manufacturers that make products for all the high end brands, but at factory prices because all the middle men have been removed from the equation. One of the lipsticks I have from them is identical to my Charlotte Tilbury ones, but cost 1/3 of the price. Their eyeliner pencils are just as good as my VBB ones too. ❤
I have some of the old Guerlain cases that I was saving to put on newly released shades of lipstick, so I'm very disappointed as well.
I am interested in the Chantecaille blushes, would love to see them on you!
Another fantastic video, thank you!
I really enjoyed this format of video. You are giving some really solid thoughts based on your experience on what you will and won't buy and why. I also love the Nerra body oil! It is amazingly good, and possibly better than my OG OSEA body oil!
Thank you, ITA with every word. It's called LVMH green-washing. I'm not buying new Guerlain Rouge G cases and lipsticks either. How is it sustainable to make all your loyal customers' Rouge G collections worthless and useless? And, I am angry, I've bought them as gifts for friends and recommended them. They ruined their foundations too, pretending it was all about sustainability with their new formulations and bottles.
I'm very intrigued by Sweed, so looking forward to your thought on the brand!
I still use Dior blusher in the old blue compact it’s fine no bad smells goes on fine don’t use it very often but love the color
Loving this kind of videos ♥ I would love to get the Dior blush/highlighter duo. 😍
Thank you for the updates. I’m excited about the new brands you’re going to start bringing to your channel.
Thank you Jenn
Great video! 😊
I agree with you about the Guerlain lipstick cases. There was NO reason to change the case shape. It's just rude!!! I am not going to buy any more cases or new lipsticks. There are other brands of lipsticks that are just as nice.
Lise Watier is a Canadian beauty company that has beautiful makeup and skincare, I think they ship to the US if your interested in having a look.
Added to the list!
Agree with you on Guerlain and about the Makeup by Mario bronzer. Splurged on higher priced cases and I still covet the denim case, which are all now useless :-( Love the fair shade and its staying power and how it sets. It pairs beautifully with TF Terra or Gucci bronzer imo, and bought a backup. Thank you for informing us about the upcoming releases and reformulations!
Happy Thursday Everyone
Thankyou for your sharing your thoughts on the guerlain lipsticks. Had purchased my very first case this year - the cherry bloom because I was so intrigued by the Japanese design story. Extremely disappointing to know I won’t be able to get a proper refill for it when the time comes.
Good morning. I’m to am very disappointed with Guerlain. I have a few of their limited edition cases, such as the cherry blossom and last summers denim Jean case that I absolutely love! The excuse that it was product sourcing for the reason to change is inexcusable….it is greed pure and simple. The cases were exclusively designed for Guerlain and were produce to their specifications and they owe the consumer an apology, imo and be responsible by offering a resource to have the older cases refilled. Will that happen…No, but it would go a long way to improve their relationship with consumers who feel cheated.
I don't know if you are interested in reviewing skincare brands but I have discovered one that I just love. The brand is Dr. Burgener and it's from Switzerland. Actually truly good for sensitive skin, I have no irritation at all from this line and it's the only line I've ever used that actually does reduce my facial redness and leave it calm and clear, even after cleansing. I am in my 6th decade and have been playing with high end skincare and makeup since I was 12 years old, so I know a thing or two. ( I probably should have been a dermatologist.) Very pure, very gentle, very pleasant to use and really treats my skin with respect, moisturizing it and protecting it by day and throughout the night, very effectively. That is the battle for me, finding products that do not irritate or cause an allergic reaction, that moisturize all day and again upon reapplication all night and are not heavy, greasy, oily, do not cause clogged pores, etc. and comfortable to wear makeup over. And no, I do not work for this brand and am not affiliated in any way, I'm just a customer, a very pleased customer. Also, Dr. Burgener makes these facial cleansing mitts that are extremely soft to wash with. They are pricy but effective in that there is no scratching, roughness, or irritation at all and I have been using wash cloths for baby's skin from many brands. My skin turns red from the slightest touch so I need the softest of items including makeup brushes. Anyway, if you are interested you may want to check it out.
