The BIGGEST PROBLEM in Netflix's Lost in Space Remake
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 06. 2024
- Lost in space was a beloved campy TV show about the Robinson family lost in space with an alien robot. The recent Netflix TV series attempted to reboot the show with a more serious and dramatic tone, but it just all gets convoluted and just as awful as the original and in less than 10% of the time!
The science in this show is so abhorrently misinformed and this video explores exactly why there is science so bad that it would make Neil DeGrasse Tyson's head explode
Follow us on twitter for our latest updates and feel free to give us an @ for questions and shout outs! We will get to everyone we can
@MediumDSpeaks
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. - Auta a dopravní prostředky
*A RESPONSE FROM THE CREATOR OF THE SHOW*
KBrot posted this on the reddit post someone made of this video. Please read before hate commenting:
"Haha, I dig it. Glad you watched and liked it overall!
1. As an amateur astronomer myself, I worked hard to pitch a believable binary system. Threw it into Universe Sandbox and all that. But when 98% of an audience isn't gonna care which elliptical orbit you pick or what barycenter you're at or if the planet crosses a Lagrange point... they went with the simple "black holes mess things up" and we think it worked alright.
2. The animals can dig in and survive, or at least some of them do. The flying "apex predators" chill in their caves and survive on the gargantuan amount of energy they clearly ingest. And we had a cut sequence that was really cool that showed a herd of animals suddenly diving and burrowing in the hotter weather. They're not evolving each event. Regardless, none of that was on screen so you're not wrong to question it.
3. The trees? Hiroki does say they have one ring. They're basically super sequoias with fire-loving cones for seeds and crazy growth cycles."
In all honesty my first reaction of annoyance was the fact that people act like a new version is horrible because older versions existed. My problem is when content creators obvious bias moves them to hate any type of entertainment because it doesn’t do what they like. You have actually shown that you don’t blatantly hate it, you just hate what it is stating as a reason. Thank you
Is it possibe for the black hole to just pop up and it is a resent blackhole
Jayden Stahl you have better chances of seeing a naked singularity
*I AM HERE FROM THE FUTURE!!!!* SCIENTIST HAVE TAKEN A PICTURE OF A BLACK HOLE!!! WE GOT EM BOYS
3:36 sigh* kinda wish you gave me a chance to stop the video after saying spoiler alert 😔
I've learned that sometimes you have to turn off your brain and overlook some things to enjoy these Sci-fi flicks.
mm.. you cant watch tv and film without it can you!? (suspension of disbelief)
@Buttocks they mean, in all shows there must be room for some suspension of disbelief and just go along with the shows logic.
Try the Dune series. At least the LIS series is internally consistent. Dune was like any addiction - always reaching for a bigger dose (of absurdity) to get that high.
@@coachhannah2403 lol.. i love the olde dune with Kyle Maclachlan.. 🙂
@@coachhannah2403 Internally consistent in bullshit science. Like literally every happenstance is utter bullshit in it.
P.S. I'm still binging it, 'cause yolo.
Actually, I’m impressed by how accurate the medical science is in this show.
@Vendicar Kahn You are crazy and need help. I'm starting to think tou have some personal vendetta against a show? It's fiction. I can point out 101 inaccuracies from star trek, the expanse and star wars. Nobody watches fiction and expect to see things that are real. Last time I checked demons and fairies weren't real. However I still like supernatural and can enjoy it knowing they don't exist, but being entertained by the thought of them existing.
Also he got a blood transfusion because a toxic element entered into his blood stream. Blood poisoning can cause symptoms similar to sepsis because of the forign chemical aspect causing whole body inflamation. Therefore red blood cell transfusion would be the correct call. The only blood transfusion was when Don got a transfusion due to the toxic element from the seaweed. I don't know where you got an alergic reaction from...
And that is it. Anything to do with space is so bad it's funny
Tyler Cronin no this guy got proved wrong by science but you are watching this in 2019 or 2020 so you should know this the uhh black hole picture
Lmao my dad is an ER doc and said the same while we were watching the operation in the first episode
Damn right
I love the show. For a Netflix show, the cgi and effects look out of this world. I was si surprised. And the new second season? That part with the gas giant was my favorite
Same
Exactly! The visuals are CRAZZY.
I wouldn't be surprised if netflix secretly built the resolute and dived into Jupiter and lied to us that it was CGi so that NASA wouldn't sue them...
The writing for the show isn't perfect, but it's extremely good at making me hate Dr Smith! And that's saying alot considering the fact I've never hated anyone before. The robot can be a bit repetitive. But the CG is fantastic!
VERY WELL SAID!
It's worse than The 100 by a mile. And I thought nothing could beat the bullshit The 100 is.
Dr. Smith`s character ruins the show for me. I doubt I will keep watching it and I am at perhaps the 3rd or 4th episode.
@@nogoodwolf nooo, you gotta keep watching. Her character really goes through alot of development. The very fact that you hate her as a character proves that the show had good writing.
Lost in space, isn't my favorite show but it is a brilliantly written one!
And also make me hate the mom that doesn’t anything goood thn to be a little bitch egotistical and worst mom to the kid William . I can’t with her she makes no fucking expression thn doing the same every single time . she doesn’t frown or get mad ( No she does poker face ) ☠️☠️☠️
It was 1965, I was eight. My younger brother and I would jump with excitement because it was Wednesday night and the weekly TV show “Lost In Space” was coming on that evening.
