Don’t mistake this opinion as hatred for Chris or Ambers versions... but Lea was practically born for this role. She owned this song and wiped the floor with them both. After listening to each version, Lea’s was definitely the best.
Jorge Garcia um, Amber does sing better by a little, but this song idk, I just felt like the range being lowered makes the song not as powerful and made Rachel sing this song weird to me so I choose Mercedes
Emanuel Manasse I'm sure that's true and she's such an amazing singer but I think she might not be able to sing this specific song in that range also because the entire song is in this range and it only gets higher.
Nienke Galis oh thats true, well she can sing in that range, but I guess since it is a Broadway type some and she doesn't really song Broadway songs so they had to change it to make it a fair chance
yeah she should have sing it solo of course, what a beautiful voice, so pure, nothing is forced! some may criticized it's academic what I like about Lea is even when she does high notes it is still really nice to listen to, what a talent! crazy she is not more famous in France!
Las canciones mas dificiles las a cantado Mercedes. La voz de Rachel es mas dulce quiza , pero la voz de Mercedes es sin duda la mas poderosa de Glee .
Gio Fernandez Como que la voz de Lea Michele sea muy original(han habido millones de cantantes de comedia músical con el mismo estilo) Amber Riley tiene mucha mas potencia y habilidad con su voz(raspa,imposta y hasta a cantado música lirica). Siempre fue la mejor, eso no implica de que Lea Michele tenga muchisimo mas protagonismo que Amber porque ella obviamente vende mas. A Lea se la puede comparar con Naya RIvera pero Amber está muy por encima
it's so sad that in the 1st season Finn, well Cory, was there listening for her and admirinh her and in s5 he is not there and it kinda breaks me, missing him watching Lea / Rachel as if she was magic
Kurt is a countertenor, which is using a falsetto voice. There was some of that in the '60s , especially Frankie Valle of the Four Seasons. It's extremely hard to maintain for very long. In opera, we mainly see countertenors in Baroque, where they currently compete with mezzos and contraltos for roles.
lea and chris win ..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Her voice are more powerful & soft now, compare when she sing this 1st season.
I agree
powerful and soft is an oxymoron
@@hunlim2117 lol. You know what they meant
Best voice for Defying Gravity
Rachel (Lea) clearly sang this better. Her voice just suits this song perfectly.
i think it's cuz she has a "broadway-style" kind of voice.
I mean, her mom is Idina Menzel- Lolol jkjk
Gasjsj
No she didn’t
idina was so much better-
They should have just let Rachel sing this as a solo from the start, she nailed it.
Nah
Nah
Don’t mistake this opinion as hatred for Chris or Ambers versions... but Lea was practically born for this role. She owned this song and wiped the floor with them both. After listening to each version, Lea’s was definitely the best.
chris and lea are a tie
Lea wins 🏆
She is so talented love her voice 💕
She's so talented. 🧡 Love her 🤩🧡
She sings so beautiful ❤😊
I love having just the Rachel Berry version. 🧡😍😊
Lea is the best! love her!
Still iconic 🔥😌⭐
Where did you find this version? I’ve been looking for her solo version since I watched glee
Rachel suits the song better. Rachel wins!
Darth Vipera no way Mercedes
gladys06 ansah WRONG
gladys06 ansah rachel voice is best for this song.
gladys06 ansah Rachel has a broadway voice, she can hit notes better
this song is totally Rachel's !
I love how she sounds at 01:52 😍
I liked her season 1 version better because she hit the high F note and belted out the end better
ya the only person who hit the F in the season 5 version was Chris I think
both versions are great this one was more calm and relaxed whereas season 1 was meant to showcase her vocals
very true she put a lot of power in that one
SAME!!
Season 5 too but she not belted.
This song make me strong
I love lea Michele love this song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
And glee
I love this!
so fucking good awwwwww
I dont know why people say that Amber sings this better, Lea is just superb and she has the supreme voice of glee.
Jorge Garcia um, Amber does sing better by a little, but this song idk, I just felt like the range being lowered makes the song not as powerful and made Rachel sing this song weird to me so I choose Mercedes
Emanuel Manasse I think the range was lowered for Amber since it was higher in season 1 when Lea and Chris sang it.
Nienke Galis but Amber can sing in that range though
Emanuel Manasse I'm sure that's true and she's such an amazing singer but I think she might not be able to sing this specific song in that range also because the entire song is in this range and it only gets higher.