Jennifer I couldn’t agree more with you about Guerlain. It’s so blatantly greedy. I liked the lipsticks but they certainly aren’t the only ones I favour and there are so many good ones available now I don’t feel that I want to support that greed further. Yes the cases are/were beautiful but a case isn’t a deal breaker for me. I will continue to buy Mitsouko and Shalimar because I have loved them for 30 years but lipsticks? Not important enough to me.
Jennifer, great update on what’s coming for our money 😱😳🤪😝 so Chanel always gets me. Even when I don’t rush to purchase right away, I digest slow…. And month later bum i am buying 😂 I said I am going to skip sun-kissed powders, and Medium coral is in the mail… especially it’s hard for me to resist everything bronzed/ sun-kissed/ summer corals . Was going to skip Dior blushes, but got poppy coral one. So as long as it’s summery I am probably getting it😂. So the big jewelry 80’s trend, I love it. But not getting Chanel costume jewelry. 3 factors why it’s crazy expensive ( I used to buy those very expensive ones from Bombay, Salzburg, dubai, etc.. collections) Quality is not there. And 3- not unique … I am craving more individuality, uniqueness and quality. There are so many vintage designs and architecture artist jewelry- most of them gold plated, , definitely unique. I just purchased old Celine archives Phoebe Philo, gold plated wide cuff. Was going to get Robert Lee Morris but the cuffs , that I liked, run so small… I am so over Chanel, right now. Still loving very discreet elegant, Chanelesque effect, no logos, Karl’s RTW, but I sold A lot, even handbags. And right now I am looking more at vintage bags also… But might Chanel become great again, VV just stepped down. Who knows which direction Chanel will go…. But for me right now, it’s Old Celine, PP brand, Jill Sander, Carven and Gabriella Hearst . Great quality… details, uniqueness…., fashion forward/ style Have a blessed day🙏❤️
Unfortunate about the New Guerlain Lipsticks because I was really excited to see and possible purchase new shades and use the cases I already own. 🖤😊. I agree with your thoughts on RMS beauty. I am excited to see where they are headed.
Prada Makeup still hasn't come to Canada, I'm interested in the lipsticks.
I definitely want ALL the Chanel. I honestly am not missing chantecaille at all these days, they aren’t really making anything interesting IMO.
I own but one Guerlain lipstick case, it's a cherry blossom one from a few years ago. But I have the most perfect unique lipstick in it, 888M Noble Burgundy METALLIC, not the matte. A warm-ish red with gold foil undertone, like red foiled wrapping paper, Christmas in a lipstick. And it tends to blur around the edges of my lips and looks like an old Hollywood film with a filter. This Metallic shade is still available at Sephora in Canada, but nowhere else in the US. I guess if the cases are rubbish, at least I have the most fabulous lipstick in mine.
Interesting Viard is leaving Chanel, I loved her tweed designs. I read an article that seemed to imply that the quality issues are what the house wants a quick pivot from. Not that Viard is necessarily at fault, rather the idea of a fast 180 is what the house wants to show.
I too hearken back to 80s and 90s Chanel, mine would be a navy tweed suit on Vogue in like 93, cheerleader type mini skirt, bows. It was a young look, I couldn't wear it now. Instead I got a St. John navy boucle suit with detachable faux fur collar and cuffs. Doesn't fit me now. 🤷🏻♀️😂
Amen Beautiful Woman!!! I could suggest a place where everyone could put their of no use anymore lipstick cases.... 🤐 I personally, will never buy from them again .
Great video! What I enjoyed most this year so far was the Chanel spring-release makeup (Rivage) and the RMS Supernatural radiance serum. I have used that RMS serum everyday since I tried it months ago- I mix the lightest and medium shades- beautiful under makeup and blurring/ radiant worn alone. Very interested in seeing what both of these brands come out with.