It was 2020, I was 26. I would jump with excitement when sreetips would make a new video explaining to me how to make money from scrap metal and old jewelry, and then he watched and commented on my super old 2nd video I ever made that somehow to this day gets more views than any other.
Jesus Christ is the King 👑
I was eight also when the show began. Loved it. Still do. I always thought Will (Billy Mumy) was my age and could be the younger brother I never had. I was shocked to learn I am younger than Billy Mumy. I thought I was a year ahead of Marcia Brady in school. Turns out, she is my year and already a senor citizen which I am not--yet. Lost in Space as my favorite show ever. The mom in this clip seems so cold and unfeminine.
I am a product of my time and was young and old enough to see women's roles in society change. That said, it's sad that a Penny, Judy, and Maurine Robinson as we knew them would not be characters in a show. Mrs. Robinson from the graduate was another interesting character. Call me old-fashioned but some of the qualities of yesterday's femininity were quite appealing.
@@sw00t_yprd79 The King of man made fictional characters?......maybe. I prefer Superman...
I like how he said you can’t see a black hole I’m watching this in December 2019
That comment didn't age well lol
And you still can't see a black hole
No but in infrared light you can
Oscar You are seeing the light around the black hole, not the black hole itself
@@crimson5719 That applies to literally everything. You don't see an object, you see the light bouncing off of the object into your eye.
I have a wife, two kids in college and I build airplanes when I'm not doing nuclear remediation at a national laboratory. I like the idea of being to decompress and I am not going to break out the calculator and run gravimetric calculations when I watch a show that literally has zero impact on my life.
Yeah this guy's is just cheesing the show for absolutely no reason.
@@privateinfo6080 Yeah. But if they make it so unbelievable that they kill off all life every year and require billions of years of evolution inside of 12 months, that makes it stupid. It has to be at least close to believable on some level.
Vendicar Kahn shut up racist.
It's sort of like when they tell you the myths of Thor or the old Greek gods; or even some fable. People like this bust out with. No. Hammer magical? Magic doesn't exist. Jedi's don't exist. They shouldn't make movies about them. I'm so boring we should just watch a movie of scientific formula. Only scientist should make movies.
Vendicar Kahn listen here kid. You shouldn’t even be allowed on CZcams so if I were you I would get off and go back to school. Or I’ll report your reckless behavior to your parents.
I love this show. I don't care if they make silly problems or mistakes like a strong wrongly calculated science problem. It means nothing to me, its just fun to watch even if they make those mistakes or errors.
Next you're going to tell me a gigantic sphere spacestation can't move at lightspeed and can't destroy planets. Get an imagination.
Omg yes 😂
Star wars is just a fantasy and that's why i don't like it much. It's just so unrealistic it's funny. Now interstellar on the other hand is absolutely the best and most accurate movie out there.
@@iCore7Gaming okay
@@iCore7Gaming nobody cares
@@iCore7Gaming i like both interstellar and star wars; i dont really care that star wars is unrealistic because im not watching star wars for the realism; im watching it for the story it wants to tell
So wait this show is horrible? I thought everyone loved this show including me
No name It's a great show, but people are just bored to the extent that they hate on a well-made series.
Exactly. It's one of the best shows on Netflix
You guys do know people can enjoy shows and still point out their factual flaws right
@@snowfox-xc1qq well the channel isn't exactly pointing out flaws in a subtle way like one does when they like the show. They are being outright accusing
There’s no need to be subtle, if you’re passionate about something people can get really really mad and still care, if you’ve ever heard people talk about their fav video game most of them are insanely tilting and often really flawed to the point it’s unfair or doesn’t work, any moba is a perfect example of this, shows are not immune to this form of criticism.
I just finished watching the second series and yes there is plenty of BS science and WTF moments but it is still a thoroughly interesting and entertaining series. If you were to apply the same kind of criticism to any TV show or movie you would end up not watching anything.
"Expanse", they really do try
@@Demmon007 yes I agree with you, still some weird moments but because they mostly stick to already existing Tech it is a lot better.
@@StephenJohnson-jb7xe I mean if you applied logic and some creative freedom, you can make worlds 10x more interesting than whatever crap is in sci fi these days. Very few planets are even remotely interesting.
For example, make a planet orbit a single red dwarf. Then you can build off there.
The expanse is a prime example because the way they portray the solar system makes it seem more alien than "alien" planets in most scifi shows. But even the expanse has pretty boring looking habitable planets (before their transformations). Like why does illus and laconia look like earth. Hell illus has the same gravity as earth and same atmosphere. Why did holden and belters not wear masks at least on this alien planet where they know nothing about its biology? For fucks sake they even get infected because of that.
12:00 When the show was warning about the hawking radiation I think they were referring to the fact that there was a black hole (I'm pretty sure only black holes release hawking radiation), so they probably weren't saying the hawking radiation itself was dangerous, but that whatever was making it was.
That makes more sense, since that would probably be the only way to detect a black hole unless you can see the distortion it creates in space.
