Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

Between Love And Hate: Understanding The Swastika - Isaac Wheeler | Quest 2020

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 08. 2020
  • To learn more about the Middle School learning programme, visit: www.greenschool.org/bali/prog...

Komentáře • 83

  • @rishi9637
    @rishi9637 Před 2 lety +50

    Wow, if American teens are even half as unbiased as you then future seems bright. Well done from an Indian.

    • @crypton_8l87
      @crypton_8l87 Před rokem +8

      He has no right to use the word Swastika when referring to their symbol of hate called HakenCreuz or HOOKED CROSS. जागरूक रहो भरतवर्षियों

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem +1

      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

    • @user-oj6re6ju9t
      @user-oj6re6ju9t Před rokem

      ​@jersey devil it originated in India but then other countries started using it in the same way

    • @entertainmentofficer6197
      @entertainmentofficer6197 Před rokem

      ​@@Channel-sp3fpSwastika is a sanskrit word that means well being than how can it originate from Ukraine do u speak sanskrit in ukraine swastika clearly originated from India a hindu symbol

    • @taj3968
      @taj3968 Před 8 měsíci

      But why though every group who wear it and believe it always act evil with them think they are the "chosen one"

  • @deepupatwal5005
    @deepupatwal5005 Před 2 lety +44

    West used it as Hakenkreuz means hooked cross where as in India it was and still using it (swastik) a symbol of peace. It has nothing to do with symbol, it's all about people who used it. 🤔

    • @bimalendusinha5702
      @bimalendusinha5702 Před rokem

      Even Hitler called it Hakenkreuz symbol of christinity but after the genocide caused by Hitler on Jews. British writer who translate the book on Hitler in English he convert Hakenkreuz to swastika not "hooked cross" just to hide the fact that what Hitler used is Christian symbol.

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

    • @deepupatwal5005
      @deepupatwal5005 Před rokem +3

      @@Channel-sp3fp please find details documentary on CZcams about swastika and it's missuse. The name of documentary is silence of swastika by aktk documentary.

    • @ceoofracism5713
      @ceoofracism5713 Před rokem

      @@Channel-sp3fp can't wait to claim that all hinduism and knowledge like geometry, mathematics, spirituality, architecture and every possible things in hinduism culture is actually given to India by white people

    • @faktiman381
      @faktiman381 Před rokem

      @@Channel-sp3fp yeah we dont believe in aryan invasion fo

  • @cliphound80
    @cliphound80 Před rokem +5

    Swastika is a Sanskrit word for good fortune and prosperity and is used all over Asia and is common in Hinduism,Buddhism,and Jainism. A Swastik is commonly placed at the entrances of households to ward off negativity and evil spirits. I have seen lamps placed in the shape of a Hindu Swastik for a Diwali Festival!

  • @rigsospuro7158
    @rigsospuro7158 Před 2 lety +11

    Awesome job young man. You have a great head on those shoulders. Stay positive see the good in everything and you will find good. God bless

  • @juanleiba2396
    @juanleiba2396 Před rokem +3

    The swastika is one of my most favorite symbols coming from the Sanskrit meaning peace and good fortune

  • @yehudahhachassid6191
    @yehudahhachassid6191 Před rokem +2

    Thank you for an eye opening lecture on ancient symbols. Shalom !

  • @Swaesyy
    @Swaesyy Před 2 lety +4

    Its acrually really common and spiritual , it is presented as welcome signs on doors of houses and hindu temples , its also a common name for boys in hinduism.

