Apostasy Punishment in a Liberal State?
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 01. 2019
- This is a spin on the usual question posed to Muslim traditionalists of what the punishment of apostasy is in an Islamic state. The question under investigation in this video is the extent to which social contract models (in liberal states) could allow punitive punishment for 'anti-state' expressions in a public domain.
This is what John Locke had to say in his letter concerning tolerance:
The case of idolaters, in respect of the Jewish commonwealth [i.e. the Kingdom of Ancient Israel], falls under a double consideration. The first is of those who, being initiated in the Mosaical rites, and made citizens of that commonwealth, did afterwards apostatise from the worship of the God of Israel. These were proceeded against as traitors and rebels, guilty of no less than high treason. For the commonwealth of the Jews, different in that from all others, was an absolute theocracy; nor was there, or could there be, any difference between that commonwealth and the Church [i.e. the Jewish religion]. The laws established there concerning the worship of One Invisible Deity were the civil laws of that people and a part of their political government, in which God Himself was the legislator. Now, if any one can shew me where there is a commonwealth at this time, constituted upon that foundation, I will acknowledge that the ecclesiastical laws do there unavoidably become a part of the civil, and that the subjects of that government both may and ought to be kept in strict conformity with that Church by the civil power.
Immanuel Kant says in the metaphysics of morals:
A Law which is so holy and inviolable that it is practically a crime even to Cast doubt upon it, or to suspend its operation for a moment, is represented of itself as necessarily derived from some Supreme, unblameable Lawgiver. And this is the meaning of the maxim, ‘All Authority is from God ‘ which proposition does not express the historical foundation of the Civil Constitution, but an ideal Principle of the Practical Reason. It may be otherwise rendered thus, ‘It is a Duty to obey the Law of the existing Legislative Power, be its origin what it may. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Subhannallah this problem caused me a lot of doubts about my religion so I prayed to allah that YOU post a video about it that’d convince me that Islam is right about this point and today I’m surprised that you actually did, I didn’t watch the video yet but all of my doubts are gone just of this little sign from allah by answering my prayer of yesterday, alhamdulillah, continue the beautiful work brother jazzakallahu khayran
"so the brother asked the question..." 0:05 hahahah like dr. Zakir😂😂
I'm a Christian but I am at an age where I am really researching religions deeply. I guess I am wanting to read the quaran but I don't read Arabic and ive heard alot of the English translations are false. I'm not looking to convert I just want to understand the similarities and the differenceses. I am really enjoying Mr hijabs videos very informative and educational and the debates I perticularly enjoy because of the patience he has, he doesn't need to be rude or aggressive to get his point across and I respect that.
You nailed it Akhi. Most people can't present like this even with preperation and notes.... May Allah bless you in abundance. Ameen.
I like Hijab, he's clearly a well-read, smart guy. However, sometimes I think he uses his philosophical arguments as a bit of a smokescreen. It seems to be a debating tactic of his to dissipate the argument into very abstract concepts in which it's very hard to prove, or disprove, anything. This subsequently confuses the opponent (particularly the characters in Speakers' Corner) and he wins the argument! But interesting video nevertheless.
I'm subscribed to tons of Chanel but this, this channel is the first I've put the notification bell on for. Amazing.
Thanks for the references in the description box bro. I'm currently studying this. Although I feel most of this video wouldn't make sense to laity who know nothing about political science/philosophy so you should break it down more by explaining how integral philosophical liberalism is to western society, culture and the way everyone thinks. The ideas of Locke, Hobbes etc are intertwined in the fabric of our society and thinking but most don't know, so first step is helping them to acknowledge that. Then we can critique it. I feel this will make your content more accessible and beneficial to the public. BarakAllaahu feek
May allah grant us jannah. Amen
I wish i have such a smart and humble husband. May Allah bless you brother.
can anyone tell me where my brother mohammed hijab holds his debates? I love to listen to him.
بارك الله في جهودكم...الترجمة لو تفضلتم
Mashallah your very intelegent brother we need more people like you to be the face of Islam in these difficult times!
when will it be translated into Arabic ??
it make so much sence to listen to bro hijab.. always...Allah bless him and protect him.
جزاك الله خيرا
My brother Hijab, Lion King! May Allah reward you Ameen! Masha Allah subhan Allah! You are truly blessed with knowledge! Alhumdolillah!💖
We can tell the girl in front didnt understand anything you said, such a shame!! LOL
Assalamu Alayqum Muhammed Hijab
MashaAllah you are legend of now days, May Allah help you and your entire Crue and team .
Dua from Hind (India)
Subhanallah; thanks for the confidence! :)
nice and informative. jazak allah khair.
Assalaamu alaykum innanaa ma'akum
From Dar es salaam Tanzania
May Allah s.w.t continue to bless you Mohammed Hijab. Your dedication to dawah and education is commendable.
This has been so useful and gives me so much confidence in expressing my views. I love Mohammed Hijab’s explanation ❤️
Assalamualaikum va rehmatullahi va barkatuhu may Allah bless u
Assalamualaikum akhi i from indonesia My greetings to friends there, we pray for you in Indonesia that you will be blessed by ALLAH SWT
I wish Br hijab could talk on average IQ level for us Average people to understand lool
Well spoken brother
subhan'Allah. How the truth is made clear. Oh people pay heed and understand what this man is saying. I hope and pray anyone viewing this has an open heart and mind.
