Massive Aggregations of Octopus Brooding Near Shimmering Seeps | Nautilus Live

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 23. 08. 2024
  • We observed over a thousand deep sea octopus (Muusoctopus robustus) while exploring Davidson Seamount with Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary. Never before seen in these massive aggregations, most female octopus were resting in a brooding posture, tucked into rocks with eight arms inverted covering their bodies and eggs. Many were tucked into rocks near shimmering fluid seeps, which were previously unknown to occur in this region!
    --------------------------------------------
    E/V Nautilus is exploring unknown regions of the ocean seeking out new discoveries in biology, geology, and archaeology. Join us 24/7 for live video from the seafloor and to ask questions of our explorers currently aboard Nautilus: www.nautiluslive.org.
    Follow us on social media for dive updates, expedition highlights, and more:
    Subscribe on CZcams: czcams.com/users/subscr...
    Facebook: nautiluslive
    Twitter: evnautilus
    Instagram: nautiluslive

Komentáře • 439

  • @PongzeLor
    @PongzeLor Před 5 lety +532

    Aside from the multitude of upside down octopus, i’m not really sure what I’m looking at.

    • @YukaponKakesu
      @YukaponKakesu Před 5 lety +24

      Corey M that helped me understand. thank you.

    • @BoilerBloodline
      @BoilerBloodline Před 5 lety +65

      Corey M The “shimmer” they’re speaking of is the same effect one gets by staring across a desert in the hot sun or even a blacktop road in the hot sun. You see the waviness of the heat rising from the ground. Very cool to see this in the depths and being utilized by one of the smarter life forms here on earth with us.

    • @chairwood
      @chairwood Před 5 lety +3

      Nice mustache

    • @darrellclark9596
      @darrellclark9596 Před 5 lety +1

      @@spaceenthusiast4836 thank you

    • @junixbiliran2152
      @junixbiliran2152 Před 5 lety +1

      Hahaha.... i feel u bro! Exactly what i was thinking! 💯🤣

  • @Del-Canada
    @Del-Canada Před 5 lety +312

    It's almost surreal to think about. As we are up here on land working, living our lives, they are just there in total darkness at this moment in the deep ocean doing just one task and not even thinking about us or what is happening on the planet.
    I'm a SCUBA diver and I often will lay in bed and think about these things, or even shipwrecks. Think about how I am just laying there in my bed while there are wrecked ships a mile down sitting there, still, completely in the dark and cold, with fish swimming about them and each wreck has a story to tell that may never be told.

    • @Del-Canada
      @Del-Canada Před 5 lety

      @Davvy Jannes Great story. Are you like 90 years old? :P

    • @Del-Canada
      @Del-Canada Před 5 lety +5

      @Davvy Jannes I'm only fifty but I am never going to grow up, ever. LOL Okay, have a great week!

    • @leonardoalbano5626
      @leonardoalbano5626 Před 5 lety +1

      yep

    • @machigiceb7788
      @machigiceb7788 Před 5 lety +1

      damn dude, you're deep. want to be like them?

    • @mortalclown3812
      @mortalclown3812 Před 4 lety +4

      Davvy Jones what an enthralling post. Thank you. Pardon my simple take here, but the world is made up of those who wonder deeply and, too, braid that pondering into all of their days. Oh and then there are the ones who don't reflect on much at all.
      Hoping you're writing much more about all the things.
      Sending cosmic well wishes to you and yours in these trying times. 🙋🌊🔭🌌

  • @JustNatax3
    @JustNatax3 Před 5 lety +318

    Incredible footage. This channel keeps on giving, it never fails to move my biologists heart. :)

  • @MotoHikes
    @MotoHikes Před 4 lety +15

    You guys should think about streaming live on Twitch when you do the live broadcasts. It'd be a great way to reach out to young people, and might even raise some funds to help with expedition costs. Great footage, keep up the great work. You guys have the best job in the world.