  • @andy260509
    @andy260509 Před 2 lety +11

    Hakenkreuz is a hooked cross, which is a Christian cross, Hitler was a Protestant Christian, how did that Hindu symbol become the swastika, which Hitler used to call Hindus a low race, would Hitler have made Swastik a part of his life for the same Hindu? E.T.S. DUGDALE first translated Hitler's book "Mein Kampf" (My Battle) in 1931, in which "Hakenkreuz" was translated into English as the Hooked Cross, a type of Christian cross. Then in order to save the hooked cross from disrepute as part of a conspiracy, a Christian priest James Murphy had to do another English translation of "My Battle", so that he could change the translation of hakenkreus from hooked cross to swastika.
    See this report with subtitles czcams.com/video/YxvBFytl5aE/video.html

    • @igorbrille8222
      @igorbrille8222 Před 2 lety +2

      Hitler was catholik not protestant

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

    • @amumohanty7630
      @amumohanty7630 Před rokem

      @@Channel-sp3fp i saw your reply in another comment. You're quite misinformed.

    • @Mr.Vitality
      @Mr.Vitality Před 10 měsíci

      H. was baptized a Catholic and kept his church membership, but he was a non-religious yet spiritual freethinker. He used the symbol because it had been used by the Germanic people in pagan times.

    • @The0ne357
      @The0ne357 Před měsícem

      As suspected the wicked missionary is behind this name changing from a type of "Christian cross" to Hindu Devine symbol of peace prosperity and well being "swastika". All this to protect their teachings from disrepute? WOW! NOTORIOUS...

  • @rahulbasurey1937
    @rahulbasurey1937 Před 8 měsíci

    The word swastika comes from the Sanskrit svastika, which means “good fortune” or “well-being." The motif (a hooked cross) appears to have first been used in Eurasia, as early as 7000 years ago, perhaps representing the movement of the sun through the sky.

  • @royrunyon1286
    @royrunyon1286 Před rokem +1

    Well researched and reasoned.

  • @jrvgameplaytrailers8527
    @jrvgameplaytrailers8527 Před 7 měsíci

    Thanks for this hard work ❤❤❤

  • @Defe353
    @Defe353 Před rokem

    this swastik is path of the dhruvtara a star in our astronomy.

  • @prithvirajr.chauhan6870
    @prithvirajr.chauhan6870 Před 2 lety +6

    It is not both because the nazi symbol was called as Hakencross which means hooked cross

    • @prithvirajr.chauhan6870
      @prithvirajr.chauhan6870 Před 9 měsíci

      @@AustinWilliam-gv8hu I never said that he invented it or any thing like that, so please.

  • @Channel-sp3fp
    @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem +2

    The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

    • @akashpatel8410
      @akashpatel8410 Před rokem

      It's a hindu symbol

    • @arvindsingh6863
      @arvindsingh6863 Před rokem +1

      swastika itself is a sanskrit word and it roots to 18000BCE in hindu tradition go do some research first

  • @landuhofficial6835
    @landuhofficial6835 Před 2 lety +2

    Amazing Vidio 🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @stardustether4739
    @stardustether4739 Před 3 lety +2

    Boy ye are a gem.

  • @aadityapratap007
    @aadityapratap007 Před 9 měsíci

    Kudos to you mate 🫡👏

  • @studdruppo
    @studdruppo Před 3 lety +2

    Good video. There are many questions that can be asked about how that symbol ties into different cultures. Robert Sepehr and his channel Alantean Gardens has some good videos on this subject.

    • @logicalhermit6570
      @logicalhermit6570 Před rokem

      Ur a answer is in silence of swastika in english by aktk documentary. Its actually hooked cross by means of which jews were killed as roman catholic hated jews people. Thank u

    • @studdruppo
      @studdruppo Před rokem

      @@logicalhermit6570 The swastika was long used as a symbol of well-being in ancient societies, including those in India, China, Africa, native America, and Europe. Although I'm no longer a practicing Catholic, I can't say I've ever heard a disparaging word spoken by a priest or a nun against the Jews. I'll check out your documentary though.

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

  • @thesureshsharmashow2871
    @thesureshsharmashow2871 Před 9 měsíci

    What is hukencross

  • @thelogicalhindu973
    @thelogicalhindu973 Před 4 měsíci

    If some killer start using your school's symbol then would it change the original meaning of that symbol? Would you stop using that symbol because now a killer is using it?

