NEW Boss Katana Bass Amp vs Fender Rumble Studio!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 68

  • @bobzuidhoek9785
    @bobzuidhoek9785 Před 2 lety +27

    Awesome as always guys! Could you add a top-camera above the amps so we can see the knob-fiddling going on? For the Fender in-depth demo later, make sure you update the amp to the latest firmware via Wifi, it addresses a few bugs.
    I have the Fender rumble stage 800, which is what you should compare to the Boss Katana bass 210. Or compare the Fender studio 40 (smaller brother of the stage, which is identical software and modeling-wise to the 800) versus the Boss 110. I don't own a Boss Katana 210, but do have the Boss Katana Artist MK2, so I can share some interesting insight regarding usability.
    The fender has fewer 'direct' knobs to tweak. The user interface screen however is pretty fast to go around and is only a few menu-levels deep. Fender could tidy up the UI a bit, but it's simple to operate if you're just mildly digital adept. The great benefit of having the screen as the Fender has, is that when you change presets, you actually see the name of the presets, amp, settings and levels of everything. This is a drawback of the Boss screenless design, because when you change presets, you can only see activated things by the lights, but not the levels of knobs or names of the presets. That is quite unhandy actually, because you have to remember your presets. So to be honest, I feel the Fender design is the better one.
    The optimal would be something entirely else, and that would be where physical knobs would only rotate and have lights around them to show the setting. That way, physical and digital blends together better. Then a optimum can be found for a selection of knobs for quick change AND onboard screen for info display and deeper settings. It's a shame the guitar industry is still so hampered by old habits such as 'tubes are better' and 'digital is scary and sounds thin', because to be honest, those digital amps are really the better choice for all but pro gigging players and are perfectly equal substitutes for tubes since about the last 5 years. I'm a software architect for a living, so it kinda hurts that my hobby is still so far behind the UI/UX-scene. But I digress...
    For the Katana Artist mk2, I mess around in tone studio a lot, for with the Fender everything can be done from the amp (or Fender tone app, which I never use because the amp is great). Fender needs to polish things better though. And not very many updates have been given to the stage since its release (which is the same software as their Mustang btw), which wonders if Fender really keeps improving it still or that we've reached then end of it (which would still be OK really, but there's things to improve).
    The tones in the Fender stage 800 are also great. I did test it in a store against the Boss 210 and liked the Fender better.
    Boss should not have created such a strange dongle Bluetooth setup. That's a poor design afterthought if you ask me.
    Ps1: I switched from a Rumble 500 to the stage 800. The cabinets are even identical, it's just the modeling that the 800 has that makes it much more versatile then the normal rumble (which I got tired of the sound of). The amp models and effects in the Fender are plain awesome.
    Ps2: I come from having many top-range and custom-built amps with pedalboards and all. I sold it all and now just have the stage 800 and Katana MK2. To be honest, these 2 amps do everything to about 90% well as the originals, for a total of 15% of the price (about 1500 EUR for the pair of them). The complexity is also vastly reduced, making things more fun to tinker with.
    Ps3: best way to explore presets are using a looper pedal. Record a loop, put your bass away and then flip through presets/settings and listen closely.
    By the way, the update process of the Fender is smarter (hook it up via Wifi and it updates itself pretty much). With Boss you need drivers and a pretty outdated procedure to update the amp.
    It's actually strange Boss dropped a few balls here, since they had 2 years of time to steal all the good ideas from Fender.
    Cheers!

  • @jcout25
    @jcout25 Před 2 lety +25

    Lee's face when Nate said "shitload of presets" was priceless!

  • @SlappaSaurus
    @SlappaSaurus Před 2 lety +16

    I own the katana 210 and about to test its gig ability now next Saturday! The 1w mode is perfect for home practice 👌

    • @EKB480
      @EKB480 Před 2 lety +1

      Great! Could you please give your experience and review with your gig? Did the 210 Katana do a good job? Thanks

    • @marshwiggle9676
      @marshwiggle9676 Před rokem +2

      Any follow up on this you’ve had it a few months now ?

  • @208414
    @208414 Před 2 lety +10

    I preferred the Fender. it sounded more pleasing to my ear.

  • @sexytrashpanda
    @sexytrashpanda Před rokem +2

    Nathan and Lee, brilliant as always fellas, thank you.
    Editors and production team.
    Why do I have to watch *only* Nathan/Lee during the demo? Why aren't we getting visual context for adjustments being made to the amps too?
    It ruins the understanding of what I'm hearing. I mean - this is a demo for things you, as a business, are trying to sell, right?