  • @cptamerica13
    @cptamerica13 Před 5 lety +187

    00:35
    "What the he'll are they doing?" - Fish probably

  • @SailorDrew
    @SailorDrew Před 5 lety +425

    "Is this enough octopus for you, Joe?" Haha!
    A string of octopuses! How interesting. Do all species starve to death as they protect the eggs?

    • @TheNeonwing
      @TheNeonwing Před 5 lety +54

      I think many species that put out hundreds of potential descendants are dying shortly after fulfilling their duty. Those who produce only a few often survive it because they need to be brought up.

    • @briesthoughts2261
      @briesthoughts2261 Před 5 lety +5

      Who raises the baby octopi? Are they just born knowing how to find food, etc.?

    • @TheNeonwing
      @TheNeonwing Před 5 lety +81

      @@briesthoughts2261 Yeah. Most animals that are born without parents (most fish and sea live in general) have a extremly strong natural instinct of what to do next.

    • @briesthoughts2261
      @briesthoughts2261 Před 5 lety +10

      Henry Sagehorn thank you 😊 they are such intelligent creatures I thought maybe they spend some time with their parent

    • @cooldude4888
      @cooldude4888 Před 5 lety +71

      @@briesthoughts2261 If they were taught stuff by their parents it would be the end of us.

  • @natekoda7661
    @natekoda7661 Před 5 lety +21

    Wow that's more Octopuses in one spot then I've seen in 10 years of diving! Amazing!

  • @Pentapus1024
    @Pentapus1024 Před 3 lety +8

    Those octopuses must have been yelling, "Hey, I'm broodin ovah heah!"

  • @TechInspected
    @TechInspected Před 5 lety +6

    What nails these videos is the commentary. And the clarity of the mic of the scientists.

  • @IaMoDiNaRy
    @IaMoDiNaRy Před 5 lety +123

    Am I the only one that feels extremely sad while watching all of these good mommies taking care of their babies... knowing they're gonna die soon..... *sniff

    • @TragoudistrosMPH
      @TragoudistrosMPH Před 5 lety +5

      ... at least one deep sea octopus species survives, so maybe this is another that does?

    • @vinegarlegate24
      @vinegarlegate24 Před 5 lety

      What? octopus numbers are actually going up because of global warming, since they like warm water.

    • @augustocesarmuniz1614
      @augustocesarmuniz1614 Před 4 lety +17

      @@vinegarlegate24 actually he is talking about the fact mommies octopuses dies after taking care of their babies

    • @tomthx5804
      @tomthx5804 Před 3 lety +1

      Yes.

    • @MrSviggels
      @MrSviggels Před 3 lety

      But imagine just how many more were born

  • @marylousherman5471
    @marylousherman5471 Před 5 lety +69

    "I'd like to be...under the sea....in an octopuse's garden...in the shade...

  • @MrDangerkeith
    @MrDangerkeith Před 5 lety +41

    So cool, sorry I missed that live stream. It's pretty special to be able to witness these things as they happen with you guys.

  • @Herbex7
    @Herbex7 Před 5 lety +15

    That is one of the coolest wildlife videos I've ever seen.

  • @payingtoplay
    @payingtoplay Před 5 lety +43

    Octopus is such a fascinating and graceful creature...

  • @ummnowwhat
    @ummnowwhat Před 5 lety +4

    Monterey Bay Aquarium is awesome. The work that they do for conservation is incredible. Plus, not only do they have otters, they also have penguins. And turtles. You really cant go wrong.

  • @kennethyapyl
    @kennethyapyl Před 5 lety +2

    I’m amazed how you guys aren’t more amazed!!! Isn’t this a first for the camera!??!
    Great job guys!! Sending love from Singapore ❤️

  • @SnowmanAgent
    @SnowmanAgent Před 3 lety +22

    Scientist: "We have a shimmer!"
    Me:"Where, when, how? I dont see it."

    • @maintaint3003
      @maintaint3003 Před 3 lety +7

      They are talking about the shimmer or distortions in water, caused by hot water rising from the seeps.