  • @rahulmukhi5764
    @rahulmukhi5764 Před 8 měsíci

    Swastika is a Common Holy Symbol Not Just in Hinduism But Also in Bouddisim And Jainism

  • @EyeOfAllah
    @EyeOfAllah Před rokem

    Like the South Korean country flag symbol white and black swirls. Good and bad come from same universal force.
    The result depends on use.

  • @positivegamingFF
    @positivegamingFF Před 2 lety +1

    Nice try but , Truth are weak in the KALIYUGA.But, I am Impressed 👏🏻😉

  • @truebangladeshi401
    @truebangladeshi401 Před rokem +2

    Hitlar used Haken-kreuz means Hooked cross, not swastik.

    • @abcdefghi2302
      @abcdefghi2302 Před rokem

      it was swastika

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      The hakenkreuz (crooked cross) is what Germans call the swastika. It is the same symbol, not exclusively used by him in Europe at the time. It is similar to how in 1942, the Americans stopped doing the Roman salute (they called it the Bellamy salute) and stopped minting coins depicting the ancient Roman Fasces (a bundle of wooden rods with an axe).

  • @taj3968
    @taj3968 Před 8 měsíci

    But why every person or group who wear it and believe it always act evil with them think they are the "chosen one"

  • @Panda-er4nd
    @Panda-er4nd Před rokem +1

    The word Swastika comes from Sanskrit which is a base language for Hinduism / Vedic religions. As I know, nazis neither followed hinduism nor they called their symbol Swastika.

  • @antonioaparicio5402
    @antonioaparicio5402 Před rokem

    I have been telling all my friends that I’m not a hater…. I am a person that promotes peace and harmony… And that’s what this symbol represents…. But they don’t get it!

  • @aryatomar625
    @aryatomar625 Před 2 lety +6

    Hooked cross and swatikas difine it's real value
    Swatikas means peace
    Hooked cross means cross related to Christianity totally on the name this sign Christian did wrong things and just divert from Christianity they used word swatikas instead of hooked cross

    • @crypton_8l87
      @crypton_8l87 Před rokem

      Exactly!! Neo Nazis and westerners have no right to use the word Swastika! Hitler only used HakenCreuz. Hooked Cross is the symbol of evil.

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria. Feel free to checkout my playlist and channel description for more info. It was popular throughout all of Europe and North America for thousands of years until WW2.

  • @jokesplanet1202
    @jokesplanet1202 Před rokem

    There should be no debate on swastika because hitler never used swastika.He used Hooked cross or hakenkreuz a symbol in christian treditions .

  • @vinodsankanal8966
    @vinodsankanal8966 Před rokem +4

    Why these westerners trying to use indian word instead of their word Hakencruez

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      It is swastika in English, borrowed from Sanskrit. The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine and Romania/Bulgaria, not in Asia. The Lithuanian language has some interesting similarities with Sanskrit
      The swastika was popular throughout all of Europe for thousands of years until World War 2, it was also popular in the American continents.

    • @vinodsankanal8966
      @vinodsankanal8966 Před rokem

      @@Channel-sp3fp I don't knw where do you get your facts...west got to knw about the word swastika only after they started colonial adventure to Asia..took the word from here and added to thier dictionary ..and carefully started addressing nazi symbol in every literature of theirs with the word swastika instead of Hakencruez just to shift focus that nazi mentality originated from Christian churches...tried to shift ble towards asian cultures ..such a shameful act..even today world is witness to hypocracy of West in each and every thing happening in the world..

  • @jayhind6397
    @jayhind6397 Před rokem +1

    It's not both of these things. Swastika is swastika and hakenkruez is hakenkruez.

  • @AA-bn7tf
    @AA-bn7tf Před rokem +1

    The swastika originates from indo-Europeans. For them, it symbolized the pole, centrality at the most basic level. The center is still and the four outer swirls rotate around it. This corresponds to the “pole star” and other stars around it which form the “Little Dipper.” For someone watching the rotation of the stars in the sky the stars seem to rotate around the pole star. On a more complex level the swastika symbolizes being and becoming, the eternal forms and the changing material world, order vs chaos. The swastika is also associated with the sun due to it also being a symbol of centrality. It is also associated with lighting and the blessing of the gods.