  • @PaulLacourse
    @PaulLacourse Před 2 lety +3

    The Goldgious Squier Jazz Basses almost stole the show. It was interesting to see you change your mood according to the tones. Great video!

  • @williamcockfield2985
    @williamcockfield2985 Před 2 lety +7

    I picked up my studio rumble used for 250$ USD. For me a beginner/ intermediate player that’s currently trying to dial in sounds I love it. I find the app has some serious bugs that still need to work out but it’s so easy to use the controls on the amp I’ve stopped using the app all together. There is a delay in the Wi-Fi also but it’s pretty easy to work around. All together a pretty great piece of gear. Definitely check it out

  • @mwpv11
    @mwpv11 Před 2 lety +16

    Weight is definitely a big factor. Both sound good, I think the Fender sounded more like a bass amp with a solid bottom

    • @yuichituba
      @yuichituba Před rokem

      That was my exact thought.

    • @phipschi4255
      @phipschi4255 Před rokem +1

      @@yuichituba and on top of that, the studio 40's weight is comporable to my tiny 10 watt warwick amp

    • @WheresTheM3tal
      @WheresTheM3tal Před 11 měsíci +1

      I owned the fender studio 40 and while it wasn’t a bad amp, I just wasn’t crazy about it and wound up selling to a friend of mine. The 110 Boss Katana on the other hand, I played in my local music shop and all I can say is Wow! I immediately went home and ordered the 210 version! That was easily the best sounding combo I’ve ever played. I will probably never use most of the effects, but the amp itself just sounded so stinking good!! I was determined to actually get the Fender 50 watt Adam Clayton all tube combo, but no bs, after playing side by side with the Katana I thought the Boss actually sounded much better! And it’s like $1500 dollars cheaper lol. This coming from a guy that has been all about tubes for quite some time, but the class ab of the boss just sounds so full and punchy, and even the 110 was freaking LOUD. I can hardly wait for my 210 to come in!!!

  • @Konoshiyo
    @Konoshiyo Před měsícem

    Presets/Effects::
    7:07 - Rumble Studio
    16:32 - Boss Katana
    (I personally found the Rumble Studio more Intuitive, which is impressive considering it gives you more customization with the effects. It sadly doesn't have a 4-band eq. It also takes about 30 seconds to start up.)

  • @nicke14
    @nicke14 Před 2 lety +2

    Fantastic playing by Lee through the Fender! Love it

  • @dominiccrimmings6925
    @dominiccrimmings6925 Před 2 lety +3

    Ah now, in regards to the Rumble footswitch - the footswitch is the same MGT-4 footswitch with 4 stomps and 4 modes (quick access / presets / FX / Looper) that comes included with the Rumble Stage 800 and been a staple pedal for the Mustang series of amps for a long time - it's around €70 (cos I bought one) and you can only access the amps looper functions (which are great) with the pedal, you can't use the looper without one. It's sturdy, well built and responsive. Looper functions aside, it's well worth getting in my opinion.

  • @cskeise
    @cskeise Před 2 lety +2

    Gent's... Great opening track, takes me back to the good old days... 💙👊😎💙👊😎

  • @kristianhansen6114
    @kristianhansen6114 Před 6 měsíci +1

    You guys keep mentioning doing an in depth review of the Fender Rumble Studio. I can't seem to find it on your channel? Did you guys end up being scared about entering the menu on the Studio and managing all the settings? 🤣I just find the Rumble Studio 40 to be a contender for best small bass amp out there. Not in the least because of all of the great options to hook up with effect chains and stereo send/return and dual XLR-outs (pre/post or stereo options in the menu). Please do an in depth review! 😁👌

  • @0826man
    @0826man Před 2 lety +3

    Need a Katana bass. Just so much stuff you can do with it

  • @LasseHuhtala
    @LasseHuhtala Před 2 lety +4

    What more could I want? A head version of the Katana of course. :-)

  • @ronaldwilson9525
    @ronaldwilson9525 Před 2 lety +4

    I have the rumble stage 800. I don’t need anything else. 800 watts with the 2 built in 2x10s and my other 2x10 cabinet. Great amp!

    • @virgomonkey68
      @virgomonkey68 Před 2 lety

      Any glitches in the control interface..reliable??