  • @nickb53
    @nickb53 Před 5 lety +81

    I've always wondered the effects of the rover lighting on each individual species. Is there any data on that sort of thing? Loved this post! 🤘

    • @nickb53
      @nickb53 Před 5 lety +11

      @@BoyBlunder66 Seeing as though most of these species haven't been exposed to light for thousands of years, it would be awesome to see how exactly they each react.

    • @opposition22
      @opposition22 Před 5 lety +4

      Except potentially those who might be guarding eggs.

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety +19

      That would be hard to test because to do a real scientific test, you need to compare how they react to lighting and how they react without lighting.

    • @literaltrash-bag7588
      @literaltrash-bag7588 Před 5 lety

      I would compare it to looking at the face of god levels of awe.

    • @pratikpandey8140
      @pratikpandey8140 Před 5 lety +1

      @@greenxmango8049 can't we use night vision cameras or goggles?

  • @alexfitch2656
    @alexfitch2656 Před 5 lety +3

    I could watch these videos all day.
    .. and I am.

  • @marcoais59
    @marcoais59 Před 5 lety +4

    octopuses also love thermal baths...in a very peaceful place !

  • @theredrover3217
    @theredrover3217 Před 2 lety

    I would ask younger generations To appreciate the etraordinary technological advancements - in my lifetime - to make this possible. And away from the bonds of the classroom. (No choice in the matter, zero opportunity to binge out.)
    Very much enjoy and appreciate you sharing your excitement and yourselves. I can't imagine how much support behind the scenes, production. Thank you.

  • @originalbadguy9520
    @originalbadguy9520 Před 5 lety +3

    I was just telling my husband, like, the internet and on top of that y'all at EVNautilus!! I cannot tell you how PROFOUNDLY GRATEFUL I am for you!! We are living in such an amazing and exciting time! Because of ppl like you, I can literally, honestly say, I have learned MORE in the past 20 years via the net and good ppl like you posting these AMAZING videos for us to see, than I learned in ALL of my years of schooling AND college!! I can also say, that my 18 year old autistic son (VERY high functioning, high IQ!) has learned more on the internet than in school. (Of course he was always that rare kid that didnt get on the internet a do SM or play games! He is ALL about the educational sites!) LOL! WE APPRECIATE ALL YOU DO! THANK YOU!!

  • @MrAnonymous878
    @MrAnonymous878 Před 5 lety +3

    this is quickly becoming my favorite channel
    so many cool things here

  • @finneganarthur1069
    @finneganarthur1069 Před 5 lety +1

    Was awesome to see this live guys :)

  • @missalisha9644
    @missalisha9644 Před 2 lety

    I can't stop watching these videos on this channel. This one is by far the best. I don't know why, bt I've always thought/imagined that Octopuses brute their eggs away from everyone else. Like when I watch under the ocean docs, they aways so one lone momma 🐙 & her eggs deep in a crack/ crater where other ocean life can't get to the eggs?! Never did I imagine a whole oven floor of them strung out for what seems like miles...

  • @originalbadguy9520
    @originalbadguy9520 Před 5 lety +8

    I find them absolutely hypnotic! Octopus are one of my very favorite beasties!! They are amazing, intelligent and beautiful! What kind of octopus are these? Anyone know?? They are such a pretty color!

  • @beautyforashes2022
    @beautyforashes2022 Před 3 lety

    That is a huge amount of octopus that are all brooding. Amazing to see so many in one place.

  • @kyoatbites7865
    @kyoatbites7865 Před 5 lety +2

    this is by far my favorite EVNAUTILUS ever so many OCTOs so many eggs very fascinating to see them encase the egg sak with their bodys beak out just amazing

  • @Antonio_4
    @Antonio_4 Před 5 lety +18

    Awesome footage and all that, but... what's the hush-hush deal with Andrew @ 1:47? 😁

  • @marciofernandes7091
    @marciofernandes7091 Před 5 lety +2

    Big fan of your work guys. This is jaw dropping.