Yes thank you! I was beyond upset that Guerlain changed their lipsticks and cases without notice. I feel so back stabbed by them a total money grab. 😡😤😤 I will not be purchasing their lipsticks in the future for sure!
Great Video Allfeisty
6:02 I feel exactly the same way I will not be buying them it ticks me off for sure will not support that brand any more… I’m sure people will tho so they won’t care … I’m glad DIOR didn’t change them … that Mario bronzer felt so good when I searched it
I agree with you about the gulerian lipstick case change. It's is annoying because my cases are now worthlesswhen I run out of lipstick. I'm not buying new cases or lipstick from gulerian anymore.
And Chanel going to launch a slightly fatty package lip balm soon, it is cute.
Fara Homidi, Mob beauty, Kulfi, Violette fr, Westman, and Phytosurgence are other brands I follow. Great video. Thanks.
Love the new Rouge G and cases❤
Will you keep an eye on Surratt Beauty?
Jane Iredale is one brand I would like to hear more about.
NARS is a continual favorite or mine
People saying there old cases will go in the trash.....OTT !! If there "collectors"you dont have to use them ! Iv got some but love the new gold case and lipsticks
You want to collect items that completely lost their purpose? What are you gonna do w empty lipstick cases😂they're pretty but far from art to have sitting around pointlessly
Hi Jen,
I live in Sydney, Australia and the makeup I am buying must be available in stores. I just buy luxury products and I need to see and try them before buying. So for me small indie brands or brands not available here are a hard pass. Since I started to wear makeup I always preferred to have less but very good products than to be a makeup hoarder with a lot of low/average quality products. The brands I am interested (available in Australia) are Chanel, Hermes, Tom Ford, Chantecaille, Sisley, Gucci and Guerlain (not lipsticks). I used to love Dior but not so much these days. RMS, Makeup by Mario, Rare Beauty, Fenty, Natasha Denona, Charlotte Tilbury, Pat McGrath, Nars etc are just average in the best case scenario and not what I am looking for on your channel.
The only things I buy online are makeup brushes with natural hair. The brushes with synthetic hair I love are from Chantecaille and Rae Morris. I already have an extensive collection and I don’t need more. I might be interested only in Sonia G limited edition if it’s something exiting. Rae Morris will come soon with a limited edition set. The brushes are gorgeous but the set will be $1299 and probably I will skip it.
Thanks for sharing!🙂
Sadly. They need to really change their lipsticks back. For those who can’t spend a crap ton to begin with. This bothers me Yeah. There are more problems. Any company. Upping their prices and then slapping us ? Wrong. I saw the Chanel runway as well. But their prices 😮😮😮😮they have really gone crazy with them.
Great video. Big big pass on the Guerlain new cases and lipsticks. I have the old ones that are now useless. I'm quite irked and it is nothing but pure simple greed. It will be a long time before I buy ANY Guerlain product which is a shame but I'm not ok with the direction.
By the way - has anyone seen in person the latest Tom Ford and Estee Lauder slim lipsticks? Was wondering if they're the same in a slightly different packaging, in terms of formula as well.
I didn’t get into the whole lipstick case thing but I think it’s a big mistake. Truly disrespecting their customers. I can’t wait for your Sweed video. I wonder if you’ve reviewed Yensa. I stumbled on few products that I like and didn’t hear about them. After purchasing, I searched around and seems like came on the scene a few years back but not sure why didn’t get too much traction. Love Chantecaille but thought the recent releases where meha. Package not to the standard I would expect at that price point. I totally love you point in terms of thinking about what we’re purchasing, a range which should have a spectrum. Great video Jennifer!
Yensa? I’ll look into them!
Need to know when the new mini clutch’s will be in the us 😭
I love rms great product
Great video
Thanks!
Kjaer Weis is a brand I’d like your opinion on.
Added to the list!