Well even though you are probably correct in your analysis of this, they arent saying that the black hole will burn us. They are using the vacuum cleaner example as you presented to suggest their planets orbit is pulled towards the black hole altering the orbit of the planet around the sun, forcing the planet closer and closer to the sun, and thus the sun will burn everything alive off the planet. I actually had to revisit the scene because the stuff you talked about reminded me of nothing in the scene and after rewatching I do believe you have misunderstood it, i mean she even says it while showing with the baseball going around the wine bottle. I would also assume that the only reason they say hawking radiation when she is up there is because it gives away that the black hole is there. So yeah you nerdraged over black holes burning people alive when that was not even what they said. Now I'm not saying that what they did in the movie would be a way things turns out in reality, but it does make this entire video obsolete.
But hey the balloon still sucks.
🤪
I was thinking that the whole time😂
He did get it wrong, but his point was still right - balloon height etc, and he made that vid hell fun to watch - yur vid rocks, bro
@@zakksscifilogs7458 yeah He was right about the balloon. And perhaps more importantly he was absolutely right on about the length of time it would take life to start over on the planet from an absolutely dead planet! I remember thinking the same thing about the planet starting it's like life cycle over and over like that and how ridiculous that sounded. Give the guy a little credit anyway. Like you said though he's definitely not a scientist.
Give the guy a little credit anyway....After all, He was right about the balloon. And perhaps even More important he was absolutely right on about the length of time it would take life to start over on the planet from an absolutely dead planet! I remember thinking the same thing about the planet starting it's like life cycle over and over like that and how ridiculous that sounded. Actually I was thinking that was total BS. But, Like he said. He's definitely not a scientist!
Chill, it is a SCIENCE FICTION, AGAIN "SCIENCE FICTION" SHOW.
Nope... No, if anything it's "Space Fantasy" my brother. Take it from a mega fan of the genre. It's the Science part that makes it Sci-fi. *Science* fiction. Scientific plausibility it what makes sci-fi so special. Go read Dune or something. The point is, even a super nerd with a hard on for pointing out flaws, would find a good science fiction story plausible.
Being set it space has nothing to do with sci-fi, and some of the best sci-fi stories I've ever read, are actually set in the distant past.
I'm not saying the show is bad, or that I'm bothered by the inaccuracies. In fact, I do agree with the whole "chill" part of your comment. I only want to "umm actually," because it seems like you may not have indulged in my favorite genre. Go read Dune plz, it's actually amazing.
@@superghost48YT don't bother trying to reason with that dude, people need to take a chill pill and rub one out, this is a fucking show made for pure entertainment, the guy contradicted him self with the "rules of physics are the same everywhere" and then saying that it differs from place to place lol
@Vendicar Kahn you must hate all shows in existence.
@Vendicar Kahn what is not garbage then?
Wait... What is it?
Where's Niel Degrasse Tyson? I came to hear from Tyso as advertised in the clickbait.
So did I.
Me too!
5:32 you can get you Niel on !!!
I don't get why he doesn't realizes it's a show
I suppose you'd have no problem with a detective show in which episodes pulled stuff out of the writers' asses far beyond anything plausible.
@@julietfischer5056 I don't it's just fun to watch
I guess these people don’t watch tv.
You don't seem to realize shows advertised as science fiction can contain valid science
@@sophocles2083 agreed
Season 2 is pretty good!
FAX but we need season 3
Every season is good
I would say awesome and waiting for 3
jim liu agree i love season 1 and 2 it’s just so fun to watch! 😀😀😀
Ya apart from the bad writing, editing, and acting
It is called "FICTION!" And maybe for a reason! Rick
Actually, we call it SCIENCE fiction. And the Science in this series really, really, sucks. (I mean really). Of course, our commentator also spouts off things he Can't know. For instance, In the 9 minute mark of this video he goes on about how our planet has had only 1 bio-genesis event. There is no way of knowing this. We may have had 1,2, 1000, 1 million bio-genesis events! Perhaps many of the very first 'live' organisms went extinct shortly after occurring (1 minute or hour or day or month or year or century etc). Perhaps a number of events survived and resulted in life that exists today. The probability of a bio-genesis event depends a lot on the 'chemical' conditions of the environment at that time - to which we can only speculate.
@@GorgeGeorg who cares?
@@mavhunter8753 obviously the person he is replying to.
"fiction" works because it builds a believable and consistent world for itself. Nearly all examples of great fiction (written, cinema or TV) do this and that is one reason why they are "great". For example, accept that the "quantum space drive" exists, therefore we can travel through the universe, now, let's move on and enjoy the stories that enables us to tell. But this only works for as long as the "quantum space drive" works consistently (a great recent example of this is the "Holdo tactic" in The Last Jedi, where going to light speed in a ship can be weaponised. This goes against everything that has been previously established about light speed travel in the Star Wars universe and thus break many viewers suspension of disbelief).
This is why bad science kills science fiction. There is no need to misuse something that is known about to create your Mcguffin; we can accept "floating space magic" far better than real, physical events that are being studied and taught.
ok - so with that logic - A giant banana can come flying in with a time travelling one legged badger with sunglasses and start singing Doris Day songs, that would also be acceptable because ... It's Science fiction? science "fiction" doesn't mean Science "dumb ass." If you can't get actual known science right then it's NOT acceptable. If it's something that science Can not explain or hasn't been known yet than it is acceptable "science fiction." otherwise it's poor writing, lazy writing ... period. And if people continue to accept this type of writing, this type of entertainment without shaking the tree then they deserve the poor to mediocre garbage that's fed to them, and it's the reason we all have to suffer through years and years of bad entertainment.