  • @ronaldrvc1553
    @ronaldrvc1553 Před 5 lety +1

    For normal eyes, it's just octopus taking a chill.

  • @cizzlebot
    @cizzlebot Před 5 lety +1

    Wow! I've seen a lot of nature documentaries and footage, but this is definitely a first! Truly incredible!

  • @gioa.1470
    @gioa.1470 Před 3 lety +1

    I'm begginning to love the ocean and thats thanks to you guys! Thank you!

  • @croatiansensation6062

    What a wonderful discovery! Thank you for taking us along for the journey.

  • @bellakatherman1477
    @bellakatherman1477 Před 5 lety +1

    My favorite part of these videos is hearing the biologists commenting.

  • @Kadelle
    @Kadelle Před 5 lety +3

    thank you so much for the amazing content, time and time again. invaluable!

  • @christopherscobie
    @christopherscobie Před 5 lety +8

    Any chance you can put some depth and heading, etc overlay the live feed? Please (rov guy)

    • @misssmisssymaria
      @misssmisssymaria Před 5 lety

      Christopher Scobie He/She did, it was in the very beginning 0:02 “Southsea Davidson Seamount, 3180m”

  • @hughesm02
    @hughesm02 Před 5 lety +18

    What's the significance of the"shimmer" around 3:00?

    • @peterwatson4634
      @peterwatson4634 Před 5 lety +3

      It shows that there is a cold fluid seep, maybe methane?

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety +3

      @@peterwatson4634 methane? you mean the octopus are farting?

    • @SammMannPitts
      @SammMannPitts Před 5 lety +19

      They think it might be heat spots that the octopi (?) are flocking to incubate their eggs

    • @ManifoldSky
      @ManifoldSky Před 5 lety +2

      @@SammMannPittsThe plural of octopus is either octopuses or octopodes, not *octopi.

  • @michaelallen714
    @michaelallen714 Před 3 lety

    🤦🏽‍♂️ I found y'all page at 11pm.... I can't stop it's 1:45am

  • @ruben3860
    @ruben3860 Před 4 lety

    “Massive Aggregations of Octopus Brooding Near Shimmering Seeps” lol that’s quite the mouthful.

  • @johnlovell8299
    @johnlovell8299 Před 5 lety +4

    Three rivers of Octopus.

  • @kazkaz6177
    @kazkaz6177 Před 5 lety

    To an incredible Team :-).
    I genuinely cannot thank you enough for this site......
    It is truly amazing and to have the opportunity to go work every day and love what you do. It really cannot get better than that!!!! 😊. Proud of you all. There really is something magical about Octopi....... They have stolen my support heart ♥. This is the best YT site by far and I hope that you have some loyal and devoted followers :-). Science is just fascinating..... I love Symmetry in Nature 🌏 🌲 🍂 as well 😊. It is also wonderful as well to hear Academics talking..... 😊.
    Love and best wishes from the UK 🇬🇧 💚. Keep Safe XxX ❤

  • @wulfsaga2
    @wulfsaga2 Před 5 lety +11

    Its disturbing how they looks like alien facehugger from afar

  • @Rjpthju
    @Rjpthju Před 5 lety +1

    спасибо за такие прекрасные съемки!!!

  • @jonanjello
    @jonanjello Před 5 lety +1

    Such amazing footage. Thanks for sharing this!

  • @jakobraahauge7299
    @jakobraahauge7299 Před 5 lety

    Thanks for sharing - the footage is super beautiful and your discussion wonderfully enlightening and entertaining! Please, do post more! 👍❤️

  • @MrWicked61671
    @MrWicked61671 Před 5 lety +7

    Holy octopi breading ground, Batman!