Nienke Galis oh thats true, well she can sing in that range, but I guess since it is a Broadway type some and she doesn't really song Broadway songs so they had to change it to make it a fair chance
yeah she should have sing it solo of course, what a beautiful voice, so pure, nothing is forced! some may criticized it's academic what I like about Lea is even when she does high notes it is still really nice to listen to, what a talent! crazy she is not more famous in France!
I Love it so much
0:19, 0:37, 0:58, 1:11, 1:29, 1:52, and 2:04!
@Elijah Parker I don't know, same outfit?
Amber's voice is like a singer voice and Lea's voice it's a Broadway voice, i'm surely, Lea wins vs Chris and vs Amber
a bway voice is a singer.
Kurt vs Rachel = tie am i right glee fans
Hermoso
amo muito a lea
I prefer the 1st time's vocal arrengement. Much more power put into it.
in season 1 diva off her voice was very powerful it blew kurt away all though he is just as good him self
This is the best
Me: *being here for only the song
Everybody else: *being here for the woman singing
1:52 kiss me godbye sounds soo soft and sad, and full of love like a "goodbye my love"
😍😍😍😍
rachel siempre ganará la mejor voz en todo el club , la mejor de todos y esta version me gusta más que la 1ra ♥
Desde siempre Mercedes fue la mejor.
x2
Las canciones mas dificiles las a cantado Mercedes.
La voz de Rachel es mas dulce quiza , pero la voz de Mercedes es sin duda la mas poderosa de Glee .
Es la típica voz de una persona de color admítanlo!
Gio Fernandez Como que la voz de Lea Michele sea muy original(han habido millones de cantantes de comedia músical con el mismo estilo)
Amber Riley tiene mucha mas potencia y habilidad con su voz(raspa,imposta y hasta a cantado música lirica).
Siempre fue la mejor, eso no implica de que Lea Michele tenga muchisimo mas protagonismo que Amber porque ella obviamente vende mas.
A Lea se la puede comparar con Naya RIvera pero Amber está muy por encima
😍😍😍
I’m playing this song in band! I play clarinet
Ava Lewis good luck
Rachel solo was beautiful
it's awesome and all but season one takes it big time! the high notes she's singing there are crazyy!
😍
I feel like lea michele is the best singer out there. Just my opinion
it's so sad that in the 1st season Finn, well Cory, was there listening for her and admirinh her and in s5 he is not there and it kinda breaks me, missing him watching Lea / Rachel as if she was magic
Amber will never sing better than Lea
Why
Where did you get these audio clips
Rachel wins she is just better
1:18
Prefiro a primeira versão que ela atinge notas mais altas
What the heck? This version cuts off the oh whoa oa oa part
There are two things wrong with this version
It's only 2.20, we deserved a full epic version
Where is the oh woa woa at the end
The first version is better
Kurt is a countertenor, which is using a falsetto voice. There was some of that in the '60s , especially Frankie Valle of the Four Seasons. It's extremely hard to maintain for very long. In opera, we mainly see countertenors in Baroque, where they currently compete with mezzos and contraltos for roles.
giantess
i do love rachel's voice it suits the song very well but kurt kills this song with his powerful voice same with mercedies
Rachel wins. Mercedes screamed too much.
Yep ❤🔥
Kurt has this all the way, his version is so beautiful
Kevin Fisher she didn't scream she sang it her way has usual, chest voice.
Kevin Fisher belting is not scream ;)
Marcedes lose, she is black, and Kurt was terrible cause he is gay
lea and chris win ..!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Rachel is great and all but I still love Kurt
San Evans Glee Bronwyn Kim Morgas Mom Did Tennis Ber Tennis hnme Hnme
i’m jus gonna say it: this version is overrated, but she was still amazing
I love her voice but, in my opinion kurt sang this like an angel.
Agreed.
I prefer Amber's version but I definitely love the progression and improvement in her voice compared to the season 1 version.
She's good but I still prefer Kurt's
mercedes wins!!
yeah I better like her.
I think her voice is too strong, I like her voice but this songs is perfect for Rachel.
Mercedes Sing this better sorry But i dont feel it
nah this song is totally Rachel's
@@Dash120z no wayyyyy
😍😍😍😍