I have a healthy ability to willingly suspend disbelief so that I can watch this show and enjoy most of it.
I like Jarjar Binks.
This guy's comprehension ability sucks.
1. The elliptical orbit was going to get the Sun to burn the planet.
2. The planet has deep caves and geothermal heating.
Look up the video “the lost in space reboot is lying to you” for the truth
Get over it bro its a Netflix show
Actually, I think they tried to adapt from one of the Original Lost In Space Episodes where the Jupiter 2 landed on a planet that had a dangerously elliptical orbit. And it was Dr Smith, using the Robot (The 1960's show version of a computer) to compute that the planet's orbit was going to make everything Freeze and then everything would Burn.It was the Pilot episode I think.Yeah...I'm old enough to remember watching it!
Is not a documentary, Is just fiction jeez
@Vendicar Kahn congratulations, you quoted someone. you must be so proud of your self.
@Vendicar Kahn its not like you are in every video i watch.
I can't stop laughing at how his frustration level goes through the roof at 12:53
Lmaooooo im dead 💀
With marijuana being legal in most states you would think he would take advantage of it before he strokes out.
@@cynthiaweeks7724 best comment
It Pisses me off 100% Dude Its Litteraly Fantasy U Know Its Fantasy Then U Should Know What Your Gonna Watch This Stupid CZcamsr Bad Jokes
@@doggo1603 The worst part is that he is angry over an explanation he made up in his own head. The astrophysics was actually pretty well thought out for a TV show, I can bet they had an actual consultant on the show, hawking radiation detected was to indicate there was a Black hole in orbit that she couldn't detect visually, of course it's a show so she is probably using far less equipment than she would need but that's scifi. The reason the planet becomes uninhabitable is because of periodic solar flares in the star caused by the orbital intersection with the Black hole, and it becomes on inhabitable to humans, all life doesn't die off, it's made pretty clear the native flaura and fauna are adapted to this, just because some plants and animals can survive doesn't mean all can. See there were these huge animals called dinosaurs see that weren't able to survive an asteroid collision, but these little creatures that were the ancestors of all mammals that thrived, happens all the time. Dude is full of crap
Neeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerd!
the theme of the show says it all Sci-Fi The last word in that is key here medium D wait for it the word your looking for is wait for it ................. FICTION its Sci-Fi buddy its Science art so to speak Take things for face value you wont stress out as much and have to make videos like this . Dude trust me im never getting back the 13:48 bit of time it took to watch this and still see that you have no point to the vid . so your telling me they based the original on science fact lol !! Sorry to brake the news to you buddy its also fiction science art again . please learn to take things for face value and not stress out
I am about ten timers as nerd as this trust me
karl tew wooosh
Of course ! This show is made for nerds.
@@karltew5486 r/wooooooooooooooooooooosh
Next video: HOW ENDGAME MADE NO SENCE
To me the biggest issue was not the science, that’s always changing and things we thought were true turns out to be only partially true or not true at all.
The biggest issue was that people’s behavior made nearly zero sense.
Are you kidding me are you really kidding me this is the complaint you have over a fantasy sci-fi show being worse then a guy in a carrot suit are you kidding me it's fantasy go with it
Asbergers is treatable
@@pakde8002 yes it is but Bruce doesn't have either
This isn't fantasy.
It's a TV show bloke!!!, just enjoy the show
I didn't mean to insult if I did I'm sorry I grew up listening to Bill Collins telling you all about the movie you are about to watch and again sorry
God, comments like these are so ridiculous
The REAL problem is:
why is rated 7+
I mean my sister is 7 and she is watching it with my family as welling as watching Stranger Things, Rasing Dion, Locke and Key and horror movies. That is just her though many 7 year olds wouldn’t watch it.
I will greatly appreciate this series as there are very little of sci fi series or movies like this
Many things are awkward if u dig deep but its okk since u are not studying physics there
And many things have basic perfect logics so its great
The original series was not noted for its scientific accuracy, either
Vendicar Kahn yep.
I disliked for the clickbait photo of Niel degrass Tyson.
1 major issue I have with lost in space is the fact how much trouble the main characters keeping getting into and how they can find a solution for everything.
I agree with your criticism about stuff going wrong, but to get on the program for the colony they need to pass a variety of tests, so everyone on the trip has experience and will be good at solving problems
Just finished all of season 3 today....still ranting about why they cancelled! I want to grab the person responsible and shake em up a bit! Netflix's Lost in Space was in my opinion was well written and actually grabbed my heart in spots. The special effects all fantastic! So much better than most shows these days....oh wait, I no longer watch most shows....its all Bar scenes, drugs, murder this murder that, car chases....get me?
4:59 "But everything's made of stardust, right?"
As a space lover. I love this show and Another life both are amazing. I don't care if they are not scientifically correct.
Which is better
@@junaidmoody8342 Lost in Space is better to me.