Is this where you been brother
Idk why i read it as autopsy first
THE TEN GEMS OF PARADISE
1.Subhan Allahi wa bi Hamdi, SubhanAllahi’l Adheem"
"Glory be to Allah and Praise be to Him, the Greatest, is free from imperfection".
"The Prophet (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) said, there are two phrases, which are beloved of the Most Merciful Allah, light on the tongue, yet heavy on the scale of reward-
(Hadith Al Bukhari)
2. Seeking forgiveness by saying "AstaghfurAllah"
We are all in constant need of "Allah subhanu wa ta’ala’s forgiveness!
"The Prophet (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) used to seek forgiveness 70 times a day, and he was a sinless person."
(Hadith Bukhari)
Imagine if we used every spare minute we have in one day to say(Astaghfirallah)
3. "La Hawla wa La Quwatta illah billah"
There is no power and strength except with Allah.
The Prophet(ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) said that this is one of the treasures of Paradise. -
(Hadith Bukhari)
4. "Surah Fatiha" can be recited in a minute
The Prophet (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) said that "Al Fatiha" is a cure for every poison-
(Hadith Al Bukhari)
5. "The Darud Ibrahim.
Allahuma Salli ala Nabiyina" "Muhammadin-""
O Allah send peace and blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam)
"The Prophet (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) said:
He who reads a single darood upon me,
Almighty Allah blessed him ten times, he is increased ten times in the stages of Jannah and ten of his sins are forgiven-
(Hadith Nisa'i)
6.( Alhamdulilah )
Gratitude is an important virtue!
7. "SubhanAllahi wa bi hamdihi adada khalqihi wa ridaa’ nafsihi wa zeenata arshihi wa midada kalimatihi "-
"Allah is free from imperfection and I begin with His praise, as many times as the number of His creatures in accordance with His Good Pleasure, equal to the weight of, His Throne and equal to the ink that may be used in recording the words (for His Praise)
Reciting this praise 3 times in the morning will weigh heavier on the scale than doing dhikr from the dawn prayer to forenoon-
(Hadith Sahih Muslim)
8. "Subhan Allahi wa bihamdihi" -
"Allah is free from imperfection and His is the Praise..
The Prophet (ṣallā Allāhu ʿalayhi wa- ala ālihi wa-sallam) said: if these words are recited 100 times a day, one’s sins will be forgiven even if they were equal to the extent of the foam of the ocean-
(Hadith Bukhari and Muslim)
9. "Surah Ikhlas" can be recited in a minute,,
(Surah 112)
It is known to have the merit and reward of reciting 1/3 of the Quran-
(Hadith Al Bukhari)
Note: this does not serve the purpose of reciting the entire Qur’an rather it is 1/3 in reward,,
10." La illaha illAllah -
There is no God but Allah"
"If everything in the Seven heavens, besides Allah were placed on a scale and the statement "La illaha illAllah" was placed on the other side of it, the statement would weigh more -
(Hadith Ibn Hibban and Hakim)
"Make use of every minute that we have! Lest that on the Day of Judgement we regret that one minute we lost, that one deed that could take Us to Jannah!
" May Allah swt,make Us all the owner of these Gems and make it easy to enter Janatul Firdus"
(AAMEEN YA RABB)
🌸
I might come to speaker corner
Before I watch this I'm going to say that if I like his answer to the question then I will convert to islam let's see
Well did you come to a conclusion?
Oiiii Legend !!!
Mashallah, well spoken. Brother where did you study?
Brother Hijab dropping gems like always 💎
He asked one question but (brother Hijab) gave him a free class
Nice to see the ertugrul hat
Mohammed Hijab always says ‘...obviously everyone knows he said in his book’ ‘obviously he stated that...’ and it makes me realise how little I know! Great explanation brother mA, keep it up
well done. alhamdulillah
all praise due to Allah, who blessed Muhammad hijab with swag🔥🔥👌
Subhanallah
Alhamdulilah
Islam is also a system. If a people living in any country reject it's system and became rebel to it he would be charged with sedition and punished. Likewise Islam is also a system and in a Islamic country if you reject the system and became rebel u will be punished
❤
الله أكبر .
this guy is a walking definition of sophism
Assalamualaikum
Mohammed hijab sir
Love you sir😘😘😘
I love you.
When people say you need to ask yourself the question, I think Mohammed takes it too literally lol
MashaAllah 😍 😍 😍 love from Germany 🇩🇪
nice nice nice
.
A like yer hat 🤠
Dyammmmmmmmmmmmmmm brother hijab
If indeed what you say Muhammad is true why do some Muslims go crazy when people are preaching about what they believe and become physically violent towards other religions. They consider it to be disrespectful to oppose Islam and the Prophet Muhammad as well as Allah. This is contradictory to what you're saying because it proves time and time when you see people act out physically towards other religions and I'm not just pinpointing Muslims but when I turn on CZcams this is what I see from the Muslim aspect
1st
Muslims from Speakers Corner is what I have experienced and from CZcams and I just don't understand that is a religion of peace and love you get when somebody leaves Islam or opposes Islam an the Prophet Muhammad. Muslims have gotten physical at Speakers Corner one of which they knocked a brother off a pedestal preaching that was a Christian or others that are preaching they yell obscenities and call them Liars of what they believe in and it just doesn't seem like a religion of peace and love
You approve the comments ?? So much for free speech. Plus youre discussing shit that ended 1000 years ago buddy.