  • @phoenixpinkmyn5535
    @phoenixpinkmyn5535 Před rokem

    Ugh, you got me guys, I guess I gotta subscribe xD You've shared so much amazing footage with us all! Truly an amazing world under the sea

  • @christiane.g.4142
    @christiane.g.4142 Před 4 lety

    these octopi are just hanging out at the octopus version of the seafloor liquor store waiting for the po-po to roll up on 'em and harass them for being in the octopus gang, lol

  • @UlrichVIII
    @UlrichVIII Před 5 lety +1

    woah! i've never seen something like this (and i've watched a lot of documentaries), great job Nautilus' ppl :)

  • @XXLSkinnyMcGee
    @XXLSkinnyMcGee Před 5 lety +3

    this was the dive that broke the vehicles iirc. good luck with repairs in San Diego

  • @judeirwin2222
    @judeirwin2222 Před 3 lety +1

    The female octopus lives only 3 years. They mate in the second year, and once they have produced eggs, they never eat again, because they spend all their time guarding their young. They starve to death about the same time their young become capable of independent life, and mum may be their first meal.

  • @thegriffin88
    @thegriffin88 Před 3 lety

    That is a A LOT of octopus (octopuses? Octopi?) in one location!

  • @fionatanzer5270
    @fionatanzer5270 Před 5 lety +2

    It is very encouraging to know that octopus still congregate to brood

  • @hanng1242
    @hanng1242 Před 5 lety +3

    Those sea stars are trying to infiltrate, but I'm not fooled!

  • @jomama5186
    @jomama5186 Před 3 lety

    So beautiful. Nature sure makes some awesome things. Such a treat. Love you guys!

  • @Lilithofeden1
    @Lilithofeden1 Před 5 lety +1

    Finally something not dying in the Fukushima radiation or getting ripped apart from the inside by the blip.

  • @EarthVibrations
    @EarthVibrations Před 4 lety

    Awesome view. People need this perspective that there is much to explore and experience here. Perspective leads to growth.

  • @faramir4290
    @faramir4290 Před 5 lety +3

    I was expecting at every moment that the mother of all of them appears.

  • @jeannettepina9114
    @jeannettepina9114 Před 4 lety

    Why do it seem that the octopus are all wrapped around rocks? And, also, whee did you shut this? Absolutely fascinating! Thank you!

  • @Willow76ny
    @Willow76ny Před 5 lety

    Simple joys of marine biology. 🦑🦐🦞🦀🐙😊❤️

  • @neliborba101
    @neliborba101 Před 5 lety +5

    Egg? I only see octopus play around but their eggs are not in sight.

    • @seileach67
      @seileach67 Před 4 lety

      The eggs are hard to see because the mothers are covering them with their heads and bodies. At 0:17 if you look at the upper left, you may be able to see white teardrop-like shapes peeking out from under the octopus's legs. Those are the eggs.

  • @anouar1414
    @anouar1414 Před 5 lety +2

    Imagina tryna sleep and some dude come shining the brightest light ever in ur face thinking u are walking to the light daymn

  • @brendamanning5235
    @brendamanning5235 Před 3 lety

    What an amazing video.I never knew that there is so many of theses little creatures around.Thanks for sharing this video.

  • @EvansvilleJill
    @EvansvilleJill Před 3 lety +1

    Not to sound completely ignorant, even though I am when it comes to life on the sea bottom, what is the "shimmer" that is being talked about? Is it shiny octopus eggs, that I cannot seem to see or the temperature difference in the water?

  • @ethanJ496
    @ethanJ496 Před 5 lety +2

    Well, that's one way to celebrate Halloween.

  • @kayden7527
    @kayden7527 Před 5 lety +18

    I read “Massive Aggregations of Octopus” as “Massive Aggressive Octopus ”. Can y’all see why I’m this confused and mildly disappointed?

  • @southofhollywood4199
    @southofhollywood4199 Před 5 lety

    Biologists: "What are they doing?" "Don't ask me, I took biology because it's easy" "I think those are plastic bottles"

  • @DavidBadilloMusic
    @DavidBadilloMusic Před 5 lety +1

    2:22 "Oh, this has a lot of amenenemones" ... Nemo, is that you?