@@derriuswashington1600 thanks...I've just finished Ozarks ,I'm looking for a quality space series
@@junaidmoody8342 You need to watch For All Mankind. It is by far my Favorite Space Show out right now.
@@derriuswashington1600 can you tell me where they showing it,for all mankind
I see what they were doing here, in the original 1st season the Robinsons discovered their world had a cycle of coming very close to the sun which would often scorch/destroy all life and force it to restart after .
Yeah I think he missed the point there. As I understood it the black hole cause the planet to move closer to it's sun for part of it's orbit. The Hawking radiation was just evidence of the black hole, thus the warning, not because it was going to toast her.
Just for those who aren't old enough to have seen the original - this new storyline is a contemporary re-write of the original storyline from the 1960's. Back then, the planet was just on an elliptical orbit that took it close to the sun. The first half-dozen or so episodes are worth a chuckle at least.
Well the planet being pulled close to the sun and out of the habitable zone is exactly what happens in the remake, this guy just understood it
3 scenarios which make this story plausible. 1. A captured black hole. 2. The orbital period of the black hole is so long that it only triggers a mass extinction event. 5 such extinction level events have occured here on earth. 3 the black hole is not gravitationally bound to the system because it's a rogue.
If the air on an alien planet is breathable it would likely be loaded with spores, yeasts, microbes and pollens etc that might be hostile to Eartling lungs.
That's assuming their biology is close enough to our own to harm us in the first place. The only reason these things affect us is because of our shared biology. Biology on an alien planet would be alien in every sense of the word. This includes trying to eat the local flora and fauna. At best it would make you sick. At worst you'd wind up starving because your body simply couldn't break down and absorb the alien proteins.
It isn’t real life, that’s why they call it science “fiction”. It’s a plot 🕳 hole deal with it. So you have no problem with a semi sentient alien robot life form? Get a life.
I know right 😂
Your clearly just being protective over the thing you like(thia show). What he said in the vid was totally right, but he made a big deal of it cause of views..
@Aaron Morris Ok...
Because an alien robot could be sentient, there is nothing wrong with that. Issue is peoplr would thing this is what real life is like. If you're going to make a science fiction ATLEAST get the basic factors of science right. The orbital mechanics in this series think if you simply go out of the atmosphere you just float and are in orbit. JUST NO. They don't even get what orbit means... to go around something. Gravity is always there ffs. That's why orbits exist to start with and why anything exists
@@CGIadviserwell other than the balloon thing this guy is misunderstanding the plot. The black hole isn’t going to pull them in or blast them with a laser beam, it pulls the planet out of the habitable zone and thus everything dies
If you floated up to the thermosphere, you wouldn't be hot, because the air is so thin as to be practically a vacuum. It would actually feel cold, not hot, unless the sun was out.
But I agree with you that she floated way too high to be possible.
Seriously? You might as well criticize every space movie ever made 🤣
My favorite part was when Stephen Hawking's turned into a Steve Jobs quote.
I can see why these things really bothered you. I didn't know about the helium and got to learn quite a lot about black holes thanks to your video, so I guess the lack of knowledge made it more enjoyable for me. I think you'll enjoy the second season more tho. I can't quite place it, but it feels like they stepped up their game. The phasing is better, the dialog smoother and man the music. Not to mention the story. I can't remember crying in the first season, but I did a couple of times in the second.
Loved your vid
As far as I remember nobody in the show said that the black hole was there all along. It could have traveled into the system disrupting the orbits of the planets around the star. It could eventually get closer and closer to the star creating that dead spiral. In the meantime, the planets, depending on the how the black hole approached the system, would start their new trajectory of either inward or outward spiral. We actually see the black hole sucking up the star which tells us that the black hole was a new addition to that system.
Oh, by the way, our understanding of black holes and Hawking radiation are extremely limited. This show is set in the future where they can observe an actual black hole within the same star system. Still, Hawking radiation's wavelength is dependent on the size of the black hole. It's not automatically radio waves. Hawking radiation doesn't even emit only one type of wavelength.
So, when you try to shoot down a sci-fi series like this as if you know better, without knowing better, you end up looking like a joke.
Yo they mentioned how it was getting hotter and hotter, gas under the surface was being heated and causing geysers, waterfalls vanished because their sources dried up somewhere else, eventually a volcano erupts because the heat causing a build in pressure.
When they left the planet and didn’t know where to go from there they said they could wait for the planet to cool down and fly back and start again.
Clearly through these context clues the problem isn’t necessarily strictly the black hole. From what I could gather, the planet is in orbit around the sun, but once the planets orbit is being affected by the black hole, bringing it closer to the sun and killing all life due to heat.
As well as this, one of their biologists stated the planet was in a “stasis of decay and rebirth” (or something like that), where life on the planet would die, but then throughout its orbit as it’s brought far away from the sun again, life would restart and this seemed to suggest that the planet would be near the same as it was before all life died again.
YES this is still unrealistic but this is the part where you realize rather than just getting something wrong about science, they embellished the story capitalizing on the fact that the planet is alien (bacteria could survive this perhaps and if the planet does this several times and has already then surviving bacteria may have evolved to reproduce and mutate faster). It’s science fiction, emphasis on fiction, and this show drifts more into science fantasy, and there’s nothing wrong with that.