  • @yoshitokin235
    @yoshitokin235 Před 3 měsíci

    wrong info swastika is different from nazi symbol which is Christian symbol and swastika is Hindu, Jain, Buddhist symbol

  • @h1g2a3r4
    @h1g2a3r4 Před 2 lety +7

    Poor job and weak analogy Issac wheeler, misinterpretation of Swastika as a symbol of hate and racistl. Hitler called his creation the Hankenkreuz which also look different. Look carefully at both symbols, the swastika is a ninety degrees angle and the Hakenkreuz is incline at forty five degrees angle. James Murphy a British priest made the mistake by calling the Hakenkreuz , the Swastika in his English translation of Hitlers book Main Campf. As a christian priest he committed this mistake to avoid linking Hitler with Christianity, although Hitler was a devout Christian. Swastika is an Indian word and Hakenkreuz is German for Hooked cross or gammadion used by Hitler. So there is no similarity whatsoever between the two symbols. I am also sending you a few place on youtube where you can learn more over this subject.: www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxvBF...
    UCnQ2NHZ_mUS6fYuW8krNurw There are more info over the subject, since you have travelled a lot I hope you understand that all cultures used the Swastika for Good. but Hitler's "Hakenkreuz" closely related to Christianity is by no means similar to the swastika.

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      Hitler was not a Christian in private, people who knew him confirmed this in their memoirs. He used the religion to unite Germany and end class divide, it would be political suicide back then to repudiate Christianity. Positive Christianity as it was called in Germany, was different from all other forms of Christianity. It was the removal of the Old Testament from the Bible, and the removal of the universalist aspects of Christianity in an effort to strengthen their blood and soil (ethnonationalist) ideology.

  • @AlexeyMedvedev55
    @AlexeyMedvedev55 Před 2 lety

    Символ креста гораздо древнее христианства или буддизма. Египтяне от которых пришёл символ креста, называли его "тау". И жрецы держали его в руках, когда посвящали своих учеников. Другие же лишь переняли этот символ, постепенно забывая о том, что он выражает. Потому символ " тау" - не креста - есть символ творения, зарождения. Но это лишь одно из объяснений.
    На самом деле, крест есть символ свободы воли. И никто никогда не может притянуть человека наверх без его на то желания и участия. Также никто не может заставить человека идти вниз. Лишь в человеке пересекаются миры, и человек волен, стоя в точке пересечения, пойти как вниз, так и вверх. Небесное и земное, пересекаясь в сосредоточении, имеют борьбу за человека живого. Крест есть также символ суда.
    Что касается христианства, то очень многое люди придумали сами. Например, ещё одна черта внизу или вверху, которая наискосок, есть не что иное, как перечёркивание креста - Христа. И великий символ свободы, призванной вознести дух, перечёркнут. Фактически, перечеркнув крест, заявили, что свободу у людей отобрали. В обмен на обещание им хлеба и жизни в достатке.
    Равносторонний крест и является символом свободы воли человека: он может пойти как вверх, так и вниз от горизонтальной полосы.
    Свастика - это тот же равносторонний крест, только показан в своём движении. Утверждается, что движение Космоса происходит по часовой стрелке. А сотрудничество с Огнём небесным и напряжение во время такого сотрудничества вызывают движение по часовой стрелке. Движение же против часовой стрелки всегда было символом зла, разрушения, смерти. Неслучайно Гитлер выбрал этот страшный знак.
    Человек должен понять, что не ум его избирает, но сердце. Настоящая свобода там, где человек следует сердцу, голосу сердца своего. Причём сердца чистого.

    • @Channel-sp3fp
      @Channel-sp3fp Před rokem

      I Google translated your comment. Very good comment, thank you for posting.
      The swastika originated in ancient Ukraine, Romania, Bulgaria.

  • @redterrorproductions1373

    #FreeTheSwastika