  • @ANTINUTZI
    @ANTINUTZI Před 5 lety +1

    ... Uh-oh ... the octopi have had enough, *they're makin' their move ...*

  • @yankeegirldownunder1375

    have you been to the great barrier reef yet ? we snorkled atblue pearl bay it was amazing, great footage glad to see youth enjoying their work ;) how exciting to see so many creatures we will never see in our lifetime good on ya mates ;)

  • @rudolphazz1263
    @rudolphazz1263 Před 5 lety

    The optopus and the potatoes are very good friends

  • @mamalovesthebeach437
    @mamalovesthebeach437 Před 5 lety

    So amazing to see this ... thank you for sharing this with us!!

  • @SaKuRaX231
    @SaKuRaX231 Před 5 lety +1

    hell of a octopus eggs so many lol

  • @davidimhoff2118
    @davidimhoff2118 Před 5 lety

    Wow you could be there all day and that would fascinate me. I wish I could see longer videos of this

  • @user-zb3yl1wu8u
    @user-zb3yl1wu8u Před 3 lety

    Octopus: "AHHHH I'M ARRIVINGGG!"
    Scientists: "nice"

  • @arnoldyu7363
    @arnoldyu7363 Před 5 lety

    that's wild that they're just all partaking in nap time

  • @jenniferparsons5543
    @jenniferparsons5543 Před 5 lety +2

    This is what I hope to me when I become a Marine Biologist. Discover new creatures in the ocean. I don't know much about what Marine Biologists do but I'm sure it will be amazing. Do you guys have fun doing what you do?

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety +2

      I'm not in your field, but I have a different perspective regarding learning in general. I'm not against the interest of discovering new things, but the excitement wears off pretty quickly for me. I would rather study something very deeply and find useful knowledge. For example, what can we learn from jellyfish that might help human beings?

    • @Locke3OOO
      @Locke3OOO Před 5 lety

      I wanna be a pimp and wear like a giant leopard skin hat and walk around with a cane. I know this is outside your field of study but do you have any tips?

    • @TragoudistrosMPH
      @TragoudistrosMPH Před 5 lety +1

      @@chunkyMunky329 at least one species is able to reverse its aging, become a baby (polyp) and then return to adulthood. How does that work? Could our old cell be taught to regenerate?
      that's just one example.

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety

      @@TragoudistrosMPH That's very fascinating

  • @utsutsu123
    @utsutsu123 Před 5 lety +2

    i wonder if brooding in groups serves some sorta purpose? or is it just a nice brooding spot lol

  • @elizabethfarrell9650
    @elizabethfarrell9650 Před 5 lety

    very good work! Thanks for sharing. ❤️

  • @redfo3009
    @redfo3009 Před 3 lety

    Is this octopus breeding/brooding ground a new discovery ?? So cool 🤩🤩

  • @sammlerjager9208
    @sammlerjager9208 Před 5 lety

    Mars: o look there's a rock which looks like a face
    Earth: am I'm a joke to you?

  • @zutalors960
    @zutalors960 Před 3 lety

    That's a beautiful cosmopolite right there.

  • @marybrantley2160
    @marybrantley2160 Před 5 lety

    Amazing! Never seen this before ! Is there a reason to the line up or any specific design to the formation of these octopus? Thank you .

  • @eugenebusico2252
    @eugenebusico2252 Před 3 lety

    Ive been watching almost all your very nice videos. Can I ask something? How do octopus and anemonies with their fragile body can withstand high pressure on deep sea? Thank You.

  • @richardhead8264
    @richardhead8264 Před 3 lety

    *Fish at **0:34* _"Y'all gonna eat those eggs?"_

  • @bensutcliffe1975
    @bensutcliffe1975 Před 5 lety +4

    So beautiful but its a shame all those octopi are going to die :(

  • @uncletatscreativeshack1702

    That’s amazing! So how many eggs does each octopus brood over?