(Also the same biologist said even the largest and oldest looking trees have only one ring so it can be assumed the planet does this once every year.)
Science FICTION!!!! 🤦🏼♂️ Sweet baby Jesus this generation is a buzzkill.
I am the future of this generation. When I'm on Mars, call me buzzkill. And yes I will make the first human print on Mars. Remember the name Elise Fredritz... 👩🚀🚀🌑
MeteorIsHere this sounds like a threat 😳
This is not science fiction but fantasy.
@@Erick999PLAYER not fantasy. Fantasy is like mythology, dragons, and stuff.
@@acctrsh fantasy meaning - the faculty or activity of imagining impossible or improbable things... one thing is being a little different like The Expanse which is real sci-fi, another is being like Star Wars which people like to say is science fantasy.
FFS dude, its science fiction set in the future. You can't say because a hot air balloon can only go so far up today, there won't be one that can go up higher years from know. Any show: Star Trek, Star Wars or any version of L.I.S. requires a certain amount of suspension of disbelief if for no other reason traveling faster than the speed of light is only theoretical. Do you get this picky with every sci-fi flick or show.
True, but they show us exactly how they're doing this. Filling a balloon with helium. It's with 19th-century technology.
Lol he liked the show. This is content, he doesn’t hate the show. He just made an entertaining video. 😋
I honestly thought it'd be something about the writing that was truly terrible and went right over my head because cool alien robot. But in the end it's just science mumbo jumbo to make the audience feel like it's a serious situation without forcing everyone to do homework in order to understand what on earth they're saying.
"ah yes mmm the dexter particles are super dangerous and if they pool on the planet it'll result a fazbear level catastrophe on the Frederick scale"
Well for some things you also have to take into account that this reboot takes place about 22 years in the future
Now THIS, is what I call quality content baby (drags cig) (smiles)
..."and the fucking balloon!" lol i'm dying here! lmao. If you thought that was bad you should see the science inconsistencies and downright, laughable science in the original series. Love it all the same - The show, though silly fodder as it was, had some amazing stuff that made it oddly watchable and even addictive. The original Jupiter 2 space craft was an epic spaceship retro but so cool. Robby the robot showed up for a few cameo's. It had a vehicle called the Chariot which was real and it was awesome. The father had a jet pack that was real and it was awesome (despite that they showed those scenes over and over whenever they needed it.) The sound effects were Star Wars worthy and speaking of Star Wars ... John Williams ( Yes, That John Williams) did the score as well and there are lots of cues in there that resemble the Star Wars soundtrack in many ways. if anything is to be taken from that show - it would be the John Williams score. It's worth the watch just for that. The show, silly, campy, odd - but somehow hypnotic, fun and you just want to forget the "bad science" and laugh and enjoy. The reboot? It's ok too. So far. The only real issue I have is The mom is a real Mary Sue (can't go wrong and is always the brains and hero) and just needs to put a sock in it already. Fun video.
Allirog Gorilla sexism and stupidity is all i hear from you I.
The balloon thing makes sense to me. I assumed the Jupiter came equipped with things to do with each members' job/role on the destination planet, so they would be fully equipped and able to set up when they arrived. Science Lady (Maureen Robinson) isn't the only person able to do aspects of her job, but she has a Science Man Friend (Hiroki Watanabe) who is able to do parts of his job too (study the planet organisms and their waste). Hence, I think the equipment weight would be factored into the Jupiter's base weight, so they would have that equipment on top of the stuff every Jupiter has.
As for the Planet, I took it to mean that due to the presence of the black hole, the orbit was warped slightly, so when they passed the black hole, they got a lot closer to the sun than they were for the other parts of the orbit, so they were out of the habitable zone. Hence the planet becoming too hot to support life, so the surface of the planet gets seared. I also took Science Man Friend to mean that the apex predator ate creatures that weren't there now as well as all the current ones, so were confirmed to survive the extinction event and live below ground. I didn't know if any others survived, but that would probably make sense and he did say it was a planet of constant life and death.
What got me was episode 1 when it was so cold that the water was flash freezing yet it was raining.
If you loved the nonsensical writing in the first season, you will LOVE the second season. A sailboat with no keel, two people taking no damage after falling down a huge waterfall in the middle of the ocean and landing on a metal platform that makes the ocean water disappear with zero explanation. All this in just one episode. Alright I get it, Science fiction is fiction and it can make the rules as it goes along but at the very least it has to obey the rules it makes up for me to accept them.
It’s not a sailboat, it’s a spaceship with added sails
@@topcheese2889 That's exactly why it can't work, a keel is NEEDED to ANYTHING using sails. If you don't believe me just look up what a keel is and you will see the idiocy of your statement and why your comment was a waste of time.
You don't need a keel... Literally 3 seconds of googling shows that flat bottom boats do not require keels, which is what the Jupiter was, it was literally a flat bottom space ship bouyant enough to act as a boat... Shut your dumbass up...
@@freeshavaacadooo1095 because a space ship has the same properties and weight distribution nessesary to avoid a keel like purpose built boat would be, nope. Sorry your 3 seconds of angry fan boi research didnt change my mind about the show or ever will.
All the Characters had the most illogical thought processes I’ve ever heard. There all so dumb for scientists. Nothing is explained and nothing goes in depth.