It is upsetting and confusing to me that Guerlain changed their so the new lipsticks do not fit properly the old cases. What is strange to me is that they claim to be more environmentally friendly, but what are we to do with the old cases… throw them out eventually? It seems very wasteful. They could have just made the new cases to fit and people would have still bought them
❤❤❤
You can get great vintage Chanel jewelry on The Real Real
The only issue is that you have to be careful regarding authenticity. Don’t get me wrong most of it is great. But just be careful. Happy to discuss details in a DM 😊
Sarah Creal has started a beauty line aimed at women over 40. I am very tempted but waiting for reviews first. Hint hint. I ordered from SWEED beauty and folks should be aware they are based in the UK and shipping is slow. Next time I will opt for expedited shipping.
Oohhhh. Ok I’ll take a look. And I mention that in my upcoming Sweed beauty video. It does take longer to get to the us
@@Allfeisty It took a full month for me to receive the lash serum.
@@camelliainzurich1262 wow!!! It only takes 1-2 weeks to get to me. Although this week I’ve had USPS state a item was delivered to NY and then it arrived here 3 days later and DHL completely mess up an overseas shipment so I guess I should not be surprised
It would have been so easy for Guerlain to make the new lipsticks fit into the old cases. There's really no excuse. But it's not just the lipsticks. They've changed the formula for my favorite fragrance, Samsara, as well. And the new fragrance for the Meteorites isn't as nice as the previous fragrance. So, yes, poor choices all around.
I'm disappointed with the new Guerlain lipsticks. I have a lot of cases (20?) This is a terrible decision from the brand.
I will not buy a new case.
Loved the formulation of the "old" (!) lipsticks . I still have the ones in each case, and when they are gone...
What a terrible decision from the brand
Outstanding First Comments
I typically agree with all of your takes on beauty but I am soo disappointed to hear content creators recommending the makeup by Mario serum. 😏
I’ve tried 3 shades and it was horrible. I think it’s disheartening to sell something for $40 to look like you put nothing on your face. I love the skin enhancing balm but this serum just took off my makeup or didn’t show up at all alone.
I’m dry/combo skin, MAC NW20, for reference.
That’s so interesting. I absolutely LOVE IT and am buying more shades. I always say no product is for everyone and I’m so sorry it doesn’t work for you. For me it’s perfect! But I absolutely agree it’s subtle. Would it help if I did a demo with it on just bare skin so you can see how it looks on me? I can also buy some deeper shades . Let me know!
@gullor11 - can you tell me why you like the enhancing balms - I’ve been interested in the balms for a while, then these serums came out - I do think the serum wouldn’t work for me for a number of reasons (past bronzing serum didn’t work) - just not necessary for me personally - but I still wonder about the balm - the balm is very shear too, right? So,why do you like the balm and not the serum - I can’t figure out the differences from CZcamsrs for some reason - it’s not clicking with me 😅
@@vwiccy the balm isn’t much color either but I feel like it makes my skin look smooth with some color. It’s never patchy or takes off my makeup. But it doesn’t last long, sadly is my only gripe.
@@Allfeisty thank you so much for offering! I just saw your latest video and think it just might not be a product for me…luckily for me I have 28 other bronzers to use hahah 😜
@@gullor11 I totally get it!! No product is for everyone!!! and as you said, we all have a few products to choose from. :)
The Guerlain lipstick and case has really irritated me. I have 3 of the older cases and love them. I will not be purchasing the new ones or any new lipsticks from them. It may sound petty but they have lost a client. I will look elsewhere.
I will not buy another Guerlain lipstick, and will think hard about their other products. This is a total ripoff
Why all this fuss about the casings and new lipsticks that do not fit in ? That s ludicrous in my opinion ! Don t buy them ! There are other brands ! Nevertheless you might be disappointed as that s what most brands do with their refill ! More eco friendly ! That s what they all say ! You have to buy the whole casing and refill or not ? Your choice !