  • @sdbracht
    @sdbracht Před 5 měsíci

    I could prolly listen to you guys all day

  • @virgomonkey68
    @virgomonkey68 Před 2 lety +2

    How about doing the fender rumble stage 800 comparison or review

  • @monkikong
    @monkikong Před 2 lety +3

    When are you going to do the review of the Fender Rumble Studio 40?
    I have one myself now but would love to see what you can do with it :)

  • @patrickr6505
    @patrickr6505 Před 2 lety

    Yes!! About time the Fender Studio 40 had limelight.. Amazing little amp .

  • @michaelbell75
    @michaelbell75 Před 2 lety +1

    Where is the video comparing the Katana to the Ampeg?

  • @AllanGildea
    @AllanGildea Před 2 lety +2

    Opening was glorious. Always fun, cheers, fellas.

  • @stephenfoley1261
    @stephenfoley1261 Před 2 lety

    I have the ruby red metallic Nathan is playing. Yes it's expensive for a Squier, but the fit, finish and tone is great regardless of price. They seem to be disappearing fast here in OZ.

  • @monkikong
    @monkikong Před 2 lety +1

    How’s that Fender Rumble Studio 40 review coming lads?!
    Looking forward to hearing what you can do with it :) please use a PBass ;)

  • @davedavem
    @davedavem Před 2 lety

    Awesome playing lads!

  • @craighenshaw4487
    @craighenshaw4487 Před 2 lety +1

    Great video and amazing playing. I just don't really see the need for an overly digital bass combo. I think the big selling point of the guitar amp was its affordability which meant it was genuinely competitive. The bass version is not that well priced and has too many competitors. I would love to go to somewhere like Andertons one day and try bass amps out. I'm still looking for a bass amp that truly suits me.

  • @ronchorivera
    @ronchorivera Před 2 lety +1

    Leave it to these 2 fellas to make a budget rig sound like a million quid :)

  • @DanielPaulo-jb3tm
    @DanielPaulo-jb3tm Před 2 lety +2

    That face at 10:45! Lol

  • @paulsummerside
    @paulsummerside Před 2 lety +2

    Well, a Rumble that actually sounded decent…. That’s a first.
    Just a pity the only options are 40 watt for the studio for a 1x10 or 800 watt for the stage.
    Fender have sorted out modelling it seems. Leaps and bounds better than their other D class amps.
    Boss is a good unit. But doesn’t really have any actual amp models. Just 3 basic settings and a load of FX.
    What it does is good. It’s good, but it’s Boss.
    For once I prefer the Fender.

    • @MrAlexjames94
      @MrAlexjames94 Před 8 měsíci +1

      To each their own I suppose. The rumbles are the only bass amps out right now that I enjoy.

  • @microdot4374
    @microdot4374 Před 2 lety +1

    The Fender sound near the end very 80s Level 42 style!!!!........😎😎🎸🎸🤘🏼🤘🏼✍🏼✍🏼

    • @Lance37a
      @Lance37a Před 2 lety

      When is he going to get Mark on the channel?

  • @bobzuidhoek9785
    @bobzuidhoek9785 Před 2 lety +1

    Hi Nathan and Lee,
    Maybe you can rectify a bit of poor marketing from Fender. In your upcoming Fender Rumble studio 40 and Stage 800 video, it may be a good idea to show those amps physically next to the regular Rumble 40 and 500 (if even only for a section of the video). And then show how identical these are. And then carry on showing that the Studio and Stage have the modeling (and truly identical tone, overdrive and switches) of the regular Rumble v3 40 and 500 (it's in the presets and in there as amp types.
    What Fender neglects to convey properly is that the Studio and Stage are actually the regular rumble v3 40 and 500, but with added modeling capability. Which makes the Studio and Stage the way better choice I think. More bang for the buck.
    It would have been smarter if Fender had just called the Rumble v3 40 the "Rumble v3 40 Plus". And for Stage have kept the wattage to 500 and then just have called it "Rumble v3 500 Plus". Or Mod instead of the word Plus. Anyhow, you get the idea.
    I think many people just buy the regular Rumbles and completely overlook the Stage and Studio. Which is a bit of shame really.
    Also note: the Stage has the foot pedal MGT-4 included. If you compare that to the Boss 210 which needs the Bluetooth dongle and pedal purchased separately, it's pretty much even.