    • @Keys879
      @Keys879 Před 5 lety +2

      Judging by the size in the brief capture we get around 0:23, probably a dozen or so.

  • @chris-hayes
    @chris-hayes Před 3 lety +1

    The octopi look sort of like sea enemeny with their tentacles like that, wonder if that's a defense mechanism.

  • @wesleyfg8761
    @wesleyfg8761 Před 3 lety

    my theory: they mimic the starfish by holding that pose, because they have less predators in that area...

  • @holosky5276
    @holosky5276 Před 3 lety

    Yes please,a basket full of octopuses! Sooooo cute

  • @justkeepbreathing3018
    @justkeepbreathing3018 Před 5 lety +2

    its really weird because i had a dream a few nights ago about a man holding a hunch of weird sea creatures that were shaped like how these octopuses are resting.
    are there any sea creatures that happen to look like that shape?

  • @andrewpennington2251
    @andrewpennington2251 Před 5 lety

    Speechless. So beautiful and special.

  • @antonettedcosta1225
    @antonettedcosta1225 Před 3 lety

    Whoaaaaa!! I have never seen anything like this before!! Wow!!

  • @ciaocici4467
    @ciaocici4467 Před 5 lety +1

    My favorite sea creature

  • @proffesserm6008
    @proffesserm6008 Před 5 lety +7

    OMG that's a lot of octillerys!!....... ; )....

  • @aleks-wp5sl
    @aleks-wp5sl Před 5 lety +1

    I’m sorry for asking the dumb question, but what is brooding? Anyone please I just happened to come across this channel , an I find myself more interested in the videos always great vid by the way thanks!

  • @alejandrorobles6865
    @alejandrorobles6865 Před 5 lety +1

    this is better than the mini octopus city, this is so massive, like a colony, they must be more intelligent than what we think

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety

      What did you see that makes them "more intelligent than what we think"? I didn't see them doing anything clever in this video.

    • @alejandrorobles6865
      @alejandrorobles6865 Před 5 lety

      @@chunkyMunky329 these animals are usually nomad and rarely interact with eachother, seeing them in such a huge aglomeration can tell us something about their social skills, which are important since that way a species can transfer knowledge

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety

      ​@@alejandrorobles6865 Yeah but you're assuming a hell of a lot without any sophisticated evidence. You see lots of octopus and automatically assume that it proves that they are way more smart than we previously thought. If social skills make an animal super smart does that mean that antelopes are the smartest non-human creatures on the planet? No. I'm not saying that you're wrong. I'm just saying that you're jumping the gun here. You don't have enough evidence.

    • @alejandrorobles6865
      @alejandrorobles6865 Před 5 lety +1

      @@chunkyMunky329 well i said maybe, you dont need to take it too seriously, this isnt a sciemtific discussion forum and neither you or i have seroous data to prove eachother wrong, you are new ro the internet i guess, this is no place for snowflakes

    • @chunkyMunky329
      @chunkyMunky329 Před 5 lety

      @@alejandrorobles6865I think you should re-read the conversation. I asked you to clarify what you saw that made you think that they "must be more intelligent". And then when you couldn't back it up with anything substantive I told you that. How exactly does that make me a snowflake? I think you're the snowflake for being so offended by a very polite discussion. I took your point seriously and gave you the opportunity to educate me. I was completely open-minded and never insulted you. I never said anything aggressive or troll like. You're really projecting your own issues onto me. All I did was mention my opinion about your statement. That's how an intellectual discussion works. One person gives their opinion about the subject and another person gives theirs. You instead are resorting to ad hominem.

  • @jessicaromo4369
    @jessicaromo4369 Před 5 lety

    Is this location inside the bay our outside? Do you do other locations or do you keep it in Northern Cal?

  • @blazemcwolf8106
    @blazemcwolf8106 Před 2 lety

    We should call this octopus City because there are so many of them here 😁