Yea that's true but if you already understand a decent amount about the subjects it's enough to understand what they are doing.
I hate how people expect realism from a show with a huge sentient alien nuclear robot controlled by a 12 year old.
Episode 1: Rains and then the water freezes immediately in the hole. Probably should have hailed, or snowed. Or neither at 10,000 feet.
Kid slides down glacier and ends up in a forest (first of all insane) and then the forest starts on fire (how is it ever dry enough)
The magnesium thing...
I was really bored on a Saturday, but we solved that problem
Me:
STOP STOP IT I LOVE MY ROBOT
I was more interested in what you thought about the story telling but this was good too. Thank you.
8:02 what clip is that from, it looks well done
My main problem was the fact that they don't have any order what so ever. The kids do whatever they want even on the planet with predator giant dinosaurs all over. People go missing for days the nobody cares to wonder why they never came back, like when the kids slept in a cave. Also the cave they were in had monster bats that hunt at night but yet they didn't come out to hunt the day they slept in the cave. Also those bat monsters would have no issues getting through the barrier that they set up to keep animals away because they can fly over it
I really enjoyed “AND THE F**KING BALLOON” at the end :D
Great video! That said I love the series so I had to stop watching or I won't be able to enjoy watching the series again. FWIW I thought of the same thing when I watched it for the first, second, third... okay whatever at any-rate, I pushed logic to the side and decided to enjoy the show for what it's worth. Oh and for logic sake, did anybody notice how every ship has gravity in season 2?
Once you read more about Lost in Space and how it is based on an old book named Swiss Family Robinson (hence the name, Space Family Robinson) you realize the whole show is an allegory for a family setting off into a new world while going through the challenges of living and working together. The science of it becomes secondary. Not to say that some sci-fi doesn't get into some heavy science. Look at 2001: Space Odyssey, which relied heavily on NASA scientists providing their feedback.
In the original series, the planet supposedly followed this eccentric orbit which would take it very close to the sun. That's rather fascinating, and exploring the sort of ecosystem that would exist if summer literally burned is perfectly valid. In the physics of the show, the planet zoomed past the sun in a couple of hours. And then the idea was completely forgotten in favor of them launching because some idiot miner (no, really) caused the planet to disintegrate.
It looks here as if they were trying to be more scientific about the idea. What should have happened was the colonists noting the disappearance of animals and how all the plants seemed to be dying or growing some manner of thick shells or whatever was necessary to survive the radiation and heat. All the animals should have been underground or had shells or laid a fuckton of eggs.
Earth-like atmosphere is an acceptable break from reality, since it's a lot cheaper to have everybody breathing normally (and as long as the plants photosynthesize, all good).
I absolutely love Lost In Space. This show is awesome. The cast is perfect. His take is like a pc gamers review. Just critical of everything.
People who try to take the fun out of sci-fi shows with current knowledge are the worst kind of people.
There is another gross error: In one scene, Dr. Robinson enters a tank of liquid methane as if it were water. Liquid methane boils at -161.6 ° C. It would be impossible for him to survive.
You know, virtual particles don’t explode when they recombine. That would imply a release of energy from nothing, which doesn’t happen. The net energy release when they recombine is zero.
Thanks for this. I just watched this episode, and my suspension of disbelief came crashing down for the same reason. Clearly the black hole in this system isn't a problem for a planet that has clearly been orbiting in it just fine for hundreds of millions of years to develop complex life. It was so shocking to me that I was compelled to go Google it and see if anyone else saw the plot hole.
Oh, yeah I kinda missed that the first time. I was so happy they didn't do anything as obvious as saying the heat from a comet could kill anyone outside the ship like in the 2nd episode of the '65 series, and that the Jupiters were just landing craft from the real Starship that I was willing to give it a pass and missed this fairly obvious mistake. Maybe part of the reason season 2 is so far out is they realized this and are trying to fix their mistake?
Here's the 1 argument to counter your whole video: It's called "science *fiction*".
What that means is that it doesn't have to be 100% accurate to real life scientific principles. The "fiction" part provides room for certain artistic liberties.
You also didn't bring up the fact that they traveled to a planet in an entirely different galaxy in what appears to be seconds, which is just as impossible as what you're talking about.
In a show with alien Robots and engines that rip a hole in space/time the balloon is what was unrealistic?
A don't watch this for scientifically accurate stuff, i watch it because the Robin's are always in danger and find an unrealistic way to get out of danger. Thats shit is entertaining.
as far as the atmosphere temperature you left out the idea that even though the atmosphere is earth-like it is different and therefore would have different temperatures at different heights
Bad for you that don't like the show cuz i enjoy every moment of the series,who cares about remake.
Well lost in space made me cry but what hits me the most is a line from season 1 “what good is it that you protect me my whole life if I can’t grow up to protect you”
Five Words:
There on an Alien Planet
😯 very interesting! Ty for this video.
Idel Amores thank you for your comment! Please subscribe for more like it
Dude, the words science fiction doesn't mean nothing to you?
If the TV series were real science then, it would not be a science fiction series.
Why the people don't understand this simple things?
Science fiction implies utilizing realistic science in a format that applies it to it's most extreme extents but is still based in factual or theoretical science. This show failed enormously in staying faithful to the "science" in scifi
@@MediumDSpeaks OK. *"fiction"* is the key word here...