    • @virgomonkey68
      @virgomonkey68 Před 2 lety

      But how reliable is the controls / display/ bluetooth etc in the stage 800 and studio 40… always worries me that these micro electronic bits cant handle vibration and fail over time?

    • @basicoptimalmouse
      @basicoptimalmouse Před rokem

      The standard Rumble isn't a digital preamp, the studio has a model based on the Rumble.

  • @MichaelBLive
    @MichaelBLive Před 2 lety +1

    i knew you would compare the baby Fender practice amp with it out of gate. The Stage is the one to look at imo

  • @juanluislima
    @juanluislima Před 2 lety

    New video ideas
    #1 Boss Katana Bass vs Boss GT-1B vs Boss Gx-100(since it has a few Bass elements)
    #2 GT-1B vs GX-100 vs Line 6 Pod Go vs Zoom B6
    Or thoughts to this online community what does everyone think?

  • @sjt4225
    @sjt4225 Před 2 lety

    I can dig it

  • @DocOrangutan
    @DocOrangutan Před 2 lety +1

    What basses are you playing please gents?

    • @jw112mail
      @jw112mail Před 2 lety +1

      6:15 feel free to watch the video lol. squier 40th anniversary gold edition jazz bass

  • @madmod
    @madmod Před 2 lety +1

    If youre looking for a decent alternative to a Katana, the Peavey Vypyr solid state 75w 1x12 or 60w 1x12 hybrid tube combo will definetly give you a bang for the buck.

  • @babapawan62
    @babapawan62 Před 2 lety +1

    What series are those? Squier basses with gold hardware? 😍

    • @dominiccrimmings6925
      @dominiccrimmings6925 Před 2 lety

      brass and adonised scratchplate

    • @jw112mail
      @jw112mail Před 2 lety +2

      6:15 feel free to watch the video lol. squier 40th anniversary gold edition jazz bass

    • @babapawan62
      @babapawan62 Před 2 lety +1

      @@jw112mail thank you

  • @acidbass
    @acidbass Před 2 lety +1

    "Let's not play anything in E"
    *reverts to E for 75% of the entire demo*

  • @eugeneg3106
    @eugeneg3106 Před 7 měsíci

    For my ears Fender has a more prominent and natural sound. More volume and presence. Boss is flatter.

  • @bryantwalley
    @bryantwalley Před 2 lety +3

    4:05 what kind of presets?

    • @KeeperOfPoops
      @KeeperOfPoops Před 2 lety

      it has a bunch of standard presets with different amp tones from Ampeg to fender bassman, some basic patches with different effects like chorus, flanger, fuzz etc. And then artist inspired presets like Chris Squire, Krist Novoselic, Geddy Lee, Flea, Steve Harris, Peter Hook, Bootsy Collins, Paul McCartney, Jaco Pastorius etc

    • @bryantwalley
      @bryantwalley Před 2 lety

      @@KeeperOfPoops lol. Maybe you missed the joke. Click the 4:05 and listen to what he says.

    • @melemel09
      @melemel09 Před 2 lety +1

      😂😂😂

    • @KeeperOfPoops
      @KeeperOfPoops Před 2 lety

      @@bryantwalley now i feel like an idiot

    • @bryantwalley
      @bryantwalley Před 2 lety

      @@KeeperOfPoops no worries. All in fun.

  • @bnatens1
    @bnatens1 Před 2 lety

    Woow verry good

  • @Bobby-wn5yr
    @Bobby-wn5yr Před rokem

    I do love the modern squire guitars, but to be honest these anniversary ones seemed a bit… swing and a miss for me. A gold plated squire? C’mon.
    BUT that red one Nate’s got looks amazing

  • @MrYatesj1
    @MrYatesj1 Před 2 lety

    I have tried to play through a few Boss Katana's and they give me a headache. I will stick with tube amps.

  • @bradd_9171
    @bradd_9171 Před rokem

    Rumble the clear winner imo. The katana did not sound pleasant at all.

  • @ZenRyoku
    @ZenRyoku Před 2 lety +1

    shouldnt a bass amp be more Scottish Claymore...and a guitar amp be more Katana...lol🤔

  • @MichaelBLive
    @MichaelBLive Před 2 lety +1

    Stage

  • @Tiger-wi5mu
    @Tiger-wi5mu Před 2 lety

    First comment

  • @Leo_prado
    @Leo_prado Před 9 měsíci

    Skipped through the entire video to find some slap, but I didn't.