Ok
Look sir its just a video calm down u clicked it SO CALM DOWN
I like to bring up the analogy, if your favourite genre was Western's/Cowboy movies and a character whipped out a modern glock pistol, or crossed the great plains in a day the viewers would be up in arms. But it's just a story you could say.
One point the differentiates good sci-fi from bad sci-fi is being based in reality.
Nah man, I think you missed this one. First, the planet just moved in and out of its habitable zone due to being in a binary system. The hawking radiation is not mentioned as it being the threat, only to verify that what she was looking at was in fact a black hole. It being a black hole was not the problem though, the problem was that it was a binary system which could easily cause a stable orbit to move in and out of a habitable zone. The only significance there is in it being a black hole is just that they didn't see it. That's literally it. If there were 2 stars, it would've been obvious the entire time, and they would've done the calculations as soon as they landed. Discovering that the planet was in a binary system was the take away, not that it was also orbiting a black hole specifically, that was just to hide it. Lastly, you assume too much on limited information. We have a grand total of 1 sample of life in all of our knowledge, we are in absolutely no place to assume that life has to take a similar path to life on earth. That's like taking a drop of water out of the ocean, examining the life in that drop, and assuming that all life in the ocean must be the same and progress the same. Then, you complain about breathable air(which only requires having enough O2 and nothing poison to humans, so not that uncommon especially on a planet with plant life), but a minute later have trouble with an atmosphere that might be twice as thick or more. I know you address that, but honestly none of what you stated sounds like messy science or TV science. It just sounds like you are 1. Comparing too much to earth and life on earth for a show that is intended to shoe just how alien other planets can be. And 2. Misunderstanding the threat created when they discover the black hole. Again, it's only a black hole so they wouldn't notice it, not because black hole means death. Binary system is what means death, but only due to the planet, which can still maintain a stable orbit, yet leave the habitable zone.
don’t apply science to a tv show or movie…you will kill the fun !
This a show where everyone did a great job, the actors, the cgi, the sound effects, location scouts.... the only people who didn't do their job were the writers for the episodes. They really let down the whole team. That was some of the laziest writing I've seen in an otherwise stellar team. Such a let down. I still appreciated the other departments efforts.
You have bad tastes aperrently.
I adored the original Lost In Space and would watch it all over again if I could.
I sampled this new show by watching the first two episodes. I decided not to subject myself to any more after that. I knew it wouldn't be exactly like the first one but there were far too many discrepancies between the two shows. For me, it was like going to a friend's house to visit and finding strangers living there. instead of people I knew.
I agree. I love the classical lost in space, it feels like home when I watch it
I also think it was a way to pay homage to the past show and movie. The ship getting stuck on the planet, almost be crushed by rocks, the ship being destroyed attempting to escape the planet. If was more of a plot device to set a few events in motion.
I like how he went through all this just because of one thing
This review is kinda cringe tbh
The movement of a planet around two big masses can be entirely unpredictable, in theory a similar szenario like in the show could happen.
Also the resolute has rings but they don't create artificial gravity, and people have to walk in circles through corridors instead of walking in a loop straight forward
Tldr, the resolute has rings for the sake of rings and they are completely useless
Soooo, I have a question:
What if it's not a binary system like you assumed? What if it's just a black hole that just so happened to enter the system at that time? This would fix your issues with this plothole as that means it's an alien celestial body to the system, and it'd have adverse effects on the planet. The heat thing was the orbit of the planet being pulled closer to the sun, since the black hole was on the other side of the sun, it was giving extra pull on its orbit.
Also, the balloon thing would make sense as it's one of the most efficient ways to get into high altitudes without wasting so much fuel just to get up there. A high altitude balloon is reusable and it would take up less in storage space than a craft with its fuel to get the service lifetime the balloon would give.
Wowsers Medium D, broski I really love this channel I'm proud to say I'm one of your early discoverers
Welcome to the fandom! We call our followers D Bags
@@MediumDSpeaks lmao I'm glad I'm a DBag
You totally missed the why and how they left the earth. I’m not going to explain to you. Pay attention. Besides its Science fiction not fact. Lost me at about half way. 👎👎👎
You owe me about 21 mins!
This happened for a fact!...just in a different timeline where helium was abundant and on sale at walmart.
The way I understood it was that the black hole altered the orbit of the planet from a standard ellipse and brought it dangerously close to the star, thus burning it and all life on it. Still weird that it all regenerates afterward though.
In about 20-30😱 years , we are gonna be looking as bad the people who followed the first series ? LoL still interesting series, worth following through second season
i think you need a hobby
What do you think making CZcams videos is?
This show creates the most ridiculous I might not make it moments for action every time.
Can these episodes just go big we might not die moments free.
You always have to turn off your brain for scifi. Starting with Frankenstein and Dracula. Water doesn’t freeze the way it did in the first episode. It loses heat fron the surface and skins over which then insulates the water underneath from losing its heat of crystallization. The amount of energy the alien engine generates is hugely problematic. An infection of metal that causes it to rapidly crumble, etc. All are BS science. I still am enjoying it as I get to the end of the second season. In GOT the dragons and the Night King are BS but it was fun.